Cap 8 The Birth of Molecules - Zewail - SciAm 1990-12
Cap 8 The Birth of Molecules - Zewail - SciAm 1990-12
Cap 8 The Birth of Molecules - Zewail - SciAm 1990-12
In less than a trillionth of a second, atoms can collide, interact and give
birth to molecules. Wit-h lasers and molecular beams, it is now possible
to witness the motions 7f molecules as one substance changes to another
(
by Ahrned H. Zewail
' n 1872 railroad magnate Leland
Stanford wagered $25,000 that a
galloping horse, at some point in
its stride, lifts all four hooves off the
ground. To prove it, Stanford employed
English photographer Eadweard Muybridge. After many attempts, Muybridge developed a camera shutter that
opened and closed for only two thousandths of a second, enabling him to
capture on film a horse flying through
the air [see illustration at top right].
During the past century, all scientific
disciplines from astrophysics to zoology have exploited high-speed photography to revolutionize understanding
of animal and mechanical motions that
are quicker than the eye can follow.
The time resolution, or shutter
speed, needed to photograph the ultrafast motions of molecules is beyond
any conventional scale. When a molecule breaks apart into fragments or
when it combines with another to form
a new n~olecule,the chemical bonds
between atoms break or form in less
than a trillionth of a second, or one picosecond. Scientists have hoped to observe molecular motions in real time
and to witness the birth of molecules :
the instant at which the fate of the
molecular reaction is decided and the
76
SCIENTIFIC
AMERICAN December 1990
77
FEMTOSECOND PHOTOGRAPHY captures the dynamics of molecular reactions in real time. The laser system
(above)generates a pump pulse and a
probe pulse. As shown in the illustration (lefi),the pump pulse and the probe
pulse leave the laser system at the same
time. The probe pulse is diverted so
that a time delay of a few femtoseconds
is introduced between the two pulses.
When the pump pulse hits a molecule in
the molecular beam, it initiates a chemical reaction. The probe pulse strikes the
molecule a few femtoseconds later. The
molecule then emits a spectrum of light,
which can be analyzed to determine
the dynamics of the atoms in real time.
or more than 100 years chemists have studied reaction mechanisms and molecular kinetics in
hope of understanding reactivity. In
the late 19th century, Swedish scientist
Svante Arrheilius took an important
step in describing the macroscopic dynamics of chemical reactions. He determined how the rate of a reaction depends on temperature. His famous exponential equation reveals that the rate
of a reaction increases as the amount
of applied heat increases.
But such equations, whch describe
the dynamic properties at the macroscopic level, yield information about
microscopic molecular dynamics only
if a number of assumptions are made.
Nevertheless, many aspects of molecular dynanlics can be deduced from
macroscopic observations, and Arrhenius's equation remains important to
t h s day.
SCIENTIFIC
AMERICAN December 1990
be analyzed by measuring the attributes of the fragments. Since the development of molecular beams aiid
other techniques that resolve the quantum states of products, chemists have
learned much about the elementary dynamics of reactions. As testimony to
the importance of molecular-beam science and reaction dynamics, the 1086
Nobel Prize in chemistry and the 1988
Welch Award were given for contributions in these fields.
In molecular-beam experiments, the
sequence of events in a reaction, including the transition states, could not
be observed in real time. Chemist Sture
Forsen of Lund University came up with
an insightful analogy that illustrates
the importance of understanding transitory stages in the dynamics. He compared the scientific community to a
theater audience watching a drastically
shortened version of a classical drama.
The audience is shown only the opening scenes of, say, Hamlet and its finale. Forsen writes, "The main characters are introduced, then the curtain
falls for change of scenery and, as it
rises again, we see on the scene floor a
considerable number of 'dead' bodies
and a few survivors. Not an easy task
for the inexperienced to unravel what
actually took place in between."
In an attempt to probe transition
states more directly than can be done
with conventional molecular-beam experiments, chemists turned to new
time-averaged techmques aiid developed methods that record the absorption, emission or scattering of light by
transition states. Like molecular beams,
these methods do not resolve the
events in real time, but they do provide
more direct possibilities for examining
transition states and dynamics.
In 1979 our research team at Caltech
first attempted to enter the field of ultrafast chemistry by using lasers and
molecular beams. In those days the
time resolution was tens of picoseconds, too gross a time scale for viewing the motion of reactions through
transition states. We concentrated on
developing techniques to study how energy moves in molecules prior to reactions. By 1984 time resolution in molecular-beam experiments had improved
to three picoseconds. That advance allowed us to measure directly the rate
of reaction as a molecule changed from
one quantum state to another. Still, we
needed a technology that could record
the spectrum of transition states in
real time with femtosecond resolution.
To build such a femtosecond, molecular "camera," we combined the technology of molecular beams with that of
ultrashort laser pulses. The molecular
79
$?b..
(A/4,k+
-- @
@i,If, p\,-:.;
o= -"
c o o
d
-- - - - -- - - - - - -
----------------------------
00
&dU,,
20 FEMTOSECONDS
BEFORE REACTION
START OF
REACTION
100 FEMTOSECONDS
AFTER REACTION
FEMTOSECOND DYNAMICS of cyanogen iodide (ICN) can be tion, because the exact momentum and position of the atoms
best described in terms of potential-energy curves. In clas- cannot be determined simultaneously,as specified by quansical mechanics, when molecules of ICN in a low-energy state tum mechanics. As shown in the diagram at the right, it
( a ) interact with a laser beam, light excites ICN to a high- is most likely, for example, that iodine is separated from
energy state (b).The molecule then dissociates into iodine cyanide by about .85 nanometer at 180 femtoseconds (d).
and cyanide, and the distance between iodine and cyanide At that instant, however, there is a small chance that they
increases ( c and d ) . The diagram at the left is a sirnplifica- might be separated by .7 nanometer or even 1.0 nanometer.
