Choral Reading of Poetry
Choral Reading of Poetry
Choral Reading of Poetry
OpenBU http://open.bu.edu
Theses & Dissertations Dissertations and Theses (pre-1964)
1957
Head, Arlene P.
Boston University
https://hdl.handle.net/2144/23918
Boston University
., \
BOSTON UNIVERSITY
SCHOOL OF EDUCATION
Thesis
Submitted by
1957
1
' 1Joston University
· 'S.chool o:f Education
.~ --~ Library_
First Reader:
M. Agnella Gunn
Professor of English Education
Second Reader:
Louise Kingman
Instructor in Speech Education
f'.b-====~======================~~~~====~========F=====
iii
r 1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
I. INTRODUCTION 1
The problem 2
poetry . . . • 7
Purposes 11
Values . 13
Objectives 16
Qualifications . . • 20
General procedure 22
r\~==+=================================~===
iv
r ,
CHAPTER PAGE
Unison speaking 27
Refrain speaking 27
Sectional speaking 27
Sequential speaking 28
Cumulative speaking 28
Orchestration 28
Antiphonal speaking 28
Dangers to be avoided 29
Summary of research 31
Letter to teachers 33
Unison • 35
Refrain •. 50
Antiphonal 58
Cumulative 71
Sectional 80
Sequential 102
(\~==~====================================~====
,,
F. INDEX BY SUBJECTS . . l3
(\k===~===================================F~====
I.
CHAPTER I
INTBODUCTION
ago, the writer had little evidence that she had helped her students to
enjoy and to appreciate poetry. The following year, exploration and ex-
periment with various methods and techniques for teaching poetry resulted
in some slight success with choral reading. Thus, that approach seemed
Literature which will extend the horizon of the reader's world and
tivate a taste for good reading which will increase and expand through
the years.
1
Dora V. Smith (director), The English Language Arts, Prepared by
The Commission on the English Curriculum of the National Council of
Teachers of English, Vol. I (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, Inc.,
1952), p. 374.
,,
ance with poetry, for inherently a child loves rhythm and thereby, poetry
The school has an obligation to foster and develop his instinctive love
concerning it.
in order to nurture the often dormant love of poetry. From that desire
to help him grow comes this study of the choral-reading approach to the
enjoyment of poetry.
I. THE PROBLEM
and (2) to compile a workbook with appropriate materials for use in the
The writer hopes that this approach will arouse an interest in poetry
selected for the junior high school level. Included in the research
··-=====II====
3
chapter are specific criteria for selection. The e~phasis is upon using
poems for class activity as a means toward greater appreciation and en-
The material in the workbook has not been tried out in the class-
~
-====~======================================*=====
4
6. Types of voices
b. Middle voices are those with a wide pitch range and good
resonance that can be used anywhere in the choir, alone,
with the light, or with the dark voices.B
school students who are experiencing that best of times and worst of
answer.
Language~ iE the
1Dora V. Smith (directar), The English
Secondary School, Prepared by The Commission on the English Curriculum
of The National Council of Teachers of English, Vol. III (New York:
Appleton-Century-Crofts, Inc., 1956), p. 3.
r-. ======~==========================================9F=====
r 6
world. The obligation of the teacher of English is, perhaps, the most
teachers of English:
experiences of others may have an important bearing upon their own lives.
that one of our purposes is to increase the competence of boys and girls
for granted and do not stop to realize the difficulties poetic language
may offer to our students. Are we impatient with their lack of quick
~=·====4=====================================~=====
-' you know through and through in half an hour is hardly the one
8
whom you wish for a life long friend. Build slowly. Mingle
humor and pathos. Mingle narrative, dramatic monologue, and
lyric. Build slowly, but build.l
poets. For example, the poet Carl Sandburg defines poetry as ". . the
silence and speech between a wet struggling root of a flower and a sun-
2
lit blossom of that flower."
1
Mirrielees, 2£· £!!., p. 381.
2Marguerite Smith, WinZs to Fly (Boston: Expression Co., 1938),
p. 18.
3Roscoe E. Parker, ~Principles and Practices of Teaching
English (New York: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1937), p. 98.
4Ibid., p. 99.
~=====9F=========================================~=====
9
are needed.
You may have within you the finest possibilities for literature
teaching: love of literature, understanding of its fundamental
problems, and practical .appreciation of the difficulties awaiting
high school pupils. Experiment. Don't be content to be artisans,
if, as some of you undoubtedly can, you might be artists.3
~=========i=========M=i=r=r=ie==le=e=s=·~££~·~c~i~t=·=·~P=·==3=3=6=·==================================~========
3
10
r
In searching for methods by which students might study poetry
various methods, and the choral reading approach offered some limited
Hamm says:
('====~~========================================~=======
11
Purposes
reading:
('====~======================================~~====
12
prime importance, for he assists the pupil in mastering the tool which
must share, cooperate, blend themselves into the overall pattern and yet
comment that:
('====~======================================~~====
13
live with all types of people. His· ability to share and to cooperate
Choral reading demands sharing and cooperating which may leave an in-
language arts except writing, and may not that, too, be an eventual out-
come?
Jersey, says:
1
Angela M. Broening (chairman), Conducting Experiences 1n English,
A Report of a Committee of the National Council of Teachers of English,
based on the Contributions of 274 Cooperating Teachers of English
(New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, Inc., 1939), p. 208.
2Dora V. Smith, £2· cit., p. 15.
