Public Toilet Strategy
Public Toilet Strategy
Public Toilet Strategy
T
Building Code of A uniform set of technical provisions to be incorporated into the design and construction
Australia (BCA) of buildings and other structures within Australia.
F
Changing Places Public toilet facilities that cater for people with severe or profound disabilities. These
A
Co-Located A public toilet that is externally accessible and attached to, or within, an existing building
structure such as a sport pavilion or a library.
R
Crime Prevention An approach to the prevention of crime focusing on the relationship between physical
Through environments and those who use them. 3
Environmental
T
2.3 COMMUNITY FEEDBACK 14
F
3 FINDINGS & RECOMMENDATIONS 15
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
3.3 PUBLIC TOILET DESIGN 25
3.4 ACCESSIBILITY 29
R
3.5 MANAGEMENT 37
4
4 PUBLIC TOILET TOOLKIT 43
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
4.1 HOW TO USE THE TOOLKIT 44
4.2 ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORKS 45
4.3 SERVICE HIERARCHY 47
5 IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 51
5.1 OVERVIEW 52
5.2 ACTION PLAN 53
5.3 CAPITAL WORKS PLAN 55
APPENDICES 57
Planisphere 2017.
PROJECT CONTROL
STATUS VERSION CHECKED PM CHECKED PD DATE RELEASED
Draft Public Toilet Strategy for Discussion 1 DF JMR/JLR 18/07/17
The Greater Bendigo Public Toilet Strategy sets out a strategic framework to
guide the delivery and upgrade of public toilets across the municipality and
establishes a vision that is consistent with Councils aspiration to create the
worlds most liveable community.
Public toilets are vital community assets that contribute to Core elements of the Strategy are:
T
the health and wellbeing of residents, workers and visitors
to Greater Bendigo. Often unacknowledged, public toilets Summary of policy context
support the vitality and accessibility of public places and Key findings from consultation and engagement
F
spaces. Summary of issues and opportunities by theme
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
The Greater Bendigo Public Toilet Strategy sets out a Recommendations for upgrades and improvements to
the toilet network
A
strategic framework to assist Council in planning for future
upgrades and installations. Toolkit comprising assessment frameworks to assist
Council in determining future upgrades
The Strategy highlights some of the key issues and Key strategic and operational actions to improve the
R
challenges associated with public toilets in Greater existing and future toilet network
6
Bendigo and also identifies opportunities for 10 Year Capital Works Plan (to be reviewed after 5
improvement. years)
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
The Strategy has been informed by a range of community
and stakeholder engagement activities including targeted
workshops, listening posts and a community survey. A
summary of the consultation process is outlined on Page
10.
s&
ion
g
itie
rin
tat
e
sul
ath
ati portu
gy
o &
on
201 n G
Feb rm und
ber rate
y
yC
teg
on
7
Op
17
201
Inf kgro
St
7
rua ati
nit
, 20
tra
Co ues,
17
ay,
al
Ma sult
mm
201
0
ft S
-M
c
ry,
r, 2
Fin
Ba
em
o
Iss
obe
n
Co
ust
Dra
rch
Dec
Oct
Aug
Council will provide high quality public toilets that are clean and safe and that
cater for the needs of all residents, workers and visitors to Greater Bendigo.
T
Provide a comprehensive, efficient and well-connected network of accessible public toilets at key locations throughout
Greater Bendigo.
F
Incorporate universal design principles into all future upgrades and ensure public toilet locations are clearly promoted and
communicated to all users.
A
Maintain toilets to a high standard of cleanliness to enhance the safety, health and wellbeing of all users.
R
7
T
social and corporate responsibility in supporting health, facilities respond to community needs. Issues around the
wellbeing and community vitality in public spaces. accessibility, design and safety of public toilets can result
F
in the marginalisation of some user groups and exclude
Council is a key provider of public toilets in Greater
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
There are opportunities to improve the process of
Some toilets are sited within public buildings such as
planning for new facilities, the standard of existing toilets
libraries or pavilions. These toilets are often only available
and improve the efficiency of the network throughout
R
during specified hours such as during business hour or
Greater Bendigo.
8 weekends, in addition to this users may be required to
pass through a control point to access a toilet. The Greater Bendigo Public Toilet Strategy provides a
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
rational and strategic planning framework to guide future
Many privately owned businesses also operate and
upgrades and installation of new facilities over the next
provide toilets for use by the public in a variety of
ten years.
locations. Although these facilities are often perceived
to be available for general public use, they are usually
provided to service the needs of staff and paying
customers.
There are also other government agencies which provide
and manage toilets on other public and Crown land such
as ParksVic and DELWP.
There are opportunities to explore future partnerships
with the private sector to increase the network of toilets
in Greater Bendigo which are explored in this Strategy.
Capital works and other recommendations outlined in this
Strategy relate directly to Councils existing assets.
There are 54 Council owned and managed public toilets
distributed throughout Greater Bendigo. Of these
facilities, 29 are located within public open space and 25
are located within activity areas.
STRATEGIC
CONTEXT
Relevant Plans and Strategies There is a range of municipal wide and local plans and
strategies which have informed the development of this
There are a number of relevant Council plans and Strategy. Throughout Chapter 3, key Council plans and
strategies that have informed the development of this strategies are listed in accordance to their relevance to
Strategy. public toilets.
The Draft Bendigo Community Plan (2017-2021) outlines The diagram below shows the relationship of the Public
six goals that will guide decision making over the next Toilet Strategy to relevant Council plans and policies. A full
four years. Of relevance is Goal 2 Wellbeing and fairness summary of the relevant Council strategies is contained in
which seeks to improve the quality of life for residents
T
Appendix A.
and visitors by enhancing their health and wellbeing
outcomes. Goal 4 Presentation and managing growth A matrix of Council strategies/plans and their relevance to
F
also identifies the need to maintain and upgrade essential the key themes of this report can be found in Appendix E.
R A Rural
Communities
Strategy 9
Draft
DPublic Toilet
Strategy
Municipal Health
Greater Bendigo
Environment
Strategy
Community
Access &
Inclusion
Plan
Greater Bendigo
Local Master
Plans
Public Space
Draft
Strategy
Greater Bendigo
Community Plan
Local Plans
Municipal Strategies
Community Frameworks
COMMUNITY
ENGAGEMENT
Consultation and engagement with the public and other Key consultation activities included:
key stakeholders was undertaken between April and
May 2017 for a period of 4 weeks. The purpose of this Workshops with Council staff, community
representatives and local business representatives
consultation was to identify key issues associated with
existing facilities, opportunities for improvement and Community Listening Posts
understand community priorities. Surveys (available in hard-copy and online)
Online engagement (e.g. social media)
A range of consultation methods was used throughout
the consultation period to engage with different users and Feedback from more than 1,000 participants was
T
stakeholders. This allowed the project team to collect a received during the consultation period. The diagram
broad range of views and perspectives. below summarises the types of consultation activities
undertaken and the approximate levels of engagement.
F
A number of key themes and suggestions for
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
consultation are contained in the Consultation
Summary Report (2017).
20 Council Attendees
R
Stakeholder Workshops: Community Survey:890
10
10
Resident Attendees Online Survey Responses
20 Council
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Attendees
4 Business Attendees
4 Business Attendees
60+ Engagements with the Community 90+ Comments on The Bendigo Advertiser Facebook
Listening Posts: 35 Hard Copy Survey Responses Other Media: 70+ Comments on Council Facebook
60+(Bendigo,
3 Locations Engagements with the Community
Heathcote, Marong) 1390+
Individual written submissions
Comments on The Bendigo Advertiser Facebook
T
public toilet as shown in Map 1.
F
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
Elmore
R
Raywood
12
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Goornong
Marong
BENDIGO
Axedale
Strathfieldsaye
Lockwood South
Heathcote
Mia Mia
Redesdale
PUBLIC TOILET
AUDIT
In 2010, Council undertook a condition audit of 49 of its Toilets that were in poor (or lower) condition that also
public toilet assets to assess building structure, condition achieved a low usage score were:
and usage.
Allingham Street Drill Hall Toilet Block
Usage was measured on a scale of 1 (high) to 3 (low). Londonderry Reserve Toilet Block
High usage facilities were used every day whilst low
South Bendigo Progress Association Toilet Block
facilities were used once or twice a week.
Recommendations/actions for these toilets is outlined in
An audit on the overall condition of the toilets was also Chapter 5 with toilets that are least used and in poorest
T
undertaken which scored toilets on a scale of 0 (brand condition prioritised for removal or upgrade.
new) to 10 (failed).
