Ultrasound Diagnosis of Early Pregnancy Loss
Ultrasound Diagnosis of Early Pregnancy Loss
Ultrasound Diagnosis of Early Pregnancy Loss
and
Version 1.0
Guideline No. 1
1
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
The purpose of this guideline is to assist all healthcare professionals in the management of
first trimester spontaneous miscarriage.
This guideline provides information relating to the diagnosis of early pregnancy loss defined as a loss,
within the first 13 weeks of pregnancy. It specifically addresses the ultrasound diagnosis of
miscarriage. This guideline is intended to be primarily used by health personnel working in the area of
early pregnancy which includes obstetricians, midwife sonographers, radiographers, radiologists and
general practitioners. All of the groups should be familiar with the various diagnostic tools necessary
to help delineate a viable from a non-viable pregnancy.
3.0 Methodology
A search was conducted of current international guidelines in the UK, USA, Canada, Hong Kong, New
Zealand / Australia. In addition, a review of literature through Medline and the Cochrane Library was
carried out. The search words used were miscarriage, spontaneous abortion, ultrasound and
diagnosis.
Acknowledgements:
2
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
4.1 Terminology
The recommended medical term for pregnancy loss less than 24 weeks should be miscarriage. The
inadvertent use by healthcare professionals of inappropriate terms such as pregnancy failure or
incompetent cervix may, in some circumstances, contribute to a womans negative self perceptions
and aggravate any sense of failure, guilt and insecurity related to the miscarriage. The terms abortion,
anembryonic pregnancy and blighted ovum should be abandoned.
It is important that all relevant health personnel are familiar with the chronological ultrasound features
of early pregnancy. The first ultrasound evidence of pregnancy is the gestational sac within the
thickened decidua. This sac which represents the chorionic cavity is a small anechoic fluid collection
surrounded by an echogenic ring that represents trophoblasts and decidual reaction. It is possible to
identify the sac with transvaginal ultrasound by 4 weeks and 2 days when the mean diameter is 2-3
mm.
The yolk sac is the first structure often seen within the gestational sac and it confirms an intrauterine
pregnancy. The yolk sac is first seen by transvaginal ultrasound when the mean gestational sac
diameter is 5 mm, and should always be visualised when the mean gestational sac diameter is >7
mm. The amnion is a thin, rounded membrane surrounding the embryo and is completely enveloped
by the thick echogenic chorion. The yolk sac is situated between the amnion and the chorion. The
amnion is thin and difficult to visualise and is best seen when perpendicular to the ultrasound beam.
The amnion grows rapidly during pregnancy and fuses with the chorion between 12 and 16 weeks
gestation. The embryo can be identified by transvaginal ultrasound when as small as 12 mm in
length. At 57 weeks gestation both the embryo and gestational sac should grow at approximately 1
mm per day. Cardiac activity immediately adjacent to the yolk sac indicates a live embryo but may not
be seen until the embryo measures 5 mm. From 5 - 6 weeks gestation a fetal heart rate of less
than 100 beats per minute is normal. During the following 3 weeks there is a rapid increase up to 180
beats per minute.
3
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
4
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
An ultrasound diagnosis of fetal demise may be made when there is no fetal heart in a fetus with fetal
pole >7mm when using transvaginal ultrasound. A diagnosis of pregnancy loss may also be made if
the mean gestational sac diameter exceeds 20 mm in the absence of a yolk sac or embryo. Particular
care should be taken to scan all of the sac in a longitudinal and vertical plain. The mean sac diameter
should be measured in 3 diameters and averaged. The area of the fetal heart should be observed for a
prolonged period of at least 30 seconds to ensure that there is no cardiac activity. The use of
transvaginal ultrasound should be encouraged as better visualisation is nearly always possible.
Different cutoffs for diagnosing miscarriage apply when using transabdominal ultrasound. If
transvaginal ultrasound is not available or not acceptable to a woman, transabdominal ultrasound
criteria for fetal demise can be made when there is no fetal heart in an embryo measuring >8 mm.
Similarly, if the mean gestational sac diameter is > 25 mm in the absence of a yolk sac or embryo, a
diagnosis of fetal demise can be made using transabdominal ultrasound. If there is no sign of either
intra or extra-uterine pregnancy or retained products in a woman with a positive pregnancy test, this
should be described as a pregnancy of unknown location.
