HPV Vaccination Acceptability in Young Boys
HPV Vaccination Acceptability in Young Boys
HPV Vaccination Acceptability in Young Boys
O riginal
DOI 10.4415/ANN_13_03_09
Abstract
Purpose. The aim of this study was to evaluate the comprehension and acceptance of
HPV vaccination in parents of adolescent boys aged 11 to 15 years.
Methods. A cross-sectional survey was conducted by means of questionnaires sent directly to the homes of all families with young males aged between 11 and 15, residents
of three municipalities of the Province of Brescia, Italy. The documentation also contained an informative leaflet summarizing the HPV-related disease characteristics, the
burden of disease and the available strategies for prevention and treatment, illustrating
the rationale of vaccination and describing the project and its phases. The questionnaire
included questions on demographic data, acceptance and motivations for HPV vaccination. The collected data was analyzed using descriptive statistics. At the end of the study,
parents who received the questionnaires were also offered the possibility of vaccinating
their male sons for free.
Results. From a total of 1072 questionnaires sent, 161 where returned from the three
selected municipalities (average response rate 15%); 97% of adolescent males involved
in the study were Italian and 91% Catholic; 97% of parents declared themselves to be
willing to vaccinate their sons: the principal motivation given (92%) was prevention of the
disease, cancerous or not, related to viral infection. Among the respondents not willing
to vaccinate their sons, the motivation was lack of information about the vaccine and the
disease. At the end of the study, around 71 boys were vaccinated.
Discussion. To our knowledge, this is the first survey in Italy exclusively conducted on
parents of adolescent males about the acceptability and feasibility of vaccination against
HPV: a very high percentage of respondents was favorable to accept the vaccination for
their sons, the main motivation being the fact that parents considered protecting their
sons from HPV-related diseases highly important. Of the 161 boys targeted by the questionnaire, 71 decided to receive the 3 doses of HPV vaccination (44%). Data suggests
that HPV vaccination is acceptable to families for their male sons and that information
is important in the decision-making process.
INTRODUCTION
Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) is the cause of the
most common sexually transmitted infection in the
world. Males, as well as females, have an important
role in the transmission of HPV. HPV DNA can be
detected in the cervical tissue in up to 45% of women 20-24 years of age [1-5]. In men, the prevalence
ranges from 20 to 65% and is high at all ages [6, 7-10]
and are related to oral cancers in around 25-35% of
cases, anal cancer in 90% of cases, and penile cancer
in 40% of cases [9]. In a recent publication it has
been estimated that in Europe more than 340 000
cases/year of HPV vaccine-preventable diseases affect only women. A similar number is also evidenced
in men (including more than 320 000 cases of genital
warts, 12 000 cases of head and neck cancer, more
Key words
HPV vaccine
young male
cervical cancer
vaccine acceptability
public health system
HPV vaccination
STI
than 1600 cases of anal cancer and around 1000 cases of the penile cancer [8, 9, 11, 12].
In the USA in October 2011, following the approval of the quadrivalent vaccine use also on males, the
American Centers for Diseases Prevention and Control
(CDC) recommended that young boys as well as girls
should get immunised against HPV [13]. The same
was recommended in Canada by the National Advisory Committee on Immunization (NACI) [14] and in
Australia [15] by the Pharmaceutical Benefits Advisory
Committee (PBAC), even if Australia had high vaccine
coverage in females and herd immunity was expected
and demonstrated. Surveys conducted with different
methodologies on the general male population at risk or
over 18 years have shown varying degrees of knowledge
and acceptability of HPV vaccination [16-25]. In Italy,
Address for correspondence: Giancarlo Tisi, Spedali Civili di Brescia, Piazzale Spedali Civili 1, 25123 Brescia, Italy. E-mail: [email protected].
METHODS
The Ethics Committee of the Hospital of Brescia approved the survey on January 11, 2011 as a no-profit,
no-sponsorized study.
A questionnaire was prepared by the authors of the
study, and was printed by INFORMA-CRO srl. A copy
of this questionnaire, both in Italian and in English, can
be sent on request contacting the corresponding author
at: [email protected].
From March 2011 to September 2011 information
leaflets on HPV burden of disease and questionnaires
to evaluate vaccine acceptability were sent to all families with young males aged between 11 and 15, residents of three municipalities of the Province of Brescia,
Italy (Montichiari, Orzinuovi and Roncadelle).
The list of families with male adolescents was obtained from the registry lists of Brescia residents, provided by the previously selected municipalities. Families were also made aware that their local pediatricians
and general practitioners were informed that the survey
was taking place. A free phone line was also activated,
operated by trained physicians coordinated by the department of gynecology and obstetrics, in case further
information on HPV-related diseases was required by
the families receiving the questionnaire. Taking into
consideration that some families already had a basic
acquired knowledge of HPV diseases and of the vaccination offered to girls by the National Health System
yet none or little on the possibility of also vaccinating
males, the educational content was centered on males
and their burden of disease. The information leaflet was
divided into different sections summarizing the disease
characteristics, the burden of disease and the available
strategies for prevention and treatment, illustrating the
rationale of vaccination, the project and its phases and
listing in detail what was being asked to the families
about the project. All of this was supported by detailed
information and didactic diagrams.