F
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
Most Used Least Used
Goornong Village Green - Toilet Block Allingham Street Drill Hall 15-17 - Toilet block
Hargreaves Mall - Unisex Toilets Bendigo Aerodrome - Toilet Block
R
Hargreaves Street Multi Storey Carpark Crusoe and No 7 Park - Portable Toilet (at Crusoe)
13
Heathcote Tourist Information Centre Toilet Block Kamarooka Public Hall - Toilet Block
Howard Place - Gardens Monument & Safe Transport Hub Londonderry Reserve - Toilet Block
T
facilities most used by respondents (blue). Council have reviewed these locations accordingly
Facilities in Need
Heathcotewith public
In regard to the overall themes, locations
Areas in Need of
and have identified priorities based on the community
Rosalind
feedback and other data sources. Chapter 5 outlines the
F
toilets identified as most in needInformation
of an upgrade were:
Coles, New Public Toilets
Lyttleton Terraceof Improvement
Centre the relevant capital works Bath
actions and priorities to be
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
Lyttleton Tce undertaken for the locationsLane Park
below. Coles,
Hargreaves Mall Lyttleton Tce
A
Lake Weeroona
Hargreaves
Facilities in StNeed
Multi-storey Car Park (Hargreaves Street)
Heathcote
Hargreaves
Areas in Need of
Target
R
Multi-Storey
Information
of Improvement Carpark RosalindNew Public Toilets
[non-Council
14
Centre Mall
Coles, Lake Bath Owned]
Hargreaves
Weroona
Lyttleton Tce
Lane Park Coles,
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Mall
Lyttleton Tce
Hargreaves HeathcoteHargreaves
St Multi-Storey
Information
Target
Rosalind
Centre Carpark Coles, [non-Council
Mall Lake
Weroona Lyttleton Tce
Owned] Bath
Hargreaves Park
Lane Cole
Lyttleto
Most Used Mall
Hargreaves Public Toilets
Hargreaves
St Multi-Storey
Target
[non-Council
Carpark
Mall Lake
Weroona
Owned]
Hargreaves
Mall
Most Used Market
Public Toilets Place
Library [non-Council Owned]
Legend
Most Used
Size of circles represent the level of response to the survey
Coles, Market Myer
Public
[non-Council Toilets
question. The larger the circle, the more frequent the
response.
Lyttleton Tce Place Owned]
Lake
Weroona
Facilities In Need Of Improvement
Library [non-Council Owned]
T
Design
Accessibility
F
Management
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
Recommendations after each topic are outlined in bold
and are also reflected in either the Key Action Plan or
R
Capital Works Plan in Chapter 4.
16
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Distribution Design Accessibility Management
DISTRIBUTION
Objective:
Provide a comprehensive, efficient and well-connected network of
accessible public toilets at key locations throughout Greater Bendigo.
Gaps within the City Centre public toilet network. Improve the connectivity and distribution of the
public toilet network at key locations.
T
Not all regional open spaces or regional level
playgrounds have direct access to public toilets. Install new toilets and upgrade existing toilets at
Should all rural townships be serviced by a public key open spaces and playspaces in accordance to
F
toilet? the relevant hierarchy.
A
opening hours, design or security. This reduces Work with private land developers and
network availability. government agencies (such as ParksVic and
Balancing and prioritising community DELWP) to improve the public toilet network and
R
expectations and need with capital works ensure a consistent level of service.
expenditure and asset management. Integrate the recommendations of the Public 17
Per Week
24% 25%
20% 24%
13% 20%
16% 13% 16%
Public ToiletToilet
Public Usage Usage
ek Weekly Less Than Once Per Month Fortnightly Hardly Ever
e Per Week Weekly Less Than Once Per Month Fortnightly Hardly Ever
Less Than Once Per Hardly Ever 277
264
Month
SHOPPING STRIP
PUBLIC PARK
188
INFO CENTRE
120 120
OTHER
SERVICE
STATION
21
Usage results based on survey outcomes with a total of 925 responses. Location results based on survey outcomes with a total of 1,655
selections (respondents could select more than 1 location)
Findings & Recommendations
Public toilets in Greater Bendigo are generally well distributed and provide
a comprehensive network of facilities across the municipality. There are
opportunities to further improve and strengthen the network of toilets
through upgrades and installations at key locations.
Activity Centres around the Hargreaves Mall toilets are largely related to
the levels of safety, privacy and accessibility of the existing
The Commercial Land Activity Centre Strategy (2015) facilities. Councils audit assessed the toilets in Hargreaves
sets out an Activity Centre Hierarchy (see Appendix A) as Mall as in very good structural condition, however
follows: community feedback has indicated that these toilets are
City Centre the most in need of improvement and should be a high
priority for a new facility.
Activity Centre
T
Neighbourhood Activity Centre Before the installation of a new toilet in Bath Lane,
Township/Rural Centre upgrades to the existing toilets (or installation of new
toilets) in Hargreaves Mall should be prioritised. Following
F
In the context of Greater Bendigos commercial areas, this upgrade, the need for a new public toilet in Bath Lane
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
public toilets should be prioritised in higher order centres should be reviewed and monitored in the short - medium
including the City Centre and Activity Centres. Public term.
A
toilets in these areas cater for the patrons of activity
centres as well as providing facilities for special events, The proposed redevelopment of the State Government
and broader community use in addition to supporting the offices also presents an opportunity to provide additional
R
commercial activities prominent in these areas. public toilets.
18
Recommendations for each level of Activity Centre in the There was no specific community feedback regarding
Hierarchy is outlined on the following pages. the need for new toilets at at other locations along key
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
pedestrian routes within the CBD. These locations should
continue to be monitored over time as land use and
City Centre development patterns change.
The City Centre contains 11 public toilet facilities, located A number of other upgrades and actions should be
within the commercial areas and large public open spaces. considered at other toilet sites within the City Centre as
Facilities in the City Centre are highly utilised, especially identified on the Map 2.
those located adjacent to or within high pedestrian
activity areas. The Council audit (2010) identified the Recommendations
following City Centre toilets as having the highest usage:
Remove, upgrade or install new public toilets in
Hargreaves Mall Toilets Hargreaves Mall to improve safety and accessibility.
Bendigo Library Toilets Refurbish existing toilets on Lyttleton Terrace to
Lyttleton Terrace Toilets. improve design, safety and siting.
Monitor the need for a new public toilet in or around
Gaps Bath Lane and review after upgrade to Mall facilities.
Spatially, toilets are generally well distributed at key Investigate future need for the existing toilet
locations and at public sites throughout the City Centre. in Londonderry Reserve in line with the
However, there are currently several gaps in the network, recommendations of the Public Space Plan.
with no public toilets in the following locations: Upgrade or install new public toilets at Queen
Elizabeth Oval.
Bath Lane (see discussion below)
Upgrade and refurbish the toilet in the Hargreaves
Mitchell Street Street multi-storey car park to improve accessibility
High Street (between Short and Mitchell Streets) and safety.
View Street (between Pall Mall and Barnard Streets) Monitor the need for new public toilets along other
Rosalind Park (close to the District Playspace). key pedestrian routes within the City Centre.
Monitor the need for new public toilet facilities
Due to the negative perceptions of the Hargreaves Mall
as part of the proposed redevelopment of State
toilets, it was perceived by the community that there is a Government offices.
network gap within the CBD. The community perceptions
Tom Flood Toilet Block
Co-located facility in very good
condition. No immediate action
required.
TOM FLOOD
Tom Flood Toilet Block
SPORT S CENTRE Co-located facility only open during
training and events.
ST
R D
RNA
BA
CH
AP
E
2 Safe Transport Hub
LS
QEO ROSALIND PARK
T
Open 24 hours, provides facility for after
Toilet block open 24 hours. Council
hours activity along Pall Mall. Newly
audit assessed as in poor condition
constructed & located and key transport
and moderate usage. Upgrade
terminus.
required (underway).
VI The Mews
EW Toilet in average conditiion in a
T
ST high profile location. Also ysed by
visitors to Rosalind Park.
Renewal required. Hargreaves St Car Park
LL
F
Difficult to find and poorly sited. Removal or upgrade
A required in short - medium term.
LM
A
Bendigo Library
New toilet in excellent condition
with high daily. Open during
Hargreaves Mall 1 & 2 library hours. No immediate
Most cited toilet amongst community and key
R
action required.
NE
stakeholders as requiring upgrade due to lack of privacy,
accessibility and cleanliness. NegativeAperceptions
L by
ST 19
the community resulting in reduced H
T usage and network
E RS
WATTLE BAlocation for upgrade.
gap. High priority Y
M
D
1 Lyttleton Terrace
Highly utilised and cited by the
community as a priority for
upgrade due to cleanliness,
hygiene and safety concerns.
