DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/star.v3i4.

23
ISSN: 2226-7522(Print) and 2305-3372 (Online)
Science, Technology and Arts Research Journal
Sci. Technol. Arts Res. J., Oct-Dec 2014, 3(4): 158-164
Journal Homepage: http://www.starjournal.org/

Original Research

Experimentation and Prediction of Temperature Rise in Turning Process

using Response Surface Methodology
Zeelan Basha N*, Semegn Cheneke and Geleta Fekadu

Department of Mechanical Engineering, College of Engineering and Technology, Post Box No: 395,
Wollega University, Nekemte, Ethiopia
Abstract Article Information
Reducing the temperature rise during turning operation improves the quality of the product and Article History:
reduces tool wear. Experiments are conducted as per the Design of Experiments (DoE) of Received : 17-10-2014
Response Surface Methodology (RSM) to predict the temperature rise by varying the cutting Revised : 23-12-2014
parameters such as cutting speed, feed rate and depth of cut. In the present study, the Accepted : 30-12-2014
experiment was conducted on Aluminium Al 6061 by coated carbide tool. A second order Keywords:
mathematical model in terms of machining parameters was developed for temperature rise Aluminium 6061
prediction using RSM. This model gives the factor effects of the individual process parameters. Cutting speed
Values of Prob> F less than 0.05 indicate model terms are significant. The cutting speed is the Prediction
RSM
most important parameter that cause the temperature of the turning process compared to the
*Corresponding Author:
other factors such as feed rate and depth of cut. Validation results show good agreement
Zeelan Basha N
between the actual process output and the predicted temperature rise. E-mail:
Copyright@2014 STAR Journal. All Rights Reserved. [email protected]

INTRODUCTION
Optimization of operating parameters is a vital step in laser transmission joining were optimized using response
machining, particularly for operating Computer Numerical methodology for achieving good joint strength and
Control (CNC) machine tools. Many researchers have minimal joint width. The central composite second-order
investigated machining optimization problems. In this Rotational Design (CCRD) has been utilized to plan the
research effective optimization techniques approach experiments and response surface methodology (RSM) is
response surface methodology is utilized for finding the employed to develop mathematical relationships between
optimal cutting conditions for best minimum temperature joining parameters and desired responses. The
rise and also developed second order mathematical experimental values nearly agree with the predicted
model for process parameters and analysis of variance values from mathematical models, indicate that the
measured for process parameters to ensure the models can predict the responses adequately and
significant effects. optimize the key process parameters quickly (Xiao Wang
et al., 2012)
Experiments are conducted as per the Design of
Experiments (DoE) of Response Surface Methodology Response surface methodology (RSM) with the help of
(RSM) to predict the spindle and work table vibration by Design Expert Version 7.1.6 (STAT-EASE Inc., USA) was
varying the tool geometry parameter i.e., radial rake angle used for optimization of the extraction process and
and cutting conditions (Spindle speed, feed rate, radial evaluation of interaction effects of different operating
and axial depth of cut) in the end mill cutter. The parameters (Keka Sinha et al., 2012).This study intends to
experiment was conducted on Aluminium Al 6063 by HSS determine the optimal cutting parameters required to
end mill cutter. This model gives the factor effects of the minimize the cutting time while maintaining an acceptable
individual process parameters. Values of Prob> F less quality level. This equation can be determined by studying
than 0.05 indicate model terms are significant (Mahesh et the output cutting times vs. input cutting parameters
al., 2012) through CATIA software, with assistance from the
statistical method, response surface Methodology (RSM)
The response surface methodology (RSM) is a (Angus Jeang, 2011)
traditional technique for experimental process
optimization. For the RSM, an experimental design was A predictive model for laser turning process
chosen and tests were performed in order to generate the parameters is created using a feed-forward articial neural
proper models. Results indicate that both methods are network (ANN) technique utilized the experimental
capable of locating optimum conditions, with a relatively observation data based on response surface methodology
small number of experiments (Davi Sampaio Correia et (RSM) (Dhupal et al., 2009). ANOVA was employed to
al., 2005).The parameters that inuence the quality of identify the level of importance of the machining
A Peer-reviewed Official International Journal of Wollega University, Ethiopia 158
Zeelan Basha et al., Sci. Technol. Arts Res. J., Oct-Dec 2014, 3(4): 158-164
parameters (Gaitonde et al., 2008).Response surface
methodology (RSM) is used for modeling whereas multi-
Identifying the important
objective optimization is performed using hybrid approach
of TM and grey relational analysis (GRA) coupled with process parameter
entropy measurement methodology. The results indicate
that the hybrid approaches applied for modeling and
optimization of the LBC process are reasonable (Amit
Sharmaet et al., 2012) Development of design
matrix
The used parameters such as helix angle of cutter,
spindle speed, feed rate, axial and radial depth of cut on
temperature rise in end milling (Sivasakthivel et al., 2013).
The development and utilization of an optimization
system, which determines optimum machining parameters Conducting the
for milling operations (Baskar et al., 2005). In this work a experiments as per the
mathematical model has been developed based on both design matrix
the material behavior and the machine dynamics to
determine cutting force for milling operations (Palanisamy,
et al., 2007).The experimentation work to determine the
effects of cutting conditions and tool geometry on the
surface roughness in the finish hard turning of the bearing Recording the responses
steel (AISI 52100) (Dilbag Singh et al., 2007)