~~===*======================================~F=====
14
r.,
is a factor in vocabulary building. It offers practice in speech
values such as variety of tone, pronunciation, enunciation, in-
flection and rate. It tends to relieve monotonous speech, develop
weak voices, soften harsh ones, and stress word endings. It opens
avenues for self-discipline since it necessitates cooperation and
interdependence. It affords an opportunity for self-expression
for the many who are denied adequate vocal outlets, for those who
are not solo singers, good debaters, public speakers, or amateur
actors.l
Boardman:
Social Values
1. Cooperation for unity of effect
a. Develops friendship and interest
2. Learns to share and communicate material to listeners
Educational Values
1. Develops high standards in choice of material
2. Acquaintance with authors and literature
3. Knowledge of accent, rhythm, voice grouping
4. Appreciation of word meanings and beauty
Personal Values
1. Shyness, over-aggressiveness and exhibitionism give
way to group spirit
2. Improved speech is a natural outgrowth
3. Improve: breath control, diction, sensitivity to the
volume of themselves and others, listening habits 2
The .final, and to the writer, the very best of the sources ex-
poetry. For the reasons just cited, much of her material bears record-
~~==~======================================~======
- Her explanation of choral reading as a mode of self-expression
15
social values, it appears that education which does not provide values
Many pupils do not do their best when the weight of class atten-
tion is on their individual efforts. They hesitate to express them-
selves. But if they can show expression at the same time that
others are doing so, their efforts will be more courageous and
successful. A child may read aloud a poem very poorly when he is
standing in front of the class; he may be afraid to show too much
feeling. When he hears himself as a member of a group, however,
he feels the attention is not centered on him, and he is at ease
to do his best. The fear of expressing himself orally, gradually
1 2
Marguerite Smith, £e• cit., p. 13. Ibid,, p. 15.
)Ibid, o. 16.
,- lessens and he achieves a greater sense of freedom. He discovers
16
a new self, one that he had never known, and this knowledge adds
to his poise and general bearing.l
specific aims and objectives for which a teacher using this method should
strive.
1
.!!2i£.' pp. 16-17 0
2 Ibid., p. 17.
~~========~=======~B;r;o~e~n;i;n~g;·~£E~·==c=i=t~·~·~P~·==2=1=2=.======================================~=========
3
17
B. In the audience
1. An apparent enthusiasm and appreciation
2. An increased interest in poetry 1
Specific Aims
1. To cultivate high ideas
2. To help pupils enjoy poetry
3. To produce or awaken the emotion that possessed the artist and
that through his work he is attempting to express
4. To cultivate a love for the rhythm and music of poetry
5. To foster a sense of beauty
6. To fix in memory a considerable body of suitable poetry which
will serve throughout life as a source of joy, a criterion for
the evaluation of other writings and a stimulus to further
reading 3
1
~·· p. 213.
2Friederich and Wilcox,££·£!!., p. 240.
by Carrie Rasmussen:
this quotation.
Boardman says:
reading in the United States: first, why choral work has been used so
sparingly in our schools; and second, that choral reading~ being used
use of choral reading just as it was twenty years ago when Robinson and
The art of choral speaking is very, very old but its modern
revival is so young that many directors of speaking choirs are
still groping for material. Some of those less experienced feel
also the need of suggestions concerning the arrangement of poetry
for use. Books in the field are few and most of those available
stress method rather than material,2
('====~======================================+=====
20
Finally, the knowledge that choral work is being used in many sit-
uations on the American scene and to some extent in many schools should
method.
Since the First World War there has been a rapid development in
the revival of this ancient art. There is hardly a school in the
country in which something is not being done in the subject.
Churches recognize the stimulus for worship in the variation it
affords through group participation. It is particularly suited
to our American way of life. It fosters community spirit. It is
an aid to socialized and creative group activities. It integrates
the individual into the group without impairment of personality.2
Qualifications.
0====~==================================~=====
22
1. A sense of sound
a. The ability to hear and produce vowels and consonants with
correct formation and placements
b. The ability to modify sounds in their combination with
other sounds
(1) Proper aspiration and unaspiration of p, t, k
(2) The voicing and unvoicing of voiced consonants
(3) Lengthening of vowel, diphthongs, and consonants
2. The recognition of strong and secondary stress and a knowledge
of correct weak forms and how to use them in connected speech
3. Observation of breath groups and accurate attack of sounds at
the same time, pausing for breathing and for the pantomiming
of the thought
4. A sense of the basic melody of English
5. Adequate voices with power and control 2
1
Friederich and Wilcox, ££.-f!!., p. 244.
~~·========~=========B=r=o=e=n=i=n=g=·=££===·=c==it==·=·=P==·=2=1=4==.====================================~==========
2
23
r '
3. Know your poem. Whether you are reading it from the printed
page or from memory, be familiar with the content of the poem.
5. Read the poem aloud to the class with sincerity and inspira-
tion. You must have sincerity, enthusiasm, vitality, and in-
telligence in your own presentation if you hope to inspire
others.
10. Let the group try various suggested arrangements with attention
to thought mastery, correct rhythm, pure tone, and good diction
11. Select the solo parts, if any, by try-out and class judgment.
12. Keep the voices light. Volume can be increased when necessary,
but tones must never be forced.
manner:
~~=======9~=======2=F=r=i=e=d=e=r=i=c=h==an=d==W==i=lc=o=x==·~~~·~c~i~t~·=·==P=·==2=4=0=.========================~==========
,,
I
24
1Ibid., p. 241.
From San Jose State Teachers College come the opinions of Dorothy
The poems suitable for junior high school add to the marked rhythm
and effective diction, narrative and imaginative elements, which
afford contrast in mood and thought.4
('""'\
======~===========================
26
In choosing poems for unison speaking, one should look for such
poems with the predominating values of melody, rhythm, prevailing
emotions, strongly contrasted moods or pictures, or thought and
feeling moving to a climax.2
In summary, the criteria used to select the poems for this work-
choral reading:
vidual teacher will make substitutions for and add to the poems included.
types and poems for which they may be used is written below.
