Canteen Management Thesis Chapter 2
Canteen Management Thesis Chapter 2
Canteen Management Thesis Chapter 2
CHAPTER II
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
This chapter deals with the review of related literature and studies, the
conceptual model of the study, the research hypothesis, and the definition of
terms used in the study.
Review of Related Literature and Studies
To intensify the knowledge and clarity the perception of the problems, a
number of books and periodicals were read to gather insights which were used
by the researcher in conceptualizing this study. Those which have been found
relevant are hereby presented.
Related Literature. The school canteen follows guidelines on operational
management set by the Department of Education Through DepEd Order No, 8, s.
2007, the Revised Implementing Guidelines and Management of school
canteens In Public Elementary and Secondary level. These guidelines are
hereby issued in order to rationalize the operation and management of school
canteens in the public elementary system and to ensure that the school canteens
shall help eliminate malnutrition among pupils/students and that the school
canteens shall serve as a laboratory for home economics retails trade in the
incidental teaching of health and nutrition. It shall provide hands-on-training for
pupils on planning, purchasing, handling and storage, preparation, serving and
sale of safe and nutritious meals. The school canteen guidelines shall serve as a
mechanism to support the departments response to the mandate of Article 2 of
Republic Act No. 6938 to create an atmosphere that is conducive to the growth
16
17
are familiar with and comply with relevant legal requirements regarding food
safety and occupational health and safety standards.
School canteens may operate under a variety of management structures,
depending on the individual characteristics and needs of the school. Most
canteens in schools are run under the direction of, and are accountable to, the
school council. Schools may decide to provide a food service to students in
several ways. A formal management agreement detailing the terms and
conditions of the management structure should be drawn up and signed by the
relevant management parties, which will usually be the school council and
principal, or the school council or principal and private contractor. Contracting a
canteen business is not as new but contains several procedures which need to
be taken seriously for a more effective means of negotiating an enterprise. The
following pointers should help you in selecting a good supplier. An ideal supplier:
is located locally has been recommended by other school canteens delivers
frequently, and will do so at a convenient and suitable time for the canteen
delivers stock in good condition, for example ice-cream which is always frozen
and fruit and vegetables which are always fresh delivers stock with the maximum
shelf life follows appropriate storage, handling and food safety requirements,
such as adequate refrigeration for chilled and frozen goods and shade and cover
for fresh produce uses adequate packaging and handling procedures to ensure
products are not damaged offers an adequate range of products communicates
well, keeping you informed of price changes, specials and product availability
offers competitive prices, as well as specials, discounts and incentives offers
18
preparation.
Children
eating
meals
and
snacks
in Head
Start
19
in
the
group
care
facility
or
program. Family
members
and
snacks at home or bring appropriate food gifts when visiting their relative
in the health care or residential facility. Family members may also need
guidance in basic food safety to ensure the foods they bring in from
outside are safe for the resident to eat.
Nadhja ( 2013 : 21) discussed that the science of nutrition is the
study of how food nourishes the body. It encompasses the study of
nutrients and how they are handled by the body as well as the impact of
human behavior and environment on the process of nourishment. As such,
this discipline involves physiology, psychology, and socioeconomics. Nutrients
are
specific
biochemical
development,
activity,
substances
reproduction,
used
lactation,
by
the
body for
growth,
health maintenance,
and
than they do alone. Also, nutrient needs change throughout the life cycle
in response to
state of health.
they are not synthesized in the body or are made in insufficient amounts.
20
nutrients
carbohydrates,
fats,
that
and
supply
protein)
energy
and
are
referred
build
to
tissue (such
as
as micronutrients.
of
preschool
age respond best to regular mealtimes. Three meals per day arent enough
for this age-group, and snacks are recommended as part of regular eating
pattern. Research indicates that snacks typically provide 20% of childrens
total caloric intake and therefore, can be a good way to provide protein,
calories, and nutrients to young children. At this age, its good to begin
involving children in meal-related activities, such as food selection and
preparation. School-age children are more independent of adults. Meeting
their nutritional needs must be must be balanced with their need for
decision making and peer acceptance. School-age children spend much of
their day at school, away from parents and, in many cases, are only
marginally supervised at lunchtime. In addition, theyre increasingly aware of
their peers behaviors and are exposed to different types of food and
eating behaviors. They begin to make their own choices about what to eat
at this age.
