SHOW MENU

Viewpoints

Why Caribbean History Matters

Lillian Guerra, March 2014

Over the years, I have had dozens of conversations on the question of whether Caribbean history really matters and for
whom it matters. Ive heard the regions history dismissed due to the relative size of Caribbean societies, historians
supposedly excessive preoccupation with slavery, and a questioning of what lessons can be learned from such allegedly
dysfunctional societies.

One particularly memorable encounter took place at a fundraising event for Haiti. Swirling his cocktail, a surgeon asked
if I could explain the erratic behavior of the Haitians who greeted him when his US medical team arrived at a
temporary field hospital after the 2010 earthquake. Much of the Haitian staff, he remarked, suddenly disappeared,
leaving the American doctors to fend for themselves. When I suggested that the Haitian staff had probably departed
because they had been on duty around the clock for days before his teams arrival, the doctor seemed not to hear me: I
think they resented us because they believe we are somehow responsible for slavery. But slavery ended in Haiti two
centuries ago. Is there really anyone in Haiti today who can remember slavery? To his obvious amazement, I replied,
Yes, actually, you would be hard pressed to find someone in Haiti who doesnt remember slavery.

This otherwise liberalleaning physicians inability to grasp the

reality of Haiti was matched only by his lack of reflection on
how the Caribbeans history shaped his own position in society.
We who live in the United Statesregardless of our class or our
colorenjoy a wide array of historically accumulated advantages
that Haitians and other people of the Caribbean do not. So while
we have the luxury of forgetting, everyone in the Caribbean
remembers slavery because they experience on a daily basis a
wide array of historically accumulated disadvantages.

I was not surprised by this conversation. But I have been

surprised by numerous colleagues who worried about what my
Photo Lillian Guerra. A grandmother and granddaughter dressed as
focus on the Caribbean, and Cuba in particular, meant for my
yabs, as part of their baptismal and ritual entry into the Santera
career. Many Latin Americanists suggested I choose a bigger
faith, Old Havana, Cuba, 2011. After decades of repression of
country after my dissertation. Several department chairs have
Santera, the main AfroCuban religion, the Cuban government's lifting
remarked that aside from slavery and the colonial origins of
 of sanctions against its practice has revitalized it enormously. poverty, Caribbean history had little to offer in terms of the
Multiple generations are now rediscovering their black identities weightier questions in the field. In fact, just as I began the
through the religion their ancestors used to help them survive slavery. manuscript for a new book on 1960s Cuba, a particularly
demoralizing colleague went as far as to say that even the study
of the Cuban Revolution was pass.

Caribbean history matters for the same reason everyone in the Caribbean remembers slavery: the legacies of slavery,
imperialism, and historical responses to it are, in the Caribbean, immediately evident in all the weightier concepts we
associate with modernity: notions of citizenship, individual freedom, collective liberation, and nation. Caribbean history
is not merely about the colonial origins of poverty; it addresses the most fundamental questions of who we are, what
we believe, and how we got that way. Yet the uncomfortable facts of Caribbean history rarely make it into the
consciousness of even the most educated of our societys elite.

Take Haiti as an example. In 1804, Haiti was host to the first successful slave revolt in the history of the world and the
first and only country to identify itself as black. Thanks to Haiti, blackness emerged as something other than a color
marking inferiority; it became a banner for unity and mobilization around a common project of freedom and equality
that defied racial and economic injustice worldwide. Haiti changed everything by questioning what nearly everyone in
the European and Europeandominated world took for granted. The history of freedom in America arguably began not
with slave owners like Thomas Jefferson and George Washington, who called for a limited, racialized vision of anti
imperialist freedom, but in the Caribbean with the revolution in Haiti and with broader struggles for freedom from
colonialism (which continued with the emergence of 20thcentury US colonialism).

While countries of the Caribbean may be geographically tiny, their impact on the development of global economies and
political thought has been fundamental. Just as Haiti was the first country to embrace blackness as an ideological
position promoting true freedom and the right of selfdetermination, the people of the British West Indies were the first
in the 20th century to invite people of the African diaspora to unite in panethnic liberation movements. These
ultimately included Garveyism, Rastafarianism, and the US civil rights movement. Without Jos Mart, Antonio Maceo,
Evaristo Estenoz, Marcus Garvey, Luisa Capetillo, Franz Fanon, Aim Cesaire, Walter Rodney, Jos Pea Gmez, Sonia
Pierre, Stokely Carmichael, Jamaica Kincaid, and Bob Marley, societies everywhere would likely have never challenged,
let alone defeated, the values of inequality, exclusion, hierarchy, and Eurocentrism as successfully as they did.

The work of these individuals and the persistent protest of so many millions of anonymous Caribbeans have redefined
global struggles and the way we think about them. While the reality of Caribbean societies efforts to subvert colonialism
and its legacies has perhaps never completely fulfilled the dream of just, democratic change, even the most controversial
of these efforts altered the course of world history. They shifted the balance of power between elites and the poor, and
transformed the political landscape of what even the most marginalized people in the world can expectnot only from
their own governments but from that of the United States.

There is no better example than Cuba. Whatever we may think of Fidel Castro, the dictatorship that the Revolution
undoubtedly became, and its longterm results, in 1959, symbolically and practically, the Cuban Revolution attacked and
subverted the fundamental right the United States had exerted over the Caribbean and Latin America for close to 100
years: the right to interrupt local political processes, define the limits of what states could do for their citizens, and
control the economy in ways that put US business interests above the interests of the majority of Caribbean and Latin
American citizens.