1 Ibid.' p. 181.
2 Ibid., p. 182.
r"'
~
I
I.
if
i
I
27
Unison speaking.
Refrain speaking.
Sectional speaking.
II
A==~======================~~~~~2s==
Sequential speaking.
Cumulative speaking.
Orchestration.
Antiphonal speaking.
Antiphonal:
(1) like church responsive reading
(2) phrasing and timing important
(3) Psalms and ballads--excellent sources
(4) pupil must be prepared to resume part 5
r"-_,===11==============~--=====~==#====
29
word of advice to the teacher who might be prone to adhering too closely
Dangers to Be Avoided
warns against dullness, singing the words, and making heavy, labored
1
Nafe, £!!.· _c_.'
it
I
P. 29 .
2 Ibid, I'
3Marjorie Gullan, Choral Speaking (Boston: Expression Co., 1936),
pp. 74-5.
0_,===!1===============-=-=---=--=-===~-=-=-=--~~==IF====
I
I!
30
but are there not in any methods used in teaching? Since the purpose of
which will aid the writer in using this material in a classroom situation
However, another reader might wish to know of other uses to which choral
1
DeWitt and others, 2£· cit., pp. 187-88. I
2Rasmussen, loc. £!!.
3
f'_,===,=Jf==== =F=r=i=e=dma==n=,=2£==·=c=i=t=·=·=P=·=9=5=.===== ====~~~~=c~"·"-·.
31
suggestions:
Summary of Research
methods, have been outlined for the use of the beginning teacher of
for choral reading in the junior high school is justified and should be
a worthwhile tool for the teacher of English who is beginning the teach-
('====~======================================+=====
'I
CHAPTER III
THE WORKBOOK
I. LETTER TO TEACHERS
group reading and interpretation of poems, is not a new art; yet to most
Before using the poems in this workbook, the teacher will do well
type of work will also be found in the research chapter. However, the
for this workbook are: rhythm, vivid language, variation and contrast in
mood or thought, and the general merit of the poem itself. Suitability
to age and interest are, of course, prime requisites for all our teaching
materials. Hence the selections chosen by the students which meet the
,....,
-'====~===========================
'I
i
I
34
These types have been explained previously in this study, but will be
I hope that you will experiment with choral reading and that you
and your students will find this limited collection useful and
Sincerely,
Arlene Head
(',
- -==+============-=-~-~~~'=- ·===#====
- 35
the poems in this workbook are intended meEely as a guide. Each teacher
will wish to adapt the poems according to the abilities and suggestions
of his specific group. For that reason, it must be emphasized that these
arrangements are simply aids and not "the correct" method of interpreta-
tion.
Within each group the poems have been arranged from easy to more
section, with the longer, more difficult ones coming at the end.
Unison
want, perhaps, to leave this method until her reading choir has attained
teacher and students act as one reader, and, psychologically, this should
be a step in the right direction. The students will certainly not read
in perfect unison at first, but they will be reading together, which jus-
1
~~,======~========Bo=a=r=dman====·~£2~·~c~i~t=·=·=P=·==3=3=8=.===========-=-==========~===~=====~=========
I'
I
36
Before using the poems in this workbook, the teacher may profit-
1
OLD NEW HAMPSHIRE
Chorus
Anonymous
._, I
Class - Three young rats with black felt hats,
Three young ducks with white straw flats,
Three young dogs with curling tails,
through
ridiculou
1
Three young cats with demd-veils, portrayal •
Went out to walk with two young pigs
In satin vest and sorrel wigs; I
But suddenly it chanced to rain,
And so they all went home again.
2
FATHER
Frances Frost
1
Matilda Bailey and Ullin W. Leavell, The World of Endless
Horizons (Boston: American Book Company, 1952), p. 504.
('====~==========================~=======-==---·====F=====
38
1
KlTHER
Frances Frost
3
RELATIVITY
1
Ibid., p. 29.
2Harb£ace Teacher's Notebook {New York: Harcourt, Brace and
Company, 1956), p. 4.
f"'. 3 Ibid,
~ -====~==~~==============~-==-=~=======-==-·'=-===*=====
I
I.
39
3
YOUNG AND OLD
Charles Kingsley
1
rbid.
2Agnes c. Hamm, Choral Speaking Technique (Milwaukee: The Tower
Press, 1946), p. 120.
3 cecile de Banke, Choral Speaking Jn the English Course (Boston:
Baker's Plays, 1942), p. 34.
,.....,
- =======~============================================================-=-c===--=-======~===========
II
40
SLUMBER SONG l
Louis V. Ledoux
~====~==================================c===9P==~==
41
~=====+==========================~1==============~====~=====
.:!]! WOMEN'S CHORUS
Aristophenes
1
~·.£!.!., p. 154. 2sailey and Leavell, ~· cit.,
n - - = = 9 F =HaiiDII,
============
• 503.
42
1
ABRAHAM LINCOLN WALKS AT MIDNIGHT
Vachel Lindsay
~========~========~s~ec~h~r~i~s~t~·~2E~·==c=it~··~P=·==4=5=.=================~I~b~i~d~·~·~P=·==l=l9=.~====~=========
1 2
43
1
!. TRAGIC STORY
William Makepeace Thackeray
I
I,,
44
A TRAGIC STORY (continued) I
il
1
From MACBETH
William Shakespeare
I
45
1
NO!
Thomas Hood
2
STRICTLY G£RM-PROOF
Arthur Guiterman
Rhythm of
Class - The Antiseptic Baby and the Prophylactic Pup words!
Were playing in the garden when the Bunny gamboled up; Gaily.
