Contemporary Culture Fueling Corruption: Case For Kenya
Contemporary Culture Fueling Corruption: Case For Kenya
Contemporary Culture Fueling Corruption: Case For Kenya
1
Assignment
Endemic corruption has been very difficult to eradicate in Kenya. Does Kenyan culture
contribute to corruption, and how can it be changed? With the help of actual examples,
explain your answer by reference to any model of culture with which you are familiar
1. Executive summary
Endemic corruption continues to deny Kenya her rightful place in the world responsible
and progressive nations. The vice has been a drain to the national coffers; undermined
provision of essential services such as healthcare and education; led to collapse of key sectors
and subsectors; led to loss of many lives as a result of flowed election; as well cost the
country enormous goodwill and standing in the eyes of international in the community of
nations.
In this paper, I have sort to link the growing cases of corruption to underlying cultural
shifts including materialism, individualism, moral relativism, tribalism, attitude towards state
resources, prosperity gospel etc. In my view the urban elite are slowly breaking from the
influences of their ethnic traditions and embracing cosmopolitan outlooks and attitudes. It is
Fighting corruption is an absolute and urgent imperative. This paper highlights some of
the campaign angles needed to combat the growing specter of corruption. These approaches
2
2. Introduction
According to the Report of the Common Wealth Expert Group on Good Governance
and the Elimination of Corruption, in the book Fighting Corruption – promoting Good
defined as the abuse of public office for private gain. This definition has been encaged
because of the widened scope of corruption to cover the abuse of all offices of trust for
private gain, whether in the public or private sectors. Corruption manifest itself in various
ways and it is useful to distinguish between Personal Corruption (motivated by personal gain)
and Political Corruption (motivated by political gain). A further distinction can be made
Legal definitions of corruption tend to stress behaviors that are crimes or actions that
involve the abuse of trust or the "improper influencing of people in positions of authority"
(i.e. blackmail or bribery). But morality and trust are social variables that cannot easily be
prescribed or defined by law. While there are clearly examples of outright corruption which
might include larceny and grand theft by public officials, there are also many shades of grey.
Nor is it necessarily the case that "corruption = immorality," at least in the public mind. For
example, tax evasion or deliberate failure to declare income may be a crime from a legal
point of view, but in countries where the government itself is widely perceived as corrupt and
parasitical, such action may be seen - rightly or wrongly - as a legitimate act of resistance
The English word "corruption" often fails to do justice to the variety of meanings and
practices that are subsumed under that label. Gifts are an interesting case in point. What
distinguishes gift-giving from bribery is not the transaction itself but the morality of the
exchange; the social context and ideas about reciprocity that govern such transactions - and
3
the relationships that they create. In much of India, China and Latin America, for example, an
entire moral economy and way of relating to power can be glimpsed from the study of
corruption. Narratives of corruption are often the means by which, and through which, people
Endemic corruption has indeed been difficult to eradicate and seem to be on the
increase by the day instead. Kenyan culture defined as “An integrated pattern of human
knowledge, belief, and behavior that depends upon the capacity for symbolic thought and
social learning; or the set of shared attitudes, values, goals, and practices that characterizes
an institution, organization or group” combined with low risk of detection and punishment;
glaring opportunity for theft; and low salaries have conspired to turn Kenya into pariah state
only comparable to Nigeria and only slightly ahead of war tone countries of Somalia and
DR Congo. In 2009, the country was placed 146th out of 180 countries surveyed, according
measure of domestic and public sector corruption. Kenya recorded a CPI score of 2.2
indicating high perception of bribery. Countries are measured on a scale from 0 (perceived
The country tied with crisis-laden Zimbabwe and performed poorer than her East
African neighbors. Tanzania was ranked 126 with a CPI score of 2.6 while Uganda was at
position 130 scoring 2.5. The CPI measures the perceived levels of public sector corruption in
a given country and is a composite index, drawing on 13 different expert and business
surveys. A total of seven reports were used to assess Kenya's performance. It is instructive
that 95% of those interviewed thought Kenya was either corrupt or very corrupt.
