Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger Design 2
Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger Design 2
Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger Design 2
ABSTRACT
Since shell and tube heat exchangers are the most used heat transfer equipment in
industrial processes, a basic understanding of their design, construction and performance is
important. This paper optimized a design of a shell and tube type heat exchanger that heats
150,000 pounds per hour of kerosene from 75 to 120F by cooling 142,105 pounds per hour
gasoline stream entering at 160F. Based on the given inlet and outlet conditions, a thermal
and mechanical design method was achieved to obtain a set of optimum dimensions and
geometry for the heat exchanger. The calculated results were tabulated in a heat exchanger
data sheet and a setting up plan was illustrated in a 2D and 3D model.
1
I. INTRODUCTION
Transfer of heat from one fluid to another is an important operation for most of
chemical industry. So it is necessary to develop the equipment which transfers the heat
with maximum rate and minimum costs. Such equipment for efficient transfer of heat is
called as heat exchanger. Thus heat exchangers facilitate the exchange of heat between
the fluids that are different temperature while keeping them from mixing with each other.
Heat exchangers have undergone numerous modifications over the ages and have become
quite efficient compared to their predecessors. There are different types of heat
exchangers with different designs, materials and have been customized to meet specific
needs. One of these types is the shell and tube heat exchanger which is one of the most
widely used heat exchanger in oil refineries and other large chemical process.
A. General Description
Shell and tube heat exchangers are the most versatile type of heat exchanger. They
provide relatively large ratios of heat transfer area to volume and weight and they can
be easily cleaned. Shell and tube heat exchangers can be designed for high pressures
relative to the environment and high pressure differences between fluid streams.
Furthermore, it consists of bundle of round tubes mounted in cylindrical shell with
tubes parallel to shell. One fluid flows through tubes, while another fluid flows across
and along the axis of the exchanger. Basically, a service of the shell ant tube heat
exchanger may be single phase such as the cooling or heating of a liquid or gas or
two-phase such as condensing or vaporizing.
B. How it works?
The two fluids that flow through the shell and tube heat exchanger will typically
begin at different temperatures. One fluid will flow through the tube side while the
other fluid will flow outside of the tubes on the shell side. Fluids may be either gases
or liquids. In order to ensure that heat is transferred efficiently, the heat transfer area
should be large. This makes it possible for any heat waste to be utilized, thus
conserving energy.
2
Shell and tube heat exchangers may feature only one phase, either gas or liquid,
on each side. In this instance, they are known as single-phase or one-phase heat
exchangers. In a two-phase heat exchanger, a liquid can be heated to the point that it
is boiled into a gas or it may be used for the purpose of cooling a vapor so that it can
then be condensed into a liquid. Such phase changes typically take place on the shell
side of the shell and tube heat exchanger. This type of heat exchanger may be used in
a variety of different applications based on the specific needs of that industry. The
shell and tube design can also include a variety of variations based on specific
industrial needs. For instance, the tubes inside the exchanger may be U-shaped or they
may be straight.
D. Components
The principal components of an STHE are:
1. Shell;
2. Tubes;
3. Channel;
4. Channel cover;
5. Tube sheet;
6. Baffles; and
7. Nozzles.
3
E. Classification
SHELL AND
TUBE ADVANTAGES LIMITATIONS
EXCHANGERS
Provides maximum Shell side / outside of the tubes
heat transfer area for a are inaccessible for mechanical
given shell and tube cleaning.
diameter. No provision to allow for
Fixed tube Provides for single and differential thermal expansion
sheet multiple tube passes to developed between the tube
assure proper velocity. and the shell side. This can be
Less costly than taken care by providing
removable bundle expansion joint on the shell
designs. side.
Floating tube sheet To provide the floating-head
allows for differential cover it is necessary to bolt it
thermal expansion to the tube sheet. The bolt
between the shell and circle requires the use of space
the tube bundle. where it would be possible to
Both the tube bundle place a large number of tubes.
Floating head and the shell side can Tubes cannot expand
be inspected and independently so that huge
cleaned mechanically. thermal shock applications
should be avoided.
Packing materials produce
limits on design pressure and
temperature.
U-tube design allows Because of U-bend some tubes
for differential thermal are omitted at the center of the
expansion between the tube bundle.
shell and the tube Because of U-bend, tubes can
bundle as well as for be cleaned only by chemical
individual tubes. methods.
