Final Draft of Sample Autopsy From Lawson Case

Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 8

COMMENT FROM DR.

WOOD: This is the 3rd and final draft


of the sample Autopsy Report from the gunshot case. I
marked up this version with additional comments that
point out specific things to pay attention to when
writing the final report as well as things that
distinguish this case from others.

Metropolitan Coroner's Office


Postmortem Examination
Of The Body Of

Linda Lawson

Case # FLC-608-Autopsy
A postmortem examination of the body of a 38-year-old Caucasian female identified as
Linda Lawson is performed at the Metropolitan Medical Examiners Office. The examination is
conducted by Dr. Thomas Burgess.
ATTENDANCE:
In the performance of their usual and customary duties, Autopsy Assistants Mike Smith
and Photographer Jane Scott are present during the autopsy. Also present during the autopsy is
Detective Joe Foster of the Metropolitan Police Department.
CLOTHING:
The body is received clad in black pants, leopard print sweater, white bra, white
underwear, black nylons and black shoes.
PROPERTY:
Yellow metal hoop style earrings are in both earlobes. A yellow metal band ring is on the
left ring finger.
IDENTIFICATION TAGS:
There is a Metropolitan morgue record band around the right wrist.
EXTERNAL EXAMINATION:
The body is that of a well-developed, well-nourished adult Caucasian female 120 pounds
and 65 inches, whose appearance is appropriate for the stated age of 38 years. The body is cold.
Rigor mortis is present. Livor mortis is purple, posterior and blanches with pressure.

The scalp hair is blonde, 4 inches in maximum length. The irides are brown. The sclerae
and conjunctivae are clear. The nose and ears are not unusual. The teeth are natural and in good
repair. The tongue appears normal.
The neck is unremarkable. The supraclavicular, cervical, axillary and inguinal lymph node
regions are free of palpable adenopathy. The thorax has a normal anterior-posterior diameter.
The abdomen is flat. The upper and lower extremities are well developed and symmetrical,
without evidence of clubbing or edema.
IDENTIFYING MARKS:
Identifying marks and scars include a small surgical scar in the right lower abdomen at
McBurneys point.
EVIDENCE OF MEDICAL INTERVENTION:
There is no evidence of medical intervention.
EVIDENCE OF INJURY:
Gunshot wound of the chest:
Entrance: On the midline chest over the sternum, 18 inches below the top of the head at the
anterior midline, is an entrance gunshot wound consisting of a 1 x 3/4 inch ovoid defect with a
circumferential red marginal abrasion ranging from less than 1/8 inch thick to 1/8 inch at its widest
point at the 3:00 position. Upon inspection by the naked eye, gunpowder particles, gunpowder
soot and gunpowder stippling are not present on the skin surrounding the wound. However,
minute punctate red abrasions are sparse on the skin up to 1/2 inch away from the wound edge.
Having washed away the blood, no other marks remain on the rest of the chest.
Path: The hemorrhagic wound track is through the skin and soft tissue of the chest, the lower
sternum, the pericardial sac, the apex of the cardiac ventricles, the lower thoracic spine, with the
bullet coming to rest in the soft tissues of the back. The right and left pleural cavities each contain
250 ml of liquid blood.
Recovery: From the thoracic spinal column is recovered a white metal bullet jacket without lead
core. From the soft tissue of the back is recovered a lead bullet core. Combined, the bullet and
jacket weigh 240 grains.
Trajectory: The wound track travels from the decedent's front to back, with minimal lateral or
vertical deviation.
Clothing: The front of the animal-print sweater has a 1 x 3/4 inch ovoid defect with torn edges.
Upon inspection by the naked eye, gunpowder particles and gunpowder soot are not apparent on
the fabric surrounding the defect.

X-Rays: An X-ray of the chest is performed, showing the described bullet and jacket that were
recovered at autopsy.
INTERNAL EXAMINATION:

COMMENT FROM DR. WOOD: A reminder that the Internal


Examination section documented the state of the
decedents organs/organ systems in the 1st draft.
Typically, you do not need to revise it in later
drafts.
The body is opened in the usual manner with a Y-shaped incision revealing the described
gunshot injuries.
CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM:
The heart is 230 grams and has the described evidence of injury. The pericardial surfaces
are otherwise smooth, glistening and unremarkable. Coronary arteries arise normally, following a
right dominant pattern with no significant atherosclerotic stenoses. The chambers and valves have
the usual size-position relationship. The cut surface of the myocardium is uniform dark redbrown. The atrial and ventricular septa are intact. The aorta and its major branches arise normally
and follow the usual course with no significant atherosclerosis. The vena cava and its major
tributaries are thin walled and patent, in the usual distribution.
RESPIRATORY SYSTEM:
The right lung is 270 grams, the left lung 230 grams. The tracheobronchial tree is patent
and the mucosal surfaces are intact. Pleural surfaces are translucent, smooth and glistening. The
pulmonary parenchyma is pink-tan to dark red-purple and exudes slight amounts of blood and
frothy fluid. Pulmonary arteries and veins are normally developed and patent.
DIGESTIVE/HEPATOBILIARY SYSTEM:
The esophagus is lined by intact, tan-white smooth mucosa. The gastric mucosa is
arranged in the usual rugal folds, and the lumen contains 300 ml of tan watery fluid. The small
and large intestines are unremarkable. The mesentery and omentum appear normal, and the
vessels are patent. The appendix is surgically absent. The colon contains formed stool. The
pancreas has the usual tan-white lobulated appearance, and the ducts are clear.
The liver is 1670 grams and has a smooth, intact capsule covering red-brown parenchyma.
The thin-walled gallbladder contains viscid bile. The extrahepatic biliary tree is patent.
ENDOCRINE SYSTEM:
The pituitary, thyroid and adrenal glands are unremarkable. Distinct parathyroid glands
are not seen.
3

