Africa

Spectrum

Philipps, Joschka / Kagoro, Jude (2016),

The Metastable City and the Politics of Crystallisation: Protesting and Policing in
Kampala, in: Africa Spectrum, 51, 3, 332.
URN: http://nbn-resolving.org/urn/resolver.pl?urn:nbn:de:gbv:18-4-9854
ISSN: 1868-6869 (online), ISSN: 0002-0397 (print)

The online version of this and the other articles can be found at:
<www.africa-spectrum.org>

Published by
GIGA German Institute of Global and Area Studies, Institute of African Affairs
in co-operation with the Dag Hammarskjld Foundation Uppsala and Hamburg
University Press.

Africa Spectrum is an Open Access publication.

It may be read, copied and distributed free of charge according to the conditions of the
Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.

To subscribe to the print edition: <[email protected]>

For an e-mail alert please register at: <www.africa-spectrum.org>

Africa Spectrum is part of the GIGA Journal Family which includes:

Africa Spectrum Journal of Current Chinese Affairs Journal of Current Southeast
Asian Affairs Journal of Politics in Latin America <www.giga-journal-family.org>
 Africa Spectrum 3/2016: 332

The Metastable City and the Politics of

Crystallisation: Protesting and Policing in
Kampala
Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

Abstract: When protests break out in downtown Kampala they tend to

transform a fluid urban environment into bounded political camps, and
myriad ambiguous concerns into comparatively clear-cut political issues.
This article traces this process and conceptualises Kampalas urban poli-
tics as a politics of crystallisation: as attempts to structure highly fluid
dynamics into something concrete. The article is based on ethnographic
research amongst opposition activists and the police forces. Both seek to
activate political boundaries and make people gravitate towards their
respective side. But in line with the fluidity of urban everyday life, they
also work and collaborate across these boundaries. The national regime
and the opposition thus function not as permanent, stable structures, but
as processes, as fields of gravity whose emergence is incited and inhib-
ited, financed, and policed. Drawing on Gilbert Simondons theory of
individuation and AbdouMaliq Simones work on urbanity, this analytical
framework offers a dynamic reading of urban contentious politics in
general, and a reinterpretation of the paradoxes of power in African
politics in particular.
Manuscript received 21 December 2015; accepted 17 June 2016
Keywords: Uganda, Kampala, political protest, power and rule, police,
Gilbert Simondon

Joschka Philipps is a postdoctoral fellow at the Centre for African

Studies Basel. The research for this article, which is part of his doctoral
thesis, was funded by the Humer Foundation for Academic Talent and
the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNF).
E-mail: <[email protected]>
Jude Kagoro is a postdoctoral fellow at the Institute of Intercultural and
International Studies (InIIS), Bremen University. His research is part of
the DFG Priority Programme Adaptation and Creativity in Africa.
E-mail: <[email protected]>
 4 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

Hybrid regimes embody paradoxes of power, Tripp (2010: 9) argues;

they exhibit divergent realities depending on what processes or actors
one is analyzing. As Tripp shows, Uganda is an exemplary case in this
regard. On first sight, for instance, the Ugandan state, dominated for
over 30 years by the National Resistance Movement (NRM) under Presi-
dent Museveni, seems extremely stable. Internationally backed as a geo-
strategic ally of the United States, nationally supported by a wealthy
business elite, equipped with a massive security apparatus (Kagoro 2014),
the state institutions and the governing party are fully intertwined in an
intricate political patronage system that secures the overall status quo. At
the same time, however, there is a widespread sense of instability within
the political matrix in Uganda, which is fluid and constantly chang-
ing, resulting in a variety of frictions within the NRM and indicating
that the biggest threats to the NRMs power emanate from those clos-
est to Museveni (Tripp 2010: 64, 56). Instability also emerges from
outside the regime. The Kayunga riots in 2009, the Walk-to-Work pro-
tests in 2011, and the deadly clashes between opposition supporters and
police during the 2016 election campaigns have manifested profound
tensions and frustrations among large parts of the urban population,
who feel marginalised from the supposedly ubiquitous national devel-
opment and enraged by widespread corruption. And yet, to add another
paradox, corruption and Big Man politics (Utas 2012) also tended to
be intricately engrained in the very dynamics of popular resistance
(Philipps 2016).
Africanist political sociology is shot through with such contradic-
tions, or, one should specify: paradoxes and contradictions have become
a prominent way for academics to frame African political and social
dynamics. The discussion on African youth was particularly explicit in
this regard, with key titles conceiving youth as Makers and Breakers (Hon-
wana and de Boeck 2005b), Vanguard or Vandals (Abbink and van Kessel
2005), and Hooligans and Heroes (Perullo 2005), highlighting that children
and youth are extremely difficult to pin down analytically [because] they
often occupy more than one position at once (Honwana and de Boeck
2005a: 3; see also Philipps 2014). But even the foundational discussion in
the 1980s and 1990s on the African state (e.g. Mdard 1982; Bayart
1993; Chabal and Daloz 1999) versus an African civil society and Afri-
can social movements (e.g. Harbeson, Rothchild, and Chazan 1994;
Mamdani and Wamba-dia-Wamba 1995) have demonstrated profusely
how divergent, heterogeneous, and sometimes contradictory the realities
are that emerge from African polities in the academic disciplines that
reflect on them. In that empirical and academic context, Tripp (2010: 9-10)
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 5

finds it problematic that the limitations of social science [] make

embracing two contradictory realities at the same time nearly impossible,
[when] that is what hybrid regimes require of us.
In this paper, which focuses on protests and policing in Kampala,
we hope to provide a theoretical-methodological framework that makes
embracing contradictory realities easier.1 Based on the work of French
philosopher Gilbert Simondon (Combes 2013; Simondon 1958, 1989,
1995), the key idea is to think of realities not in terms of objects and
substances (Lakoff and Johnson 2003: 25) for contradictions become
problematic when one thing also appears to be something else but in
terms of crystallisation processes: as solid forms emerging from a fluid
environment. Such a perspective traces politics in dynamic terms, exam-
ining how different actors we refer to them as political entrepreneurs
(Tilly 2003: 34) work on different political realities as projects: how
they construe and scheme political stability or instability, how they mo-
bilise popular support for regime sovereignty or for anti-government
protests, and how they generally create contours in a fluid political field
by crafting in-groups and out-groups.
We will elaborate this perspective in three steps. The first section
outlines the fluid urban environment as a political context, taking the
case of Kisekka Market, a market for spare car parts in downtown Kam-
pala. At Kisekka, shopkeepers, hustlers, police spies, and middlemen are
oftentimes unaware of who supports the opposition and who the gov-
ernment. While all are fated to interact with one another, politics remains
within the realm of the intangible: less a matter of fixed and known
identities than of dynamic and unknown identifications (see Brubaker
and Cooper 2000). From this ambiguous context, however, highly unam-
biguous phenomena can emerge; Kisekka Market, for instance, has long
been known (and stigmatised) for its protests and riots. In the second
part of this article, we delineate how this transformation happens, or
more generally, how political entrepreneurs attempt to turn a highly fluid
environment into something concrete by sparking processes that engen-
der political alignments. The third section looks at police, arguing, maybe
unconventionally, that the police work through similar dynamics as
Kisekka Market. With their fluid borders and vast networks, police
forces extend way into the civilian population and sometimes even
overlap with the very opposition networks that they seek to control.

1 The authors thank Anna Baral, Elsio Macamo, Mats Utas, Sverker Finnstrm,
Anders Sjgren, and the lively and critical voices at the Nordic Africa Institute
in Uppsala (where the paper was first presented) for their valuable input. Many
thanks also go to the two anonymous reviewers at Africa Spectrum.
 6 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

Moreover, since even the core of police is fraught with uncertainty and
instability, the police are evidently part of what we call the metastable
city and to police it, they need to remain flexible and fluid while also
creating or maintaining the impression of being a bounded state institu-
tion. Politics, from this perspective, is only secondarily about the conflict
between a government and an opposition. Prior to this, and more fun-
damentally, it is about crafting concrete realities, groups, and movements
that gather momentum and followers in a context of contingency and
uncertainty (see Philipps 2016; Simone 2001; Utas 2012).
This idea draws heavily on the philosophy of Gilbert Simondon
(1958, 1989, 1995; see also Combes 2013), currently gaining popularity as
a strong inspiration for the work of Gilles Deleuze.2 Simondons primary
concern is to understand how phenomena emerge as distinguishable and
tangible, a process he calls individuation. This process, he argues, is
best understood as an interplay of innumerable factors that are intangible
in their diversity and heterogeneity, but gradually develop into definite
forms. Specific ideas, for example, emerge from relations between our
subconscious and our consciousness that cannot be clearly defined
(Lakoff and Johnson 2003); artefacts emerge from a variety of contexts
(cultural, material, historical, technological, etc.) that are never conceiv-
able in their entirety (Burke 2002); and, to reiterate Simondons (1995:
31) key metaphor, solid crystals emerge from a metastable solution that
is initially fluid and intangible. African cities have widely been described
in terms of similarly intangible relations by authors like Diouf (1996, 2003),
Mbembe and Nuttall (2004), Pieterse (2011), and especially AbdouMaliq
Simone (1998, 2001, 2003, 2004a, 2004b, 2008). Simone gives a captivat-
ing depiction of what one may call the metastable city: a space of poten-
tiality and spontaneous formations where economic pressures require
that large numbers of individuals eking out a living take chances and
spontaneously follow cues, intuitions, social ties, and dynamics without
knowing where these dynamics may take them. In this context, uncer-
tainty is ubiquitous as a constraint but also as a resource. As Simone
(2008: 22) describes in the case of Bepanda Market in Douala, Came-
roon, uncertainty provides
much room for dissimulation[,] much room for making things
seem as if they are real when they are not, or making them real
simply through the sheer mobilizing of money, interest, or sup-
port on the part of those schemed or part of making a scheme.

