East Sussex Schools Transgender Toolkit
East Sussex Schools Transgender Toolkit
East Sussex Schools Transgender Toolkit
uk
Trans* Inclusion
Schools Toolkit
Supporting transgender and gender questioning
children and young people in East Sussex schools and colleges
Originally produced by Brighton & Hove City Council and Allsorts Youth Project
Reproduced and amended by Childrens Services, East Sussex County Council
October 2014
Trans* Inclusion Schools Toolkit
eastsussex.gov.uk
Some People
Are you lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender or questioning
your sexuality and/or gender (LGBTQ) and aged 14 to 19?
If so, Some People is the project for you. A safe and inclusive
space for you to come together with like-minded people.
Meeting every Tuesday, 6pm to 8pm. Contact us for venue.
Support around lots of
LGBTQ community
Internet access
Forewords
I am delighted that this toolkit has been produced. We need to make
sure that all children and young people feel safe and supported in our
schools. Learning can only take place when children and young people
feel that their needs are being met. With the right support at this difficult
transition point we can ensure that all trans* pupils feel welcome and
enjoy their learning within school and college environments.
Councillor Nick Bennett,
Lead Member for Learning and School Effectiveness
The purpose of this toolkit is to provide clear information and guidance
to schools and colleges in East Sussex on how to support transgender
and gender questioning pupils and students. Some schools are already
doing good work in this area but there is more work to be done to
prevent transphobia. This toolkit will enable our schools to develop their
approach to trans* inclusion and support and enable trans* pupils and
students to enjoy their studies and achieve their potential.
Stuart Gallimore, Director of Childrens Services,
East Sussex County Council
Ive always been told that its just a phase or that I was copying things Ive read
online. People have patronised me throughout my whole life as a trans person. Itd be
really great if people could try to listen to me for once and took me seriously. Being told
that you arent the person you know yourself to be is really depressing and demeaning.
Tom, 14
Contents
Section
Title
Page
Introduction
1.1
1.2
Underlying principles
2.1
Definitions
2.2
3.1
National data
3.2
3.3
4.1
4.2
Safeguarding
4.3
5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
Language
5.5
6.1
6.2
6.3
Timing of transition
6.4
Support services
7.1
7.2
7.3
7.4
7.5
Toilets
7.6
Changing rooms
7.7
PE and fitness
7.8
Residential trips
7.9
Appendices
Appendix 1
Trans* glossary
Appendix 2
Appendix 3
Appendix 4
CornwallSchools
TransgenderGuidance
Transphobic
Bullying
Could you
deal with it in
your school?
A commitment from
Mermaids
1 Introduction
1.1
The purpose of this document is to provide information and guidance to schools and colleges
in East Sussex on how to more effectively support transgender and gender questioning pupils
and students and prevent transphobia. This toolkit will enable schools to further embed the
good work they are doing in this area and develop their approach to trans* inclusion and
support. We hope that using this toolkit will:
Increase the confidence of staff in supporting transgender pupils and students or those
that are coming out as trans* or beginning to question their gender identity, by providing
an introduction to trans* identities and the issues that trans* children and young people
may face
Provide information that will allow schools to feel confident that they are complying with
the Equality Act 20101 and anti-bullying guidance in relation to trans* children and young
people
Highlight areas to consider when developing whole school policy and practice that will
allow trans* children and young people to achieve at school and will reduce transphobic
discrimination and bullying.
See section 4.1 and for further national advice on the Equality Act. For specific school guidance
visit Equality Guidance for Schools
Consider gender as a spectrum and take a non-binary approach to gender. Gender is often
an important part of our identity and developing a positive sense of gender identity is
part of growing up. However, gender identity is often complex and there is a spectrum of
gender which is wider than just male and female
Listen to the child or young person and their parents and carers, and wherever possible
follow their lead and preferences
Providing support to a trans* child or young person at any particular point in time does
not signal that they are or will conform to any single trans* identity or follow any particular
path of transition
Avoid where possible gender segregated activities and where this cannot be avoided,
allow the child or young person to access the activity that corresponds to their gender
identity
Work on transphobia links closely to work on challenging and preventing sexism,
homophobia and biphobia ensure that the school community is aware of this in terms of
curriculum content and the challenging of prejudice and bullying
In supporting a trans* or non-binary gender conforming child, schools and individuals
may have to re-think views and practices on gender and identity which have been
accepted as standard for a long time. This can be challenging, but no pupil should be
made to feel that they are the ones who are causing problems or that they owe anything
to their school in return for being treated with the equality they deserve and are legally
entitled to.