M
IT
CH
EL
LS
Edward Street Car Park T
No immediate action required
on this toilet. 3
Londonderry Reserve
Low usage and poor condition.
Toilet may be surplus to need.
Consider removal.
T
SS
ILL
W
METRES N
Shopping Centres Activity & Neighbourhood Centres
Community consultation has revealed a clear preference Greater Bendigos activity and neighbourhood centres
for shopping centres as their preferred location for public play a key role in servicing the local needs of the
toilets (See Page 17). community and include a range of open spaces and larger
format retail commercial areas.
While public toilets within shopping centres are an
integral part of the Greater Bendigo public toilet network, Toilets in these areas are generally clustered around
they are often privately owned and operated making it Kangaroo Flat and Eaglehawk as shown in Map 3.
difficult to ensure access and accommodate new public
toilets. Gaps
There are no Council owned or managed toilets in the
Recommendations following centres.
Advocate for the inclusion of publicly accessible Activity Centres:
toilets as part of the planning process for
development of private commercial sites. Epsom
T
Kangaroo Flat (Lansell Square)
Strathdale
F
Neighbourhood Activity Centres:
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
California Gully
A
Golden Square
Ironbark
Long Gully
R
White Hills
20
Characteristic of outer suburban developments, these
locations are vehicle-dominated destinations and most
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
contain privately held commercial tenancies and/or
big box retail outlets. Due to the types of commercial
land uses within these locations and the car-dominated
access, the provision of additional toilets in the above
Activity Centres is not currently required. Furthermore the
provision of Council owned and managed public toilets in
Neighbourhood Activity Centres should not be prioritised
over other higher order centres.
Toilets at Lake Weeroona were identified by the
community as a priority location for upgrades. Although
Councils audit assessed these toilets as in good
condition, the facilities are highly utilised and not meeting
community expectations.
Council is currently undertaking investigations to upgrade
toilets at Lake Neangar and Victoria Street (Eaglehawk
Activity Centre).
Recommendations
Upgrade toilets at Lake Neangar and Eaglehawk
Activity Centre.
Upgrade toilets at Lake Weeroona to improve design
and siting.
Monitor the land use activities and development of
Activity and Neighbourhood Centres and review the
need for public toilets in five years.
Map 3: Activity & Neighbourhood Centres
LEGEND
Public Toilet
Regional Playpace HUNTLY
District Playspace Greater Bendigo
National Park
Commercial Land
Open Space with Organised
Sport Function
Other Open Space
Major Walking/Shared Trail
Rail Line
Rail Station
Watercourse
EPSOM
T
Water Body
EAGLEHAWK
F
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
CALIFORNIA GULLY
WHITE HILLS
R
EAST BENDIGO 21
MAIDEN GULLY
State Forest
BENDIGO
GOLDEN SQUARE
KANGAROO FLAT
One Tree Hill
Regional Park
Crusoe Reservoir
& No.7 Park
0 2.5
KILOMETRES N
Rural Bendigo Public Open Space
There are six Township/Rural Centres within Bendigos Councils Public Space Strategy (in progress) identifies five
Activity Centre Hierarchy. categories of open space in the following hierarchy (see
Heathcote is Bendigos largest rural township and is a Appendix B):
popular tourist destination for weekend and seasonal State/National
visits. While there are a number of toilet facilities in Regional
Heathcote (e.g. the swimming pool, pavilion, behind the
Municipal
Council offices), the most frequented facility is co-located
with the Visitor Centre on High Street. This toilet has been Township/Neighbourhood
identified as an upgrade priority by the community and Local
other stakeholders due to its high utilisation leading to Definitions and functions of each of these open space
poor condition. areas are outlined within the Strategy. The existing Open
$300,000 has been approved in the 2017/2018 budget to Space Strategy does not provide any specific direction
rebuild the facilities at the Heathcote Visitors Centre. about where public toilets should be located. It is
T
acknowledged that Council is currently updating the Open
Gaps Space Strategy.
Presently, all of Bendigos rural townships are serviced
F
In the first instance, toilets should be provided in higher
by at least one public toilet although in many instances order public open space. There may be circumstances
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
Council is not the committee of management, for example where toilets are required in lower level open spaces (i.e.
in Redesdale and Raywood.
A
local or sub-municipal) due to high usage or co-location of
The public toilets at the Heathcote Visitors Centre are other activity drivers such as playspaces or formal sport/
heavily utilised, particularly on weekends and during recreation. In these situations Council should refer to the
R
seasonal activities. Feedback from the community has assessment frameworks contained in the Implementation
22 identified these facilities as a priority for upgrade due to Plan (See Chapter 4).
lack of capacity at peak times and overall accessibility.
Gaps
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
There are a number of other smaller rural locations, Network gaps have been identified in the following higher
(for example Costerfield and Myers Flat) which do not order open spaces:
have public toilets. In these locations, the provision of
facilities is not considered necessary due to the small local Rosalind Park, Bendigo
catchment they serve. Garden Gully Reserve, Ironbark
Quarry Hill Reserve, Quarry Hill
Recommendations
Barrack Reserve, Heathcote
Replace the toilet at the Heathcote Visitors Centre Truscott Reserve, California Gully
in consultation with the local community to
accommodate high volumes of users and to improve In addition to these locations, many survey respondents
the perceived level of safety of the facility. identified the need for upgrading of facilities at the
Review the cleaning frequency of the toilets at Bendigo Botanical Gardens (White Hills) as a key priority.
Heathcote Visitors Centre to ensure they are
maintained to a high standard. Recommendations
Continue to maintain toilets in regional townships Consider and monitor the need for new public toilets
to the same standard as other Council owned and in Rosalind Park area.
managed facilities.
Upgrade toilets at the Bendigo Botanic Gardens,
White Hills.
Prioritise public toilet upgrades/installations
in higher order open spaces and monitor the
community need over time. Should demonstrated
demand arise, apply the assessment frameworks to
justify future provision.
Insert reference to the Public Toilet Strategy in the
new Public Space Plan.
Identify, investigate and consider the need for future
public toilets at RV dumping sites.
Map 4: Regional Townships
LEGEND
Rural Public Toilet
T
with people sleeping
overnight. Refurbishments
and upgrades reguired
F
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
Toilets in Raywood and ELMORE
A
Sebastian managed by
CoM. Isolated and low
usage. RAYWOOD
R
Toilet in poor condition
and has high usage in
prominent Gateway
location.
MARONG
BENDIGO
AXEDALE
Very high usage and do
not cater for peak demand
on weekends and tourist
STRATHFIELDSAYE events. Upgrade required.
LOCKWOOD SOUTH
HEATHCOTE
The provision of public toilets should be prioritised in Consideration for different modes of active transport (e.g.
T
locations that contain regional and district level facilities. walking and cycling) should also be taken into account.
Playspaces are generally located in public open space,
Gaps
F
and similarly, there may be a demonstrated community
need for a toilet adjacent or near to a local or other small
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
assessment frameworks contained in the Implementation
The Bendigo Bushland trail primary traverses through
Plan to assist with decision making.
Crown land and non-Council owned/managed open
space, therefore the provision of public toilets in these
R
Gaps
locations is outside the jurisdiction of Council. There is
24
There are no public toilets within proximity to the an opportunity to use this Strategy to advocate for the
following regional or district level playspaces: provision of public toilet facilities at this location.
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
McIvor Road Skateboard Park, Bendigo Of the other major trails, there is a gap in provision along
Splash Park Playground, Long Gully the OKeefe Trail between Axedale and Heathcote. The
Garden Gully Reserve Playground, Ironbark township of Knowsley would be a candidate location for
the installation of a new toilet facility to service not only
Rosalind Park Playground, Bendigo
the needs of the small township but also users of the trail.
Quarry Hill Reserve Playground, Quarry Hill
Truscott Reserve Playground, California Gully Council should continue to work in partnership with
other land managers to ensure the public toilets are
Waratah Road (Viewpoint Estate) Playground, Huntly
appropriately distributed and sited on Crown land.
Long Gully Splash Park has been identified as a key priority
among community groups and survey respondents as a Recommendations
location in need of a new toilet.
Investigate a location for a new public toilet in along
There are opportunities to improve existing public toilets the OKeefe Trail.
as part of playspace upgrades and in the other locations Partner and work with relevant Committee of
identified above, community need and demand should be Managements to provide public toilets in key
monitored. locations along tracks and trails.
Recommendations
Construct new toilet at Long Gully Splash Park to be
accessible and accommodate peak seasonal usage.