21
infection
22
include
developing
guidelines
for advertising
and
than
23
crops,
noodles, rice and corn products in native preparation, fruits and vegetables
in season, and fortified food products labeled rich in protein, energy,
vitamins and minerals shall be sold in the school canteen. Beverages shall
include milk, shakes and juices prepared from fruits and vegetables in
season.
The sales of carbonated drinks, sugar-based synthetic or artificially
flavored juices, junk foods and any food product that may bedetrimental to
the childs health and that do not bear the Sangkap Pinoy seal and/or did
not pass the BFAD approval is probihited.
Iodized salt shall be used, in controlled quantity, in the preparation
of cooked foods to ensure that iodine requirement of the clientele shall be
met and to eliminate iodine deficiency disorders. The use of monosodium
glutamate (vetsin) shall be regulated.
A reasonable mark-up price for all merchandise in the canteen shall
be allowed, provided that the selling retail price does not exceedthe
prevailing prices in the locality.
FNRI DOST ( 2013 ) , nutritional guidelines for Filipino revised and
organized by the (FNRI DOST) , an inter agency and multi disciplinary
24
technical working group. The new Nutritional Guidelines for Filipinos was
approved by the National Nutrition Council during its October 31, 2012
meeting. The revision was in response to the changes in the nutrition
situation of the country as reported by the FNRIs survey results and in
lieu
of new nutrition
intervention to
address
and
sugar rich
foods
to
prevent
cardiovascular
diseases.
7.
Consume milk, milk products, and other calcium - rich foods, such as small
fish and shellfish, everyday for healthy bones and teeth. 8. Use iodized
salt to prevent Iodine Deficiency Disorders. 9. Consume safe foods and
water to prevent diarrhea and other food - and water borne diseases. 10.
Be physically active, make healthy food choices, manage stress, avoid
alcoholic beverages and do not smoke to help prevent lifestyle related
non-communicable diseases.
25
RA
6939
( Cooperative
Development
Authority ) , towards
social justice, and economic development, has tasked the agency for the
noble purpose as cited. Created under the Office of the President, the
Cooperative Development Authority (CDA) disseminates provisions concerns
the
annual
report
of
cooperative,
capital,
property
and
funds
of
among
members
systematic
production
and marketing;
4)
cooperative
wholesale
and retail
complexes,
insurance
and
26
any and all other activities for the affective and efficient implementation of
the provisions.
Mendoza
( 2009 )
service
institution,
sanitation
is
the
primary
concern
of
the
production
is food
sanitation and safety. However, its true importance is often not seen until
such time that the food establishment encounters legal problems resulting
to civil and provable criminal liabilities. Besides this, the non-observance of
proper sanitation and safety practices usually lead to other situations that
would hinder the success of food establishment. Poor hygiene in the
handling and preparation of food leads not only to products of poor quality
but also increases the cost of producing goods and services because they
lead to a lot of wastage and spoilage. More often than not, over
production and improper storage due to insufficient planning and lack of
knowledge increases the risks of food poisoning and inspection as well as
the higher cost not only due to spoilage but also due to higher storage
27
deal
with
quantity
or
institutionalized
food
production.
Because
refreshment and dining services help clients turn the companys vending and
dining offerings from what can be a compromise for the sake of convenience, to
clients and employees first choice for food and beverages. For clients who need
more than traditional vending machines, canteens provide full-service vending
options with a greater, fresher selection than traditional machines. For clients
who require the next level in dining services, canteens offer Dining Solutions,
from food kiosks to full-service cafs and restaurants which give more
convenience to everyone. The Canteen provides customized foodservice
programs in-house or through one of concessionaire type, semi-outdoor set-up
whether for break room, office coffee service or pantry provisions and office
supplies selling scheme. Most vending machines are self-service but the canteen
28
gives clients a middle ground, offering full service vending with the convenience
and speed of traditional self-service machines.