Both the tube bundle Due to U-tube nesting,
U-tube
and the shell side can individual tube is difficult to
be inspected and replace.
cleaned mechanically. No single tube pass or true
Less costly than countercurrent flow is possible.
floating head or packed Tube wall thickness at the U-
floating head designs. bend is thinner than at straight
portion of the tubes.
4
III. DESIGN PROBLEM
150,000 lb per hour of kerosene will be heated from 75 to 120F by cooling a 142,105 lb
per hour of gasoline stream which enters at 160F. Inlet pressure will be 50 psia for each
stream and the maximum pressure drop of 7 psi for gasoline and 10 psi for kerosene are
permissible. Design a shell and tube heat exchanger for this service.
A. Given
B. Figure
Gasoline
Kerosene
Tci Thi h 142,105
m
lb
lb
c 150,000
m h
h
Tho Tco
5
C. Physical Properties
Btu
Specific Heat 0.48
lb F
Btu
Thermal Conductivity 0.083
h ft F
lb
Density 49.8
ft 3
lb
Viscosity 3.872
h ft
Btu
Specific Heat 0.57
lb F
Btu
Thermal Conductivity 0.075
h ft F
lb
Density 42.7
ft 3
lb
Viscosity 0.484
h ft
V. THERMAL DESIGN
Pressure drop is a major constraint in the thermal design of shell and tube heat
exchangers. A thermal design of a shell and tube heat exchanger is meaningful only when
it is optimum and the extent of the optimality is constrained by the pressure drop.
Optimization of thermal design requires maximization of overall heat transfer coefficient
and effective mean temperature difference so as to minimize the heat transfer area subject
to the constraints, pressure drop being the major one. The main steps of the thermal
design following the Kern method are summarized in the design procedure.
6
A. PROCESS DESIGN
Specification
Define duty
Make energy balance if needed to O
calculate unspecified flow rates or
temperatures
Accept Design
Calculate number of tubes
7
B. CALCULATIONS
STEP 1:
TUBE DIAMETER
D 0 = 1in = 25.40mm
Di = 0.834in = 21.18mm
TUBE LENGTH
L 16 ft
BWG NUMBER
BWG =14
TUBE PATTERN
Square Pitch, Pt = 1.25 D 0
= 1.25 25.40 mm
= 31.75 mm
STEP 2:
FOULING FACTOR
1
Gasoline (Hot Fluid) : = 0.0005
h id
1
Kerosene (Cold Fluid) : = 0.001
h od
STEP 3:
CARBON STEEL
Btu
k w = 70
h ft F
STEP 4:
Assume three known temperatures,
Th in = 160F Tc in = 75F
Th out = unknown Tc out 120 o F
8
KEROSENE:
q = m c cp c (Tc o - Tc i )
lb Btu
q = (150,000 )(0.48 )[(120 - 75)F]
h lb F
Btu
q = 3,240,000
h
GASOLINE:
q = m h cp h (Th i - Th o )
Btu lb Btu
3,240,000 = (142,105 )(0.57 )[(160F - Th o ]
h h lbF
Th o = 120F
STEP 5:
For Co-Current LMTD (Log Mean Temperature Difference),
(Th i - Th o ) - (Tc o - Tc i )
Tlm =
(Th i - Th o )
ln
(Tc o - Tc i )
(160 - 120)F - (120 - 75)F
Tlm =
(160 - 120)F
