Case Study: Healthy Workplace Programs at American Express Canada March 2002
Case Study: Healthy Workplace Programs at American Express Canada March 2002
Case Study: Healthy Workplace Programs at American Express Canada March 2002
March 2002
Gordon DiGiacomo
Table of Contents
Page
Introduction..................................................................................................................... i
I. Context ................................................................................................................1
VII. Conclusion.........................................................................................................16
March, 2002
Introduction
This case study is one of a series of twelve such studies conducted by the Canadian
Labour and Business Centre during 2001 2002.
Issues of workplace health and wellness are an ongoing priority for the Centre, which is a
joint organization founded on strong membership from the main workplace parties
business and labour. We believe that approaches which promote workplace health and
wellness are in the best interests of both employers and workers a clear win-win. In
particular, in a period of anticipated growing skill shortages, those employers who pay
attention to workplace health issues will have a competitive advantage over others in
recruiting and retaining workers with much-needed skills.
The following case study reflects the Centres main objective in undertaking this work,
namely:
In short, the case studies are as much about the process of workplace wellness as about
the content and impacts of individual workplaces initiatives.
Taken as a group, the full set of cases has been deliberately assembled to reflect, as
widely as possible, a broad diversity of workplaces in terms of geography, sector, size,
and union/non-union status. As a group, the cases are intended to tap the experience and
practice of a variety of workplaces, in order to maximize the benefit from the case study
work. Readers will note, as a result, that no two cases are alike, and that the lessons to be
learned from each case vary considerably.
The full set of case studies will be available on the Centres website at www.clbc.ca,
where they will be published individually. The Centre is also preparing a summary
commentary on the cases, which will identify key common features and important
differences among them. Finally, the Centre is developing a series of regional seminars
at which some of the workplaces featured in these case studies will share their
experiences. As they are scheduled, the seminars will also be listed on the CLBC website.
The Canadian Labour and Business Centre welcomes readers comments and questions,
which may be communicated to the Centre at (613) 234-0505, or to [email protected]
-i-
-1-
Senior managers believe that the healthy workplace program has contributed
significantly to employee satisfaction.
I. Context
Amex Canada Inc. provides travel and financial services. A wholly-owned subsidiary of
the U.S.-based American Express Company, it has been operating in Canada for about
150 years. It employs about 3,700 non-unionized workers, 2,100 of whom are located at
the firm's Markham facility. The vast majority of the Markham employees, 80 percent,
work in the call centre.
Amex Canada has revenues in excess of $600 million annually and it has two and a half
million charge and credit cards in force. Since 1997, the company has improved its
profitability by 500 percent, doubled its customer base and added 800 jobs.
The company has been recognized in a number of ways. It:1
received the Canada Award for Excellence from the National Quality Institute in
1998;
was listed in the 2001 and 2002 editions of Canada's Top 100 Employers by
author, Richard Yerema;
was included in Report on Business magazine's 2001 list of the Best 35
companies in Canada to work for and its 2002 Best 50 companies in Canada to
work for; and
received the Employment Equity Merit Award from Human Resources
Development Canada in February 2001.
In 2001, Amex received another award from the National Quality Institute; this one the
Institute's Healthy Workplace Award.
The average age of the employees is in the late thirties. The tenure of the firm's
employees is as follows:
The gender make-up of the work force is 67 percent female and 33 percent male.
In the early 1990s, the company set out a statement of values. It reads as follows:
1
Amex Canada Inc., Report on Healthy Workplace Programs, 2001, p. 1.
-3-
What eventually emerged was called Formula for Growth. It sets out three objectives for
the company. Unless an activity is in support of one or more of the following objectives,
it will not be undertaken or it will be cancelled:
to provide excellence in quality and service; among the sub-goals are to deliver
instant customer service such as on-line card application and approval, and to gain
100 percent card member access at bank machines;
to deepen customer relationships; among the sub-goals are to gain 10 percent to
12 percent of the credit/charge card market, and to gain 30 percent of the
corporate travel market;
to become a top 25 employer; this objective has six elements:
1. Tools to do the Job ensuring that employees have the tools to do their
jobs effectively and efficiently;
6. Work-Life Balance.
The view among Amex managers is that, by becoming "a great employer" in the above
six areas, the company can become a top 25 employer. There is also a deeply rooted
cultural belief among Amex managers that satisfied and engaged employees mean
satisfied customers which mean better business results. Thus, according to one senior
manager, measures intended to enhance employee satisfaction in one or more of the six
areas have "a pretty good chance of getting some attention and likelihood of getting a
sponsor. A company document makes the same point: "The Company strongly believes
having an effective Healthy Workplace Program will positively impact the employee
constituent and in essence create a productive environment; thereby creating value for
customers and shareholders."3 And again:4
This process is known as the "Service Profit Chain Theory", a concept that was
developed by a former Vice President at Sears, Tony Rucci.
