1 HowToImportProductsFromChinaMoreSuccessfully PDF
1 HowToImportProductsFromChinaMoreSuccessfully PDF
1 HowToImportProductsFromChinaMoreSuccessfully PDF
1
How To Import From China More Successfully
Table of Contents
Establishing Communication.........................................................15
About Tariffs...............................................................................16
2
How To Import From China More Successfully
Factory Tours.............................................................................25
Quality Control............................................................................26
Delivery Times............................................................................27
Subcontracting...........................................................................27
Shipping....................................................................................28
Payment Terms...........................................................................29
Negotiating Prices.......................................................................29
3
How To Import From China More Successfully
Selection Considerations..............................................................40
Inspection Frequency...................................................................41
Rejected Goods...........................................................................48
Obtaining an L/C.........................................................................62
A Better Strategy........................................................................69
4
How To Import From China More Successfully
Capacity Constraints....................................................................76
Starting Early.............................................................................80
Rework Scenarios........................................................................86
5
How To Import From China More Successfully
Importing from China presents businesses both big and small with an
outstanding opportunity to greatly increase profit margins and still offer
fantastic products at prices consumers are anxious to pay. The big guys
might buy massive amounts of products at incredibly lower prices for the
mass markets but there are phenomenal opportunities for small and
medium size business to make fantastic buys of smaller quantities that
still bring huge profits.
6
How To Import From China More Successfully
who want to buy them. As an importer and retailer, you know the first
rule to success is knowing your customer(s) and what they will pay
handsomely for.
If you only follow what your competitors are already pursuing, you will
end up importing too many “Me Too” products. Too much competition
drives your profits down. The real China importing opportunity is the right
product at rock bottom prices. Therefore, by all means, avoid looking for
products that are already being imported by large buying organizations
like retail chain stores, department stores or specialized importers with
their own distribution channels. It will prove too difficult for you to
compete with their buying power and their own buying offices in China.
7
How To Import From China More Successfully
minute video explaining in detail how to use the program and where to
find the latest trends.
Trendy products allow you to pull in huge profits when you are among the
first importing them to your home country. The key is moving fast,
otherwise the selected products are already out of fashion.
The market frequently changes and products which you sold for a couple
of years, a decade ago, now may have a life cycle no longer than 8
months or so. This also explains why you must go and visit Chinese
manufacturers more frequently to avoid missing the latest developments.
You need to know in advance what’s in the pipeline and who else other
than the manufactures can tell you.
8
How To Import From China More Successfully
Since you know that you have to move fast, you better start with
preparations for your corporate identity by establishing your own brand
name and gift box design.
Creating your own gift box design may seem like wasting money since
many manufacturers can also provide you with their own design (usually
a very simple one) at no extra charge. Unfortunately, they will provide
this service to everyone who is asking for it and these goods may even
enter your home market without your knowledge. You just become
another look alike retailer in a crowed field.
The result is more competition and you become unable to achieve your
planned profit margin. In other words, you wasted a lot of time and
money without benefiting from it.
9
How To Import From China More Successfully
established brand name owner after you have distributed your imported
products in your home country.
Ask a lawyer to do this for you because they have the tools to do
thorough research and can register your brand name for either worldwide
or only local use. Theoretically, your chosen brand name may only be
available for a certain kind of product, but I suggest choosing one that
can be used for a wide range of products. This supports your future
expansion strategy and you don’t want to be stopped by not having the
suitable brand name to do so.
Once you have created a nice and professional looking gift box design,
there is always the risk that some factory or other importer may copy it
and use it for other customers not necessarily in your home country.
There is not much you can do about it but you now can see why your own
brand name is so important. Do everything you can to protect it from the
beginning. When you become hugely successful, it will be very valuable.
At this point, your gift box design is only a concept about color
combinations, graphics, use of photos, etc. The final design can be only
created after you have finalized your product selection.
10
How To Import From China More Successfully
Identifying suitable suppliers in China is not easy because there are tens
of thousands of them and you cannot visit everyone. First of all, you must
filter down to the suppliers which may have the products which you want
to import.
Alibaba is by far the largest one of these companies. Each company not
only provides you with search engines but they are also involved in
arranging exhibitions in China and overseas. Additionally, they publish
monthly magazines that you can and should subscribe to, after you have
found your market niche and know exactly what you are looking for.
11
How To Import From China More Successfully
At this stage, you may not be aware that many of the companies in your
search results (mostly the better-organized ones) are not manufacturers
but in fact are trading companies or agents. This is not necessarily bad if
you are new to importing because they can provide services that the
factory is unwilling to provide.
If you have a large enough buying volume, I strongly suggest you to buy
directly from the factory, simply because it is cheaper. Also in the case of
a claim, you can more easily deal with the factory directly than through a
middleman.
12
How To Import From China More Successfully
I believe there is no need to teach you how to write your inquiry e-mails
because you are already in business and know which questions have to be
asked. The communication nowadays is much easier than 10 years ago.
Today, most factories employ marketing or sales managers who can
communicate reasonably well in business English.
13
How To Import From China More Successfully
Let me give you some help for your decision with the pros and cons of
buying from a middleman. Buying factory direct or through a middleman
both have their merits and you have to ask yourself what is more
important for you.
Pros and Cons of Working With Middlemen
Pros
• Easier communication for you with a single contact for several
factories
• They usually have a better showroom for product selection
• They are experienced in dealing with customers from different
countries
• They sometimes invest in their own tooling and therefore have their
own products
• Their staff is more proficient in English which makes discussions and
negotiations easier
Cons
• Their prices are less competitive because you have to pay for their
service
• They may not be able to present you with the latest products
because they choose not taking the risk to be first
• They will try directing you to certain factories because they have
trade agreements with them
• Solving claims through their help may prove more difficult due to
the relationship with their factories. Since they have projects to
execute for other customers, their factories may be more important
to them than your business.
In some cases, you will be forced to work with an export agent simply
because the factory does not have an export license or does not want to
invest in extra marketing personnel.
