The 7 Pillars of Visionary Leadership
The 7 Pillars of Visionary Leadership
The 7 Pillars of Visionary Leadership
"puts them into shape." That's a the field is. The visionary leader is
tough job; hence, exhaustion, one who creates and nourishes the
burnout, stress and death 4-7 context for everyone not just
years after retirement have been executives or managers to be
the norm! Insurance companies "field creators" through ongoing
became quite clear about their conversations of employee fields
policies because they could predict continuously interacting and filling
the demise of their clients so organizational space. Since space
easily! is never "empty," visionary leaders
know intuitively and concretely
But with quantum theory and a that organizational space needs to
field theory of vision, we can begin be filled up with coherent and
to imagine an invisible geometry sincere vision. Authentic vision,
of fields filling organizational integrity, and ROIR Return-on-
space. Fields can be very powerful, Integrity/Investment-in-
as we know from the intensity and Relationships, become the new
pervasiveness of corporate culture "life blood" of this visionary
an invisible, yet powerful, force organization.
influencing behaviour and The Book of Proverbs states,
organizational outcomes.14 "Where there 16 is no vision, the
Hopper, the lead and mean people perish." We now know
grasshopper in "A Bug's Life" was from quantum theory why this so:
correct: "Ideas are dangerous!" If we do not participate genuinely
Robert Hass, CEO of Levi Strauss & and authentically is creating fields
Co., says that "conceptual of endeavour and of enterprise, we
controls" are what matter: "It's the will be at the mercy of the invisible
ideas of a business that are forces surrounding us and
controlling, not some manager experience the dissonance of
with authority."15 broken living. We can only tolerate
this kind of existential dissonance
By shifting from the linear model for so long before something
of vision to a quantum theory snaps. In a world that is now given
perspective, as some companies so many concrete answers to
and organizations are now doing questions of the spirit, is it any
we begin to believe the following: wonder that suicides, alcoholism,
despair and ennui pervade our
The field theory visionary leader: culture.
This person "creates and nourishes
the context" for vision to flourish. Spiritual questions of hope, of
The "conceptron" becomes the vision, of meaning and purpose
liberating energy package of life. demand spiritual pathways and
The visionary leader not only fields. Ironically, modern quantum
believes that vision and values physics gives the modern spiritual
inform the organization, but also, doubter a spiritual answer: field
that vision and values and ideas theory constructs, or "invisibles,"
must be disseminated throughout or "intangibles." Theology has
the organization. The visionary spoken of this mysticism of the
leader creates a conceptual universe for thousands of years.
network of thinking and feeling Science is now discovering what
and communicating the vision. we have known all along in our
There is no such "thing" as a hearts.
"vision statement." Rather,
"visioning" is everywhere, just as The Business Question
6
Question: Will business "buy" this? "perform." As you can see, it fits
perfectly with the Newtonian
Answer: What other choice have quantitative mindset. But work is
they got? an expression of who we are. In
the Middle Ages, the great
The new organizational wine theologian Thomas Aquinas wrote:
cannot be poured into old "To live well is to work20 well, or
organizational metaphors and display a good activity." He also
constructs. When it tries to do said that "despair is the most
that, it creates what psychologist dangerous of sins," for when
Marti Smye calls 17the 3 Fs: fear, despair takes over "all kinds of
frustration, fatigue . The statistics wickedness follow."21 We are
on what these 3 Fs cost the seeing a lot of that now in the
organization and the economy are tremendous social and economic
simply overwhelming, not only in costs, as well as the lost
terms of lost money and opportunities for people to belong
opportunities, but especially in to the human project of living a
broken lives. There has to be a worthy life. The "top line" does
better way. matter for it is more inclusive than
a "bottom line" with its number
In the chapter on "Visioning," The crunching mentalities. The top line
7 Pillars of Visionary Leadership includes vision, right brain
book describes this time as one of (intuition) and left brain (analysis);
"dead reckoning." In a reductionist but, most important, it provides
vision, control is everything. hope and asks people and
Hence, short-term thinking and employees to live out their
"quarterly results" mean vocation to be the best they can
everything. "Making the numbers" be. We can make new choices with
becomes the altar of sacrifice. And new visions. We can "do more with
what a sacrifice it is and has been. more" and truly unleash a future
In 1994 in Canada, $300-million worth going to.