Past kneejerk attempts to fight corruption have been at best token and at worst a
4
fight corruption including Governance, Justice, Law and Order Sector (GJLOS), Kenya Anti
Corruption Commission (KACC), parliamentary committees (e.g PAC, PIC), Kenya Police,
etc seem not to have had any major impact on corruption or public perception of it. The tussle
between parliament and the executive over reappointment of Justice Aaron Ringera as the
Executive Director of KACC raised questions of procedure, transparency and favoritism. Past
attempts to investigate and prosecute grand corruption have bore no fruit leading to
Endemic corruption in Kenya has been the subject of various books (Mute 2001;
Kidombo 2004; Sihanya 2005; Mati 2007). Anti-corruption has become an ‘industry’ of non-
governmental and governmental organizations well funded by donors and the tax payer, with
the former head of Kenya’s Anti-Corruption Commission, Justice Aaron Ringera, earning
Throughout the country’s short life, numerous scandals have been unearthed the
most notorious being the infamous Goldenberg and Anglo-Leasing scandals. With the
deluge of scandals the question that bothers many commentators and observers is "where
did the rain start beating us? In the 1970s the late Tanzania President Julius Nyerere
unflatteringly referred to Kenya as a man eats man society. Kenyan officialdom protested
then, but today, even Nyerere’s fiercest critics must admit that he was right. Corruption
invaded Kenya country in its infancy; almost immediately after independence the political
aggrandisement and not as positions of trust. The story is told by Philip Ochieng and Karimi
in their book The Kenyatta Succession where President Jomo Kenyatta chided Bildad
Kaggia, a freedom fighter, for not using his position to amass wealth.
5
Mega corruption started taking root after the recommendations of the [in]famous
Ndegwa Commission. Named after its Chairperson Phillip Ndegwa, The Commission
recommended among other things that Civil Servants be allowed to engage in business.
This was at a time of centralised economic governance when Government was the biggest
business partner and Civil Servants with insider information had a field day. They became
what PLO Lumumba calls “New warlords of corruption”. Indeed, it is instructive that the
senior Civil Servants of those early years and even their latter-day successors despite their
poor/low pay are some of the richest Kenyans; obviously not from business but
The abject abandon with which corruption was embraced in Kenya became blatant
in the 1977 and 1978 when Senior Government officials openly participated in smuggling
Ugandan coffee through lake Victoria’s Sio Port, Usenge and overland at Chepkube in
Western Kenya. Nobody was punished for these crimes and the culture of impunity had
arrived. When Daniel Moi took office nothing changed. First, because the players remained
the same and the culture of disrespect for public property and impunity was alive and well.
Culture is broadly defined as the set of shared attitudes, values, goals, and
lifestyle. For purposes of this paper, I have chosen to treat Kenya’s urban elite as separate
“cultural community” distinct from their rural Kenya cousins. Even though a Kikuyu and a
Kenyan of Indian origin may speak different mother tongues, eat different “home-cooked
6
meals” and worship at different temples; their contemporary view of money, material
possession, morality etc though may differ in intensity are in many ways on average similar.
This culture is informed by such factors as colonialism and its attendant discriminatory
flock according to their tithe contribution and faith, and forgiveness; Indo-china concepts of
gifting, reciprocity and materialism; Pastoralist economics of “grazing to the ground” then
tribalism/racism etc.
a. Materialism
Most people seek after what they do not possess and are thus enslaved by the very
things they want to acquire. William R. Bradford -Anwar El-Sadat. This great, though
disastrous, culture can only change as we begin to stand off and see... the inveterate
materialism which has become the model for cultures around the world. Materialism is when
a person must have all the physical items they desire, such as high end clothes and jewelry or
“There is absolutely no doubt that the so-called ‘First’ World has exported up to now
and continues to export its spiritual toxic waste that contaminates the peoples of other
7
Materialism in Kenya manifests itself in form of grand architecture, multiple car
ownership, expensive dressing, etc. Growing appetite for housing has driven the price of land
and houses in middle-income neighborhoods to an ever high. Banks have taken advantage of
this phenomenon by providing ready mortgages, instant car loans, credit cards. The
competitive nature of materialism has pushed a large section of the population to engage in
embezzlement and outright stealing a clerk in the Ministry of Lands owns a block of flats in
Kayole, drives a Mercedes Benze 200, and lives in Kileleshwa on a government salary of Ksh
value, however large or small in value. The gift can be money or something else of value
gift should be a voluntary free transfer not requiring any form of compensation or
reciprocity. A voluntary gift is neither a gratuity nor a tip, provided as full or partial
compensation for some personal service (such as restaurant tipping), or a bribe, provided or
A transfer of value with the appearance of a gift might arise in a number of motives
8
extortion by agents in which typically money, or some other item of value, is exchanged for
The key feature of corruption, demonstrated in the form of bribery, is that an agent
accepts something of value from a third party to act contrary to the interest(s) of the agent's
principal(s). Public employees in democracies and private enterprise employees are agents.