The questionnaire contained questions on demographics data (place of birth, municipality of residence, education, profession and age of the parents),
willingness to accept or not the proposed vaccination
and provided several options for returning the finished
questionnaire: either to the hospital help desk, by fax,
through a dedicated internet based website or by phone
calling the toll-free number, which was also activated
to offer answers to all doubts about the disease or the
project. Each questionnaire was anonymous, although
a unique numeric code was necessary in order to identify the studys population cohort that answered the
questionnaire. The collected data was analyzed using
descriptive statistics (mean, standard deviation for continuous variables and absolute and percentage distributions for discrete variables).
In January 2011, the quadrivalent anti HPV vaccine
summary product characteristic (SPC) already included
vaccine immunogenicity data on children and adolescents irrespective of the sex (Il vaccino produce inoltre
la formazione di anticorpi in bambini ed adolescenti di
eta compresa tra 9 e 15 anni) this evidence of immunogenicity also in males younger than 14 years of age
permitted that parents who received the questionnaires
O riginal
287
O riginal
288
Table 1
Distribution of parents by gender, age and some socio-demographic characteristics
Mother
Father
< 40
35
21.7
5.6
40-44
59
36.7
50
31.1
45-49
40
24.8
56
34.8
50
12
7.5
31
19.2
Missing
15
9.3
15
9.3
Mean age
42.9 4.9
Age (years)
45.9 5.1
Education
Elementary
1.2
2.5
Middle school
68
37.9
71
44.1
Higher school
77
12.4
68
42.2
University
14
24.8
16
9.9
Missing
1.3
Unemployed
1.2
1.9
Housewife
61
37.9
Worker
20
12.4
53
32.9
Employee
40
24.8
30
18.6
Manager
1.9
3.1
Self employed
29
18.0
Other
29
18.0
34
21.1
Missing
3.7
4.4
129
80.1
32
19.9
Occupation
DISCUSSION
Extending vaccination to boys will not only protect
males but it will also reduce rates of HPV related cases
among females (via herd immunity). In some countries,
local health authorities have already taken into consideration the previous unknown HPV burden in males
and have started to offer vaccination campaigns also
for males. The United States of America, Australia and
Canada are among the first countries to recommend
and offer routine vaccination in boys too [13-15].
This is the first survey in Italy exclusively conducted
on parents of adolescent males about the acceptability
and feasibility of vaccination against HPV infection: it
was possible to propose an active offer of vaccination,
even if only through a written communication, involving families of the three municipalities. A total response
rate of 15%, for a questionnaire that was sent by traditional mail can be considered a good rate [22], also
considering that no other active intervention was programmed to remind families to complete the questionnaire, such as telephone calls or an eventual reminder
letter, nor any type of information about the possibility
of vaccination offer of males; in this sense studies have
observed that additional actions exponentially increase
the answer rates of a survey [37]. According to the observational target of the study, returned questionnaires
were anonymous, so a second call was not performed to
non responders.
The study was designed by University of Brescia according to Spedali Civili of Brescia Ethic Committee.
The source of information from public health Institutions probably determined a very high (97%) proportion
of respondents willing to vaccinate their male sons. The
main motivation being the fact that they considered the
disease of high importance also for males having the
right to receive the vaccine. It should be noted that, at
present, the medical community and public opinion in
Italy consider HPV vaccination to be a vaccine needed
and indicated exclusively to females. The results also
showed that among respondents not willing to vaccinate their sons, the motivation was lack of information
about the vaccine and the disease. We have also to affirm that the high proportion of parents in favour of
vaccination may be a bias due to the high percentage of
ones having a daughter already vaccined: probably only
already sensibilized people participated the survey. On
these bases, we suppose that a more invasive campaign,
than a simple informative leaflet on the disease risks,
might obtain a better response rate.
The results obtained emphasize some aspects, which
are at the base of the external limits found in order to
implement a working vaccination offer. Due to the fact
that the information campaign was necessarily and deliberately non-invasive (no further actions were taken to
increase response rates), it was not possible to collect
socio-demographic information on the non respondents. Also, the fact that the results relate to a small,
< 12
21
13.0
12-13
77
47.8
14-15
63
39.2
Age (years)
Missing
Age median ds
13.1 1.3
Level of study
School
108
67.1
High School
50
31.3
Missing
1.8
36
22.4
97
60.2
20
12.4
5.0
Missing
1.9
1.1 1.1
N of vaccinated brothers/sisters
0
55
34.2
69
42.9
0.6
Missing
36
22.3
Italian
147
95.7
Other
4.3
Catholic
147
91.3
Islamic
3.7
Other
1.3
Missing
3.7
Nationality
Religion
O riginal
289
O riginal
290
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
O riginal
291