Informed Choice and Volunteersim
Informed Choice and Volunteersim
Informed Choice and Volunteersim
December 2014
This document is made possible by the support of the American People through the United
States Agency for International Development (USAID). The contents of this document are the
sole responsibility of Chemonics International, Inc. and do not necessarily reflect the views of
USAID or the United States Government.
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acronyms............................................................................................................................................................................. ii
Background.......................................................................................................................................................................... 1
Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................................ 1
Planning for ICV Compliance Monitoring .................................................................................................................... 2
Necessary Actions to Ensure ICV Compliance .......................................................................................................... 3
Orientation of Partners and Service Providers on ICV............................................................................................ 5
Monitoring of Compliance to ICV Policy Requirements.......................................................................................... 6
Training of Staff and Partners on ICV Monitoring ..................................................................................................... 7
Ensuring Compliance with Environmental Mitigation Policies ................................................................................ 9
Annexes ............................................................................................................................................................................. 11
Annex A: Matrix of Possible Actions to Ensure Compliance with ICV Mandates ...................................... 12
Annex B: Contractual Provisions Relevant to ICV in Family Planning ........................................................... 16
Annex C: Partner Level Checklist for Implementation of ICV Policy Requirements ................................. 19
Annex D: Commitment to Compliance with ICV Policy Requirements ....................................................... 21
Annex E: ICV Policy Compliance Information Dissemination Certificate ..................................................... 22
Annex F: Informed Choice and Voluntarism as a Quality Issue in FP-MCH (PowerPoint) ...................... 23
Annex G: The Rights of Clients ............................................................................................................................... 47
Annex H: National Family Planning Program Policy (DOH AO 50-A s. 2001)............................................ 48
Annex I: Pre/post-Test for ICV Orientations and Trainings............................................................................. 49
Annex J: ICV Monitoring Questions for Facility Managers, Supervisors and Providers ............................ 52
Annex K: ICV Monitoring Questions for Clients ................................................................................................ 54
Annex L: ICV Monitoring Observation Checklist ............................................................................................... 55
Annex M: Narrative Report of Vulnerability or Possible Violation of Family Planning Policies ............... 56
Annex N: Conducting an ICV Monitoring Practicum ......................................................................................... 57
Annex O: Guidance for Conducting an ICV Monitoring Planning Workshop ............................................. 59
Annex P: Joint DENR and DOH AO 02, series of 2005 ................................................................................... 60
Annex Q: PhilHealth Benchbook Quality Standards for Health Provider Organizations ........................ 76
Annex R: Orientation and Compliance to Health Care Waste Management (PowerPoint) .................... 79
Annex S: Environmental Compliance Assessment Tool................................................................................... 91
ACRONYMS
AO Administrative order
DENR Department of Environment and Natural Resources
DOH Department of Health
DOH-RO Department of Health Regional Office
FP-MCH Family planning and maternal and child health services
ICV Informed consent and voluntarism
LGU Local government unit
PhilHealth Philippine Health Insurance Corporation
USAID United States Agencies for International Development
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 1
BACKGROUND
USAID places a high priority on ensuring that family planning activities supported by the agency adhere
to the mandates of the Philippine government on the principles and practices of voluntarism and informed
choice and environmental mitigation. These policies are very important in ensuring quality of care in
family planning service provision. Given these requirements, it is incumbent upon all USAID projects to
develop plans of action for ensuring the project’s and its partners’ implementation of these
commitments.
This document describes strategies to ensure compliance with these requirements. The focus of the
document is primarily informed choice and voluntarism (ICV) compliance and monitoring, but in the
latter sections of the document there is discussion of specific activities and tools related to
environmental compliance. Integration of environmental compliance initiatives with those related to ICV
is an efficient and effective way to work with project teams and partners to address these two
important issues. The document focusses on effort that can be implemented by USAID projects to
strengthen their own teams’ efforts in these areas and to build the capacity of their partners to ensure
ICV and environmental mitigation compliance.
INTRODUCTION
An individual’s decision to use a specific method of family planning or to use any method of family
planning is considered voluntary if it is based upon correct information and the exercise of free choice,
and is not influenced by any constraints, special inducements or any element of force, fraud, deceit,
duress, or other forms of coercion or misrepresentation.
Clients have to be provided with adequate service options such as broad range of family planning
services, appropriate information, counseling, privacy and confidentiality as regular features of quality
client-provider interaction. These are mandated in the Philippine laws and Department of Health
(DOH) Family Planning Program policies and principles. Informed and voluntary decision-making in
family planning is one of the four pillars of the national family planning program as embodied in DOH
Administrative Order (AO) 50-A series of 2001. In June 2011, the DOH issued, an improved policy, AO
2011-0005 providing Guidelines on Ensuring Quality Standards in the Delivery of Family Program and
Services through Compliance to Informed Choice and Voluntarism. The Magna Carta of Women also
provides for ensuring Filipino women’s right to information, choice, family planning and maternal health
services. Above all, the Philippine laws prohibit abortion and classify it as a criminal offense.
Projects funded by USAID have to comply with several U.S. legislative and statutory policy requirements
relating to informed choice and voluntarism in the provision of family planning services.
b. program personnel for achieving a numerical target or quota of total number of births,
number of family planning acceptors, or acceptors of a particular method of family
planning;
3. The project shall not deny right or benefit, including the right of access to participate in
any program of general welfare or the right to access to health care, as a consequence of
any individual’s decision not to accept family planning services;
4. The project shall provide family planning acceptors comprehensible information on the
health benefits and risks of the method chosen, including those conditions that might
render the method inadvisable and those adverse side effects known to be consequent to
the use of the method; and,
5. The project shall ensure that experimental contraceptive drugs and devices and medical
procedures are provided only in the context of a scientific study in which participants are
advised of potential risks and benefits.
B. The Population Policy of 1982, provides for specific requirements for USAID-supported
programs that include voluntary sterilization. These requirements include informed consent,
ready access to other methods, and guidelines on incentive payments, which define payments
to acceptors, providers and referral agents. This is referred to as the PD-3 provision.
C. USAID strongly restricts the use of its resources for activities that directly or indirectly help
promote abortion as a family planning method. These principles are embodied in the
provisions of the different US Government family planning statutory and policy requirements.
Although, the Mexico City Policy was rescinded in January 2009 and is no longer relevant, all
other abortion-related legislative and statutory requirements remain intact and shall be
enforced:
1. The Helms amendment prohibits the use of funds for the performance of abortion as a
family planning method or to motivate or coerce any person to practice abortions.
2. The Leahy amendment clarifies the term “motivate” as it relates to family planning
assistance saying it shall not be construed to prohibit the provision, consistent with local
law, of information or counseling about all pregnancy options.
3. The Siljander amendment prohibits US government funds from being used to lobby for or
against abortions.
4. The Biden amendment restricts the use of funds for biomedical research that relates to
performance of abortions or involuntary sterilization.
5. The Kemp-Kasten amendment guards against using US funds for involuntary sterilization
or coercive abortions.
6. The DeConcini amendment provision limits the use of funds only to voluntary family
planning projects which offer, either directly or through referral to, or information about
access to, a broad range of family planning methods and services.