2 Developing understanding of
trans* and gender questioning
children and young people
2.1 Definitions
Some definitions used in the area of gender identity are given below and in Appendix 1. The
umbrella terms transgender and trans* are viewed by many people as being acceptable
terms to describe people whose sense of their gender or gender identity is seen as being
different to typical gender norms. However, wherever possible, individuals should be given
opportunities to say how they identify or describe themselves rather than labels being
ascribed to them.
Cisgender Person A person whose biological sex matches their gender. For example, a
female sexed person who identifies with their female gender. In other words, it is a term for
non-trans* people.
Transgender/Trans/trans* Umbrella terms used to describe people who identify as:
Transgender
Transsexual
Cross-Dresser
Intersex
Neither male nor female
Androgynous
A third gender
Or who have a gender identity which we do not yet have words to describe
In this toolkit, the term trans* is used to describe any person who would fit into the definition
above.
Transgender Person A person whose gender identity is different from the sex they were
assigned at birth. Some transgender people will choose to transition socially and some will
also take medical steps to physically transition (with the help of hormone therapy and/or
surgery) to live in the gender role of their choice.
Transsexual Person A person with a consistent and overwhelming desire to transition and
fulfil their life as the opposite gender. Most transsexual people actively
desire and complete gender re-assignment surgery.
10
11
12
It is important to remember that while trans* and gender questioning children and young
people may face problems in some areas of their lives, these problems are not caused by
being trans* but by societys attitude towards people who are trans* or who do not conform
to gender norms. Transphobia can be defined as an irrational fear, hatred and abuse of
trans* people and people who do not conform to traditional gender norms. Transphobia can
take many forms including direct or indirect pressure on trans* people to conform to their
perceived sex.
Mermaids, a support group for gender variant children and teenagers, and Action for
Children, have produced a powerful collection of testimonies from trans* children and young
people in a publication called Where Do Mermaids Stand? It is recommended that these are
used in PSHE lessons and staff training to develop understanding of the experiences of trans*
children and young people; including those of primary school age.
13
14
15
4.2 Safeguarding
There are no issues under child protection or safeguarding law, or practice specific to trans*
children and young people, aside from what is in place to keep all children and young people
safe.
16
17
Effectively challenge, record and deal with transphobic abuse, harassment and bullying
(eg name-calling, derogatory jokes, graffiti, unacceptable or unwanted behaviour,
intrusive questions) and then monitor incidence of transphobic abuse, harassment and
bullying, and use this information to inform whole school developments. See Appendix
5 for some ideas on how to challenge homophobia, biphobia and transphobia and local
authority guidance
Develop a variety of methods for children and young people to report transphobic bullying
and incidents
Include trans* issues in equality training for staff and governors
Create an environment in which all staff and pupils/students, whatever their gender
identity, feel equally welcome and valued and in which transphobic behaviour is
challenged
Participate in events such as LGBT History Month and ensure visibility of trans* people
and their achievements
Provide appropriate support to children and young people who identify as trans* and refer
them and their families when needed to services such as Allsorts Youth Project.
18
Hate Incident recording and Reporting Guidance for East Sussex schools
Trans* Inclusion Schools Toolkit
There is also a relationship between transphobia, homophobia and sexism. Sexist, sexual
or transphobic bullying are the not the same as homophobic bullying. However, very often,
sexist attitudes manifest themselves in homophobic bullying and any child or young person
who is perceived as not expressing stereotypically masculine or feminine traits expected of
their sex, might experience homophobic or transphobic bullying. Staff will need to use their
professional judgement as to whether some incidents should be recorded as homophobic
or transphobic, but take care not to under-record transphobia. Sexist, sexual or transphobic
bullying may also occur in conjunction with other forms of bullying, such as racist bullying or
bullying related to special educational needs or disabilities.
If a transphobic incident occurs in public and the member of staff dealing with it is aware
that the child or young person is trans* but they are not out to the rest of the community,
the member of staff must challenge the prejudice, but may need to take care not to label the
incident as transphobic in front of other pupils and students and then as a result out the
person being targeted. The incident would still be recorded as a transphobic incident.
There may be occasions where transphobic bullying has wider safeguarding implications, or
involves criminal behaviour, and in these cases schools need to follow normal safeguarding
processes and/or notify the police.
5.4 Language
Members of the school community should strive to use the preferred pronoun for a trans*
child, young person or adult. In addition, staff should think carefully about the language they
use and when possible, attempt to use language which does not reinforce a binary approach
to gender (ie there are just males and females).
