Excerpt from Chapter 2, Sustainability, of Design and Control of Concrete Mixtures, 15th edition.

Life-Cycle Analysis
A life-cycle analysis is a tool used to select building materials and influence design choices.
Life-Cycle Cost Analysis
A life-cycle-cost analysis (LCCA) is the practice of accounting for all expenditures incurred over
the servicelife of a particular structure. An LCCA is performed in units of dollars and is equal to
the construction (initial or first) costs plus the present value of future utility, maintenance,
insurance, and replacement costs over the service life of the building. Quite often, designs with
the lowest first costs for new construction require higher maintenance costs and generate higher
energy costs during the service life. Thus these structures will have a higher lifecycle cost.
Conversely, durable designs using concrete, often have life-cycle costs that are less than those
using other construction materials.
The service life must be accurately reflected in an LCCA study for the impact of concrete use to
be correctly measured. The service life of building interiors and equipment is often considered to
be 30 years, but the average life of the building shell ranges from 50 to 100 years. Studies that
use too short of a service life, for example a twenty year service life, produce skewed and
incorrect LCCA results. Such studies overstate the cost of construction materials and understate
the cost of maintaining and operating the structure.
Life-Cycle Assessment and Inventory
A life-cycle assessment (LCA) is an environmental assessment of the life cycle of a product or
process. Moving towards sustainable engineering solutions requires a better understanding of
construction activities that affect the natural environment. The products and services that we
consume impact the environment throughout their service life, beginning with raw materials
extraction and product manufacturing, continuing on through use and operation, and finally
ending with a waste management strategy (Figure 1). Alternately, the ultimate use may include
evolution of the building or product back into its natural constituents. The LCA of a structure is a
requisite measure necessary to evaluate the environmental impact of a product or structure over
its useful life. Conventional assessments often overlook one or more of these phases, leading to
incomplete results and indefensible conclusions.

Figure 1. Generic Product Life Cycle.

A life cycle inventory (LCI), the first portion of an LCA, includes all of the materials and energy
inputs as well as any emissions to air, water, and land (solid waste) from the stages listed in
Figure 1. Marceau, Nisbet, and VanGeem (2007) provide a detailed life cycle inventory of
portland cement concretes using a variety of mixture proportions with and without
supplementary cementitious materials. Marceau, Nisbet and VanGeem (2006) also provide a life
cycle inventory of portland cement manufacture. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory
(NREL) U.S. Life Cycle Inventory Database provides an accounting of energy and material
flows for materials, components, and assemblies in the United States (www.nrel.gov/lci).
An LCA provides a consistent methodology applied across all products and at all stages of their
production, transport, use, and recycling at end of life or disposal, A full LCA includes the
effects of operational energy such as heating and cooling (and associated emissions) and raw
material use over the life of the product or structure. A full LCA categorizes these effects into
impact categories such as land use, resource use, climate change, health effects acidification, and
toxicity. ISO Standard 14044 provides guidance on conducting a full LCA (ISO 2006).
These guidelines offer a standardized method for conducting an LCA, but do not discuss the
specifics relevant to a particular product. Mapping the life cycle, developing functional units,
drawing systems boundaries, and mining data are left to the discretion and challenge of
individual practitioners. As more information regarding the product and its application are
known, the specifics can be better described and assessed. Tables 1 and 2 demonstrate the
life cycle phases and components for concrete pavements and buildings. Even though the basic
material (concrete) and phases (materials, construction, use, and end of life) are the same, many
of the components in the life cycle are different, especially in the use phase. Understanding and
modeling the application of the product are key steps in accurately quantifying its impact.
Table 1. LCA Phases and Components for Concrete
Pavements

Table 2. LCA Phases and Components for Concrete

Data for LCA come from a wide variety of sources, including government databases, industry
reports, system models, and first-hand collection. Since the entire life cycle is being analyzed,
the volume of necessary data is often large and overwhelming. There are a number of other
LCA tools that have been developed for general building professionals. LCA software packages,
such as GaBi, SimaPro, and EIO-LCA, can assist in the data collection process, and can provide
modeling framework. The NREL U.S. LCI Database provides data for cement and concrete
as well as other materials. The NIST LCA model, Building for Environmental and Economic
Sustainability (BEES), addresses a variety of concrete elements and structures with numerous
mixture proportions (www.bfrl.nist.gov/oae/software/bees/bees.html). These types of packages
are generally proficient at quantifying upstream impacts for commodities, but third-party
information is often necessary to evaluate detailed processes and niche products. External
models, such as those describing building energy consumption, vehicle dynamics, or electricity
generation, are commonly used to complement the core LCA and provide spatial, temporal, and
system-specific data. Such models are particularly useful when characterizing the operation
phase of the life cycle.
It is important to use tools that consider all aspects of a comprehensive LCA, including all of the
impact categories (not just primary energy and CO2, for example), over the entire life of a
building, pavement or product (including operational energy). A unique strength of LCA is the
ability to quantify environmental impact using a host of different metrics. While LEED and other
environmental rating systems measure performance using a single point score, LCA breaks
results into individual pollutant emissions and environmental impact categories. The life-cycle
inventory (LCI) stage generates results in the form of specific inputs and outputs of the systems,
such as carbon dioxide to air or copper to water. The life-cycle impact assessment step (LCIA)
provides additional information to help assess the inventory results by categorizing the results
into impact categories. Some widely used categories include global warming potential,
eutrophication, water consumption, ecotoxicity, and human health impact. With such a large
variety of ways to characterize impact, assessments can be tailored to address specific goals and
objectives for an individual study.
When concrete is used, the LCA tool should allow the input of the cement content and the use of
supplementary cementitious materials. This is critical as the cement content dominates the
environmental impact of the concrete. Most simplified LCA tools assume a single cement con
tent to represent all concrete and this oversimplification does not include the value derived from
operational energy efficiencies. Although results for individual impacts may vary, full LCAs
performed according to ISO 14044 usually show similar overall results for concrete, wood, and
steel structures unless a particular system is optimized for maximum energy performance or
minimal material usage. This is in contrast to simplified tools that use far too many assumptions
or consider too few impact categories that one material or product will dominate the results.
LCAs can be used for any number of purposes. The flexible analysis framework and quantitative
approach make LCA particularly useful for comparing alternative systems, validating and
marketing green claims, establishing environmental footprints, and identifying opportunities for
improvement within the life cycle. However, arguably the strongest applications are those
centered on creating sound environmental policies. As a policy instrument, LCA provides
comprehensive and scientifically defensible strategies to reducing environmental impact. The
life-cycle approach ensures that policies are not implemented that benefit from near-term

improvements at the expense of long-term deficits. Adopting such insightful policies is the key
to establishing a sustainable path towards environmental goals.
References
ISO, Environmental Management Life cycle Assessment Requirements and Guidelines,
ISO14044:2006, International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland, 2006, 46
pages.
Marceau, Medgar L.; Nisbet, Michael A.; and VanGeem, Martha G., Life Cycle Inventory of
Portland Cement Manufacture, SN2095b, Portland Cement Association, Skokie, Illinois, 2006,
69 pages.
Marceau, Medgar L.; Nisbet, Michael A.; and VanGeem, Martha G., Life Cycle Inventory of
Portland Cement Concrete, SN3011, Portland Cement Association, Skokie, Illinois, 2007, 69
pages.

Click here to purchase Design and Control of Concrete Mixtures