7. Livingston-Obey amendment requires that in awarding grants for natural family planning,
no applicant shall be discriminated against because of such applicant’s religious or
conscientious commitment to offer only natural family planning; and, additionally, all such
applicants shall comply with the requirements of the DeConcini Amendment.
There are three levels in which projects can develop plans of action to avoid violations. These are:
1. Project- level – actions that project staff can do in collaboration with other USAID projects.
a. Activities that individual staff will conduct for internal use or benefit (such as annually
accomplishing the US Government’s online e-learning course on family planning legislative
compliance)
b. Activities that projects will conduct to help others (the next level) preempt, prevent or
avoid vulnerabilities or outright violations of the policies (such as develop ICV materials to
be used in orienting staff)
2. Project-partners level – these are activities that projects should expect partners to conduct or
comply with as part of the terms of partnership.
a. Internal or intra-organizational activities – among its staff or as assistance to its own
partners (such as heads or leaders of the partner organization are expected to orient their
own staff on ICV policies)
b. Activities to be conducted by the partner-organizations’ partner implementers or actual
service providers (such as post the all-family planning methods posters in every clinic under
the partner organization)
3. In areas not directly covered by the project, some minimum activities will have to be conducted
to ensure compliance and prevention of vulnerabilities or violations (such as conducting ICV
orientations for health officers through the DOH Regional Offices (DOH-ROs)).
Proposed types of actions and specific activities for each level are collated and summarized in the matrix
in Annex A. This matrix guides staff in the conduct of activities relating to the project, its partners, and
the context in which the project operates. Implementing activities at these three levels has three overall
objectives for ensuring ICV policy compliance: 1) expand or increase the awareness on ICV policies
from project central and field personnel to project partners, grantees, and allied service providers; 2)
strengthen project implementation of internal controls and partner organization’s capabilities; and 3)
improve monitoring, evaluation and feedback systems to provide better information, decision-making,
and further improvement of operational policies.
1. The inclusion of US government family planning policies and statutory requirements as standard
provisions in grants and sub-contracts (see Annex B),
2. Inclusion of Philippine government family planning policies related to ICV as standard provisions
in grants and subcontracts
3. ICV-related activities for grants and subcontracts awardees, such as:
a. explanation to the grantees/subcontractors the conditions for funds utilization provided for
in the various family planning and abortion-related policy requirements as early as cost
negotiations stage
b. orientation on ICV for grants and subcontracts recipients
4 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
c. in the course of the partners implementation of its activities, the partner (grantee or
subcontractor) should be required to accomplish a Partner Level Checklist for
Implementation of ICV Policy Requirements (sample in Annex C)
d. partners submit signed forms of Commitment to Compliance with ICV Policy Requirements
(see Annex D).
e. grantees/subcontractors to obtain from its partners/implementers signed compliance
commitment forms (Annex D).
f. grantees/subcontractors integrate in their information provision, monitoring activities
regarding ICV compliance, utilizing the recommended forms in this plan.
g. grantees/subcontractors integrate ICV orientation into its general human resource
orientation for newly hired staff.
h. grantees/subcontractors monitor and submit reports on ICV compliance on a quarterly
basis
4. Inclusion of orientation on ICV as an issue of quality of care and as basic information and
principles imparted to recipients of project-funded training for family planning service providers.
a. inclusion of signed commitment to comply with ICV policies in registration forms for
supported training courses (Annex D)
b. requiring all trainers to submit at the end of each training course ICV Policy Compliance
Information Dissemination Certificate (Annex E) certifying that the trainees had received
information on these policies during the training and had understood the implications of
non-compliance with the same.
5. Distribution of the latest family planning reference book, the Family Planning: A Global
Handbook for Providers, to grantees, subcontractors and project partner family planning service
providers.
6. Distribution of the all-methods family planning wall poster and desk flipcharts to all partner
family planning service providers.
7. Require grantees/subcontractors to ensure that the all-methods family planning wall posters and
desk flipcharts are available in their network of clinics and providers.
8. Mandatory annual accomplishment of the web-based e-learning course on United Stattes
government family planning policies and statutory requirements for all project staff
9. Technical staff participation in inter-agency ICV compliance monitoring orientation-training
workshops.
10. Formation of a committee, or ICV compliance core team, with the following core members:
a. a point or focal person who will be responsible for all activities related to the
implementation and monitoring of ICV compliance in all project-assisted areas as part of
their scope of work;
b. a focal person as secretariat at the national office who shall be responsible for
documentation, submission and filing of all ICV compliance-related documents
c. a quality specialist, or equivalent, designated as over-all focal person for ICV at the national
level, mandated to collate/consolidate all reports from project sites, document
vulnerabilities, organize trainings or orientation, and materials
11. Whenever and wherever applicable and practicable, inclusion of ICV policies and compliance
discussions in all meetings, presentations and conferences whether as formal orientations or
informal reminders to audiences – such as grants pre-award orientations, private practicing
midwives consultative working group meetings, grants final technical and cost negotiations with
proponents, regular visits to partners, and others.
12. Regular reporting of ICV compliance activities from the field and regional office based staff.
13. Development and implementation of a functional monitoring and reporting system within the
project.
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 5
14. Train public and private partners to enact local policies and ensure programs are consistent with
Philippine laws respecting, upholding, enabling Filipinos to exercise their right to be informed,
choose, act on their choices, access quality family planning and maternal and child health services
(FP-MCH) information, products and services.
While the focus of this orientation is on ICV, the conduct of this orientation with partners is also a good
opportunity to consider including additional modules on environmental impact mitigation and/or gender.
Objectives
General Objective: To enable public and private hospitals to strengthen its family planning provision and
use in compliance with government policies on ICV [and promotion of gender equality and
environmental mitigation, if desired].
Specific Objectives: At the end of the one-day orientation the participants will be able to: (1) understand
the principles of ICV-compliant [gender responsive and environment-friendly] family planning
information, product and service provision to clients based on relevant Philippine Government family
planning statutory and policy requirements; (2) determine what is ICV-compliant family planning
provision and discuss what constitutes vulnerability or violation; (3) adapt the provisions/guidelines of
the DOH AO on ICV [and environmental mitigation] measures to local realities of the hospital; and (4)
plan for next steps to strengthen family planning program implementation.
Preparation
The orientation is supported by a PowerPoint presentation (Annex F), thus requiring the availability of
some technology where this orientation will take place. Otherwise, the presentation may be printed and
converted into transparencies, or participants may be given printed hand-outs to take home or make
notes on during the presentation.
The PowerPoint presentation includes suggested talking points or script to help the facilitator present
the material. Answers and explanations to case studies are included. The presenter must study the notes
well ahead of the presentation itself in order to be familiar with the content and script. It would be best
to get additional background information on quality of care in family planning in order to provide clear
examples or illustration for each of the client’s rights and provider’s needs. (Annex G is a summary of
these clients’ rights and providers’ needs. This was taken from EngenderHealth’s COPE: Client-Oriented
Provider-Efficient Services Manual which is a good resource material on the subject).
The presenter must likewise be familiar with the National Family Planning Program Policy (DOH AO 50-
A s. 2001), a copy of which is attached here as Annex H. The slide deck also includes additional slides on
the Magna Carta of Women and the DOH Administrative Order 2011-0005, Guidelines on Ensuring
Quality Standards in the Delivery of Family Planning Program and Services through Compliance to
Informed Choice and Voluntarism.