14
How To Import From China More Successfully
Establishing Communication
After you have browsed the sourcing search engines and narrowed your
selection down to a handful of suppliers you must start communicating
with them for price inquiries and gathering information about new
developments they have in their pipeline.
At this stage, you will find out which factories or suppliers are more
responsive and show a better understanding of your needs. If they do not
reply as expected at this early stage, how can you expect them to reply
quickly later on, after you have placed your orders to them? In most
cases, you will however experience that their response is reasonably
good. Some companies are also using Skype or MSN Messenger as an
additional means for communication, which makes the communication
more personal.
15
How To Import From China More Successfully
It is also a good idea to visit their online bookshop and find out which
books you may need for staying on top in following subjects:
• Model Commercial eBooks
• Trade Reference eBooks
• International Banking eBooks
• Institute of World Business Law eBooks
About Tariffs
Here is a link to the different import tariffs for most countries. It is
essential you familiarize yourself with the details because it is needed for
your cost calculation - you cannot expect that every factory knows the
details for your import costs.
16
How To Import From China More Successfully
After you have familiarized yourself with the Incoterms and the Customs
Tariffs, you want to establish your import calculation scheme for the
selected products.
Other Costs
This may seem to you like too much bureaucracy, but believe me, it is
necessary if you want to become successful with your import business.
Before you travel to China, you must do some homework and do your
calculation for the different products you want to import, otherwise
negotiations will be much more time consuming.
You already have a rough idea of the achievable buying price from your
recent communications with the suppliers but of course, rough means not
final. You should do some reverse calculating because you need an idea at
what price you can sell larger quantities in your home country at the
highest possible profit margin for your company. Based on that price, you
will do your reverse calculation by taking into consideration all costs that
apply - only then can you arrive at your ideal buying price.
If you want to negotiate better prices from your factories, you need to
first decide which buying terms will apply.
The Incoterms most commonly chosen by importers are FOB and CIF.
FOB
This stands for Free On Board and its terms are:
• Carriage to be arranged by the buyer
• Risks transfer from seller to buyer when goods pass the ship’s rail
17
How To Import From China More Successfully
• Costs transfer from the seller to the buyer when the goods pass the
ship’s rail
CIF
This stands for Cost, Insurance, and Freight and its terms are:
• Carriage and insurance to be arranged by the seller
• Risks transfer from seller to buyer when goods pass the ship’s rail
• Costs transfer at port of destination with buyer paying such costs as
are not for the seller’s account under the contract of carriage
Most importers will choose buying at FOB prices because it allows them
more flexibility in choosing their own freight forwarder, insurance
company, and a greater transparency of total costs.
Once you have built up a business relationship with your forwarder you
can expect preferential treatment and receive early warnings. For
instance, if there is an indication that the freight rates will go up in near
future.
The same applies to the insurance costs, which you can reduce by
negotiating better terms with insurance companies in your home country.
18
How To Import From China More Successfully
Here is a comparison of buyer & seller responsibilities for FOB versus CIF:
19
How To Import From China More Successfully
20
How To Import From China More Successfully
I strongly advise you against this and will explain why. My more than 25
years experience of importing goods from China has taught me otherwise.
You will usually deal with smaller or medium size factories which need
clear instructions from you and this is best done by meeting face-to-face.
One of the issues working with a middleman or agency is that they may
be knowledgeable about a wide variety of products, but not necessarily
sufficiently experienced in any of them. In the end, there is no way of
getting around the fact that the Chinese mentality favors frequent
personal contact with overseas trading partners and visiting their factory
is the way to go.
21
How To Import From China More Successfully
By visiting your preselected factories, you can make your decisions about
whom you want to strike a deal with after concluding your negotiations.
During your factory visits, you will be in for many surprises and you may
have to revise the first judgment you arrived at from previous
communication with some of the factories. You will find that some
factories are smaller than expected and have only a limited production
capacity available on their own premises. They do not want to miss out on
your orders and hire a subcontractors to produce for them instead.
22
How To Import From China More Successfully
Since the transportation takes a lot of time, you are well advised to make
inquiries first with your factories for their exact locations. If you set your
schedule according to their suggestions, you can save substantial time,
which is better spent in discussions.
There is really no excuse for not having enough business cards with you.
In all major cities, there are print shops that can print your name cards
for you in a very short time. It looks very unprofessional if you cannot
hand out enough name cards to your negotiation partners.
23
How To Import From China More Successfully
24
How To Import From China More Successfully
The notebook computer saves precious time once you are back home or
you could send your daily reports to your head office for further
instructions or recommendations.
Try to learn the position your contact person occupies in the management
hierarchy, along with who is in control of the factory, and who makes final
decisions. This is important because the Chinese may want to delay
decisions and will tell you that they have to wait for the decision maker
who is not available. Since the whole concept of visiting the factories is to
reach your final conclusion about who will be selected as your business
partner in future, it is understandable that you need to talk to competent
decision makers and not middle managers.
Factory Tours
After arriving at the factory, you will be shown around the premises. Be
sure to take your time studying the production lines, their QC
arrangements, and the amount of technical equipment the factory is
using. Additionally you must check whether the factory is complying with
the Chinese labor laws, which prohibit the use of child labor and
excessively long work hours. It is important to include a clause in your
P/O later to protect your own interest. Since you are only asking the
factory to comply with existing laws, there is nothing wrong with it.
25
How To Import From China More Successfully
When the factory manager walks you through the building(s), you should
check out what is in production currently and who the customer is. Ask to
see packing materials or shipping samples. These give you a clue about
who else is buying from that factory. Sometimes factory management
may be reluctant to disclose that information but they cannot stop their
production to prevent you from seeing it.
Don’t be shy about taking photos. You should ask before but I have
seldom been prevented from doing so.
Quality Control
Seek out their QC management to learn about QC processes for defective
products. Are problems simply registered, without taking any further
action? Or are they proactively working to eliminate the cause of defects.
It could be that a single less experienced worker is creating the problem
and if this worker is not replaced, the problem will continue and cost the
factory money because they have to rework the products or simply
through them away.