The CRL does not include the yolk sac. If the mean gestational sac is smaller than expected, the
possibility of incorrect dates should always be considered, especially when there is no pain or vaginal
bleeding. In these circumstances, a repeat transvaginal scan should be arranged after 7-10 days.
It is not essential for a second sonographer to confirm fetal demise, provided that the first sonographer
is appropriately qualified and has adhered to the guidelines. It may be distressing for the woman to
undergo another unnecessary transvaginal assessment. It should, however, be emphasised that if
there is any doubt in the diagnosis, a second opinion should be sought. Also, if a second opinion may
benefit a woman psychologically, it should be facilitated. It is important to listen carefully to the views
of the woman, particularly in circumstances where she has had a prior pregnancy.
5
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
Transvaginal
Ultrasound
Miscarriage Miscarriage
Transabdominal
Ultrasound
Miscarriage Miscarriage
6
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
Any clinical interventions, however, must be based on diagnostic and not predictive features.
Visualise all of the uterus. Pan the uterus in saggital, and then rotate the probe 90 degrees to
visualise from cervix to fundus. Failure to visualise all of the uterus will result in missing gestational
sacs in multiple pregnancies.
Neglecting to scan the adnexae will result in missing hererotopic pregnancies and ovarian masses
which may require surgery.
Avoid labelling subchorionic bleeds as additional gestational sacs. Do not tell a woman that she
has a twin pregnancy with one empty sac unless you are very experienced in ultrasound.
Pseudosacs. Exercise caution in labelling intrauterine saclike structures as gestational sacs unless
they have contents i.e. yolk sac or fetus. Pseudosacs will follow the uterine cavity and are more
ellipitical, while gestational sacs are fundal and eccentrically placed.
Fibroid Uterus. The fundus of a fibroid uterus may not be included in the scan field at TVS. Both TVS
and abdominal scans are needed in these women to avoid missing gestational sacs.
7
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
5.2 Equipment
The ultrasound machines should be of good quality and should be regularly maintained, serviced and
checked for safety. Records of maintenance and service should be easily discoverable. Urine
pregnancy testing and -HCG estimation should be available. In addition, access to laboratory
facilities for Rhesus antibody testing and full blood counts should be available.
The decontamination of reusable invasive medical devices including transvaginal ultrasound probes
should be compliant with the HSE Code of Practice for Decontamination of Reusable Invasive Medical
Devices available here:
http://www.hse.ie/eng/services/Publications/services/Hospitals/Code_of_Practice_for_Decontaminatio
n_of_Reusable_Invasive_Medical_Devices_.html
5.3 Staffing
Ideally, the EPAU should be staffed by a receptionist / secretary and a midwife sonographer /
radiographer, supported by appropriately trained medical personnel. All staff should use clear and
consistent language and convey consistent information. This communication should always be carried
out in a caring and sympathetic fashion.
Sonographers should be formally trained in both transabdominal and transvaginal ultrasound as both
methods are complementary.
8
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
5.4 Reporting
The sonographer should produce reports using standardised documentation.
This includes:
Standardised information leaflets, referral and transfer of care (discharge) letters should also be
readily available, utilised and regularly reviewed. Each unit should produce quarterly statistics of the
number of women attending the EPAU and the clinical outcomes. Where possible, patients should be
diverted to early pregnancy units instead of presenting out-of-hours to maternity units. Systems should
be in place to inform local general practitioners (GPs) of the early pregnancy service and ensure easy
access. All units should provide training to highlight the importance of accurate early pregnancy
diagnosis. Evidence that this has taken place should be readily available to outside reviewers.
A thorough discussion and provision of written information may suffice. If the general practitioner has
received the appropriate communication follow-up appointments may be more appropriately done in a
primary care setting. Some hospitals may choose to review couples at a designated Miscarriage Clinic
if resources allow. All women should be given contact numbers with the appropriate leaflets, which
contain contact telephone numbers should they require further support and advice. In individual
circumstances formal counselling may be required.
9
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
All women with a history of recurrent miscarriage should be offered a review in the gynaecological
outpatients (or the Miscarriage Clinic) following discharge. A recurrent miscarriage is defined as three
or more consecutive clinical miscarriages.
Brown DL, Emerson DS, Felker RE, Cartier MS, Smith WC. Diagnosis of early embryonic demise
by endovaginal sonography. J Ultrasound Med 1990;9:631-6.
Chen BA, Creinin MD. Contemporary management of early pregnancy failure. Clin Obstet Gynecol.