was spent just on prescriptions for
depression for employees!18 In If the Newtonian mindset and
1995, workplace accidents due to vision "divided us up," the new
workplace change was estimated quantum mindset and vision
to be now costing Canadians $10- reconnects us, to one another and
billion annually!19 to the world around us. Our real
crisis will be if we do not have
For me personally, the most what it takes to be connected
devastating injury to ourselves and effectively: through
our nation in the 1990s has been communication, love and
our myopic vision around what compassion. At a time when the
constitutes work. The national world is "going global," many
vision has mistakenly equated a individual countries and territories
job as being the same thing as (witness Québec) are
work. They are not the same. A job disconnecting! I believe it is not
is an industrial metaphor and coincidence that the topics of (a)
construct that shaped the spirituality in the workplace and
manufacturing plant and, by (b) emotional intelligence loom so
extension, today's workplaces. It large in society today. We are all
was a "box" of duties and looking for meaning and heart.
responsibilities that employees The basics.
"had" and were required to
7
He toured relentlessly for the best new vision. We will then, as Pierre
part of 20 years, and earned the Teilhard de Chardin, once
kudos of critics around the world. remarked, discover fire for the
Perhaps he speaks for all of us second time.26
when he says, from his home in
Oakville, Ontario, that success is PILLAR II: Mapping
"being able to make a living, "Globalizing the Mind:
supporting your family by doing Charting a Future"
what you love ... avoid[ing] (Part 2 of 7)
cynicism, ... be[ing] patient.
Impatience can make you We are marching towards a more
desperate, and desperation forces liberated society in which free
compromise. If you compromise creativity will coexist with
your integrity, you've lost it all."24 interpretation of already written
Professor Stephen Ralls, director of texts. Okay, I like this. But we
the opera division at the University mustn't say we have substituted an
of Toronto's faculty of music, says, old thing with another one. We
"The touchstones of a successful can have both, thank God. TV-
career in opera are self- zapping is a kind of activity that
confidence, the concrete has nothing to do with watching a
possession of a good voice, movie. A hypertextual device that
stamina, the ability to withstand allows us to create new texts has
rejection and failure, the nothing to do with our ability to
conviction to make your career interpret pre-existing1 texts.
work, and the ability to get on with - Umberto Eco
people."24
"The British created a civil service
Should it be any different with our job in 1803 calling for a man to
vision for doing business? stand on the Cliffs of Dover with a
spyglass. He was supposed to ring
Finally, I believe also that when we a bell if he saw Napoleon coming.
experience laughter again in our The job was abolished in 21945."
lives and in our workplaces, we will - Robert Townsend
have left behind the intellectual
fascism of political correctness. We Canada Post's deep thinkers might
will have allowed joy and surprise want to hire King Canute as their
back into our lives and workplaces. advertising agency. The English
Dr. Wheatley remarks, "Were we to king achieved fame when he
become truly good scientists of demonstrated the limitations of his
our craft, we would seek out power by showing that, even if he
surprises, relishing the commanded it, he couldn't keep
unpredictable when it finally the tide from rolling in. A
decided to reveal itself to us. technological tide is rolling in over
Surprise is the only route to Canada Post. It is called E-mail.
discovery, the only path we can The number of electronic missives
take if we're to search out the is today in the gazillion range.
important principles that can - Editor, The Globe and Mail3
govern our work."25
Life is a journey. Any journey
When the day arrives, as surely it begins with a vision conscious or
must, when we become those otherwise of what the potential
"good scientists of our craft," we path will look like. There is a age-
will have the new wineskins for our old sequence of step that I have
9
an ethic of respect for the different If you're the best in the world at
maps that people carry around in making airplanes and everyone is
their heads. using your corporate map to
navigate, so to speak, when it
Once again the importance of comes to buying these planes,
emotional intelligence and EQ what do you do when sales don't
(emotional quotient) is critical. materialize the way they once did?