Whether the factory has achieved ISO 9000 or ISO 9001 certification is
not so important as long as they take action to improve their production
quality on continuous basis.
26
How To Import From China More Successfully
If you want to import to the EC, the factory must only deliver products
that comply with the ROHS directives, otherwise you would get into deep
trouble. If they say there is no problem, ask them how they can
guarantee it. You can also ask them to provide lab certificates or in case
of electronic products, they must be able to show you their existing
approval certificates from internationally recognized labs. You should
refrain from accepting certificates from local Chinese labs because they
are difficult to verify.
Delivery Times
You need to ask the factory management about their delivery time during
the low and peak seasons so that you have clear information about how
long it will take to have your products shipped out. It is also good to ask
them about their present order situation, which gives you an indication
how well or poorly the factory is performing. If they do not have many
orders, there should be an understandable reason. Good or bad, it is
important for your decision-making. If the factory won’t tell you, there is
a chance that their competitors know which proves one more time how
important it is to visit the factories in person. A middleman may have his
own interest in mind and would not inform you.
Subcontracting
Another very important factor is whether the factory needs outside help
for some production processes, these can include plastic injection
molding, metal punching, painting, PCB injection, etc., or whether they
can do everything in house. If a major part of the production cannot be
done in house, there is always the risk that they cannot completely
control the plastic injection factory and receive their plastic parts too late
for timely assembly.
27
How To Import From China More Successfully
Factories are usually very reluctant to let you visit their subcontractors
and for good reason. They work for other factories as well and the
managers don’t want to introduce you to competitors you are not
currently considering.
Shipping
Since factories sometimes use different ports of loading, you need to
inquire which one is usually used because the applicable freight charges
will apply and you need that information to calculate your landed cost
properly. Some ports will only have one vessel departing per week and
you must know this in advance when planning shipments for promotions.
I should not forget to mention that some products should only be shipped
by airfreight. Notebook computers and MP3 players are typical examples.
The key components of these products are ICs that fluctuate in price and
at present, their prices are in constant decline. Buyers must therefore
receive their goods quickly. Otherwise they will not be able to make any
profit because the buying price could exceed the achievable selling price
in their home country. Shipments by air are therefore unavoidable.
28
How To Import From China More Successfully
Payment Terms
When discussing the payment terms with factory management, ask them
for their banking details which allows you to do some background
checking before you place orders with them.
Finally, you need to negotiate the payment terms, which are usually by
irrevocable letter of credit at sight (L/C). This is usually the safest way to
pay the factory and also allows them to obtain loans from their bank to
start production on time.
Never ever let the factory convince you to remit a down payment of let’s
say 20 or 30% of the total order volume by T/T to them to enable them to
start your production. Ask yourself why are they asking for this? There is
only one reason, which is that the factory has no money and obviously no
other orders. They want to jumpstart their production with your cash. If
something goes wrong and the likelihood is rather great, you will lose
your money and never receive a shipment.
Negotiating Prices
Now you can negotiate your prices with the factory. Inform them about
your requested specifications, quality standards, and terms. Otherwise
you will receive very competitive prices but for a substandard quality
which will cost you dearly later on.
29
How To Import From China More Successfully
Many importers use the Pantone Color Chart numbers to inform the
factory about their color or color combination requirement. I can tell you
from my experience that the results will not be very good. Especially if
you have several factories involved which need to meet your color
specifications. It is much more practical and produces better results,
when you use color chips instead. You can buy items having the correct
color in your home country and cut off pieces of the plastic material.
Always keep several reference samples for yourself and handover to each
factory a piece of a reasonable size. Reasonable does not mean a
thumbnail sized one because it is not large enough for the factory to
make the injection color accurately.
Not only will there be little or no warranty but worse, you risk serious
legal action and possibly a criminal conviction if you cannot show proof of
ownership of the brand name or an agreement with the brand owner
when you import. You have been warned now and please don’t even
30
How To Import From China More Successfully
Your request automatically sets the standards for the sample preparation,
mass production, and inspection. You now understand why negotiations
should be done in person by talking to the responsible managers.
If you use identical procedures for all your negotiations; you will receive
directly comparable quotations from the different factories to make your
choice from.
Since you will visit one or more factories on the same day or soon after,
you will have a pretty good impression about their performance, which
also needs to be considered besides the price for your important decision
making.
31
How To Import From China More Successfully
After making your decision about which factory to contract with, order
your product samples but plan to evaluate them once you return home.
You have reached a turning point in your own quality control. The first
step was your scrutiny of each factory visited during the trip. You should
have a good idea how each factory will perform and how talented their
management is.
Imagine that you did not pay adequate attention to instructing the factory
about your sample requirements and they prepare the sample according
their own factory standards. As mentioned before, timing is important and
you need the samples checked for compliance with your requirements in
your home country. It needs to be right the first time.
If the first sample is incorrect, you could take a risk and place your orders
in hopes that the factory will get it right the second time. It is not a good
32
How To Import From China More Successfully
idea to take the risk because there cannot be a guarantee that the factory
will actually follow your new instructions.
Never place any order with new suppliers before you receive acceptable
samples of the proper quality and they have been approved by your QC
people or an authorized lab. Anything else is a gamble and you don’t want
to begin production with that level of risk. Only after establishing a sound
business relationship with your suppliers, can you be confident the factory
will closely follow your instructions. It is important to set things right from
the very beginning.
With this information, you can calculate the freight cost. It may be
necessary to change the sales packaging size in order to fit more pieces
into one container and save substantial freight charges. It makes a big
difference if you can pack for 1,400 coffeemakers in a 40’ container
instead of only 1,200 pieces and it will certainly affect your selling price.
33
How To Import From China More Successfully
That is only the beginning of a long list and believe me, large buying
offices like hypermarkets, department stores, and other large volume
importers ask for even more samples because they are aware of the
extensive need when introducing a new product.