They looked upon the Creature with a loathing undisguised;--
It wasn't Disinfected and it wasn't Sterilized.
Seriously.
They said it was a Microbe and a Hotbed of Disease;
They steamed it in a vapor of a thousand-odd degrees;
They froze it in a freezer that was cold as Banished Hope
And washed it in permanganate with carbolated soap.
Seriously.
In sulphureted hydrogen they steeped its wiggly ears;
They trimmed its frisky whiskers with a pair of hard-boiled
shears;
They donned their rubber mittens and they took it by the hand
1 2
- Leiberman, .2.1!.· cit., 289. Ibid., p. 306.
, '~·====9F==================================~~=====9======
- STRICTLY GERM-PROOF (continued) il
46
i
And 'lected it a member of the Fumigated Band.
Class - Ah! on Thanksgiving Day, when from East and from West,
From North and from South come the pilgrim and guest,
When the gray-haired New Englander sees round his board
The old broken links of affection restored,
When the care-wearied man seeks his mother once more,
And the worn matron smiles where the girl smiled before,
What moistens the lip and what brightens the eye?
What calls back the past, like the rich pumpkin pie?
"=====+======================================~======
47
REFLECTIONS DENTAL
Phyllis McGinley
2
SILVER
Walter de la Mare
"====~==================================~====
48
r '
Edwin Arlington Robinson
2
WINTER !I>RlUNG
1
Leiberman, £2· cit., p. 275.
Gelett Burgess
Ogden Nash
1
Ibid., p. 357.
2
.!!U!!.' p. 358.
~·='===9F===================================~====
50
Refrain
Teachers who are a little more hesitant about using choral read-
ing may wish to begin with the refrain response, for it is undoubtedly
the easiest approach. The teacher may take the greater part of the in-
terpretation and have his class come in on the responses after he has
1
Boardman, 2£• £!!., p. 338.
2May Hill Arbuthnot, Children and Books (New York: Scott, Foresman
and Company, 1947), p. 185.
r'~===~===========================================4=====
51
!!!! ~ UMBRELLA l
Elizabeth Upham
1
f"", Hamm, .Ql!.• cit., p. 125.
====~======~~~==========================F=====
!ost"on University
Bohool of Educati~
-~......_ "b brary, .-- ......."~:
52
~'====9F======================================~~===
.Tim. GBBEN UMBRELLA (continued)
In a puddle of mud!
Her skirt was torn
And her nose was red,
Class - But the green umbrella
Was over her head--
Hi 0 for a green umbrella!
1
THERE HA§. ! FROG
Engliilh Ballad
~~,======~f========l~H~amm~~·=£2~~·=C:1:'t~·~·~P~·=9~8~·~=========================================#==========
54
1
BALLAD
Girls - The auld wife sat at her ivied door, Enjoy the
Boys - (Butter and eggs and a pound of cheese) rhythm.
Girls - A thing she had frequently done before;
And her spectacles lay on her apron'd knees.
Part II
BUMPETY .!H!§.l
2
!W!!.!!h~-THRUSH
l
Hamm, .2£· .£!!., p. 99.
2 Ibid.
~====9F======================================~====
- ROBIN-!-THRUSH (continued)
56
l
THE CHi.ISTMAS PUDDING
Author Unknown
2
SONG OF m CHATTAHOOCHEE
Sidney Lanier
2
- lHanm, .21!.· cit., p. 45. Leiberman, .21!.· cit., p. 45.
1.====~====================================~====
'=
57
~,====~=====================================9=====
SONG OF ~ CHATTAHOOCHEE (continued)
~-====~=====================-=-==-===========~===
-
f' '
Antiphonal
58
choral reading. These dialogue poems may be tried with two voices, but
for the development of all of the children it would seem that two choirs
for the classroom would be to have a chorus of boys and one of girls.
reading.
2
Girls - "Is John Smith within?" Crisp, quick
Boys "Yes, that he is. " questions and
answers.
Girls
Boys
- "Can he set a shoe?"
"Aye, marry, two. "
and dark (D) may be used most effectively to attain the desired pitch,
1
Boardman, £2· £!!., p. 339.
2Arbuthnot, £2· £!!., p. 186.
n =====9F==================================
- WHISTLE, WHISTLE
1
59
Ballad
2
UPHILL
Christina Rosetti
Light + medium - Does the road wind uphill all the way?
Dark Yes, to the very end.
L+M Will the day's journey take the whole long day?
D From morn to night, my friend.
1
Marjorie Gullan, Choral Speaking (London: Methuen & Co., Lta.,
1949), p. 52.
~~·=========i=========c~e~c~i~l~e~d:e~B:a~n~k:e~,~C;ho;;r;a;;l~S~p;e;a;k;i;n~g~i~n;;t;h;e~E;ng;;l;;is;h~C;;o;u;r;s;e~,~P~-~3=4~·~==~==========
2
- 1
60
FATHER WILLIAM
Lewis Carroll
Boys, "You are oiLd, Father William," the young man said,
Medium "And your hair has become very white; The youth
And yet you incessantly stand on your head-- assumes a
Do you think, at your age, it is right?" needling
tone until
Boys, "In my youth," Father William replied to his son, the last
Dark "I feared it might injure the brain; stanza.
But, now, that I'm perfectly sure I have none,
Why, I do it again and again."
M- "You are old," said the youth, "and your jaws are too weak
For anything tougher than suet;
Yet you finished the goose, with the bones and the beak--
Pray, how did you manage to do it?"
Contrast
D - "In my youth," said his father, "I took to the law, tones
And argued each case with my wife; of youth
And the muscular strength which it gave to my jaw, and
Has lasted the rest of my life." father.
M- ''You are old," said the youth, "One would hardly suppose
That your eye was as steady as ever;
Yet you balanced an eel on the end of your nose--
What made you so awfully clever?"