Review the provision of public toilets in conjunction
with upgrades to play spaces.
Monitor the community need for new public toilets
in district and regional playspaces. Should the need
or demand arise, apply the assessment frameworks
to determine future need.
PUBLIC TOILET DESIGN
Objective:
Design toilets to be attractive, safe and accessible to users of all ages
and abilities.
Many existing toilets do not support the needs Develop a hierarchy of preferred typologies that
of particular user groups including the elderly, clearly sets out minimum standards for design,
people with disabilities and parents with children. fixtures and fittings.
T
Some toilets are poorly integrated into the public Develop overarching design and siting principles
realm, creating negative perceptions of safety and to improve the integration of toilets into the
F
usability. public realm and reduce anti-social behaviour.
Automated fixtures and fittings are not intuitive Improve design and integration of toilets
A
Hargreaves Mall).
Older toilet blocks are often not DDA compliant Upgrade toilets that are not DDA compliant to
Inconsistent provision of fixtures and fittings improve accessibility to facilities across the toilet
R
across all facilities in Greater Bendigo. network.
Proximity and location of public toilets to other Upgrade toilets that are highly used but in poor 25
D
toilets to reduce life cycle costs of individual
facilities.
Preference results based on survey outcomes with a total of 925 responses. Preference results based on survey outcomes with a total of 925 responses.
Findings & Recommendations
The design and siting of a public toilets greatly influences its usability and
accessibility. Design is also important for promoting positive perceptions of
public toilets to the community.
Typologies Configuration
There are many different ways of categorising public The most common configuration of public toilet in Greater
toilet designs with regard to form and typology. Broadly Bendigo is split gender; comprising separate male and
speaking, there are two types of facilities used throughout female toilet entrances either in a toilet block style or an
Greater Bendigo: stand alone toilet blocks and co- open unit style. Unisex or split gender cubicles with single
located facilities. Within each of these typologies there access doorways can also be found in Bendigo (e.g. The
are various different configurations, interpretations and Safe Transport Hub). The consultation findings indicate
adaptations. that the split gender configuration is the preference of
Key features of stand-alone public toilets are: surveyed residents in Greater Bendigo.
T
Freestanding (not attached to or within another Balancing design and configuration requirements with
building structure) practical needs should be carefully considered when
developing new facilities. For example, in some high use
F
Externally accessible from public realm
locations, it may be more appropriate to build larger
Separate male/female entrances or single fronted unit
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
Can include separate or integrated disabled access The configuration of public toilets should respond to the
needs of the local community in which the public toilet is
Key features of co-located public toilets are: located. In some suburbs, the provision of unisex facilities
R
Attached to, or located within a building structure may be appropriate, however in other areas split gender
26 Externally accessible from the public realm facilities may be better.
Either separate male/female entrances or single Prior to the development of a new public toilet facility,
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
fronted unit doors engagement with the immediate community and local
Opening hours restricted by building and activity (such residents should be undertaken to ensure that future
as sport fixture, training or event). toilet designs meet community expectations and needs.
Stand-alone public toilets (toilet blocks) are the most Recommendation
common typology across Greater Bendigo. While these
are the most common, toilet block configurations can When appropriate, undertake consultation and
present various design constraints due to their rigid engagement with the local community prior to the
construction, often resulting in minimal compliance with development and installation of a new public toilet.
Australian Standard 1428 (AS 1328). Many older blocks
lack natural lighting or ventilation and are commonly
perceived to be unsafe and unhygienic. Toilets that are
poorly integrated into their environment can further
create perceptions of exposure and lack of privacy.
The provision of new public toilets should be contextual
to the site and scale of the location. Activity generators
must also be considered when designing public toilets and
in locations with high peak usage. The scale fixtures and
fittings should be commensurate to use. The Assessment
Framework (see Chapter 4) outlines key decision making
considerations for determining the most appropriate
typology for specific locations.
Recommendation
Refer to the Service Provision Hierarchy when
determining the typology of new public toilets (see
Public Toilet Toolkit Chapter 4).
Fixtures and Fittings
Council has a number of public toilets which are hybrid
typologies and provide automated functions such as
locking doors, hand washing and cleaning (e.g. Hargreaves
Mall). There are a number of issues associated with these
facilities in regard to their usability and accessibility for
different user groups.
Toilets in Greater Bendigo contain a range of basic fixtures
and fittings. In certain locations, fixtures and fittings
should be customised to reflect the needs of specific user
groups. For example in locations with high peak usage
such as sport pavilions, male urinals should be considered;
Stand Alone Public Toilet Facility, Axedale Skate Park
or in locations where there are high volumes of families
with children, the provision of baby change tables should
be considered.
T
The Implementation Plan (Chapter 3) contains a suite of
standard and custom fixtures and fittings and provides
F
guidance to where they may be appropriate.
A
Standardise the provision of fixtures and fittings
in accordance with the service provision to ensure
consistency across the network (see Public Toilet
R
Toolkit Chapter 4).
27
Incorporate additional features in site specific
Co-Located Public Toilet Facility, Bendigo Law Courts locations as appropriate to the site.
1 12 13 14
F T
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
Integrate toilets seamlessly New toilets should reflect the
multi-use community entrances toward well lit into the public realm and local character and where
facilities that draw areas to maximise safety. avoid obstructing toilets appropriate, encourage
on existing walking
R
with dense landscaping, artistic design expression in
catchments and maximise vegetation or impermeable locations with high usage or
28
visibility to the street/
barriers. visitation.
public space.
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
15 16 17 18
T
Many public toilets are inaccessible for people Identify key toilets that provide limited
with disabilities or special access requirements. accessibility and upgrade accordingly.
Develop a standard suite of fixtures and fittings
F
DDA requirements can be restrictive and can
result in poor design outcomes. that consider the needs of various user groups.
A
Review the availability of facilities co-located with
with children. sport pavilions and consider opening well located
Some facilities are poorly sited, obscured and/or facilities to the public on a permanent basis.
R
not visible from the street. Improve wayfinding and legibility around public
Co-located facilities are often locked or toilets. 29
inaccessible. Investigate interactive communication tools (eg.
smartphone app) to improve the wayfinding
D
within Greater Bendigo. capabilities.
Wayfinding and promotion of toilets in Investigate key locations for changing places
inconsistent across Greater Bendigo. facilities throughout Bendigo.
Walking distance results based on survey outcomes with a total of 925 responses.
Findings & Recommendations
T
commitment and wherever possible, must be planned actions
around the needs of people with a disability. In delivering Low Physical Effort the design can be used efficiently
F
on the Public Toilet Strategy, Council seeks to increase the and comfortably with a minimum of fatigue
number of universally designed toilet facilities through
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
toilets and the State Governments support of building manipulation and use regardless of users body size,
new Changing Places. posture or mobility.
Cultural and social preferences are also important
A key aspect of inclusion is accessibility and over the last
R
Considerations for groups such as the LGBTI community
10 years, Council has upgraded many of its existing toilet
30 and residents with specific cultural practices. Gender
facilities, by providing DDA compliant fixtures such as
segregation and lack of unisex facilities can also cause
ramps and assistance bars. These actions are consistent
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
issues for single parents with a child of the opposite sex.
with Councils vision to become the most liveable
community that supports the needs of its residents and There is increasing research around the promotion of age-
visitors. friendly cities and designing for people with dementia.
Specific requirements such as use of colour contrasts
As Council continues to actively upgrade facilities over
between materials, tactile surfaces and clear graphic
time, there still remains a number of toilets that are non
signage are amongst the key considerations. Many of
DDA compliant and do not cater for the needs of people
these principles and considerations cross over with
with mobility difficulties. Accessibility is not just about
other objectives sought by universal design and CPTED
catering for people with additional mobility requirements,
principles.
it also should consider people with different social,
cultural and demographic preferences. Other key user Families with children and infants are another key user
groups include children, parents with infants, the elderly group that often rely on the availability of public toilets.
and members of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender Many of Councils current public toilets lack basic facilities
and intersex (LGBTI) community. In this context, it is such as family change areas or tables to change baby
appropriate to consider universal design principles that nappies, particularly in key locations in public parks and
cater for the needs of all users, rather than just those with playspaces.
physical mobility requirements.
Recommendation
Using public toilets can be a confronting experience for
different user groups and in order to reduce barriers it is Apply the principles of universal design to all toilet
important to ensure that future upgrades and installations upgrades and new installations.
new toilets adopt the key principles of universal Upgrade toilets in key locations to include family
design. At its core, universal design promotes fair and friendly facilities.
inclusive environments that allow people to be safe and Undertake an assessment of facilities across the
independent and that are fair and inclusive. The seven municipality to determine their accessibility.
principles of universal design are: Ensure accessible public toilets are included in
pavilion and building upgrades.