2007 Mar;50(1):67-88.
Clinical Green Top Guideline 25. The Management of Early Pregnancy Loss. RCOG, October
2006. (www.rcog.org.uk)
Elson J, Salim R,Tailor A, Banerjee S, Zosmer N, Jurkovic D.Prediction of early pregnancy viability
in the absence of an ultrasonically detectable embryo. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2003;21:5761.
Farquharson RG, Jauniaux E, Exalto N. ESHRE Special Interest Group for Early Pregnancy
(SIGEP). Updated and revised nomenclature for description of early pregnancy events. Hum
Reprod 2005;20:3008-11.
Graziosi GC, Mol BW, Ankum WM, Bruinse HW. Management of early pregnancy loss a
systematic review. Int J Gynecol Obstet 2004;86:33746.
Hatley W, Case J, Campbell S. Establishing the death of an embryo by ultrasound: report of public
inquire with recommendations. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 1995;5:353-7.
Jauniaux E, Johns J, Burton GJ. The role of ultrasound imaging in diagnosing and investigating
early pregnancy failure. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2005;25:61324.
Kerkhoff, B. Management of Miscarriage in an Early Pregnancy Clinic. Modern Medicine, 2006; 36:
3.
Levi CS, Lyons EA, Lindsay DJ. Early diagnosis of nonviable pregnancy with endovaginal US.
Radiology 1988;167:383-5.
10
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. The Management of Early Pregnancy Loss.
Guideline No. 25. London:RCOG;2006.
Royal Womens Hospital Clinical Practical Guideline, Miscarriage: management. July 2007.
(www.thewomens.org.au)
Royal Womens Hospital Clinical Practical Guideline., Early pregnancy assesment service:
assesment, diagnosis and management planning. March 2007. (www.thewomens.org.au)
Trinder J., Brocklehurst R., Porter M., Read M., Vyas S., Smith, L. Management of Miscarriage:
expectant, medical, or surgical? BMJ 2006; 332: 1235-40.
Turner MJ, Flannelly GM, Wingfield M, Rasmussen MJ, Ryan R, Cullen S, Maguire R, Stronge JM.
The miscarriage clinic: an audit of the first year.
Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1991;98:306-308.
Turner MJ
Spontaneous miscarriage: this hidden grief.
Ir Med J 1989;82:145.
11
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
These guidelines have been prepared to promote and facilitate standardisation and consistency of
practice, using a multidisciplinary approach. Clinical material offered in this guideline does not replace
or remove clinical judgment or the professional care and duty necessary for each pregnant woman.
Clinical care carried out in accordance with this guideline should be provided within the context of
locally available resources and expertise.
This Guideline does not address all elements of standard practice and assumes that individual
clinicians are responsible to:
Discuss care with women in an environment that is appropriate and which enables respectful
confidential discussion.
Advise women of their choices and ensure informed consent is obtained.
Meet all legislative requirements and maintain standards of professional conduct.
Apply standard precautions and additional precautions as necessary, when delivering care.
Document all care in accordance with local and mandatory requirements.
12
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
Appendix One
13
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
Appendix Two
Sometimes the scan may show up a small haematoma (blood clot) around the pregnancy sac but very
often nothing abnormal is seen and it is difficult to explain why the bleeding has occurred. The
bleeding may have come from the implantation site which is when the placenta of your baby burrows
itself into the lining of the womb. This process may cause some bleeding. If we can see a babys
heartbeat on ultrasound it is very likely that your pregnancy will continue with success rates exceeding
95%.
Follow-Up
If there is a collection of blood around the pregnancy sac or the bleeding continues, it may be
appropriate to repeat an ultrasound scan in 1-2 weeks. In any case the heartbeat will be checked at
your first booking visit in the hospital. If the bleeding settles down there is probably no need for a
further scan unless you have further anxieties. Traditionally bed rest has been advised for mothers
with threatened miscarriage but all the evidence would suggest that this does not prevent miscarriage.
It may help some patients psychologically to rest in bed but it is not necessary. Unfortunately there is
no specific treatment to stop the bleeding and if you do adopt bed rest there is the possibility that on
standing up bleeding may become heavier due to pooling of blood in the vagina that results from lying
down.