2 We also relied on Combess (2013) English citations of Simondon, translated by

Thomas LaMarre.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 7

The metastable city can thus be characterised as a site of crystallisa-

tion, where vague and fluid ambiguities can be turned into concrete
realities that people work and align with to probe into their potentiality
(Cooper and Pratten 2015: 1; see also Newell 2012).3 In capital cities,
such alignments easily gain an explicitly political character, for it is here
where political power is continuously staged and attacked, solidified and
undermined, through incessant negotiations of reciprocity and solidarity
with the broader urban public (see Bekker and Therborn 2012;
Christensen and Utas 2008; Diouf 1996, 2003; Utas 2012). To illustrate
this rather abstract idea, we enter Kampalas former Kisekka Market as
an exemplary site of metastability.

The Metastable City: The Case of

Kisekka Market
A place of multiple interactions towards uncertain outcomes, of diverse
activities and heterogeneous realities, Kisekka Market illustrates key
features of the metastable city all the more since it is also associated
with Kampalas most unambiguous protests and riots (see Goodfellow
2013: 6-7). Up until 2014, when the market was demolished in order to
be rebuilt, it is said (though this has not been confirmed) that major
incidents of political violence were concentrated or spread from here. In
2007 and 2008, riots erupted over the lease of the Kisekka Market land
to a retired army colonel (see Goodfellow and Titeca 2012: 267). In Sep-
tember 2009, the Kayunga riots that spread throughout Kampala seemed
to have sprung from Kisekka Market (Baral and Brisset-Foucault 2009;
Branch and Mampilly 2015: 122; Golooba-Mutebi 2011: 10-11; Human
Rights Watch 2010a), and since the massive 2011 Walk-to-Work protests
(see Branch and Mampilly 2015), opposition politicians have frequently
aroused militant support and sparked anti-government protests when
appearing in the vicinity of the market.4 It is in that context that Kisekka
Market had come to be known as, and stigmatised as, the hotbed of riot-
ers and demonstrations in Kampalas central business centre (Mukisa

3 As a theoretical side note, this inverts how we tend to think about hybridity (see
Albrecht and Moe 2015): while hybridisation implies, quite controversially, that
previously bounded entities turn into a less distinct mix, the idea of crystallisation
sees the indistinct mix as a universal primary condition from which intelligible
entities, i.e. realities, unfold in indeterminate ways.
4 On the riots in Kampala and the institutionalisation of noise in Ugandas urban
politics, see Goodfellow (2013).
 8 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

2014) although, to reiterate, these riots were only a tiny fraction of what
was going on at Kisekka Market, only a snippet of its diverse incidents,
coincidences, and potentials.5
Kisekka Markets metastable character also bespeaks the ways in
which the past routinely resurfaces in the present. Nowadays centrally
located in downtown Kampala, the area of Kisekka Market used to be a
swamp in the Kingdom of Buganda. As all land in Buganda, it was the
king, the kabaka, who owned the land; still today, he is widely considered
the Bagandas landlord, an issue that we shall return to below. The mar-
ket emerged in the late 1980s as an informal trading spot for spare car
parts, many of them stolen, exchanged, and sold through opaque net-
works associated with Ugandas magendo underground economy (see
Prunier 1983). In the early 1990s, 26 row houses were built to accommo-
date the ever-increasing workforce, estimated to be at least 10,000 peo-
ple in 2014 (Mukisa 2014), in a narrow space between Nakivubo Chan-
nel and Nakivubo Road. Since this space was inaccessible by car, the
trades at Kisekka Market relied on middlemen. Hundreds, some say
thousands, of brokers would intercept customers arriving by car at
Nakivubo Road. They would negotiate a price and get the demanded
spare part from inside the market, keeping the difference between the
price they charged the customer and what they paid the shop owner.
These could be substantial sums, given the high value of the traded
goods and the ambiguity of prices. Customers, too, could profit from
good deals if they had the right connections and a working knowledge of
how Kisekka Market functioned. Much depended on being in the right
networks, on being at the right place at the right time, and on being
cunning enough to tilt the trades to ones advantage. Such an aura of
potentiality was not restricted to the hawkers, brokers, shopkeepers,
dealers, mechanics, flows of customers, and hundreds of food vendors:
many youth from the citys outskirts would roam the market in search of
random possibilities, action, and income, and interlocutors repeatedly
emphasised that Kisekka Market attracted Kampalas sharpest and
toughest hustlers, widely known as bayaye (see Frankland 2007), looking
not only for individual deals but for projects, ideas, and formations that
could yield something.6 As one informant vaguely put it, I wont be

5 Anna Barals insights from her ethnographic fieldwork at Kisekka Market have
been helpful in this regard, all the more as she problematises rather than re-
traces the emergence of the markets stigma as a hotbed of rioters.
6 Interviews with Julius, 5 April 2014, Wabigalo, Kampala; Marc, 9 March 2014,
Kazo, Kampala. The same goes for other markets and similar public spaces (see
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 9

paying anything, and I will be making something. [] So when some-

thing just comes up, youre already tuned. The second something
refers here to riots and protests.
The riots usually responded to previous political events in Kampala:
arrests of opposition politicians such as Kizza Besigye and Erias Lukwago,
election results that were suspected or proven to be fraudulent, contro-
versial legislative decisions and executive measures (see Goodfellow
2014). Though each instance certainly featured specificities, market ven-
dors described a recurrent pattern of rioting over the past years: a small
group would block Nakivubo Road, chant slogans, and sometimes ignite
car tires, growing into a sizeable crowd that anticipated the arrival of
police. Confrontations ensued between stone-throwing and sometimes
looting protesters and anti-riot police using teargas, rubber bullets, ba-
tons, and water cannons. Such stand-offs could last several hours, as
Kisekka Markets dense architecture made it difficult for police to clear
the space of protesters. With an audience of journalists filming the scene
and onlookers from the surrounding arcades multilevel buildings
with additional shops that feature open facades and balconies the con-
frontation between protesters and police was embedded in observation.
Since the 2009 Buganda riots, which spread throughout the capital city
and to other urban areas in central Uganda (Branch and Mampilly 2015:
122), there was an anticipated potentiality that the upheavals could
proliferate beyond the confines of Kisekka Market, both spatially and in
the sense of building political momentum as a media phenomenon,
through newspapers, television, and radio shows, through the radio trottoir
(Ellis 1989), and through the Internet. During Ugandas Walk-to-Work
protests in 2011, for instance, online video snippets of the polices vio-
lent arrest of opposition leader Kizza Besigye became an important fac-
tor for the movement gaining further momentum through an increasing
focus on police brutality and the right to protest (see Baker 2015;
Kagoro 2015a; Goodfellow 2013, 2014).7 Layer by layer, to draw on the
crystallisation metaphor, the scope and significance of the event could
thus evolve and change.
Despite the recurrent patterns of rioting, their origins usually re-
mained opaque. Indeed, amongst all interviewees and informants for this
research including opposition activists, police spies and officials, deal-
ers at Kisekka Market, and investigative journalists consensus was