Their principals are the citizens or the owners, respectively. With certain exceptions, it is
not generally possible under this definition to bribe a principal. Some transactions with a
hereditary sovereign, as a principal, might still be corrupt or unethical on some other basis.
Gifts and entertainment expenses are important even in advanced market economies.
“about-turn” resulted in Africans taking over the reins of government and the attendant
control of resources and contracts. The Indian community and their culture of gifting and
reciprocity went on overdrive. African civil servants found themselves deluged by gifts of
shocking magnitude ranging from houses, expensive cars, holiday tickets, cash etc
c) Power distance
Hofstede’s Power distance Index measures the extent to which the less powerful
members of organizations and institutions (like the family) accept and expect that power is
distributed unequally. This represents inequality (more versus less), but defined from below,
not from above. It suggests that a society’s level of inequality is endorsed by the followers as
Compared to Arab countries where the power distance is very high (80) and Austria where it
very low (11), Germany is somewhat in the middle. Germany does not have a large gap
9
between the wealthy and the poor, but have a strong belief in equality for each citizen.
On the other hand, the power distance in the United States scores a 40 on the cultural scale.
The United States exhibits a more unequal distribution of wealth compared to German
society. As the years go by it seems that the distance between the ‘have’ and ‘have-nots’
Kenya’s power distance index of 64 means it is more unequal than the USA but less
so than Arab countries. The higher the PDI, the less ordinary citizens and subordinates are
d) Individualism
Individualism is defined as: (1) a doctrine that the interests of the individual are or
ought to be ethically paramount; (2) : the conception that all values, rights, and duties
the individual and stressing individual initiative, action, and interests; also : conduct or
responding to the specific demands of the citizens. Government is not created to establish a
another actor in commerce that competes for and distributes resources such as tax dollars,
patronage jobs, contracts and zoning decisions. In this way participating in government is a
career choice that one makes much like any other profession. As a professional, one is
expected to make a decent living. Therefore a certain amount of corruption is acceptable and
tolerated, since government officials have traditionally been unpaid or under paid.
10
In Kenya, the phenomenon of individualism is best exemplified the neglect or
hospitals, schools, universities, the Kenyan elite are sending their children to expensive
private providers.
e) Moral Relativism
Moral relativism is the view that ethical standards, morality, and positions of right or
wrong are culturally based and therefore subject to a person's individual choice. We can all
decide what is right for ourselves. You decide what's right for you, and I'll decide what's right
for me. Moral relativism says, "It's true for me, if I believe it."
Bhikkhu Bodhi, an American Buddhist monk, wrote: “By assigning value and
spiritual ideals to private subjectivity, the materialistic world view, threatens to undermine
any secure objective foundation for morality. The result is the widespread moral degeneration
that we witness today. To counter this tendency, mere moral exhortation is insufficient. If
justifying scheme but must be embedded in a more comprehensive spiritual system which
grounds morality in a transpersonal order. Religion must affirm, in the clearest terms, that
morality and ethical values are not mere decorative frills of personal opinion, not subjective
superstructure, but intrinsic laws of the cosmos built into the heart of reality.”
Moral relativism has steadily been accepted as the primary moral philosophy of
morality. While these "Judeo-Christian" standards continue to be the foundation for civil law,
most people hold to the concept that right or wrong are not absolutes, but can be determined
by each individual. Morals and ethics can be altered from one situation, person, or
11
circumstance to the next. Essentially, moral relativism says that anything goes, because life is
ultimately without meaning. Words like "ought" and "should" are rendered meaningless. In
this way, moral relativism makes the claim that it is morally neutral. (All-about God News;
www.allaboutgod.com )
In Kenya moral relativism has given elite Christians and Muslims alike a blank
cheque to engage in all manner of corrupt practices without the risk being ostracized by the
community. Justification for search practices often include: – rampant misuse of taxes by
government, previous office holder stole a lot more, it is for the benefit of our community.
