Akin 2014
Akin 2014
Akin 2014
Classification of Mastocytosis in
2014
a, b
Cem Akin, MD, PhD *, Peter Valent, MD
KEYWORDS
Mastocytosis Diagnosis Classification World Health Organization c-kit
Tryptase
KEY POINTS
The diagnosis of mastocytosis in skin is established by presence of characteristic macu-
lopapular skin lesions and confirmed by skin biopsy.
Systemic mastocytosis should be diagnosed based on World Health Organization (WHO)
criteria. Presence of unexplained symptoms of mast cell activation should prompt the
pathologic investigation; however, the diagnosis cannot be based on symptoms alone.
According to WHO, mastocytosis is classified into 7 categories, with distinct clinicopath-
ologic and prognostic features that guide the therapy.
Tryptase level greater than 20 ng/mL is associated with systemic mastocytosis. However,
lower tryptase levels can be seen in patients with cutaneous mastocytosis, monoclonal
mast cell activation syndrome, and systemic mastocytosis with limited bone marrow
involvement.
More than 90% of adults and 80% of children with mastocytosis are detected to have
somatic gain of function mutations in c-kit. In most patients with systemic mastocytosis,
the c-kit mutation D816V is detectable.
pigmentosa (UP) or mastocytomas within the first year of life.57 Mastocytosis diag-
nosed in infancy has a good prognosis; there is no evidence of pathologic mast cell
accumulation in tissues other than skin (cutaneous mastocytosis), and most patients
experience resolution or fading of skin lesions by adolescence. In contrast, adult-
onset mastocytosis is almost always associated with bone marrow involvement and
has a persistent course. When mastocytosis is present in any extracutaneous tissue
(proved by biopsy) and shows multifocal or diffuse organ infiltration, it is termed sys-
temic mastocytosis (SM). SM is a heterogeneous group of disorders with variable
prognosis.8 Most patients have indolent SM (ISM), meaning that bone marrow exam-
ination shows abnormal mast cell collections but no other hematologic disease, and
there is no evidence of end-organ damage attributable to mast cell infiltration. Patients
with ISM have a comparable life expectancy with the general age-matched popula-
tion.911 Up to 20% of patients with SM may have a second bone marrow disease,
usually with myeloproliferative or myelodysplastic features. These patients have SM
associated with a hematologic nonmast cell clonal disease (SM-AHNMD). The prog-
nosis in these patients depends on the course of the AHNMD.10 A few patients
(approximately 5%) have evidence of end-organ damage caused by mast cell infiltra-
tion (aggressive SM [ASM]), in whom the disease follows an accelerated course
resembling a malignancy.12,13 Mast cell leukemia (MCL) is a rare subset of SM, which
is diagnosed when mast cells in bone marrow aspirate smears are greater than
20%.14,15 In several of these cases, circulating mast cells are found. Mast cell sar-
coma (MCS) and extracutaneous mastocytosis are extremely rare variants with solid
mast cell tumors, bearing malignant and benign pathologic features, respectively.16
DIAGNOSIS
7. The patient has been diagnosed with a myelodysplastic syndrome, acute myeloid
leukemia (AML), or chronic myelomonocytic leukemia (CMML), and the molecular
workup showed a c-kit mutation. In these cases, no histology was available or
the pathologist had overlooked SM.
The first step in all patients who are suspected to have mastocytosis is a thorough
skin examination to detect typical skin lesions (UP type). These lesions range in size
from a few millimeters to a few centimeters and have a brownish hyperpigmentation
along with a hyperemic component. The lesions are fixed and do not appear and
disappear at different locations like classic urticarial wheals. They are usually nonprur-
itic at baseline but may be triggered to urticate with friction, temperature changes, fe-
ver, emotional or physical stress, exercise, alcohol, and spicy foods. Stroking of the
lesion results in a wheal localized to the lesion (Darier sign); however, some patients
may lack this sign if they are on H1 antihistamines. Skin lesions in young children
may not be hyperpigmented and may show blistering in the first 3 years of life.