Most published studies on metal cutting regard the

cutting speed as having the greatest influence on tool
wear and, thus, tool life, while other parameters and
characteristics of the cutting process have not attracted as Development of the
much attention in this respect (Viktor P. Astakhov,2007) mathematical model
The design variables used in this research such as
depth of cut, cutting speed and the feed rate in each pass.
Bounds on depth of cut, cutting speed, feed; surface
finishing, cutting force, cutting power and tool life were Checking the adequacy
considered as technological constraints (Conceicao
of the models developed
Antonio et al., 2009). The second-order mathematical
models, in terms of the machining parameters for each of
these five roughness parameters prediction using
response surface method on the basis of experimental
results (Routara et al., 2009).
Conducting the conformity
The literature indicated above reveals that not much
test runs and comparing
work has been reported on prediction and optimization of
temperature rise in turning operation. The main objective the results.
of this research is to develop a model based on response
surface methodology to the cutting temperature rise in
terms of machining parameters such as cutting speed, Figure 1: Methodology of optimization
feed rate, and depth of cut. During turning process, the
cutting temperature rise is measured using pyrometer. MATERIALS AND METHODS
The second order mathematical model helped us to study Experimental Designs
the direct and interaction effect of each parameter to Response surface methodology is the most effective
ensure the significant effects. method to analyze the results obtained from factorial
experiments. It is an effective tool for modeling and
Response Surface Methodology (RSM) analyzing the engineering problems. It provides more
Response surface method (RSM) is the combination of information with less number of experimentation. In most
experimental and statistical techniques which are useful of the RSM problems, the form of the relationship
for the modeling and analysis of problems in which a between the response and the independent variables is
response of interest is influenced by several variables. unknown (Routara et al., 2009)
RSM saves cost and time by reducing the number of
experiments required for investigation. In this RSM The limit of the process parameters has to be defined
technique, the main objective is to optimize the response in response surface methodology and the initial
i.e temperature rise which is influenced by cutting experimentation was done to identify the machining
parameters using design expert software. A second order parameters that affect the temperature rise and to explore
regression equation is developed. The (Fig.1) flow chart the range of the selected machining parameters
has given to understand the methodology used to study (Sivasakthivel et al., 2013). In the present work, cutting
the effect of important parameters: speed, feed rate, depths of cut have been considered as
the machining parameters. The response temperature rise
T can be expressed as a function of process parameters
cutting speed (X1), feed rate (X2), and depth of cut (X3).
159
Zeelan Basha et al., Sci. Technol. Arts Res. J., Oct-Dec 2014, 3(4): 158-164
Temperature Rise= (X1, X2, X3) + eui
Where is the response surface, eui is the residual, u
is the number of observations in the factorial experiment
th th
and ui represents level of u observation in the i factor.
When the mathematical form of is unknown, this
function can be approximated satisfactorily within the
experimental region by polynomials in terms of the
process parameter variable.