Not surprisingly, the wellness program found a receptive audience among both managers
and employees.
The company's healthy workplace initiatives fall primarily within the Work-Life Balance
component of becoming a top 25 employer. Their direct link to one of the three Formula
for Growth objectives is thus clear and explicit.
2
Ibid., p. 3.
3
Ibid., p. 3.
4
Ibid., p. 11.
-5-
1. Work-Life Balance
Work-life balance is seen as central to employees' control over their lives and the role of
work in their lives. As a result, work organization is highly flexible, and includes:
part-time work, which enables employees to work fewer than 36.25 hours (which
are the full-time hours) per week;
the virtual office, enabling employees to work from remote locations;
compressed work weeks, enabling employees to work full-time hours in fewer
than five days;
telecommuting, whereby employees can work from home; in this arrangement,
Amex pays for home office set-up for employees who work permanently from
home;
job sharing, which enables two employees to share one job;
personal leaves of absence, which give employees up to ten weeks of unpaid leave
for personal reasons;
paid sabbaticals, which give employees from one month to twelve months of paid
leave, depending on years of employment; this option is open to employees who
want to contribute their skills by educating others or participating in some activity
that helps "make the community a better place to live and work."
There is no child care assistance at Amex. The preference among managers is to institute
benefits and programs that are of use to as many employees as possible. Child care
assistance would benefit only those employees with young children.
The 30-acre grounds of the Amex Markham facility feature volleyball courts, barbecue
pits and picnic benches. The inside of the no-smoking, three-story building has a full-
service cafeteria, which offers healthy alternatives to accommodate the dietary needs of
all employees. In addition, there are an outdoor patio and terrace, fitness centre, quiet
room (for meditation, prayer and reflection), and a variety of health-related facilities,
including rest areas, treatment and examination rooms.
-6-
Two company departments play a key role in promoting health, safety and wellness. One
is the Facilities Department. It has a Building Engineer and Maintenance Team which
ensures that indoor air quality meets or exceeds provincial standards and that
workstations and workspaces meet legislated requirements. An Architect ensures that
workstations and workspaces meet the employee's ergonomic needs. The Department
also partners with the Global Procurement Team to select workstation equipment, which
must meet the company's health and safety standards.
The Facilities Department has established a Service Desk. Employees with concerns
about their workstations or chairs can contact the Service Desk for appropriate action.
The Department also conducts spot inspections of workstations, chairs and equipment to
ensure that they are functioning as they are supposed to.
The second is the Health Services Department. It is responsible for the fitness centre and
it provides a range of medical services, including allergy and flu shots, blood pressure
monitoring, travel profiles, health-care videos, and diet, nutrition and general health-care
information. It also conducts ergonomic assessments and preventive hearing loss
assessments for employees in high-noise areas.
In addition to these departments, the company has the legally required Joint Health and
Safety Committee, which reports directly to the Chief Financial Officer. This Committee
meets monthly to review relevant occupational health and safety legislation, workplace
inspections and incident reports. It also makes recommendations to the company's senior
management on health and safety matters.
If, during its monthly inspection, the Committee identifies a hazard, a report is prepared
and recommendations are made. This report is sent to the department leader who is asked
to address the hazard within a specified time period. A Committee member follows up
with another inspection.
B. Programs
Most of the lifestyle and wellness activities of Amex can be grouped into four
categories: nutrition, physical activities, the Employee Assistance Program, and health
and wellness education.
a) Nutrition
a subsidized full-service cafeteria is on site and open seven days a week, offering
healthy and low-fat foods daily;
-7-
b) Physical Activity
all employees have access to the fitness centre, which is staffed by certified
fitness professionals; the centre is managed by an outside contractor, the Health
Systems Group;
individual fitness evaluations and programs are available to members of the
fitness centre;
bicycle racks are available to encourage employees to use bicycles to get to and
leave work;
walking and running clubs have been established at the facility;
during the spring and summer months, the fitness centre offers numerous outdoor
activity learning sessions, such as golf lessons and rollerblade lessons;
the company sponsors and promotes employee participation in many charitable
fitness events, including the Toronto AIDS Walk and the Ride for Diabetes.