ln
(120 - 75)F
Tlm = 42.75F
STEP 6:
Based on the exchanger configuration,
9
Th i - Th o 160 - 120
R= = = 0.889
Tc o - Tc i 120 - 75
Tc o - Tc i 120 - 75
S= = = 0.529
Th i - Tc i 160 - 75
(1 - S)
(R 2 + 1)ln[ ]
(1 - RS)
Ft =
2 - S(R + 1 - (R 2 + 1)
(R - 1)ln[ ]
2 - S(R + 1 + (R 2 + 1)
(1 - 0.529)
(0.889 2 + 1)ln[ ]
(1 - (0.889)(0. 529)
Ft =
2 - (0.529)[0. 889 + 1 - (0.889 2 + 1) ]
(0.889 - 1)ln[
2 - (0.529)[0. 889 + 1 + 0.889 2 + 1)]
Ft = 0.802 : ACCEPTABLE
STEP 7:
Calculate,
MEAN TEMPERATURE DIFFERENCE
Tm = Ft Tlm
Tm = (0.802)(42 .75F)
Tm = 34.2855F
STEP 8:
Assume,
OVERALL HEAT TRANSFER COEFFICIENT
Btu
U o = 45
h ft 2 F
STEP 9:
Calculate,
PROVISIONAL AREA
q
A=
U o Tm
Btu
(3,240,000 )
A= h
Btu
(45 )(71C)
h ft 2 F
A = 2100 ft 2
10
STEP 10:
Based on the assumed tube diameter Do and tube length L,
NUMBER OF TUBES
A
Nt =
D o L
2100 ft 2
Nt =
1
( ft)(16ft)
12
N t = 502 : make it 518 because it is taken correspond ing to the closest standard
N t = 518 tubes
11
VOLUMETRIC FLOW
TUBE SIDE VELOCITY =
AREA PER PASS
3327.986 ft 3 /h
=
42.7 ft 2
ft
= 3,386.918 : VELOCITY IS NOT SATISFACTO RY BECAUSE
h
TUBE SIDE VELOCITY MUST WITHIN 11,811.02362 -
23,622.04724 ft/h
Assume 4 PASS:
AREA PER PASS = 129.5 3.79367 10 3 ft 2
= 0.4913 ft 2
3,327.986 ft 3 /h
TUBE SIDE VELOCITY =
0.4913 ft 2
= 6,773.83676 ft/h : NOT SATISFACTO RY
Assume 6 PASS:
AREA PER PASS = 86.333 3.79367 10 3 ft 2
= 0.32752 ft 2
3,327.986 ft 3 /h
TUBE SIDE VELOCITY =
0.32752 ft 2
= 10,161.1647 ft/h : NOT SATISFACTO RY
At L= 24 ft,
A
Nt =
D o L
2100 ft 2
Nt =
1
( ft)(24ft)
12
N t = 335 : make it 318 because it is taken correspond ing to the closest standard
N t = 318 tubes
Assume 2 PASS:
AREA PER PASS = 159 3.79367 10 3 ft 2
= 0.60319 ft 2
ft 3
3,327.986
TUBE SIDE VELOCITY = h
0.60139 ft 2
ft
= 5,517.278 : NOT SATISFACTO RY
h
12
Assume 4 PASS,
AREA PER PASS = 79.5 3.79367 10 3 ft 2
= 0.3016 ft 2
ft 3
3,327.986
TUBE SIDE VELOCITY = h
2
0.3016 ft
ft
= 11,034.55621 : NOT SATISFACTO RY
h
Assume 6 PASS,
AREA PER PASS = 53 3.79367 10 3 ft 2
= 0.201064 ft 2
ft 3
3,327.986
TUBE SIDE VELOCITY = h
0.201064 ft 2
ft
= 16,551.83432 : ACCEPTABLE
h
Nt = 318 tubes: 6 passes at L=24 ft
STEP 11:
TUBE PITCH AND BUNDLE DIAMETER
Pt = 1.25DO : TUBE PITCH
Pt = 1.25(1 in)
Pt = 1.25 in
N t n11
Db = D o ( ) : BUNDLEDIAM ETER
K1
For 6 tube passes, square pitch
K 1 = 0.0402
n 1 = 2.617
N t n11
Db = D o ( )
K1
1
318 2.617
Db = (1 in)( )
0.0402
Db = 30.872 in = 0.78 m
13
STEP 12:
TYPE OF FLOAT HEAD OF THE HEAT EXCHANGER AND THE BUNDLE
DIAMETER CLEARANCE (BDC)
Assume Split-Ring Floating Head Exchanger
Since, Db=0.78 mm = 30.872 in
BDC= 67 mm = 2.638 in
STEP 13:
SHELL DIAMETER
Ds = Db + BDC