Frankland 2007). The names of all of Joschka Philippss interviewees and in-
formants have been anonymised.
7 The incident happened not at Kisekka Market, however, but at the Mulago Hos-
pital roundabout.
 10 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

restricted to the claim that the opposition had regularly given out money
to spark riots, and that the government had paid money to impede them.
Some argued that a clique in Kisekka Markets Block A was in touch
with the opposition; others hinted that the Bangawa group, a Baganda
youth organisation based in and around Kisekka, were behind the large
majority of riots happening at Kisekka. Most said the middlemen started
the riots, but many others argued that rioters were mobilised from else-
where and had no relation to Kisekka Market. Several interviewees ar-
gued that the driving force behind the riots was Ganda ethnicity, while
others emphasised urban youth unemployment and outrage against gov-
ernment impunity. Throughout the research, several of these claims
could be partly verified, while none of them could be decisively refuted.
Ambiguity persisted, and started at the individual level of who is who,
and who is for whom at Kisekka. According to an anonymous police
officer, there were between 500 and 1,000 police spies among the 10,000
workers at Kisekka Market, and this was widely acknowledged by the
dealers and brokers themselves.8 Government spies are there, one
shopkeeper at Kisekka said. He went on:
The people who came to work focused on getting money are there,
everybody is there, [but] we dont see you dont see where is which
one or what.9
Relationships between shopkeepers and middlemen also oscillated be-
tween trust and mistrust. They are all about survival, one shopkeeper
argued of the middlemen, they work for you but they can also destroy
you, citing examples where looting and rioting middlemen had stolen
from shopkeepers they had just dealt with hours before.10 In short,
appearances could rarely be taken at face value, and the crucial concern
in interactions was not necessarily what was real, but what could crystal-
lise into some beneficial reality to pursue.
Ambiguity also pertained to the one thing that seemed beyond
doubt at Kisekka Market: allegiance to the kabaka. Though almost every
interviewee at Kisekka Market was quick to emphasise that love for the
kabaka is strongest here in Kisekka, that you can be killed for saying
anything even slightly degrading about the king here because we see
him as superior in all aspects,11 the kabaka also remained, as an inform-

8 Interview with anonymous police officer, 22 March 2014, Kampala.

9 Interview with Mohamed, 29 March 2014, Kisekka Market, Kampala.
10 Interview with Ian and Daniel, 30 March 2014, Kisekka Market, Kampala.
11 Interviews with Saadiq, 2224 March 2014, Kisekka Market, Kampala.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 11

ant would remark, a mystery person.12 Gerald, the informant, said

most youth knew little about the king since he did not talk much in pub-
lic (see also Brisset-Foucault 2013b: 6). Whatever we, the youth, know
about the king, and whatever we believe in, stays what we believe in, he
said. Since the previous kabaka, Mutesa II, was exiled under the Obote
regime, and the current kabaka, Mutebi II, was hindered by police from
entering his territory of Kayunga District in 2009, the kabaka, to many,
epitomised the oppressed dignity of the Kingdom of Buganda, which
was continuously put down and ridiculed by a corrupt central govern-
ment (on the same narrative, see Mutibwa 1992, 2008). Love for the
kabaka, then, could be more political than ethnic, more concerned
with marginalisation and government corruption than with Ganda cul-
ture, and a vehicle of expression for multiple concerns, emotions, and
positions.13 This was evidenced during the 2009 Kayunga riots, which
followed the polices interception of the kabaka at Kayunga District:
surprisingly, a substantial number of rioters, possibly even the majority,
were non-Baganda.14 Side by side with Baganda youth, they would chant
slogans, loot, and attack military forces while some of their peers stopped
and beat people who could not walk like a Muganda meaning those
who could not identify their lineage within the Baganda clan system. In the
midst of highly heterogeneous and contradictory concerns and energies,
along with a carnival of disparate forces, ethnicity emerged as an over-
arching conceptual frame to designate what is largely understood today as
an ethnic riot, in which the Baganda took to the streets of Kampala to
protest the police action (Baker 2015: 378; emphasis added).
In a context where such highly contradictory dynamics can coalesce
into such consistent representations, Simondon urges analysts not to sever
the event from its representation, but to understand the event as a seed,
around which further layers of representation crystallise. Since these layers
may alter the form and significance of the initial event quite considerably,
they are often deliberately crafted to pursue specific political agendas (see
Philipps 2016). The NRM, for instance, benefitted tremendously from
depicting the riots as an instance of ethnic violence to undermine Ganda
opposition vis--vis the central government. As Goodfellow (2014: 13)
notes, the government

12 Interview with Gerald, 22 August 2013, Makindye, Kampala.

13 For a strikingly similar case in Guinea-Conakry, see Philipps (2013a, 2013b).
14 According to numerous interviews with police, less than half of the arrested
suspects were Baganda. For instance, conversation with Moses Kafeero, who, at
the time, was regional police commander of the Kampala Metropolitan Police,
16 December 2015, Kampala.
 12 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

lost no time in capitalizing on [the violence]. Officials declared

that the riots had been planned by the Kingdoms leaders, and be-
gan a clampdown on public space, arresting journalists accused of
inciting the violence and closing CBS radio [Bugandas main me-
dia institution], which was taken off air for a full year.15
This leads us to outlining the politics of crystallisation in Kampala.

The Politics of Crystallisation

Though the concept is new, politics of crystallisation have been widely
discussed in terms of framing, brokerage, boundary activation, and po-
larisation, most explicitly in McAdam, Tarrow, and Tillys (2001) works
on dynamics of contention (see also McAdam and Tarrow 2011; Snow
et al. 1986; Tilly 2003, 2004). Even if the crystallisation approach is situ-
ated in quite a different theoretical tradition, it analyses similar phenom-
ena for instance, how political entrepreneurs craft political groups and
representations, and how these groups and representations serve as ref-
erence points in periods of contention. One key difference is that the
crystallisation approach focuses specifically on how these contours
emerge from a context of political opacity (Vigh 2015). It describes a
process whereby a highly fluid environment becomes solidified into
something concrete, whereby ambiguity is transformed into tangible
realities. To Simondon (1958, 1989, 1995), this individuation process is
universal: anything that is perceived as a concrete entity a group, idea,
or institution is in fact the product of intangible and diverse relations.
These intangible relations, in turn, only become perceptible through the
things they produce. A plant, for instance, emerges from a relational
process between sunlight and minerals in the ground. The relation be-
tween the sun and the minerals is usually intangible, but emerging from a
seed, the plant absorbs these intangible relations and transforms them
into a concrete form. An individuated entity thus absorbs into itself
the relation that gave rise to it, thus obscuring it (Combes 2013: 16).
Simondon therefore challenges us to approach anything any event,
phenomenon, or artefact with the question of how it emerges from
relations. It is in this sense that Simondon provides an analytical method
as much as a theory, in which individuation constitutes a universal pro-
cess of becoming that can be retraced from a metastable milieu, through
an induced seed, to an indeterminately crystallising phenomenon. Thus,
as much as Kampalas urban protests may seem particularly amenable to

15 See also Baral and Brisset-Foucault (2009), Brisset-Foucault (2013a).

 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 13

Simondons analytical framing, it needs to be emphasised that the crys-

tallisation metaphor originally relates to a much broader philosophical
claim and easily applies to quite different phenomena as well. The pro-
cess of things going viral on the Internet, for instance, is another im-
portant case in point (see Nahon and Hemsley 2013).16
The crystallisation approach advocated in this paper highlights the
contingency and the unpredictability of such processes. Simondons
analogy to the natural sciences notwithstanding, the approach also em-
phasises the importance of human agency (see also Emirbayer and
Goldberg 2005; Emirbayer and Goodwin 1994; Emirbayer and Mische
1998).17 In short, in a political context where it is particularly uncertain
how things will play out, political actors will be all the more intent to
strategically make things crystallise in their favour. To describe these
politics of crystallisation, we focus on what Charles Tilly (2003) calls the
political entrepreneur: a transversal figure (Wilson 2009: 16) who
tries to carve out the contours of an initially fluid political field to gain
political capital. As Tilly writes with regard to the conflict in former
Yugoslavia:
[Political entrepreneurs] specialize in activating (and sometimes de-
activating) boundaries, stories, and relations, as when Bosnian Serb
leaders sharpened boundaries between Serbs and their Muslim or
Croatian neighbors with whom Bosnians of Serbian lineage had
long mingled, married, traded, and collaborated. They specialize in
connecting (and sometimes disconnecting) distinct groups and net-
works, as when those same leaders integrated armed Serbian gangs
into larger nationalist coalitions. They specialize in coordination, as
when those leaders organized joint action on the part of those coa-
litions. Political entrepreneurs specialize, finally, in representation, as
when Bosnian Serb leaders claimed to speak for all Bosnians of Ser-
bian lineage [...]. In these ways, political entrepreneurs wield signifi-