('=====*================================~~====+=====
- ORGAN RECITAL
1
61
Arthur L. Lippmann
Girls, "Oh, yes, Mrs. Proctor, for months I've been ailing;
Light You know my physician's forbidden all sweets.
voices My health, Mrs. Proctor, has stead'ly been failing--
I'm not allowed pastries, potatoes, or meats.
My heart is erratic,
I'm weak and asthmatic; Emphasize that mud
The doctor's emphatic-- of the humor comes
I ~.m badly run down! from the clear
My stomach's awry. It diction of the
Demands a strict diet-- medical terms.
! must be kept quiet,"
1st girl solo - Enthused Mrs. Brown.
1
Leiberman, £2· £!!., p. 318.
('====~======================================~F=====
62
1
1!!! QbQ CLOCK ON .TI!!!, STAIRS
Henry W. Longfellow
"'
Publishing Company, no date), p. 17.
=====9F=================================
63
1
THE THROSTLE
Alfred Tennyson
1
,... sechrist, .!!!!.· cit., p. 155.
r .'~·====~======~~~~====================~~====
-
r
1]1 THRQSTLE (continued)
64
L - Amen.
D - Amen.
L - Amen. Reverently.
D - Amen.
1
Ibid., p. 30.
~====~=========================================9F=====
66
1
m_ BUGLE SONG
Alfred, Lord Tennyson
2
THE RIDDLING KNIGHT
Unknown
1
Poems Teachers Ask f2!, Book One, op. cit., p. 183.
2Bailey and Leavell, £2· cit., p. 336.
67
3
FRIDAY STREET
Eleanor Farjeon
1
Hamm, .Q.E_ • .£!.!:.. , p. 93.
2 3
"============9F===========I=b=id=·=·====P=·=4=7=.=====================================I=b=i=d=·=·=P=·=9=2=.==================#============
·I
69
r '
FRIDAY STREET (continued)
1
"NO, SIR"
Old English Ballad
Boys - "Good evening, pretty maiden, with your eyes of heaven's blue,
May I step within your garden gate and spend the time
with you?"
Girls - "No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO. Serious.
No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO."
Boys - "The night is very lovely and the hour is not late,
May I look into your deep blue eyes, across this garden gate?"
Girls - "No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO.
No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO."
Boys - "Tell me one thing, tell me truly, tell me why you scorn me so;
Tell me why, when asked a question, you must always answer
'No. '"
Girls - "No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO. Mock-serious.
No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO."
Boys - "My father was a Spanish merchant, and before he went to sea
He told me I must answer ''No" to everything you said to me."
Girls - "No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO. Gay.
No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO."
1
Hamm, £2· cit., p. 161.
~~·====~===================================9~====
70
Boys - "If when walking in your garden, I should ask you to be mine
And should tell you that I love you, would you then my heart
decline?"
Girls - "No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO. Spirlted.
No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; N0. 11
No, sir; no, sir; no, sir; NO."
T. H. Bayley
2
HEAVEN
George Herbert
1 2
~~========i=========~An~s~o~r~g~e~,~E~n;l;o;yme~~n~t~,=~~o~·~c~i~t~·~·~P~·~7~3~3~·=====H~amm::~·~~~·~c~i~t~·~·~P~·~l~4:8~·~==========
71
HEAVEN (continued)
Cumulative
This type of response may best be used when the poem rises to a
climax. The plan here is to begin with a few voices and add more voices
Many poems which use the cumulative approach are often adaptable
2
GOLDENROD
1 2
Boardman, £2· cit., p. 339. HaiiiDI, £2· cit., p. 147.
"====~======================================~=====
'I
72
T ,
GOLDENROD (continued)
Dorothy Plowright
1
r-\~·========~======~H~a~mm~·~£E~·~c~i~t~··~P~·~l~OO~·~==================================~~========
73
1
~ BEATITUDES
Matthew, v, 3-10
Author Unknown
1 2
- Ibid,, p. 194. Ibid., p. 100.
~~
1.====9F==========================================~======
74
1
AN EASTER CAROL
Christina G. Rossetti
2
FOREST FIRE
Light voices - Whispers of little winds low in the leaves Begin ver
Rustle of warm wind through tall green trees, softly;
A full resinous fragrance, rich, warm, sweet, volume
A sharp acrid odor, a hint of heat. increases
as fire spreads.
1 2
sechrist, ££• cit., p. 77. Iverson, ££· £11., p. 283.
~~·==~F===================================~====
75
0====~===================================96====
76
Anonymous
1
Hilda Adams, ! Poetry Speaking Anthology (London: Methuen and Co.
Ltd., 1950), p. 171.
"'
-====~=====================================+=====
77
l
VELVET SHOES
Elinor Wylie
2
THE BELLS
~ BELLS (continued)
~ BELLS (continued)
Sectional
within one selection. It should begin with relatively simple poems and
2
~ GOBLIN
Rose Fyleman
1 2
Boardman, £2· £!!., p. 341. Arbuthnot, £2· cit., p. 185.
('====~====================================9F=====
81
1
THE BALLAD OF THE OYSTERMAN
B + G - And he has leaped into the waves, and crossed the shining
stream,
And he has clambered up the bank, all in the moonlight gleam
Oh, there were kisses, sweet as dew, and words as soft as
rain--
But they have heard her father's step, and in he leaps
again!
Solo boy - Out spoke the ancient fisherman: "Oh, what was that,
my daughter?"
Solo girl
Solo boy -
- "'Twas nothing but a pebble, sir, I threw into the water."
"And what is that, pray tell me, love, that paddles off
so fast?"
Solo girl - "It's nothing but a porpoise, sir, that's been a-swimming
past."