The worst-case scenario is if you give the only color reference sample to a
key customer and after they place an order with you, you cannot
34
How To Import From China More Successfully
Besides the sample charges, you will be asked to pay the freight charges
for the sample delivery. This can get expensive because samples are
usually sent by air courier in order to make up lost lead-time and stay on
schedule. Factories don’t want to pay for these charges and it is often
difficult to convince them to do so. If they do so, it is usually only after a
successful business relationship has been established.
If you need the samples urgently and is that usually the case, you are
better advised to look for a compromise otherwise you may lose the
competitive edge in your home market.
35
How To Import From China More Successfully
However, if you have the feeling during your visit that this is not the best
factory, simply shorten your visit and focus on the next factory, which
may be more qualified. We are not living in a perfect world and you
cannot expect all factories to be acceptable.
A first hand visit quickly teaches you which are factories to do business
with and which you want to avoid. You can do it the hard way and place
your orders without a visit but chances are high a mistake will be made.
The cost of a bad production shipment will cost much more than the cost
of a personal visit to China.
The Chinese understand that you cannot fly in every time something
needs attention. You can always hire an in country agent to attend to
future activities but if you are going to be an importer from China, it is
vital to occasionally visit and develop a good relationship with your
factories.
36
How To Import From China More Successfully
After returning from your business trip to China, you will be very busy
evaluating the huge amount of information collected during the trip. As
suggested before, you will have a much easier task if you used a
notebook computer and can print all information at once. If you sent daily
reports, your job becomes even easier because most of your information
has already been processed by your staff or colleagues during your trip.
Monitoring Progress
As you have learned already, timing is important. Therefore, your
company must track progress of the samples to make sure they ship on
time. According to my experience, most samples will be delayed in one
way or another. There are several reasons for it but one of the main
reasons is that nobody really likes to handle samples because it is not
productive and therefore this job is often passed to someone at the lower
end of the factory hierarchy.
The factory managers may have promised you to deliver the samples at a
certain date but they are not making them and have to wait until their
sample production staff completes them. You are well advised to monitor
progress closely otherwise, you may not be able to recover from the
delay. The one who cries the loudest will be heard first.
Without approved samples, you cannot place orders, confirm orders with
customers, or begin a sales promotion. In other words, you will lose
turnover and the chance to sell products at maximum profit margin.
Unfortunately, this step in the product creation chain is frequently
underestimated. Now that you are aware of it, get your sample act
together.
37
How To Import From China More Successfully
Only after all the samples arrive can you start the evaluation. Check
whether the samples meet every specific requirement, e.g. are the colors
correct, is the size as requested, and did you receive the correct number
of products and samples. Depending how complex the products being
imported are, you may elect having the samples evaluated by your own
QC department or a special authorized lab.
The numerous recent cases of lead paint tainted toys gives you an idea
of what you are in for if you neglect your responsibility for thorough
sample evaluation. Household items are easier to check than more
sophisticated electrical home appliances or consumer electronics products.
Always bear in mind that the submitted samples represent the standard
that will be used during mass production.
At this stage, you have several key data points to make your decisions
easier:
• Price quote
• Sample performance
• Factory performance
• Your impression of factory management during your visit
38
How To Import From China More Successfully
If a price discrepancy remains between your target prices and the quoted
prices it will be relatively easy to convince the selected factories to
improve their quote. This should become your standard practice because
some factories do not quote the very best price at the first meeting. After
visiting China, it is probably fine calling the factory manager to negotiate
a better price by phone because it is faster and you have met him in
person. Given a good reason why you need a better price, he will seldom
refuse to negotiate.
Remember to be fair and inform the other factories that you will not be
placing any orders with them. Keep in mind you may decide to place a
future order with them and want to be on good business terms.
Factory performance can change very quickly for the better or for the
worse. A change of management can sometimes do wonders. Never take
for granted that a factory will maintain the same level of performance as
you experienced during a previous visit. That means you must not say:
“Been there, have seen it all” and take no further action. Doing business
with China is a constant evaluation process and only the one that
understands the game stays on top.
39
How To Import From China More Successfully
When verifying the quality of goods imported from China you have three
choices to consider.
• Let the manufacturer perform a self inspection
• Have someone in your company perform the inspection
• Appoint a third party inspection agency to perform the
inspection for you
Selection Considerations
If you really want to be on the safe side, I would not suggest letting any
manufacturer check their own quality. It is much too risky and you will
only find out after the goods have already arrived at your warehouse that
something is wrong and by then it is too late.
40
How To Import From China More Successfully
usually familiar with the area and may even speak the local dialect, which
makes the communication with the factory staff easier.
It is also obvious that they can visit your factory much faster because
they are in the vicinity. This becomes important when an inspection has
previously failed and the re-inspection needs to be conducted only1 or 2
days later. Usually the factory has to pay the re-inspection charges after
failing an original inspection due to the factory’s own fault. If the re-
inspection charges are too high because of extraordinary travel expenses
from your inspection agency’s head office, you are in for lengthy
negotiations with the factory. They will argue and try to avoid the
payment. In other words, the practical decision is appointing an
inspection agency that already has offices near major production centers.
Inspection Frequency
Depending on the size and importance of the order volume, you may want
to consider more than a single inspection after production is complete.
There are three primary inspection methods you can choose from.
This inspection method is used mostly when the order volume is very
large and production needs to be closely monitored from the very
beginning to assure the delivery deadline will be met.
41
How To Import From China More Successfully
The benefits of an Initial Production Inspection are that the status of the
production can be verified at every stage. If problems are found early,
there is still time to take corrective action and prevent the early problems
from affecting the entire order. Since the production is already in
progress, you will have a clear picture of the factory’s performance at that
time.
The benefits of a During Production Inspection are that the status of the
production can be verified at this stage. By performing this inspection you
can verify that corrections have been implemented since the Initial
Production Inspection. Additionally you will still have a chance to apply
other corrective actions before the final inspection.
