FYP Report
FYP Report
FYP Report
Transmission
By
NUST201200522BSMME11112F
NUST201200287BSMME11112F
NUST201201370BSMME11112F
NUST201200818BSMME11112F
Supervised By
Assistant Professor Dr. Samiur Rahman Shah
By
NUST201200522BSMME11112F
NUST201200287BSMME11112F
NUST201201370BSMME11112F
NUST201200818BSMME11112F
Supervised By
Assistant Professor Dr. Samiur Rahman Shah
We hereby recommend that the dissertation prepared under our supervision by: Fajar Sohail
Latif
(NUST201200522BSMME11112F),
Khuldoon
Usman
grade)
1.
Name:
Signature:_________________
2.
Name:
Signature:_________________
Supervisors Name:
Signature:_________________
Date:__________________
_____________________
Head of Department
__________________
Date
COUNTERSIGNED
Date:_______________
__________________
Dean/Principal
Declaration
We certify that this research work titled Design, Analysis and Prototype Manufacturing of a
Sequential Transmission is our own work. The work has not been presented elsewhere for
assessment. The material that has been used from other sources has been properly
acknowledged / referred.
Khuldoon Usman
NUST201200287BSMME11112F
Mukaram Ali
NUST201200818BSMME11112F
Copyright Statement
Copyright in text of this thesis rests with the student author. Copies (by any process)
either in full, or of extracts, may be only in accordance with the instructions given by
author and lodged in the Library of SMME, NUST. Details may be obtained by the
librarian. This page must be part of any such copies made. Further copies (by any
process) of copies made in accordance with such instructions may not be made without
the permission (in writing) of the author.
The ownership of any intellectual property rights which may be described in this thesis is
vested in SMME, NUST, subject to any prior agreement to the contrary, and may not be
made available for use of third parties without the written permission of SMME, NUST
which will describe the terms and conditions of any such agreement.
Further information on the conditions under which disclosure and exploitation may take
place is available from the library of SMME, NUST, Islamabad.
ii
Acknowledgments
First of all, we would thank Allah Almighty, who gave us the knowledge and dedication to be
able to complete this project. We are extremely grateful to our supervisor, Dr. Samiur
Rahman Shah, for giving us the guidance required to complete this endeavor of ours. Our
departments Design and Manufacturing Resource Centre also assisted us greatly. We would
like to extend our gratitude to our entire department, its faculty and staff, for all their
assistance in our project.
iii
Abstract
The purpose of this project was to design a sequential transmission for our departments
formula student car, and also to analyze that design. We successfully performed both, using
Solidworks and Ansys for the respective tasks. We also produced a 3D-printed prototype of
the transmission. The latter part of project, though, involved preparing the prototype vehicle
for the formula student competition, of which some components were already available,
while the rest we had to manufacture
iv
Table of Contents
Declaration................................................................................................................................. i
Copyright Statement ................................................................................................................ii
List of Figures .........................................................................................................................vii
List of Tables ........................................................................................................................... ix
Symbols ................................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Chapter 1 Introduction............................................................................................................ 1
1.1
Background ................................................................................................................. 1
1.2
1.3
Research Methodology................................................................................................ 2
1.4
2.2
2.2
2.3.1
Methodologies...................................................................................................... 5
2.3.2
Problems .............................................................................................................. 6
2.4
2.5
2.6
3.2
3.3
3.3.1
3.4
3.4.1
3.4.2
3.5
Components............................................................................................................... 25
4.2
4.3
Conclusions ............................................................................................................... 33
5.2
References ............................................................................................................................... 34
vi
List of Figures
Figure 2.1 Front wheel drive. a) Longitudinal engine in front of axle, longitudinal gearbox; b)
longitudinal engine behind axle, longitudinal gearbox; c) longitudinal engine above axle,
longitudinal gearbox; d) transverse engine beside the gearbox; e) transverse engine
above the gearbox; f) transverse engine behind the gearbox ............................................. 4
Figure 2.2 Bending stress at the tooth root with force acting on the tip .................................... 5
Figure 2.3 Deflection f and bending angle in shafts with large distances between bearings
and asymmetrical loading. ................................................................................................. 6
Figure 2.4 Torque limits of case-hardened, lubricated gearwheels plotted against tangential
speed. ................................................................................................................................. 8