Under a weak legal system such as Kenya’s the negation of universal good and evil
through creeping moral-relativism is probably the single largest contributor to the current
state of affairs.
f) Prosperity gospel
Prosperity theology (also known as prosperity doctrine, the health and wealth gospel, or
the prosperity gospel) is a religious belief found among "tens of millions” of Christians
centered on the notion that God provides material prosperity for those he favors. It has been
defined by the belief that "Jesus blesses believers with riches” or more specifically as the
teaching that "believers have a right to the blessings of health and wealth and that they can
obtain these blessings through positive confessions of faith and the 'sowing of seeds'
In the words of journalist Hanna Rosin, the prosperity gospel "is not a clearly defined
denomination, but a strain of belief that runs through the Pentecostal Church and a
It arose in the United States after World War II championed by Oral Roberts and became
12
particularly popular in the decade of the 1990s.More recently, the theology has been
exported to less prosperous areas of the world, with mixed results. Prosperity theology is
most commonly found within the charismatic and Pentecostal traditions of Christianity
gospel beliefs is more common amongst charismatics than the practice of speaking in
tongues. The teaching is based on interpretations of certain Biblical verses such as:
Malachi 3:10 - "Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse, so that there may be food in
My house, and test Me now in this,' says the LORD of hosts, 'if I will not open for
you the windows of heaven and pour out for you a blessing until it overflows" (New
American Standard Bible).
Deuteronomy 8:18 - "But you shall remember the Lord your God, for it is He who is
giving you power to make wealth, that He may confirm His covenant which He swore
to your fathers, as it is this day" (New American Standard Bible). [7]
John 10: 10 - "I have come that they may have life, and that they may have it more
abundantly."
3 John 2-4 - "Beloved, I pray that you may prosper in all things and be in health, just
as your soul prospers."
g) Instant gratification
America, our economy, our markets and our future as a world power. The narrow thinking
represented by Cramer's Mad Money world, Tolle's spiritual fantasyland and the USA Today
poll are more dangerous than massive deficits, Washington corruption, Wall Street greed,
global warming and the war on terror because short-term thinking is eating away at the soul
These gratifications are actually a hangover of the very old Persian system of Nazrana
that marked the pre-Mughal, Mughal and subsequent periods in the entire sub continent.
Every seeker of favours from an Emperor, his Emirs or other officials was expected to offer a
13
tribute to a superior and these were given and accepted with grace and absolutely no sense of
shame.
g. Mali ya Umma
When asked by a reporter why he robbed banks, a famous American bank robber Willie
Sutton is alleged to have replied: "Because that is where the money is." Over to Kenyan
leaders, why are you corrupt? I guess the answer is: "Because public wealth/property belongs
to no one in particular!" says Columnist: James Shikwati in his Feature Article Corruption in
Africa: Not in My Name! Wed, 28 Jan 2009 carried in Modern Ghana blog
(modernghana.com).
flourished during the colonial times when ordinary Kenyans and by extension Africans felt
disconnected from governance systems and would sabotage all that symbolized authority.
Vandalizing public property was part of the fight against colonialism for those who could not
get to the bush to confront the Whiteman. Driven by the ideology of "it is our turn to eat," the
founding fathers at independence engaged in a plundering orgy that left the common citizenry
bewildered. The resultant effect was the perpetuation of the culture of sabotage which
The generation that grew up when destruction of mzungu (Whiteman) property could
turn one into a village hero is currently running the affairs of government. It is currently
heroic to steal from government. Wired deep in the minds of leadership elites is the erroneous
belief that government does not exist to serve the interest of Kenyans but that of others
(perhaps Western powers). A number of Kenyan leaders are graduates from public
universities where destroying toilet sinks, bathroom taps, and fire-fighting equipment
14
amongst others was seen to be a 'normal' affair. To them, pinching a few billion shillings
from public coffers is not stealing anyone's goat, for the goat belongs to all of us!
h. Tribalism
Titus Naikuni is CEO of Kenya Airways; he recently made a speech condemning the
practice of tribalism. When describing the potential damage tribalism poses to Kenya's
economic prospects he stated, " When people start looking at each other from a tribal point
of view, and you are not employed because of your own credentials, then it starts affecting
Tribalism and corruption long have been singled out as having the most devastating
effect in slowing Kenya’s ascendance to a modern society. Extreme form of tribal politics
has led political assassinations, rigging of elections, election related violence. Indeed
Kenya’s economic growth graph mirrors political activity and elections. The current
impasse on who becomes the managing director of New KCC is driven by tribalism. That
this happens at a time when the dairy industry is saddled with challenges of glut goes to
Those who by virtue of their positions of privilege plunder public funds find ready
protection from politicians, journalists and trade unionists who hail from their tribes. “We
War against corruption in Kenya will not be worn until tribalism is tamed.
3. Fighting Corruption
The fight against corruption in Kenya calls for concerted and extra-ordinary efforts
15
enforcement and legislation; corporate governance and ethics; strengthening of internal
redirect public opinion and correcting flawed stereotypes that perpetuate corruption.