Multi-Health Systems Inc. (MHS), a
leading test publishing company That's exactly what happened to
and owners of the world rights to the U.S. aerospace industry at the
the BarOn EQ-i, the world's first end of the Cold War. Where
scientific measure of emotional before the 'fat map' fostered a
intelligence, recently tested (1998) mentality that "bigger and more
the emotional intelligence of 104 complicated was better," now the
information technology specialists new mantra is "simplify, simplify,
using the BarOn EQ-i. simplify." A radical shift to a new
map -- a new way of doing things
The groups surveyed included --has taken place.
systems analysts, technical support
specialists, MIS, network The concept of 'lean' production
administrators, systems analysts, swept North America in the 1980s
and programmers. Interesting and early '90s.
trends were detected. With an
average EQ score of 97.512, IT The concept of 'lean' is hardly lean
people were found to have a lower itself these days: It's been saddled
overall EQ than most groups that with mounds of mumbo-jumbo.
have been examined (e.g., human But at its heart, it's simple. It
resources professionals tested had involves mapping out all the steps
an average EQ of 110). Among the it takes to produce a product and
IT groups, the highest EQ went to trying to eliminate those that add
the technical support specialists no value. That includes such things
[113], and the lowest was scored as storing an item in inventory, or
by programmers [92]. The MIS keeping it waiting on an assembly
group was 13 the second highest line for a machine to become
scorers [110]. available.
The message is clear: not only do To address this need for a new
we need a new shared map, but 'lean map,' MIT (Massachusetts
we also need well-developed EQ, Institute of Technology) put
or emotional smarts, to build that together a consortium called the
map. Otherwise, like the ancient Lean Aerospace Initiative. The
Tower of Babel, we will find, at group studied how lean practices
best, that nothing gets done or, at could be applied to aid the
worst, we end up with aerospace business amid such
interpersonal and financial warfare. tumultuous changes as we have
That's the recipe for potential today.
bankruptcy, lower profits,and
huge, costly stress-related The results of the new mapping?
illnesses. Chris Cool, vice-president of lean
integration for Dallas - based
2. 'Fat'14and 'Lean' Maps and Flying Northrop Grumman, holds 'lean
Planes events' throughout the year at his
company. One of their products is
13
the wing for the Gulfstream V Why is all this important? Because
business jet. Ron Vuz, its program he is Canada's loss, even though
manager, points out that work he's the computer world's gain. He
flows much more steadily from left Canada in the late 1970s
one end of the building to the because Canada didn't have a
other. A year ago it took 250 thinking map that would take risks,
Northrop Gumman employees foster innovation, and reward
eight days to make a wing; now it excellence. David Crane,
takes91 workers just nine days to economist - writer for The Toronto
do the same thing. Worker Star, has long complained of this
acceptance through reassignments lack of vision and map on
became part of the new map as Canada's part16. Gosling casually
well. The unions were promised says, "The kind of stuff I was
that no workers would be laid off interested in doing and had been
in the process. To get executives trained to do really wasn't being
on board with the new map, the done here [in Canada]."
company based 35% of their
compensation on meeting the What is Gosling now famous for?
goals of new lower costs and The industry-shaking JAVA
higher production targets. computer language!
Was switching to a new map He says that when he was 22,
difficult? For some it was. For Canada's high-tech industry wasn't
those workers used to procedures, worth sticking around for. In The 7
forms, and the bureaucracy of Pillars context, that's like saying
doing things the old 'fat way', the that Canada psychologically and
'leanness map' redefined their spiritually and intellectually didn't
jobs. Chris Cool said that the old have a map innovative enough to
map was "their identity." appreciate who he was.