GENITOURINARY SYSTEM:
The normal shaped kidneys together are 260 grams. The capsules are smooth, thin,
semitransparent, and strip with ease from the underlying, smooth, red-brown, firm, cortical
surfaces. The cortices are sharply delineated from the medullary pyramids. The calyces, pelves
and ureters are unremarkable. The urinary bladder contains 450 ml of clear urine; the mucosa is
gray-tan and intact.
Aside from surgical interruption of the fallopian tubes, the vagina, uterus, ovaries and
fallopian tubes are unremarkable. The breasts have the usual fibrous and adipose mixture.
HEMATOPOIETIC SYSTEM:
The thymus is appropriate in size and configuration for the age of the decedent. The
spleen is 100 grams and has a smooth intact capsule covering red-purple parenchyma with wellpreserved follicular and trabecular markings. The regional lymph nodes have their usual
distribution and appearance. The bone marrow, where seen, is red-brown and homogeneous,
without focal abnormality.
MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM:
Aside from the described injuries, the bony framework, supporting musculature and soft
tissues are not unusual.
NECK:
Examination of the soft tissues of the neck, including strap muscles and large vessels,
reveals no abnormalities. The hyoid bone and larynx are intact.
NERVOUS SYSTEM:
The scalp is reflected without difficulty, and is unremarkable. The brain is 1340 grams.
The dura mater and falx cerebri are intact, and the leptomeninges are thin and delicate. The
cerebral hemispheres are symmetrical, with a normal pattern and distribution of sulci and gyri.
The structures at the base of the brain, including cranial nerves and blood vessels, are intact and
free of abnormality. Coronal sections of the cerebral hemispheres reveal no lesions within the
cortex, subcortical white matter, or deep parenchyma of either hemisphere. The cerebral
ventricles are of normal caliber, containing clear cerebrospinal fluid. Sections through the brain
stem and cerebellum are unremarkable.
MICROSCOPIC EXAMINATION

COMMENT FROM DR. WOOD: A reminder that the Microscopic


Examination section documented the results of the
microscopic analysis in the 2nd draft. Typically, you
do not need to revise it for the final report.
Heart, lungs, liver, kidney, brain: No significant pathologic changes.
Skin, entrance wound: No soot seen. This finding supports the theory of a distant or intermediate
range wound. A weapon fired from either intermediate or distant range would not leave soot
marks on the skin surrounding the entry wound.

PATHOLOGIC DIAGNOSES

COMMENT FROM DR. WOOD: This section should have


documented the cause of death and identified any
additional factors that may have contributed to the
death (e.g., disease or behaviors of decedent) as part
of the 2nd draft. The sample case has not changed since
the 2nd draft.
I.

Penetrating gunshot wound of the chest


A.
Entrance wound of anterior chest, intermediate to distant range
B.
Perforation of heart with internal bleeding
C.
Recovery of 240 grain bullet and white metal jacket
D.
Trajectory: Front to back without significant lateral or vertical deviation
OPINION

COMMENT FROM DR. WOOD: As part of the final report, it


is very important that the Opinion section is well
written, easy to understand (by non-medical readers),
and polished. Build on the detailed analysis from your
earlier drafts. Expand on your explanations of the
biological reasons behind the death and any
contributing factors that increased the likelihood of
this persons cause of death. Remember: this is the
section the decedents family and other non-medical
professionals (e.g., police investigators, attorneys)
who are involved in the case will read to understand
what happened. It needs to be detailed and easy to
follow.