42
How To Import From China More Successfully
The benefits of a Final Random Inspection are that usually the most
serious defects or deviations from given specifications will be detected
and any shipment can be stopped at this stage. However since this
inspection is already close to the actual shipment date, there is a risk that
the scheduled shipment date cannot be met which could cause serious
problems if the requested re-work is impossible or takes considerable
time. In other words, a Final Random Inspection alone prior to releasing a
shipment may not prevent or uncover risks that might appear at earlier
stages of the production process.
43
How To Import From China More Successfully
However, I assume that you and/or your staff did a very good job by
giving the full information to your factory and that the factory also closely
followed your requirements. Therefore, it is the right time to provide at
least one sample together with all your specifications and requirements to
the inspection company of your choice.
Since this inspection company will act on your behalf as your savior in
case of a non-compliant production, it is very obvious that you must feed
them all the information you have to let them do the job. This is even
more important when your product is more complex like home appliances
and consumer electronic products.
Please consider that they can only follow the general inspection
procedures and your specific requirements. If you do not inform the
inspection agent about certain details, they will not take the necessary
action and can’t be blamed.
44
How To Import From China More Successfully
The inspection company prepares a checklist which you have to verify and
at this stage you can still make corrections.
Home appliances make a good example. Some years ago, Toasters were
operated without any bread during the inspection. Nobody cared to test
whether bread was toasted consistently from top to bottom and side to
side. That has completely changed because end consumers have also
become more demanding and don’t accept slices of toast bread where the
top completely burned and the bottom is still white.
Some years ago coffee makers were operated without ground coffee and
it was sufficient when the boiled water dripped into the glass jar proving
the coffee maker was functioning properly. Today inspections are
conducted with ground coffee along with paper or permanent filters in
order to simulate a normal operation. Only then, can the inspector
45
How To Import From China More Successfully
discover whether the coffee will run fast enough through the filter and
coffee without overflowing.
You should get the point about how much effort is necessary to inspect
products to make sure that they meet the consumer’s expectations for
day-to-day use. Therefore, you will understand that only an experienced
inspection company can cope with ever-changing requirements and
directives. It makes no sense to employ someone without this experience
but who may charge less.
After you have selected your inspection company and they have received
your sample(s) you must provide them with a copy of your P/O. It is
advisable to blank out the FOB prices because inspectors could be
tempted to pass such information to competitors.
In general, you should know there are not many secrets in China.
Inspectors frequently run into counterparts from other companies when
performing their job at several different factories. It may well be that they
have lunch together (usually provided by the factory) and talk shop. And
talk they will. Important information spreads faster than you can imagine.
FOB prices are not necessarily something you want discussed among
inspectors. Don’t give them the chance by showing it on your P/O copies.
46
How To Import From China More Successfully
After everything is clear, you will book your inspection(s) with your
inspection company. This is usually done by filling out an online
application form. Follow this link to view a sample booking form for the
major Hong Kong quality control company Hong Kong Standards and
Testing Centre
Application Form
Booking the inspection must be arranged at least 5-7 working days prior
to the estimated date of production completion or at least the date when
80% of your production will have been completed. It is very important to
know, that the inspector will refuse to perform an inspection if the total
completed production quantity is less than 80% and if the products have
not been packed in their sales packaging and export cartons. The factory
will be charged for the inspector’s expense for the failed inspection.
Following this link provides more details about the sampling plan
procedure:
http://www.itl.nist.gov/div898/handbook/pmc/section2/pmc231.htm
47
How To Import From China More Successfully
That is easy to understand and usually you do not need to take further
action when the result is “Passed”. I can however tell you, that
unfortunately you will have more “Rejected” results than “Passed”.
Rejected Goods
Be very careful about making a decision releasing rejected goods for
shipment. Once the shipment is on its way, there is not much what you
can do to protect your own interests. As mentioned before, manufacturers
will always try to convince you that the cause for the rejection was a
48
How To Import From China More Successfully
minor one and you should not worry. The factory may also offer you a
compensation payment (minor price reduction) to convince you. It is up
to you to accept it but please be aware that the labor cost in your home
country is much higher than in China and if you are faced with a claim
from your customers, the small compensation will not even cover your
own cost.
The normal procedure is for the factory to rework the rejected goods
within a couple of days and a re-inspection will be called for. The re-
inspection is always on the manufacturer’s account because they created
the problem by lack of performance.
There could be many disputes about the reasons for the rejection if you
did not provide clear information about your requested specifications,
standards, and specific requirements. Be aware that you immediately
change the rules when you release goods with a lower than requested
quality standard. The factory will take note, that an on-time delivery is
more important to you than the quality and act accordingly during the
next production run.
49
How To Import From China More Successfully
The good thing is that the factory has to comply because if they ship
goods without having received the Inspection Certificate (this happens
sometimes) they will not be paid from your bank if you included such
clause in your L/C. You would be then in a much stronger negotiation
position because it would be up to you when the factory would receive
their payment.
I believe I have covered the most important points and you will find more
in my other eBooks, for instance How to assure Quality of imports from
China.
50
How To Import From China More Successfully
Most have offices in other Chinese or Asian cities and will provide an
excellent service for you.
51
How To Import From China More Successfully
Before placing your Purchase Order (P/O), be sure to you check one more
time about the earliest possible delivery date. Circumstances change and
you delivery is an essential part of your Purchase order along with the
price.
52
How To Import From China More Successfully
You should also know it is the factory’s discretion who gets their goods
first. It is primarily an economic decision and a matter of good
relationships between the factory and their customers. Please bear in
53
How To Import From China More Successfully
mind, if you squeeze your factory too much for lower prices, you will be
automatically allocated a later production slot, and there is nothing you
can do about it.
When you issue your P/O to the factory, it is typically your last chance to
negotiate prices.
54
How To Import From China More Successfully
• Guarantee clause
• Indemnification clauses
• Late delivery clause
• Transshipment clause
• Clause for compliance with requirements in your home country
• Information whether goods must be inspected and by whom
• A clear statement that the mass production must comply with the
submitted and approved samples
However, don’t overdo it. I have seen P/Os which could have been issued
by lawyers and you can imagine that factories don’t make the effort to
employ lawyers just for the sake of checking P/Os. Remember, it’s all
about partnership and if you are still afraid the factory will cheat you,
your factory evaluation was not thorough enough.