Technology reporter Tyler
The lesson for us: oftentimes we Hamilton writes, "This country
don't have a choice. We can live treated him as the Canadian-born
with an old map and never get to guy who had to go south to do
where were supposed to, or we something neat."
can learn to become familiar with
a new map. Like the Israelites The lesson for us and the new
before us 4,000 years ago, we map? Gosling says, "The real
must make the decision to rethink, payoffs you never understand. You
relearn, and eventually, rejoice in should just give good people
the freedom of the new promised money and tell them to do good
land. things."
3. 'Brain Drains' and Maps15 Conclusion
James Gosling is a Canadian Let me conclude these thoughts
turned Californian and a very on mapping by highlighting a
bright person. He has a Ph.D. in study that my colleague and co-
computer science from Carnegie- author, Dr. Michael Cox, did. He
Mellon University in Pittsburgh. He researched 250 companies in the
did his undergraduate degree at province of Ontario to try to
the University of Calgary in 1977. identify if there was a direct
connection between attitudinal
mindset or map its readiness to
14
the word “chart” in the legend staff, or fire the person. While we
part of the chart (above). can argue that many toxic
Managers and executives spent individuals should have been fired,
much time “charting” out the 5, 10, we can also state that 75% of the
and sometimes 15 year strategic reason for those who were fired,
plan. It was a logical, analytical was EQ-related: they could not be
experience, and when companies team players, get along with
stuck to the plan, they usually did others, show empathy, etc. Today,
quite well. Mental smarts were at a this kind of toxic individual – an
premium. While being mentally employee, manager or executive
prepared is still a sine qua non, with low EQ – is an absolute
that preparedness is not enough liability. Low EQ will cost the
today. I tell my students, “Your organization – time, resources,
diploma or degree will get you in money, reputation – and possibly
the door. To have it does not even force it into bankruptcy. The
necessarily guarantee you a job. reason for this is that today's
Not to have it of necessity does workplace is a workplace
not guarantee you a job.” It's a bombarded by change. Since
“Catch-22" for students and “change = learning,” if an
potential hires. Even though organization is not in “learning
enough research abounds that mode” on a continual basis, it will
indicates a very high correlation be unable to adapt. That is why
between traditional job success the second word I use in the chart
factors and high IQ or intellectual above is the word change. It
smarts, more is needed today for should also be obvious the much
success. larger area of competency (or EQ)
needed for managing this change.
Research now also shows that this Notice also the tapering of the
IQ benchmark – while important – charting competency (or IQ). At
only accounts for 2-6% of life this point, managers and
success and about 20% of job executives have to learn to steer
success! What has emerged over more than plan.
the past 20 years is Dr. Reuven
BarOn's research and his EQ-i Finally, there is a third element to
(Emotional Quotient-Inventory) the chart, what I call “SQ” or
which now has studies showing “strategic quotient” or “strategic
that “EQ” – emotional smarts – smarts.” What impacts the
accounts for almost 50% of life organization in the globalized
and job success. Dr. BarOn tried to marketplace are the chance
answer the question, “Why are occurrences, the opportunities for
some very bright people capable either success or deep failure. We
of some very stupid and even can have the best of mental and
unethical behaviours?” The answer emotional smarts, but we need
was that high IQ did not entrepreneurship of the mind and
necessarily mean an emotionally execution of will to navigate the
and interpersonally accomplished waters of opportunity. The Chinese
individual. Actually, the opposite have a wonderful expression:
was often true: a very bright and Success is Preparation x
intellectually adroit individual was Opportunity. SQ allows an
often cold, aloof, belligerent, etc. organization to “seize the
The organization was then left moment,” as the Roman poet
with a choice: keep this smart, but Horace wrote in naming his poem
interpersonally toxic, individual on (“Carpe Diem”).
30
are attuned to and living out that Purpose. Trust. Optimism. Action.
ethic of learning. Eric Hoffer, who Four qualities the modern leader
lived from 1902-1983, wrote: must inspire or exemplify
according to business academic
In a time of drastic change Warren Bennis. Leadership helps
design the 'social architecture'
it is the learners capable of building intellectual
capital. It is the main instrument
who inherit the future. for leveraging that capital1.
