Park County Shooting Report

Colorado Bureau of Investigation
ACISS Case Master Report 2016-59

Date Initiated 02/24/2016
Primary Information
AGENCY:
COLORADO BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
DIVISION:
INVESTIGATIONS
OFFICE:
DENVER
Lead LEO:
LEE, TAMMY AGT (5202 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Type Of Case:
Homicide
Case Description:
Officer Involved Shooting
Total Time:
391:30
Related Tips
Number
T2016-466
Entry Date
02/24/2016 13:08
Occurred Date
---
Status
CLOSED
Description
Park County Request -Officer
Involved Shooting
Case Status
Case Status:
CLOSED ASSISTANCE GIVEN
Case Status Date:
05/26/2016
Disposition Code:
CLOSED ASSIST GIVEN
Disposition Date:
05/26/2016
Dissemination:
System Wide
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
ACISS software licensed by Colorado Bureau of Investigation
Page 1 of 1

ACISS INVESTIGATIVE 2016-59
Report Date: 02/26/2016
Primary Information
Description:
SCENE OBSERVATIONS
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Source Of Info:
LOCAL AGENCY
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Confirmed
Reporting LEO:
MEANS, JERRY AGT (5640 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/01/2016
Approved By:
LEWIS, KIRBY QUINN AIC (5223 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Synopsis
SYNOPSIS:
The Reporting Agent (RA) was requested to respond to the scene of a shooting in Park County were several officers were shot while
serving legal papers. The RA arrived at the scene and met with several other agents from the Denver Colorado Bureau of
Investigation office. The RA was assigned to stand by the scene.
The RA documented scene observations, assisted the Colorado State Patrol with traffic, and provided cell phone photographs
(Attached) of the home to assist Agent TAMMY LEE with the search warrant. The RA provided scene updates to other Agents at the
command post, and documented the position of two of the Park County Sheriff's Office vehicles so they could be placed back into
service (Per Sergeant F. CONNER).
Address #1 - DISPATCHED TO #1 - 36 IRIS DR

Primary Information
Address:
36 IRIS DR, BAILEY, COLORADO 80421 , UNITED STATES
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Related Officers
LEO
CONNER, FRANK (SERGEANT / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
MOEN, ROBERT (SPECIAL AGENT / FBI COLORADO SPRINGS)
Record Status Information

Record Origination Operator:
Record Origination Date:
02/26/2016 10:10
Last Update Operator:
Last Update Date:
03/01/2016 13:39
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 1 of 4

ACISS INVESTIGATIVE 2016-59
Reporting LEO
MEANS, JERRY AGT (5640 / DENVER /
Colorado Bureau of Investigation Denver)
Date
Supervisor
LEWIS, KIRBY QUINN AIC (5223 /
DENVER / Colorado Bureau of
Investigation - Denver)
Date
5/26/2016
Narrative begins on the following page.
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 2 of 4
2016-59
SYNOPSIS:
The Reporting Agent (RA) was requested to respond to the scene of a shooting in Park County were
several officers were shot while serving legal papers. The RA arrived at the scene and met with several
other agents from the Denver Colorado Bureau of Investigation office. The RA was assigned to stand
by the scene.
The RA documented scene observations, assisted the Colorado State Patrol with traffic, and provided
cell phone photographs (Attached) of the home to assist Agent TAMMY LEE with the search warrant.
The RA provided scene updates to other Agents at the command post, and documented the position of
two of the Park County Sheriff's Office vehicles so they could be placed back into service (Per Sergeant
F. CONNER).
ACTION TAKEN:
The RA responded to the scene of an officer involved shooting in Park County at the request of Agent
in Charge (AIC) KIRBY LEWIS. The RA was advised three Park County officers were shot while they
were attempting to serve legal papers to the occupant of 36 Iris Drive, Bailey Colorado. The RA
arrived at the scene at approximately 10:55a.m. The scene and surrounding area were secured by
members of the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office. Three Park County Deputies were present at the
scene. Agent TAMMY LEE met with the deputies and made initial arrangements to begin interviews
away from the scene. The RA met with Agent TAMMY LEE and was assigned to stand by the scene
while other agents responded to the local fire department and the designated command post.
The RA assisted the Colorado State Patrol with traffic control. The RA observed numerous Jefferson
County deputies at the scene and learned they were in the process of coordinating with their bomb
squad to travel through the home and survey the area for hidden explosive hazards. Agent LEE sent out
a page indicating she was in the process of writing a search warrant. The RA remained on stand by at
the scene during the process.
The RA was contacted by Agent LEE at approximately 1:00 p.m. and requested the RA obtain
photographs of the structure to aid in the drafting of the search warrant. The RA met with the Jefferson
County Sheriffs Office sergeant and was cleared to approach the home from the south side where
deputies securing the area were located. The RA took 4 cell phone photographs and texted them to
Agent LEE. The home sits on its lot at an angle. The RA considered the east side of the home the side
the fifth-wheel trailer was located. The photographs were taken from what was considered the south
side. Once the RA had the opportunity to pull the address up on Google Earth it appeared the fifth
wheel was actually located more on the north side of the home, and the warrant photographs were taken
of east side.
The RA was contacted by Sergeant FRANK CONNER of the Park County Sheriff's Office who
indicated he needed to remove two of the perimeter vehicles that had responded to the scene. The RA
attempted to contact the lab agents that had responded to the incident. The lab could not be contacted.
The RA examined the vehicles and documented their locations. The vehicles were both parked away
from the site of the shooting and it appeared responding deputies had staged their vehicles and walked
up toward the house (36 Iris Drive). A vehicle with plate (CO 680-ZEC) was parked along the right
LEE, TAMMY AGT (5202 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation)
02/26/2016
Page 1
2016-59
side of Iris Drive, approximately 80 feet southeast from S. Pine Drive. The vehicle was pointed
towards the southeast. The vehicle was a dark grey Chevy Tahoe. The second vehicle with plate (CO
654-ZEC) was parked along the south side of South Pine Drive approximately 125 yards southwest of
Iris Drive. The second vehicle was parked facing downhill. The second vehicle was a white Dodge
SUV marked with #5188. Sergeant CONNER removed both vehicles from the area.
The RA remained on the scene until the lab personnel arrived and began their documentation. Agent
TAMMY LEE requested the RA respond to the command post for a debrief meeting conducted by AIC
CHRIS SCHAEFER. The RA was assigned to respond to a non-related structure fire and provided no
additional assistance on this incident.
LEE, TAMMY AGT (5202 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation)
02/26/2016
Page 2

ACISS INVESTIGATIVE 2016-59/1
Primary Information
Description:
FIRST DEGREE MURDER OF CPL NATHANIEL CARRIGAN
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
SCHAEFER, CHRIS AIC (7713 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/23/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, at approximately 10:30 A.M., I, Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Agent TAMMY LEE, was
asked to respond to Bailey, Colorado, in reference to an Officer Involved Shooting. Agents received an initial briefing from CBI
Agent-in-Charge KIRBY LEWIS and learned three (3) Park County Sheriffs Office (PCSO) Deputies had been shot resulting in (2) of
the Deputies injured and one (1) Deputy who was deceased. The condition of the suspect was unknown during the initial briefing.
After the briefing, I was asked to respond to the scene of the shooting, which was 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, as the CBI was
requested to be the lead agency for the investigation. I was assigned to be the Case Agent for the investigation.
During the initial investigation, I learned Park County Sheriff's Office Corporal NATHANIEL CARRIGAN was fatally shot while trying
to serve an eviction at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado. In addition, PCSO Captain MARK HANCOCK sustained an injury to his left
ear and PCSO Deputy KOLBY MARTIN was shot multiple times in his legs and groin area. Both Captain HANCOCK and Deputy
MARTIN were transported to St. Anthony Hospital in Lakewood, Colorado, for treatment of their injuries. The suspect, MARTIN
WIRTH, was also deceased at the scene.
Modus Operandi
Description
MURDER IN THE FIRST DEGREE
Weapons
Weapon Type
FIREARM
Weapon Sub-Type
---
Firearm Finish
BLUE/BLACK
Caliber
MASTERPIECE ARMS .45
CALIBER CARBINE
Address #1 - CRIME SCENE #1 - 36 IRIS DR

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Offenses
Offense Type
FELONY
Offense
MURDER 1 OF PEACE OFF-EXT INDIFFERENCE
Attempted/Committed
COMMITTED
FELONY
MURDER 1 OF PEACE OFF-EXT INDIFFEREN-ATT
COMMITTED
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Statute
UCR Class
18-3-102(1)( a
d)
18-3-102(1)( a
d)
Page 1 of 8

Offenses - Continued
Offense Type
FELONY
Offense
MURDER 1 OF PEACE OFF-EXT INDIFFEREN-ATT
Attempted/Committed
COMMITTED
Statute
UCR Class
18-3-102(1)( a
d)
Subject #1 - VICTIM #1 - CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Personal Information
Deceased:
YES
Subject #2 - VICTIM #2 - HANCOCK, MARK

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #3 - VICTIM #3 - MARTIN, KOLBY

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #4 - SUSPECT #1 - WIRTH, MARTIN THOMAS

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
WIRTH, MARTIN THOMAS
Sex:
MALE
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 2 of 8

Subject #4 - SUSPECT #1 - WIRTH, MARTIN THOMAS - Continued
Primary Information - Continued
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
Facial Characteristics:
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Analysis Information
Sick Or Injured:
YES
Sick Or Injured Type:
OTHER
Sick Or Injured Treated By:
NONE
Sick Or Injured Transport By:
CORONER STAFF
Sick Or Injured Transport To:
CORONER'S OFFICE
Location Type:
RESIDENCE
Alcohol Related:
UNKNOWN
Drug Related:
UNKNOWN
Computer Crime:
NO
Hate Crime:
NO
Sex Crime:
NO
Juvenile Crime:
NO
Domestic Violence:
NO
Senior Abuse:
NO
Child Abuse:
NO
Gang Related:
NO
School Zone:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 3 of 8

Analysis Information - Continued
Public Housing:
NO
Victim Injury Type:
SHOT
Apparent Motive:
LAW ENFORCEMENT
Offense Unique Detail:
HOMICIDE
Body Disposal:
RELEASED TO CORONER
Related Officers
LEO
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL (PARK COUNTY CORPORAL / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
HANCOCK, MARK (CAPTAIN / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
LOWRANCE, JEREMY (DEPUTY / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
WEGENER, FRED (SHERIFF / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
LEFFLER, DAVID (Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
HANNIGAN, DJ (DETECTIVE / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
MARTIN, KOLBY (DEPUTY / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
THRELKEL, TRAVIS (DEPUTY / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)