Ds = 30.872 in + 2.638 in
Ds = 33.51 in 2.7925 ft
STEP 14:
BAFFLE SPACING
Bs = 0.5Ds
Bs = 0.5(33.51 in)
Bs = 16.755 in
STEP 15:
AREA FOR CROSS-FLOW
(Pt - D o )
As = DsBs
Pt
(1.25 - 1) in
As = (33.51 in)(13.404 in)
1.25 in
As = 112.292 in 2
As = 9.358 ft 2
STEP 16:
SHELL-SIDE MASS VELOCITY
shell - side flow - rate
Gs =
As
lb
(142,105 )
Gs = h
2
(9.358 ft )
lb
Gs = 15,185.942
h ft 2
14
SHELL-SIDE VELOCITY
Gs
us =
lb
15,185.942
us = h ft 2
lb
42.7 3
ft
ft
u s = 355.643
h
STEP 17:
SHELL EQUIVALENT DIAMETER
For a square pitch arrangement
1.27 2 2
de = (Pt - 0.785D o )
Do
1.27
de = [(1.23 in) 2 - 0.785(1 in) 2 ]
1 in
d e = 0.987 in 0.082 ft
STEP 18:
SHELL-SIDE REYNOLDS NUMBER
u s d e
Re =
ft lb
(355.643 )(0.082 ft)(42.7 3 )
Re = h ft
lb
0.484
ft h
Re 2572.825 z
STEP 19:
SHELL-SIDE PRANDTLS NUMBER
c p
Pr = ft
k
lb Btu
(0.484 )(0.57 )
Pr = ft h lb F
Btu
(0.075 )
h ft F
Pr 3.6784
15
STEP 20:
SHELL-SIDE HEAT TRANSFER COEFFICIENT
1
k
h o = hs = [(j h RePr 3 )( ) 0.14 ] neglect the viscositycorrelation
de w
1
k
ho = (j h RePr 3 )
de
Btu
0.075 1
ho = ( h ft F -2
)[(2.9 10 )(3216.087)(3.6784) 3 ]
0.082 ft
Btu
h o = 155.3
h ft 2 F
STEP 21:
PRESSURE DROP IN THE SHELL
f G s2 D s (n b 1)
Ps =
(7.5 1012 ) De S
Ps =
Ps =
Ps =
STEP 22:
NUMBER OF TUBES PER PASS
Nt
Nt pp =
number of passes
316
Nt pp =
6
Nt pp = 53 tubes per pass
16
STEP 23:
TUBE-SIDE MASS VELOCITY
tube - side flow rate
Gm = 2
D i
Nt pp
4
lb
(150,000 )
Gm = h
1 ft 2
(0.834 in )
(53) 12 in
4
lb
G m = 746,029.32
h ft 2
STEP 24:
TUBE-SIDE VELOCITY
Gm
t =
lb
746,029.32
t = h ft 2
lb
49.8 3
ft
ft
t = 14,980.509
hr
STEP 25:
TUBE-SIDE REYNOLDS NUMBER
dv
Re =
lb ft
(49.8 3 )(0.0695 ft)(1.4,98 0.509 )
Re = ft h
N -s
3.2 10 -3
m
Re = 13390.76
STEP 27:
OVERALL HEAT TRANSFER FACTOR
1
Uo =
1 A d di A 1 A
+ R dg o ( o ) + o ( ) o (R ak )
ho A1 2 k w A1 h i A1
1
Uo =
1 0.834
1 (1) 2
(1) 2 1 (1) 2
+ 0.0005 + ( 12 12 ) + ( )+ (0.0001)
155.3 0.834 2 2 70 0.834 2 153.86 0.834 2
( ) ( ) ( )
12 12 12
Btu
U o = 48.3
h ft 2 F
STEP 28:
TUBE-SIDE PRESSURE DROP
8jf L -m i 2
P = (1.5 + N p [2.5 + + ( ) ])
di w 2
8(5.5 10 -3 )(5000) 820(1.52) 2
P = {1.5 + 4[2.5 + ]}( )
14.83 10 -3 2
N
P = 67,103.40 2
m
P = 0.67 bar
18
VI. MECHANICAL DESIGN
Mechanical design involves the design of pressure-retaining and non-pressure-
retaining components and equipment to withstand the design loads, pressure and
temperature and the deterioration in service so that the equipment will function
satisfactorily and reliably throughout its codal life. Mechanical design is done as per the
procedure given in the construction codes and standards. In this mechanical design of
shell and tube heat exchanger, the design standard used is IS:4503.
