Aviation & Emissions A Primer: Federal Aviation Administration Office of Environment and Energy
Aviation & Emissions A Primer: Federal Aviation Administration Office of Environment and Energy
Aviation & Emissions A Primer: Federal Aviation Administration Office of Environment and Energy
January 2005
Aviation & Emissions
A Primer
Aviation plays a key role in the economic prosperity and lifestyle Americans enjoy. Our economy benefits
greatly from the ability to move people and products all over the globe - quickly and safely. Aviation
contributes to our quality of life - allowing us to visit friends and relatives, to travel, to experience new
places, to shrink the borders of the world. The statistics are impressive. In 1903 the year of the Wright
brothers first flight, earths population was 1.6 billion1; today, over 1.6 billion people use the worlds
airlines2. The air transport industry provides 28 million direct, indirect, and induced jobs worldwide3. And
aircraft carry about 40% of the value of all world trade4, driving the just in time deliveries critical to
productivity improvements.
Air transport links our world and is a key tenet of continued economic development and security for the
U.S. However, aviation also has environmental impacts primarily noise and atmospheric emissions.
While aircraft noise issues are better known, less focus has been placed on emissions. This paper provides
vehicle engines, produce carbon dioxide (CO2), water vapor (H2O), nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon
monoxide (CO), oxides of sulfur (SOx), unburned or partially combusted hydrocarbons (also known as
volatile organic compounds (VOCs)), particulates, and other trace compounds. A small subset of the VOCs
and particulates are considered hazardous air pollutants (HAPs). Aircraft engine emissions are roughly
composed of about 70 percent CO2, a little less than 30 percent H2O, and less than 1 percent each of NOx,
CO, SOx, VOC, particulates, and other trace components including HAPs. Aircraft emissions, depending on
whether they occur near the ground or at altitude, are primarily considered local air quality pollutants or
greenhouse gases, respectively. Water in the aircraft exhaust at altitude may have a greenhouse effect, and
1
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
hydrocarbons and CO, are produced during combustion of hydrocarbon fuels like gasoline, jet
fuel, and diesel. Carbon in fuel combines with oxygen
airport ground level operations and during
in the air to produce CO2 .
landing and takeoff. The bulk of aircraft
H2O Water vapor is the other product of complete
emissions (90 percent) occur at higher altitudes. combustion as hydrogen in the fuel combines with
oxygen in the air to produce H2O.
For hydrocarbons and CO, the split is closer to
30 percent ground level emissions and 70 percent NOx Nitrogen oxides are produced when air passes
through high temperature/high pressure combustion
at higher altitudes.
and nitrogen and oxygen present in the air combine
to form NOx.
Aircraft are not the only source of aviation
emissions. Airport access and ground support HC Hydrocarbons are emitted due to incomplete
fuel combustion. They are also referred to as volatile
vehicles produce similar emissions. Such
organic compounds (VOCs). Many VOCs are also
vehicles include traffic to and from the airport, hazardous air pollutants.
ground equipment that services aircraft, and CO Carbon monoxide is formed due to the
shuttle buses and vans serving passengers. Other incomplete combustion of the carbon in the fuel.
emissions sources at the airport include auxiliary SOx Sulfur oxides are produced when small
quantities of sulfur, present in essentially all
power units providing electricity and air
hydrocarbon fuels, combine with oxygen from the air
conditioning to aircraft parked at airport terminal during combustion.
2
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
and freight transportation, is increasing forecast is for continued strong growth as shown
substantially. According to the U.S. Bureau of in the following graph7. This is consistent with
Transportation Statistics5 a 21.5 percent increase the demand for transportation generally, which is
in population, 32 percent increase in the labor increasing largely in response to very positive
force, and 90 percent increase in GDP between structural changes in both the domestic and
1980 and 2000 have driven this demand. The global economies.