Staff could reflect on the use of language when working with groups of pupils or students.
It is sometimes not necessary to use gender specific language. It may be preferable to say
come on Year 8s, off to your lesson now or come on pupils, time to get on with your
learning.
The purpose of this is not to deny gender as an important part of our identity, in fact this can
be explored as part of learning in lessons such as PSHE; however, care needs to be taken to
avoid excluding those who do not see themselves as male or female, or make assumptions
about someones gender identity because of how they appear.
19
There may be times when single gender work is needed. This may include aspects of sex
and relationship education or to support the learning needs of particular groups (e.g. boys
and literacy). Providing a clear need is identified, the Equality Act allows for such provision.
However, for participants it needs to be made clear that they can participate according to
their gender identity. For example, a trans* boy could attend a boys reading group if his
literacy required targeted support.
20
21
22
23
As has been stated, a pupil or student has the right to be addressed by a name and pronoun
that corresponds to their preferred gender identity. A change of name by deed poll is not
required to make a change to school records on systems such as SIMS. To make a change
of name on a SIMS record, please see Appendix 3. Currently it is understood to be the case
that the gender has to remain the one that was registered at the time of the Unique Pupil
Number assignment, unless the birth certificate/legal gender is changed by way of a Gender
Recognition Certificate. This is because all of the DfE analysis for that school would be based
on the individual's birth gender.
However, entry for exams and exam certificates are more complex. The Joint Council for
Qualifications paper work states that:
The centre agrees to: enter candidates under names that can be verified against
suitable identification such as a birth certificate, passport or drivers licence. You
may need to check that the name the candidate is using within the centre is his/
her legal name rather than a known as name.
Furthermore, once a result is accredited, it will need to be linked with a Unique Pupil Number
(UPN) or Unique Learner Number (ULN) which existed in the school census information
submitted in January of the exam year. UPNs and ULNs are only linked with legal names,
not preferred names. In order to use a chosen or preferred name on an exam document, a
student will need to have changed their name by deed poll. If the student is under 16 then the
consent of all people with parental responsibility is required. Once the student is 16, they can
apply for a deed poll in their own right. Parental consent is not needed.
Although some young people may feel that they want to change their name by deed poll,
others may not feel that this is a step that they are ready to take. This will unfortunately mean
that although they may have established themselves within the school under a chosen name
and gender identity, when filling in exam documentation, they will have to use their birth
name and gender. This could potentially be a source of distress for that individual and care
should be taken by staff to support such a young person to accept that this is a necessary
measure, but that it does not invalidate their chosen identity. Emphasis could be put on the
notion of them biding their time, perhaps until they are finished with their exams, before
taking steps to change their name and gender identity officially. Staff should remain sensitive
and supportive during such times.
Schools and colleges are encouraged to ensure a strategy is agreed with the pupil or student
and their parents and carers. This then needs to be agreed with the various exam boards
prior to starting GCSE courses, as some exams may be sat in Year 10 and the length of time
the process of re- registering may take. Schools will also need to be aware that the DfE
analysis of school performance may still present the student in the gender registered by their
UPN.
24
25
7.5 Toilets
Pupils and students have the right to access the toilet that corresponds to their gender
identity. Any pupils or student who has a need or desire for increased privacy, regardless
of the underlying reason, should be provided access to a single stall toilet, but no pupil or
student shall be required to use such a toilet.
Ideally schools would provide single stall toilets that can be used by all. Some schools have
already begun to use this system with success. If need be, a member of staff or designated
pupils or students can be allocated as toilet monitor during break times to ensure that
pupils and students feel safe while using the facilities. Some cisgendered females, however,
have expressed concerns about these toilets and the fact others might know they have their
periods because of time spent in the toilet there may be a case for also exploring how this
range of needs can be met.
If a school is undergoing refurbishment/building work and has an opportunity to make
changes to the toilet facilities, it is considered good practice to involve the pupils at the
design stage. Where unisex toilets are being added it is generally best to consult with pupils,
parents/carers and staff so that they have a chance to understand the layout of the new
facilities and the practicalities of using them. This is a good way of addressing any concerns
before installation takes place. Gender-specific facilities should also be available.
The Department for Education publishes detailed guidance to help schools understand their
obligations and duties in relation to the School Premises Regulations 2012. There are fewer
regulations than previously and they are less prescriptive, allowing schools more flexibility in
how they use their premises. Working closely with architects, contractors, and local authority
school property teams is the best way to provide specific facilities for schools.