6 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
The tool in Annex J is for use with facility managers, supervisors and providers. It is intended to serve as
a rapid assessment of national family planning policy compliance. It is not necessary to follow this tool
verbatim, but rather during the course of conversation to obtain the information requested it may be
necessary to ask additional questions and probe deeper to obtain details about a given issue. It is the
responsibility of the user to continue the in-depth discussion to the point necessary to gather all the
necessary information and provide a comprehensive report to the ICV compliance core team. This tool
is intended to serve as a guide to the interviewer. It is not necessary to fill in the guide during the
interview. However, for record keeping purposes, please fill in the tool immediately following the
interview and submit the form to the appropriate entity within your respective office.
When all pertinent questions in the interview have been asked and answered, all feedback and
comments have been taken, be sure to address the service provider’s questions, issues or concerns. Do
not leave the interview without addressing issues that you had noted during the interview.
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 7
Annex K provides a tool for interviewing family planning clients at the facility. The results of this tool
must be reported jointly with the results of the assessment tool for facility managers and providers. If
the results obtained by the two tools do not match, further investigation will be required. When
conducting site visits for interviews, ICV monitors should also briefly take the time to make some
observations at the facility. A checklist for this purpose is in Annex L.
Based on the answers to the questions in this tool and the facility tool, the interviewer will draw a
conclusion as whether there is a potential vulnerability in a service delivery site or whether there is a
potential violation of legislative and policy requirements to ensure quality of care initiatives in family
planning. If during the use of the tool there is a ‘red flag’ that indicates a potential violation, it is
necessary to report the potential violation immediately to the ICV compliance core team and
appropriate USAID representative to initiate an in-depth investigation.
Should vulnerabilities or violations occur at anytime, anywhere, the project partner or staff who
identifies such a situation must immediately report it to the project focal person or team for ICV. The
latter shall then help facilitate the documentation of the alleged possible vulnerability or violation by
filling up a reporting or incident report form (sample in Annex M). This signed report will then be faxed
or scanned/emailed immediately to the project focal person who will then notify the Chief of Party. The
project Chief of Party is required to notify the USAID Office of Health through its Agreement/Contract
Officer Representative within 72 hours of being aware of the possible vulnerability or violation, if it is
related to targeting or coercive issues.
USAID will conduct the investigations together with the DOH to determine whether a violation has
been committed or not. USAID Philippines will then communicate with USAID Washington for the next
steps. In the event that a violation has indeed been committed, USAID Washington is required by law to
report such violation to the United States Congress. The project will await instructions from USAID for
the next steps. Relationships should continue. Feedback must be given to the partner and the DOH-RO
explaining the situation and the steps being taken.
Objectives
General Objective: To enable project personnel/local stewards to facilitate attainment of family planning
outcomes by strengthening information, service, product provision and use.
Specific Objectives: At the end of training participants will be able to: (1) understand the principles of
ICV in family planning service provision; (2) determine what ICV-compliant family planning provision is;
(3) demonstrate the use of monitoring tools for family planning clients and service providers for the ICV
compliance; (4) identify needs for improvement of the local service delivery network in relation to
provision of ICV-compliant family planning information, product and services to clients; adopt a
monitoring and reporting system for family planning policy compliance in relation to local realities; and
(5) plan for next steps to strengthen family planning provision and use, and the local health referral
system, as mandated by the DOH AO on ICV;
8 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Preparation
All preparatory activities outlined in the section above are also relevant to this training for ICV
monitoring teams. In addition, it is important that all participants in this training have a basic, scientific,
evidence-based knowledge of all family planning methods, and have read and understood the DOH
Administrative Order on ICV.
Program of Activities
Date/Time Activity/Topics Facilitator/Speaker
DAY 1
9:00- 10:00 Pre-test (see Annex I) Project
Opening Message DOH-RO
Objectives and Expectations DOH-RO
10:00 – 11:00 Session 1 - Presentation: DOH family planning DOH-RO
program
Session 2 - Presentation: Broad range of family
planning methods
11:00 – 12:00 Session 3 - Presentation: Overview and review of Project
national laws and policies related to ICV presented as
quality of care in the Philippine setting; DOH
Administrative Order 2011- 005: Guidelines on
Ensuring Quality Standards in the Delivery of Family
Planning Program and Services through Compliance to
Informed Choice and Voluntarism
1:00 – 3:00 Session 4 – Workshop: Identification of gaps related to Project and DOH-RO
ICV compliance in respective geographical areas
Followed by plenary session
3:00 – 4:00 Session 5 – Presentation: Familiarization with the Project
monitoring tools, reporting forms, reporting systems
and lines of reporting
Followed by open forum
4:00 – 5:00 Session 6 – Workshop: Familiarization with the Project and DOH-RO
monitoring tools through role playing, and discussions
Followed by plenary session
DAY 2
8:30 – 9:00 Recap of Day 1 Project
9:00 – 11:00 Session 6 – Practicum: Hands-on ICV compliance Participants travel to
monitoring in family planning (Annex N) identified facilities
11:00 – 12:00 Session 7 – Plenary: Discussions on issues and Project
concerns regarding compliance to ICV and
environmental mitigation as experienced during the
practicum
1:00 – 4:15 Session 8 - Workshop: Planning for next steps in Project and DOH-RO
implementing ICV compliance (Annex O)
Followed by plenary session
4:15 – 5:00 Synthesis DOH-RO
Post-test (see Annex I) PRISM2
Closing Remarks DOH-RO
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 9
There are policies that govern healthcare waste management. The DOH has published the Health Care
Waste Management Manual1. Likewise, the DOH and Department of Environment and Natural
Resources (DENR) issued the Joint Administrative Order 02, series of 2005 which presents policies and
guidelines for the effective and proper handling, collection, transport, treatment, storage, disposal of
healthcare waste (Annex P). The Philippine Health Insurance Corporation (PhilHealth) likewise has its
accreditation standards related to environmental mitigation (Annex Q).
It is therefore incumbent upon health projects to comply with these policies, including projects that
conduct activities that do not directly produce waste. Projects can develop a work plan on
environmental compliance monitoring. Some of the activities to be considered are described below.
2. In collaboration with other USAID partners, develop reporting mechanisms and tools
Collaborate with other USAID partners at the national level to improve tools, monitoring
and reporting systems
3. Assist DOH, LGUs and project partners to develop local policies/program on environmental
mitigation monitoring related to management/disposal of potentially hazardous waste in FP-
MCH provision and use:
Orient grantees on environmental compliance and monitoring. A sample PowerPoint
presentation, designed for use with private practicing midwives, which could be adapted for
this purpose is included in Annex R.
Collaborate with grantees and other partners regarding activities related to environment
mitigation monitoring and reporting
Collaborate with grantees and other project partners on support activities related to
environmental mitigation specifically on health care waste management such as simple
product inventory mechanisms, expired pharmaceutical products, sharps, etc
Together with grantees, conduct monitoring among health care facilities of partners
Feedback the information that will be generated to local stewards to be used in their
program implementation reviews, annual operational planning, regular technical meetings for
immediate operational resolution and to fast track compliance to LGU, DOH and PhilHealth
standards on environmental mitigation and protection
1
http://www.doh.gov.ph/sites/default/files/Health_Care_Waste_Management_Manual.pdf
10 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Together with local stewards, gather local policies passed and programs implemented by
LGUs and other partners in relation to environmental mitigation. Evaluate these policies as
their relevance to FP-MCH provision and use
Develop technical initiatives to assist partners in improving implementation of environmental
mitigation and protection measures in relation to FP-MCH services, product provision and
use
Project staff, together with LGUs and partners can conduct a baseline assessment of environmental
mitigation and decide on the frequency of monitoring visits. A simplified environmental compliance tool
is found in Annex S.