02/26/2016 16:09
Last Update Date:
04/23/2016 15:08
Reporting LEO
LEE, TAMMY AGT (5202 / DENVER /
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 4 of 8
2016-59/1
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, at approximately 10:30 A.M., I, Colorado Bureau of Investigation
(CBI) Agent TAMMY LEE, was asked to respond to Bailey, Colorado, in reference to an Officer
Involved Shooting. Agents received an initial briefing from CBI Agent-in-Charge KIRBY LEWIS and
learned three (3) Park County Sheriffs Office (PCSO) Deputies had been shot resulting in (2) of the
Deputies injured and one (1) Deputy who was deceased. The condition of the suspect was unknown
during the initial briefing. After the briefing, I was asked to respond to the scene of the shooting, which
was 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, as the CBI was requested to be the lead agency for the
investigation. I was assigned to be the Case Agent for the investigation.
During the initial investigation, I learned Park County Sheriff's Office Corporal NATHANIEL
CARRIGAN was fatally shot while trying to serve an eviction at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado. In
addition, PCSO Captain MARK HANCOCK sustained an injury to his left ear and PCSO Deputy
KOLBY MARTIN was shot multiple times in his legs and groin area. Both Captain HANCOCK and
Deputy MARTIN were transported to St. Anthony Hospital in Lakewood, Colorado, for treatment of
their injuries. The suspect, MARTIN WIRTH, was also deceased at the scene.
ACTION TAKEN:
learned three (3) Park County Sheriffs Office Deputies had been shot resulting in (2) of the Deputies
injured and one (1) Deputy who was deceased. The condition of the suspect was unknown during the
initial briefing. After the briefing, I was asked to respond to the scene of the shooting, which was 36
Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, as the CBI was requested to be the lead agency for the investigation. I
was assigned to be the Case Agent for the investigation.
At approximately 11:12 A.M., I arrived at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, along with CBI Agents
JERRY MEANS, GREG ZENTNER, JENNIFER MOORE, COLLIN NORDGREN, and KELLON
HASSENSTAB. Upon arrival, it appeared the scene was secured by numerous Jefferson County
Sheriffs Office Deputies as well as Troopers from the Colorado State Patrol. While walking up to the
scene, I was contacted by Park County Sheriffs Office Sergeant W.E. TONJES. Sergeant TONJES
explained Park County Deputies went to serve an eviction at 36 Iris Drive (Bailey, CO) and three (3)
deputies were shot, one of which was deceased. Sergeant TONJES explained the suspect was also shot
during the incident and he was believed to be deceased, although it was not confirmed. Sergeant
TONJES explained the suspect was still at the residence.
Sergeant TONJES was receiving numerous phone calls while I was speaking with him, so I spoke with
a Jefferson County Sheriffs Office (JCSO) Deputy (unknown name) and asked him to brief me on the
scene. The JCSO Deputy told me a Park County Sheriffs Office Deputy, later determined to be
Corporal NATHANIEL CARRIGAN, had been shot and was deceased. The JCSO Deputy also said
the suspect, later identified as MARTIN THOMAS WIRTH (Age 58; 05/14/1957), had been shot and
was deceased. In addition, the JCSO Deputy explained the suspect was a survivalist type and there
were concerns he had explosives inside his residence, so the JCSOs bomb squad was enroute to secure
the scene. In addition, the JCSO Deputy informed me a Park County Sheriffs Office Deputy (Captain
MARK HANCOCK) had been shot in the ear and a second Park County Sheriffs Office Deputy
(Deputy KOBLY MARTIN) had been shot 3-4 times in the groin area. I was told both Captain
Page 1
02/26/2016
2016-59/1
HANCOCK and Deputy MARTIN were transported by ambulance to the hospital for treatment of their
injuries.
While speaking with the JCSO Deputy, Sergeant TONJES walked up to me (still on his cellphone) and
informed me the deceased deputy was taken to the fire station after the incident and asked me if they
should move him to the coroners office. I called and spoke to CBI Crime Scene Agent KEVIN
TORRES who requested the deceased deputy stay at the fire station until he had a chance to process
him. I relayed the information to Sergeant TONJES and also requested Agent MOORE and Agent
ZENTER respond to the fire station to stand by until Agent TORRES arrived. A short time later, I was
contacted by Park County Sheriffs Office Detective DAVID LEFFLER who informed me three (3)
Park County Deputies involved in the incident (later identified as Deputy TRAVIS THRELKEL,
Deputy JEREMY LOWRANCE, and Corporal DAVID D.J. HANNIGAN) were still on scene. I told
Detective LEFFLER we would need to process the Deputies and possibly conduct interviews at an
offsite location. Detective LEFFLER spoke with the Deputies and agreed to meet me at the Park
County Sheriffs Office Substation, which was located at 59865 US HWY 285 in Bailey, Colorado.
Shortly after speaking with Detective LEFFLER, I was informed an attorney arrived on scene, handed
each of the Deputies a business card, and requested they not make any statements to the CBI without
him present. I told Detective LEFFLER I understood if he did not want to make a statement today, but
requested the Deputies still respond to the substation so they could be photographed and their weapons
and magazines logged and collected. Detective LEFFLER said he understood and left the scene. At
that point, I requested Agent HASSENSTAB and Agent NORDGREN meet me at the substation and
Agent MEANS indicated he would remain at the crime scene.
At approximately 11:40 A.M., I arrived at the PCSO Substation and met with 11th Judicial District,
Deputy District Attorney (DDA), AMY WREN. DDA WREN advised an investigator from her office,
Investigator ALEX WALKER, would be responding to the substation to write a search warrant for
WIRTHs residence. While waiting for Investigator WALKER to arrive, I spoke with Detective
LEFFLER who indicated he did not shoot during the incident and agreed to make a statement in the
presence of his attorney, BRIAN WILSON JR.
The interview was conducted at 12:27 P.M., inside a large storage type room in the basement of the
substation. Also present during the interview were Agents HASSENSTAB and NORDGREN as well
as Attorney BRIAN WILSON JR. The interview was audio recorded. During the interview, Det.
LEFFLER told us the following: (Note: This is only a summary of the interview. Please review the
audio recording and/or transcript for full details on the interview.)
He has worked full-time for the Park County Sheriffs Office since March of 2012.
He started his shift at 6:00 A.M. on Wednesday, February 24, 2016.
He was on scene during the officer involved shooting, although he was not a shooting
officer.
A few weeks prior to the shooting incident, Jefferson County Sheriffs Office received a
complaint regarding a Park County resident, MARTIN WIRTH, making threats at a State
Farm Insurance office, which was located in Jefferson County.

Page 2
02/26/2016
2016-59/1
He was told WIRTH was denied insurance at State Farm for not having a valid
drivers license and WIRTH got very upset and told the office staff he was going
to get a gun and shoot the first officer he saw.
The Jefferson County Sheriffs Office attempted to contact WIRTH in his vehicle
and WIRTH failed to yield for deputies and drove to his residence located at 36
Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado.
He (LEFFLER) was present when WIRTH was contacted at his residence and
WIRTH became combative with officers on scene and was restrained.
After the contact with WIRTH, WIRTH made comments consistent with hating
police officers and comments indicating he was going to have it out with law
enforcement.
Sometime after the incident with WIRTH, the Park County Sheriffs Office posted an
eviction notice on WIRTHs residence (36 Iris Drive, Bailey, Colorado).
He did not know the circumstances surrounding the eviction.
Today, February 24, 2016, at approximately 9:15 A.M., he was assigned to be the spotter
for the residence as Deputies were going to serve the eviction on WIRTH.
He was positioned at 177 South Pine in Bailey, Colorado, where he had a view of
WIRTHs residence.
At approximately 9:40 A.M., he observed Park County Sheriffs Office Captain
MARK HANCOCK and Park County Sheriffs Office Master Deputy
NATHANIEL CARRIGAN drive their marked patrol cars down the drive-way of
WIRTHs residence.
He was watching the incident through his spotting scope and observed a white
male in his 60s with gray hair wearing jeans walk outside onto the upper deck of
the residence.
He could see the male exchange words with Deputy CARRIGAN and then the
male retreat inside the residence.
He was then notified by radio from Park County Sheriffs Office Master Deputy
KOBLY MARTIN to head towards the house.
He observed Park County Sheriff FRED WEGENER pull into the drive-way
behind Deputy CARRIGANs vehicle.
He followed behind Sheriff WEGENER and parked his vehicle directly behind
Sheriff WEGENERs patrol car.
As soon as he pulled into the drive-way, he heard gunshots.
He removed his rifle from his patrol car and took a position of cover on the side of
his patrol car.

Page 3
02/26/2016
2016-59/1
He heard what he believed were four (4) gunshots and could see debris project
from the inside of the home towards the outside.
At that point, he observed Deputy MARTIN on the ground outside the

residence who had been shot three (3) times in the groin and shot one (1)
time in the leg.
He attended to Deputy MARTIN and assisted with loading Deputy

MARTIN into the ambulance.
He drove the ambulance to the fire station where Deputy MARTIN was
later transferred to St. Anthonys Hospital.
While he was on scene he observed Deputy CARRIGAN lying on his back on the
ground who was later determined to be deceased.
He was also aware Captain HANCOCK was shot, but he did not know the extent
of his injuries or his condition.
He returned to the scene after the incident and collected Captain HANCOCKs duty
firearm, which had been collected by Sheriff WEGENER.
He also spoke to Detective DAVID HANNIGAN who indicated he also fired his
weapon during the incident.
He collected Det. HANNIGANs duty firearm and handed Det. HANNIGAN his
(Det. LEFFLERs) personal duty weapon.
He placed both of the firearms in evidence bags.
After speaking with Detective LEFFLER, I returned upstairs and assisted Investigator WALKER
with the search warrant for 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado. While typing the search warrant,
Investigator WALKER and I received a phone call from CBI Agent JEFF SCHIERKOLK. Agent
SCHIERKOLK had responded to St. Anthonys Hospital, located at 11600 West 2nd Place in
Lakewood, Colorado, following the incident. Deputy KOLBY MARTIN and Captain MARK
HANNCOCK had been transported to the hospital for treatment of their injuries. Agent
SCHIERKOLK reported Deputy KOBLY MARTIN sustained injuries to his left hand and eight
bullet wounds to his body and Captain MARK HANNCOCK sustained an injury to his left ear
lobe.
While at the substation, I was also informed there was an operational plan drawn on one of the
white boards in the patrol room. I went to the patrol room and took photographs of the board.
The pictures are attached to this report.
After the search warrant was complete, I responded to the Command Post, which had been
established at Crow Hill Bible Church, located at 63555 US Hwy. 285 in Bailey, Colorado. A
short time later, I responded to 36 Iris Drive in Bailey and conducted a walk-through of the crime
scene.
Investigation Continues.
Page 4
02/26/2016

ACISS INVESTIGATIVE SUPPLEMENT 2016-59/2
Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH CAPTAIN MARK HANCOCK
Occurence From:
02/25/2016 10:30
Occurence To:
02/25/2016 12:00
Reporting LEO:
HASSENSTAB, KELLON (DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Backup LEO:
NORDGREN, COLLIN (DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/22/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, CBI Agent COLLIN NORDGREN and I (CBI Agent KELLON HASSENSTAB) interviewed Park County
SO Captain MARK HANCOCK, at this residence.
Address #1 - OCCURRED #1 - 9946 GARLAND DR

Primary Information
Address:
9946 GARLAND DR, WESTMINSTER, COLORADO , UNITED STATES
Property #1 - SCENE DIAGRAMS AND NOTES, CAPT HANCOCK

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
SCENE DIAGRAMS AND NOTES, CAPT HANCOCK
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Property #2 - USB DRIVE CONTAINING VIDEO FILES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
COMPUTER SOFTWARE/ACCESSO
Description:
USB DRIVE CONTAINING VIDEO FILES
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/21/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Related Officers
LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 1 of 8

Related Officers - Continued

LEO
HANCOCK, MARK (CAPTAIN / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)