Equitable in Use - the design is useful and marketable
to people with diverse abilities
Flexibility in Use - the design accommodates a wide
Changing Places The Victorian State Government has recently released
funding to assist Councils in building Changing Places
Changing Places facilities were introduced in Australia in facilities. $100,000 has been allocated to the City
2014 and there are currently 15 certified facilities across of Greater Bendigo to provide a facility within the
the country. Originating in the United Kingdom in 2006, municipality. The most mentioned locations amongst
Changing Places facilities are designed for people who survey respondents (in the DHHS survey) were:
require a hoist to use a toilet. The facilities differ from
standard accessible or disabled toilets as they include Bendigo CBD & Bendigo in general
additional features such as an adult change table, hoist, Bendigo Train Station
shower, screens and large circulation spaces. Hargreaves Mall
There has been an increasing interest in the provision Other locations which may be potential candidate sites for
of Changing Places facilities across both the private and a changing places toilet include:
Respondents Familiar with
government sectors, particularly in locations that attract Changing Places Facilties
regular crowds, such as sports and recreation facilities. Heathcote Visitors Centre, Heathcote
Strathdale Park, Strathdale
Changing Places facilities are vital pieces of community
Rosalind Park, Bendigo CBD
T
infrastructure which allow members of the public who
with specific needs to participate in the day-to-day Barrack Reserve, Heathcote
activities across the municipality. Council has recently Long Gully Splash Park, Long Gully
42%
F
retrofitted an accessible toilet with an adult change table Lake Weeroona
A
There are a number of barriers and perceptions around Bendigo Botanical Gardens
Changing Places facilities that constrain Councils in
There is an accessible playground at Strathdale Park which
providing these facilities:
contains a liberty swing for use by people in wheelchairs.
R
Lack of understanding or awareness for Changing Strathdale Park could be considered for a Changing Places
31
Places toilet in the future. Accessibility
Top 5 Most to Requested
Changing Places
Locations for New
Respondents Familiar with
Confusion of terminology between Changing Places facilities, particularly proximity to easy
Changing access
Placesparking
Facilities
D
and changing rooms should be a key consideration when determining suitable
Expense of facilities (upward of $150,000 each) locations for Changing Places
MAJOR facilities.
SHOPPING CENTRES 62%
Respondents Familiar with Top 5 Most Requested Locations for New Most Requested Locations for
Changing Places Facilties Changing Places Facilities New Changing Places Facilities in Bendigo
LANSELL 20 votes
SQUARE
Top 5 Most Requested Locations for New Most Requested Locations for LAKE 18 votes
Changing Places Facilities New Changing Places Facilities in Bendigo WEROONA
Source: Funding Guidelines and Application Form, Appendix 1 Changing Places Survey 2017, Department
LIBRARY 15 votes
of Health and Human Services
MAJOR SHOPPING CENTRES 62%
BENDIGO CBD 64 votes
PUBLIC PARKS & 42%
Signage, Wayfinding & website which lists Barbecue locations and also links to
the National Public Toilet Map (see Case Study). Although
Communication the National Public Toilet Map is a useful community
Signage and wayfinding are important factors in resource, it is an external data source that is not always
promoting an accessible and connected public toilet updated. Council should regularly check and update
network. Often considered a minor detail, signage assists information within Greater Bendigo on Council owned
residents, workers and visitors to Greater Bendigo in assets. A number of apps allow users to also access this
navigating Councils toilet network. database information on their smart phones as discussed
in the case studies below.
Existing signage on public toilet facilities is varied across
the municipality. Many toilets currently have large The communication of public toilet locations and
Council signs/branding on the exterior of the facility that availability should be provided across a number of
identify the name of the toilet. Industry best practices different platforms. Whilst digital tools allow users to
recommends that additional information should be easily locate toilets, some members of the community are
provided on the exterior of all public toilets to convey key unable to access or have difficulty connecting to digital
aspects of the facility including: communication platforms. The inclusion of toilet locations
T
on key maps and publications throughout Bendigo should
Gender accessibility still be considered.
Opening hours
F
Contact information (to report repairs or closures) Recommendation:
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
The upgrading of signage on public toilets should be
Council owned assets, including public toilets.
an integrated approach and there are opportunities to
develop a municipal wide strategy or prepare guidelines Update information annually about Council owned
and managed toilets on the National Public Toilet
R
to improve signage and wayfinding across Greater
Map within Greater Bendigo
32 Bendigo.
Update list of public toilets on Councils Community
Another way of promoting the accessibility and Compass web page to include information including
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
connectivity of Councils public toilet network is through opening hours and DDA compliance.
online information. Council currently has a page on its
Case Study 1
F T
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
34
R A
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Case Study 4 Case Study 5
T
As discussed previously, the provision of new council Further investigation into the viability of CTS should be
owned and managed facilities should not necessarily be undertaken to determine whether the community and
prioritised in locations where there is a concentration of local business would be accepting of such a Scheme.
F
large private commercial areas. There are opportunities to Two case studies are presented below of two CTSs in the
A
community scheme or program. Recommendation:
A Community Toilet Scheme (CTS) is a partnership Investigate the viability of a community toilet scheme
R
between Council, local businesses and other through a trial in a local community.
organisations. The purpose of the CTS is to increase the 35
network of available public toilets within an area using
Recommendation:
This Strategy does not recommend that Council adopt a
user paid system in the short to medium term. Should a
T
need for such a system arise in the longer term, Council
should undertake further investigations and consultation
F
with the community.
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
consultation with the public as well as key user
groups.
R
36
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
MANAGEMENT
Objective:
Prioritise the safety of all public toilet users in Greater Bendigo by minimising
occurrences of anti-social behaviour.
Maintain toilets to a high standard of cleanliness to enhance the safety, health and
wellbeing of all users.
T
Poor perceptions of hygiene and cleanliness Refurbish facilities (as required) at key locations
among the community. to improve perceptions of safety.
F
Council does not manage the majority of open Reduce antisocial behaviour through site
space with Greater Bendigo. responsive interventions (CPTED).
A
managed facilities and those which are leased to facilities.
toilets sometimes make it feel unsafe
sporting clubs. Develop a capital works program to secure
Seasonal demand and events put pressure on future funding and investment for public toilet
R
existing toilet infrastructure. improvements.
Poor perceptions of safety and hygiene are Consider fixtures that discourage or minimise 37
common
Rarelywithin
clean,the
feelcommunity.
unsafe. Always make instances of anti-social behaviour or loitering
such as automated locking doors.
Safety
Historically, public toilets have become known as hotspots There are a number of responses to anti-social behaviour
for antisocial behaviour and undesirable activity. As that Council can employ such as:
Council continues to upgrade its facilities and improve Installation of CCTV cameras
T
the level of service provision, it also seeks to reduce and
Time-sensor lighting (solar panel operated)
minimise occurrences of anti-social behaviour such drug-
related activity, sexual activity or overnight stays. Quick response to reactive maintenance
F
Regular cleaning and reporting
The safety and security of public toilet users should
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
be prioritised ahead of any other decision-making Facilities that are old, in poor structural condition and
subject to ongoing anti-social behaviour should be
A
considerations. From a user perspective, perceptions of
safety can be as influential as actual or recorded levels of considered for decommissioning.
safety. If a toilet is perceived to be unsafe, unhygienic or Feedback from stakeholders indicates that some toilets
R
dangerous, users will generally avoid usage of the facility. in isolated locations are used for overnight stays. In
38 There are a number of factors that contribute to negative particular, Elmore was identified as a hotspot due to the
safety perceptions: presence of shower facilities.
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Poor integration into the streetscape/public realm
Recommendation
Obstruction behind dense landscaping or away from
passive surveillance Upgrade/refurbish toilets in Elmore to reduce anti-
Age and condition of the facility social behaviour and improve safety.
Presence of graffiti or vandalism Incorporate CPTED principles into all decision and
assessment processes.
Loitering
Assess the safety and structural condition of all toilet
Lack of natural light facilities through a Council audit process every five
Odour or lack of cleanliness years.
There are many ways that design can minimise anti-social Record all reports and instances of anti-social
behaviour and contribute to positive perceptions of safety. behaviour and reactive maintenance and monitor
For example, the objectives of Crime Prevention Through over time to identify key hot spots.