Stewards and public health managers of DOH-ROs and LGUs can utilize the results of the environment
compliance monitoring to further assist health care providers to set up structures and mechanisms to
ensure that their practices protect the environment and do not further contribute to its degradation.
Further, the results can then be forwarded to the regulatory bodies of the DOH-RO and LGUs, as well
as to the local PhilHealth office, to ensure compliance of individual health care providers. Figure 1 below
shows a simplified workflow on monitoring and feedback.
Results are forwarded to licensing offices of Results are fed back to managers of health
DOH RO & LGU, accreditation body of local care facilities for them to improve their
Philhealth office practices & structures, if necessary
ANNEXES
a. Requirements for Voluntary Sterilization Program. None of the funds made available under this
contract shall be used to pay for the performance of involuntary sterilization as a method of family
planning or to coerce or provide any financial incentive to any individual to practice sterilization.
(1) No funds made available under this award will be used to finance, support, or be attributed to
the following activities: (i) procurement or distribution of equipment intended to be used for the
purpose of inducing abortions as a method of family planning; (ii) special fees or incentives to any
person to coerce or motivate them to have abortions; (iii) payments to persons to perform
abortions or to solicit persons to undergo abortions; (iv) information, education, training, or
communication programs that seek to promote abortion as a method of family planning; and (v)
lobbying for or against abortion. The term "motivate", as it relates to family planning assistance, shall
not be construed to prohibit the provision, consistent with local law, of information or counseling
about all pregnancy options.
(2) No funds made available under this award will be used to pay for any biomedical research which
relates, in whole or in part, to methods of, or the performance of, abortions or involuntary
sterilizations as a means of family planning. Epidemiologic or descriptive research to assess the
incidence, extent or consequences of abortions is not precluded.
(1) The recipient agrees to take any steps necessary to ensure that funds made available under this
award will not be used to coerce any individual to practice methods of family planning inconsistent
with such individual's moral, philosophical, or religious beliefs. Further, the recipient agrees to
conduct its activities in a manner that safeguards the rights, health and welfare of all individuals who
take part in the program.
(2) Activities which provide family planning services or information to individuals, financed in whole
or in part under this agreement, shall provide a broad range of family planning methods and services
available in the country in which the activity is conducted or shall provide information to such
individuals regarding where such methods and services may be obtained.
(1) A Family planning project must comply with the requirements of this paragraph.
award, except fund solely for the participation of personnel in short-term, widely attended training
conferences or programs.
(3) Service providers and referral agents in the project shall not implement or be subject to quotas
or other numerical targets of total number of births, number of family planning acceptors, or
acceptors of a particular method of family planning. Quantitative estimates or indicators of the
number of births, acceptors, and acceptors of a particular method that are used for the purpose of
budgeting, planning, or reporting with respect to the project are not quotas or targets under this
paragraph, unless service providers or referral agents in the project are required to achieve the
estimates or indicators.
(4) The project shall not include the payment of incentives, bribes, gratuities or financial rewards to
(i) any individual in exchange for becoming a family planning acceptor or (ii) any personnel
performing functions under the project for achieving a numerical quota or target of total number of
births, number of family planning acceptors, or acceptors of a particular method of contraception.
This restriction applies to salaries or payments paid or made to personnel performing functions
under the project if the amount of the salary or payment increases or decreases based on a
predetermined number of births, number of family planning acceptors, or number of acceptors of a
particular method of contraception that the personnel affect or achieve.
(5) No person shall be denied any right or benefit, including the right of access to participate in any
program of general welfare or health care, based on the person's decision not to accept family
planning services offered by the project.
(6) The project shall provide family planning acceptors comprehensible information about the health
benefits and risks of the method chosen, including those conditions that might render the use of the
method inadvisable and those adverse side effects known to be consequent to the use of the
method. This requirement may be satisfied by providing information in accordance with the medical
practices and standards and health conditions in the country where the project is conducted
through counseling, brochures, posters, or package inserts.
(7) The project shall ensure that experimental contraceptive drugs and devices and medical
procedures are provided only in the context of a scientific study in which participants are advised of
potential risks and benefits.
(8) With respect to projects for which USAID provides, or finances the contribution of,
contraceptive commodities or technical services and for which there is no subaward or contract
under this award, organization implementing a project for which such assistance is provided shall
agree that the project will comply with the requirements of this paragraph while using such
commodities or receiving such services.
(9) (i) The recipient shall notify USAID when it learns about an alleged violation in a project of the
requirements of subparagraphs (3), (4), (5) or (7) of this paragraph; (ii) The recipient shall investigate
and take appropriate corrective action, if necessary, when it learns about an alleged violation in a
project of subparagraph (6) of this paragraph and shall notify USAID about violations in a project
affecting a number of people over a period of time that indicate there is a systemic problem in the
project; (iii) The recipient shall provide USAID such additional information about violations as
USAID may request.
18 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
(1) None of the funds made available under this award shall be used to pay for the performance of
involuntary sterilization as a method of family planning or to coerce or provide any financial
incentive to any individual to practice sterilization.
(2) The recipient shall ensure that any surgical sterilization procedures supported in whole or in part
by funds from this award are performed only after the individual has voluntarily appeared at the
treatment facility and has given informed consent to the sterilization procedure. Informed consent
means the voluntary, knowing assent from the individual after being advised of the surgical procedures
to be followed, the attendant discomforts and risks, the benefits to be expected, the availability of
alternative methods of family planning, the purpose of the operation and its irreversibility, and the
option to withdraw consent at any time prior to the operation. An individual's consent is considered
voluntary if it is based upon the exercise of free choice and is not obtained by any special inducement
or any element of force, fraud, deceit, duress, or other forms of coercion or misrepresentation.
(3) Further, the recipient shall document the patient's informed consent by (i) a written consent
document in a language the patient understands and speaks, which explains the basic elements of
informed consent, as set out above, and which is signed by the individual and by the attending
physician or by the authorized assistant of the attending physician; or (ii) when a patient is unable to
read adequately a written certification by the attending physician or by the authorized assistant of the
attending physician that the basic elements of informed consent above were orally presented to the
patient, and that the patient thereafter consented to the performance of the operation. The receipt of
this oral explanation shall be acknowledged by the patient's mark on the certification and by the
signature or mark of a witness who shall speak the same language as the patient.
(4) The recipient must retain copies of informed consent forms and certification documents for each
voluntary sterilization procedure for a period of three years after performance of the sterilization
procedure.
(1) No funds made available under this award will be used to finance, support, or be attributed to the
following activities: (i) procurement or distribution of equipment intended to be used for the purpose
of inducing abortions as a method of family planning; (ii) special fees or incentives to any person to
coerce or motivate them to have abortions; (iii) payments to persons to perform abortions or to
solicit persons to undergo abortions; (iv) information, education, training, or communication programs
that seek to promote abortion as a method of family planning; and (v) lobbying for or against abortion.