02/26/2016 21:37
Last Update Date:
03/22/2016 17:11
Reporting LEO
HASSENSTAB, KELLON (DENVER /
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 2 of 8
2016-59/2
SYNOPSIS:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, CBI Agent COLLIN NORDGREN and I (CBI Agent KELLON
HASSENSTAB) interviewed Park County Sheriff's Office (PCSO) Captain MARK HANCOCK, at this
residence.
ACTION TAKEN:
The above-referenced interview was regarding a shooting incident on Wednesday, February 24, 2016,
that occurred at 36 Iris Dr, Bailey, Park County, Colorado, which resulted in the death of PCSO
Corporal NATE CARRIGAN and shooting suspect MARTIN WIRTH.
The interview occurred at Captain HANCOCK's residence (9946 Garland Dr, Westminster) and was
completely audio recorded and partially video recorded (several technical difficulties resulted in some
missing time in the video recording). Following the interview, notes written by Captain HANCOCK
about the incident, and scene diagrams he created were booked into CBI Denver Investigations
evidence. Additionally, the audio recording of the interview is entered as an attachment to this report
and the video files were submitted to evidence on a USB drive.
The following is a summary which utilizes paraphrases, and does not necessarily follow the order the
information was obtained in the interview. Captain HANCOCK advised of the following:
Captain HANCOCK was advised the CBI investigation is a criminal investigation and not an internal
affairs investigation.
Captain HANCOCK said he has been employed at the PCSO for 21 years. He said he is currently
assigned as the Patrol Captain and SWAT Commander. He said he has served 6 years as Patrol Captain.
With regard to his position as SWAT Commander, I asked Captain HANCOCK to describe the
specialized training he received. He said he attended the FBI basic SWAT school in 1999, a couple of
team leader schools, one commander school, and a couple of high-risk planning courses.
I asked Captain HANCOCK if he had any other specialized training or expertise in law enforcement,
and he said he did in Community Policing, School Safety, and Arrest Control. He added that he is a Use
of Force expert witness.
Captain HANCOCK said his schedule varies, but was recently Tuesday through Friday, 10 hour shifts.
He does not have set hours, but generally works from the morning to the evening. Captain HANCOCK
wears prescription sunglasses, and wore them at the time of the incident.
Captain HANCOCK created hand-written notes prior to our interview. He referred to his notes at times
during the interview, and the notes were collected as evidence and attached to this report.
He said on February 24, 2016, he started his shift at approximately 5:50 a.m. by doing RADAR traffic
enforcement. He said he went to the Bailey substation around 7:00 a.m. and had some food/drink.
Captain HANCOCK waited for PCSO deputies to arrive at the substation, which they did between 8:00
a.m. and 8:30 a.m. Captain HANCOCK said he started a briefing at 8:30 a.m., which was attended by
Page 1
02/26/2016
2016-59/2
Detective DJ HANNIGAN, Deputy KOLBY MARTIN (who arrived late), Deputy JEREMY
LOWRANCE, Deputy TRAVIS THRELKEL, and Corporal NATE CARRIGAN. Captain HANCOCK
said Sheriff FRED WEGENER later showed up to the briefing, but Sheriff WEGENER was planning
on being at a meeting in Denver and not being present at the eviction.
Captain HANCOCK said he had either Detective HANNIGAN or Corporal CARRIGAN call Platte
Canyon Fire to have them staged around 9:30 a.m. Captain HANCOCK said Corporal CARRIGAN
told him eviction personnel would be in the neighborhood near MARTIN WIRTH's house.
Captain HANCOCK said he had "intel" indicating WIRTH may become physically combative. He said
he thought there was a possibility WIRTH may become barricaded in the home. Captain HANCOCK
said they discussed making the eviction a "SWAT call" and they decided it wasn't necessary.
Regarding the eviction, Captain HANCOCK said it occurs in stages. He said that papers are required to
be posted, and then an eviction occurs. He said it was his understanding the papers had been posted at
WIRTH's residence.
At the briefing, Captain HANCOCK said Corporal CARRIGAN had the paperwork packet from the
courts regarding the eviction. Captain HANCOCK said the eviction had been postponed several times,
and Wednesday was a good day to perform the eviction due to higher staffing levels. Captain
HANCOCK thought Corporal CARRIGAN planned the eviction date with PCSO Sergeant WELLES
TONJES.
Captain HANCOCK had knowledge of an incident that occurred approximately three weeks prior. He
said PCSO deputies assisted Jefferson County SO deputies with an incident that resulted in WIRTH
being detained after making threats earlier in the day. Captain HANCOCK did not go to the scene, but
heard via the police radio WIRTH was released on a summons.
Captain HANCOCK said he thought they needed a minimum of six officers to execute the eviction,
along with someone providing over watch at the residence. Captain HANCOCK contacted and assigned
Detective DAVID LEFFLER to the over watch role (with a spotting scope). Captain HANCOCK said
Detective LEFFLER immediately went out to the area and got a view of the residence.
In executing the eviction, Captain HANCOCK said he wanted four PCSO deputies at the door with
him, and two in the rear of the residence.
With regard to Corporal CARRIGAN's role, he said he wanted him to carry the papers at the front
because he (Corporal CARRIGAN) knew and dealt with WIRTH in the past. Captain HANCOCK
remarked on Corporal CARRIGAN's kindness. Captain HANCOCK thought WIRTH would remember
and recognize Corporal CARRIGAN. Captain HANCOCK also noted Corporal CARRIGAN was
driving a marked patrol vehicle, and he wanted him parked first in the driveway.
Captain HANCOCK said he planned if gunfire occurred, they would retreat to the patrol cars and have
a perimeter already set up before calling in SWAT. Captain HANCOCK said he planned to have
Corporal CARRIGAN as the breacher of the front door, if necessary.

Page 2
02/26/2016
2016-59/2
Captain HANCOCK wanted the other deputies to park unnoticed, approach the rear of the residence,
and be in place when he and Corporal CARRIGAN came up the driveway.
Captain HANCOCK later said if WIRTH barricaded inside the home, they planned on surrounding the
residence.
The above-mentioned information is Captain HANCOCK's synopsis of the plan he provided in the
briefing. He said he requested the PCSO Undersheriff (MONTE GORE) go to the communications
room to monitor the incident via radio.
I asked Captain HANCOCK if all of personnel involved in the operation would have been readily
identifiable as law enforcement officers. He said all would, with the exception of Detective
HANNIGAN, who was dressed in "detective clothing."
Captain HANCOCK said the assigned PCSO personnel drove to Fire Station 2 and regrouped (and
spoke with personnel there about staging) prior to finishing the drive-in as a convoy to WIRTH's home.
Upon arriving to WIRTH's home, Captain HANCOCK recalled being told by Detective LEFFLER
about smoke coming from the chimney in the home and seeing an extension cord (both indications the
home was occupied).
Captain HANCOCK was asked if there were any adverse weather conditions during the incident. He
said it was windy, and the wind was blowing snow off the ground.
Captain HANCOCK said he and Corporal CARRIGAN drove up the driveway, with Corporal
CARRIGAN eventually parking his marked PCSO patrol vehicle (Chevrolet Tahoe) near the
camper/RV in the driveway. Captain HANCOCK parked behind Corporal CARRIGAN. Captain
HANCOCK said when he got out of his car (unmarked black Chevrolet Tahoe), he saw Corporal
CARRIGAN talking to an individual he (Corporal CARRIGAN) called Mr. WIRTH.
Captain HANCOCK said he had not met WIRTH prior to the incident. Captain HANCOCK said
Corporal CARRIGAN told WIRTH they were there to serve the eviction. Captain HANCOCK heard
WIRTH saying something about not having time to get his property out. This conversation lasted
approximately 25 seconds, according to Captain HANCOCK. He said it was obvious to him WIRTH
would have known they were on-duty PCSO personnel serving an eviction. Captain HANCOCK saw
WIRTH go back inside the house and began getting uncomfortable about the situation.
Captain HANCOCK then called other PCSO personnel to the front of the house and went to the front
door area with Corporal CARRIGAN. Captain HANCOCK said he got to the door area with Corporal
CARRIGAN, and Deputy LOWRANCE and Deputy THRELKEL arrived and fell in behind him.
Captain HANCOCK said he reached around Corporal CARRIGAN and began knocking and
announcing at the door (he said he announced "Sheriff's Office" and "Come to the door"). He said
Corporal CARRIGAN also knocked and announced at the door. Captain HANCOCK said he called the
Sheriff (upon learning the Sheriff was coming to the area).

Page 3
02/26/2016
2016-59/2
Captain HANCOCK said he told Sheriff WEGENER there was too much of a delay, and feared
WIRTH may be barricading inside the home. Captain HANCOCK was afraid something bad was going
to happen. Captain HANCOCK said as a former Marine he is "super-aggressive" and does not like to
give others the opportunity to plan or fortify against him.
Captain HANCOCK said he told Corporal CARRIGAN to force the door to the residence by kicking it
a couple of times. Captain HANCOCK said he advised Corporal CARRIGAN to breach the door and
then get out of the way. Captain HANCOCK said after breaching the door, Corporal CARRIGAN "fell
in" and to the left in the mud room area inside the door way. At that time Deputy MARTIN, followed
by Deputy THRELKEL, went past them into the home (advancing in the hall/kitchen).
Captain HANCOCK said he went by Corporal CARRIGAN on the right. He saw Deputy MARTIN
raise his rifle and give verbal challenges (get your hands up). At that point, Captain HANCOCK
described hearing "massive" amounts of gunfire, hearing the shots and feeling physical pressure from
the discharge of the gunfire.
Captain HANCOCK heard Deputy MARTIN screaming and assumed Deputy MARTIN had been shot.
Captain HANCOCK said he did not know where Corporal CARRIGAN went, but he thought he may
have leaned left into the wall (not making it into the kitchen area).
Captain HANCOCK felt pain and felt shots hit him (graze wound to the ear and neck). Captain
HANCOCK said he may have fallen back to the right. Captain HANCOCK saw Deputy THRELKEL
come out, pulling Deputy MARTIN (who was screaming) and the two went out the front door, towards
the patrol cars.
Captain HANCOCK saw Corporal CARRIGAN turn and possibly hold his (Corporal CARRIGAN's)
vest. Captain HANCOCK said they went out the door at approximately the same time, and Corporal
CARRIGAN went to Captain HANCOCK's left.
Captain HANCOCK said he fell on his buttocks. Captain HANCOCK said he raised his pistol (which
he described as a department issued Sig 9mm handgun with department issued ammunition, not
modified in any way) and fired "suppressively," and moved to the right. He could hear Deputy
MARTIN screaming. Captain HANCOCK said bullets were being fired out of the residence (he did not
know how many but described the situation as "hot").
Captain HANCOCK saw the window to the right of the front door, and thought bullets may be being
fired out of it (or Deputy THRELKEL firing in). Captain HANCOCK said he fired several bullets into
the window to "suppress" the gun shots he saw. He said it seemed like the gunfire stopped at that time,
and he went to Corporal CARRIGAN.
Captain HANCOCK said he asked Corporal CARRIGAN if he was okay, and received a grunting
sound as a response. Corporal CARRIGAN never verbalized any words, according to Captain
HANCOCK.
Captain HANCOCK said he did not see Corporal CARRIGAN get hit with gunfire, or hear a sound (so
he did not know Corporal CARRIGAN was injured). He said he shook Corporal CARRIGAN, but got
no response. Captain HANCOCK said he called "officers down" over the radio at that point. Captain
Page 4
02/26/2016
2016-59/2
HANCOCK said Deputy MARTIN seemed worse (of Deputy MARTIN and Corporal CARRIGAN)
because he was screaming, while Corporal CARRIGAN was not making any sound.
Captain HANCOCK said he heard gun shots again. He glanced down the side of the house, and could
hear gunshots from the rear of the house. Captain HANCOCK said he heard Detective HANNIGAN
say he either shot the suspect, or shot at the suspect. Captain HANCOCK remembered where Detective
HANNIGAN was, and thought WIRTH was flanking their position (at the front of the residence).
Captain HANCOCK said he panicked and began running to the rear of the house. Captain HANCOCK
said as he "cut the corner" he saw WIRTH on the ground, with his rifle, moving. Captain HANCOCK
said it looked like WIRTH was about to shoot at Detective HANNIGAN (which he feared would kill
Detective HANNIGAN), who was behind a small tree, according to Captain HANCOCK.
At that point, Captain HANCOCK said he "opened up" and fired at WIRTH (while WIRTH was in the
prone position), emptying his magazine (he later verified he had not re-loaded from his previous shots
prior to moving around the house).
Captain HANCOCK said WIRTH's body was moving as bullets appeared to strike WIRTH. Captain
HANCOCK said he was pointing his pistol at WIRTH's center mass. Captain HANCOCK said he saw
WIRTH's pony tail's move with the first impact, which he thought may have struck WIRTH's head.
He said he re-loaded and Deputy LOWRANCE moved up to his position. At that time, "someone" took
WIRTH"s rifle away.
Captain HANCOCK then saw a SWAT medic at Corporal CARRIGAN's position. He and the medic
took off Corporal CARRIGAN's clothing looking for wounds. He said it was clear Corporal
CARRIGAN was in "bad shape." He later heard Corporal CARRIGAN was deceased, and radioed that
information in. Captain HANCOCK did not know when Corporal CARRIGAN got shot. Captain
HANCOCK said he was stunned and was walking around, back and forth for a time period.
Captain HANCOCK said he gave his handgun to Sheriff WEGENER. He said Sheriff WEGENER
gave him his (the Sheriff's) handgun in exchange.
Captain HANCOCK said he wanted to clear WIRTH's house, but Sheriff WEGENER would not let
him due to the possibility of explosives inside.
Captain HANCOCK said he went to the hospital, via a transport from Platte Canyon Fire. He said his
"bell was rung" from the shots that grazed his ear and neck. He also said at that point, he was feeling
pain from the gunshot injury.
From the hospital, Captain HANCOCK said he was picked up by his wife and taken home.
Captain HANCOCK said he went through the Platte Canyon High School shooting and going through
that experience is similar to this shooting (in terms of emotions, memories, and hearing different
accounts).
Please refer to the transcription for the full details of the conversation.
Page 5
02/26/2016
2016-59/2
Nothing further.