(See Appendix 2 for specific initiatives.)
First Aid/CPR Training is made available to all employees twice a year; certified
First Aid and CPR employees also have an opportunity to take Defibrillator
Training;
for third shift workers, the Health Services Department runs lifestyle change
programs on shift work;
videos on a range of health and wellness subjects are available for employee use;
under its Educational Assistance Program, the company will reimburse employees
who receive certification in a health and fitness field, e.g., certification as a
Fitness Instructor;
-8-
Joint Health and Safety Committee members have received Code 8 Emergency
Response training;
ergonomic training is available to all employees;
an annual Health and Fitness Expo is held during which external health and
fitness vendors set up displays and provide information on their services and
products.
(See Appendix 2 for specific initiatives.)
A variety of mechanisms are used to inform employees of health, safety and wellness
activities, including word-of-mouth, the fitness centre newsletter, e-mail, voice mail,
pamphlets (frequently handed out to employees at the entrances), posters, bulletin boards,
and the television monitors located throughout the facility.
The centrepiece of the company's healthy workplace program is the fitness centre. Most
of the above listed initiatives were organized by the fitness centre staff. In addition to
providing equipment, it offers a range of fitness and wellness programs, as well as
program demonstrations and fitness assessments.
Money for the fitness centre comes from memberships and the company. Employees pay
a small membership fee, $15 per month, while the company provides a subsidy.
Financial results for the year, 2000, are shown in Table 1 below.
Table 1
Financial Results, Fitness Centre, for 2000
2000
Revenue $83,941
Expenses
Staffing and management $97,457
Program expenses $51,621
Total expenses $149,078
Company contribution $65,137
The company has taken out liability insurance on the centre but members do sign a
release form to absolve the company of responsibility for any injuries incurred by
members.
In its 2000 year-end report, fitness centre managers identified several objectives for the
year 2001:
D. Ergonomics
Over the last few years, the company has focused attention on ergonomics issues.
The Health Services Department has conducted ergonomic assessments, held ergonomic
learning sessions and produced an ergonomics guidebook to generate awareness and
change behaviours. As noted earlier, the company purchases workstations that meet its
ergonomic standards.
Also, computer monitors have been replaced with new ones that give a sharper image,
which reduces eye strain. Laptops with larger screens have also been purchased for ease
of use and reduced eye strain.
Some areas of the company's Markham facility are high noise areas. Employees who
work in these areas are provided with protective equipment and their hearing is assessed
annually.
Through its annual employee survey, the company became aware of concerns regarding
indoor air quality. As a result, the air quality is monitored annually and the results are
expected to meet or exceed Ontario government standards.
Amex also employs a full-time occupational nurse, and contracts the services of a part-
time doctor, massage therapist and physiotherapist. Massage therapy and physiotherapy
- 10 -
are covered by the health spending account within the company benefits plan. The
benefits plan also includes naturopathic services, orthopedic and chiropractic services.
It is the Vice President of Human Resources who is ultimately accountable for the health,
safety and wellness programs at Amex Canada. The occupational nurse and the fitness
centre's manager and assistant manager report directly to this Vice President, who is a
member of the executive team.
Senior managers have made it common practice to consider employee well being in the
decision-making process. When new business opportunities are being studied, senior
managers take into account numerous employee-related concerns, including new
positions, the hours of operation, the type of work required, and the shifts expected for
the positions. According to a company document, the managers "make any necessary
adjustments or create programs that will ensure the new business opportunities have a
positive impact on employee well being and the overall organization."5
The importance of senior management backing of the health and wellness program was
emphasized by one middle-level manager interviewed:
5
Ibid., p. 14.
- 11 -
V. Employee Involvement
Employee involvement in health and wellness activities can be measured on two levels:
the degree of employee input into decision-making around wellness programs and the
degree of participation in the activities.
There are no formal structures at Amex, aside from the legally required Joint Health and
Safety Committee, that provide opportunities for employees and managers to discuss and
make decisions about health, safety and wellness matters. However, Amex uses a variety
of measures that provide managers with data on employee needs and wants and that give
employees an opportunity to advance their views on health and wellness issues. So
frequently is employee input solicited that one employee described Amex as "a feedback-
focused company." Another stated that, "Our culture is a feedback culture.
So employees don't hesitate to tell us how they feel ". That includes "telling the
President of the company how they feel ".