The term "motivate", as it relates to family planning assistance, shall not be construed to prohibit the
provision, consistent with local law, of information or counseling about all pregnancy options.
(2) No funds made available under this award will be used to pay for any biomedical research which
relates, in whole or in part, to methods of, or the performance of, abortions or involuntary
sterilizations as a means of family planning. Epidemiologic or descriptive research to assess the
incidence, extent or consequences of abortions is not precluded.
e. The recipient shall insert this provision in all subsequent subagreements and contracts involving
family planning or population activities that will be supported in whole or in part from funds under
this award. The term subagreement means subgrants and subcooperative agreements.
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 19
Date: ____________________________________
1. Project partner personnel have attended an orientation on the ICV Policy Requirements from any
USAID supported project?
Yes No
2. Is the project partner aware of any member/ /beneficiary/partner within the project that:
If response is “YES” to any of the above, kindly provide details (please include name of provider,
brief description, and action taken by project partner):
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
20 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
1. What activities have the project partner undertaken to ensure compliance of its staff, member firms,
family planning service providers, or other partners?
2. The project partner is aware that their partners’ project management teams at the mid-level
managers, as well as service providers are required to report any alleged possible violation of the
restrictions on quotas, incentives, withholding benefits or experimental activities.
Yes No
3. Has the grantee developed or have access to tools for monitoring and evaluating its member firms
or grantee-partners’ compliance to the family planning ICV Policy Requirements?
Yes No
Yes No
1. No targets or quotas shall be imposed on individual family planning service providers or referral
agents
2. No incentives shall be provided to family planning providers and family planning clients in exchange
for accepting family planning methods.
3. No denial of rights or benefits shall be imposed on those who do not accept family planning
methods
4. Comprehensible information shall be provided to family planning clients on the family planning
method they have chosen
5. Experimental family planning methods shall be used only in the context of a scientific study and with
full disclosure of information to the family planning clients
6. Informed consent shall be documented prior to procedures for those choosing sterilization services
7. Ready access to other (temporary) methods shall be ensured for those who choose sterilization
services
8. No incentive payments shall be provided to clients for undergoing sterilization services and for
family planning personnel for doing the procedure
9. To ensure informed choice, a broad range of methods shall be offered to family planning clients
directly or indirectly by family planning service providers
10. The project partner shall have no relationship with organizations managing programs of coercive
abortion or involuntary sterilization or practices that may be illegal
11. No USAID funds will be used to perform or motivate/coerce people to practice abortions
12. No USAID funds will be used for lobbying for or against abortion
13. No USAID funds will be used for any biomedical research related to abortion
14. The grantee further certifies that they will not perform or actively promote abortion as a method of
family planning.
I understand that to ensure compliance to the above mentioned informed choice and voluntarism policy
requirements, project partner will accomplish and submit to […name of project…] the Partner Level
Checklist for Implementation ICV Policy Requirements and allow […name of project…] staff and
partners to conduct formal ICV policy compliance monitoring as integrated in the regular project
monitoring visits.
I further agree that if, in spite of the efforts to comply with the ICV Policy Requirements, a possible
violation occurs at any time anywhere in the project, our organization will extend full cooperation with
[…name of project…] in immediately reporting the situation to […name of project…] and cooperating
with any subsequent investigation that may be conducted thereafter.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
______________________ _____________________
Signature over printed name Date of Execution
22 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
1. No targets or quotas shall be imposed on individual family planning service providers or referral
agents
2. No incentives shall be provided to family planning providers and family planning clients in exchange
for accepting family planning methods.
3. No denial of rights or benefits shall be imposed on those who do not accept family planning
methods
4. Comprehensible information shall be provided to family planning clients on the family planning
method they have chosen
5. Experimental family planning methods shall be used only in the context of a scientific study and with
full disclosure of information to the family planning clients
6. Informed consent shall be documented prior to procedures for those choosing sterilization services
7. Ready access to other (temporary) methods shall be ensured for those who choose sterilization
services
8. No incentive payments shall be provided to clients for undergoing sterilization services and for
family planning personnel for doing the procedure
9. To ensure informed choice, a broad range of methods shall be offered to family planning clients
directly or indirectly by family planning service providers
10. The project partner shall have no relationship with organizations managing programs of coercive
abortion or involuntary sterilization or practices that may be illegal
11. No USAID funds will be used to perform or motivate/coerce people to practice abortions
12. No USAID funds will be used for lobbying for or against abortion
13. No USAID funds will be used for any biomedical research related to abortion
14. The grantee further certifies that they will not perform or actively promote abortion as a method of
family planning.
Furthermore, I understand that the trainees or participants are not just expected to be aware of these
policy requirements but, more importantly, to comply with all of them as well. In order to ensure
compliance, I have coordinated with the responsible organization regarding their responsibility to
proactively and deliberately inform and monitor their trainees, staff and all project partners whenever
and wherever the need arises.
I further agree that if, in spite of the efforts to inform and comply with the ICV policy requirements, a
possible violation occurs at any time anywhere in the project, I will extend full cooperation to […name
of project…] by immediately reporting the situation to […name of project…] and cooperating with any
subsequent investigation that may be conducted thereafter.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
______________________ _____________________
Signature over printed name Date of Execution
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 23
Greetings
Philippine Constitution Also, what policies have been put in place by the DOH to
Magna Carta of Women ensure quality of care in the provision of FP?
and
Department of Health
Family Planning
Program Policies
24 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
• Seeks to eliminate
discrimination against
women by recognizing,
protecting, fulfilling and
promoting the rights of
Filipino women
DOH FP Program Service Delivery How do these program policies translate to service delivery?
Program Principles (Four Pillars in FP As a guide to service providers, the DOH came up with the
Program Implementation) following program principles…
1. Respect for the sanctity of life.
2. Respect for human rights. Again, discuss each one briefly as they are described in the
3. Freedom of choice and voluntary A.O.
decisions.
4. Respect for the rights of the clients to
determine their desired family size.
DOH Memo
In memorandum to all regional directors of all the regional
June 29, 2006 health offices or Centers for Health Development nationwide
Re: issued June 29, 2006, the DOH reiterated the importance of
Reiterating
Compliance
complying with these four pillars or guiding principles in the
with Various implementation of the FP program in the country and
Issuances
Regarding the
providing further explanations by restating the four pillars as
Guiding follows: .
Principles or
“Four Pillars”
of the Family
Planning
Program
28 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Ensuring Informed & For example, as far as Respect for Life is concerned…
Voluntary Decision-Making:
Program Principles (Four Pillars in FP Program
Implementation)
1. Respect for life
• No to abortion; illegal in the Revised Penal Code
2. Informed choice
• Full information and voluntary decision-making
3. Birth spacing
• Birth spacing of 3 to 5 years
4. Responsible parenthood.
• The right to determine family size according to couple’s
capacity , beliefs, etc.
to perform or motivate/ coerce people to Neither is it allowed to conduct biomedical research related
practice abortions
to abortions
any biomedical research related to abortion In addition, if your NGO or the LGU or other stakeholders
are receiving funds from the U.S. government, aside from
the above prohibitions, you are also not allowed to use US
Government monies to lobby either for or against abortion.