Solo boy - Out spoke the ancient fisherman: "Now bring me my harpoon!
I '11 get into my fishing boat, and fix the fellow soon."
~~======~~=======l~B~a~i~l~e~y~a~n~d~L~e~a~v~e~l~l~,~W~o~r~l~d~s~to;:E~x~p~lo~r~e~,~P~·~4~9~8~.~================~b:=========
- THE BALLAD .QK THE OYSTERMAN (continued)
82
All - Alas for those two loving ones! She waked not from her
swound,
And he was taken with the cramp, and in the waves was
drowned;
But Fate has metamorphosed them, in pity of their woe,
And now they keep an oyster shop for mermaids down below.
1
M KITCHEN ClDCK
~~======~======"'~w;e;l~ls;·~£2~·=cs1~·t~·~·~P~·~z~z;o~·~==================================9F=========
83
THE KITCHEN CLOCK (continued)
Take a plenty.
Billy, Milly,
Milly, Billy,
Right--left, left--right,
That's right, all right,
Knockety-nick, nickety-knock,"--
All - Goes the kitchen clock.
1
ANGUS McGREGOR
Lew Sarett
1
Iverson, .2.1?.· cit., p. 153.
('=.====+=======================================~=====
84
~ McGREGOR (continued)
Solo two - "I've battled her weather, her winds, her brutes,
I've stood with them toe to toe;
I can beat them back with my naked fist Gruffly and
And answer them blow for blow. " Carelessly
l
COLUMBUS
Joaquin Miller
~~=======i=========B=a=i=le~y==a=n=d==L=e=a=v=e=l=l=,~2£~·~c~i~t=.='=P==·=3=3=0=.==========================9F=========
1
-
f',
COLUMBUS (continued)
85
1
.!!!! LISTENERS
Walter de la Mare
"====~==================================+=====
86
~ LISTENERS (continued)
1
~EMBARRASSING EPISODE OF LITTLE MISS MUFFET
1
-~========~=========H=amm==='=~~·==c=i=t=·=·=P==·=l=5=~=~=·======================================9F=========
87
1
SALUTE TO M FLAG
Author Unknown
1
~~======~=========H=amm===·~~~·~c~i~t~·=·~P=·==l8=3=.========================================~========
88
1
1!!! OWL Mill THE PUSSY-CAT
Edward Lear
Solo 1 - "Dear Pig, are you willing to sell for one shilling
Solo 3 - Your ring?" Said the Piggy, "I will."
Class - So they took it away and were married next day
By the Turkey who lives on the hill.
1
- wells, .2.1?.· cit., p. 901.
~ ~====~============================================~=====
89
--------
THE OWL AND THE PUSSY-CAT (continued)
1
~OWL CRITIC
Solo 1; All - "Who stuffed that white owl?" No one spoke in Loudly.
the shop:
The barber was busy, and he couldn't stop;
The customers, waiting their turns, were all reading
The Daily, the Herald, the Post, little heeding
The young man who blurted out such a blunt question;
No one raised a head, or even made a suggestion;
And the barber kept on shaving.
~~=======9F=========B=a=i=l=e=y==a=n=d==L=e=av==e=l=l='=£2===·=c=1=.t==.,==p=.==3=5=4=.============================#==========
1
90
~=·====~======================================~=====
- THE OWL CRITIC (continued)
91
All - He'll sell you his fruit if you come out and buy,
But if you don't he will keep up his cry:
1st Boy Solo - "Ah got ya alligators, ripe red tomatoes,
And banana, lady, twenty-one fo' dime!"
1
~========~========H=a=mm==·~££~·~c~i~t~·=·=P==·=2=0=5=.======================================~==========
92
1
THE COBBLER
Paul Edmonds
II
1
- Ibid., p. 112.
r '~·==~====~~============================4=====
93
~
1
MUSICAL TRUST
Author Unknown
Gr. 3 - While the men with drum and the cymbal thing
Went Boom-boom-boom, zing-zing!
1
Ibid. , p . 117 .
"====9F====================================9F=====
94
Gr. 1 - Tootle-ootle,
Gr. 2 - Oom-pah!
1
PIRATE DON DURK OF OOWDEE
Boys - Ho, for the Pirate Don Durk of Dowdee! Help listeners
He was wicked as wicked could be, to "see"
Girls - But, oh, he was perfectly gorgeous to see; this
All The pirate Dan Durk of Dowdee. swaggering hero!
1
Ibid., p. 119.
r~===9F=====================================~=====
95
PIRATE DON DURK OF OOWDEE (continued)
Author Unknown
0====9F==================================~=====
96
~ WIFE (continued)
1
THE BALLAD OF DENNIS McGINTY
Dana Burnet
Solo girl - "I will marry none but a king," she said, Haughtily.
All - Wid a flash av her eye and a toss av her head;
(And she was but barely turned twinty).
And all av the lads who came ridin' down,
They smothered their sighs and wint back to town -
All excipt Dennis McGinty.
r-\~======~=========B=a=i=l=e~y==an=d==L;e=a=v=e=l=l~·~£e~O~·=C~1~·t=·~·~P=·==3=5=1=.==================~====~~========
1
- THE BALLAD Q! DENNIS McGINTY (continued)
97
Solo g. - "I will marry the bravest who comes," she sighed, Thought
"The man av most courage shall have me to bride"; fully.
All - (And she was then six-and-twinty).
And out came the weapons for miles around,
And all the lads fought till they fell to the ground -
All excipt Dennis McGinty.
1
~ LEGEND OF ~ FIRST CAM-U-EL
Arthur Guiterman
1
,..... Leiberman, 22· £!!., p. 306.