Although most experts can diagnose UP-like skin lesions on visual inspection, skin bi-
opsy may confirm the diagnosis of mastocytosis (in the skin) in suspected cases. In
these patients, skin biopsy shows a perivascular mast cell infiltrate in the upper
dermis. Some scattered eosinophils may be mixed with the infiltrate, but other inflam-
matory cells are typically absent. Increased melanin deposition is noted in epidermis.
Mastocytomas are typically solitary and larger lesions with histologic evidence of a
solid mast cell tumor. Physical irritation of mastocytomas may cause systemic symp-
toms, such as hives. Teleangiectasia macularis eruptive perstans is a rare manifesta-
tion of cutaneous mastocytosis, in which the skin has flat teleangiactatic macules in a
generalized distribution. Skin lesions in adults generally spare sun-exposed areas,
such as face and hands, and tend to aggregate in areas prone to irritation, such as up-
per thighs and axillae. However, it is not uncommon to have lesions on scalp, face, and
neck in young children.
After visualization of skin lesions, the patient is said to have mastocytosis in the skin,
and a decision has to be made whether a bone marrow biopsy is necessary to look for
evidence (criteria) of systemic mastocytosis or to classify the patient as having cuta-
neous mastocytosis if bone marrow histopathology is normal or criteria for SM are not
fulfilled. A simple guide for this decision is the patients age. Children in whom the skin
lesions start in the first 2 years of life rarely have bone marrow involvement, and these
children are presumed to have cutaneous mastocytosis. A bone marrow biopsy in chil-
dren is not routinely recommended unless the child has a persistently high serum tryp-
tase level (or shows an increasing trend in serial measurements) or has abnormal
complete blood count or liver or spleen enlargement. In contrast, most patients with
adult-onset disease have evidence of bone marrow involvement when skin lesions
are detected, and therefore, a bone marrow biopsy is recommended to establish
the diagnosis of SM, to assess bone marrow mast cell burden, and to rule out pres-
ence of other hematologic disease.
Therefore, a bone marrow biopsy is recommended in adult patients presenting with
skin lesions of UP type as well as those presenting with clinical scenarios 2 to 5, out-
lined earlier. Biopsy of tissues other than bone marrow is not recommended to estab-
lish a diagnosis, because bone marrow is always involved, and the histopathologic
aspects of mast cell disease are not well studied in other tissues. Gastrointestinal bi-
opsies are sometimes needed to establish the cause of symptoms such as diarrhea
and malabsorption, whether they are caused by mast cell infiltration or simply caused
by systemic effects of mast cell mediator release, and a subset of patients were first
diagnosed on gastrointestinal biopsies by astute pathologists.17
210 Akin & Valent
Major Criterion
Multifocal dense aggregates of mast cells with more than 15 cells per aggregate in an
extracutaneous tissue. The tissue of choice in diagnosis is bone marrow. Both a bi-
opsy and an aspirate should be obtained. Biopsy should be of good quality without
significant crush or bleeding artifact. Formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded bone marrow
biopsy sections should be stained for tryptase, CD117 and CD25 in addition to routine
hematoxylin-eosin stains. In normal bone marrow, mast cells are distributed intersti-
tially and singly, with a predominantly round shape. Although even a small clustering
of mast cells should raise suspicion for mastocytosis, to meet the major criterion, the
clusters should contain at least 15 mast cells. Mast cell clusters in mastocytosis occur
paratrabecularly, perivascularly, or interstitially. Sometimes, a spindle-shaped infil-
trate is observed to line the bone trabeculae. Eosinophils are frequently found in
increased numbers around the infiltrate. Some samples may have a polytypic lympho-
cytic infiltrate around or within the lesions.21,22 Patients with smoldering or ASM or
MCL often have a high degree of involvement in bone marrow biopsy (>30%), with
associated marked fibrosis. The cells have spindle shapes, oval and eccentric nuclei
with pale cytoplasm in hematoxylin-eosin staining. Tryptase stain confirms the nature
of the infiltrate as mast cells.