SCIENTIFIC
AMERICAN December 1990
-..
SODIUM
IODIDE
Alkali halide reactions were the prototype for the "alkali age" of molecular-beam experiments, and it is insightful to study them in the "femtosecond age." Furthermore, researchers at
the University of Toronto had investigated the emission spectra of the sodium iodide molecule during its transition to atoms of sodium and iodme.
What intrigued us about sodium iodide is a rather interesting potentialenergy surface for the interaction of
FREE ATOMS OF
SODIUM AND IODINE
UPPERCURVE
\
0
LOWERCURVE
.5
1.0
1.5
SEPARATION BETWEEN Na AND I (NANOMETERS)
FEMTOSECOND MOTIONS of the salt sodium iodide (NaI) reveal the molecular dynamics of the chemical bond linldng
sodium and iodine. In the potential-energydiagram at the left,
the ionic (attractive)curve intersects the covalent (repulsive)
curve. As a result, sodium iodide can break up into sodium
and iodine, acting in a covalent manner, or sodium iodide can
-2
2
4
TIME DELAY (PICOSECONDS)
exist in a high-energybound state, alternating between covalent and ionic behavior. If sodium iodide dissociates into
atoms, then the intensity of part of the spectrum will jump in
steps, as shown in the experimental results (top at right). If
sodium iodide is in its high-energybound state, then the intensity of part of the spectrum will oscillate (bottom at right).
SCIENTIFICAMERICAN December 1990
81
sodium and iodine atoms. If these atoms are brought together, they repel
one another, particularly at short &stances. On the other hand, if the same
elements are brought together as oppositely charged ions of sodium and iodine, they attract each other. In fact,
at a short enough distance, a stable salt
composed of sodium and iodine ions
will be formed. When the sodium and
iodine form a covalent bond, they share
electrons to create a stable energy state.
When the atoms form an ionic bond,
the sodium atom donates an electron
to the iodine atom to create charged
ions that attract.
Nah~re,however, does not work exactly in this way. Actually, the atoms
behave as if they are both ionic and covalent. The true potential-energym e s
are therefore composed of an ionic and
a covalent curve [see illustration on preceding page]. The ionic curve crosses
the covalent curve at a certain distance.
In this region of interaction, the molecular system has a mixture of covalent and ionic characteristics; in other
words, the molecule has a certain probability of being covalent and a certain
probability of being ionic.
Theorists have divided the potentialenergy curves into two parts: a lower
and an upper. The lower curve, which
represents low-energy states, is composed of the ionic curve at short distances and the covalent curve at long
distances. The upper curve depicts the
opposite situation: it is covalent at
short distances and ionic at long distances. The upper curve also represents a state high in energy.
The behavior represented by the lower surface usually dominates when the
sodium and iodine atoms are brought
together slowly so that they begin to
interact. In t h ~ case,
s
an electron passes from sodium to iodine to create a
stable n~oleculeof sodium iodide. If,
however, the atoms come together too
rapidly, they can jump, with a certain
probability, from the lower to the upper surface. The upper surface no longer represents the covalent repulsive
(or slightly bound) curve and instead
has a poirlt of least energy (a minimum). Molecules in this potential minimum will thus be somewhat stable.
(More specifically, the molecules enter
a quasi-bound state.)
We hoped to view the femtosecond
dynamics of the bond in sodium iodide
as it breaks to form atoms of sodiunl and iodine. In particular, we focused on the jump from the upper potential surface to the lower one, or vice
versa. We observed the motion as the
molecules change from being covalent
to being ionic and as they go through
82
SCIENTIFIC
AMERICAN
December l !
-..
...
FURTHER READING
STATE-TO-STATE
REACTION DYNAMICS.
kchard N. Zare and Richard B. Bernstein in Physics Today, Vol. 33, No. 11,
pages 43-50; November, 1980.
INVESTIGATION
OF ULTRAFAST
PHENOMENA. Charles V. Shank in Science, Vol.
233, No. 4770, pages 1276-1280; September 19, 1986.
THE NOBELPRIZEFOR CHEMISTRY
in Les
Prix Nobel 1986. Almquist & Wlksell International, 1987.
REAL-TIME LASER FEMTOCHEMISTRY:
VIEWINGTHE TRANSITION
FROM REAGENTS TO PRODUCTS. Ahmed H. Zewail and Richard B. Bernstein in Chemical and Engineering News, Vol. 66, No.
45, pages 24-43; November 7, 1988.
LASERFEMTOCHEMISTRY.
Ahmed H. Zewail in Science, Vol. 242, No. 4886,
pages 1645-1653; December23,1988.
EXPOSING MOLECULAR
MOTIONS.
Ian W.
M. Smith in Nature, Vol. 343, No. 6260,
pages 691-692; February 22, 1990.
ULTRAFAST
MOLECULAR
REACTION DYNAMICS.
L. Khundkar and Ahmed H.
Zewail in Annual Review of Physical
Chemistry, Vol. 41, pages 15-60; 1990.