300.0
Commercial Aircraft Operations
100
250.0
Growth Index 1981 = 100
Airline RMT
50
200.0
Gross Domestic
Product
150.0 0
Roadway VMT 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
100.0
other travel modes. It only faces competition on Technological advancement has reduced aircraft
short trips or when moving low value or high fuel consumption and emissions significantly
volume products. Looking to the future, the over the last 30 years and this is expected to
3
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
The industrys historical transition from piston As they age, existing aircraft are retired and
engines to modern high-bypass turbofans replaced with new aircraft. New aircraft also are
resulted in major advancements in energy added to the fleet for new capacity. By 2020,
efficiency and environmental performance. 70% of the fleet will be aircraft added since
During this same era, the industry developed and 2002, which will have advanced technology and
deployed new, lightweight, high-strength capabilities. The chart below, replicated from an
and engine control systems, and employed vast (ICAO) report 9, illustrates this transition of the
70.0
How do aviation emissions
60.0
compare to general trends
50.0
in local air pollutants?
40.0
Compared to other sources, aviation emissions
93
95
97
99
01
03
05
07
09
11
13
15
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
4
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
Relative Emissions/passenger-mile
NOx
the air pollutants EPA regulates (nitrogen
CO2
dioxide, ozone, sulfur dioxide, particulate matter, H2O
110
NOx, a key constituent of ozone, has proven to
100
NOx
be the most difficult pollutant to control both
Emissions Index 1980 = 100
90
HC
70 wide variety of sources in all sectors of the
PM10
60
economy. Since esssentially all NOx comes from
50
combustion processes, electric utilities, industry,
40
1980 1985 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001
and transportation are significant emitters and
Local air quality pollutants have declined steadily over the past
several years. NOx has been the most challenging pollutant to make up the largest share of the total inventory.
constrain and progress has lagged that of other pollutants.
Currently aviation contributes 0.4 percent of the
Aircraft emissions have also declined over time
inventory as can be seen in the illustration12 on
when you consider the emissions from
the following page.
transporting one passenger one mile. The
following chart11 shows that relative aircraft Aviations contribution to the national NOx
emissions have fallen consistently over time. emissions inventory has recently declined further
Total aircraft emissions have increased, however, as air travel growth has been interrupted during
since aviation has grown considerably over the the past two to three years due to the terrorist
same period. As with emissions nationally, a acts of 9/11, the war on terrorism in Iraq, the
great deal of progress has been made reducing emergence of severe acute respiratory syndrome
5
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
environment. These conditions have caused a Point sources large stationary, industrial
more than ten- percent decline in air traffic and a facilities that are regulated under Federal,
state, or local regulations,
similar drop in emissions. However, these factors
On-Road Mobile sources cars, trucks,
are not likely to have a permanent effect on air
buses, and other vehicles licensed for
transportation and growth of travel demand and highway travel,
Total national pollutant inventory numbers do farm equipment, boats, locomotives, and
lawn and garden equipment, and
not tell the full story with regard to aviations
Area sources small sources that
contribution in regions with air quality problems.
individually have low emissions but that are
The worst local air quality generally occurs in significant when combined throughout the
area like dry cleaning establishments,
and around cities, which is also where aviation
bakeries, painting, and vehicle fueling.
activity primarily occurs. The Clean Air Act
requires EPA to identify air quality areas and to The table on the following page summarizes
determine whether they comply with (i.e. attain) aviations contribution to NOx emission
National Ambient Air Quality Standards13. inventories in several metropolitan areas. All of
Ozone is by far the principal air quality problem these areas have at least one airport that is among
in U.S. cities today. According to EPA data14, the 50 largest airports in the country. To provide
6
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
a context, Atlanta, Chicago OHare, and Los In the Southern California area, categorized as
Angeles International are the three busiest U.S. severe nonattainment, EPAs most restrictive
airports. In 2002, Atlanta had nearly 900,000 designation, aviations contribution was less than
aircraft operations and enplaned over 37 million two percent even where the cumulative NOx
passengers; Chicago OHare had over 900,000 from multiple airports was included. While it is
aircraft operations and enplaned almost 32 apparent from this data that aviation emissions
million passengers; and Los Angeles make only a small contribution to regional
International had nearly 800,000 aircraft emissions, even at the largest airports and even
operations and enplaned almost 27 million in areas with the worst air quality, it is still a
effectively.