Minor Criteria
1. More than 25% of the cells have morphologic abnormalities such as spindle
shapes, hypogranulation, eccentric nuclei, cytoplasmic projections, and multilobed
Box 1
Diagnostic criteria of SM
Major
Multifocal dense aggregates of mast cells with more than 15 cells per aggregate in an
extracutaneous tissue
Minor
1. Greater than 25% of mast cells have morphologic abnormalities such as spindle shapes,
cytoplasmic projections, hypogranulation (see text)
2. Expression of CD25 with or without CD2 by mast cells
3. Detection of a codon 816 c-kit mutation by a sensitive technique in lesional tissue or
peripheral blood
4. Serum baseline tryptase greater than 20 ng/mLa
a
Not valid if there is AHNMD.
Data from Refs.1820; see text for more detailed discussion; major 11 minor, or 3 minor, criteria
are required.
Diagnosis and Classification of Mastocytosis 211
or clefted nuclei.23,24 Normal bone marrow mast cells have round cytoplasm, with a
centrally located nucleus and dense granulation. In bone marrow aspirate smears,
mast cells are usually located in or near bone spicules. The percentage of mast
cells in bone marrow aspirate smears has been shown to correlate with advanced
mastocytosis and prognosis. If mast cell percentage is greater than 20% in an as-
picular area, the diagnosis is MCL. Mast cells of less than 5% are generally seen in
ISM, whereas mast cells between 5% and 19% signify an intermediate prog-
nosis,23 which is often the case in ASM, and termed ASM in transformation
(ASM-t), because these cases often progress to MCL.15
2. Mast cells aberrantly express CD25 and CD2.25,26 Normal or reactive mast cells
usually do not express these markers. CD25 is more sensitive and specific than
CD2.27,28 Expression of these markers can be detected by immunohistochemistry
(IHC) or flow cytometry. IHC has the advantage of being applicable to archived
paraffin-embedded samples.29 Serial sections should be stained for tryptase to
detect coexpression of CD25 in mast cells. CD2 staining does not always yield pos-
itive results, especially in advanced disease. Flow cytometry is also a sensitive and
reliable method of detecting aberrant mast cell marker expression, if it is performed
in reference centers with expertise on this technique. Because the mast cell per-
centage of the marrow aspirate is usually low (in many cases <1%), special gating
techniques and acquisition of many events (at least 500,000 or preferably higher)
are required for an accurate analysis.26,30
3. Using a sensitive technique, c-kit point mutation at codon 816 is detectable in
peripheral blood or lesional tissue.3134 Detailed accounts of c-kit mutations in
mastocytosis in pathogenesis of mastocytosis and their roles in altered signal
transduction are discussed in other articles by Cruse and colleagues, Arock and
colleagues in this issue. D816V c-kit mutation is detectable in more than 80% of
patients with SM in bone marrow mast cells34,35 and in approximately 40% of chil-
dren with cutaneous mastocytosis in lesional skin.36 Analysis of peripheral blood
may yield false-negative results in most commercially available tests, because of
the somatic nature of the mutation, although recently introduced polymerase chain
reactionbased sensitive tests approach the sensitivity in bone marrow sorted
mast cells.33 Mutation may be confined to mast cells in patients with indolent dis-
ease, whereas it may involve multiple other myeloid and even lymphoid lineages in
patients with advanced disease.35,37,38 Patients with multilineage involvement were
shown to have a higher risk of progression to aggressive mastocytosis and carry a
poorer prognosis. c-kit D816V mutation renders the mast cells resistant to the
currently available tyrosine kinase inhibitors, including matinib.3941
4. Serum tryptase greater than 20 ng/mL.4246 Normal median tryptase level in the
healthy population is 5 ng/mL. Mast cells are the major source of the neutral pro-
tease tryptase. Basophils and myeloid progenitors also produce smaller amounts
of this enzyme. Therefore, tryptase levels may be increased in other myeloid
neoplastic processes and do not count as a minor criterion in SM-AHNMD.47
Commercially available tryptase assay uses an enzyme-linked immunosorbent
assay method to measure a combination of mature tryptases and protryptases.