16 For the overall theoretical argument on social movements, protests, and riots in
African Studies, see Philipps (2016).
17 In this regard and many others, the crystallisation approach decidedly runs
counter to Robert Kaplans The Coming Anarchy (1994). Though Kaplan uses a
similar sort of crystallisation imagery (he likens West African young men to
loose molecules in a very unstable social fluid, a fluid that was clearly on the
verge of igniting), his perspective discards human agency as much as the
open-endedness of history. Mainly intent on creating an apocalyptic image of
the global future, Kaplan abuses the experience of a number of African coun-
tries [as] merely a dress rehearsal for an ecological fate towards which humanity
is ineluctably moving (Mkandawire 2002: 183).
 14 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

cant influence over the presence, absence, form, loci, and intensity
of collective violence. (Tilly 2003: 34)
Sam, who owned a shop at Kisekka Market, was a paradigmatic political
entrepreneur from the opposition who tried to turn fluid dynamics into
tangible events and political camps.18 An ambitious young politician who
stood for a parliamentary seat, he had built diverse networks within three
different opposition parties of which he was a member. Much of his
political clout came from commanding a so-called youth brigade with a
branch in Kisekka Market that could spread rumors, execute protests,
blackmail political rivals, or confront police in favour of any politician
who gets a problem and is willing to pay for its solution. He recounted
stories of how he organised 30 of his Kisekka Market members into
command, information, and implementation sections during the
Kayunga riots, and mobilised urban Baganda youth by emphasising that
the government doesnt like your king! Another time, they staged a
violent attack on an opposition politician, to then publicly allege that the
perpetrators were government thugs. Once, they destroyed a public toilet
to tell bystanders and residents that the government was going to tear
down the informal settlements and build new houses in the area, spark-
ing protests against the Kampala Capital City Authority (KCCA). Once
the information was out, it crystallised into a phenomenon, and had
already gathered momentum by the time the KCCA dismissed the alle-
gations and rumours as false and fabricated.
Media coverage was central in these schemes; the goal was to
throw information at the public eye,19 possibly even vis--vis interna-
tional audiences and donors that both the regime and civil society heavily
depended on (see Tangri and Mwenda 2006, 2010; Tripp 2010; Kagoro
2015a).20 Both police and activists therefore informed and paid journal-
ists to report about the spectacle from a specific angle.21 A former
opposition activist elaborated,
And, the good thing, how all this [protest mobilisation] is
achieved, is media. Cause we buy media. Guys buy the media, []
and the media reach the scene, very early enough and keep wait-
ing. Then they start filming. Police will start beating the [journal-

18 Interview with Sam, 15 October 2012, Makerere, Kampala.

19 Interview with Sam, 15 October 2012, Makerere, Kampala.
20 Interviews with various informants, e.g. Sam, 15 October 2012, Makerere, Kam-
pala; Dixon and Ron, 17 October 2012, Makerere, Kampala; Gerald, 4 October
2012, downtown Kampala.
21 Conversation with Gerald, 4 October 2012, Kampala.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 15

ists], h? Not to cover the event. They are calling the radio station.
Ahhh, police are running, roughing up, they are taking my cam-
era, directly reporting [live], you get? So those on radio also tell
others []. By evening, the whole city is on fire.22
External observation and media coverage was crucial in particular be-
cause of the observers partial knowledge of what was taking place
partial in terms of both its incompleteness and the political biases that
would guide the observers interpretations of what they saw. Police and
protesters actively appealed to that partiality: protesters would place
women activists close to cameras to visualise their vulnerability;23 in
front of other cameras, police commanders would explain the need to
protect law-abiding citizens from irresponsible rabble-rousers. Journalists
gravitated towards these different versions as avenues for advancement.
Everything is politicised, said Daily Monitor journalist John Njoroge:
You cannot get by, in Uganda, just by simply being the average per-
son. If you want to get ahead, you must affiliate yourself with some
form of political persuasion.24
These affiliations were neither long-term nor clear-cut, however, as many
journalists took sides as those sides emerged, or, more precisely, as the
journalists helped those sides emerge. After all, opposition and police
emerged as two sides to a considerable degree through journalistic
observation, through being seen and talked about as bounded groups
from the outside. Just like during the 2009 Kayunga riots, where Ganda
ethnicity was an attribute ascribed to the rioters rather than one the riot-
ers experienced, there are good reasons to believe that the groupness of
government and opposition forces is at least as much a matter of outside
attribution as of internal experience.
Political entrepreneurs, who actively constructed what emerged as
political realities, would accord rather little credibility to these construc-
tions themselves. Even when asked about his own youth brigade, Sam, the
above-mentioned political entrepreneur, said dryly: We use these youths.
You know, we want power, we want to get legislative seats. Many political
entrepreneurs had worked for both the opposition and the NRM; some
had switched sides multiple times during their career and some were
working for both simultaneously. Although senior politicians shifted po-
litical sides as well ex-PM Amama Mbabazi, who ran for president

22 Interview with Dixon and Ron, 17 October 2012, Makerere, Kampala.

23 Conversation with Gerald, 4 October 2012, Kampala.
24 Interview with John Njoroge, 22 October 2012, Kampala.
 16 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

against Museveni in 2016, is a noteworthy case in point such dynamics

were magnified amongst a large population of young urban graduates who
aspired to a successful career. As most opportunities for professional and
economic advancement depended on connections, and since the im-
portant nodal points were situated within the NRM government, which is
close to synonymous with the state, many youth were almost inevitably
drawn to these political networks and the enormous sums of money that
circulated through them.25 Adam, a former youth mobiliser and protester
for the Black Monday Movement in Kampala, for instance, had first reg-
istered with the NRM in 2006. I realised that I cannot get anything if I am
not with [the] NRM, he said, and eventually worked his way up to be-
coming the NRM Youth League chairman in Kampalas Makindye Dis-
trict. He left the NRM in 2011, disappointed in its system of ubiquitous
nepotism in which he, as a fatherless young man with no family ties, was
unable to advance. He recalled,
People were wondering: Why are you running from where money is? And
where are you going to go? And I was disturbed, really, [because] I never
trusted in any opposition party.
He then coordinated the Uganda Youth Platform, an opposition move-
ment by General Sejusa, the former coordinator of the intelligence ser-
vices under Museveni.
Cross-cutting political boundaries was so entrenched that political
entrepreneurs could coordinate and connive across the lines they would
draw. Dixon, for instance, a police spy at Kisekka Market working for
the inspector general of police, usually sought to prevent upheavals by
channelling money to opposition groups who would otherwise organise
riots.26 But when things go sour at the end of the month, he also
collaborated with them:
Im broke, so I organize my gang []. They tell him [the inspector
general of police] all sorts of lies. That maybe the opposition to-
day approached us; theyre saying tomorrow we should go for this
demonstration. So, chief will call me and say, Dixon, you have to
go to Kisekka and, you know, handle this situation. And eventu-
ally he will give me some small money, I will also get my commis-
sion, I go and (laughing) meet my gangstas and give them some-

25 According to Andrew Mwenda (2011), the NRM spent an equivalent of USD

350 million on the 2011 election campaign, which would amount to a per capita
spending of approximately USD 10, dwarfing Barack Obamas former record
spending of USD 2.50 per American citizen in 2008.
26 Interview with Dixon and Ron, 17 October 2012, Makerere, Kampala.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 17

thing and we survive. Yeah, this is (pauses), basically, this is how our
government has survived. For all these years!27
In sum, uncertainty and ambiguity constituted a productive resource
for political entrepreneurs (Cooper and Pratten 2015: 3), even vis--vis
their bosses, as it allowed them to invent schemes and create realities,
which they hoped would gather momentum. Such momentum depended
on how different forces would react to a specific seed for example,
an event of public uproar and political entrepreneurs prided them-
selves on knowing that very well. I know youth politics, h? Ron said,
having worked for both the opposition and the government:
I know violence, how it comes up, h? I know how opposition
operates, and I know how government operates, properly! [] In
this nation I know.
Such knowledge was relative to a surrounding that political entrepre-
neurs tended to picture as comparatively nave. Gerald, less self-confi-
dent than Ron, said,
There are some things I understand. But I want to tell you that the
youth who follow me, know absolutely little about so many things.
About so many things. So, this person, if I decide to put something
in him [an idea or a political affiliation], me, myself, I can.
In a context of manipulable surroundings, then, the scope of schemes
depended on how well connected a political entrepreneur was.28 Those
able to draw from a broad range of connections could induce the most
wide-ranging crystallisation processes, while others had to pitch their
ideas to better-placed peers to benefit from their connections. For in-
stance, during the interview with Dixon, the police spy, his phones rang
and vibrated incessantly. You see my phones here? he asked at some
point. I receive sooo many calls every day, these gangsters, whoever
calling me [,] [I receive] soooo many ideas every day! Asked to specify
the kind of ideas, Dixon answered, Blackmail threatening someones
power by exposing subversive information. While the content of the
information itself was comparatively negligible and oftentimes fabricated,
the threat consisted of the expected effect what would happen if the
information gathered momentum.
The NRM state was in a strikingly similar position: blackmailed on
charges of corruption, which is common knowledge across the country,

27 For a similar point on urban patronage politics in Kampala, see Goodfellow

and Titeca (2012).
28 On connectionwork in Kampalas music industry, see Schneidermann (2014).
 18 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

the subversive element was not the information that corruption existed
but that frustrations about it gathered political momentum in large-scale
protest. The question preoccupying Dixon was how long the govern-
ment could pay the ransom:
The moment the government runs out of money, we get [it gets]
scared, trust me: (whispering suspiciously) Now, these people, criticising
on the street, what shall we give them? If there is no money?
Indeed, it is in this context that the state has increasingly counted on
police to handle the issue.