In statistics, BoxBehnken designs are experimental

designs for response surface methodology, devised
by George E.P. Box and Donald Behnken in 1960.Each Figure 3: Tool AK10 Carbide Inserts
factor, or independent variable, is placed at one of three
equally spaced values, usually coded as -1, 0, +1. In each
block, a certain number of factors are put through all
combinations for the factorial design, while the other
factors are kept at the central values. It has three
factorsthree levels BoxBehnken rotatable design
consisting of 17 sets of actual conditions (Table 1). The
design of experiment with response as shown in (Table 2)

Table1: Process Parameters and their Levels

No Cutting parameters unit -1 0 1
1 Cutting speed (X1) m/min 90 110 120
2 Feed rate (X2) mm/rev 0.18 0.27 0.36
3 Depth of cut (X3)` mm 0.2 0.4 0.6

Experimental Procedure Figure 4: Workpiece material aluminium6061

The (figure2) experiments were conducted based on
the design of experiments using XLTURN-CNC lathe. The The work piece material was Aluminium alloy (Al 6061)
specification of the XLTURN-cnc lathe has been given commonly available machinable metal which finds
below application in many manufacturing industries such as
aircraft and aerospace components, marine fittings,
Specification: Control system-fanuc emulated transport, bicycle frames, drive, shafts, electrical fittings
Spindle power-1Hp and connectors, brake components, valves, couplings.
Spindle speed-100 to 3000 rpm The dimension of the work piece specimen was 40mm
Max. Turning dia-32mm diameter and 100mm in length. A pyrometer is a type of
Rapid traverse rate-1.2m/min thermometer used to measure high temperatures. In the
modern usage, it is a non-contacting device that
intercepts and measures thermal radiation. By using
digital pyrometer, the initial temperature was noted and
during machining, the maximum temperature was
measured, the difference between the maximum and
initial temperature gave the temperature rise (figure 5).

Figure 2: XLTURN-cnc lathe

The figure 3 suitable tool insert has been selected

from the tool selection guide. The model tool AK10
Carbide Inserts turning Ground and Polished for
Aluminium Uni-tip was used for turning process.

The figure 4 work material used for the turning process

is aluminium 6061 and the material hardness has been Figure 5: Digital pyrometer measures temperature
tested, found to be 43 HRC. The chemical composition of
aluminium 6061(Table 3) The temperature was measured by using pyrometer
and the observations are tabulated to obtain the
mathematical model (Table 2).

160
Zeelan Basha et al., Sci. Technol. Arts Res. J., Oct-Dec 2014, 3(4): 158-164
Table 2: Experimental values with responses
Cutting parameter Responses
Cutting speed Feed rate Depth of cut Temperature Temperature
m/min mm/rev mm Rise C (observed) Rise C (predicted)
90.00 0.27 0.60 27.2 27.68
105.00 0.27 0.40 22.3 23.76
105.00 0.36 0.60 23.6 26.50
90.00 0.36 0.40 32.3 28.93
105.00 0.27 0.40 25.3 23.76
105.00 0.18 0.60 22.5 21.15
120.00 0.18 0.40 24.6 27.98
105.00 0.18 0.20 23.6 20.90
90.00 0.27 0.20 28.5 30.53
90.00 0.18 0.40 26.3 27.18
120.00 0.36 0.40 38.2 37.32
120.00 0.27 0.60 37.4 35.38
105.00 0.27 0.40 23.6 23.76
105.00 0.27 0.40 23.4 23.76
105.00 0.36 0.20 25.1 26.45
105.00 0.27 0.40 24.2 23.76
120.00 0.27 0.20 32.5 32.05

Table 3: Chemical composition for Aluminium 6061

Al 6061 Al Si Fe Cu Mn Mg Cr Zn Ti
Weight (%) Balance 0.40-0.80 0.70 max 0.15-0.40 0.15 0.8-1.2 0.04-0.35 0.25max 0.15max

Development of Mathematical Model values of these coefficients. The second order

In statistics, regression analysis is a statistical process mathematical model is developed using the experimental
for estimating the relationships among variables. It values and responses by neglecting the insignificant
includes many techniques for modeling and analyzing coefficients to predict the temperature rise (T).
several variables, when the focus is on the relationship Temperature rise (T) =407.17500-7.10200*X1-77.72222
between a dependent variable and one or *X2-62.02500*X3+1.40741*X1*X2+0.51667*X1*X3-5.55556*
more independent variables. The general form of a 2 2 2
X2*X3+0.031756*X1 -68.51852*X2 +12.37500*X3 ----equ.2
quadratic polynomial which gives the relation between Where
response surface y and the process variable x under X1=cutting speed m/min
investigation is given by X2=feed rate mm/rev
2 2 X3=depth of cut mm
Y=0+ 1x1+ 2x2+ 3x3+ 11x1 + 22x2 + 12x1------------ equ. 1
Where 0 is a constant, 1, 2 , 3 is the linear term Statistical Analysis
coefficient, 11 , 22 is the quadratic term coefficient and
The effects of cutting speed, feed rate, and depth of
12 is the interaction term coefficient (Sivasakthivel et al.,
cut on temperature rise were experimentally investigated
2013).
and calculated with a statistical analysis of variance
Regression equations (equ.2) were formed using (ANOVA) were performed. The ANOVAs (Table 4) shows
values of the coefficients of the polynomials .A statistical that the parameter experimented have been significant
software design expert 8.0was used to calculate the effect and it is sufficient.