Environmental Design (CPTED) establish guiding principles
to reduce the incidence and perceptions around crime
and safety. Developed by the Queensland Government
in associated with the Queensland Police in 2007, CPTED
principles consider factors such as surveillance, legibility,
territoriality, ownership, management and vulnerability.
With regard to public toilets, the guidelines consider:
The likelihood to expose users to risk (for example
during hours of darkness)
Organised surveillance (such as regular security patrols
or cameras)
Discourage loitering by not placing seating or public
telephones in close proximity to toilet entrances
Ensure entrances to public toilets are clearly visible
from the street and other public areas
Maintenance & Cleaning Alongside routine site inspections by Council staff, there
are other ways to collect information about damage or
Public toilet ownership and management arrangements broken fixtures through a variety of user-sourced smart
vary across the municipality. Council has a number of phone data apps. There have been a number of trials
public toilets that they own and manage including other across different local government areas that have seen
toilets on crown land reserves. The majority of these the implementation of municipal wide apps to allow users
public toilets (regardless of ownership) are managed and to directly report issues about Councils assets (see Case
serviced by a private cleansing contractor appointed via a study below). There are further opportunities to test the
public procurement process. In some instances, in more usefulness and implementation of a similar program in
rural or isolated areas, public toilets that are located Greater Bendigo across Council owned and managed
on crown land reserves are cleaned by committees of assets.
management, which are financially supported by Council.
In these instances Council has a funding and service level Recommendation
agreement in place with the committees. Refer to Maps 5
and 6 which show the different ownership arrangements. Remove surplus toilets in poor condition with low
usage at Caradon Way, Bendigo Aerodrome and
Council has an active schedule of maintenance and Camp Street and Londonderry Reserve.
T
cleaning across all of its public toilet facilities. The levels Record and collect information about usage and
of usage of a facility is reflected in its cleaning frequency cleaning performance using counters or other
F
with higher usage toilets cleaned the most often. In methods.
high use locations, some toilets are cleaned up to three
A
Ongoing monitoring and toilet usage should continue usage and peak demand.
to inform Councils cleaning priorities. Usage can be Update Councils audit data to include information
measured in a number of ways: about other Council owned and managed toilets not
R
currently captured.
Installation of temporary pedestrian counters at toilet
entrances Investigate the viability of a municipal wide app that 39
LEGEND
Public Toilet - Council Owned
F T
ELMORE
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
RAYWOOD
A
Morshead Park
R
Sebastian Recreation Reserve
40
GOORNONG
Greater Bendigo City Council
MARONG
D BENDIGO
STRATHFIELDSAYE
AXEDALE
HEATHCOTE
REDESDALE
Redesdale
0 10
KILOMETRES N
Map 6: Ownership - Urban
LEGEND
Public Toilet - Council Owned
Public Toilet - Committee of Management HUNTLY
Commercial Land Greater Bendigo
National Park
Open Space
Rail Line
Rail Station
Watercourse
Water Body
EPSOM
F T
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
EAGLEHAWK
A
CALIFORNIA GULLY
WHITE HILLS
R
EAST BENDIGO 41
MAIDEN GULLY
State Forest
BENDIGO
QUARRY HILL
STRATHDALE
GOLDEN SQUARE
KANGAROO FLAT
One Tree Hill
Regional Park
Crusoe Reservoir
& No.7 Park
KILOMETRES N
Opening Hours Seasonal Demand
The opening hours of toilets in Greater Bendigo vary As well as being a key tourist attraction, Greater Bendigo
between 24 hours and dawn and dusk. Generally, stand- hosts a number of seasonal and annual events throughout
alone toilets are open 24 hours and co-located toilets are the year that attract large crowds. These events are held
open from dawn to dusk. at key locations throughout the municipality including
the Bendigo CBD, large parks, sporting venues and the
In some locations, particularly in rural or remote areas,
Showgrounds.
toilets that are open 24 hours can attract anti-social
behaviour. There are several known hotspot locations The use of portable toilets is common practice for large
where antisocial activities have been reported. Actions municipal events. Legislative and planning requirements
to minimise anti-social behaviour through alternative require approval of an event management plan prior
management practices include: the commencement of a large event. Unless there is
a considerable demonstrated community need, the
Locking toilets during the evening provision of permanent toilet infrastructure is not
Installation of CCTV cameras necessary as it encourages the proliferation a dormant
Installation of automatic door locks toilet network (i.e. toilets that are inaccessible to the
T
Security patrols public as they locked for the majority of the year).
Determining the most appropriate response to an issue In addition to the requirements of event management
F
should be site/context specific and what works in one plans, consideration for accessible and changing places
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
location to deter anti-social behaviour may not apply facilities should be taken into account for large events.
in other locations. Responses should also consider Council is in the process of purchasing a portable
A
the diversity and density of activities around the toilet, Marveloo Changing Places facility that is to be made
particularly evening activities. 24 hour availability presents available for rent at large events. The provision of
a range of challenges, particularly in relation to safety these facilities will enable members of the community
R
and perceptions around anti-social behaviour during the with additional mobility requirements to participate in
42
evening. A number of 24 hour toilets are available for use municipal events.
in the CBD at key locations that attract night time activity Aquatic centres and other recreational facilities
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
including: The Safe Transport Hub and Lyttleton Terrace. for waterplay are locations where peak demand is
The provision of additional toilets to service the night concentrated around the summer months. Feedback from
time economy is not considered necessary due to the the community identified Long Gully Splash Park as a high
availability of privately owned toilets found in: priority for a new public toilet.
Restaurants and bars Another way that municipal authorities have managed
Nightclubs and other entertainment precincts and increased the toilet network is through the private
toilet network via apps such as AirPnP (refer to case
Transport hubs such as major train, bus and taxi
study).
terminals.
Council should continue to monitor this need as Recommendation
development and land use patterns change over time. Construct new toilet at Long Gully Splash Park to be
accessible and accommodate peak seasonal usage.
Recommendation
Continue to investigate the need for a Marveloo
Investigate the need for alternative management Changing Places Facility at key Council run events
practices at known hotspot locations to minimize throughout the year.
anti-social behaviour.
Monitor the need for a new toilet in the CBD or other
location with a concentration of night time activities.
43
The Public Toilet Toolkit has been developed to assist The Service Hierarchy sets out four different levels of
Council in determining future priorities. It is to be service provision based on different toilet configurations
reviewed in conjunction with the Implementation Plan to and typologies. The hierarchy should be used to
guide future decision making processess around the need determine the minimum level of service provision for a
for upgrading, removing or installing new public toilets. specific location.
Two Assessment Frameworks have been developed to A standard suite of Fixtures & Fittings has been
assist Council in determining future upgrades to public developed to guide the internal and external configuration
toilets (or installation of new toilet) should a request of new public toilets. In addition to the standard suite, a
T
arise outside the capital works plan. The Assessment number of site-specific features have been listed. These
Frameworks should be reviewed in conjunction with the features should be installed in premium public toilets, or
overall vision, objectives and principles outlined in this in locations where there is a demonstrated community
F
Strategy and used in the following instances: need. The suite should be used as a guide only.
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
removal of a public toilet as part of a planning process
(e.g. Recreation Reserve Master Plan)
Where there is a volume of community requests for a
R
new facility, upgrade or removal of a public toilet in a
44 location outside of the Capital Works Plan. This refers
to occasions where there are consistent community
requests or persistent maintenance issues associated
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
with a public toilet facility.
Is there a demonstrated community demand or volume of requests for this facility to be replaced or refurbished?
RESOURCES:
Evidence from the community or Council audits/records that the existing facility is not adequately functioning
Maintenance requests from community
Community surveys
Public Space Strategy
Local masterplans or structure plans
T
Is the existing public toilet in poor condition?
CONSIDERATIONS:
F
Presence of vandalism or graffiti
A
Obvious signs of wear on the existing facilities within the toilet
Features within the toilet are broken or do not work
Issues with odour or presence of vermin
R
Environment/facilities are unsafe or dangerous
45
Negative perceptions of safety or presence of antisocial behaviour
RESOURCES:
Counters
Empirical observations or anecdotal information from the community, Council staff, cleaning, service or
maintenance contractors
Maintenance costs
Water usage, levels of toilet paper, soap consumed weekly, monthly or annually
DDA Compliance
Universal access
Site specific features
RESOURCES:
F T
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
Is there a high movement of pedestrian, cycling or other active transport modes and the proposed location in an
area with a growing catchment?
A
CONSIDERATIONS:
R
46 Transport and connectivity
RESOURCES:
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
ABS Population protections
Surrounding mixture of land uses
Public Space Strategy
Greater Bendigo Aquatic Facilities Strategy (2010)
Bendigo Regional Tourism Destination Management Plan 2016
Local masterplans or structure plans
Will the new toilet enhance community safety, health and wellbeing?