Mature tryptase (b tryptase) is stored in mast cell granules and is released after a
mast cell degranulation or anaphylactic event, with peak levels found in approxi-
mately 1 hour after the degranulation. b Tryptase levels are undetectable in sera
from healthy individuals. In contrast, protryptases (mainly encoded by a tryptase)
are targeted to cell membrane and constitutively secreted out of the mast cells.
Therefore, the total tryptase level at baseline reflects a (pro) tryptase and correlates
with total body mast cell burden. A basal tryptase level less than 20 ng/mL does not
212 Akin & Valent
rule out mastocytosis, whereas slight tryptase increases greater than 20 ng/mL can
be seen in individuals other than those with mastocytosis (including those with
renal disease, myeloid neoplasms, and idiopathic) and even in apparently healthy
controls. Therefore, tryptase levels alone should not be used as the sole criterion
to diagnose mastocytosis.
Some patients with mast cell activation symptoms and lower tryptase levels may not
meet the full WHO criteria for the diagnosis of mastocytosis but may have CD251
mast cells in bone marrow biopsies or have the c-kit D816V mutation detectable.4850
These patients meeting only 1 or 2 minor criteria are termed to have monoclonal mast
cell activation syndrome (MMAS). It is not clear whether patients with MMAS progress
to full-blown mastocytosis with time.
A rare histopathologic variant of SM termed well-differentiated SM (WDSM) is char-
acterized by aggregates of mast cells with round shapes and fully granulated
morphology with no CD25 expression.51 Aberrant CD30 expression may be a useful
marker for these patients, who generally have childhood-onset mastocytosis with
skin lesions and progress to have adult-onset systemic disease.52,53 Most patients
with WDSM do not carry the D816V c-kit mutation and thus may respond to imatinib.54
The WDSM morphology may be found in patients with ISM but can sometimes also
be found in patients with advanced SM requiring therapy. Therefore also, the term
WDSM should be used as a descriptive appendix to the final diagnosis, for example,
ISM-WDSM, ASM-WDSM, or ASM with WDSM morphology. Sometimes, it is nearly
impossible to differentiate between WDSM and reactive mast cell hyperplasia.
CLASSIFICATION
The WHO classification divides mastocytosis into 7 categories (Box 2). A major check-
point in classification of mastocytosis is to determine whether the patient has cuta-
neous mastocytosis or SM. This determination correlates with the age of onset of
disease and is defined by histopathologic criteria, as discussed earlier. If a diagnosis
of SM is made, the next step is to classify the disease into 1 of 4 categories of SM.
1. ISM. Most patients with adult-onset disease fall into this category. Patients with
ISM satisfy the WHO diagnostic criteria for SM but do not have other hematologic
Box 2
Classification of mastocytosis
Cutaneous mastocytosis
ISM
Smoldering SMa
SM-AHNMD
ASM
MCL
MCS
Extracutaneous mastocytoma
a
The smoldering subtype of SM has recently been accepted as a separate category by the
consensus group, but was not implemented as such in the WHO classification of 2008.
Diagnosis and Classification of Mastocytosis 213
SUMMARY
The current diagnostic criteria and classification of mastocytosis are well validated by
clinical studies and have been shown to correlate with prognosis and to guide in the
selection of therapy. As new knowledge is gained regarding clinical course, molecular
pathogenesis and therapy for disease, evidence-based revisions to improve the cur-
rent criteria should be considered by international consensus. Using the guidelines in
this article, it should be straightforward to establish a diagnosis of mastocytosis in
most cases. Cases with low mast cell burden or uncertain diagnostic interpretation
should be referred to centers of expertise. In Europe, centers of excellence have
been organized under the umbrella of the European Competence Network on Masto-
cytosis (http://www.ecnm.net). Although no similar organization exists in the United
States, there are several centers of excellence, including the Brigham and Womens
Hospital, Stanford, Mayo Clinic, MD Anderson, and National Institutes of Health. It
is the hope for the future that these centers will develop and merge as a robust collab-
orative competence network in the United States. The patient support groups, such as
the Mastocytosis Society, also provide valuable education and organize yearly meet-
ings (http://www.tmsforacure.org/) and should thereby support academic studies and
networking in this emerging field of science.