====~~==========================================4======
98
('=====+======================================~====
99
1
Iverson,~· cit., p. 368.
~~==~====================================9F=====
100
.!!Q.!i ~ Mm ~ ~ (continued)
1
THE FRIENDLY BEASTS
Author Unknown
~~=======+========~Ha~mm~~·~22~·~c~i~t~·~·~P~·~l2~8~,~====================================~f=========
1
101
1
~ MOCKINGBIRD
Maurice Lesemann
1
Ibid.' p. 129.
~~==9F==================================~=====
lr.:o'lltoh Univers'i ty ·~
~cl1o<'>l of Educatie« J
LibrarY. ~-~"'. ,..,
102
1
FABLE
Stephen Crane
All - In heaven
Some little blades of grass
Stood before God.
Dark solo - ''What did you do?"
All - Then all save one of the little blades Quickly.
Began eagerly to relate
The merits of their lives.
This one stayed a small way behind, Slow down.
Ashamed.
Presently, God said,
Dark solo - "And what did you do?"
Light solo - The little blade answered, "O my Lord,
My memory is bitter to me, Timidly.
For if I did good deeds
I know not of them."
All - Then God, in all his splendor,
Arose from his throne. Generously
Dark solo - "O best little blade of grass!" he said. and
benevolent!
Sequential
may speak individual lines and then blend together on the closing verses
~b··====~====================================~=====
I
103
1
WHERE Is MARY?
Ivy 0. Eastwick
2
THE ANIMALS I PARADE
1
Arbuthnot, .21?.· £!.!:.., p. 187.
2 Hamm, 2£· £!.!:.., p. 105.
~~==9F==================================~=====
104
Student 1 - I'n a lean dog, a keen dog, a wild dog, and lone; Allit-
2 - I 'n a rough dog, a tough dog, hunting on my own; eration
3 - I'n a bad dog, a mad dog, teasing silly sheep; Make d's
4 - I lpve to sit and bay the moon, to keep fat souls clear.
from sleep.
~~·========~========~L~e~i~b~e~rma~~n~·=2E~oe;·~c§i~t~·~·=P~·=3~04~~·==========~R~o~s~s~,~2E~·~c~i~t~·~·~P~·~3~0~8~.==~==========
1 2
105
1
TWELVE ARTICLES
Dean Swift
III
3 - When a paradox you stick to,
I will never contradict you.
IV
v
5 - When your speeches are absurd,
I will ne'er object a word.
VI
('~==~==================================4=====
106
TWELVE ARTICLES (continued)
VII
VIII
IX
XI
XII
('~==~==================================~====
107
1
COLORS
S. M. M.
Sara Coleridge
1 2
" £!!., p. 107.
HaDIIl, m!.· Ibid., p. 103.
'==9F==================================~=====
r==
108
1
SOLOKlN GRUNDY
2
! WAS ~ ARCHER
1 2
f"., Hannn, on . .£.!.._.,
"t p. 104 . Ib1"d.
=·==~~====~=~~=========================9F=====
109
1
WRITTEN ,!!! MARCH
William Wordsworth
Row 1 - The
cock is crowing, Panorama of March
Row 2 - stream is flowing,
The stretches before
Row
Row
3
4 -
- small birds twitter,
The
lake doth glitter,
The
students.
1
Hamm, .QE. .£.!!. , p . 142 •
~~··====~========================================*======
.,. ,
CHAPTER IV
SUMMARY
classes grow up liking poetry depends largely upon the teacher, how well
he has chosen the poems, how well he has read the poetry aloud, and how
Since children must hear and say poetry before they have really
had the thrill of enjoying and appreciating its richness, choral reading,
fact that choral reading may and can enrich immeasureably the student's
play in an orchestra. The great satisfaction that comes from being part
visible, for groups of all ages and abilities may happily participate
in this activity.
~~===~======================================~====
111
theoretical.
students.
book.
situations.
~~==~======================================~====
T 1
BIBLIOGRAPHY
""""====~================================~=====
113
BIBLIOGRAPHY
A. BOOKS
Arbuthnot, May Hill, Children and Books. New York: Scott, Foresman and
Company, 1947.
La Brant, Lou, We Teach English. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company,
1951.
Leiberman, Elias, editor, Poems for EnJoyment. New York: Harper and
Brothers, Publishers,~.---
Newton, Muriel B., The J!!!!! Plan for Choral Reading. Boston:
Expression Company, 1938.
~~==~======================================~====
115
Smith, Dora v., director, The English Language Arts. Prepared by the
Commission on the English Curriculum of the National Council of
Teachers of English, Volume I. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts,
Inc., 1952.
B. PERIODICALS
Nafe, Janet, "Choral Reading," The Grade Teacher, LXXI (March, 1954),
29.
~~==~======================================+=====
-
T•
APPENDIX A
INDEX OF AUTHORS
(\=·====~====================================~====
ll7
..., '
INDEX OF AUTHORS
De la Mare, Walter
Plowright, Dorothy
Poe, Edgar Allan
Eastwick, Ivy 0.
Edmonds, Paul
Estelle, Sister M. Riley, James Whitcomb
Robinson, Edward Arlington
Romig, Edna Davis
Farjeon, Eleanor Rosetti, Christina G.