Figure 2.5 Vibration fatigue failure in a spur gear..................................................................... 8
Figure 2.6 Macropitting due to flank surface fatigue ................................................................ 9
Figure 3.1 Input shaft (with the first gear) ............................................................................... 12
Figure 3.2 2nd gear input shaft ............................................................................................. 12
Figure 3.3 3rd gear input shaft .............................................................................................. 13
Figure 3.4 4th gear input shaft .............................................................................................. 13
Figure 3.5 5th gear input shaft .............................................................................................. 14
Figure 3.6 Bushing ................................................................................................................... 14
Figure 3.7 Output shaft ............................................................................................................ 15
Figure 3.8 1st gear output shaft............................................................................................. 15
Figure 3.9 4th gear output shaft ............................................................................................ 16
Figure 3.10 Input shaft assembly ............................................................................................. 16
Figure 3.11 Output shaft assembly .......................................................................................... 17
Figure 3.12 Gearbox assembly ................................................................................................ 17
Figure 3.13 Final input shaft assembly .................................................................................... 18
Figure 3.14 Final output shaft assembly .................................................................................. 19
Figure 3.15 Casing cross-section ............................................................................................. 19
Figure 3.16 Gear Selector Cam Drum (Barrel) ........................................................................ 20
Figure 3.17 Final Gearbox assembly ....................................................................................... 20
Figure 3.18 1st gear torque ...................................................................................................... 21
Figure 3.19 2nd gear torque ..................................................................................................... 21
vii
viii
List of Tables
ix
Chapter 1
Introduction
1.1
Background
Less than nearly four decades ago, a competition was started in which teams of university
students would design and construct racing vehicles and compete against eachother.
Nowadays this competition is known as Formula SAE. Three years ago, the School of
Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering (SMME), NUST commenced work on a vehicle
to participate in this competition in the near future. Since then, its students, under the
supervision of the departments automotive expert Dr. Samiur Rahman Shah, have been
involved in the construction of this vehicle. The design and fabrication of various
components of this vehicle have been undertaken as final year projects by groups of students.
This year, one of those components was the transmission of the vehicle.
1.2
The aim of this project was to design a sequential transmission for the formula student
vehicle. The required design would need to satisfy the following criteria:
Be lighter in weight
Another major deliverable was to complete the Formula Student vehicle. This deliverable
included the following objectives.
Design of Upright components and their integration with the chassis and the
suspension system of the vehicle.
1.3
Designing and constructing the suspension components along with chassis mountings.
Steering behavior and suspension analysis for camber, caster and scrub radius setup.
Research Methodology
The literature study was carried out by technical books reading, video lectures and tutorials,
seeking professional design help and through physical examination of similar components.
1.4
Thesis Structure
The brief description of the contents of the remaining chapters in thesis is described below.
Chapter 2 Literature Review: This chapter outlines the details of the literature consulted
and other aides used for the initial design concept of the transmission. This includes, besides
deign, the study carried out for making modifications to the stock transmission available and
suspension design setup.
Error! Reference source not found. Transmission Design and Analysis: This chapter will
discuss the basic rules and criteria defined for designing the transmission. This includes all
details from gear ratios, gear sizing, mesh type and sizing of the shafts. The FEM modeling
of all the parts is also part of this.
Error! Reference source not found. Vehicle Construction: This chapter will discuss the
design and manufacturing limitations faced during the process; including FSAE rules
modification limitations on available components. Gearbox alterations and iterative failures
to adhere to the chassis dimensional limits.
Chapter 5 Conclusions and Future Work: This chapter presents the conclusion of the
conducted research along with the proposed future work.
Chapter 2
Literature Review
2.1
Type of Transmission
This chapter discusses the type of transmission that we undertook from designing. Categories
include constant mesh and synchromesh transmissions, gear types, speeds for transmission,
transverse or longitudinally mounted transmission etc. The book Automotive Transmissions
Fundamentals, Selection, Design and Application (1) was consulted to decide this.