Page 6
02/26/2016

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH DETECTIVE DAVID LEFFLER
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 12:30
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/22/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, at approximately 12:30 p.m., CBI Agents COLLIN NORDGREN and TAMMY LEE, and I (CBI Agent
KELLON HASSENSTAB) interviewed Park County SO Detective DAVID LEFFLER, in the presence of his attorney, BRIAN HERBERT
WILSON.
Address #1 - OCCURRED #1 - 59865 US HIGHWAY 285

Primary Information
Address:
59865 US HIGHWAY 285, BAILEY, COLORADO 80421 , UNITED STATES
Property #1 - SCENE DIAGRAM BY DET. LEFFLER

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
SCENE DIAGRAM BY DET. LEFFLER
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Related Officers
LEO
LEFFLER, DAVID (Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)

02/26/2016 21:38
Last Update Date:
03/22/2016 17:28
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 1 of 3

Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/3
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, at approximately 12:30 p.m., CBI Agents COLLIN NORDGREN
and TAMMY LEE, and I (CBI Agent KELLON HASSENSTAB) interviewed Park County SO (PCSO)
Detective DAVID LEFFLER, in the presence of his attorney, BRIAN HERBERT WILSON.
ACTION TAKEN:
The interview occurred in the basement of the Park County Sheriff's Office Bailey Substation (59865
US Highway 285, Bailey) and was audio recorded. Following the interview, the file containing the
audio recording of the interview was entered as an attachment to this report. Additionally, a scene
diagram completed by Detective LEFFLER was booked into evidence at CBI Denver Investigations.
The interview is summarized by Agent LEE in report 2016-59/1.
During the interview, Detective LEFFLER provided two handguns collected from personnel who fired
their weapons during the incident, Captain MARK HANCOCK and Detective DJ HANNIGAN. Each
handgun was in a paper bag, and labeled with the name of the respective PCSO personnel.
At 12:58 p.m., I took custody of each bag from Detective LEFFLER and at 1:10 p.m. I locked each bag
in the lockbox in the trunk of my assigned vehicle. At approximately 1:25 p.m. CBI Crime Scene
Analyst (CSA) KEVIN TORRES arrived on scene. I transferred the two bags to CSA TORRES at that
time for his processing.
Please refer to the transcription of the interview for the full details. It is entered as an attachment to this
report.
Nothing further.

Page 1
02/26/2016

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WTH DEPUTY JEREMY LOWRANCE
Occurence From:
02/25/2016 15:00
Occurence To:
02/25/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/22/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, at approximately 3:00 p.m., CBI Agent COLLIN NORDGREN and I (CBI Agent KELLON
HASSENSTAB) interviewed Park County SO Deputy JEREMY LOWRANCE, in the presence of his attorney, BRIAN HERBERT
WILSON.
Address #1 - OCCURRED #1 - 710 KIPLING ST

Primary Information
Address:
710 KIPLING ST OFFICE #200, DENVER, COLORADO 80215 , UNITED STATES
Subject #1 - ATTORNEY #1 - WILSON, BRIAN HERBERT

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
ATTORNEY
Subject Name:
WILSON, BRIAN HERBERT
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
Property #1 - CD CONTAINING VIDEO INTERVIEW DEP LOWRANCE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CD AND DVD DISC
Description:
CD CONTAINING VIDEO INTERVIEW DEP LOWRANCE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Property #2 - SCENE DIAGRAMS BY DEP. LOWRANCE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 1 of 7

Property #2 - SCENE DIAGRAMS BY DEP. LOWRANCE - Continued
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
SCENE DIAGRAMS BY DEP. LOWRANCE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Related Officers
LEO
LOWRANCE, JEREMY (DEPUTY / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)

02/26/2016 21:38
Last Update Date:
03/22/2016 17:48
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 2 of 7
2016-59/4
SYNOPSIS:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, at approximately 3:00 p.m., CBI Agent COLLIN NORDGREN and I
(CBI Agent KELLON HASSENSTAB) interviewed Park County Sheriff's Office (PCSO) Deputy
JEREMY LOWRANCE, in the presence of his attorney, BRIAN HERBERT WILSON.
ACTION TAKEN:
The interview occurred at the CBI Denver Investigations office (710 Kipling St, Suite 200, Lakewood)
and was audio and video recorded. Following the interview, the compact disc containing the recording
of the interview was booked into evidence, along with scene diagrams completed by Deputy
LOWRANCE.
The following is a summary which utilizes paraphrases, and does not necessarily follow the order the
information was obtained in the interview. Deputy LOWRANCE advised Agents of the following
information during the interview:
Deputy LOWRANCE has been a sworn officer at PCSO since May 27, 2015. He has had no previous
law enforcement experience or specialized training. He had not previously been involved in a deadly
force incident.
He started work at 6:00 a.m. as normally scheduled. His typical work schedule is Wednesday through
Saturday, 6:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. and he works patrol from the Como to Pine Junction area of Park
County. The date of the incident was his first work day of the week. He does not require any eyewear
(prescription glasses or contacts).
Upon starting his shift, Deputy LOWRANCE had breakfast at the Cut Throat (restaurant in Bailey),
which is a standard practice for many PCSO personnel on Wednesdays according to Deputy
LOWRANCE.
Deputy LOWRANCE went back the Bailey Substation. Deputy LOWRANCE said Corporal
NATHANIEL CARRIGAN received a phone call related to the eviction, possibly from the real estate
company or movers. Deputy LOWRANCE said a secretary named "TERRY" brought the eviction
paperwork in to where the deputies were meeting. Deputy LOWRANCE said an eviction notice was
posted prior to the eviction.
Deputy LOWRANCE was at the substation with Captain MARK HANCOCK and Corporal
CARRIGAN, waiting for Deputy KOLBY MARTIN and Deputy TRAVIS THRELKEL to arrive.
There was a briefing, led by Captain HANCOCK which Deputy LOWRANCE attended, which
involved putting officer safety in mind and approaching the house with caution. Deputy LOWRANCE
stated MARTIN WIRTH was known to have made threats in the past towards law enforcement. Deputy
LOWRANCE said he knew in 2014 WIRTH's house was foreclosed on, and WIRTH moved out
(before subsequently moving back in).
Page 1
02/26/2016
2016-59/4
According to Deputy LOWRANCE, Captain HANCOCK came up with the tactical plan and assigned
roles to involved personnel.
Deputy LOWRANCE said all of the assigned personnel would have been identifiable as law
enforcement officers and were wearing issued PCSO uniforms.
Deputy LOWRANCE said he had knowledge WIRTH stated to his neighbor that if anyone came to get
him (WIRTH) it would be the "OK Corral." Deputy LOWRANCE said he did not know the source of
that information.
Deputy LOWRANCE had knowledge of the incident that happened several weeks prior that WIRTH
told an insurance agent he (WIRTH) was going to get a gun and kill the first cop he saw. Deputy
LOWRANCE was not personally involved in that incident. Deputy LOWRANCE said he knew
WIRTH received a summons in relation to that incident.
Deputy LOWRANCE had knowledge Captain HANCOCK put EMS (Station 2) on standby for the
eviction.
Up responding to the area of WIRTH's residence, Deputy LOWRANCE, Deputy MARTIN, Deputy
THRELKEL and Detective DJ HANNIGAN parked their vehicles near the Deer Creek Christian Camp
to approach the house from the rear.
Deputy LOWRANCE said there were no adverse weather conditions at the time they arrived.
Deputy LOWRANCE, Deputy MARTIN, Deputy THRELKEL and Detective HANNIGAN began
walking through the field from the road to the rear of WIRTH's home.
Deputy LOWRANCE observed Corporal CARRIGAN's patrol vehicle (a white Chevrolet Tahoe with
PCSO markings) parked in the driveway, with Captain HANCOCK parked behind him.
Deputy LOWRANCE said deputies were set up behind the house and could see both corners of the
residence.
Deputy LOWRANCE described Corporal CARRIGAN's demeanor in his initial conversation with
WIRTH as "unaggressive" and unassuming. Deputy LOWRANCE said he could hear a "little bit" of
Corporal CARRIGAN's comments and stated Corporal CARRIGAN asked if WIRTH would come out
and talk to him.
Over the police radio, Deputy LOWRANCE heard that WIRTH went back inside the house. After 30
seconds, Deputy LOWRANCE heard Captain HANCOCK tell him and Deputy THRELKEL to go to
the entry way area of the home.
As PCSO personnel lined up at the door to knock and make announcements, Deputy LOWRANCE
noted Corporal CARRIGAN was at the door, with Captain HANCOCK behind Corporal CARRIGAN.
He and Deputy THRELKEL fell in behind Captain HANCOCK, with Deputy MARTIN off to the side
to see the window.
Page 2
02/26/2016
2016-59/4
Deputy LOWRANCE heard Captain HANCOCK and Corporal CARRIGAN make announcements at
the door for WIRTH to come out. Deputy LOWRANCE heard Sheriff FRED WEGENER give
permission for PCSO personnel to enter the home, when requested to by Captain HANCOCK.
With regard to the time they were knocking and announcing at the door, Deputy LOWRANCE said it
felt like 2 to 3 minutes and WIRTH had the time to come out if he wanted to.
Deputy LOWRANCE said Corporal CARRIGAN was the breacher on the door (which had been
designated prior to the incident), with Deputy MARTIN to the side of Corporal CARRIGAN, and
Captain HANCOCK behind Corporal CARRIGAN. Deputy LOWRANCE got behind Deputy
THRELKEL, who was behind Captain HANCOCK.
Deputy LOWRANCE said Corporal CARRIGAN breached the front door on the third kick, with
Deputy MARTIN going in the residence first, followed by Deputy THRELKEL and himself. Deputy
LOWRANCE said they were in a "stack" with he, Deputy MARTIN and Deputy THRELKEL all
having department-issued AR-15 style rifles. Deputy LOWRANCE heard verbal commands from
Deputy MARTIN and Deputy THRELKEL saying "Sheriff's office," and "get down."
Deputy LOWRANCE never saw Corporal CARRIGAN or knew where he went, until after the initial
shooting incident.
Deputy LOWRANCE said it was pretty dark in the house. Deputy LOWRANCE described WIRTH as
being back in the hallway past the kitchen (though he did not see him).
Deputy LOWRANCE said his foot was on the step from the mudroom into the kitchen entry way when
he first heard gun shots (which followed the aforementioned verbal commands).
Deputy LOWRANCE said he heard three shots, and started backing out. Deputy LOWRANCE said no
one from PCSO returned fire at that time. Deputy LOWRANCE said he thought WIRTH was trying to
kill the PCSO personnel and he feared for his life.
Deputy LOWRANCE saw Deputy MARTIN fall back on to Deputy THRELKEL, and saw Deputy
THRELKEL trying to use Deputy MARTIN's "drag strap" to drag him backwards. Deputy
LOWRANCE said Deputy MARTIN was screaming loudly, seemed to be in a lot of pain, and Deputy
LOWRANCE thought he might die. Deputy LOWRANCE heard two more shots from the suspect at
that time.
Deputy LOWRANCE said he and Deputy THRELKEL (who was dragging Deputy MARTIN) reached
the home's doorway at the same time while extracting from the home. Deputy LOWRANCE said
Deputy MARTIN and Deputy THRELKEL settled on the ground just outside of the doorway in view of
the front window, while he went further down the driveway. Deputy LOWRANCE said Deputy
THRELKEL was attending to Deputy MARTIN and trying to get his equipment off and find out where
he was hit.
Once outside, Deputy LOWRANCE said he could see bullets come out of the house, impacting the
siding and sheetrock.
Page 3
02/26/2016
2016-59/4
As he was backing away from the home, Deputy LOWRANCE could see WIRTH five or six feet back
from the front window (squared up) in a dark jacket. Deputy LOWRANCE said WIRTH had several
feet of elevation on him, and could have shot him, Deputy MARTIN and Deputy THRELKEL from his
position. Deputy LOWRANCE thought he saw either the "glint" from the scope on WIRTH's weapon
or a muzzle flash from WIRTH's rifle. He said shots were being fired at Deputy MARTIN and Deputy
THRELKEL.
Deputy LOWRANCE said he was in danger, as was Deputy MARTIN and Deputy THRELKEL.
Deputy LOWRANCE said he shot through the window at the suspect's center mass, firing 12 rounds
from his 30 round magazine (Deputy LOWRANCE said his military training made him count the
rounds fired) from his rifle (an issued and unmodified Colt AR15, assigned to him in June or July of
2015, which utilized department-issued ammunition). Deputy LOWRANCE said he did not use his
handgun (an issued Sig P320, 9 mm). Deputy LOWRANCE said he did not know if he hit WIRTH.
After firing the shots, Deputy LOWRANCE said he went to the other side of a snowbank in the
driveway due to being exposed.
Deputy LOWRANCE said he thought 3 to 5 minutes passed. He said he felt exposed and could hear
Deputy MARTIN screaming in pain. Deputy LOWRANCE did not know where the suspect was.
Deputy LOWRANCE changed his position to being behind Corporal CARRIGAN's vehicle. At that
time, Deputy LOWRANCE heard Detective HANNIGAN say the suspect was behind the house and
down.
Deputy LOWRANCE then went around Corporal CARRIGAN's car and the RV next to the house. He
said he could see WIRTH laying prone on the ground, looking through his scope. Deputy LOWRANCE
thought WIRTH was looking through his scope for Detective HANNIGAN to find and shoot Detective
HANNIGAN. At that time, Deputy LOWRANCE said he took a knee, brought his rifle up and put his
finger on the trigger.
Prior to firing, Deputy LOWRANCE saw WIRTH being fired upon (which he later found out was from
Captain HANCOCK). He approached the suspect with Sheriff WEGENER (who had come up behind
him at some point) and Detective HANNIGAN, and Sheriff WEGENER rolled the suspect over.
Deputy LOWRANCE could see WIRTH was deceased (his head was perforated from an apparent
bullet strike) and there was no possibility of medical aid.
EMS was called up to the residence.
Sheriff WEGENER asked Detective HANNIGAN and Deputy LOWRANCE to cuff WIRTH
(ultimately WIRTH was not handcuffed). Deputy LOWRANCE stood where he could see the suspect,
and EMS was working on Corporal CARRIGAN near the front of the house. Deputy LOWRANCE
said he did not know Corporal CARRIGAN had been shot at that time.
Deputy LOWRANCE saw Deputy THRELKEL pick up WIRTH's rifle and move it to a fire box on the
side of the house. Deputy LOWRANCE said Deputy THRELKEL put his (Deputy THRELKEL's) rifle
near the firebox as well. Deputy LOWRANCE said they did not know how to make WIRTH's rifle safe.
Page 4
02/26/2016
2016-59/4
Deputy LOWRANCE saw the Assistant Fire Chief working on Corporal CARRIGAN. He saw EMS
personnel working on Deputy MARTIN.
Deputy LOWRANCE said he was assigned to move vehicles from the drive way so EMS could better
access the scene. He backed Captain HANCOCK's vehicle down the drive way. When Deputy
LOWRANCE came back up the driveway, Deputy MARTIN was in the ambulance being transported.
He was informed Corporal CARRIGAN was deceased.
Deputy LOWRANCE was checked for gunshot wounds and none were found on his person.
Deputy LOWRANCE helped EMS get Corporal CARRIGAN on to the pram and in the ambulance. At
that time, Deputy LOWRANCE gave his rifle to Detective HANNIGAN. He later found out Detective
HANNIGAN put his rifle with Deputy THRELKEL and WIRTH's rifle on the side of the house.
Deputy LOWRANCE said no one went in the house and a scribe was started to record who came and
went into the scene. Deputy LOWRANCE later turned over his scribe assignment to PCSO Deputy
NATE GILLESPIE. Deputy LOWRANCE went back to the Bailey Substation in his patrol vehicle.
At about 2:00 p.m., Deputy LOWRANCE left to go home and change his clothing. He attended a
debriefing that lasted between 5:00 p.m. and 7:30 p.m. and went home again.
Please refer to the attached transcription for the complete details.
Nothing further