Airports, including aircraft, ground support equipment, and all other vehicles operating around the
airport, contribute only a small percentage of NOx emissions to regional inventories even in cities with the
greatest concentration of aviation activity. All of the cities shown include at least one of the 20 largest
airports in the country and, except for Seattle-Tacoma, are nonattainment for NOx under the new 8-hour
ground-level ozone designation.
(Inventories are computed from available data for 1996 Atlanta & Dallas/Ft. Worth, 1999 Houston, New York, Seattle & Boston, 2000
Chicago & St. Louis, 2001 South Coast)
7
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
9,000
3,000
transportation and is expected to outpace them in
2,000
0
contribution to local air quality inventories On-Road Railroad Marine Aviation
compared to other transportation sources has Total NOx emissions from on-road transportation dwarf
emissions from all other transportation modes combined
remained modest. (1998 data).
500
Cumulative Percentage Growth
8
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
and particulate matter standards at the same time compare the composite of sources that make up
non-aviation source reductions become more an airport to another emission source like an
difficult and costly. industrial facility or power plant even when their
aviation emissions to other sources in local air emissions occur at higher altitudes, thus
quality areas. For example, the total mass of generating greenhouse gases and potentially
emissions coming from an airport may be contributing to climate change. Also, under
comparable to those of a power plant or certain conditions, aircraft engine exhaust can
petroleum refinery in the same region. produce contrails. Scientists in the U.S. and
sources. Aircraft arrive at the airport, stay for a Concern regarding greenhouse gas emissions has
short period and depart, with a different aircraft been building worldwide. The following graph30
taking off or landing every few minutes. shows the recent growth of total greenhouse gas
Passenger cars, shuttle buses, and taxis calling emissions in the U.S. The drop in emissions in
on the airport do not operate there exclusively, 2001 reflects the slow economic growth and
also serving homes and retail, commercial, and reduced industrial output that year in addition to
governmental establishments. Power boilers and the warm winter, which reduced fuel use for
chillers at the airport are independently heating. Growth in greenhouse gas emissions is
permitted, as is similar equipment at other expected to resume as the economy recovers and
locations. For these reasons it is difficult to continues to expand in the future. While there are
9
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
many different greenhouse gases, CO2 and NOx greenhouse gas inventory. Global estimates32 are
are generally most relevant from an aviation similar with emissions of the worlds aircraft
7,000
majority of which come from commercial
6,700
U.S. greenhouse gas emissions grew steadily throughout the 1990s as the projection shown below conservatively assumes
economy expanded. The recent downturn is expected to be temporary due
to economic recession. With recovery and expansion the upward trend is the relationship between aircraft operations and
forecast to continue.
greenhouse emissions remains constant. As such,
The chart below31 breaks down national
emissions track expected growth in aviation.
emissions of greenhouse gases. In the U.S.,
According to the projection, aircraft greenhouse
transportation makes up about 27 percent and
gas emissions in the U.S. will increase 60
aviation about 2.7 percent of the national
percent by 202534.
350
300
250
Tg CO2 Eq.
200
150
Industry Non-Road Vehicles 1990 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
Agriculture Aviation
Commercial
Greenhouse gas emissions from aviation have declined recently due to
Residential
the fall off in air travel following the terrorist acts of 9/11, the war on
terrorism in Iraq, and the worldwide recession. As air travel recovers in
National greenhouse gas emissions in 2001
the coming years, greenhouse gas emissions are expected to resume their
came from all sectors of the economy with all
climb.
transportation equal to 27% of the total
10
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
greenhouse gas emissions transit buses have the highest energy intensities.
compare to other
Comparing the energy intensity of aircraft and
transportation sources?
cars shows how energy efficiency and
Energy intensity, that is the amount of energy consequently greenhouse gas emissions per
consumed to transport one passenger one mile, is passenger mile have changed over the past 35
a useful metric for comparing greenhouse gas years. The chart below36 shows how significant
emissions among different transportation modes. this has been, especially for aircraft.