Policing the Metastable City

Ugandas police had long remained in the shadows of Musevenis National
Resistance Army (NRA). While the army embodied the Ugandan liber-
ation after the Bush War from 1981 to 1986, the police, adopted from the
former Obote regime, were poorly equipped, notoriously underfunded,
and unheeded in public. The fact that it is now a highly visible, well-
equipped, and equally prominent and controversial institution in Ugandan
politics that no longer requires military assistance in anti-riot operations
has a lot to do with the current inspector general of police (IGP), Kale
Kayihura. Kayihura had joined Museveni in the Bush War in 1982 after
completing his LLM at the London School of Economics, and was then
appointed to lead sensitive operations in Congo and to conduct internal
investigations. Kayihura became IGP in 2005, and the polices manpower
has increased enormously since then, from 8,000 in 2001 to an estimated
60,000 today (Kagoro 2014: 120). From 2004 to 2014, the police budget
grew from UGX 75 billion to 303 billion (i.e. from USD 22 million to
90 million),29 the number of vehicles has mushroomed,30 and for the 2016
elections period alone, police secured UGX 212 billion (USD 63 million)
for mobilising, recruiting, training, and equipment purchases.31 Recently,

29 See Ministry of Internal Affairs, Ministerial Policy Statement FY 2013/2014. Pre-

sented to parliament for debate of estimates of revenue and expenditure by
James Baba, minister of State for Internal Affairs, on 30 June 2013; 83134.
30 The number of armored personnel carriers (APCs) has grown from 0 to 30;
patrol pickups (trucks) from 125 to 591; motorcycles from 0 to 3,556; and sa-
loon cars from 41 to 232. See Uganda Police Force Fleet Statistics FY 2003/2004
2013/14.
31 Kayihura also negotiated that police may retain all non-tax revenues such as
traffic fines rather than remitting them to the Uganda Revenue Authority
(URA) (see Kagoro 2014: 120).
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 19

the police established a new anti-riot division, the so-called Field Force
Unit (see Baker 2015: 381382), and in 2013 President Museveni signed
the Public Order Management Bill, which gives police discretionary au-
thority to break up gatherings of as few as three people in a public arena
who are deliberating political issues (Kagoro 2014: 114115).
Despite these legal-institutional instruments, the police tend to op-
erate not as a bounded institution but an open-ended network, defying
distinctions as to who is in the police and who is not. Street kids indicate
traffic offenders to policemen to later pocket a fraction of the bribe
(chai ). Paramilitary youth brigades join police in ad-hoc anti-riot oper-
ations on the basis of personal and financial arrangements whose specif-
ics remain opaque to most of those involved.32 At police stations, infor-
mal middlemen, so-called kayungerizi, liaise constantly between police
officers, suspects, and complainants in nebulous shuttle mediations
about allegations, bribes, and brokerages. Akin to Kisekka Market, such
jockeying involves a multiplicity of connections, phone calls to people of
potential influence, some of them fake, some of them real, most of them
transgressing institutional boundaries. Police actively engender such
entanglements, and have amassed a plethora of informants, to the point
where Kampalas urbanites half-jokingly say that if four people meet,
you can be sure that one is a spy.33 Just like during the Ugandan Bush
War, when civilians were military-trained under the democratisation of
the gun discourse to later participate in the removal of the Obote re-
gime (Mudoola 1991: 239; Museveni 2000: 80), and akin to the post-war
nationwide mchaka-mchaka politico-military trainings of civilians that
interlaced Ugandan society with a marked military ethos (Kagoro 2015b:
183), current crime preventer trainings are turning millions of Ugan-
dan citizens into police partners, including for political mobilisation
purposes on behalf of the ruling party.34
One of the polices greatest assets in the spy apparatus are boda-boda
motorcycle taxi drivers. Estimated at 200,000 and continuously growing

32 Interview with journalist Angelo Izama, 18 October 2012, Kisementi, Kampala.

33 E.g. informal conversation with Adam at Kisekka Market, Kampala, 5 October
2012.
34 For more on crime preventers, see Moses Khiza, Here is the absurdity of crime
preventers. In: The Observer, Kampala, 28 August 2015, online: <www.observer.
ug/viewpoint/39546-here-is-the-absurdity-of-crime-preventers> (3 June 2016).
See also Crime preventers demand payment for Museveni Kololo rally, anti-
Mbabazi demo. In: The Observer, Kampala, 6 November 2015, online: <www.
observer.ug/news-headlines/40873-crime-preventers-demand-payment-for-mu
seveni-kololo-rally-anti-mbabazi-demo> (3 June 2016).
 20 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

in number,35 they are critical for Kampalas traffic infrastructure and

were long thought of as raw material for the opposition.36 They now
constitute a main source of intelligence information for police, especially,
in the IGPs words, to fight the opposition rioters who only want to
destabilise the city.37 The boda-boda drivers political affiliation shifted
notably after the Kayunga riots, in which they featured prominently as
protesters and mobile linkages between riot settings. Soon after the riots,
IGP Kale Kayihura installed and co-opted the Boda-Boda 2010 Associa-
tion, organised the motorcycle trade with a company in India that sup-
plies motorcycles at a cheap price, and became the middleman between
the boda-boda drivers and President Museveni. In 2010 Kampalas boda-
boda leadership, headed by Abdallah Kitaka, was flown on the presiden-
tial jet to Arua, in northwestern Uganda, to meet Museveni, who later
handed out more than 500 motorcycles for free and thousands more
under favourable repayment plans. Today, innumerable boda-boda riders
work closely with police, sometimes in arrests of suspected traffic of-
fenders, but mostly in the field of intelligence. Hundreds have undergone
crime prevention trainings, including stripping and shooting AK47 guns,
martial arts, and ideology classes. Boda-Boda 2010 Association offices
are often painted yellow, the color of the ruling party, and feature pic-
tures of President Museveni, IGP Kale Kayihura, and the polices former
director of operations, Andrew Felix Kaweesi.38 Police are always invited
to oversee elections of boda-boda leaders.
Given these overall developments, the crystallisation of police may
easily be misunderstood as an institutionalisation towards greater stabil-
ity, when in fact police, too, are inherently metastable representing a
fluid terrain whose inside and outside are constantly negotiated and
blurred, where positions and alliances can shift overnight and turn into
rivalries, contingent on myriad informal relations whose specifics remain
opaque, and where money and spies, rather than securing control, am-
plify the agitation. For instance, senior officers recalled an incident where
the director of the Kampala Metropolitan Police went to meet with the

35 These figures were revealed during a meeting between the RPC Kawempe and
all Kampala city division boda-boda chairmen held at Makerere, Kikoni on 26
March 2015.
36 Interview with a senior police officer at the rank of assistant inspector general
of police (AIGP) and with a regional police commander, both in Kampala, on
18 March 2015 and on 26 March 2015, respectively.
37 Conversation with the IGP Kale Kayihura, 18 April 2015, Kololo, Kampala.
38 Kaweesi is now the director of Human Resource Development.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 21

National Forum of Crime Preventers, expecting to be received with due

honour, when the crime preventers told him squarely,
It is a good thing you have come, you did a good thing, because all
those that did not come here to see us did not succeed, they were
stripped of their jobs. Without us you cant work in this city and
we can cause your sacking.39
As another senior officer intimated with respect to boda-boda riders,
In 2011 after the presidential elections [,] I mobilised over
20,000 boda-boda riders, gave them fuel [worth] 20,000 [shillings]
each so that they can ride ahead of Mzee Musevenis convoy to
Kololo for the swearing-in ceremony. This of course would make
it seem that the youth have been overwhelmingly and with enthu-
siasm behind the president. It would also make the function more
colourful. But the boda-boda cannot be trusted 100 per cent; they
are slippery characters. After escorting Mzee, they immediately
turned their bikes to go and also pick [up] Besigye [the arch-rival
of Museveni] from Entebbe Airport [Besigye was returning from
Kenya where he had gone for treatment after the police had pep-
per-sprayed his face during a political rally], saying, Oyo tumutusiza
kati katu kime omulwadde. [Since we have safely escorted this one
let us go and collect the one who is sick.]40
Added to the slippery character of the polices supposed allies, subver-
sion may also come from within the police forces. A substantial minority
of police personnel self-reported feeling hostile to the sitting govern-
ment, and disunity about the politicisation and militarisation of police
exists amongst the highest echelons.41 Competition over better-paid
posts, commonly referred as wet deployments, leads to diverse con-
flicts and rivalries. Influential officials are frequently blackmailed by their
peers, and disgruntled Field Force Unit officers have even undermined
anti-riot interventions by shooting tear gas canisters when the order had
been not to, sometimes at schools or hospitals, to make their superiors
lose their position.42 In that regard, protests not only emerge as an exter-
nal threat, but also trigger uncertainty within the police as to what will
crystallise out of their own ranks.