The table above is a guide to different types of gear configurations that could be used for
designing the transmission.
Figure 2.1 Front wheel drive. a) Longitudinal engine in front of axle, longitudinal gearbox; b) longitudinal
engine behind axle, longitudinal gearbox; c) longitudinal engine above axle, longitudinal gearbox; d)
transverse engine beside the gearbox; e) transverse engine above the gearbox; f) transverse engine behind the
gearbox
The transmission that was finalized was an all spur gear transversely-mounted constantmesh 4-speed gearbox.
2.2
The Formula Student rule book 2016 was used to decide on design and machining of any
components. This includes maximum allowed tracks speeds, different types of differentials
allowed and manufacturing materials allowed.
The formulas for gear design were consulted, and so were the stress and bending formulas for
analysis.
Equation 2.1
where:
Ft
b
ma
YFa
YSa
Y
Y
KA
KV
KF
KF
where:
F, lim
YST
YNT
Y,relT
YX
The safety factor can then be calculated as a quotient of the two values calculated above,
Equation 2.3
Figure 2.2 Bending stress at the tooth root with force acting on the tip
2.2
Shaft Design
2.3.1 Methodologies
Following are the three approaches when designing shafts for transmissions:
1. Initially specifying the diameters of the shafts: This involves an initial estimate of the
shaft diameters required for a given loading.
5
2. Designing shafts for endurance strength: Using the maximum engine torque to work
out the maximum expected force, the transmission is designed such that is able to
sustain that load without succumbing to fatigue. An over-engineered transmission is
one which is entirely fatigue resistant, even under maximum load.
3. Specifying the operational fatigue strength of the shafts: Having decided upon a
service life for the shaft, it is designed based on existing load profiles. These profiles
are built base on the load each gear carries, and the mileage sun by each gear.
2.3.2 Problems
Two problems to which transmission shafts are particularly vulnerable to are deflection and
vibrations.
Deflection: In vehicle transmissions, there are large distances between shaft bearings and the
shaft loading is generally unbalanced. This results in large deflections f and large bending
angles (Figure 8.3). Additionally, the teeth become inclined, reducing the contact area
between gears in a pair, increasing stress. Shaft deflection, thus, has to be taken into account
alongside strength calculations.
Figure 2.3 Deflection f and bending angle in shafts with large distances between bearings and asymmetrical
loading.
Vibration: Vibrations, in essence, cause the transmission to become more rigid while it
undergoes its rotary motion. This additional stiffness varies with speed and gear position,
resulting in stress peaks at certain points. It is vital to study, and thus, nullify these peaks for
the transmission to serve its desired life. Vibration analysis can be performed on either test
benches or via computer simulation. There are numerous mathematical models available.
2.4
The use of spurs gears is solely based on their efficiency rating and easy availability and
machine-ability in the current market.
2.5
Gears are designed based on their performance limits, i.e. their causes of failure. These limits
basically consist of 4 different types of gear failure:
tooth failure,
These damage types limit the load capacity of the gearwheels (Figure 2.4). The major factors
affecting the performance limits indicated above are:
the material,
gear geometry,
manufacturing accuracy,
Out of the 4 above-mentioned damage types, the two more prominent ones, tooth failure and
macropitting, are discussed below.
Tooth failure: it is defined as failure where the tooth breaks off, partly or in its entirety. This
is further classified into overload failure and vibration fatigue failure. The former occurs
when the gear pair is briefly burdened with an intense overload. For the latter to occur, the
stress level should at least intermittently be greater than the vibrational resistance of the gear.
This resistance is largely determined by factors such as tooth root design, surface and heat
treatments, etc. Figure 7.3 shows vibration fatigue failure in a straight spur gear.
Macropitting: Characterized by formations such as pin holes or pits on the flanks of gear
teeth, usually below the pitch circle. It indicates fatigue at the tooth flanks. Pitting load
capacity is calculated using Hertzian stress, which forms the basis for computing surface
stress. However, it should be notes that the corresponding subsurface stress is as responsible
for pitting as surface stress.