Dunhill (2013: 209) explained that lunch rooms have provisions of
innovative snack and beverage vending machines, and also canteen which
offers micro-markets with an expanded product selection, more akin to a
convenience or grocery store as well as comprehensive dining solutions, like
meal service in university or business center dining halls. There are customize
vending services programs to fit the needs of virtually any workplace or multilocation company, serving businesses in professional, financial, retail, healthcare,
manufacturing, and education industries. Whether a company need a
comprehensive vending program, self-service food or beverage vending machine
which satisfies all business needs, canteens technicians and service
representatives should be regularly available to keep machines stocked and
maintained, bringing new meaning to full service vending. No one wants to
wrestle with an outdated machine for a stolen peso or a snack stuck in the
dispenser, but with a full service canteen, this will never have to happen. In an
industry that is always on, any company can count on canteens to go beyond the
vending machine to provide them with a full service vending experience.
Taylor (2012: 59) postulated that many organizations provide canteens as
an additional subsidized facility for their employees as a welfare measure. The
usage of the canteen by the employees depends on many factors like a
centralized food distribution center with swift and simple in operations. Canteens
design provides a user-friendly system that facilitates quick and efficient
29
30
fun words for products is also good. Reconsider how the product is wrapped and
presented product. Marketing the menu through be beautiful presentation in
wraps and rolls with a student (seek permission from parents first) and enlarge
these photos. These photos not only decorate the canteen but also work as
treats at promoting the item. Seek help from a parent who may be willing and
able to Photoshop and enhance the pictures.
canteen as if one were the customer, making sure that food looks appetizing and
appealing. Look at the display counter as if one is opening the fridge door looking
for a snack. Its the food that looks the best that grabs ones attention.
A fun
and effective way to draw attention to key food items is to tuck a novelty item in
with the display to attract the attention of the students. A silly spider or obvious
toy mouse, which changes location occasionally, makes the customer notice
items for sale.
Johannes (2013: 39) discussed that school canteens should provide
cheap, sanitary, nutritious food such as fresh milk, fresh fruits and fresh drinks,
boiled root crops, high calorie indigenous recipes and the like. Canteen
personnel handling food in the canteen should be required to undergo training for
food handlers, obtain a certificate of good health from the municipal health
department and observe hygiene. Operational practices that will be to the welfare
of the students, teachers and to the school as a whole as well as any violation of
the provision of the Memorandum of Agreement and the operational
management guidelines should be considered as grounds for the return of the
canteen operation to the school.
31
32
is considered by clients but the services that workers are executing for the clients
(Dexter, 2012: 123)
As discussed by Sears (2009: 117), the college canteen is a service
provided by the college for the benefit of students and staff. The college canteen
sells food and drinks that are healthful, nutritional and tasty. It is a valid business
enterprise and is operated according to good, ethical business practices
committed to holistic education; therefore the whole life of every student is of
concern to the college canteen which includes students physical well-being as
much as their spiritual growth and intellectual development. All operations of the
college canteen reflect its values and vision. The canteen is an important part of
the schools life and as such, its management and operations need to also reflect
the colleges aims and mission. The canteen of the college must always consider
the different needs of the students and also the cultures where they came from.
Some students and even other non-student clients might not eat pork as their
religion and cultural values may dictate. Some might not eat fish that has no
scales and other might not eat beef. These are some of the considerations that,
no matter how good the services may be and how tasty and nutritious the foods
are, would make these foods unfit to the likes and choices of the students.
Ray (2011: 301) discussed the aim of the canteens in schools where they
provide a healthful variety of food and drinks, support classroom teaching of
nutrition and health, encourage the development of good eating habits, provide
friendly and prompt services encourage courtesy and consideration, operate as
an effective, efficient and profitable business enterprise consider the special
33
dietary needs of some students, and demonstrate high standards in food safety
and hygiene in relation to the preparation, storage and serving of food.
All the references cited are related to the present study since they all
discuss canteen management and considerations, including effective means of
implementation. The suggestions posted have been of great help to this research
as basis for the outcome of the study.
Related Studies. The study of DonJun (2013) emphasizes on the need
to effectively manage the canteen stocks that he made the observation and
recommendation that only one person in the canteen should be responsible for
ordering stock, which includes foods, drinks, packaging, utensils, first aid and
cleaning materials. Ideally this will be the canteen manager, or a person who
oversees most of the canteen and has the largest time involvement. Allocating
this responsibility to only one person is important as it prevents confusion and
overordering, maintains consistency and ensures maximum efficiency. Canteens
generally return higher profits when they restrict the number of suppliers and
range of stock. Restricting the number of suppliers can be beneficial as it allows
canteen staff to develop management rapport with a supplier. This can also result
in special services and treatment, such as discounts and better quality of service.