The different modes use similar fuels and
12000
6000
As you can see in the following chart35, in the
4000
U.S., aircraft and automobiles have very similar Automobiles
2000
6000
3000
this is an indication of their total greenhouse gas
1000
automobiles and personal trucks though
Energy intensity in terms of energy used to carry one passenger one fuel technologies to land-based transport in the
mile is lowest for rail, followed by aircraft and automobiles, with
personal trucks and transit buses as the least energy efficient.
11
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
next two decades, aviation greenhouse gas Practically all aviation emission sources are
emissions are likely to represent a greater share independently regulated through equipment-
Personal Trucks
practices, and operational guidelines, which are
28%
Transit Buses
1% established by a variety of organizations. For
Commercial Airlines
11% example, on-road vehicles, which take
Other (motorcycles,
recreational boats, general
boilers and refrigeration chillers, must meet
aviation, intercity and
school buses)
4%
independent state regulations. And FAA
12
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
aviation. ICAO sets emission standards for jet Airport air emissions from all sources also are
engines. These are the basis of FAAs aircraft constrained by the General Conformity
engine performance certification standards, regulations of the Clean Air Act Amendments of
Current NOx standards were established in 1996. projects a year that do require further analysis
New standards go into effect for engines entering essentially are able to meet the needs of state air
service beginning in 2004, which reflect a 16 quality plans through minor project modification.
13
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
only on airport property, will be required to meet agreements, open emissions trading, and
these standards. This new equipment will emission related levies are being analyzed.
percent more efficient than its early jets.39 Fuel Under this multidimensional regulatory and
economy and energy conservation are also voluntary structure, aviation has made significant
priorities at many airports. Dallas/Fort Worth environmental progress. Given the complexity of
International Airport for example looks at the industry and the need for different strategies
business practices at all of their facilities to and technological approaches for different types
minimize energy consumption. They realize that of vehicles and equipment, a coordinated effort
this benefits local air quality through reduced between the aviation industry and the many
emissions as well as regional air quality as a regulatory agencies that share environmental
ICAO to evaluate policy options to limit or There are a number of initiatives underway that
reduce greenhouse gas emissions from aviation. will achieve significant emissions reductions
Various market-based options, such as voluntary both at airports and within the national aviation
14
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
system in the next few years. First, there are In addition, many airports have independently
voluntary programs underway at airports to taken action to reduce emissions from buses,
reduce emissions from ground support trucks, taxicabs, and other on-road vehicles that
equipment and other airport vehicles. For operate in and around the airport. Hybrid-electric
example, FAA developed a pilot program, with vehicles are being used for staff transportation
EPA and DOE, to demonstrate air quality and customer service vehicles. Airport police
improvements with alternative fuel ground departments are using compressed natural gas
support equipment. The program is called the automobiles and maintenance departments are
Inherently Low-Emissions Airport Vehicle using alternative fuel trucks. Airport shuttle
Texas have agreements with the major airlines to Based on their experience with the ILEAV
reduce emissions from their ground support Program, FAA and EPA have expanded the
equipment. These new agreements will reduce initiative to reduce ground emissions at
emissions by converting gasoline and diesel commercial service airports in all air quality
equipment to electricity and alternative fuels. A nonattainment areas. The new Voluntary Airport
representatives of FAA, EPA, major airlines, eligibility for airport low emission projects under
state and local environmental regulators, airports, the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) and the
and environmental interest groups is currently Passenger Facility Charges (PFC) program.