i. Design Temperature
10C greater than the maximum allowable temperature
T 1.1 160 F
T 176 F (80 C)
ii. Design Pressure
10% greater than the maximum allowable working pressure
P 1.1 50 psia
N
P 55psia (0.38 )
mm 2
B. MATERIALS OF CONSTRUCTION
i. Carbon Steel
Allowable Fluid Temperatur e 540 C (1004 F)
N
Permissibl e Stress 100.6
mm 2
Corrosion Allowance 3mm
19
C. DESIGN COMPONENT CALCULATION
i. Shell Thickness
PD s
t s:
fJ 0.6p
where : t s shell thickness
P design pressure
f maximum allowable stress
J joint efficiency
N
(0.38 )(787.4mm)
ts mm 2
N N
(100.6 2
)(0.8) (0.6)(0.38 )
mm mm 2
t s 3.72mm C
t s 6.72mm : Including corrosion allowance
: Use 8 mm thickness
20
Thickness of the Head
PR i W
th
(2fJ 0.2p)
where : R i crown radius D
P design pressure
f permissibl e stress
J joint efficiency
1 Ri
W (3 ) 1.77mm
4 ri
N
(0.38 2
)(787.4mm) (1.77mm)
th mm
N N
2(1)(100.6 mm 2 ) (0.2)(0.38 mm 2 )
t h 2.63mm C
t h 5.63mm : Including corrosion allowance
: Use 8 mm, same thickness as for shell
D c C1 P
t cc ( )
10 f
where : D c outside shell diameter
kgf
(0.3)(3.88 )
803.4mm cm 2
t cc ( )
10 kgf
(10.26 )
cm 2
t cc 8.45mm C
t cc 11.45mm : Including corrosion allowance
: Use 12mm
21
iv. Tube Sheet Thickness
FG p P
t ss ()
3 kf
where : G p diameter over which pressure is acting D s
F 1 (for fixed tube sheet)
f allowance stress
k 0.5 (for square pitch)
P pressure
N
(0.38
(1)(787.4m m) mm 2
t ss ( )
3 N
(0.5)(100. 6 )
mm 2
t ss 22.8mm : Satisfies the IS : 4503 specificat ion for 1in. outside diameter t ube
v. Impingement Plate
k density of kerosene
g
k 0.8
cm 3
kg
k 800 3
m
k mass flow rate of kerosene
m
kg
k 18.91
m
s
lb
150,000
m
h
k velocity of kerosene
mk
k 2
D
( n ) k
4
where : D n Nozzle diameter
203.2mm 0.2032m
kg
18.91
k s
(0.2032m) 2 kg
(800 3 )
4 m
m
k 0.73
s
22
Impingemen t Parameter, v 2 (0.8)(0.73 ) 2
v 2 0.426 125
The impingemen t protection is not required
Note:
The pressure at the entry point of both shell and tube fluids are same. Therefore,
the same nozzle specification can be used for the tube side fluid also.
D OG Y Pm
D IG Y P(m 1)
kgf kgf
5.35 (0.0388 )(3.75)
D OG mm 2
mm 2
D IG kgf kgf
5.35 2
(0.0388 )(3.75 1)
mm mm 2
D OG
1.05
D IG
23
DIG 787.4mm 0.25 787.65mm
DOG 830mm
Gasket Width
D OG D IG
N
2
830mm 787.65mm
N
2
N 22mm : Use 35mm
24
viii. Bolts
The bolt load due to gasket reaction under atmospheric condition is given:
Wm1 bGY
N
Wm1 (2.09mm)( 808mm)(52. 4835 )
mm 2
Wm1 278,5151N
The minimum bolt cross-sectional area (both material is carbon steel, fa=fb)
Wm1
Am
fa
278,515N
Am
N
100.6
mm 2
A m 2,769mm 2
25
ix. Flange Thickness
Moment due to HD
MD HDh D
(C b B)
where :h D
2
(860 803.4)mm
hD
2
h D 28.3mm
M D (192,635N)(28.3mm)
M D 5,451,570N mm
26
Gasket load under operating conditions
HG W H
G 2 P
where : H
4
N
(808mm) 2 (0.38 )
H mm 2
4
H 194,848N
W Wm2
H G 207,870N 194,848N
H G 13,022N
Moment due to HG
MG HGhG
(C b G)
where :h G
2
(860 808)mm
hG
2
h G 26mm
M G (13,022N)(26mm)
M G 334,572N mm
Moment due to HT
MT HThT
h P h G
where :h T
2
28.3mm 26mm
hT
2
h T 17.15mm
M T (2,213N)(27.15mm)
M T 60,083N mm
27
Summation moments under operating condition
Mf MD MT MG
M f (5,451,570 60,083 338,572)N mm
M f 5,850,225N mm
Mf Y
tf
ff a B
(14,270,714N mm)(18)
tf
N
(100.6 )(803.4mm)
mm 2
t f 56.4mm
28
VII. THE OPTIMIZED DESIGN
A. 2D Model
B. 3D Model
29