Table 4: ANOVA for Response Surface Quadratic Model Analysis of variance table [Partial sum of squares - Type III]
Source Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Value P-value Prob > F
Model 346.37 9 38.49 4.62 0.0280 significant
A-cutting speed 42.32 1 42.32 5.08 0.0588
B-feed rate 61.61 1 61.61 7.40 0.0298
C-depth of cut 0.13 1 0.13 0.015 0.9059
AB 14.44 1 14.44 1.73 0.2293
AC 9.61 1 9.61 1.15 0.3183
BC 0.040 1 0.040 4.804E-003 0.9467
A2 214.95 1 214.95 25.82 0.0014
B2 1.30 1 1.30 0.16 0.7048
C2 1.03 1 1.03 0.12 0.7352
Residual 58.28 7 8.33
Lack of Fit 53.43 3 17.81 14.68 0.0126
Pure Error 4.85 4 1.21
Cor Total 404.65 16

161
Zeelan Basha et al., Sci. Technol. Arts Res. J., Oct-Dec 2014, 3(4): 158-164
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION atomic diffusion between the tool and work piece material
Interaction Effect of Cutting Speed on Temperature takes place, which in turn propagates the tool wear. The
Rise temperature rise slightly increases with decreasing cutting
From the (Figure 6) it is noticed that feed rate has the speed from 96 to 90m/min; this may be due to the
direct influence on temperature rise at lower cutting adhesion of work material on the tool, which results in
speed. This may be due to the fact that as the feed rate more friction. From the change of levels in the figure 2
increases, the speed of cutting tool movement relative to observed that, which shows that the cutting speed
the work piece also increases resulting in higher resulted in a decrease in temperature rise from 96 to
temperature rise; An increasing cutting speed results in 104m/min, increase in temperature from 114 to 120
increasing the cutting temperature rise to a point where m/min, and optimal in between 104 and 106m/min.

Figure 6: Interaction and direct effect of cutting speed

Interaction Effect of Feed Rate on Temperature Rise cut increases, the contact area between the tool and the
From (Figure 7) and (Figure 8) shows that the work piece also increases resulting in the formation of
interaction effects of feed rate and depth of cut on more chips and thus increases the temperature rise. For
temperature rise are less significant. It has been reducing the temperature rise, it can be noticed from the
concluded from the interaction effect that Increasing feed results that the feed rate and depth of cut should be
rate and depth of cut increases the temperature rise. This minimum in the range of 0.18 to 0.23 mm/rev and 0.20 to
may be due to the fact that, when feed rate and depth of 0.30mm.

Figure 7: Interaction and direct effect of feed rate

Figure 8: Interaction and direct effect of depth of cut

Prediction Vs Actual Validation of the Model

Figure 9 shows the significant error in normal line The (Table 5) shows that a regression model
between the prediction and actual responses. The graph developed using BoxBehnken by RSM of design of
is obtained from the experimental and prediction experiment were verified using confirmatory test. It shows
responses using RSM. the comparison of predicted vs experimental value of
temperature rise for the cutting parameters. The
percentage of error is found to be within 3% which
shows the validity of the model.

162
Zeelan Basha et al., Sci. Technol. Arts Res. J., Oct-Dec 2014, 3(4): 158-164
Conceicao Antonio, C.A., Castro, C.F., Davim,J. P., (2009).
Optimisation of multi-pass cutting parameters in face-
milling based on genetic search. International Journal of
Advanced Manufacturing Technology 44:1106-1115.
Davi Sampaio Correia., Cristiene Vasconcelos Goncalves.,
Sebastiao Simoes da Cunha, Jr., Valtair Antonio
Ferraresi., (2005). Comparison between genetic
algorithms and response surfacemethodology in GMAW
welding optimization. Journal of Materials Processing
Technology 160: 70-76.
Dhupal, D., Doloi, B., Bhattacharyya, B.,(2009). Modeling and
optimization on Nd:YAG laser turned micro-grooving of
cylindrical ceramic material. Optics and Lasers in
Engineering 47: 917-925.
Figure 9: Prediction Vs Experimental
Dilbag Singh, P., Venkateswara Rao (2007). A surface
Table 5: Validation of observed Vs predicted roughness prediction model for hard turning process.
International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing
Cutting Responses Technology 32: 1115-1124.
Error
Trail