Fields, James Thomas
Frost, Frances
Fyleman, Rose Sarett, Lew
Saxe, John Godfrey
Shakespeare, William
Guitermsn, Arthur Stevenson, Robert Louis
Swift, Dean
Kingsley, Charles
Whittier, John Greenleaf
Wordsworth, William
Wylie, Elinor
~~==~======================================+=====
T '
APPENDIX B
INDEX OF TITLES
~====~F=========================================~=======
119
T ,
INDEX OF TITLES
Page
Ballad......................................................... 54
Ballad of Dennis McGinty, The.................................. 96
Ballad of the Oysterman, The................................... 81
Beatitudes, The..... . . . • . . • . . . . • . • . . • . • • • . . . • . . • . . . . • . . • . • . . . . . 73
Bells, The. • . • . . . . . . . • . . . • • . . • • • . • . • . • • . • . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . • 77
Boy 1 s Mother, A. . . . . . • . . • . • . . . • • . • . • . . • . • • • • • . • . . • . • • • • • • . . . • • • 42
Bugle Song, The .•.......•..•..•..•..•••••.........•..•. ; . . • . . . . 66
Bumpety Bus ...•....•.•.• ~ .•.•..•.•..•...•••.•.. ·. . . . • . . • . . . • • . . . 55
Cherub, The. • . • . • • • • . • . • . . • . . . . • . . . . • • . • . . . . . . . . . • . • . • . . . . . . . • . 49
Christmas Pudding, The......................................... 56
Cobbler, The... • • . • . • • . • . . . • . • • . • . • . . . . • . . • • . • . . • . • . • • . . • . • • . . . 92
Colors .•••..••....•.••....•.....•.••.••.••.••.•.... :. . . • . . . • . • . 107
Co 1umbus . . . . . . • . . . • . . • . . • . • • . • . . . . • . • • . • . . • . • . . • . . • • • . • • . • • . . • • 84
Come Quick, Msry Anne.. . • . . • . . . • . . . . • • . • . • . . . • • • • • • . • . • . . • . . • . • 73
Fable. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102
Father •................ ~ ....................................... 37
Fs,ther William ••.•.......••.•...••••..•.... ,................... 60
Fat ~ife......... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95
Forest Fire. . . • • • • • • • • . • . . • . • • • . • • • . . • • • • • . • . . . . ... • . • . . . . . . • . . . 74
Friday Street •.•••...••.•.••.••••.•. , • . • . . . . • . . • . . • . . . . • • . . . . . . 68
Friendly Beasts, The........................................... 100
From Macbeth................................................... 44
Goblin, The..................................................... 80
Goldenrod ....................................... :.............. 71
Green Umbrella, The ••.••••.••••.••••••.......•..••....••.••• ;.. 51
~~======~F==I=t==W=a=s==a==L=o=v=e=r==a=n=d==H=i=s==L=a=s=s=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=···=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·~·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·====44====~===========
120
Page
No ~ ........................................................... . 45
No, Sir ! ..................................................... . 69
Not Just for the Ride 0 •••••••••• 0 •••• 0 •••••••••• 0 • 0 ••••••••••• 39
I""'\
=====9~============================~============~=====
121
r '
Page
Uphill ........................................................ . 59
~b·====~======================================~=====
APPENDIX C
r'~==~====================================~=====
-
'I' '
123
Page
Page
''You are old, Father William," the young man said •.• , .•.••.•••• 60
~=·===9F===================================~====
-
APPENDIX D
""=====+=========+============================+=====
.I
127
Page
Ballad...................... . . . . • . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54
Ballad of Dennis McGinty, The., .•••• , ............... ,........... 96
Ballad of the Oysterman, The .............. ,..................... 81
Bumpety Bus •••••••. ·• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • . • • • . • . • • • • • • • • • • . • • 55
'Goldenrod....................................................... 71
Green Umbrella, The............................................. 51
No, Sir!........................................................ 69
Not Just for the Ride ........•........•......•............ :...... 39
Old Woman........................................................ 68
Organ Recital ••••.•••••..•..• , • • • . • • • • . • • • • . • • . . • . • • . • • . • . . • • • • . 61
OwlCritic,The ••••.•.• : •...•.•...•••••.••.••........•.••.•••••• 89
~====~==================================~=====
128
T ,
Page
~~==~======================================~====
-
APPENDIX E
~~==9F==================================~=====
.,.. . 130
Page
Heaven • •••.••••••..••• 70
How Cyrus Laid the Cable •• • ••••• 0 • 99
Listeners, The.
Long, Long Ago.
...... •
•
••••••
• • • • •
0 • • •
•
•••••••••
•••• 0 ••• 0
0
••••
•••••••
0 • 0 •
85
70
Pumpkin, The ..•..•.. ... . . . ....... .. ...... ... ... .... . .. . . ... .. ... 46
~=====*==========================~~==========~======
131
Page
~====~==========================================~=====
-
APPENDIX F.
INDEX BY SUBJECTS
~~===4======================================~F=====
134
Page
Holidays
Humor
Page
Parents
Patriotism
'
People
Seasons
Silence
~b·====~========================================~=====
133
INDEX BY SUBJECTS
Page
Bible
Evening
Silver.......................................................... 47
Six Poets Gazed upon the Moon. . • • • • • • • • • . . • • • . • • . • • . • . • • • • . • • • • • 104
Slwnber Song ...........•...................... ·.................. 40
Song at Dusk........... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39
Famous People
Page
States and Places
Transportation
Bumpety Bus. . • • . • . • . . . • • . • . • . . • . . • . • • . . . . . . • • . . . . . . • . • . • . . . . . . . • 55
Weather
Wind, The....................................................... 50
Youth
~b·-·===9~===================================9P=====
-
APPENDIX G
~'~==9F==================================~=====
138
Page
Reflections Dental •• 47
....... .
••• 0 ••
Imagiilation
..........
Velvet Shoes. 77
Wind, The ....•.. .... . ........ . ........ . 50
Comparisons
~========~==E=a=s=t=e=r==C=a=r=o=l=,==An==·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·=·f======·=·=··=·=·=·=·=========7=4==~~=========
139
Character Studies
Rhythm
Sounds
"====~====================================9F=====
140