39 Interview with a senior police officer on 20 November 2015, Kampala.

40 Interview with a senior police officer at the rank of AIGP, 12 March 2015 at
Bukoto, Kampala.
41 Interview with anonymous police officer, 22 March 2014 in Kampala.
42 Interview with the AIGP held on 15 March 2015 in Wakiso.
 22 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

At the same time, while the polices own ranks can pose risks, the
opposition can be won over. The IGP himself is known to frequently
take rioting youth to his personal home in Muyenga to dissuade them
from organising and participating in riots offering tea and food, hand-
ing out money, promising development projects to individual ringleaders,
integrating others into the spy apparatus, keeping them tied up in talks
when they are supposed to be mobilising, and appealing to their hopes
that they can make it within the current metastable order, and that they
need to continue trying like everyone else. Ron, a former opposition
mobiliser, when asked why he would stay with the IGP instead of mobi-
lising fellow protesters, exclaimed,
This is the general who has called you, everything is there. Hes tell-
ing you how he used to do what youre doing. [] Personal expe-
rience. [inaudible] That these [opposition] people are not going to
help you, they are doing selfish businesses, youre young, you lose
your life.
Ron later worked for the IGP himself: Hes a nice person, this guy. He
listens to you. If you have personal challenges, you seek something, he
gives you money.43 The IGPs personal budget per quarter for such ad-
hoc purposes is now at UGX 3.6 billion (approximately USD 1 million),
making him a key player in the urban politics of crystallisation.44
Money, however, was only one way of silencing dissent. While police
pay journalists who report favourably about their operations,45 they muzzle
others whose reports may threaten the regime (Human Rights Watch
2010b). In the wake of the 2009 Kayunga riots and in addition to repress-
ing the demonstrations in the street, the state shut down four radio sta-
tions and banned the so-called ebimeeza open radio debates that had been
key sites of political deliberation (see Brisset-Foucault 2013a: 241). Numer-
ous newspaper offices and radio stations have been raided and shut down
over the years, and various journalists have been arrested, leading to
considerable insecurity and precariousness amongst journalists without
political protection (see Tripp 2010: 96-101). At the same time, many jour-
nalists seek such protection from police. Police headquarters are crowded
with journalists who hope to establish good relations with influential offic-
ers, to have a number to call in difficult situations, but also to get the latest
news, a fuel card, or UGX 100,000 for positive coverage. This goes for
journalists from both private and state-owned media, as Ugandas media

43 Interview with Ron, Kampala, 16 March 2014.

44 Personal conversations with senior officers.
45 Ethnographic observations by Jude Kagoro.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 23

outlets tend to defy the idea of stable political camps. Journalists from the
state-owned New Vision newspaper, for instance, might be critical of police,
while the previously police-raided Independent news magazine might be full
of praise, due to a diverse range of favours, threats, personal rivalries, and
other contingencies.
An important upshot from this discussion on police is that any
crystallising entity in a metastable context must maintain responsiveness
to change and uncertainty. Just like the Boda-Boda 2010 Association or
different media outlets, police were forced to become neither too stable,
bounded, or paralysed in an ever-shifting environment, nor too unstable,
fluid, or indistinguishable from that environment. While ensuring visibil-
ity as a distinct institution, police also connived with boda-boda drivers,
some of whom had been involved in anti-government protests, some of
whom still were, and some of whom sympathised with the protests, but
would argue that the difference between the government and the oppo-
sition is that the opposition doesnt have power. Thats all.46

Conclusion
Thinking through these dynamics of protest and policing in Kampala in
terms of stable political camps, where a bounded opposition stands
against a bounded government or state apparatus, ignores both the rela-
tions that transgress these boundaries and the shifting political positions
between these camps. Though political camps do obviously exist in
Kampala, this paper has suggested treating them not as structures, not as
a priori, permanent, and definitive parameters of agency, but as emerging
fields of gravity once a protest, riot, or any other seed transforms the
metastable milieu into an antipodal political spectrum. This process is
akin to what Brubaker (2002) has argued about ethnicity and the for-
mation of ethnic groups. Brubaker, who notably defines ethnicity as a
crystallization of group feeling (2002: 167), rejects the concept of
ethnic groups because it presupposes the groupness, whose genesis
the analyst is actually supposed to account for (2002: 176). Since ethnic-
ity is contextually fluctuating, waxing and waning over time, and often-
times a corollary of conflict rather than the underlying cause of it, it
should be thought of as a project or an event rather than a collective
entity: schemed by political entrepreneurs, solidified through external
representation by media, and self-perpetuating as it crystallises (Brubaker
2002: 168).

46 Interview with Lawrence, boda-boda driver, 22 February 2014, Kololo, Kampala.

 24 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

In this paper, we applied a similar idea to opposition and govern-

ment forces in Kampala, outlining how political entrepreneurs construe
situations through which opposition and government forces emerge as
bounded entities that people gravitate towards. Since such gravitation
processes are essential for party politics to work, the incentives to incite
them are by no means restricted to the Ugandan opposition. The NRM,
too, capitalises profoundly on events that polarise and make the opposi-
tion visible as a threat to the regime especially when these events are
violent. Indeed, the NRM has long benefitted from security threats to
expand its military apparatus and present itself as the only alternative to
violence and mayhem (Baker 2015; Branch and Mampilly 2015). As
Goodfellow (2014) has shown in a variety of cases, NRM politicians
have in recent years strategically stirred up legislative debates whose main
effects were political unrest and state crackdown. Rather than trying to
implement the debated laws which appeared to be a secondary concern
at best the NRM used the violence they provoked as a motive to
criminalise the opposition, demonstrate the regimes dominance, and
justify further legal maneuvers that restricted political space and did
little to ease underlying tensions (Goodfellow 2014: 2).47
Designating the Ugandan state as politically stable or politically
unstable becomes problematic in this context, not only because both
are simultaneously true (cf. Tripp 2010). Rather, it is problematic because
such designations tend to absorb the very processes that they refer to,
the whole gamut of politicking that goes into crafting the stable or the
unstable state, the actual making of politics as they appear. To account
for these processes, Simondons framework provides a rich set of
instruments that can be applied to matters far beyond the question of
urban politics in Kampala. One is Simondons idea of the pre-individual,
metastable realm. Put simply, one could think of the metastable realm as
a truly empirical world that is inconceivable because it is not yet con-
ceptualised, not yet divided into distinct phenomena that one could de-
scribe, assess, and evaluate. Additionally, this idea implies that the emer-
gence of any conceivable reality from the metastable realm is contingent
on the different interests of those who partake in defining its contours,
and thus inevitably controversial, as we elaborated in the politics of
crystallisation section. Related to that, Simondons framework hints at
the need for a self-reflexive understanding of how our analytical con-
cepts also work as agents of crystallisation (Brubaker and Cooper 2000;

47 In a context of allegedly ubiquitous security threats, such a political strategy is

clearly of global concern.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 25

Combes 2013; Lakoff and Johnson 2003). A concept like police, as we

have shown in the final section, bundles a diversity of oftentimes incon-
gruous elements into something homogeneous and perceptible, for bet-
ter or for worse, and scholars face the complex challenge of finding
methods and languages that account for what gets lost in that process.
AbdouMaliq Simones work on urbanity remains noteworthy in this
regard, as he refrains from fixing and determining what he describes, and
instead highlights and performs interdependences and elusiveness. As
Simone said in a recent interview, I guess what has always interested me
about urban life is that aspect which it refuses to be folded into
(Philipps 2015: 58).
The crystallisation approach, finally, aside from lending itself to in-
vestigating the metastable city as experienced by its residents (Simone
2014: 4), or to scrutinising protest movements (Philipps 2016), encour-
ages analysts to reconstruct the crystallisation of realities about African
politics that emerge in a rather top-down fashion. Indices used in global
governance, such as the Fragile States Index,48 are a crucial case in point
(see Merry, Davis, and Kingsbury 2015). Widely accepted and used as
objective measurements, indices construe easily digestible realities
(The Fund for Peace 2016) from exceedingly more complex national
contexts, which these indices hierarchise according to standards mostly
set in the Global North with marked effects on governance (Cooley
and Snyder 2015; Merry 2011; see also Jerven 2013, 2015). A Simon-
donian politics of crystallisation approach would problematise, but
also retrace how such indices work. As regards the Fragile States Index,
such an approach would, for instance, question the idea of political
(in)stability as the aggregate sum of standardised indicators and, with
that, the indexs ability to perform an early warning function on that
basis (The Fund for Peace 2016). The so-called Arab Spring has amply
manifested how contentious politics can crystallise unpredictably, in
unlikely settings and in unforeseeable ways, and how they can destabilise
states across and beyond the MENA region, which the Fragile States
Index and other expert institutions had ranked as comparatively stable
at the time (The Fund for Peace 2011; see also Philipps 2016). Neverthe-
less, as indicators provide a transition from ambiguity to certainty (Merry

48 The Fragile States Index, which until 2014 used to be called the Failed States
Index, has been published annually since 2005 by the American think tank The
Fund for Peace and the journal Foreign Policy. It is based on 12 social, economic,
and political indicators, each with an average of 14 sub-indicators. Criticisms of
the index abound. See, e.g., Beehner and Young (2012); Evers (2014); Leigh
(2012).
 26 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

2011: S88), the crystallisation framework is well equipped to also retrace

and retrieve the diverse processes and relations that indicators absorb,
and to explore the functions of indices at the nexus of global politics and
knowledge production. As such, Simondons theoretical apparatus pro-
vides valuable tools for both classic empirical analyses and critical reflec-
tions on African politics as an object of knowledge.