CONSIDERATIONS:
T
Standard Individual cubicles comprising: 3 Neighbourhood parks, Dawn to x1 per day
reserves and open space dusk
One unisex disabled cubicle
F
One male and one female Adjacent to high use play OR
cubicle (or two unisex cubicles) grounds
A
areas
Other high use locations
R
Co-located Individual cubicles comprising at 4 Multi-use recreation Dawn to x1 per day/
least: reserves dusk after event 47
F T
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
48
R A
Greater Bendigo City Council
F T
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
1 3
R
Examples of Standard Toilets 49
3 1
T
Stainless steel hand basin
Tempered water tap
F
Baby Change table
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
materials, fixtures Communal hand wash basins
Jumbo rolls
and fittings for Screening
Sanitary napkin disposal
premium/high
Urinal Public art
R
use locations or
50 other site-specific Amenities
toilets*
Electric hand dryer
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Syringe disposal
Sensors to conserve energy and water
consumption
Mirror
Rubbish bins
Non-slip surfaces
Disabled and In accordance with AS 1428 In accordance with AS 1428
ambulant toilets
Changing Places In accordance with Changing Places In accordance with Changing Places guidelines
Facilities guidelines
Notes
*The use of specific fixtures and fittings should be considered on a site-specific basis. For example in high use locations,
where accommodating the maximum number of people is a priority, fixtures such as urinals and jumbo rolls should be
considered. In locations where there is anti-social behaviour the use of security cameras or automatic locking doors may
be appropriate.
51
An Implementation Plan has been developed that sets out Refer to Appendix D to compare the additional coverage
the key priorities for public toilet upgrades over the next proposed as part of the new Capital Works Plan in
10 years. It should be read in conjunction with the vision, reference to 1km and 5km radius.
objectives and principles for public toilets in Greater
It is recommended that the Implementation Plan is
Bendigo.
reviewed after 5 years in order to assess the future
The strategic and operational recommendations of priorities, community need and demand.
this Strategy have been translated into an Action Plan,
categorised by theme and each assigned an indicative
T
timing.
The Capital Works Plan sets out a 10 year list of upgrades
F
and actions for all public toilet in Greater Bendigo. The
time line provided in the capital works plan is indicative
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
phasing and timing of the capital works plan in accordance
with budget and expenditure. Prioritisation of actions are
categorised as:
R
Short Term: 1-2 years
52 Medium Term: 2-5 years
Long Term: 5-10 years
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Implementation Plan Components
T
and review the need for public toilets in five years.
Review the cleaning frequency of the toilets at Heathcote Visitors Centre to ensure they Short Term
F
are maintained to a high standard.
A
Consider and monitor the need for new public toilets in Rosalind Park (location to be Medium Term
determined).
R
Prioritise public toilet upgrades/installations in higher order open spaces and monitor Ongoing
the community need over time. Should demonstrated demand arise, apply the 53
Partner and work with relevant Committee of Managements to provide public toilets in Ongoing
key locations along tracks and trails.
DESIGN
Refer to the Service Provision Hierarchy when determining the typology of new public Ongoing
toilets (see Public Toilet Toolkit Chapter 4).
When appropriate, undertake consultation and engagement with the local community Ongoing
prior to the development and installation of a new public toilet.
Standardise the provision of fixtures and fittings in accordance with the service provision Ongoing
to ensure consistency across the network (see Public Toilet Toolkit Chapter 4).
Action Timing
Incorporate additional features in site specific locations as appropriate to the site. Ongoing
Apply the design and siting principles as relevant to the upgrade of existing facilities and Ongoing
the installation of new toilets (see Public Toilet Toolkit Chapter 4).
ACCESSIBILITY
Apply the principles of universal design to all toilet upgrades and new installations. Ongoing
T
Develop a municipal signage/wayfinding strategy to improve the accessibility and Medium Term
standard of signage on Council owned assets, including public toilets.
F
Update information annually about Council owned and managed toilets on the National Medium Term
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
information including opening hours and DDA compliance.
Investigate the viability of a community toilet scheme through a trial in a local Long Term
R
community.
54 Monitor the need for a user paid system in the long term. Should the need arise, Long Term
undertake further consultation with the public as well as key user groups.
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
MANAGEMENT
Incorporate CPTED principles into all decision and assessment processes. Ongoing
Assess the safety and structural condition of all toilet facilities through a Council audit Every 5 years
process every five years.
Record all reports and instances of anti-social behaviour and reactive maintenance and Ongoing
monitor over time to identify key hot spots.
Record and collect information about usage and cleaning performance using counters or Ongoing
other methods.
Review and update current cleaning and maintenance schedules commensurate to levels Annually
of usage and peak demand.
Update Councils audit data to include information about other Council owned and Annually
managed toilets not currently captured.
Investigate the viability of a municipal wide app that allows individual users to report Medium Term
maintenance issues. directly to Council through their smart phone.
Investigate the need for alternative management practices at known hotspot locations to Medium Term
minimize anti-social behaviour.
Monitor the need for a new toilet in the CBD or other location with a concentration of Medium Term
night time activities.
Continue to investigate the need for a Marveloo Changing Places Facility at key Council Short Term
run events throughout the year.
E Capital Works Plan
REF. TOILET NAME/ SUBURB ACTION COMMENT PRIORITY
NO. LOCATION
56 Bath Lane Bendigo New Provision of new facility for Bath Lane Short Term
Precinct Precinct pending community consultation
and needs analysis, Land may need to be
purchased in addition to these works
36 Bendigo East Bendigo Decommission Low usage surplus asset Short Term
Aerodrome
38 Camp Street Kangaroo Flat Decommission Low usage surplus asset requiring removal Short Term
Kangaroo Flat
39 Caradon Way Eaglehawk Decommission Very poor condition, low usage requiring Short Term
Eaglehawk removal
T
16 Cooinda Park Golden Square Upgrade High use, high profile location requiring Short Term
upgrade
F
1 Elmore Elmore Upgrade (incl. Very high usage, very high profile Short Term
A
Places) Places' capability
57 Epsom Epsom New Provision of new facility for Epsom Short Term
pending community consultation and
R
needs analysis, Land may need to be
purchased in addition to these works 55
19 Goornong Village Goornong Renewal Average condition, high usage, high Short Term
T
Stadium facilities
33 Victoria Street Eaglehawk Renewal Upgrade of ageing stock Short Term
F
Eaglehawk
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
35 Allingham Street Golden Square Upgrade Very poor condition requiring demolition, Medium
Reserve relocation and rebuild Term
A
37 Bill Cole Reserve Neilborough Renewal Poor condition requiring renewal Medium
Neilborough Term
R
14 Blucher Street Strathfieldsaye Renewal Upgrade of ageing stock Medium
56
Strathfieldsaye Term
41 Crusoe Heights Kangaroo Flat Renewal Upgrade of ageing stock Medium
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Reserve Term
42 Crusoe No.7 Kangaroo Flat Renewal Upgrade of ageing stock Medium
Reservoir Term
43 Crusoe Reservoir Kangaroo Flat Upgrade Poor condition, low usage portable facility Medium
requires removal and rom full upgrade Term
62 Eaglehawk BMX Eaglehawk New Replacement of poor condition facility to Medium
Track allow Public Access Term
55 Epsom Huntly Epsom Upgrade Retrofit to allow Public Access to pavilion Medium
Recreation facilities Term
Reserve Pavillion
64 Evergreen Jackass Flat New Provision of new facility for Jackass Flat Medium
Boulevard Creek pending community consultation and Term
Reserve Jackass needs analysis
Flat
45 Heathcote Heathcote Decomission Average condition, surplus asset requiring Medium
Council Office disposal Term
58 Junortoun Junortoun New Provision of new facility for Junortoun Medium
pending community consultation and Term
needs analysis, Land may need to be
purchased in addition to these works
66 Kennington Kennington Upgrade Retrofit to allow Public Access to pavilion Medium
Recreation facilities Term
Reserve Sports
Pavilion
22 Kennington Kennington Upgrade Upgrade of ageing stock Medium
Reservoir Term
REF. TOILET NAME/ SUBURB ACTION COMMENT PRIORITY
NO. LOCATION
67 Knowsley (on Knowsley New Provision of new facility for Knowsley and Medium
O'Keefe Rail Trail) the O'Keefe Rail Trail pending community Term
consultation, Land may need to be
purchased in addition to these works
59 Longlea Longlea New Provision of new facility for Longlea Medium
Recreation Reserve and Historic School Term
House pending community consultation
and overall site design
26 Marong Marong Renewal High use, high profile facility Medium
Term
70 McIvor Road Bendigo New Provision of new facility for McIvor Medium
Skate Park Road Skate Park pending community Term
consultation and needs analysis