Page 5
02/26/2016

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH PARAMEDIC ERNIE WALKER
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
ZENTNER, GREG AGT (9844 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
INTERIVEW WITH ERNIE WALKER. WALKER WAS A FIRST RESPONDER TO THE OFFICER INVOLVER SHOOTING. WALKER WAS
ONE OF THE MEDICAL PERSONNEL ON STAND-BY IN THE AREA WHEN THE SHOOTING OCCURRED.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Address #2 - RELATED #1 - 153 DELLWOOD DR

Primary Information
Address:
153 DELLWOOD DR, BAILEY, COLORADO 80421 , UNITED STATES
Description:
PLATTE CANYON FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Deceased:
YES

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 1 of 6

Subject #2 - VICTIM #2 - MARTIN, KOLBY - Continued
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Subject #4 - EMERGENCY MEDICAL RESPONDER #1 - ERNIE WALKER

Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
ERNIE WALKER
Juvenile:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 2 of 6

Subject #5 - EMERGENCY MEDICAL RESPONDER #2 - JOE BURGETT
Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
JOE BURGETT
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #6 - LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER #1 - HANCOCK, MARK

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(303) 909-9099
Relationship
RELATED

02/28/2016 10:43
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 11:11
Reporting LEO
ZENTNER, GREG AGT (9844 / DENVER /
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 3 of 6
2016-59/5
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, at approximately 10:15 a.m. I, Colorado Bureau of Investigation
(CBI) Agent GREG ZENTNER received a request from the Park County Sheriff's Office (PCSO) to
assist with an officer involved shooting which occurred at 36 Iris Drive, Bailey, Colorado, earlier in the
morning.
I arrived on scene at approximately 11:30 a.m. CBI Agent TAMMY LEE requested that I respond to
the Platte Canyon Fire District located at 153 Dellwood, Drive, Bailey, Colorado to meet with
personnel from the Platte Canyon Fire District and interview the individuals who responded to the
scene.
At approximately 2:05 p.m. I interviewed Platte Canyon Fire District paramedic ERNIE WALKER.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, at approximately 2:05 p.m. I interviewed Platte Canyon Fire
District (PCFE) Paramedic ERNIE WALKER at153 Dellwood, Drive, Bailey, Colorado.
WALKER provided a detailed statement about his response to the officer involved shooting at 36 Iris
Drive, Bailey, Colorado. The following is a summary of WALKER's interview. For a complete
account of WALKER's interview please review the attached audio recording.
WALKER said at about 9:00 a.m. this morning the PCSO advised the PCFD they were going to do a
high risk warrant service and the PCSO requested paramedics be on stand-by in the area in case
anything happened. WALKER said the PCSO wanted to execute the warrant at about 9:30 a.m.
WALKER said he was not aware of what the warrant was for.
WALKER said members of the PCSO and PCFD discussed where to stage before the warrant was
executed. WALKER said they decided to take the long way around and stage in an area where they
were not visible to the occupant at 36 Iris Drive.
WALKER said when he and PCFD Assistant Chief JOE BURGETT were staged they could monitor
the radio traffic from the PCSO Deputies who were serving the warrant. WALKER said they were
joined in the ambulance by PCFD Captain DEVIN MACDONALD. WALKER said he heard the
Deputies on the radio as they were approaching the residence. WALKER said he could not see the
Deputies as they approached the house. WALKER said he heard someone on the radio say there was a
person on the front porch of the residence as the Deputies approached. WALKER said he heard on the
radio that the Deputies made contact with the suspect (later identified as MARTIN WIRTH) who was
standing on the deck, and then heard on the radio that WIRTH went back into the house. WALKER
said he did not know if the Deputies knocked on the door of the residence but he did hear someone say
there was a "green light to breach the door". WALKER said just after that announcement on the radio
he heard a sound which he thought was the door being breached.
WALKER said within moments of the call to breach the door, he could hear what he thought were
numerous gunshots. WALKER said almost immediately after the gunshots he heard a call on the radio
for a medical response to the residence. WALKER said as he was responding to the residence he heard
on the radio, "shots fired, officer down". WALKER said as he was approaching the residence he heard
ZENTNER, GREG AGT (9844 / DENVER / CBI - Denver)
02/28/2016
Page 1
2016-59/5
another call on the radio of another officer who had been shot. WALKER said he had to park the
ambulance about halfway up the drive way to the residence because the driveway was blocked with
Sheriff's Department vehicles. WALKER said as he was walking up the driveway he could still hear
gunshots being fired in the area.
WALKER said at this point he heard a call on the radio for two Flight for Life helicopters to be
launched immediately.
WALKER said when he arrived at the house he initially saw Deputy MARTIN laying on the ground in
the driveway and he was yelling that he had been shot in the legs. WALKER said he could also see
there was another Deputy just beyond Deputy MARTIN. This Deputy was laying face down in the
snow and did not appear to be moving. WALKER identified this second Deputy as NATHANIEL
CARRIGAN.
WALKER said he and BURGETT gave MARTIN a quick check to find out where he was shot.
WALKER said MARTIN told him he was shot in the legs. WALKER said they immediately went to
CARRIGAN to check on him because CARRIGAN was not moving. WALKER said MACDONLAD
stayed with MARTIN and provided medical attention.
WALKER said as he was approaching CARRIGAN it appeared that CARRIGAN had not moved since
CARRIGAN fell down because the snow around CARRIGAN was not disturbed. WALKER said when
he got to CARRIGAN he did an initial blood sweep to see if he could found out where CARRIGAN
was shot since CARRIGAN was not responding to verbal direction. WALKER said he did not initially
see any gunshot wounds on CARRIGAN. WALKER said he rolled CARRIGAN onto his right side
and then onto his back to check him again for gunshot wounds. WALKER said he noticed right away
that CARRIGAN was in Agonal respiration (an abnormal pattern of breathing characterized by gasping,
labored breathing) and he did not have a pulse and he was turning blue in color. WALKER also
commented CARRIGAN appeared lifeless to him.
WALKER said he then cut/tore open CARRIGAN's uniform shirt and removed the front panel of he
bullet resistant vest to check him for gunshot wounds. WALKER said CARRIGAN was wearing a full
blue PCSD uniform with a tactical vest on over the uniform. WALKER said he thought CARRIGAN
was wearing a duty belt but could not remember for certain. I asked WALKER if he remembered
seeing CARRIGAN's duty weapon and WALKER said he did not remember seeing CARRIGAN's
weapon at all. WALKER said he did not know what happened to this outer vest. WALKER said he
thought he may have cut the shoulder straps of the ballistic vest under the uniform shirt and he may
have released the Velcro on the torso part of the vest to remove the front part. WALKER said he threw
the front part of the vest out of the way. WALKER said as he was checking CARRIGAN he noticed
there was some blood in CARRIGAN's left arm pit.
WALKER commented he could still hear gunfire at this point but he was not certain where the gunfire
was coming from. WALKER said he just knew it was coming from the direction of the house which
was behind him at the moment.
WALKER said at this point he and BURGETT had to triage both Deputies and make a decision about
who to give medical attention to with the limited resources on scene. WALKER said because
CARRIGAN was not responding at all he labeled CARRIGAN as "black", meaning the likelihood of
CARRIGAN recovering from his injuries was very small. WALKER said he based this decision on his
02/28/2016
Page 2
2016-59/5
initial observations of CARRIGAN and his experience and training as a paramedic. WALKER said he
left BURGETT with CARRIGAN and went to start treating KOLBY MARTIN with MACDONALD.
WALKER said eventually he and MACDONALD were able to get KOLBY MARTIN onto a
backboard and into their ambulance which was parked near the bottom of the driveway. WALKER
said he was not sure where the backboard came from. WALKER said they cut MARTIN's clothing off
of him to find out where he was shot and where to apply pressure to stop the bleeding. WALKER said
they also removed MARTIN's duty belt and left it at the scene. WALKER said he thought MARTIN
was shot four times, two in the lower torso and one in each thigh. WALKER said it appeared as though
MARTIN had a fractured femur in his left leg because of the angle of MARTIN's lower leg as he was
laying on the stretcher in the ambulance. WALKER said he helped stabilize MARTIN while they
transported MARTIN to PCFD station 2. MARTIN was then flown to St. Anthony's Hospital in
Lakewood, Colorado via Flight for Life helicopter.
WALKER said he and MACDONALD drove back to the scene and started checking all of the other
Deputies who were on scene for injuries. WALKER said they checked everyone who was on scene at
the time of the shooting and then took PCSD Captain MARK HANCOCK to St. Anthony's Hospital in
Lakewood, Colorado via ambulance. WALKER said HANCOCK appeared to be shot in the left ear.
WALKER said as they were transporting HANCOCK to the hospital he performed a check to see if he
had other injuries. WALKER said he noted there was a mark on HANCOCK calf which may have
been from a ricochet.
WALKER said after he transported HANCOCK to the hospital he cleaned out the ambulance and then
drove back to Bailey.
Nothing further,
G. Zentner
02/28/2016
Page 3