Minimizing the range of stock assists in reducing slow turnover items, which can
lead to spoilage. It will also allow you to use employees and volunteers with less
training given there are less products to work with. Both of these practices will
also result in more efficient ordering with fewer orders needing to be placed. It is
important to ensure that when minimizing the range of stock in a canteen the
34
range and variety of nutritious foods, such as fruit and vegetables, is not
reduced. Finally, never select food or drink products that fail to reflect nutrition
standards detailed in the canteen policy even if the supplier can offer a lucrative
deal, such as bargain prices or equipment rewards.
Bertland (2013) was able to come up in his study that the conclusion that
the canteen needs to ensure that all canteen money can be accurately tracked at
all times. Management of money involves: running off cash registers at the end of
each trading period during the day (if applicable) counting money and balancing
cash registers at the end of each day maintaining a standard float banking each
day and keeping minimal money in the canteen accurately recording payment of
all orders and invoices accurately recording all cheques accurately recording all
petty cash expenses. It is recommended that all stock should be paid for by
cheque or electronic transfer, with petty cash being used only for the purchase of
items of a minor or unexpected nature. Only a small petty cash float should be
kept. In order for a canteen to be financially viable, income from selling food
must either be equal to or greater than the expenses involved in running the
canteen. Accurate costing of foods plays a very important part in determining
income. A financially successful canteen also requires efficient management of
all canteen resources. The following section details why it is important to:
account for all canteen money account for all stock determine the cost price of
pre-packaged items and recipes determine the selling price of pre-packaged
items and recipes per serve.
35
Canteens role in feeding students are just roles as parents must do. The
average healthy 8-year-old weighing 30 kg (66 lb) requires about 1,750 ml
of fluid per day. Many school-age children have only one meal a day with
their family, at dinner. Mealtime should be a social time enjoyed by all,
and parents should retain from discussing a childs poor eating habits at
this time. Parents should be aware that children learn many of their food
habits by observing their parents. Eating a balance diet should be the
norm for both parent and child. Thus, canteen must serve foods which can
uplift the childs nutritional needs and benefit their overall being. (Camaya, 2013)
According to Garan (2013), the school-age child generally eats lunch
at school. The children may bring lunch from home or buy lunch at the
school. Many dietary problems stem
from
this independence
in
food
choices. The children may trade their food, not eat lunch at all, or buy
sweets or junk food with their lunch money. Parents should discuss with
the child the foods that they should eat and continue to provide a
balanced diet in the home setting. In this juncture, the presence of good food
at canteen services must be complied with specifically if the snacks brought in
from the childs lunch boxes are improperly prepared at home. The availability of
food choices which can make children at school be nutritionally good is a role
that can never be compromised.
As evidenced in the observation of Ching (2013) , nutrition continues to
be a high priority for growing children. School-age children require a
balanced diet including 2.400 Kcal per day. School-age children eat three
36
meals a day and one or two nutritious snacks. They need a protein-rich
food at breakfast to sustain the prolonged physical and mental effort
required at less by late morning and have decreased problem-solving
ability. Undernourished children become fatigued easily and face a greater
risk of infection, resulting in frequent absences from school. This risk in their
studies must be complemented by a better canteen ambiance and management
which would derail them if not properly executed. Innovations in canteens were
suggested including having potable water for free and nutritious foods in a
balanced form of diet must be served.
The study of Jamil (2013) focused on the assessment of the canteen in
San Pedro Relocation
privatization in almost four years. The study was conducted to assess the
services and the benefits it can give to the school. Based on the study, the
canteen, which was concessional, was found to be effective in its service to
students and faculty. This was due to the fact that the concessionaires are
subject to further evaluation of the administration before their contract is to be
renewed. This has posted a healthy competition among the canteen
concessionaires in which they have to perform best by offering good food of
reasonable prices and offer good services as well. The study also brought to light
the fact that the monthly rentals are a good source of income for the school.