Here are additional comments about what must be included in your P/Os:
1. Order quantity - Should match the container loading capacity or the
total quantity of products in case you want to place different
products from the same factory in one container.
2. Packaging information - Very important because it is a cost for the
factory and could be manipulated in their favor. There are for
instance several levels of corrugated cardboard quality. These are
measured in grams per square meter. If you did not specify the
weight you could end up with a 2-layer corrugated cardboard sheet
which is so thin that you could easily punch a hole through with
your fist. This quality is unacceptable for a sales packaging because
you cannot stack sufficient cartons on top of each other. The
barcode information is also very important because the inspector
has to verify it during the inspection. If a barcode scanner cannot
read the barcode properly, the product cannot be registered during
checkout by the hypermarket/supermarket cashier. Companies like
55
How To Import From China More Successfully
Wal*Mart consider this a major defect and would not allow any
shipment under such conditions.
3. Spare parts or spare units - This depends on what kind of products
you import. For technical products, you can negotiate 1 or 2% of
free spare parts/spare units included in the buying price. The
factory will of course calculate it. If these goods come without a
guarantee or service agreement, you had better negotiate net
prices.
4. Defective rate - Putting a clause in your P/O will help to protect
your compensation claim in case of epidemic defects or overall poor
product performance. It splits responsibilities between the factory
and your company. Nobody can demand that production be
completely without faults and defects. Therefore, it is fair enough to
allow the factory a certain percentage of defects as an upper ceiling
limit. You have to negotiate this and usually the factory will have
some historic figures in mind. Everything exceeding this percentage
will be the factory’s responsibility. You may say I will employ a good
inspection company, which will help me to protect my interests.
That may be true but there is still a risk that something has been
overlooked or a defect shows up later in time. You can imagine that
this could become very expensive because there will be
compensation claims from your customers or demands for price
reductions.
5. Guarantee clause - Most countries have laws protecting the end
consumer’s rights and provide them with a guarantee period of
anything between 1-2 years. In some cases, retailers even have
extended this guarantee period by another year. Three years is a
long time for some products with a limited life cycle. Because it is a
legal requirement (except the additional year offered by retailers)
you must comply and protect your interests by adding a clause in
your P/O. This gives you the right to ask the factory for
compensation. Most factories however will not accept these clauses
56
How To Import From China More Successfully
57
How To Import From China More Successfully
outlets, you may be in for a surprise when they find that the goods
you supplied do not comply with local directives or laws. You should
not assume that all factories are fully aware of all requirements in
your home country. The opposite is mostly true. You, as the
importer, are responsible to import only goods which comply with
your countries laws and you must protect your company from
damage for non-compliance by adding a clause in your P/O.
9. Information whether goods must be inspected and by whom - This
clause is easy. If you want the goods to be inspected, which I
strongly recommend, then you have to inform the factory about the
details. The inspection procedure was previously explained Chapter
11.
10. Information that mass production must comply with the submitted
and approved samples - As already mentioned several times before,
you set the quality standard by approving the samples and must
enforce it now by not allowing the factory to produce anything else.
If you are lenient in this request, your efforts evaluating the
samples and factory will have been a waste of time.
Please be aware that any P/O is only legally binding after an authorized
factory representative signs it. Sometimes factories delay signing for quite
some time. In that case, the best solution is calling the person in charge
to ask what is going on. There could be a reason for the delay but the
factory will try to change the delivery date. Therefore, act immediately
rather than waiting in good faith.
58
How To Import From China More Successfully
Other than adding your specific terms, try to write P/Os which are easily
understood and are no longer than 2-3 pages. Anything else becomes too
complicated and requires too much effort on both sides to read and
comprehend. You should be able to establish the P/O format one time and
then copy and paste the contents for other products without starting from
scratch.
59
How To Import From China More Successfully
Product Liability Insurance indemnifies the insured against all sums which
the insured becomes legally liable to pay in respect of accidental bodily
injury or illness to third parties, and accidental loss of or damage to third
party property, arising out of the use, misuse, consumption, or handling
of insured products or goods.
You may believe that your products are flawless. But have you thought
about misuse? In some jurisdictions, even the deliberate misuse of a
product can be a basis for a liability claim.
Therefore, you may want to check with one of your insurance companies
about Product Liability Insurance they can offer to you. This may be
especially important if you are considering importing electrical or
electronic goods.
60
How To Import From China More Successfully
After you have issued your P/O to your factory and they in return issue
their Performa Invoice, there is one more important action to be taken.
Opening your L/C to your factory or your supplier. Be aware that nothing
will be arranged by the factory without first receiving your L/C, especially
if your business relationship with the factory is still in its infancy.
For example, you want to import a shipment of clothing and the seller
(exporter) asks for a L/C. You accept the exporter’s terms and need to
apply for a L/C from your bank in favor of the seller. L/Cs usually state a
time period and manner in which the exporter must provide documentary
61
How To Import From China More Successfully
proof that they have shipped the goods. Other obligations may also be
included.
Obtaining an L/C
Obtaining a L/C is not as simple as just asking for one. Your bank is
pledging to pay the exporter on your behalf, so you will be required by
your bank to demonstrate that they will be able to recover the funds from
you.
Once it has agreed to open a L/C, the opening bank (the importer’s bank)
will transmit the L/C to its branch or correspondent (the advising bank)
closest to the exporter. The advising bank will notify the exporter that
credit has been established in their name after receiving the L/C.
Exporters should make sure that they are capable of meeting the terms
and conditions of a L/C upon receiving it. This is very important because if
the shipment does not match the description in the L/C, payment will be
delayed in most cases until the discrepancy is resolved.
Since that may be time consuming and time is what you don’t have if you
want to be among the first importing new products, you should use the
following method to avoid such unnecessary delays.