Primary Information
Description:
INTERIVEW WITH FIREFIGHTER JACOB GLEASON
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
INTERVIEW WITH JACOB GLEASON. GLEASON IS A VOLUNTEER FIREFIGHTER WITH THE PLATTE CANYON FIRE PROTECTION
DISTRICT. GLEASON RESPONDED TO THE SCENE OF THE OFFICER INVOLVED SHOOTING TO ASSIST.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 1 of 4

Personal Information - Continued
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Subject #2 - EMERGENCY MEDICAL RESPONDER #1 - JOE BURGETT

Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
JOE BURGETT
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #3 - EMERGENCY MEDICAL RESPONDER #2 - GLEASON, JACOB

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
GLEASON, JACOB
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(303) 838-5853
Relationship
RELATED

02/28/2016 10:45
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 11:23
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 2 of 4
2016-59/6
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
the Platte Canyon Fire District located at 153 Dellwood, Drive, Bailey, Colorado to met with personnel
from the Platte Canyon Fire District and interview the individuals who responded to the scene.
At approximately 12:45 p.m. I interviewed Platte Canyon Fire District volunteer Firefighter JACOB
GLEASON.
ACTION TAKEN:
District (PCFD) volunteer Firefighter JACOB GLEASON at 153 Dellwood Drive, Bailey, Colorado.
GLEASON provided a detailed statement about his response to the officer involved shooting at 36 Iris
Drive, Bailey, Colorado. The following is a summary of GLEASON's interview. For a complete
account of GLEASON's interview please review the attached audio recording.
GLEASON said he is a volunteer Firefighter I with the PCFD and has been with the department since
2014. GLEASON said his medical training only consisted of CPR training to this point. GLEASON
said he is not EMT certified.
GLEASON said this morning at about 9:55 a.m., as he was arriving at the PCFD he heard on the fire
department radio a request for two Flight for Life helicopters to fly to PCFD station 2 located at 153
Dellwood Drive, Bailey, Colorado.
GLEASON said when he got to the PCFD he saw a couple of the fire department trucks staged by the
helipad located just behind station 2. GLEASON said he put on his bunker gear and went up to the
helipad to see if he could help in any way.
GLEASON said as he and EMT PAUL STOLTMAN were waiting for the helicopters they heard a call
on the radio for a second ambulance to respond to the scene of the officer involved shooting at 36 Iris
Drive, Bailey, Colorado. GLEASON said he and STOLTMAN drove a second ambulance (PCFD
ambulance number 3) to the scene as requested.
GLEASON said when they arrived on scene they drove up the driveway to the house where they met
with JOE BURGETT. GLEASON said it was not immediately clear to him who needed medical
attention. GLEASON said BURGETT directed him to get the stretcher out of the ambulance so
emergency personnel could put Park County Sheriff's Deputy NATHANIEL CARRIGAN in the
ambulance for transport to station 2. GLEASON said he has known CARRIGAN since GLEASON
was in high school.
02/28/2016
Page 1
2016-59/6
GLEASON said he could see Deputy CARRIGAN laying on the ground. GLEASON said CARRIGAN
was laying on his back and his shirt was open and the front part of his body armor was missing.
GLEASON said CARRIGAN did have on uniform pants and boots as well as a duty belt, but
GLEASON did not see CARRIGAN's firearm. GLEASON said he could see there was a little bit of
blood underneath CARRIGAN's left arm. GLEASON said he did not see any other Deputies which
needed medical attention.
GLEASON said he was trying to stay out of the way while the other PCFD members were loading
CARRIGAN into the ambulance.
GLEASON said after CARRIGAN was loaded into the ambulance they drove him down to PCFD
station 2 and backed into the ambulance bay and shut the overhead door. GLEASON said
STOLTMAN instructed GLEASON to be sure all of the doors to the ambulance bay were secure and
not let anyone inside except law enforcement officers and the Coroner.
Nothing further,
G. Zentner
02/28/2016
Page 2

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH EMT PAUL STOLTMAN
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
INTERVIEW WITH EMT PAUL STOLTMAN. STOLTMAN RESPONDED TO THE SCENE OF THE OFFICER INOLVED SHOOTING.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Deceased:
YES

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 1 of 5

Subject #2 - VICTIM #2 - HANCOCK, MARK - Continued
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Page 2 of 5

Subject #5 - EMERGENCY MEDICAL RESPONDER #1 - PAUL STOLTMAN
Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
PAUL STOLTMAN
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(720) 370-6133
Relationship
RELATED

02/28/2016 10:45
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 11:55
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 3 of 5
2016-59/7
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
the Platte Canyon Fire District located at 153 Dellwood Drive, Bailey, Colorado to met with personnel
from the Platte Canyon Fire District and interview the individuals who responded to the scene.
At approximately 1:15 p.m. I interviewed Platte Canyon Fire District Emergency Medical Technician
PAUL STOLTMAN.
ACTION TAKEN:
District (PCFE) volunteer Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) PAUL STOLTMAN at 153
Dellwood Drive, Bailey, Colorado.
STOLTMAN provided a detailed statement about his response to the officer involved shooting at 36
Iris Drive Bailey, Colorado. The following is a summary of STOLTMAN's interview. For a complete
account of STOLTMAN's interview please review the attached audio recording.
STOLTMAN said earlier today he was at PCFD station 2 and he was upstairs exercising. STOLTMAN
said he had his headphones on so he did not hear the initial call from the officers on-scene of the
shooting for assistance. STOLTMAN said at about 9:48 a.m. he heard a call over the radio for a call
for a second helicopter to start towards Bailey.
STOLTMAN said he put on his bunker gear and took PCFD engine 58 up to the helipad to wait for the
Flight for Life helicopter to land. STOLTMAN said the standard operating procedure is to block off the
access to the helipad for any unauthorized vehicles and wait for the ambulance to arrive to transfer the
victim to the helicopter.
STOLTMAN said as he was blocking off the helipad he received instructions from the Chief to take
another ambulance to the scene. STOLTMAN said he took PCFD Firefighter GLEASON and they
responded to the scene in ambulance 3.
STOLTMAN said when they arrived on scene they were directed to drive straight up the driveway to
the top. STOLTMAN said he met with Chief BURGETT who instructed STOLTMAN that his job was
to transport Deputy CARRIGAN down to PCFD station 2.
STOLTMAN said when he first saw CARRIGAN he was already on a backboard and ready to be
placed on a stretcher and into the ambulance. STOLTMAN said CARRIGAN's uniform shirt was open
in the front and his chest was exposed. STOLTMAN said he did not see the front panel of
CARRIGAN's body armor. STOLTMAN said someone told him CARRIGAN was deceased due to a
gunshot wound.
02/28/2016
Page 1
2016-59/7
STOLTMAN said he did see numerous items of evidence laying on the ground. STOLTMAN said he
saw casings, police radios, police gear, rifles and medical bags scattered around the area.
STOLTMAN said CARRIGAN was loaded into the ambulance and then drove CARRIGAN to PCFD
station 2. STOLTMAN said Chief BURGETT placed a blanket over CARRIGAN during the ride to
the station.
STOLTMAN said when they arrived at the station he backed into the ambulance bay and then closed
the doors. STOLTMAN said he then waited for law enforcement to arrive.
Nothing further,
G. Zentner
02/28/2016
Page 2

Primary Information
Description:
FLIGHT FOR LIFE DISPATCH RECORDINGS
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
CONTACTED KATHLEEN MAYER FROM FLIGHT FOR LIFE BASED AT SAINT ANTHONY'S HOSPITAL IN LAKEWOOD, COLORADO.
SAINT ANTHONY'S RECEIVED AN OFFICER FROM A SHOOTING SCENE IN PARK COUNTY. MAYER PROVIDED A COPY OF THE
DISPATCH TAPES FROM THE FLIGHT FOR LIFE.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Address #2 - DISPATCHED TO #1 - 153 DELLWOOD DR

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
Address #3 - RELATED #1 - 11600 W 2ND PL

Primary Information
Address:
11600 W 2ND PL, LAKEWOOD, COLORADO 80228 , UNITED STATES
Description:
ST. ANTHONY HOSPITAL

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 1 of 5

Subject #1 - VICTIM #1 - CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL - Continued
Deceased:
YES

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
Number
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
State
Country
As Of Date
Fictitious
Comment
Page 2 of 5

Identifications - Continued
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Subject #5 - MEDICAL CARE FACILITY #1 - MAYER, KATHLEEN

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MAYER, KATHLEEN
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(720) 321-3920
Relationship
RELATED
Property #1 - FLIGHT FOR LIFE CALL FOR SERVICE RECORDINGS

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
AUDIO TAPE
Description:
FLIGHT FOR LIFE CALL FOR SERVICE RECORDINGS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/26/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
ON A THUMB DRIVE
Collected Date/Time:
02/26/2016 00:00

02/28/2016 12:20
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 12:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 3 of 5

Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:32
Page 4 of 5
2016-59/8
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
As part of the investigation I contacted KATHLEEN MAYER, who is the Flight for Life Program
Director at St. Anthony's Hospital located at 11600 W. 2nd Place, Lakewood, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, at approximately 3:30 p.m. I contacted KATHLEEN MAYER at
St. Anthony's Hospital about making a copy of the Flight for Life dispatch tapes connected to the
officer involved shooting in Park County earlier in the day.
MAYER said she would be able to provide a copy of the dispatch recordings.
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, MAYER contacted me via telephone and said she had a copy of the
dispatch recordings for the Flight for Life helicopters.
At approximately 9:45 a.m. I met MAYER at St. Anthony's Hospital and she provided me with a black
flash drive which contained the recordings. MAYER signed a CBI Property/ Evidence form releasing
the flash drive to me.
I have attached the audio recordings to this report and the flash drive has been submitted to evidence.
Nothing further,
G. Zentner
02/28/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
PARK COUNTY DISPATCH RECORDINGS
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
DISPATCHER MARIA MITCHELL PROVIDED A COPY OF THE DISPATCH RECORDINGS FROM PARK COUNTY SHERIFF'S
DEPARTMENT FOR OFFICER INVOLVED SHOOTING.
Address #1 - BUSINESS #1 - 1180 COUNTY ROAD 16

Primary Information
Address:
1180 COUNTY ROAD 16, FAIRPLAY, COLORADO 80440 , UNITED STATES
Address #2 - BUSINESS #2 - 59961 US HIGHWAY 285

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
PARK COUNTY- SHERIFF DEPARTMENT SUBSTATION

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Deceased:
YES
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Page 2 of 4

Subject #5 - OTH AGY - LAW ENFORCE #1 - MITCHELL, MARIA
Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MITCHELL, MARIA
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(303) 816-0732
(719) 836-2494
(719) 839-0965
Relationship
RELATED
RELATED
RELATED
Property #1 - DISPATCH RECORDINGS FROM PARK COUNTY, LIST OF CALL SIGNS, CALL SUMMARY
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CD AND DVD DISC
Description:
DISPATCH RECORDINGS FROM PARK COUNTY, LIST OF CALL SIGNS, CALL SUMMARY
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
02/25/2016 00:00

02/28/2016 12:49
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 12:30
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 4
2016-59/9
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
As part of the investigation I contacted MARIA MITCHELL, who is a dispatcher with the PCSO, to
inquire about obtaining a copy of the dispatch recordings surrounding the officer involved shooting.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, at approximately 2:00 p.m. I contacted MARIA MITCHELL via
cell phone at the PCSO dispatch center about making a copy of the PCSO dispatch tapes connected to
the officer involved shooting in Park County earlier in the day.
MITCHELL said she would be able to provide a copy of the dispatch recordings.
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, MITCHELL provided a copy of the PCSO dispatch recordings on a
compact disc along with a PCSO roster and call summary.
I have attached the audio recordings to this report and the CD has been submitted to evidence along
with the PCSO roster and call summary.
Nothing further,
G. Zentner
02/28/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
POST MORTEM EXAMINATION OF DEPUTY CARRIGAN AND MARTIN WIRTH
Occurence From:
02/25/2016 08:30
Occurence To:
02/25/2016 17:00
Reporting LEO:
VOLZ, DANIEL LEE AGT (9103 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/07/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
Post Mortem examination of Deputy Carrigan and Martin Wirth.
Subject #1 - CORONER #1 - KINTZ, David