However, problems arise during times when delayed payment occurs, specifically
when vacation is upcoming. The concessionaires encounter payment problems
since, according to them, return of profit is very hard when students and teachers
37
are not willing to buy from the canteen and would instead go home early specially
during examination periods and near vacation periods. On the other hand,
enrollment period gives good opportunity for them as bulks of students and even
parents come to the canteen for refreshment and meals. Thus, it was suggested
that payment schemes should be more flexible during the time when sales are
low as a matter of new policy in canteen management.
Echiverri (2011) studied the management of the school canteen in the
Laguna State Polytechnic University campuses. Based on the findings of this
study, the following conclusion were drawn: (1) Majority of the canteens were
managed by private individuals and found out that all canteen facilities and
equipment were moderately adequate; (2) food procurement was supervised by
outside paid helpers; (3) canteen managers ensured that the food to be cooked
was washed thoroughly and prepared nutritiously; (4) majority of the canteens
were implementing self-service in food serving; and (5)
problems in the
38
accessibility of the building to pupils and teachers. The lowest rating given were
noted in the following: time schedule for recess of intermediate grade pupils and
distribution of time allowance for recess, the quality and quantity of foods being
served. The highest rating on the other hands was on the perception of the
quality of fruits and vegetable for sale. All the respondents gave the highest
ratings to the drive to put up a normal-sized canteen room/building. On the
contrary, the lowest ratings were noted in terms of the ability to solicit assistance
from NGOs and GOs for canteen improvement and the ability to put up the
needed accessories in the canteen.
The conclusions made on this study were as follows: 1) canteens in public
elementary schools are properly managed and systematically run by the staff and
personnel involved, 2) teachers have different reactions on some policy
implementations particularly in class programming, food service operations and
teachers assignment. These conclusions led to the recommendations that the
school heads should prepare a workable and viable long range master plan on
canteen operations and personnel functions. Similarly, it is the suggested that
part of the canteens proceeds should also be used for other school projects.
Service assistance by government and non-government organizations should
also be tapped and finally, a wider and deeper study should be made in order to
validate and compare the findings of this study.
Salik (2013) conducted a research on the canteen management in
National high schools in the Victoria district division of Laguna, school year 20112012. The aim of the study was to make a system analysis of the canteen
39
management of the said school. The results revealed that efficient canteen
management is necessary in order to provide food of the lowest cost and highest
nutritious value. Common problems met in the management of the canteens
were as follows: 1) lack of space to accommodate the students; 2) helpers
chores were given to the teacher in charge of managing the canteen; 3) lack of a
full-time canteen manager; 4) the time allotted for cooking is very limited; 5) the
food being prepared is not enough for the consumers, and finally the buyers do
not have plenty of choices of food. Possible solutions were recommended to
lessen or totally eliminate the existing problems such as: 1) expansion of school
facilities; 2) addition of more tables and chairs, and cooking utensils, 3)
installation of a deep well and better water connection, 4) hiring of more helpers,
5) having dialogues with a co-signers to assess the quality and quantity of the
food services they render, and 6) finally, the canteen teachers should be free
from teaching loads to enable them to supervise the helpers in food preparation.
Canteen operations and management are considered to be two of the services
offered by the school, and others become part of the school administrations
tasks and part daily operations. In fact, most of these schools already have
handbooks on how to properly maintain and operate canteens. Canteen
management is also considered not just as a school function but also a full job
that needs formal training and that many schools.
In the study conducted by Yumol, et al (2010) presented during the 2010
research forum on annual agency in-house review proceedings in the KalingaApayao State College, it was found out that the canteen needs further
40
41
The canteen billboard also helped students have knowledge of nutrition with
practical application. Nutrition information about meals prepared was posted on
the board, along with other similarly nutritious meals. Also, the canteen board,
detailing its regulation, showed the steps of canteen services. In addition, its time
frame, opening at 6:30am and closing at 4:00 pm, was established for the needs
of the students, serving breakfast for those who have early classes and late
snacks for those who will travel home.
In another related study, Wongkhum (2012) evaluated the Watweruwan
School Lunch program and presented the results to the Research Institute of
Donghua University. The purpose of the study was to evaluate the lunch
programs implemented by the school administrator during the academic year of
2011. Respondents included 296 students, parents and teachers. The study
evaluated whether the lunch program management aim of students having good
health with good hygienic habits and saving attitudes, was achieved and realized.