As noted earlier, the company conducts an employee survey annually. It contains 106
questions on 12 dimensions: customers and clients; quality; people; job itself; employee
development; diversity; manager effectiveness; integrity; meritocracy; employee
satisfaction; teamwork; and good citizenship. Health and safety is not among the twelve
dimensions but it is dealt with indirectly in many of the questions. Employees also have
an opportunity to comment on any issue they would like to. Generally, the response rate
to the survey is above 90 percent and the comments are extensive, suggesting that the
employees believe that their concerns, ideas and opinions will be received.
Once results are analyzed, employee survey action teams, comprised of managers and
employees, are formed to develop action plans and to monitor progress in the
implementation of those action plans.
Another company survey is the health services and fitness centre survey. It
measures employee satisfaction with the health and fitness centre services. It is
also used to plan future events and activities.
Employee focus groups are held as needed to obtain input from employees on
how Amex can be a top employer.
"Town hall" meetings, led by the company president, are held quarterly.
Executive team members hold breakfasts with employees from their business
areas to discuss employee issues.
- 12 -
Finally, since senior managers use the health and fitness facilities and programs,
employees are able to discuss issues face-to-face with executives on an ad hoc
basis.
The numbers appear to demonstrate considerable take-up of the wellness activities and
services. The wide range of programs offered is likely one reason for the high take-up
rate. According to one employee, who is also one of 14 volunteer fitness instructors,
"What's great about Amex and the wellness program is that they try to have programs that
are suitable for every level; every age group, every fitness level, every interest level ".
Also, the fitness centre manager points out that, "We offer a lot of seminars and
workshops on various topics, depending on what the feedback is from the employee
survey ". [Emphasis added.] What the foregoing suggests is that the health and
wellness managers at Amex make a serious effort to attract, and are having success at
attracting, those who do not normally exercise regularly or practice healthy living habits.
The on-site fitness centre has capacity for 650 members. It currently has 650
members, up from 500 in January 2000.
The Health Services Department reports that the massage therapist had 407 visits
in 2000, the physiotherapist had 296 visits and the doctor had 424 visits. Massage
therapy visits are said to have increased dramatically in recent months.
The CPR clinics, the blood pressure clinics, the Food and Fitness Fair, the Health
Expo, and the Amex Extreme Games are all well attended health and fitness
events.
During the third quarter of 2001, almost 20 percent of the employees at Amex's
Markham facility participated in one or more fitness centre activities or programs.
Employee Assistance Program counsellors had 221 cases in 1998-99 (August to
July), 315 in 1999-00 and 397 in 2000-01. Table 2 below shows the reasons for
the visits.
- 13 -
Table 2
Employee Assistance Program
Percentage Breakdown of Reasons for Visits
VI. Impacts
Amex Canada managers do not expend a lot of effort determining and measuring the
impacts of their wellness program. As already explained, they accept that healthier
employees make for increased customer satisfaction which, in turn, means increased
profitability and growth. They also point out that it is exceedingly difficult to prove that
a given outcome, say reduced absenteeism, was due to their wellness initiatives. It is
particularly difficult to determine the extent to which a given business performance
outcome, e.g., increased productivity, is attributable to the wellness program. In addition,
senior Amex managers are personally committed to healthy lifestyles. Thus, they do not
need hard data to convince them of the worth of a fitness program.
The numbers that the managers do look at carefully are the employee survey results.
From these data, they determine whether or not the company's policies, including the
human resource policies, are being well received by the work force. As noted earlier,
employee satisfaction is linked, in management's view, to profits and growth.
Because of this employee satisfaction/profitability link, the firm monitors various aspects
of employee satisfaction over time. The firm also benchmarks other measures to industry
averages and averages in the subsidiaries around the world.
The statements in Table 3 below, which appear on the annual employee survey, are
related to employee well being and measure satisfaction levels among Amex employees
at the Markham facility and at other Amex facilities in Canada. It is significant that, for
the most part, positive results are increasing over time.
- 14 -
Table 3
Employee Survey Selected Results
Another employee survey question asks employees how long they intend to stay with
American Express.
- 15 -
Table 4
How Long Employees Say They Intend to Stay with Amex
Time Frames %
0 to 1 year 4
1 year from now 10
3 to 5 years 18
5 to 10 years 21
10 + years 43
The fact that over two-fifths of respondents would like to stay with Amex for ten or more
years provides further evidence of a high level of satisfaction among employees. It also
suggests relatively low turnover rates in the future and, thus, lower recruitment costs.