working to establish a national agreement to Through the use of funding and emission credit
reduce ground support equipment emissions at incentives, the voluntary program includes the
other airports in air quality nonattainment areas. conversion of airport vehicles and ground
This has proved challenging, and it is still support equipment to low emission technologies,
15
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
electricity and air for parked aircraft, a pilot airlines, has improved the efficiency of the entire
Second, it is also worth noting that many Airlines generally employ standard procedures
strategies for reducing the environmental impact for operating their aircraft to meet company
of aviation are inherent to the intended design goals for safety, adherence to flight schedules,
and operation of the air transport infrastructure. fuel conservation, complying with labor
With airports for example, access roadways are agreements, and other factors. Standard
often limited access, high-speed and free flowing procedures vary by aircraft type, airport-specific
and parking facilities are readily available. These constraints, and weather. The use of alternative
features minimize motor vehicle emissions and procedures or best practices offers some prospect
keep them contained in areas away from the for reducing emissions.
public.
Some procedures affect the engine-operating
Third, looking at aviation more broadly, many regime, which can directly influence the rate of
recent changes have improved the system pollutant emissions. NOx emissions are higher
efficiency and reduced environmental impact. In during high power operations like takeoff when
the past few years, better meteorological combustor temperatures are high. On the other
information, available in the cockpit in real time, hand, HC and CO emissions are higher during
has allowed for optimized flight planning with low power operations like taxiing when
shorter routing. Yield management tools have combustor temperatures are low and the engine
allowed airlines to increase load factors, which is less efficient. As a result, reducing engine
moves more people on every flight. The hub and power for a given operation like takeoff or climb
spoke system, combined with the growth of low out generally increases the rate of HC and CO
cost point-to-point carriers and a significant emissions, reduces the rate of NOx emissions,
increase in the number and reach of regional and has little or no effect on CO2 emissions.
16
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
effect on engine use and can reduce all pollutants more efficient. These systems are expected to be
10-15 years43.
As another example of alternative operating
practices at an airport, United Airlines launched A near term example is RVSM Reduced
a new initiative last year to reduce the average Vertical Separation Minimums. Reducing
use of its auxiliary power units by using ground vertical separation between aircraft from 2000
power whenever possible. Based on early tests of feet to 1000 feet separation at cruise altitude (i.e.,
the program they expect to save approximately above 29,000 feet) adds flight levels and
12 million gallons of fuel during the year, which increases airspace capacity by as much as 85%.
will result in reduced emissions of all pollutants These routes are among the most fuel efficient
at the airport as well41. Many of the strategies for long flights such as oceanic or cross-country
discussed in this section are published in ICAO traffic and increasing their availability allows for
Minimize Fuel Use & Reduce Emissions42. routing. RVSM has been in use for transatlantic
17
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
simultaneously reducing NOx emissions. New setting long term goals and standards that
aircraft designs improve aerodynamics and optimize overall environmental performance and
With regard to engines, there are complex for wing surfaces to reduce drag, and improved
emission interrelationships that make it difficult manufacturing techniques that will produce
to modify their design as a mitigation strategy smoother surfaces. New and improved metal
since it forces a tradeoff among individual alloys and composite materials are being
pollutants as well as between emissions and developed to reduce aircraft weight while
engines were introduced to reduce noise and performance. Significant improvement of control
improve fuel efficiency. They require higher systems has come about by replacing mechanical
engine pressure ratios, which increase engine and hydraulic systems with electrical systems,
temperatures, and hence generate more NOx. It which often reduce system weight while
has only been in the past 25 years that the providing more precise control. Improvements of
resulting NOx increase became a concern. FAA these systems and development of new systems
and other stakeholders have recently initiated an for enhanced flight stability will contribute to
effort to better understand and quantify these improved overall fuel efficiency.
18
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
Aircraft technology development and capital analytical tools to quantify emissions more
turnover follow relatively long cycles, which accurately, which are used to understand
limits the pace of fundamental changes in design. aviations contribution to local air quality
It takes approximately 10 to 15 years for fleet concerns and global emissions. These tools are
average fuel efficiency to equal the efficiency of developed on a foundation of research that FAA
the newest aircraft46. However, the ongoing has conducted both independently an in
evolutionary change in technology has realized conjunction with airports and other
substantial benefits over time. According to the organizations. The Emissions and Dispersion
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, in Modeling System (EDMS) has been developed
their report Aviation and the Global to quantify emissions from aircraft and other
Atmosphere47, aircraft fuel efficiency has airport emission sources. It is used routinely to
improved by 75 percent in the past 40 years assess the impact of airport expansion projects
through improvements in airframe design, engine and other operational changes. The System for
technology, and rising load factors. assessing Aviations Global Emissions (SAGE)
A comprehensive research program starts with a between emissions and noise due to changes in
clear and complete understanding of the effects technology and operational procedures.