Before your L/C is officially opened, send your draft to the (exporter) and
let them check it. If amendments are needed, you simply correct your L/C
draft before you pass it to your bank for processing. Since both parties
will have checked the content before, everything should be fine and no
delay will occur.
62
How To Import From China More Successfully
payment may take a few days. Both importers and exporters may request
that the paying bank be in their country as they are looking to the L/C to
protect their interests.
63
How To Import From China More Successfully
There are different kinds of L/C but the most common one is L/C at sight.
Other forms of L/C delay payment until a later day, after 30, 60, 90, or
120 days. You will however find, that factories cannot afford these
payment terms because it seriously impacts their cash flow.
64
How To Import From China More Successfully
After executing all the necessary steps to get the production process
going, it is the right time to ask your sales managers to get into action
and sell your products to existing and most importantly to new
customers.
You are the expert in your home market and I will not give you too much
advice about marketing your wonderful new products.
All major retail organizations plan their promotions months ahead and
most buyers are very happy if they have something new to sell. Your
selling price should not be a stumbling block, while still bringing you a
handsome profit.
65
How To Import From China More Successfully
The more effort you spend to create good sales packaging, the more you
will be awarded with larger volume orders.
66
How To Import From China More Successfully
You know that time is money and the factory will not start their
production without graphic materials. A company in your hometown can
be to be instructed one time in the details and can then work
independently on several products. They can also create the concept from
the beginning if you choose.
Graphic mockups are bulky and usually need a special protective packing
to assure that they are not damaged during transport. Therefore, the
67
How To Import From China More Successfully
The best solution is using a password protected FTP server and allowing
the factory to download all graphics from there. Since uploading and
downloading is relatively easy and convenient for the factory and includes
taking advantage of time zone differences, you should seriously consider
this latest method. Mockups and CD-ROMs, even when expedited, take
several days to get to the factory, compared with instantly downloading
from a FTP server.
Please take my advice and double check the measurements of the die-cut
before you ask your marketing department to begin with their artwork
preparation.
68
How To Import From China More Successfully
After the factory receives the final graphics, you will receive their printed
proofs of the packaging and the instruction manuals. This takes between
1-3 weeks plus courier time. Of course, you do not need to check the
proofs and the instruction manuals if you think the factory is reliable.
Unfortunately, my experience is that the factory staff usually has a
different understanding of what is acceptable and what is not.
Shades of Trouble
I had projects with products in 5-6 different factories expecting that the
colors to be identical because we provided every factory the same
information. The outcome was very disappointing because of vast color
deviations, which become more obvious when a group of products is
placed together on a retail shelf. Retailers don’t take well to this.
How does that happen? The factory outsources the package preparation
and if you have 5-6 different factories you may have also the same
number of different printing companies. Of course, the printing companies
try very hard to follow your requests but as I said, any deviation from the
original colors can vary greatly. You end up with everything from very bad
to quite close.
Your corporate identity strategy suffers when the colors are wrong.
A Better Strategy
You might be tempted to fine tune the printing at each print shop. But
that is very time consuming and time is what you do not have. It is also
costly because each proof has to be expedited to avoid losing even more
time.
69
How To Import From China More Successfully
One large German retail organization came up with a different idea, which
many people were skeptical about in the beginning. They appointed one
large printing company in China to do the printing for all of their projects.
The outcome was of course much better because there was no color
deviation when everything was printed at the same print shop. The only
major problem they had to overcome was managing the logistics to
transport the printed gift boxes in the right quantity and on time before
the production start at each of the factories involved.
There was a side benefit when they asked for 2 quotations for their
projects:
a) With gift boxes and instruction manual
It was interesting to compare the cost each of the factories claimed for
their packaging. The cost from factory to factory in many cases was not
even close for comparable gift box sizes.
70
How To Import From China More Successfully
Instruction manuals could be printed on a very thin paper, which lets the
printing bleed through to the next page. This is of course totally
unacceptable and you must inform the factory immediately to change the
paper quality to the requested one. If you did not specify it before, the
factory will claim that this is their standard and everything else will cost
more money.
It is the same with the corrugated cardboard but the savings for the
factory would be even greater if they get their way. Also, the export
carton must be checked thoroughly. Since most importers and large
retailers maintain warehouses to store received goods before they are
distributed, the quality of the export carton must comply with normal
operations in the warehouses.
Large retailers have specifications for maximum size and allowable gross
weight of export cartons along with the cardboard quality to make sure
that they can stack sufficient quantities of cartons on top of each other
without damaging the contents. If you are in doubt about the quality, you
can ask your inspection company to check on it for you.
It is often claimed the factories are unreliable and do not follow given
instructions but I ask you to reconsider whether you really gave them all
the instructions they needed?
71
How To Import From China More Successfully
After everything is checked and finally found satisfactory, you instruct the
factory that they can go ahead with the mass printing.
After you have done this, there is no easy way out if you want changes
later.
72
How To Import From China More Successfully
Now is the time to take out the reference samples and compare them with
the production samples. They should be close or identical but
unfortunately, that is not always the case. There could be minor
deviations, which could even be an improvement and it is up to you to
make the right decisions.
I do not suggest letting this decision out of your hands. Only you or your
company representative know the complete picture and should be the
ones to release the mass production for all its consequences.
You can now see how a local representative can save time and money,
especially if you are on a tight schedule which sometimes happens for
reasons which are out of your control.
73
How To Import From China More Successfully
74
How To Import From China More Successfully
The release of the mass production will be a major impact to the factory’s
internal organization. They must allocate sufficient production lines and
workers to complete your project on time. They also must have prepared
all printed and packing material to pack the finished goods after they
come off the conveyor belt. All materials, components, cabinet parts if
any, must be on hand to start the production.
There must be sufficient QC staff available and familiar with your detailed
instructions. Workers without QC supervision may not deliver the
expected results.
I am not going into the details, but you know if some preparations were
not completed on time the whole project cannot start smoothly.