References
Abbink, Jon, and Ineke van Kessel (eds) (2005), Vanguard or Vandals: Youth,
Politics, and Conflict in Africa, Leiden: Brill.
Albrecht, Peter, and Louise Wiuff Moe (2015), The Simultaneity of Au-
thority in Hybrid Orders, in: Peacebuilding 3, 1, 116.
Baker, Bruce (2015), Unchanging Public Order Policing in Changing Times
in East Africa, in: The Journal of Modern African Studies, 53, 3, 365389.
Baral, Anna, and Florence Brisset-Foucault (2009), Les meutes de sep-
tembre 2009 en Ouganda, in: Politique africaine, 116, 4, 165184.
Bayart, Jean-Franois (1993), The State in Africa: The Politics of the Belly, Lon-
don: Longman.
Beehner, Lionel, and Joseph Young (2012), The Failure of the Failed States
Index, World Policy Blog, The World Policy Institute, 17 June 2012,
online: <www.worldpolicy.org/blog/2012/07/17/failure-failed-states-
index> (17 June 2016).
Bekker, Simon, and Gran Therborn (eds) (2012), Capital Cities in Africa:
Power and Powerlessness, Cape Town: HSRC Press.
Branch, Adam, and Zachariah Mampilly (2015), Africa Uprising: Popular Pro-
test and Political Change, London: Zed Books.
Brisset-Foucault, Florence (2013a), A Citizenship of Distinction in the
Open Radio Debates of Kampala, in: Africa, 83, 2, 227250.
Brisset-Foucault, Florence (2013b), Buganda Royalism and Political Com-
petition in Ugandas 2011 Elections, in: Journal of Eastern African Stud-
ies, 7, 3, 509529.
Brubaker, Rogers (2002), Ethnicity Without Groups, in: Archives Europ-
ennes de Sociologie, 43, 2, 163189.
Brubaker, Rogers, and Frederick Cooper (2000), Beyond Identity, in:
Theory and Society, 29, 1, 147.
Burke, Peter (2002), Context in Context, in: Common Knowledge, 8, 1, 152
177.
Chabal, Patrick, and Jean-Pascal Daloz (1999), Africa Works: Disorder as
Political Instrument, Oxford: International African Institute.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 27

Christensen, Maya, and Mats Utas (2008), Mercenaries of Democracy:

The Politricks of Remobilized Combatants in the 2007 General
Elections, Sierra Leone, in: African Affairs, 107, 429, 515539.
Combes, Muriel (2013), Gilbert Simondon and the Philosophy of the Transindi-
vidual, Cambridge: MIT Press.
Cooley, Alexander, and Jack Snyder (eds) (2015), Ranking the World: Grad-
ing States as a Tool of Global Governance, Cambridge: Cambridge Uni-
versity Press.
Cooper, Elizabeth, and David Pratten (2015), Ethnographies of Uncertain-
ty in Africa: An Introduction, in: E. Cooper and D. Pratten (eds), Eth-
nographies of Uncertainty in Africa, Anthropology, Change and Develop-
ment series, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 116.
Diouf, Mamadou (1996), Urban Youth and Senegalese Politics: Dakar
1988-1994, in: Public Culture, 8, 225249.
Diouf, Mamadou (2003), Engaging Postcolonial Cultures: African Youth
and Public Space, in: African Studies Review, 46, 2, 112.
Ellis, Stephen (1989), Tuning In to Pavement Radio, in: African Affairs,
88, 352, 321330.
Emirbayer, Mustafa, and Chad Alan Goldberg (2005), Pragmatism, Bour-
dieu, and Collective Emotions in Contentious Politics, in: Theory and
Society, 34, 5/6, 469518.
Emirbayer, Mustafa, and Jeff Goodwin (1994), Network Analysis, Cul-
ture, and the Problem of Agency, in: American Journal of Sociology, 99,
6, 14111454.
Emirbayer, Mustafa, and Ann Mische (1998), What Is Agency?, in:
American Journal of Sociology, 103, 4, 9621023.
Evers, Miles M. (2014), The Fatally Flawed Fragile States Index, in: The
National Interest, online: <http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/
the-fatally-flawed-frag-ile-states-index-10878> (17 June 2016).
Frankland, Stan (2007), No Money, No Life: Surviving on the Streets of
Kampala, in: James Staples (ed.), Livelihoods at the Margins: Surviving
the City, Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press, 3152.
Golooba-Mutebi, Frederick (2011), Settling the Buganda Question, in:
Transition: An International Review, 106b, 1025.
Goodfellow, Tom (2013), The Institutionalisation of Noise and Si-
lence in Urban Politics: Riots and Compliance in Uganda and
Rwanda, in: Oxford Development Studies, 41, 4, 436454.
Goodfellow, Tom (2014), Legal Manoeuvres and Violence: Law Making,
Protest and Semi-Authoritarianism in Uganda, in: Development and
Change, 45, 4, 753776.
 28 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

Goodfellow, Tom, and Kristof Titeca (2012), Presidential Intervention

and the Changing Politics of Survival in Kampalas Informal
Economy, in: Cities, 29, 4, 264270.
Harbeson, John W., Donald S. Rothchild, and Naomi Chazan (eds)
(1994), Civil Society and the State in Africa, Boulder: Lynne Rienner
Publishers.
Honwana, Alcinda, and Filip de Boeck (2005a), Children & Youth in
Africa: Agency, Identity & Place, in: Alcinda Honwana and Filip de
Boeck (eds), Makers & Breakers: Children and Youth in Postcolonial Af-
rica, Oxford: James Currey, 118.
Honwana, Alcinda, and Filip de Boeck (eds) (2005b), Makers & Breakers:
Children & Youth in Postcolonial Africa, Oxford: James Currey.
Human Rights Watch (2010a), Uganda: Investigate 2009 Kampala Riot Killings,
online: <www.hrw.org/news/2010/09/10/uganda-investigate-2009-
kampala-riot-killings> (18 October 2015).
Human Rights Watch (2010b), A Media Minefield: Increased Threats to Freedom
of Expression in Uganda, online: <www.hrw.org/report/2010/05/02/
media-minefield/increased-threats-freedom-expression-uganda> (18
October 2015).
Jerven, Morten (2013), Poor Numbers: How We Are Misled by African Devel-
opment Statistics and What to Do about It, 1 edition, Ithaca: Cornell
University Press.
Jerven, Morten (2015), Africa: Why Economists Get It Wrong, 1 edition,
London: Zed Books.
Kagoro, Jude (2014), Militarization in Post-1986 Uganda: Politics, Military
and Society Interpretation, Berlin, Mnster: Lit Verlag.
Kagoro, Jude (2015a), Militarization in Post-1986 Uganda: Politics, Military
and Society Interpretation, Mnster: LIT Verlag.
Kagoro, Jude (2015b), Competitive Authoritarianism in Uganda: The Not
so Hidden Hand of the Military, in: Zeitschrift fr Vergleichende Poli-
tikwissenschaft, 10, 1, 155172.
Kaplan, Robert D. (1994), The Coming Anarchy: How Scarcity, Crime,
Overpopulation, Tribalism, and Disease Are Rapidly Destroying the
Social Fabric of Our Planet, in: The Atlantic, February, 4476.
Lakoff, George, and Mark Johnson (2003), Metaphors We Live By, Chi-
cago: University of Chicago Press.
Leigh, Claire (2012), Failed States Index Belongs in the Policy Dustbin,
in: The Guardian, 2 July, online: <www.theguardian.com/global-de-
velopment/poverty-mat-ters/2012/jul/02/failed-states-index-pol
icy-dustbin> (17 June 2016).
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 29