19
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
NASA is the U.S. federal agency responsible for UEET project will develop and transfer to U.S.
development, and demonstration. One of the key will contribute to enabling a safe, secure, and
local environmental quality and the global system. This project is currently underway.
operational procedures. The goals of this Achieving research goals will allow the aviation
program are to reduce NOx emissions of future industry to significantly reduce its environmental
aircraft by 70 percent by 2007, and by 80 percent impact and begin to reduce its total emissions of
beyond 2007 using 1996 ICAO standards as a NOx and CO2. This takes time, however. As
baseline. They also intend to reduce CO2 noted earlier it takes 10 to 15 years for fleet
emissions of future aircraft by 25 percent and by average performance to achieve current new
50 percent for these same milestones using 2000 technology performance. To go from NASA
20
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
Aviation52, that concluded, while the goals of Looking to the future, FAA has a roadmap for
the federal research program are admirable and continuing to mitigate the environmental impacts
focused on the right issues, the schedule for of aviation. This includes continuing to improve
achieving the goals is unrealistic in view of its understanding of the role of aviation
shrinking research budgets. The report went on emissions on the environment. FAA is working
to call for further federal investment in engine with industry and other stakeholders to advance
research and technology development. the performance of the national and international
reducing emissions.
Aviation has progressively improved its
1
Population Timeline, http://www.pbs.org/kqed/population_bomb/danger/time.html.
2
http://www.atag.org/files/FAST%20FACTS-120341A.pdf
3
Ibid
4
http://www.iata.org
21
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
5
U.S. Department of Transportation, Bureau of Transportation Statistics, Transportation Indicators
http://www.bts.gov/publications/transportation_indicators/december_2002/ , December 2002.
6
U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration, FAA Long-Range Aerospace
Forecasts Fiscal Years 2015, 2020 and 2025, Office of Aviation Policy and Plans, FAA-APO-00-5,
http://apo.faa.gov/lng00/lng00.pdf, June 2000.
7
GDP - U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis, National Accounts Data
http://www.bea.gov/bea/dn1.htm; RTM - U.S. Department of Transportation, Bureau of Transportation
Statistics, Historical Air Traffic Statistics, http://www.bts.gov/oai/indicators/airtraffic/annual/1981-
2001.html; VMT U. S. Department of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration, Traffic Volume
Trends, December 2002 http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ohim/tvtw/02dectvt/tvtdec02.pdf.
8
Ibid. Table 9-15.
9
Wickrama, Upali, International Civil Aviation Organization, Committee on Environmental Protection,
Forecasting and Economic Analysis Support Group, Report of the FESG/CAEP/6 Traffic and Fleet
Forecast, copy of Figure 8, 2003 op. cit.
10
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, National Air Quality 2001 Status and Trends,
http://www.epa.gov/airtrends/aqtrnd01/, September 2002.
[http://www.epa.gov/air/airtrends/aqtrnd03/fr_table.html]
11
Waitz, I. A., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, private communication based on Boeing data,
November 2003.
12
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Average Annual Emissions, All Criteria Pollutants; Years
Including 1980, 1985, 1989-2001, http://www.epa.gov/ttnchie1/trends/index.html, February 2003.
13
Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990, Title I Provisions for Attainment and Maintenance of National
Ambient Air Quality Standards, Section 101(d)(1), November 15, 1990.
14
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 8-Hour Ground-level Ozone Designations,
http://www.epa.gov/ozonedesignations/statedesig.htm, May 6, 2004.