75
How To Import From China More Successfully
It is a good idea to ask the factory for a status report on daily basis if
necessary. Certainly ask them to inform you immediately about
production problems that come up.
If a problem does arise, ask the factory for an estimated date it will
corrected. If the delay is long, check back with them regularly, and have
them confirm when the problem is fixed. After the problem is fixed, have
the factory confirm the production completion date can still be met. If It
cannot, have them provide a new date.
Capacity Constraints
The factory may have limited control over some capacity constraints.
These include:
• Available number of production lines
• Number of trained workers
76
How To Import From China More Successfully
77
How To Import From China More Successfully
Workers that previously migrated to southern China for jobs are now
finding them in the north. You might recall the terrible events shown on
TV at the Guangzhou railway terminal when approximately a million
migrant workers waited for days to catch a train to their home provinces.
Severe weather prevented the trains from running on schedule and
hundreds of thousands got stuck at the railway station.
You can certainly understand that these people appreciate finding jobs
near their northern hometowns rather than going through such an
odyssey again.
One reason for the southern migration was for better pay. That
enticement no longer exists. With all of the new development, workers in
the north are now receiving nearly the same pay as those as in the South.
78
How To Import From China More Successfully
After the holidays, 10-20% of the workers fail to return to the factories
for various reasons. The result is, that again the factory is short of
manpower and even if they manage to hire new workers, they have to be
trained. It could be your schedule that suffers. Be sure to take
precautions if you are forced to run production during this time.
79
How To Import From China More Successfully
Remember, China is a very big country and the distances from factory to
factory are quite large. Therefore, the inspection company tries to
coordinate inspections with inspectors who are already in the vicinity. In
some cases, the factory may arrange to pick up the inspector up from
another location.
Starting Early
Inspector(s) try to arrive early because the production is stopped during
lunch, which is one hour long and starts as early as 11:30AM. During that
time, management, QC staff, and workers are not available. Inspectors
will normally take their own lunch break. If they arrive late in the
morning, there will not be enough time to get the inspection started. Of
course, there are some lazy guys that purposely arrive shortly before
lunch break but most inspectors are tightly controlled and have to report
80
How To Import From China More Successfully
back to their head office by phone several times each day, especially if
they have to inspect an important project.
Once started, the inspector(s) will randomly selected the correct quantity
of products from the production lot. They will then compare each
production sample for compliance with the checklist requirements.
The following link was provided in Chapter 11 but in case you missed it
here it is again:
http://www.itl.nist.gov/div898/handbook/pmc/section2/pmc231.htm
The inspector’s job is time consuming and for more complex products,
such as bread makers or microwave ovens, they may even need two
man-days to complete the job.
Some really good advice from me is, if a factory cannot offer inspection
rooms and equipment, you better refrain from working with them. They
do not want you to have their quality checked and probably a good reason
for it.
81
How To Import From China More Successfully
After the inspector has finished their inspection, usually late in the
afternoon, they will discuss the results with the factory management and
ask them to sign a handwritten report. Often factory management
disagrees with their findings and refuse to sign. In this case, the inspector
must inform his head office immediately because lengthy negotiations are
not in your interest. The handwritten report is then faxed to the
inspection company’s head office for further processing. The inspector
may take one or more samples with him as supporting evidence of his
findings.
82
How To Import From China More Successfully
The head office of the inspection company can overrule the inspector’s
findings and amend the inspection report. That might happen after
discussing the content with you and receiving your approval.
You should only give approval for minor defects that will not affect your
future sales. Remember, you are responsible for quality for your
customers and must protect both your and their interests.
After taking everything into consideration, you may not want to accept
the factory’s discount and instead ask them to re-work the goods.
The factory has two separate self-interests here. First, they want to avoid
paying the re-inspection charges and secondly they simply want the
goods out of their factory because space is needed for other projects.
83
How To Import From China More Successfully
Now you should better understand why I suggested you avoid a tight
shipping schedule. If you must ship to catch your customer’s promotion
date, you are in for a hard time. One thing you can consider to protect
your company’s interest is asking the factory to issue a letter of
guarantee. In the letter of guarantee the factory should pledge to take full
responsibility for all claims resulting from a specific defect found during
inspection.
84
How To Import From China More Successfully
After the goods pass inspection or you have agreed to accept the
inspection result with minor defects and the factory issues a Letter of
Guarantee to you, the next step is asking your inspection company to
issue their Inspection Certificate. This automatically releases the goods
for shipment. The factory is paid from the L/C when the necessary
documentation is presented to the advising bank and after no
discrepancies are found with the documentation.
Some countries require additional documents that would have been noted
when your home bank opened the L/C.
85
How To Import From China More Successfully
Rework Scenarios
What happens if the goods are rejected during the inspection? Several
possible actions can result.
A good question is, what could and will they do with the rejected goods?
In some cases, they could sell them at a huge discount to less quality
conscious customers but this is not easy because the goods carry your
brand name and are packaged to your specifications. This not a good
solution because you don’t want defective goods with your brand going to
the market.
86
How To Import From China More Successfully
87
How To Import From China More Successfully
The goods will arrive at your warehouse after a long voyage and clearing
customs. The next step is performing an incoming inspection ASAP.
Complex products can have the quality affected during shipment. Another
inspection is necessary to assure quality products are sent to your
customers. This inspection is less intense because characteristics like
color do not need verification again.
Once the products pass this last hurdle, it is time deliver the goods to
your customers
88
How To Import From China More Successfully
For economic reasons, importers usually cannot wait until the arrival
goods arrive to begin selling to customers.
Most goods should have been pre-sold long ago and are now ready for the
retailers to begin promoting a hot new product to a hungry market. This
entire process should have begun about the time the L/C was opened and
the firm order placed with the factory.
89
How To Import From China More Successfully
Chapter 26 - Epilog
I sincerely hope my eBook helps make your Importing from China more
successful and that you now have a better understanding about how
business is done in China.
I would like to express my gratitude for buying this eBook from me and
hope that you will consider some or all of my other eBooks as well.
Klaus-Dieter Hanke
90