Ensuring Informed & Let’s now discuss the second pillar – Informed choice
Voluntary Decision-Making:
Program Principles (Four Pillars in FP Program We ensure this by doing good family planning counseling:
Implementation)
the objective of which is – client makes the decision and that
1. Respect for life
• No to abortion; illegal in the Revised Penal Code
decision is made based on adequate information…
2. Informed choice
• Full information and voluntary decision-making
3. Birth spacing
• Birth spacing of 3 to 5 years
4. Responsible parenthood.
• The right to determine family size according to couple’s
capacity , beliefs, etc.
• ask questions,
• express concerns, or
• learn about different methods from someone who is
knowledgeable and concerned.
DOH Memo It should be noted that targets and quotas for FP programs
Sept. 1, 2006 per se is actually allowed for as long as these targets are
Re: not passed on as targets or quotas assigned to or required
of individual FP service providers. Targets for programming
Prohibition of
Setting and budgeting purposes are actually allowed but these
Service numbers should not be passed on to individual health
Quotas or
Targets For workers or referral agents as assigned or required target
Family numbers or quotas.
Planning
Program
Let us further define these terms…
Targets that are not allowed under this provision are those
that are:
(1) predetermined;
(2) assigned to a specific health worker and
(3) enforced, or of consequence.
1) Case # 1: A private midwife’s business plan 1) A private midwife’s business plan states that for her to
states that for her to break even, she needs
to have at least 10 deliveries and 10 IUD
break even, she needs to have at least 10 deliveries and
insertions in her clinic a month. 10 IUD insertions in her clinic a month.
3) Case # 3: Community health workers have 1) Community health workers have annual workload
annual workload projections for family projections for family planning clients, based on community
planning clients, based on community needs
assessments.
needs assessments.
4) Case # 4: Outreach workers are scolded, In some countries, community needs assessments are used
salary is withheld, or they may be transferred to help field workers learn the needs for reproductive,
to other sites when they do not achieve their maternal, and child health services as defined by the clients
workload projections.
themselves. The field worker then estimates what proportion
of the demand can be met during the year, in order to plan
for supplies and other requirements. This is not a violation,
unless there are consequences for individual health
workers for achieving (or not) the workload projected
(see Case study #2).
Case Studies: Incentives for Clients 5) The best “performing” health centers in a program receive
and/or Providers supplies and/or equipment as rewards, based on health
indicators including family planning acceptance.
5) Case #5: The best “performing” health
centers in a program receive supplies and/or
The FP Policy Requirement applies to incentives or rewards
equipment as rewards, based on health being given to “program personnel for achieving a numerical
indicators including family planning acceptance. target or quota” only the following three items: on total
number of births, number of FP acceptors or number of
acceptors of a particular method. Such “personnel” are not
limited to providers or outreach workers, but can also
include program managers. When a health center as an
institution is rewarded for the performance of its staff
overall, the rewards are presumably not given to
individual staff, and it would not be a violation.
No Denial of Rights or Benefits Based on FP projects shall not deny any right or benefit, including the
Decision not to Accept FP
right of access to participate in any program of general
Examples: welfare or the right of access to health care, as a
consequence of any individual's decision not to accept
• Food assistance or health benefits not family planning services…”
dependent upon accepting FP services
FP Policy requirements prohibits the tying of rights or
• Employment positions or privileges not
limited to FP users benefits, including legal privileges and powers, to the
decision to accept a method of family planning, or not.
Examples of violations would include denying access to
health care, access of food programs, or employment to
those people who do not accept family planning.
6) Case # 6: Government jobs are limited to The “denial of benefits” relates to consequences of not
those who have no more than two children. accepting family planning. But having a small family is not
the same as being a family planning acceptor, so there’s no
7) Case # 7: Community-based distribution
direct connection between this situation and the policy of
(CBD) workers must be family planning informed choice. However, the impact of this policy on
acceptors themselves. decision-making by couples should be considered, to see
what effect it may have on informed choice and whether it
reflects positively or negatively on family planning services
in general (e.g., that they are seen as being driven by the
government’s needs and priorities and not reflecting the
needs and concerns of individuals).
(5) Full Disclosure for Experimental This provision is not relevant since there are no
Contraceptive Methods
experimental studies going on with FP methods in the
country.
• Experimental FP methods and procedures to be
provided only in the context of a scientific study
Suffice it to say that experimental contraceptive drugs and
devices and medical procedures are allowed only in the
• Client’s rights to informed consent to participate
in the study, including the knowledge of the risks context of a scientific study in which participants are advised
and benefits, as well as other options for of potential risks and benefits.
services, must be ensured
Guidance on payments
•Payments cannot be used as an incentive to
accept, provide, or refer for VS services.
•Certain types of payments are not considered
incentives provided they are “reasonable” and
related to the procedure.
•Determination of “reasonable” payment must be
based on country and program-specific basis
using knowledge of social and economic
circumstances.
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 41
Guidance on payments
Acceptors:
Guidance on payments
VS Providers:
Guidance on payments
Referral agents:
Case Studies: Incentives for Clients and/or 8) Sterilization clients receive money, food, and/or clothing
Providers
after completing the sterilization procedure.
8) Case # 8: Sterilization clients receive money, The definition of an incentive, bribe, gratuity or financial
food, and/or clothing after completing the
sterilization procedure. reward requires the transfer of an item of value, in order to
influence or induce specific behavior by clients or program
9) Case # 9: Government employees get a pay personnel -- that is, an action occurred because of the
increase if they provide documentation of
sterilization after the birth of the second
payment. In the case of clients, such payments must be a
child. significant factor in the client’s decision to become a family
planning acceptor, in order for it to be a violation. Money,
food, or clothing given to sterilization clients is usually done
to reimburse clients for lost wages and/or out-of-pocket
expenses, and to remove cost barriers in their voluntary
choice of methods, and are not normally considered (by
providers) to be significant factors in the client’s decision.
However, client interviews are needed to confirm whether
such reimbursements are perceived as incentives and may
actually be a factor in their decision-making.
Case Studies: Incentives for Clients and/or 10) Providers receive per-case payment for sterilization
Providers
clients.
10) Case # 10: Providers receive per-case There can be legitimate reasons for being paid more for a
payment for sterilization clients.
greater number of acceptors of a specific FP method (e.g.
sterilization) because it requires more work or skill. Thus,
providers can make more money by providing more
services, as long as there is no “predetermined number”
that they are required to achieve in order to receive
payment.
Informed Choice (& voluntary decision-making) as a Better method use and client compliance leads to reduction
good program strategy in unplanned pregnancies and improved health
Ensuring informed choice leads to: Continued method use results from clients getting the
method they want and being prepared for side effects –
better method use and client compliance
continued method use This results in more clients that are satisfied with their
methods because they get to choose the method that is
satisfied clients are good ads
appropriate for them and are well prepared to handle
possible side effects that may or may not come with the use
of the method. These satisfied clients will be the best
promoters of the use of family planning.
44 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
To explain further…
This pre/post-test contains a number of case studies. As part of the post-test each case should be
discussed in a plenary session.
1. Translating the national target for contraceptive prevalence into numerical targets for individual
health service providers is a violation of the DOH Administrative Order on Ensuring Standards in
the Delivery of Family Planning Program and Services through Compliance to Informed Choice and
Voluntarism.