The employee satisfaction levels at Amex Canada compare very favourably with those at
other firms. As a subsidiary of American Express Company, Amex Canada is a member
of a worldwide group of fifty Fortune 500 global companies which study and compare
employee satisfaction levels. Table 5 below compares employee satisfaction scores at
Amex Canada with employee satisfaction scores at the Canadian operations of the fifty
Fortune 500 firms.
Table 5
Employee Satisfaction at Amex Canada:
Comparison with the Canadian Industry Average
Another indicator that Amex managers track is the attrition rate. It has declined
considerably since 1998, when the wellness initiatives began in earnest. In 1998, the
attrition rate was 40.31 percent, in 1999, it was 29.84 percent, and in 2000, it stood at
22.99 percent. These numbers are for the Markham facility only where, as pointed out
- 16 -
earlier, about 80 percent of employees are call centre operators. It is generally thought
within the call centre industry that the attrition rate in the industry is in the 40 percent
range.
One could not say with certainty that the attrition rate decline was due to the wellness
program. It could have been due to other factors. However, it seems reasonable to
suggest that it had some influence.
The importance of the healthy workplace program to recruitment and retention was noted
by the Vice President of Human Resources. He found from his experience that job
seekers being interviewed by Amex are excited by the prospect of working at a company
that has a fitness centre. It is one benefit that Amex has established to partly make up for
the fact that its compensation is only at the industry average.
The number and types of medical and short-term disability claims being filed by
employees are other statistics that the company pays attention to. By tracking trends over
time, it can make appropriate changes to its benefit plan and its healthy workplace
program.
When assessing a wellness initiative, one would want to know, at the very least, whether
or not the users, in this case employees, feel good about the program, perceive that they
are deriving some benefit from participating in the activity. At Amex, the Health
Services Department, which has responsibility for the fitness centre, regularly surveys
users of the centre and the Department's services to determine satisfaction levels, as well
as user interests.
In 2001, Amex employees reported exceptionally high levels of satisfaction with the
fitness centre. For instance, 100 percent of respondents say they are either very satisfied
or satisfied with the class instructors and with the variety of services and activities
offered. To the question, "Are you achieving results with your program?", 82 percent said
yes.
Respondents also indicated very high satisfaction levels with the services provided by the
nurse, doctor, massage therapist, and physiotherapist. In addition, 95 percent were either
very satisfied or satisfied with the health education provided, and 91 percent said they
were very satisfied or satisfied with the ergonomic assessments.
Clearly, Amex employees perceive that they are getting value from their involvement in
the wellness activities.
VII. Conclusion
The preceding has described the healthy workplace program at a Canadian subsidiary of a
U.S.-based company. It has shown the broad range of wellness activities and programs
offered at Amex, attempted to explain the link between the company's business strategy
and the wellness program, shown how senior management demonstrates its commitment
- 17 -
to the health of employees, and outlined the extent of employee involvement in the health
and wellness activities. The discussion of impacts pointed out that Amex managers do
not feel a need to measure, in a precise and thorough-going way, the impacts of the
wellness program on individuals or the organization. They simply accept that healthier
employees will mean more effective, creative and committed employees which, in turn,
will mean better organizational performance. They also believe that it is not possible to
show a cause-and-effect relationship between the wellness program and a given business
performance outcome. Still, there are indicators that the company pays close attention to;
they include employee satisfaction levels, (satisfaction with the company and with the
wellness programs); attrition and absenteeism rates; and medical and short-term disability
claims. Data provided by the company show high levels of satisfaction with the company
and with the health and wellness program.
- 18 -
Appendix 1
Pace of work X
Two-way communication X
Incentive/recognition X
programs
Other (specify)
Healthy Living (individual Substance abuse X (EAP)
lifestyle factors, promotion
of healthy living, prevention
of illness)
Smoking cessation/control X (EAP)
Nutrition/weight control X
Disease prevention X
(chronic/infectious)
Stress management and X
mental health
Active living and fitness X
Other (specify) X (fairs, education sessions)
Supplemental Health and General health benefits X
Dental Benefits (e.g., home care, out-of-
country coverage, vision
care)
Dental benefits X
Other (specify) X
Other (specify) Diversity X
- 21 -
Appendix 2
The following are some of what the company considers to be "notable initiatives" in
health and wellness undertaken over the last few years:
a) Nutrition
b) Physical Activity
d) Other