Primary Information
Record Type:
CORONER
Subject Name:
KINTZ, David
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #2 - LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER #1 - GOVE, Cres

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
GOVE, Cres
Sex:
MALE
Rank/Position:
Investigator
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #3 - LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER #2 - JENNINGS, James

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
Subject Name:
JENNINGS, James
Sex:
MALE
Rank/Position:
Photographer
Subject #4 - LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER #3 - ROTH, Gentry

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
Subject Name:
ROTH, Gentry
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 9

Subject #4 - LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER #3 - ROTH, Gentry - Continued
Sex:
MALE
Rank/Position:
Laboratory Investigator
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #5 - MEDICAL EXAMINER #1 - GALLOWAY, BEN MD

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
GALLOWAY, BEN MD
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
US Citizen:
YES
Property #1 - Shirt and Undershirt of CARRIGAN

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
Shirt and Undershirt of CARRIGAN
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Property #2 - Socks and Shoes of CARRIGAN

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
SHOES
Description:
Socks and Shoes of CARRIGAN
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Property #3 - Belt, Pants, Underwear of CARRIGAN

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 9

Property #3 - Belt, Pants, Underwear of CARRIGAN - Continued
Description:
Belt, Pants, Underwear of CARRIGAN
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Property #4 - Vest Back of CARRIGAN

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING ACCESSORY
Description:
Vest Back of CARRIGAN
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Property #5 - Swabs of CARRIGAN

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BUCCAL SWABS
Description:
Swabs of CARRIGAN
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Property #6 - Projectile from Chest of CARRIGAN

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Projectile from Chest of CARRIGAN
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 9

Property #7 - Projectile from sternum on top of clothes of WIRTH
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Projectile from sternum on top of clothes of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Property #8 - Projectile in body bag under head of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Projectile in body bag under head of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Property #9 - Projectile loose in body bag of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Projectile loose in body bag of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Property #10 - Fragment from head wound of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Fragment from head wound of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 4 of 9

Property #11 - Projectile from right arm of WIRTH
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Projectile from right arm of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Property #12 - Projectile from right chest of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Projectile from right chest of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Property #13 - Projectile from right neck of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Projectile from right neck of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Property #14 - Projectile from 5th ICS - WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Projectile from 5th ICS - WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 5 of 9

Property #15 - Fragment from left hip of WIRTH
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Fragment from left hip of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Property #16 - Swabs of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BUCCAL SWABS
Description:
Swabs of WIRTH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Property #17 - Jacket and shirt of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
Jacket and shirt of WIRTH
Property Status:
RELEASED TO AGENCY
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Remarks:
Retained by Jefferson County for drying at their facility.
Property #18 - Boots of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
SHOES
Description:
Boots of WIRTH
Property Status:
RELEASED TO AGENCY
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 6 of 9

Property #18 - Boots of WIRTH - Continued
Remarks:
Retained by Jefferson County until drying complete.
Property #19 - Clothing of WIRTH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
Clothing of WIRTH
Property Status:
RELEASED TO AGENCY
Status Date:
02/29/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
NO
Remarks:
Clothing of WIRTH retained by Jefferson County for drying of blood at their facility.

VOLZ, DANIEL LEE AGT (9103 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
02/29/2016 08:59
Last Update Date:
04/07/2016 17:54
Reporting LEO
Date
VOLZ, DANIEL LEE AGT (9103 / DENVER
/ Colorado Bureau of Investigation Denver)
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 7 of 9
2016-59/10
ACTION TAKEN:
On February 25, 2016, I met with Dr. BEN GALLOWAY at the Jefferson County Coroners Office
located at 800 Jefferson County Pkwy #1000, Golden, Colorado. An autopsy was scheduled to be
performed on Deputy NATHANIEL CARRIGAN at 8:30 AM.
At approximately 9:00 AM, Dr. GALLOWAY began conducting the post-mortem examination. Also
present were Agent-in-Charge CHRIS SCHAEFER, Jefferson County Sheriffs Investigator CRES
GOVE, Jefferson County Sheriffs Laboratory Investigator GENTRY ROTH, Park County Coroner
DAVID KINTZ and other Coroner Office personnel. The examination was documented by Jefferson
County Sheriffs Office Photographer JAMES JENNINGS.
During the examination, GENTRY ROTH documented, packaged, sealed and took custody of evidence
consisting of clothing that CARRIGAN was dressed in, buccal swabs, and a projectile taken from the
chest area of the body. The projectile appeared to be .45 caliber.
Upon further examination, the projectile appeared to enter and exit CARRIGANS upper left arm and
then re-enter his body through the area of the left armpit. The projectile appeared to have traveled
from a slightly downward angle coming to rest in the mid to lower right chest area. Dr. GALLOWAY
indicated the path of the projectile caused massive bleeding from both chambers of the heart.
Laboratory tests and final reports from Dr. GALLOWAY will be forthcoming.
concluded at approximately 10:33 AM.
The exam was
Deputy CARRIGANS body was removed from Coroners Office and transported back to Park County.
The body of MARTIN WIRTH was then delivered to the examination room. At approximately 11:15
AM, Dr. GALLOWAY began conducting the post-mortem examination.
Again, GENTRY ROTH documented, packaged, sealed and took custody of evidence consisting of
clothing that WIRTH was dressed in, buccal swabs, and projectiles during the examination.
Upon further examination, approximately 10 projectiles appeared to enter WIRTHS body from the
back, ranging from the left buttocks to the upper shoulder areas. From X-Rays of the body, all
projectiles appeared to be of similar shape and size. Once removed, the projectiles appeared to be
9MM.
There appeared to be at least 3 exit wounds from projectiles on the upper chest area of WIRTH. There
was also a bullet wound to the left forehead area, which appeared to be from front to back. There
appeared to be a small skull fracture and projectile fragment near the entrance above the left eyebrow.
The projectile appeared to continue along the skull for several inches before exiting.
One projectile was left in the body as it was unable to be retrieved. Upon X-Rays, it appeared to be
imbedded in the pelvis area.
Laboratory tests and final reports from Dr. GALLOWAY would be forthcoming.
concluded at approximately 2:23 PM.
The exam was
A transfer of evidence from GENTRY ROTH to AIC SCHAEFER and I took place at approximately
2:47 PM. ROTH maintained custody of WIRTHS clothing for the purpose of drying blood at the
VOLZ, DANIEL LEE AGT (9103 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation)
Page 1
02/29/2016
2016-59/10
Jefferson County Sheriffs Office facility. AIC SCHAEFER and I took custody of the remainder of the
evidence.
I placed Deputy CARRIGANS clothing and buccal swabs into evidence at the Denver Office of the
CBI at approximately 4:20 PM.
Immediately after, AIC SCHAEFER and I placed the remainder of the evidence into the CBI Denver
Laboratory for future examination, which consisted of the following:
1. Projectile from chest area of Deputy CARRIGAN
2. Projectile on top of sternum area of clothes from WIRTH
3. Projectile under head of WIRTH in body bag
4. Projectile loose in body bag of WIRTH
5. Projectile fragment from head of WIRTH
6. Projectile from right arm of WIRTH
7. Projectile from under skin of right chest from WIRTH
8. Projectile from right neck of WIRTH
9. Projectile from 5th intercostal space of WIRTH
10. Projectile fragment from left hip of WIRTH
11. Buccal swabs from WIRTH
No further reporting.
VOLZ, DANIEL LEE AGT (9103 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation)

Page 2
02/29/2016

Primary Information
Description:
Analytical Assistance
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/25/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
LUNN, MARIA ELENA (5369 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
MARTINEZ, TIMOTHY JOSEPH AIC (5517 / GAMING / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Synopsis
PROVIDED ANALYTICAL SUPPORT TO INVESTIGATION.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------

bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2

Record Status Information - Continued
02/29/2016 09:14
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:27
Reporting LEO
LUNN, MARIA ELENA (5369 / DENVER /
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
MARTINEZ, TIMOTHY JOSEPH AIC (5517
/ GAMING / Colorado Bureau of
5/26/2016
Page 2 of 2

Primary Information
Description:
Audio of interview with RICH GABRISCH
Reporting LEO:
SCHAEFER, CHRIS AGT (7713 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
RICH GABRISCH was interviewed regarding his dealings with suspect MARTIN WIRTH.
Address #1 - RESIDENTIAL #1 - 116 IRIS DR

Primary Information
Address:
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - GABRISH, RICH

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
GABRISH, RICH
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
10/22/1939
Age:
76 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(303) 838-6276
(303) 229-8582
Relationship
RELATED
SUBSCRIBER

02/29/2016 09:15
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:28
Reporting LEO
Date
SCHAEFER, CHRIS AGT (7713 / DENVER
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2
2016-59/12
SYNOPSIS:
Myself and Agent In Charge (AIC) DAN VOLZ conducted an interview with RICH GALBRISH on
February 24, 2016.
ACTION TAKEN:
On February 24, 2016, I, along with AIC VOLZ conducted an interview with RICH GALBRISH.
GALBRISH is a neighbor to suspect MARTIN WIRTH and spoke of WIRTH's hatred toward the
police and his overall demeanor.
The interview was audio taped and was sent for transcription.
SCHAEFER, CHRIS AGT (7713 / DENVER / COLORADO BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION)

02/29/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
Range qualification records sent by SVEN BONNELYCKE from PCSO
Reporting LEO:
SCHAEFER, CHRIS AGT (7713 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/23/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
SVEN BONNELYCKE with the Park County Sheriffs Office provided me with range qualifiction records for the Park County officers
involved in the homicide of Corporal NATE CARRIGAN.
Address #1 - BUSINESS #1 - 1180 COUNTY ROAD 16

Primary Information
Address:
1180 COUNTY ROAD 16, FAIRPLAY, COLORADO 80440 , UNITED STATES
Subject #1 - OTH AGY - LAW ENFORCE #1 - BONNELYCKE, SVEN

Primary Information
Record Type:
Subject Name:
BONNELYCKE, SVEN
Juvenile:
NO
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(719) 839-0791
Relationship
RELATED

02/29/2016 10:31
Last Update Date:
04/23/2016 14:51
Reporting LEO
Date
SCHAEFER, CHRIS AGT (7713 / DENVER
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2
2016-59/13
SYNOPSIS:
Captain SVEN BONNELYCKE of the Park County Sheriff's provided me, AIC CHRIS SCHAEFER,
with range qualification records for the officers involved in the death of Corporal NATE CARRIGAN.
ACTION TAKEN:
The qualification records are in the attachment portion of this report.
SCHAEFER, CHRIS AGT (7713 / DENVER / COLORADO BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION)

<<CaseReport.ReportDate[Date]>>
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
INITIAL RESPONSE AND INTERVIEW WITH ASSISTANT FIRE CHIEF JOE BURGETT
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 12:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 12:00
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Probable
Reporting LEO:
MOORE, JENNIFER AGT (GAMING / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/08/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
ON WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 24, 2016, CBI AGENT GREG ZENTNER AND I INTERVIEWED PLATTE CANYON ASSISTANT FIRE
CHIEF, JOE BURGETT, IN REFERENCE TO AN OFFICER-INVOLVED SHOOTING AT 36 IRIS DRIVE IN BAILEY, CO.
Address #1 - BUSINESS #1 - 153 DELWOOD DR

Primary Information
Address:
153 DELWOOD DR, BAILEY, COLORADO 80421 , UNITED STATES
Description:
PLATTE CANYON FIRE DEPARTMENT

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Rank/Position:
PARK COUNTY CORPORAL
Juvenile:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 6

Subject #2 - CORONER #1 - DON COMSTOCK
Primary Information
Record Type:
CORONER
Subject Name:
DON COMSTOCK
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #3 - CORONER #2 - KINTZ, David

Primary Information
Record Type:
CORONER
Subject Name:
KINTZ, David
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #4 - FIRE FIGHTER #1 - JOE BURGETT

Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
JOE BURGETT
Juvenile:
NO
Property #1 - HANDWRITTEN DIAGRAM OF SCENE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
HANDWRITTEN DIAGRAM OF SCENE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/07/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Disposition:
PROPERTY EVIDENCE STORAGE
02/24/2016 00:00
Related Officers
LEO