Parameters (temperature rise)

%
X1: X2: X3: Gaitondea, V.N., Karnikb, S.R., Paulo Davimc, J., (2008).
Observed Predicted Taguchi multiple-performance characteristics optimization
(-1) (0) (1)
1 96 0.20 0.20 25.2 24.57 2.5 in drilling of medium density fibreboard (MDF) to minimize
delamination using utility concept. Journal of Materials
2 114 0.24 0.25 26.1 25.8 1.14
Processing Technology 196:73-78.
3 96 0.18 0.30 23.1 23.24 -0.6
Keka Sinha., Papita Das Saha., Siddhartha Datta., (2012).
CONCLUSIONS Extraction of natural dye from petals of Flame of forest
(Buteamonosperma) flower: Process optimization using
Based on the experimental investigation, application of
response surface methodology (RSM). Dyes and
RSM and BoxBehnken for modeling and optimization of Pigments 94: 212-216.
temperature rise of turning process has been discussed.
Mathematical model equations were derived for Mahesh, G., Muthu, S., Devadasan, S.R., (2012).
temperature rises by using mathematical software Experimentation and Prediction of Vibration Amplitudein
package DESIGN EXPERT 8.0. The confirmatory test End Milling with Reference to Radial Rake Angle.
shows the predicted values from the model equations International Review of Mechanical Engineering 6(6):
were found to be good agreement with observed values 1164-1174
and the percentage of error is found to be within Palanisamy, P., Rajendran, I., Shanmugasundaram, S.
3%.Considering the factors such as cutting speed, feed (2007). Optimization of machining parameters using
rate and depth of cut using design of experiments concept genetic algorithm and experimental validation for end-
the following conclusions are drawn; The cutting speed, milling operations. International Journal of Advanced
feed rate and depth of cut were the most important Manufacturing Technology 32: 644-655.
parameters to be considered for reducing the temperature
Routara, C., Bandyopadhyay, A., Sahoo, P., (2009).
rise of the turning process. For reducing the temperature
Roughness modeling and optimization in CNC end milling
rise, cutting speed should be between 96 and 114 m/min, using response surface method: effect of
Feed rate should be less than 0.23 mm/rev, depth of cut workpiecematerial variation. International Journal of
should be between 0.20 and 0.30 mm. Advanced Manufacturing Technology 40:1166-1180.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Sivasakthivel, P.S., Sudhakaran, R. (2013). Optimization of

machining parameters on temperature rise in end milling
The authors are grateful to the Management, of Al 6063 using response surface methodology and
Department of Mechanical Engineering and Department genetic algorithm. International Journal of Advanced
of Production Engineering, Karunya University, Manufacturing Technology 67: 2313-2323.
Coimbatore, India.
Viktor, P. Astakhov (2007). Effects of the cutting feed, depth
REFERENCES of cut, and work piece(bore) diameter on the tool wear
rate. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing
Amit Sharma., Vinod Yadava., (2012). Modelling and Technology 34: 631-640.
optimization of cut quality during pulsed Nd:YAG laser
cutting of thin Al-alloy sheet for straight profile. Optics and Xiao Wang., Xinhua Song., Minfeng Jiang., Pin Li., Yang Hu.,
Laser Technology 44: 159-168. Kai Wang., Huixia Liu. (2012). Modeling and optimization
of laser transmission joining process between PET and
Angus, J., (2011).Robust cutting parameters optimization for 316L stainless steel using response surface methodology.
production time via computer experiment. Applied Optics and Laser Technology 44: 656-663.
Mathematical Modelling 35: 1354-1362.
Zeelan Basha N., Selva Ganesh Kumar., Endalkachew
Baskar, N., Asokan, P., Saravanan, R., Prabhaharan, G. Mosisa. (2013). Determining the Effect of Cutting
(2005). Optimization of Machining Parameters for milling Parameters on Surface Roughness Using Genetic
operations using non-conventional methods. International Algorithm. Science, Technology and Arts Research
Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 25: 1078- Journal 2(4): 98-101.
1088.

163