On the cultural front, Kenya needs to confront entrenched and emerging trends,
moral dilemmas, lifestyles, schools of thought, attitudes and beliefs that grease the wheels
of corruption as seen above. As this is essentially a competition over the hearts and minds
of Kenyans, it will require the complete buy-in and active support of opinion shapers
business, investment, economic growth, houses of warship, way of life, image, and political
stability will go a long way in debunking the growing the myth that corruption contributes to
personal well being. Without doubt corruption has a negative impact on Socio-economic,
political and institutional domains of the body politic of Kenya and other African states. Its
impact is not only limited to the size of the payments involved, but the very process of
extorting and giving bribes has distortionary effects that are socio-economic and political,
disproportionate impact on the poor and disadvantaged. It undermines the integrity of all
involved and damages the fabric of the organizations to which they belong. The reality that
laws making corrupt practices criminal may not always be enforced is no justification for
16
accepting corrupt practices. To fight corruption in all its forms is simply the right thing to
do.
There are many reasons why it is in any company's business interest to ensure that it
does not engage in corrupt practices. All companies, large and small, are vulnerable and the
potential for damage to them is considerable. Some of the key reasons for avoiding
involvement in corrupt practices are: legal and reputational risks, financial cost, security,
c) Economic case
Corruption slows down investment and economic growth, the fact that bribery
contracts are unlike regular contracts that are enforceable. Corruption also raises the cost of
doing business as officials may introduce certain conditions to ensure that they get bribes,
through delays and unnecessary requirements; discourages new ideas and innovations; leads
to the decline in real per capita incomes, inflation, a widening budget and balance of payment
deficits, and declining official production and exports. Other negative consequences of
corruption include: promotion of inequality among firms; leads to a reduction in the quality
of products; diversion of funds from investment and other production activities. Politically,
corruption leads to a loss of faith on the part of the people and thus its legitimacy and power
with equality and democratic values are undermined. It strengthens bad governance, through
the absence of the rule of Law, respect for human rights, no accountability, and transparency.
Corruption has also led to massive neglect of the social sector, which has substantially
decreased the quality of human resources in African states over the years. The provision of
educational and health opportunities have been limited, this impacting negatively on the
17
reduction in Africa States. Donor’s creditability has also been eroded. There have been
instances in which donors have been critical as to the commitment of Africa State in handling
corruption in their respective states. Corruption has also led to the weakness of structure and
mitigated when Africa states are committed to ensure Good Governance. Existing structures
and the national Campaigns against corruption intensified in African Countries. Unless and
until Africans are committed, corruption is the cancer that will eat up all the socio-economic
and political achievements of the continent and Africa might not see the light of day.
d) Religious Case
Most religions in Kenya in Kenya prohibit corruption and its attendant accumulation
of wealth. In Exodus 6:15, The bible says, “Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe blinds those
who see and twists the words of the righteous”. Micah 3: 15 says, “You will plant but not
harvest; you will press olives but not use the oil on yourselves, you will crush grapes but
e) Professional case
misappropriation of client money, infringement of patents and copy rights are conspiring to
give Kenyan professionals a bad name. Soiled reputation will mean leads to reduced flow of
18
Where rent seeking proves more lucrative than productive work, talent will be
misallocated. Financial incentives may lure the more talented and better educated to engage
in rent seeking rather than in productive work, with adverse consequences for the country's
growth rate.
Every politician has to raise political funds for their political campaigns so even the
personally honest ones have to condone corruption. Funds are needed to feed and transport
several hundred party workers over the poll period and supply posters and polling booth
stationary to say nothing of liquor or other inducements for some of their supporters and
competitive politics gets more expensive every year. But politicians have uncertain futures so
all their collections do not go to their parties and some is retained in their own accounts in
case they do not get party tickets and have to go it alone. This practice legitimizes the
amassing of personal wealth by every politician who despite often humble origins quickly
becomes seriously wealthy. The practice by every party is so openly known that it no longer
5. Conclusion
Kenya today. Cultural phenomenon such as materialism, tribalism and ethnicity, moral
relativity, prosperity gospel, gifting and reciprocity; have weakened Kenya’s natural
defenses against temptations of corruption. To undo the impact of shifting cultures, the
country needs to engage in sustained public discourse designed to highlight the impact and
cost of the vice as well as debunk the emerging world view that fuel corruption. This
combined with rigorous law enforcement and legislation; corporate governance and ethics;
19
strengthening of internal controls in government institutions; will slowly but certainly
References
20