Cuba also made many Americans in the United States aware, for the first time, of the nature of 20thcentury US
interventions in Latin Americathat is, of their own history. In history and other disciplines, Cuba catalyzed radical
changes in how scholars conceived the fundamental building blocks of US power abroad, especially the role that myths of
US exceptionalism and democracy played in justifying government policies and their results to the US public. The Cuban
Revolution also forced scholars to unravel the central paradox that defined and united the political histories of large
swaths of the Caribbean including Puerto Rico, the Dominican Republic, Haiti, and Cuba to the United States.

This paradox can be found in the contradiction between what the United States says it believes versus what the United
States has actually done historically to promote its values abroad: consecutive US administrations from McKinley to
Obama have crafted foreign policies promising to promote the growth of political democracy and a fair capitalist system
based on a level playing field. Yet we have mostly promoted this mission through the antitheses of democracy and fair
capitalist competition: repeated US military occupations, violations of sovereignty, and training of surrogate armies to
ensure US business interests. The study of the Caribbean today might be more relevant than ever as it reveals the limits
of US power and the limits that liberation can take when crafted in opposition to US power.

Like Haiti, Cubas historic precedent forced a global reconsideration and questioning of everything that the worlds elites
once took for granted. And like Haiti in the 19th century, Cuba became a hemispheric pariah.

Slavery is also a living memory in the Caribbean because its greatest legacy is still with usa legacy that is mostly
invisible and yet resides in the clothes we wear and probably much of the food we eat. Before the mass production by
slaves of stimulants like sugar, coffee, tobacco, and chocolate, people had never had the experience of consuming a
commodity on a daily basis whose production process was invisible. For hundreds of years, Europeans ate sugar every
day, never stopping to think that the cost of producing the sugar was human life. Pleasure justified the enslavement of
nine million human beings and the wholesale destruction of African cultures, political systems, and lives.

Today, the invisibility of the labor that goes into the production of consumer goods is probably one of the greatest
legacies of slavery. We dont think about the age of the person who made our tennis shoes in Nicaragua or the average
hourly wage of the woman in the Dominican Republic who stitched our shirts together for the same reason that European
and North American consumers never bothered to question the source of the labor that went into making their sugarit
was just easier not to.

Knowing about injustice often means doing something to change it, and so, more often than not, people decide they
would rather not know. Ignorance continues to be the benefit and the bliss of privilege. History should continue to work
against it.

Lillian Guerra is professor of Cuban and Caribbean history and director of the Cuba program at the Center for Latin
American Studies at the University of Florida.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons AttributionNonCommercialNoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Attribution must provide author name, article title, Perspectives on History, date of publication, and a link to this page.

The American Historical Association welcomes comments in the discussion area below, at AHA Communities, and in
letters to the editor. Please read our commenting and letters policy before submitting.

Related Content
 READ OUR COMMENTING POLICY

8Comments HistoriansOrg
1 Login

Recommend 4 Share SortbyBest

Jointhediscussion

Jamrock 2yearsago
wow!Excellentpiece!AsaCaribbeanmanlivingwithinthe
CaribbeanIendorsethispaper!Keepwritingandhopethereisapart
2....ItwasindeedsolidCaribbeanfoodofroastyam,dumplin,boiled
greenbananawithsaltfish!
6 Reply Share

tashez 4hoursago
thankyouforthispiece.itaddressesaveryimportantissuethatI
hopeisaddressedintheCaribbeansoonerratherthanlater.We
knowsomuchaboutthehistoryofothersandnotourown!I've
constantlybeenaskingforafilmorothervisualmediumtoaddress
slaveryandcolonialismintheCaribbeanbutnooneseemswillingto
touchit.
Reply Share

PeterOliva 7hoursago
Goodpiece,LilliamGuerra!DoyouhavetheSpanishversionfor
thosewhocan'tfollowthisone!
Reply Share

Mari 7hoursago
Greatpiece.Manyofuswishyouhadn'ttakenthispictureasitis
againsttheyearlongrulesforiyawos.Andifyousaythatyou
obtained"permission",Iurgeyoutoconsiderthatpermissionindirect
relationtohowCubansmanagerequestsbyforeignersevenLatina
ones.
Reply Share

JhensenOrtiz ayearago
Importantandpowerfulpiece!AsasonofDominicanimmigrantsI
understandwhatwillallmustdotoensurethehistoricalcontributions
 understandwhatwillallmustdotoensurethehistoricalcontributions
oftheCaribbeanarenotforgotten.Extremelyvitalthankyou.
Reply Share

DelightLuther 2yearsago
Thankyou,Ineededtounderstanditfromthisperspective.
Reply Share

Siusaidh 2yearsago
Havingworkedonthehistoryoftheslavetradeandwrittenadiss.on
20thcenturyTrinidadworkingclasshistory,Ireallyappreciatewhat
you'vewrittenhere.Sorelyneeded.
Reply Share

KEW 2yearsago
Excellent.Thankyou.
Reply Share

ALSOONHISTORIANSORG

JamesMatthewKittleson(1941 ElcineanarquistadePeter
2003) Watkins
1comment5monthsago 2comments2monthsago

AvatarGeraldDaveyJamesKittelson AvatarFrancisUnderwoodWow,this
wasoneoftwomentors(hereI reallyblewmeaway.Great
havetomentionDr.Robert writing.

Full Site Map

Why should I join AHA?

How can I support AHA?

400 A St. SE, Washington DC 20003

Directions >

Phone: 202.544.2422
Fax: 202.544.8307
Email: [email protected]

2013 American Historical Association