CORRECT ANSWER: TRUE. The specific guidelines of the DOH AO on ICV, DOH AO 2011-0005
reiterate that “Service providers shall not be subjected to target/quota, or other numerical targets
of total number of births, number of family planning acceptors or acceptors of a particular method
of family planning that may run contrary to clients’ decision”.
2. The performing LGU in Mainit province wanted to increase its contraceptive prevalence, among
other indicators, to facilitate the release of a performance-based grants by DOH. To ensure the
increase in contraceptive prevalence, the LGU provided educational assistance to two children of
mothers who agreed to under-to bi-tubal ligation. Is this an ICV-violation?
___Yes ____ No
CORRECT ANSWER: YES. The specific guidelines of the DOH AO on ICV, DOH AO 2011-0005
reiterate that incentives and financial rewards, gratuities and bribes shall not be provided in
exchange of or to influence clients’ decision for becoming an family planning acceptor or for service
provider to achieve a target or quota.
3. Our midwife saw that the public health nurse in the city of Ilang-ilang provided each vasectomy
client with Ph1,000, 10 kilos of rice, 21 capsules of antibiotics, 10 tablets of pain reliever. She
thought that this is a probable ICV vulnerability, but since this happened three months ago, she did
not report it to the local ICV monitoring committee. Do you agree with the midwife’s decision?
___Yes ____ No
CORRECT ANSWER: NO. The DOH AO mandates to do monitoring and reporting every three
months.
4. Since committing an abortion is a criminal offense, the health service provider with whom the client
consulted to manage her high fever and vaginal bleeding due to abortion should turn the client away
because treating the client will incriminate her and her license is in danger of being revoked. Do you
agree?
___Yes ____ No
CORRECT ANSWER: NO. It is the client’s right to be provided with the necessary health services.
50 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
5. A 28-year old woman, pregnant of her first child, is in labor and suffers from eclampsia (with
hypertension, seizure, maybe unconscious). The service provider asks her to sign a consent for bi-
tubal ligation, saying that having another pregnancy will endanger her life. Do you agree with the
health service provider’s action?
___Yes ____ No
CORRECT ANSWER: NO. The client is suffering from eclampsia. Therefore, she is not in her
proper state of mind to decide whether to undergo ligation or not. The health provider should wait
until the client has fully recovered or until such time that she can understand the procedure and its
consequences.
6. LGUs must ensure that their maternal health service, product and information provision follow the
four pillars (respect for the sanctity of life, respect for human rights, freedom of choice and
voluntary decisions or ICV, respects of the rights of clients to determine their desired family size) of
the DOH policies on family planning as a quality measurement of their family planning program
implementation.
CORRECT ANSWER: TRUE. DOH has been consistent in these principles as explicitly expressed in
DOH AO 50-A series of 2001, Memorandum issued on Sept. 1, 2006 to all DOH-ROs and in DOH
AO 2011-0005.
7. A 32 year-old mother, who did not finish Grade 1 and has four children consulted the government
city hospital of Malinis LGU, together with her husband. The mother does not want to get pregnant
anymore and her husband supports her. The nurse-on-duty, thinking that there was no trained
doctor on surgical sterilization, told the couple that the hospital could not provide any services of
that nature and just sent them home without telling them on where they could get information and
services. Do you agree with the nurse’s action? Why?
CORRECT ANSWER: DISAGREE. The nurse-on-duty is duty bound to refer the couple to other
health facilities offering family planning information, product and services. The DOH AO on ICV
mandates that private and public health facilities shall provide universal access to quality family
planning information and services to men and women whenever and wherever needed and enable
them to make informed choice and voluntarism. Further, the DOH AO states that family planning
services shall be part of the basic core packages of both public and private health care facilities.
8. The provincial Family Planning Coordinator of Masigla LGU found out that a private hospital
conducted a bi-tubal ligation without counselling and without securing an informed consent from the
client. The Family Planning Coordinator reported this to the Provincial Health Officer and the
Regional ICV compliance committee. She also discussed the AO on ICV with the Medical Director
and management of the private hospital. Are private health care facilities also mandated to follow
the DOH AO on ICV?
CORRECT ANSWER: YES. The DOH AO on ICV “applies to all DOH units and attached agencies
such as the Commission on Population and Philippine Health Insurance Corporation, non-
government organizations and the private sector.” “Compliance to ICV policy requirements shall
cover the operations of both public and private health facilities providing FP services under the local
government units and other government agencies in so far as their health service operations are
governed by technical guidelines, standards and policies mandate by DOH.”
52 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Annex J: ICV Monitoring Questions for Facility Managers, Supervisors and Providers
If services are not provided at the facility, do you refer clients to another provider/facility? If so,
what is your relationship with that provider/facility? Do you have an existing referral agreement? Is
the referring provider given compensation for making referrals?
2. Clinic Level: For family planning, how is your clinic performance evaluated? Do you have planned
family planning targets or goals? If yes, what kind of targets do you have for this facility?
Provider Level: Are you required to achieve any assigned specific targets/goals for family planning? If
so, what are these targets? What happens if you meet/fail your targets?
4. Comprehensive Information:
What information do you provide to clients interested in family planning? Do you provide
specific information for family planning methods chosen? If so, what?
Do you have materials (wall chart, brochure, flipchart etc.) that explain the various family
planning methods and their risks and benefits?
5. Have clients ever asked you advice about abortion? If so, what do you do?
6. Have clients ever asked you about regulation of menstruation? If so, what do you do?
7. Sterilization Services:
What kind of information do you provide to clients interested in bitubal ligation or vasectomy?
Do you ask the client to sign an informed consent form before any surgical sterilization
procedure? If so, do you keep client record of informed consent?
Are any benefits (food, money etc.) provided to clients who choose to undergo surgical
sterilization?
Closing Remarks: Thank you very much for your participation in this interview. We really appreciate
your feedback and please do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions or additional
information you would like to share.
3. Did you feel any pressure from anyone to use family planning? If yes, from whom?
4. Did someone give you anything in exchange for using a family planning method (e.g. food, money,
gift)? If yes, what did they give you and how much?
5. Was there a time that you preferred not to use a family planning method? Why?
If so, were you denied any benefits or access to any programs at this facility?
Do you know someone whose benefits are denied because of not accepting family planning?
Closing Remarks: Thank you very much for your participation in this interview. We really appreciate
your feedback and please do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions or additional
information you would like to share.
______________________________________________
______________________________________________
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 57
At least 2 to 4 weeks prior to the actual training, the organizers should choose and prepare the
practicum sites. The practicum sites shall be varied as follows:
a. Public or private hospital
b. Public or private birthing home
c. Population program office
d. Rural or city health unit
The organizers will need to write to the heads of these health care facilities, mentioning the objectives
of the practicum visit, points for discussion, and the data that the participants may look at.
The following matrix will help the organizer in prepping for the practicum. It contains the sample matrix
of practicum sites.
Practicum guide
Participants should be briefed on the practicum on the day prior to the actual site visit. Herewith is a
sample practicum guide.
3. Upon arrival at the facility, the facilitator, together with the group, shall pay a courtesy call to the
contact person whose name is indicated in the practicum site list.