15
U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration, Enplanement Activity at Primary
Airports, http://www.faa.gov/arp/planning/stats/2002/CY02CommSerBoard.pdf , November 6, 2003.
16
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Classifications of Ozone Nonattainment Areas, op.cit.
17
U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration, Federal Highway Administration
(cooperating agency), Final Environmental Impact Statement for 9,000-Foot Fifth Runway and Associated
Projects: Hartsfield Atlanta International Airport, August 2001.
18
Illinois Environmental Protection Agency, Illinois 1999 Periodic Emissions Inventory And Milestone
Demonstration, December, 2001. The higher value for in the area inventory data in the table is for a typical
summer day, which is the ozone season and probably represents a worst case since it is the most active
period for aviation activity. The non-road data also is based on typical summer day. The lower value, which
is more representative for an annual value is from U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation
Administration, Final Environmental Assessment for the World Gateway Program and Other Capital
Improvements: Chicago OHare International Airport, Chicago, Illinois, June 21, 2002.
19
South Coast Air Quality Management District, Emissions by Category, 2001 Estimated Annual Average
Emissions, South Coast Air Basin.
http://www.arb.ca.gov/app/emsinv/emssumcat_query.php?F_DIV=0&F_YR=2001&F_AREA=AB&F_AB
=SC , 2001.
20
Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission, Dallas/Fort Worth Ozone Nonattainment Area
Emission Data, http://www.tnrcc.state.tx.us/air/aqp/ei/rsumdfw.htm, 1996 inventory data. Data includes all
airports in the nonattainment area including, DFW International Airport, Dallas Love Field, and Alliance
Airport.
21
U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration, Final Environmental Impact
Statement Runway 8L-26R and Associated Near-Term Master Plan Projects; George Bush Intercontinental
Airport/Houston, July 2000.
22
Compilation of data from the SIP inventories for New York and New Jersey provided by Mr. Raymond
Forde, Region 2, U. S. Environmental Protection Agency, June 16, 2004. Additional data provided by Mr.
Kevin McGarry, New York State Department of Conservation and Ms. Tonalee Key, New Jersey
Department of Environmental Protection.
22
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
23
Agyei, Kwame, Puget Sound Clean Air Agency, airport emissions calculated using EDMS 4.0; area non-
road and total emissions from 1999 Air Emission Inventory Summary spreadsheet, February 11, 2003.
24
Nonattainment area non-road and total NOx emissions, 68 FR 25431, May 12, 2003; Airport emissions
escalated from 1995 estimate by URS Greiner, Inc. (1997) based on 2000 data provided by Tony Petruska, U.S.
EPA.
25
Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, Massachusetts Periodic Emissions Inventories
1999, April 2003, for nonattainment area off-road emissions and total emissions, which are based on
summer day emissions. U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, Logan Airside Improvements Planning Projects: Boston Logan
International Airport, June 2002 for Logan Airport emissions, which are typical for an annual value.
26
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, National Air Pollutant Emission Trends, 1990-1998,
http://www.epa.gov/ttn/chief/trends/trends98/index.html, March 2000.
27
Ibid.
28
For NOx, aircraft represent anywhere from 60 to 80 percent of total airport emissions with the balance
coming from the other sources like ground support equipment and ground access vehicles. This is based on
a review of recent Environmental Impact Statements for eleven airports (ATL, BOS, CLE, DFW, IAD,
IAH, LAX, ORD, PTI, SFO, and STL).
29
For more information about the production of contrails by aircraft, see U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency, Aircraft Contrails Factsheet, http://www.epa.gov/otaq/regs/nonroad/aviation/contrails.pdf,
September 2000.
30
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks: 1990-
2001, http://yosemite.epa.gov/oar/globalwarming.nsf/UniqueKeyLookup/LHOD5MJQ6G/$File/2003-
final-inventory.pdf, April 15, 2003. Estimates are presented in units of terragrams of carbon dioxide
equivalents (Tg CO2 Eq.), which weight each gas (e.g., CO2 and NOx) by its Global Warming Potential, or
GWP, value.