REFERENCES
mutations show different inhibitor sensitivity profiles than wild-type kinases and
those with regulatory-type mutations. Blood 2002;99:1741.
41. Akin C, Brockow K, DAmbrosio C, et al. Effects of tyrosine kinase inhibitor
STI571 on human mast cells bearing wild-type or mutated c-kit. Exp Hematol
2003;31:686.
42. Schwartz LB. Clinical utility of tryptase levels in systemic mastocytosis and
associated hematologic disorders. Leuk Res 2001;25:553.
43. Schwartz LB. Diagnostic value of tryptase in anaphylaxis and mastocytosis. Im-
munol Allergy Clin North Am 2006;26:451.
44. Schwartz LB, Irani AM. Serum tryptase and the laboratory diagnosis of systemic
mastocytosis. Hematol Oncol Clin North Am 2000;14:641.
45. Schwartz LB, Metcalfe DD, Miller JS, et al. Tryptase levels as an indicator of
mast-cell activation in systemic anaphylaxis and mastocytosis. N Engl J Med
1987;316:1622.
46. Schwartz LB, Sakai K, Bradford TR, et al. The alpha form of human tryptase is
the predominant type present in blood at baseline in normal subjects and is
elevated in those with systemic mastocytosis. J Clin Invest 1995;96:2702.
47. Sperr WR, El-Samahi A, Kundi M, et al. Elevated tryptase levels selectively clus-
ter in myeloid neoplasms: a novel diagnostic approach and screen marker in
clinical haematology. Eur J Clin Invest 2009;39:914.
48. Akin C, Scott LM, Kocabas CN, et al. Demonstration of an aberrant mast-cell
population with clonal markers in a subset of patients with idiopathic anaphy-
laxis. Blood 2007;110:2331.
49. Akin C, Valent P, Metcalfe DD. Mast cell activation syndrome: proposed diag-
nostic criteria. J Allergy Clin Immunol 2010;126:1099.
50. Valent P, Akin C, Escribano L, et al. Standards and standardization in mastocy-
tosis: consensus statements on diagnostics, treatment recommendations and
response criteria. Eur J Clin Invest 2007;37:435.
51. Akin C, Fumo G, Yavuz AS, et al. A novel form of mastocytosis associated
with a transmembrane c-kit mutation and response to imatinib. Blood 2004;
103:3222.
52. Morgado JM, Perbellini O, Johnson RC, et al. CD30 expression by bone marrow
mast cells from different diagnostic variants of systemic mastocytosis. Histopa-
thology 2013;63:780.
53. Teodosio C, Garcia-Montero AC, Jara-Acevedo M, et al. Mast cells from different
molecular and prognostic subtypes of systemic mastocytosis display distinct
immunophenotypes. J Allergy Clin Immunol 2010;125:719.
54. Alvarez-Twose I, Gonzalez P, Morgado JM, et al. Complete response after ima-
tinib mesylate therapy in a patient with well-differentiated systemic mastocyto-
sis. J Clin Oncol 2012;30:e126.
55. Akin C. Anaphylaxis and mast cell disease: what is the risk? Curr Allergy Asthma
Rep 2010;10:34.
56. Brockow K, Jofer C, Behrendt H, et al. Anaphylaxis in patients with mastocyto-
sis: a study on history, clinical features and risk factors in 120 patients. Allergy
2008;63:226.
57. Gulen T, Hagglund H, Dahlen B, et al. High prevalence of anaphylaxis in pa-
tients with systemic mastocytosisa single-centre experience. Clin Exp Allergy
2014;44:121.
58. van der Veer E, van der Goot W, de Monchy JG, et al. High prevalence of frac-
tures and osteoporosis in patients with indolent systemic mastocytosis. Allergy
2012;67:431.
218 Akin & Valent