5. After the introduction and courtesy call, the group shall start to interview the service providers and
clients:
a. If there are enough service providers and clients for each of the group members then they shall
work individually.
b. But if the facility does not have enough service providers, they may work in pairs.
58 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
c. If at the time of the visit there is only one service provider and one family planning client, the
group members shall divide themselves into two. One group shall interview the health provider
and the other group shall interview the family planning client.
d. Assign somebody from the group to look at the data of the facility on family planning.
7. After the interview, thank the respondent for their participation and cooperation.
8. If the interviewees have questions, and none of the group members are sure of the answer, kindly
discuss the question and the answer with the facilitator.
9. Once all members of the team have completed their respective service provider and client
interviews, the group leader shall return to the contact person and thank her/him for welcoming the
group into the facility and for the cooperation given.
The following is the planning matrix that can participants can fill up during the workshop:
ICV
ICV
ICV
Health care
waste
management
60 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Goal: Patients, staff & other individuals within the organization are provided a safe, functional and
effective environment of care
Standards:
The organization plans a safe & effective environment of care consistent with its mission,
services & with laws and regulations
Criteria:
o The organizational environment complies with structural standards and safety codes as
prescribed by law
o There are management plans which address safety, security, disposal and control of
hazardous materials and biological wastes, emergency and disaster preparedness, fire safety,
radiation safety and utility systems
o There are management plans for the safe and efficient use of medical equipment according
to specifications
The organization provides a safe & effective environment of care consistent with its mission,
services & with laws and regulations
Criteria:
o Policies and procedures that address safety, security, control of hazardous materials and
biological wastes, emergency and disaster preparedness, fire safety, radiation safety and
utility systems are documented and implemented
o Policies and procedures for the safe and efficient use of medical equipment according to
specifications are documented and implemented
o The design of patient areas provides sufficient space for safety, comfort and privacy of the
patient and for emergency care
o All personnel understand and fulfill their role in safe practice
o Risks are identified, assessed and appropriately controlled. Where elimination or
substitution is not possible, adequate warning and protection devices are used.
o A coordinated security arrangement in the organization assures protection of patients, staff
and visitors.
The organization routinely collects & evaluates information to improve the safety and adequacy
of the environment of care
Criteria:
o The effectiveness of safety procedures and devices are routinely tested, monitored and
improves
o An incident reporting system identifies potential harms, evaluates causal and contributing
factors for the necessary corrective and preventive action.
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 77
Standards:
Emergency light and/or power supply, water and ventilation systems are provided for, in keeping
with relevant statutory requirements and codes of practice
Regular maintenance of grounds, facilities & equipment in keeping with relevant statutory
requirements, codes of practice or manufacturers’ specifications are done to ensure a clean and
safe environment
Only people trained in the maintenance of that equipment shall be allowed to provide service to
said equipment. Registers and records of equipment and related maintenance are kept
Current information and scientific data from manufacturers concerning their products are
available for reference and guidance in the operation and maintenance of plant and equipment
3. Infection control
Goal: Risks of acquisition and transmission of infections among patients, employees, physicians and
other personnel, visitors and trainees are identified and reduced
Standards:
An interdisciplinary infection control program ensures the prevention and control of infection in
all services
The organization uses a coordinated system-wide approach to reduce the risks of nosocomial
infections
Criteria:
o The organization undertakes case finding and identification of nosocomial infections
o The organization takes steps to prevent and control outbreaks of nosocomial infections
The organization uses a coordinated system-wide approach to reduce the risks of infections
acquired by the staff in the performance of their duties
Criteria:
o There are programs for prevention and treatment of needlestick injuries and policies and
procedures for the safe disposal of used needles are documented and monitored
o There are programs for the prevention of transmission of airborne infections and risks from
patients with signs and symptoms suggestive of tuberculosis or other communicable diseases
are managed according to established protocols.
When needed, the organization reports information about infections to personnel and public
health agencies
78 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Goal: The provision of equipment and supplies supports the organization’s role.
Standards:
Planning of facilities and selection and acquisition of equipment and supplies involve input from
relevant staff and is undertaken by appropriately qualified personnel.
Criteria:
o Appropriate equipment and supplies that support the organization’s role and level of
service are provided with due considerations to at least, the intended use, cost benefits,
infection control, safety, waste creation and disposal, storage.
Items designated by the manufacturer for single use are not reused unless the organization has
specific policies and guidelines for safe reuse which take into consideration relevant statutory
requirements and codes of practice
Goal: The organization demonstrates its commitment to environmental issues by considering and
implementing strategies to achieve environmental sustainability
Standards:
The handling, collection and disposal of waste conform to relevant statutory requirements and
codes of practice
The organization implements a waste disposal program which involves reuse, reduction and
recycling
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 79
Slide 1
Slide 2
Slide 3
Slide 4
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 81
Slide 5
Slide 6
Slide 7
Section 3. Scope. These Rules and Regulations shall cover the importation,
manufacture, processing, handling, storage, transportation, sale, distribution, use and
disposal of all unregulated chemical substances and mixtures in the Philippines including
the entry, even in transit, as well as the keeping or storage and disposal of hazardous and
nuclear wastes into the country for whatever purpose.
Slide 8
I. RATIONALE
The Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR)
and the Department of Health (DOH) hereby jointly provide the
following guidelines on the management of health care wastes
pursuant to, among others, the following laws, rules and regulations:
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 83
Slide 9
Slide 10
II. OBJECTIVES
Slide 11
Slide 12
Slide 13
“Healthcare Facilities” (HCF), for this purpose, are public, private and
non-governmental institutions/facilities that contribute to the
improvement of the health status of an individual, which includes:
• Clinics and healthcare units related to patient care including but not limited to
dispensaries, alternative medicine clinics; obstetrics and maternity lying-in clinics;
out-patient clinics; dialysis centers; drug testing centers; transfusion centers;
military medical services; prison hospital and clinics; emergency medical care
services; physician’s offices/clinics; dental clinics; specialized healthcare
establishments such as convalescing homes and Differently Abled Person (DAP)
centers; derma, vein and skin clinics
• Rehabilitation centers, hospices, psychiatric centers, and centers providing long-
term healthcare services
• Related laboratories and research centers such as medical and bio-medical
laboratories, biotechnology laboratories and institutions, medical research
centers, blood banks and blood collection services, nuclear medicine laboratories,
animal research laboratories
• Ambulance and emergency care mobiles (including medical mission and health
services provided in evacuation centers)
• Teaching and training hospitals and medical schools
Slide 14
86 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Slide 15
Slide 16
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 87
Slide 17
Slide 18
Infectious Waste
88 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Slide 19
Sharps
Slide 20
Slide 21
Slide 22
90 | Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation
Slide 23
Thank you!
Toolkit for Monitoring Compliance on Informed Choice and Voluntarism and Environmental Mitigation | 91
As part of the baseline quality assessment and monitoring on environmental compliance, the team or the
assessor can look at the following documents at the facilities:
All these documents are pertinent and have to be available if the facilities are licensed by the
DOH and the LGU or accredited by PhilHealth.
Further, to verify what is written in their documents, the team can inspect on-site and look at the
following in the facilities:
a. What are the waste products that the LGU’s garbage collector collects (sharps, placenta,
commodities, etc.)
b. How are they collected (dumped together with the other regular household waste)
c. Where are they disposed of
d. Distance of septic tank/vault from source of water in meters