With regard to work, our advice will depend on the nature of work, your history and the nature of
bleeding, but it is probably prudent to stop work if you are having significant bleeding. If you have
further heavy bright red bleeding, particularly if this is associated with crampy abdominal pains, it is
appropriate to get in touch with the early pregnancy assessment unit (EPAU) again for advice. There
is no evidence that having intercourse at any stage in pregnancy causes miscarriage or pregnancy
loss though again it seems sensible to avoid intercourse until the bleeding has completely stopped. If
you are Rhesus Negative you probably do not need Anti-D immunoglobulin if you are less than 12
weeks pregnant unless you have experienced very heavy bleeding.
We hope you have found this information leaflet of some benefit. We are constantly modifying
information leaflets and if you have any feedback on the above please do not hesitate to contact us.
14
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
1) It is possible that we have not seen a fetus and fetal heartbeat because you are too early in the
pregnancy. A repeat scan in 7 to 10 days should clarify whether the pregnancy is healthy or
not.
2) It is also possible that the pregnancy is not growing as it should and the bleeding may be a sign
of an impending miscarriage. Similarly a repeat scan will clarify the situation.
3) There is also the outside possibility that the pregnancy is outside the womb. This is unlikely
but we cannot exclude it at this stage as it is too early to diagnose. If we suspect that this may
be the case we may suggest doing a blood test called eta HCG (human chorionic
gonadatrophin). It is a hormone produced by the placental tissue and its levels roughly double
every two days in a normally growing early pregnancy. We may also repeat the scan in a few
days.
It is quite possible that you will have further bleeding if you have bled already and as long as it
is not too heavy you may stay at home and wait for the follow-up scan in 7 10 days which
should clarify the situation for you. However, if you develop sharp pain or are aware of
increasing crampy abdominal pains, it is reasonable to take paracetamol tablets. If the pain
becomes too severe or the bleeding becomes too heavy, or indeed if you are anxious about
your situation, please do not hesitate to get in touch. The contact numbers are as follows:
15
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
If your miscarriage has been diagnosed as being a missed or incomplete that means that there is
some pregnancy tissue retained within the womb. Depending on your own individual circumstances
there are some incomplete miscarriages which are best treated surgically with a D&C and others that
may be treated either with no treatment or occasionally using tablets to expel the remaining pregnancy
tissue. You may be advised as to which approach is best for your situation. Often it is appropriate to
discuss the different approaches. The three ways of dealing with a pregnancy that is not progressing
are as follows:
1. Wait and see approach (leaving things to nature). In the past an operation was nearly always
performed in cases of miscarriage, however, with the use of ultrasound we can reasonably confidently
predict those miscarriages that do not require any treatment. If you have had no bleeding it may take
up to 3 weeks for you to start miscarrying. The bleeding may be heavier than a normal period and you
may experience strong period like pains in your lower tummy as the womb contracts in an attempt to
expel the pregnancy tissue. If the bleeding is very heavy, the pain very severe or you feel unwell you
should attend the hospital for review. In a small number of cases an operation may still be necessary
should there be some tissue left within the womb or if the bleeding becomes too heavy.
2. Medical approach. Medicines may be used to start a miscarriage if you prefer not to wait. Misoprostol
is a medicine that you can take by mouth (or occasionally by placing the tablets in the vagina). You
may need to take a few doses before bleeding commences (as described above). The advantages of
this approach is that you avoid a hospital admission, an anaesthetic and a surgical procedure all of
which carry a small risk. In about 10% of cases an operation may still be necessary should there be
some tissue left within the womb or if the bleeding becomes too heavy.
3. Surgery (D and C). D and C means dilation and curettage. We dilate the cervix (neck of the womb)
and by using either plastic or metal instruments we remove the pregnancy tissue from the womb. It is
correctly called an ERPC (evacuation of retained products of pregnancy). This is done under general
anaesthesia through the vagina and you will not have any cuts/stitches. Like with all operations there
are small risks such as infection or injury to the womb and cervix. The advantage of this approach is
that it clears out the womb quicker than the above approaches.
Generally your chances of having a successful pregnancy in the future are just as good with whichever
approach you choose. Following any of the above approaches you may have a period like loss for up
to 14 days which is quite normal and should gradually diminish with time.
16
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
A 2.4 Miscarriage
17
CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE ULTRASOUND DIAGNOSIS OF EARLY PREGNANCY MISCARRIAGE
A miscarriage is a common event. It is an experience, however, that affects each woman and her partner
differently. This leaflet is intended to help answer some of the questions women ask after they miscarry. If
you need additional, or more specific information, please ask the doctor or midwife looking after you.
18