2.6
Lubrication System
Under consideration were splash lubrication vs forced lubrication systems for the
transmission. The conventional splash lubrication system was selected keeping in view its
simplicity over forced lubrication, its application in our 4-speed sequential transmission and
RPM range.
Chapter 3
Transmission Design and Analysis
3.1
Design Concept
The basic design of the transmission was based on a motorcycle transmission - a sequential
type of transmission - with gears and gear ratio calculations defined by parameters including
but not limited to top speed, acceleration, mass of transmission, maximum torque and
horsepower of the engine.
We had also acquired a Daihatsu Mira transmission, which we dismantled and examined
each component individually not only to understand its working, but also to take
measurements from, which would serve as the initial iterations of our gears parameters.
These parameters were modified to suit both standards and our requirements.
The table below details all data relevant to gearbox:
10
The design is based on metric standards of gears and shafts, and the designing was carried out
in Solidworks 2015.
3.2
The table below shows the calculations needed for the vehicle:
Table 3.2 Speed, force and acceleration calculations for each gear
3.3
First Draft
The initial draft was totally based on Daihatsu Mira 5-speed gearbox with a top speed of
approximately 200 km/h with a time to top speed of around 11 seconds.
The pictures below show the first draft.
11
12
13
14
2nd and 3rd gears are similar to 1st gear, just with different gear ratios.
15
16
17
3.4
Final Draft
The initial draft comprised of a 5-speed transmission. After further research and
consideration, a final draft with a 4-speed transmission was designed. Major factors under
consideration were top speed, weight and moment of inertia.
3.4.1 Transmission Components
All the gear ratios were kept the same. The fifth gear configuration was removed, shafts
adjusted accordingly and the dogs altered to suit the shifting mechanism.
The final shafts and assembly along with the pinion gear for the differential are shown below.
18
19
20
21
The next three figures display the gear-tooth analysis of each gear pair.
22
The analysis behavior of the output shaft and 4th gear assembly are similar because of their
given diameter and relation to the other gears and input shaft. The stresses and strains in each
simulation were within the elastic limits of the materials.
23
3.5
3D printed prototype
24
Chapter 4
Vehicle Construction
4.1
Components
The following components were already available to us at the start of our project:
The chassis
25
Engine mountings
The unequal A-arms were used in conjunction with the uprights and Honda CG125
suspension springs to make up the suspension system. The caster factor was introduced for
optimum steer feel and behavior. This was simulated through a model in Solidworks (Fig.
4.2.). Limited adjustability of around 8 degrees allowed for camber settings.
26
A custom built steering system was used in conjunction with quad bike tie-rods for length
adjustments.
The axles had to be elongated due to the modifications in the hub and suspension.
Furthermore, custom mountings had to be constructed for the engine.
27
28
29
4.2
Caster = 12 degrees
Scrub Radius = 4 mm
Standard SS bolts were used. Majorly 10mm with certain exceptions e.g. Uprights
bolts
All construction and manufacturing were carried out keeping into consideration FSAE
rules.
30
4.3
Final Vehicle
Figure 4.9 Mounting the suspension and tires onto the frame
31
32
Chapter 5
Conclusions and Future Work
5.1
Conclusions
In summary, we were able to design a sequential transmission for the Formula Student
vehicle of our department. Furthermore, we conducted successful stress analyses on the
gearwheels and shafts of our transmission, and even produced a 3D-printed prototype. On the
other hand, we also assembled the prototype vehicle to near-completion, putting together the
previously available parts with newly manufactured ones.
5.2
Future Work
1. Vibrational analysis of the designed gearbox.
2. Manufacturing of the sequential transmission and attaching it to the Daihatsu Mira
engine of the actual racing vehicle for the competition.
3. Completing the prototype vehicle with the wiring of the engine, installation of the
brakes, and attachment of body kits, seats and other external elements. With this
vehicle up and running, the team will be able to secure sponsors for manufacturing the
actual vehicle for the competition. This vehicle will also serve as a test vehicle on
which the team will be able to perform trial and error.
4. Completing the competition vehicle which will feature a new chassis, suspension,
braking and steering systems and the manufactured transmission as well.
33
References
[1]
34