The learned
We have just witnessed a
usually find themselves crystallizing point in the lack of
mentorship: the killings at
equipped to live in a world Columbine High School in
Littleton, Colorado. History may
that no longer exists. show that April 1999 was indeed a
turning-point. The evil and the
horror that was evident in those
PILLAR V: Mentoring killings shocked the world and
"Sharing Knowledge: especially North American society
Empowering a Future" in a way that other events did not.
(Part 5 of 7) Most parents were asking
themselves, "What have we bred in
"If ye break faith with us who die our midst? What has happened to
We shall not sleep." us?" As in the opening quote,
"Where have all the flowers gone?"
Lt. Col. John McCrae, M.D. (1872- Or, "Where have all the mentors
1918) gone?"
"In Flanders Field"
The word "mentor"
"How many roads must a man comes from a character
walk down named Mentor in
Before they call him a man ... Homer's Odyssey.
The answer, my friend, is blowing Because Odysseus had
in the wind been away for many
The answer is blowing in the wind" years, his son Telemachus
was deprived of a father
Bob Dylan, "Blowin' in the Wind," figure who could serve as
1962 a role model. The
goddess Athene
therefore disguised herself as
Mentes and encouraged
"Where have all the flowers gone, Telemachus to take a journey.
long time passing? Telemachus was gratified "in his
Where have all the flowers gone, spirit, courage, and determination,
long time ago?" and he remembered his father
even more." The next guise Athene
chose was Mentor -- Odysseus'
Peter, Paul and Mary, 1960s former companion -- who
encouraged the youth: "You are no
thoughtless man, no coward, if
truly the strong force of your
32
If you scored 0-24: You're are, or it let slip out of its hands the some
will be, in trouble. of the very heart of technology
that makes the new economy tick.
James Corridoren, an analyst at
Standard & Poor's in New York
The Teachable Point of View: says, "Top to bottom, Xerox has
Ancient Athens the best technology in
One of my favourite mentoring documents." Writer Amanda Lang
passages in The 7 Pillars of of The Financial Post comments,
Visionary Leadership is the one "To be true, there are examples
about the young man who visits where the company seemed to
his mentor, Socrates, in the early hold the future in its hands, only
hours of the morning: to fumble on the way to a slam
dunk. Remembering that past
A beautiful story recounts one could be all Xerox needs to focus
young man's excitement about on the future." 7
learning. A young manknocks on
Socrates' door in the early dawn. Case example #2:
Socrates is still half asleep when
heanswers the door and says, In mentoring a roadmap to
"What's here?" The young man manage stress, Elaine Calder, 51,
cries out, "O Socrates. Goodnews, Canada's pre-eminent arts
good news!" Of course, Socrates is troubleshooter, passes on her
wondering what could be such wisdom. In her efforts to make
news at suchan early hour. The sure "the centre holds" (literally)
young man continues: "O Socrates, for the National Arts Centre in
Protagoras has come. I heard Ottawa, she outlines her four
ityesterday evening. And I was steps:8
going to you at once but it was so
late ." By this timeSocrates is
getting curious and wants to know You have to do an enormous
what this Protagoras talk is all amount of listening;
about. Heasks, "Has he stolen You have to be really honest;
something of yours?" At this the Don't waver in your
young man bursts out commitment; and
laughing."Yes, yes, that's just it. Have an understanding
He's robbing me of wisdom. He partner who puts up with
has it, wisdom, and he can give it long hours and rented digs.
to me. Oh, come and go with me
to him. Start now."6 Case example #3:
Women Entrepreneurs of Canada
is a volunteer program run by
Concluding Scenarios partners who match
businesswomen with more
Case example #1: experienced advisors. Marian
Pitters found such a mentor in
At the heart of mentoring is the Wendy Banting, the owner of a
reality of remembering. To forget secure paper shredding company.
or not to know one's history, for Mentors provide the type of
example, is to walk foolishly into guidance they are seeking -- from
the future. One company that has a non-competitive standpoint.
learned its lesson about mentoring Mentors, suchas Ms. Banting,
is Xerox Corp. It realizes today that spend at least three hours a month
35