31
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks: 1990-
2001, 2003 op.cit.
32
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Aviation and the Global Atmosphere, 1999.
33
Actual Emissions 1990-2001 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse
Gas Emissions and Sinks: 1990-2001, 2003 op.cit.
34
Forecast Emissions 2001-2025 calculated based on FAA long-range activity forecasts assuming a
constant rate of emissions from aircraft. The forecast is deemed conservative since it does not account for
improvements in aircraft energy efficiency over the next 20 years, which are deemed likely. Estimates are
presented in units of terragrams of carbon dioxide equivalents (Tg CO2 Eq.), which weight each gas (e.g.,
CO2 and NOx) by its Global Warming Potential, or GWP, value.
35
U.S. Department of Energy, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Transportation Energy Data Book: Edition
22, http://www-cta.ornl.gov/data/tedb22/Full_Doc_TEDB22.pdf, September 2002.
36
US Department of Transportation, Bureau of Transportation Statistics, National Transportation Statistics
2002 (BTS 02-08), Table 4-20: Energy Intensity of Passenger Modes (Btu per passenger-mile), page 281,
http://www.bts.gov/publications/national_transportation_statistics/2002/pdf/entire.pdf.
37
Ibid.
38
See FAR Part 33 Airworthiness Standards: Aircraft Engines
http://www.airweb.faa.gov/Regulatory_and_Guidance_Library/rgFAR.nsf/CurrentFARPart?OpenView&St
art=1&Count=200&Expand=10.
39
Colpin, J. and Altman, R., Dependable Power Reinvented, AIAA 2003-2882, AIAA-ICAS International
Air and Space Symposium and Exhibit: The Next 100 Years, July 14-17, 2003, Dayton, OH.
40
The use of market-based options for limiting or reducing greenhouse gas emissions from aviation may
also prove potentially useful applied to local air quality emissions.
41
Air Transport World, United says cutting APU runtime to save $12 million, ATW Online.com, February
10, 2003.
42
International Civil Aviation Organization, Circular 303 - Operational Opportunities to Minimize Fuel
Use & Reduce Emissions, February 2004.
23
Aviation & Emissions A Primer
43
U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration, National Airspace System
Operational Evolution Plan, December 2002
44
U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration, Final Regulatory Impact Analysis,
Final Regulatory Flexibility Determination, Unfunded Mandates and Trade Impact Assessment, Reduced
Vertical Separation Minimum Operations in United States Domestic Airspace, March 10, 2003
45
Drew, P., et al., Technology Drivers for 21st Century Transportation Systems, AIAA 2003-2909, AIAA-
ICAS International Air and Space Symposium and Exhibit: The Next 100 Years, 14-17 July 2003,
Dayton, OH
46
Waitz, I. A., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Aircraft, Gas Turbine Engines and Emissions
Primer, August 3, 2001.
47
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 1999 op.cit.
48
ICAO has established a Long-Term Technology Goals (LTTG) task group within Working Group 3 to
monitor and track future aircraft technologies that may demonstrate better environmental performance. The
LTTG will evaluate the prospects for setting emissions goals as targets for future technology performance.
49
National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NASA Aerospace Technology Enterprise Strategy
2003, http://www.aerospace.nasa.gov/strat_plan2003_low.pdf.
50
More information on the FAA-NASA Center of Excellence for Aircraft Noise and Aviation Emissions
Mitigation can be found at http://web.mit.edu/aeroastro/www/partner/.
51
Waitz, I. A., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2001 op. cit., estimates 22 to 37 years total time
from basic technology (e.g. NASA research) to significant fleet impact.
52
National Research Council, Division on Engineering and Physical Sciences, Aeronautics and Space
Engineering Board, Committee on Aeronautics Research and Technology for Environmental Compatibility,
For Greener Skies: Reducing Environmental Impacts of Aviation, available at
http://bob.nap.edu/html/greener_skies/notice.html, 2002.
24