Evaluation results revealed conserving context, input processes, and product
indicated in the performance in all aspects. Details of the performance include:
1)students, parents, and teachers understand the aim of the program and
develop hygienic habits; 2) personnel budget and material are adequate, 3) on
duty teachers give or help hand out lunch; 4) clean food is served with proper
nutrition; 5) and students are requested to clean dishes and put dishes in place.
The study concluded that the lunch program was able to reach or achieve its
aims for the program, which is that students with good health and hygienic habits
knew how to save.
42
43
44
45
46
Respondents:
__ Teachers
__ Canteen
personnel
Questionnaires
School Data
Process
Distribution,
Administration
and Retrieval
of the
Questionnaires
Collection of
data on
teachers
canteen
management
problems.
Statistical
treatment of
data.
Analysis and
interpretation of
data and
information
gathered.
Output
Assessment of
status of the
school canteen
practices .
Difference between
perception of the
two groups of
respondents on the
school canteen
management
practices in
selected public
elementary
schools in
Marikina City
District II during
school year 2016
2017.
Comments and
suggestions of the
respondents
Proposed
enhanced
handbook
47
FEEDBACK
The first frame shows the input of the study: the respondents of the study
where the number of which shall be determined using the Slovins Formula and
shall be chosen by stratified random sampling in the four schools in district II of
the Division of Marikina City.
In the second frame, the process, includes the following: distribution,
administration and retrieval of the questionnaires, the statistical treatment of
data and the analysis and interpretation of the data and information gathered will
be the next process.
For the third frame as output, the following was included: Assessment of
status of the school canteen practices, significant difference between the
perception of the two groups of respondents on the school canteen management
practices in selected public elementary schools in Marikina City District II
during
school
year
Research Hypotheses
48
On the basis of the statement of the problem and the research framework,
the hypotheses that were used for this study are the following:
1.
Definition of Terms
In order to arrive at a common understanding, the following terms used in
the study are hereby defined:
Academic. It refers to the performance of the students in all their classes
being assessed in their classroom skills and actions.
Assessment. It refers the observation of the pupils the teacher and
principal as means of evaluating the effectiveness of the canteen. It means how
the respondents feel about what they actually experience or see of the situation
of the school of the in the management of the activities, utilization of facilities
quality and quantity of food serve kind of service rendered to the consumers.
Canteen. Also known as cafeteria, a restaurant in which customers serve
themselves or are served at a counter and take the food to eat.
Canteen Management. In this research it includes the management of
the daily routine of the canteen. It is the administration of the direction of the
means and objectives of the school canteen which include operation food service
management physical facilities and canteen services,
49
cleaning
the use of water or another liquid, or with the use of soap, for the purpose
of removing soil, dirt, and/or microorganisms.
Meal Management. This means the efficient use of available resources in
providing meals that are nutritionally adequate, sanitary, economical and
aesthetically pleasing to the client.
Non-academic. It refers to the activity and performance of the students
during extra curricular actions which are basically non-academic in nature.
Nutrition . It is the intake of food, considered in relation to the
bodys dietary needs. Good nutrition an adequate, well balanced diet
combined with regular physical activity is a cornerstone of good health.
Poor nutrition can lead to reduced immunity, increased susceptibility to
disease,
impaired
productivity.
physical
and
mental
development,
and reduced
50
Quality of food. This refers to the aspects of the food which describes or
characterize in terms of nutrition, palatability, variety appearance and the like.
Quality of service. This refers to the manner of service employed by the
cafeteria personnel reflecting the personality of the server.
School Canteen . This refers to one of the ancillary services in the
school system that sells food items to the pupils/students and serves as a
support mechanism in the effort to eliminate malnutrition concerns of the
school. It can be used as a laboratory canteen on food planning,
preparation, serving, storage, and selling. A school canteen can either be
school management or teachers cooperative managed.
School Managed Canteen . Refers to a school canteen that is
operated and managed by the school under the general supervision of the
school head/principal.
Teachers Cooperative Managed Canteen . Refers to the canteen
that is operated and managed by a duly registered teachers cooperative.
Micronutrients . A substance, such as a vitamin or mineral, that
51
29
52