50 Morshead Park Raywood Upgrade Poor condition, low usage facilities Medium
Raywood requiring upgrade. Questions regarding Term
T
location of these facilities - should they be
in the main street of Raywood? Or located
F
at Recreation Reserve? $125k Raywood
Masterplan Pending
A
Recreation beyond renewal requiring demolish and Term
Reserve rebuild. Consideration of location and
potential to include these facilities as part
R
of North Bendigo Pavilion upgrade
57
61 Quarry Hill Quarry Hill Upgrade Retrofit to allow Public Access to stadium Medium
Reserve Pavilion facilities Term
T
South Recreation South
Reserve
F
60 Marist College Maiden Gully Upgrade Retrofit to allow Public Access to pavilion Long Term
Sports Pavilion facilities
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
69 Marita Drive Maiden Gully New Provision of new facility for Maiden Gully Long Term
A
Reserve Maiden South pending community consultation
Gully and needs analysis
9 North Central Bendigo Renewal Very high usage, very high profile Long Term
R
Goldfields Library requiring renewal
58
28 Redesdale Redesdale Renewal Upgrade of ageing stock Long Term
53 South Bendigo Flora Hill Upgrade Poor condition, low usage requiring Long Term
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Progress demolish and rebuild with timing
Association consideration of Scout Hall renewal
29 Spring Gully Spring Gully Renewal Upgrade of ageing stock Long Term
Recreation
Reserve
54 Strathfieldsaye Strathfieldsaye Renewal Upgrade of ageing stock Long Term
Recreation
Reserve
74 Waratah Road Huntly New Provision of new facility for Huntly Long Term
Reserve Huntly pending community consultation and
needs analysis
12 Albert Richardson Ironbark None As new facility with no works required in Long Term
Memorial Park the short-medium term
40 Costerfield Costerfield None Built by CoGB on DELWP land hand gifter Long Term
to the community, As new facility with no
works required in the short-medium term
46 Kamarooka Public Kamarooka None As new facility with no works required in Long Term
Hall the short-medium term
52 Sebastian Sebastian Renewal Upgrade of ageing stock Long Term
Recreation
Reserve
*Refer to Appendix D for maps showing existing network and proposed capital works network coverage
59
POLICY SUMMARY
NAME OVERVIEW IMPLICATIONS FOR PTS 2017
Greater Bendigo Replaces the Council Plan 2013-2017 and sets out six key objectives Opportunities to reflect objectives and vision through
Community Plan 201 relating to governance, wellness & equality, the economy, managing recommendations of the Final Strategy.
-2021 (Draft) growth, environmental sustainability and culture. Sets out a vision for The Plan outlines a lists of relevant strategies currently in use.
Bendigo to be the worlds most liveable community.
Council Plan 2013 - 2017 Sets a vision for Greater Bendigo and identifies strategic objectives, No direct reference to public toilets, however the Plan emphasises
(Year 4) challenges and opportunities in reference to five themes: leadership the importance of taking action to improve Greater Bendigos
and good governance, planning for growth, vibrancy, productivity liveability by improving the health and wellbeing of the community.
and sustainability. This is intended to be achieved through a strong focus on accessible
Current Council Plan will be replaced with the Greater Bendigo open space with direct links to important community facilities and
Community Plan. services.
Greater Bendigo Public Provides an overview of the issues and challenges associated with There are a number of key information sources contained within the
Space Plan Strategic public space in Bendigo. The Report explores a range of themes and Report including the hierarchy of open spaces, play spaces and land
Context & Issues Report influences that impact the delivery and operation of public space. ownership arrangements. Many of the issues effecting public space in
The plan will eventually replace the existing Open Space Strategy. Greater Bendigo also broadly influence public toilet provision.
T
Open Space Strategy Outlines the key strategies required to realise Councils open space The definition of open space within this document identifies good
2005 vision, ensuring that open space within Bendigo continues to serve public toilet access as a necessary requirement for successful open
as a major contributor to the quality of life of residents. spaces.
F
Recommended actions for the development of a walking/cycling trail
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
Community Access and An action plan that aims to reduce barriers to any person with a As part of the plan to reduce barriers to facilities, the document
Inclusion Plan 2015-2018 disability from accessing goods, services, facilities and employment outlines a need to review the Citys Public Toilet Strategy. This will
opportunities. Also aims to change attitudes and practices that can include identifying accessibility issues and setting out a plan for the
lead to discrimination against those with disabilities. next 5 years to implement any required changes.
R
The Plan also advocates for inclusion of accessible toilet information
60 on the Bendigo regional maps and communications.
Addresses the feasibility of purchasing accessible portable toilets for
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
community events.
Positive Ageing Strategy Outlines the actions that are required to address the needs of Discusses the idea of a Travellers Aid service at Bendigo Station that
2011-2014 all elderly people within the municipality. This will be done by would include accessible public toilets.
addressing social connection, health, housing and transport access.
Commercial Land and Provides a framework for the planning and development of activity No direct mention of public toilets, however it prioritises in its
Activity Centre Strategy centres for the next two decades. outcomes a healthy and safe community with improved wellbeing.
Environment Strategy Sets out a 20 year vision for the municipality that recognises No direct mention of public toilets, however there is a strong focus
2016-2021 the challenges and opportunities involved with environmental on open space within the municipality.
sustainability.
Play Space Strategy Outlines actions required to manage and improve 115 child friendly Establishes a hierarchy of criteria for the Citys play spaces. In
2009-2014 play spaces across the municipality. particular regional level play spaces must contain a wide variety of
amenities including public toilets.
Also outlines the importance of supporting amenities including
disabled toilets.
Public Health and Sets goals for protecting and improving the health of people living No direct mention of public toilets, however it does highlight
Wellbeing Strategy within the municipality. the importance of well serviced public spaces when it comes to
improving health in the community.
Municipal Early Years Focuses on the needs of children aged from birth to eight years by Identifies the need for more parent rooms/family toilets around the
Plan 2015-2018 improving access to high quality and accessible services to their municipality.
families and carers Also identifies the need for visible toilets in playgrounds and play
spaces.
Appendix B
T
Municipal open spaces Municipal open spaces serve the total community living in the Council area. They are classified as municipal because:
Depending on their nature, they are used by individuals, groups or teams, which are drawn from across the whole municipality;
F
They are provided by Council or others for residents of that Council.
A
The size of the land requirements, higher cost of provision and, for some types of use, the size of catchment needed to ensure viability,
mean that no more than one or two venues can be provided by a Council; and
They have been sited so as to be accessible to the whole Council community.
R
Municipal level open spaces may include sports grounds, City/town centre reserves, botanic gardens, walking/cycling trails, airport and
sewerage works land and undeveloped reserves retained to meet future municipal needs. 61
Regional open spaces Regional open spaces serve the needs of the residents of a number of Councils. They are classified as regional for one or more of the
T
Service a number of neighbourhood areas
Generally located in close proximity to large open space areas suitable for ball games
F
Generally contain a range of amenities including seating, shade, car parking, paths, bins, drinking fountains
Has a catchment area of 500m-2km
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
Situated close to residential areas
Provides basic play opportunities
May contain basic play ground equipment
R
May contain basic amenities such as seating and shade trees
62 Has a catchment of approximately 400m or 5 minutes walking (which equates to a 280m radial distance for spatial mapping purposes)
Other Play spaces that are located on City of Greater Bendigo owned land but not accessible to the general public at all times, e.g. Aquatic
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Centre play space and play spaces located at pre-schools, kindergarten and childcare centres
LEGEND
Appendix
D Toilet
Existing Public
Proposed New Public Toilet
5km Radius Existing Toilet
5km Radius Proposed Toilet
Urban Area
T
Goornong
F
Elmore
R
Marong 63
BENDIGO Goornong
Strathfieldsaye
Lockwood South
Marong
BENDIGO
Heathcote
Axedale
Strathfieldsaye
Mia Mia
Lockwood South
Redesdale
Heathcote
Mia Mia
0 10
KILOMETRES N
Redesdale
Appendix E
T
Greater Bendigo 2036 Community Plan (2011)
F
Municipal Public Health and Wellbeing Plan (2013-2017)
Draft Public Toilet Strategy
A
Violence Prevention Plan (2012)
R
64 Rural Communities Strategy (2016)
Greater Bendigo City Council
D
Public Space Strategy (In Progress)