Mamdani, Mahmood, and Ernest Wamba-dia-Wamba (eds) (1995), Afri-

can Studies in Social Movements and Democracy, Dakar: CODESRIA.
Mbembe, Achille, and Sarah Nuttall (2004), Writing the World from an
African Metropolis, in: Public Culture, 16, 3, 347372.
McAdam, Doug, and Sidney Tarrow (2011), Introduction: Dynamics of
Contention Ten Years On, in: Mobilization: An International Quarterly,
16, 1, 110.
McAdam, Doug, Sidney Tarrow, and Charles Tilly (2001), Dynamics of
Contention, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mdard, Jean-Fanois (1982), The Underdeveloped State in Tropical Af-
rica: Political Clientelism or Neopatrimonialism?, in: Christopher
Clapham (ed.), Private Patronage and Public Power. Political Clientelism in the
Modern State, New York: St. Martins Press, 162192.
Merry, Sally Engle (2011), Measuring the World: Indicators, Human
Rights, and Global Governance, in: Current Anthropology, 52, S3,
S8395.
Merry, Sally Engle, Kevin E. Davis, and Benedict Kingsbury (eds)
(2015), The Quiet Power of Indicators: Measuring Governance, Corruption,
and Rule of Law, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mkandawire, Thandika (2002), The Terrible Toll of Post-Colonial Rebel
Movements in Africa: Towards an Explanation of the Violence
against the Peasantry; in: The Journal of Modern African Studies, 40, 2,
181215.
Mudoola, Dan (1991), Institution Building: The Case of the NRM and the
Military in Uganda, 1986-1989, in: Holger Bernt Hansen and Michael
Twaddle (eds), Changing Uganda, London: James Currey, 230246.
Mukisa, Farahani (2014), Kisekka Market: Beyond Rioters, Seeing Inno-
vators, in: Sunday Monitor, 5 May, online: <www.monitor.co.ug/
artsculture/Reviews/Kisekka-market--beyond-rioters--seeing-innova
tors/-/691232/2303520/-/1246lb3z/-/index.html (18 October 2015).
Museveni, Yoweri (2000), What is Africas Problem?, Minneapolis: Univer-
sity of Minnesota Press.
Mutibwa, Phares (1992), Uganda after Independence: A Story of Unfulfilled
Hopes, London: Hurst.
Mutibwa, Phares Mukasa (2008), The Buganda Factor in Uganda Politics,
Kampala: Fountain Publishers.
Mwenda, Andrew M. (2011), Why Museveni Won and Besigye Lost, and What
Can Be Done for the Future, in: Andrew Mwendas Blog, online: <www.
andrewmwendasblog.blogspot.com/2011/04/why-museveni-won-an
d-besigye-lost-and.html> (3 June 2016).
Nahon, Karine, and Jeff Hemsley (2013), Going Viral, Cambridge: Polity.
 30 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

Newell, Sasha (2012), The Modernity Bluff: Crime, Consumption, and Citizen-
ship in Cte dIvoire, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Perullo, Alex (2005), Hooligans and Heroes: Youth Identity and Hip-
Hop in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, in: Africa Today, 51, 4, 75101.
Philipps, Joschka (2013a), Ambivalent Rage: Youth Gangs and Political Protests
in Conakry, Guinea, Paris: ditions LHarmattan.
Philipps, Joschka (2013b), Youth Gangs and Urban Political Protests: A
Relational Perspective on Conakrys Axis of Evil, in: Brigit
Obrist, Veit Arlt, and Elsio Macamo (eds), Living the City in Africa:
Processes of Invention and Intervention, Zurich: Lit-Verlag, 8198.
Philipps, Joschka (2014), Dealing with Diversity: African Youth Research
and the Potential of Comparative Approaches, in: Journal of Youth
Studies, 17, 10, 13621377.
Philipps, Joschka (2015), Rencontres. Begegnungen. Encounters, Inter-
view with AbdouMaliq Simone, in: Schweizerische Gesellschaft fr Afri-
kastudien: Newsletter, 1, 5761.
Philipps, Joschka (2016), Crystallising Contention: Social Movements,
Protests and Riots in African Studies, in: Review of African Political
Economy, 43, 150, online: <www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/
03056244.2016.1171206> (17 August 2016).
Pieterse, Edgar (2011), Grasping the Unknowable: Coming to Grips with
African Urbanisms, in: Social Dynamics, 37, 1, 523.
Prunier, Gerard (1983), Le magendo: Essai sur quelques aspects margi-
naux des changes commerciaux en Afrique orientale, in: Politique
africaine, 9, 5362.
Schneidermann, Nanna (2014), Connectionwork: Making a Name in Ugandas
Music Industry, Aarhus: Department for Culture and Society, Faculty
of Arts, Aarhus University.
Simondon, Gilbert (1958), Du mode dexistence des objets techniques, Paris:
Editions Aubier-Montaigne.
Simondon, Gilbert (1989), Lindividuation psychique et collective, Paris: Edi-
tions Aubier-Montaigne.
Simondon, Gilbert (1995), Lindividu et sa gense physico-biologique, Grenoble:
Editions Jrme Millon.
Simone, AbdouMaliq (1998), Urban Social Fields in Africa, in: Social Text,
56, 7189.
Simone, AbdouMaliq (2001), Straddling the Divides: Remaking Associa-
tional Life in the Informal African City, in: International Journal of Urban
and Regional Research, 25, 1, 102117.
 Protesting and Policing in Kampala 31

Simone, AbdouMaliq (2003), Resource of Intersection: Remaking Social

Collaboration in Urban Africa, in: Canadian Journal of African Studies,
37, 2/3, 513538.
Simone, AbdouMaliq (2004a), For the City yet to Come: Changing African Life
in Four Cities, Durham: Duke University Press.
Simone, AbdouMaliq (2004b), People as Infrastructure: Intersecting Frag-
ments in Johannesburg, in: Public Culture, 16, 3, 407429.
Simone, AbdouMaliq (2008), Emergency Democracy and the Govern-
ing Composite, in: Social Text, 26, 2, 1333.
Simone, AbdouMaliq (2014), Jakarta: Drawing the City Near, Minneapolis:
University of Minnesota Press.
Snow, David, Burke Rochford, Steven Worden, and Robert Benford
(1986), Frame Alignment Processes, Micromobilization, and Move-
ment Participation, in: American Sociological Review, 51, 4, 464481.
Tangri, Roger, and Andrew M. Mwenda (2006), Politics, Donors and the
Ineffectiveness of Anti-Corruption Institutions in Uganda, in: The
Journal of Modern African Studies, 44, 1, 101124.
Tangri, Roger, and Andrew M. Mwenda (2010), President Museveni and
the Politics of Presidential Tenure in Uganda, in: Journal of Contem-
porary African Studies, 28, 1, 3149.
The Fund for Peace (2011), The Failed States Index 2010, Washington,
DC: The Fund for Peace.
The Fund for Peace (2016), The Fragile States Index: Methodology, online:
<http://fsi.fundforpeace.org/methodology> (15 June 2016).
Tilly, Charles (2003), The Politics of Collective Violence, Cambridge: Cam-
bridge University Press.
Tilly, Charles (2004), Social Boundary Mechanisms, in: Philosophy of the
Social Sciences, 34, 2, 211236.
Tripp, Aili Mari (2010), Musevenis Uganda: Paradoxes of Power in a Hybrid
Regime, Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Utas, Mats (ed.) (2012), African Conflicts and Informal Power: Big Men and
Networks, London: Zed Books.
Vigh, Henrik (2015), Social Invisibility and Political Opacity: On Percep-
tiveness and Apprehension in Bissau, in: Elizabeth Cooper and David
Pratten (eds), Ethnographies of Uncertainty in Africa, Basingstoke: Pal-
grave Macmillan, 111128.
Wilson, Eric (2009), Deconstructing the Shadows, in: Eric Wilson (ed.),
Government of the Shadows: Parapolitics and Criminal Sovereignty, London:
Pluto Press, 1355.
 32 Joschka Philipps and Jude Kagoro

Die metastabile Stadt und die Politik der Kristallisierung:

Protest und Polizei in Kampala
Zusammenfassung: Wenn in der Innenstadt Kampalas Unruhen ausbre-
chen, entstehen in einem dynamischen Prozess geschlossene politische
Lager, und aus einer Vielzahl unterschiedlicher Anliegen werden ver-
gleichsweise festumrissene politische Forderungen. Die Autoren des vor-
liegenden Beitrags zeichnen diesen Wandel nach und deuten das politische
Geschehen in Kampala als Politik der Kristallisierung: als Versuch, aus
uerst fluiden Bewegungen feste Strukturen zu machen. Ihre Analyse
basiert auf ethnographischer Feldforschung und Interviews mit Aktivisten
der Opposition und Angehrigen der Polizei. So sehr beide Formationen
versuchen, Menschen auf ihre Seite zu ziehen, so wenig sind sie im stdti-
schen Alltag voneinander abgegrenzt. Individuen bewegen sich mitunter
auf beiden Seiten der politischen Grenzlinien und suchen die Kooperation.
Das nationale Regime und die Opposition stehen sich nicht als perma-
nente stabile Strukturen gegenber, sondern als Gravitationsfelder, deren
Entstehen angeheizt und unterdrckt, finanziert und kontrolliert wird.
Unter Bezugnahme auf Gilbert Simondons Theorie der Individuation und
AbdouMaliq Simones Arbeiten zu Urbanitt versuchen die Autoren, std-
tischen Widerstand und staatliche Kontrolle dynamisch zu erfassen und
auf diese Weise eine neue Interpretation afrikanischer Politik anzuregen.
Schlagwrter: Uganda, Kampala, Politischer Protest, Macht und Herr-
schaft, Polizei, Gilbert Simondon