In some cases, it is also appropriate to explain


relevant aspects of the autopsy process. In this
sample case, the ballistics process is explained
because the range of fire plays a key role in
determining whether the death was a homicide or
suicide. These are important details that the family
and law enforcement officials need to understand.
When finalizing an Autopsy Report, it is helpful to
summarize basic details of the case including a
definition of the cause of death, epidemiology,
etiology, etc. This provides the family with important
context for the case when compared to other cases where
the cause of death is the same. Follow the same
structure (i.e., use same headings, etc.) when writing
any Autopsy Report but provide details that are
specific to each individual case (e.g., laboratory
findings are relevant in a case where the person dies
of a hereditary disease but not relevant to a gunshot
case, as noted below).
This 38-year-old woman, Linda Lawson, died of a gunshot wound of the chest.
According to reports, she was in an altercation with her husband that resulted in her being shot.
At the time of investigation, it was unclear whether it was self-inflicted or not.
Autopsy examination revealed a penetrating gunshot wound of the chest, which damaged the
heart and resulted in internal bleeding. The bullet was recovered in two pieces from the spine and
from the back. While the ballistics findings allow some room for interpretation, the characteristics
of the entrance defect are consistent with an intermediate to distant range wound.
TOXICOLOGY FINDINGS
Toxicology testing on the decedent did not show any drugs of abuse or toxins that would
contribute to her death. Ethanol (0.120 mg%) was at a moderately elevated level. While alcohol
affects people differently, this level would not cause or contribute to the death. However, it may
have contributed to circumstances surrounding the death (e.g., arguments).
RANGE OF FIRE / BALLISTICS FINDINGS

In this case, determination of "range of fire" is the most important aspect of the investigation.
"Range of fire" defines the distance between the end of the gun barrel and the decedent when the
gun was fired, and can be divided into four main categories. A distant range of fire (greater than
2 feet in this case) is defined by the absence of any gunshot materials around the gunshot wound
on the skin and clothing. An intermediate range of fire is defined by gunpowder stippling (injury
from gunshot particles on the skin) or distinct gunshot particles on the clothing, without
gunpowder soot. A close range of fire is defined by the presence of both gunpowder soot and
gunshot particles around the wound or on the clothing. Lastly, a contact range of fire is defined
by extensive damage to the skin and/or clothing from heat, soot and searing when the gun is held
in contact to the person when it is fired.
In this case, the range of fire appears to be either distant or at least at the far end of intermediate
range, making it nearly impossible for the decedent to have shot herself.
Determining range of fire takes a coordinated effort between the pathologist and ballistics expert.
Any alteration in the tissues or destruction of clothing can adversely affect the test results.
Therefore, it is important that all evidence has a documented chain of custody and is not
mishandled prior to examination. Further, it is just as important to have a thorough autopsy
performed by an experienced and well-trained forensic pathologist.
The ballistics findings show that the weapon was fired from an intermediate range of about 14
inches (in this case) (14-inch distance determination test results match most closely to the results
of the Greiss test). However, other findings suggest the gun may have been fired at a more
distant range than that. There are no findings that suggest a close range of fire.
Findings consistent distant range include:
No stippling on the skin (consistent with either longer-range intermediate distance or
distant range distant equaling 24 or more inches from the body, in this case)
Findings consistent with intermediate range include:
Gunpowder particles on the clothing (If the gun were shot at a closer range, there should
be more gunpowder and stippling would be more clearly identifiable.)
There is the presence of some red marks on the skin, which could be interpreted to be stippling.
The opinion of this pathologist is that it is not stippling, but is more likely to have been caused by
the material of the decedents sweater against the skin at the time of the bullets impact.
However, if it were stippling, it could suggest a closer intermediate range of fire.
The closer range of fire is unlikely, because, the Greiss test shows only three nitrite particles,
suggesting a further intermediate range of fire. If the gun were shot at closer range there would
be more nitrite particles. If the gun was fired from a more distant range, there would be no
gunpowder particles at all.
In conclusion, the bullet would, or defect, is consistent with an intermediate to distant range (most
likely longer range of intermediate) wound, and most certainly not consistent with a close range of
fire wound, making it nearly impossible for Linda to have shot herself. Therefore, the manner of
death is conclusively homicide.

SUMMARY FINDINGS
Definition
A gunshot wound is a wound made with a bullet or missile projected by a firearm.
In this case, the bullet struck the decedent in the heart.
Epidemiology
Homicide rates are highest among teens while rates for adults over 35 remain
steady. Based on 2005 statistics, men are almost four times as likely to be
murdered than women and blacks are six times as likely to be murdered than
whites.
Etiology
Gunshot wound is either inflicted by another person (homicide) or self-inflicted
(suicide). This is a case of homicide.
Pathogenesis
When someone suffers a gunshot wound to the chest/heart, there is a massive
amount of immediate blood loss and the heart stops bleeding, most often resulting
in immediate death.
Manifestations
Gunshot wounds to the result in death in nearly all cases. Death is usually instant
when the heart stops beating due to the physical damage caused by the bullet. In
few cases, there may be a short period (e.g., several seconds to a minute) during
which the gunshot victim may still be able to make purposeful movements.
Laboratory Findings
Not relevant in this case.
Prognosis
The prognosis for a gunshot wound to the chest/heart includes the possibility of
survival, if immediate medical treatment (i.e., surgery to repair organ damage).
Death is statistically more likely when significant damage is done to the heart, a
vital organ. Death is even more likely (and/or more immediate) in cases where the
gunshot victim had a history of heart disease.
Treatment
Treatment, when possible (i.e., damage is not too extensive), would call for
immediate surgery to repair the organ damage done by the gunshot wound to the
heart.
Given the evidence, the defect is consistent with an intermediate to distant range wound, making
it nearly impossible for Linda to have shot herself. Therefore the manner is homicide.

You might also like