26
27
Schools and colleges should consider and investigate the laws regarding trans* communities
in countries considered for school visits. The International Lesbian and Gay Association
(ILGA) have information on their website about countries that pose a risk to trans*
individuals.
28
29
Scenario 1
My daughter doesnt want a boy changing next to her,
what if he looks at her body?
For example, in this scenario it would not be appropriate to remove the trans* person
from the changing rooms if a concern is raised by a parent or carer. In this situation, it
would be far more appropriate to look at offering an alternative changing arrangement
for the child who feels uncomfortable around the trans* person. A Human Rights
response would be to state that although the individual in question may have the
body of a boy, they are in every other respect a girl and as such have the right under
the Equality Act to change with the girls and to be treated fairly as such. It is the
responsibility of members of staff to support both trans* students and cisgendered
students to feel comfortable around one another.
Scenario 2
Its not fair that he enters the 100 metres race for girls
when he is a boy/Or Wont she get injured playing rugby
with boys?
Similarly, pupils or students who feel that a trans* child should not be involved in
certain sporting activities may themselves need to be supported to do a different
activity.
This kind of support acknowledges that some individuals may struggle to understand
trans* people or initially feel uncomfortable around them, but does not support the
idea that trans* people should be treated any differently to cisgendered people. The
responsibility lies with the individual who has the problem to deal with that problem,
not with the trans* person to accommodate for that persons insecurity around them or
their child.
30
Some People
Hastings group for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender or gender questioning young people
between the ages of 14 to 19. Meets every Tuesday from 6.00pm to 8.00pm. Run by the
Targeted Youth Support Service (TYS).
For more information please contact Neil Fidler or Nicola Marshall at
[email protected] or phone/text Nicola on 07974 579865.
31
32
33
34
Race/Ethnicity
Religion/Belief
Sexual Orientation
Disability and learning difficulties
Gender or gender identity
35
What is bullying?
Behaviour by an individual or group, usually repeated over time, that intentionally hurts
another individual or group either physically or emotionally (DSCF, 2007)
This behaviour can include:
Verbal bullying e.g., Verbal bullying e.g. making personal threats, name-calling, nasty
comments or jokes
Physical bullying e.g., hitting, kicking, poking, punching, pushing, shoving, slapping,
tripping or spitting, inappropriate touching or being forced to do things you dont want to
do.
Indirect, e.g., ignoring, or excluding someone from the group e.g. not including them in
activities , gossiping or spreading rumours, dirty or intimidating looks stealing, damaging
belongings, targeted graffiti, or gestures
Cyber bullying e.g., sending threatening comments via email, text messages or Facebook,
or taking humiliating, pictures or video, clips which are then sent or shared with others
36
Biphobic bullying
Bisexual people may experience homophobic
bullying but they are also likely to experience
biphobia, that is, prejudice which is
specifically related to their bisexual identity.
Biphobia often takes the form of stereotypes:
for example, that bisexual people are
greedy, promiscuous or confused.
Bisexual people can feel marginalised by
both the straight world and the lesbian and
gay community.
Sexist bullying
This is bullying based on sexist attitudes
that when expressed demean, intimidate or
harm another person because of their sex or
gender.
Transphobic Bullying
Trans* is an umbrella term that describes people whose sense of their gender or gender
identity is seen as being different to typical gender norms. Where children and young people
are perceived not to be conforming to the dominant gender roles that may be widely expected
of them, schools should be alert for signs of bullying.
Transphobic bullying is commonly underpinned by sexist attitudes and can affect any child
or young person. An individual may also experience Transphobic bullying as a result of
perceptions that a parent, relative or other significant figure displays gender variance, or is
Transgender.
(Adapted from Preventing and responding to sexist, sexual and Transphobic bullying; Safe to
Learn Department for Children, Schools and Families, 2009)
37
You can choose to add details on this change to the Name History area, but this is entirely
optional. To do this, click on the History button on the right hand side and then click New.
Once you have made the name amendment, it is advisable to check that registers and reports
will be displaying the preferred forename.
38
Reports
Some commonly used reports, such as the registration group reports, are set up to use the
Legal Forename and Surname, therefore you may wish to amend these* via Reports | Design
Reports
Editing reports is relatively straightforward, however, if this is something that you have not
done before please contact the School ICT Service Desk for assistance.
*please ensure that you save any amended reports with a new unique name i.e. do not
overwrite the standard reports.
Any questions regarding any of the steps in this guidance should be referred to the School
ICT Service Desk on 01273 482519 or via email: [email protected].
39