02/29/2016 10:34
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 6

Last Update Date:
03/08/2016 10:41
Reporting LEO
MOORE, JENNIFER AGT (GAMING /
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 6
2016-59/14
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Agent GREG ZENTNER
and I interviewed Platte Canyon Assistant Fire Chief, JOE BURGETT, in reference to an
officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I (CBI Agent JENNIFER MOORE) was requested by CBI
Agent-in-Charge KIRBY LEWIS to respond to 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, in reference to an
officer-involved shooting. Initial information was provided that three Park County Sheriff's deputies
and a civilian had been shot during the incident, but the details of the situation were unknown at the
time. During the drive to Bailey, updated information was provided that one of the involved deputies
did not survive his injuries.
Other CBI Agents responded to the scene as well, and had arrived shortly before me. While en route, I
heard Agent HASSENSTAB advise over the CBI police radio that the Jefferson County bomb squad
was en route, and that the house at 36 Iris Drive had not yet been cleared of potential threats to law
enforcement. Agent HASSENSTAB suggested that due to possible unstable conditions, responding
CBI Agents should stage at the fire truck parked in the area.
Upon arrival, I met with other CBI Agents at the staging area near the fire truck. I was informed the
deputy who did not survive had been transported to the Platte Canyon Fire Department (PCFD). Agent
ZENTNER and I responded to the fire station to secure the body, as well as interview the responding
fire personnel.
When we arrived at the fire station, we met briefly with the Park County Coroner, DAVID KINTZ JR,
and Chief Deputy Coroner, DON COMSTOCK. COMSTOCK escorted me into the back of an
ambulance, where I observed Deputy NATHANIEL "NATE" CARRIGAN. CARRIGAN was lying on
his back on a stretcher with his arms secured across his chest with straps. His body was covered up to
his neck/chest area with a white blanket. COMSTOCK told me he moved the blanket in order to take
photographs of CARRIGAN, but otherwise CARRIGAN had not been moved from the above described
position.
Agent ZENTNER and I then began interviewing Platte Canyon and Elk Creek fire personnel, who had
all gathered at the Platte Canyon fire station after the incident. Our initial interview with PCFD
Assistant Chief, JOE BURGETT, was conducted jointly, however all additional interviews were done
separately.
BURGETT said he started with the Platte Canyon Fire Department as a volunteer firefighter in 1997,
and was hired on as a paid employee approximately 12 years ago. BURGETT received an Emergency
Medical Technician (EMT) basic certificate approximately 8 years ago, and he has since maintained his
certification.
MOORE, JENNIFER AGT (GAMING / CBI - Denver)
03/01/2016
Page 1
2016-59/14
BURGETT said the fire department received a request from the Park County Sheriff's Office (PCSO)
this morning to be on standby for an eviction. BURGETT told me it was not unusual for the fire
department to be put on standby for "high-risk" evictions, or when a person has made threats in the past
or been difficult to evict.
At approximately 9:00 a.m., PCSO Detective HANAGAN called the fire station directly and relayed
the request to Paramedic WALKER. PCSO personnel then met with PCFD personnel at the fire station
for a briefing at approximately 9:30 a.m. BURGETT said PCSO informed them that the individual at
36 Iris Drive (where the eviction was going to take place) had made threats toward law enforcement
officers in the past. According to BURGETT, specific details with regard to the threats were not
discussed. After the briefing, PCFD Captain MACDONALD, PCFD Paramedic WALKER, and
BURGETT responded to the area and staged on South Pine Drive. They were able to monitor what
PCSO deputies were doing by listening to radio channel "800 OPS 5."
According to BURGETT, they were on scene for only "moments" when they heard over the radio that
the door was being breached, shots were fired, officers were down, the suspect was down, and the
request for medical came out. BURGETT told me he was not able to see anything from his position
where they were staging, but he was able to hear the sound of gunfire through their vehicle windows
that were cracked open. BURGETT described the gunfire as several "pops", which were accompanied
by PCSO indicating on the radio that shots had been fired. BURGETT could not estimate how many
"pops" he heard, but said it was "multiple" coming from what he thought was either different guns, or
from different directions.
BURGETT said that after medical was requested, he made contact with the Sheriff who advised 2
officers were down and the suspect was down and secured. As BURGETT and his team approached
the scene, he first noticed one officer lying on the ground with obvious gunshot wounds to his legs. I
asked him to describe in further detail what he saw, and BURGETT said the officer had obvious
disfigurement to the left femur and was clutching his legs in pain. BURGETT said the only statements
the officer was making was something similar to, "my legs, my fucking legs...".
BURGETT said he and WALKER were directed to a second officer, who was lying face down on the
ground toward the back of the home. They rolled the officer over to his back in an attempt to identify
any wounds, and noticed agonal breathing, that he was blue in color, and had bloody sputum coming
from his mouth. BURGETT attempted to get a response from the officer by doing several sternum
rubs, but was unsuccessful.
WALKER and BURGETT then began removing the officer's equipment and clothing to assess for
injuries. His shirt, the front panel of his ballistic vest, and his undershirt were removed, which was
when BURGETT observed what appeared to be a single gunshot wound to the center of the left armpit.
When asked about the officer's gun, BURGETT said the gun became visible when they rolled him over
his right shoulder onto his back. WALKER grabbed the gun, removed the in-weapon magazine,
cleared the round from the chamber, and then placed the gun aside and out of the way.
As we were discussing what BURGETT observed about the scene, he asked for a piece of paper to
draw a map. As he was drawing the diagram, BURGETT identified the deputy with the leg injuries as
"KOLBY", and the deputy he found face down as "NATE."
03/01/2016
Page 2
2016-59/14
(NOTE: when BURGETT drew the officers on the diagram, he labeled the one he called KOLBY with
a "K", and the one he referred to as NATE with an "N". It was determined that the officer BURGETT
went to, who was initially face down, was NATHANIEL CARRIGAN).
After BURGETT and WALKER assessed CARRIGAN for survivability, CARRIGAN was labeled as a
"black". BURGETT explained that when the number of patients on scene outnumbers medical
personnel, decisions have to be made about survivability and where the medical resources are best used.
BURGETT said KOLBY was a yellow, but was "rapidly approaching a red" and needed to "be in the
air" immediately. It was BURGETT's opinion that KOLBY would have declined rapidly if he didn't get
immediate medical attention, and therefore WALKER left BURGETT and CARRIGAN to begin
treating KOLBY. BURGETT remained with CARRIGAN and tried to talk to him until CARRIGAN
"was gone."
BURGETT then asked the Sheriff if he wanted CARRIGAN to be transported or left on scene, and the
Sheriff requested a transport. BURGETT said he stayed with CARRIGAN during the transport to the
PCFD until another Sheriff's deputy was able to take over. BURGETT advised that the only thing he
did with CARRIGAN was secure him to a backboard and cover him with a blanket. There were no
additional life-saving efforts by himself or anyone else after the initial assessment on scene.
I asked BURGETT about any other scene observations, and he told me he noticed the front door of the
house standing open, but he never saw the suspect at any time. He also saw bullet holes in the window
to the right of the door, as well as a camper near the house and a white Ford F150 in the barn.
BURGETT could not provide any additional information, and was instructed to call me in the event
that he remembered anything else, or anything differently. A copy of the interview recording has been
attached to this report.
03/01/2016
Page 3

Primary Information
Description:
DANIEL SPYKSTRA interview
Occurence From:
02/25/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/25/2016 00:00
Source Of Info:
DANIEL SPYKSTRA
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Probable
Reporting LEO:
BROWN, JEFF AGT (1107 / GRAND JUNCTION / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/01/2016
Approved By:
REESE, COLLIN AIC (7366 / GRAND JUNCTION / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Synopsis
On February 24, 2016 I was contacted by CBI Agent in charge DAN VOLZ. AIC VOLZ stated he was assisting with an officer involved
shooting investigation in Park County, CO. The suspect in the case was identified as MARTIN WIRTH. Mr. WIRTH died at the scene.
AIC VOLZ received information about a permanent restraining order against Mr. WIRTH. The protected party was identified as
DANIEL SPYKSTRA. AIC VOLZ said he had been in contact with Mr. SPYKSTRA who was now living in the Durango, CO area. Mr.
SPYKSTRA was willing to speak to investigators about Mr. WIRTH and the details surrounding the restraining order. AIC VOLZ
requested that I conduct the interview with Mr. SPYKSTRA. I contacted Mr. SPYKSTRA and arranged to meet him the next morning at
the FBI office in Durango.
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - Spykstra, Daniel

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Spykstra, Daniel
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
12/22/1970
Age:
45 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Employment Information
Employed:
YES
Occupation:
UPS driver in Durango,Co
Date Employed:
02/25/2016 00:00

BROWN, JEFF AGT (1107 / GRAND JUNCTION / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
02/29/2016 12:54
REESE, COLLIN AIC (7366 / GRAND JUNCTION / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Last Update Date:
03/01/2016 15:33
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

Reporting LEO
BROWN, JEFF AGT (1107 / GRAND
JUNCTION / Colorado Bureau of
Date
Supervisor
REESE, COLLIN AIC (7366 / GRAND
JUNCTION / Colorado Bureau of
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4
2016-59/15
ACTION TAKEN:
On February 24, 2016 I was contacted by CBI Agent in charge DAN VOLZ. AIC VOLZ stated he was
assisting with an officer involved shooting investigation in Park County, CO. The suspect in the case
was identified as MARTIN WIRTH. Mr. WIRTH died at the scene. AIC VOLZ received information
about a permanent restraining order against Mr. WIRTH. The protected party was identified as
DANIEL SPYKSTRA. AIC VOLZ said he had been in contact with Mr. SPYKSTRA who was now
living in the Durango, CO area. Mr. SPYKSTRA was willing to speak to investigators about Mr.
WIRTH and the details surrounding the restraining order. AIC VOLZ requested that I conduct the
interview with Mr. SPYKSTRA. I contacted Mr. SPYKSTRA and arranged to meet him the next
morning at the FBI office in Durango.
I met Mr. SPYKSTRA at 8:00a.m. on February 25, 2016. I advised Mr. SPYKSTRA that we are
interested in any background information he may have about Mr. WIRTH.
Mr. SPYKSTRA said he was from the Bailey, CO area and recalled that Mr. WIRTH moved to the area
in the late 1990s. He met Mr. WIRTH during court ordered substance abuse counseling in 2004 or
2005. Mr. SPYKSTRA said he was a supervisor for Gateway Youth and Family Services at that time.
He said Mr. WIRTH was in counseling with Gateway two separate times, but he only met Mr. WIRTH
the second time he was ordered to attend Gateway counseling. Mr. SPYKSTRA described Mr. WIRTH
as a disruptive person during sessions and would often talk over everyone. He described Mr. WIRTH as
a conspiracy theory type of individual.
Mr. SPYKSTRA said Mr. WIRTH became more threatening after an incident where Mr. WIRTH had
upset one of his employees so bad that he had to take over the counseling session for her. (This
employee died in a vehicle accident about 2 years ago, according to Mr. SPYKSTRA). Mr.
SPYKSTRA had to effectively kick Mr. WIRTH out of the counseling session because of his
aggressive behavior. Mr. WIRTH then became very upset and verbally attacked Mr. SPYKSTRA and
started making statements to Mr. SPYKSTRA that he had no constitutional right to kick him out of a
court ordered therapy session, and that Mr. SPYKSTRA better watch his back and that Mr. WIRTH
was going to come after him. Mr. WIRTH went on to say that he could put a bomb in Mr.
SPYKSTRAs mailbox or on his desk, and that he could shoot Mr. SPYKSTRA as he was driving
home from work. This concerned Mr. SPYKSTRA so much that he applied for, and was granted a
permanent restraining order from the courts. Sometime after this, Mr. SPYKSTRA overheard Mr.
WIRTH telling another person about a murder he had committed in the past, and Mr. WIRTH was
basically telling the other person that he got off on self-defense. Mr. SPYKSTRA said it sounded
as though Mr. WIRTH was kind of bragging that he had beat the system. Mr. SPYKSTRA said he
believed Mr. WITRTH was definitely capable of making good on his threats and thought he was a
violent man. Mr. SPYKSTRA said, I thought he was a Unabomber kind of guy. Mr. SPYKSTRA
BROWN, JEFF AGT (1107 / GRAND JUNCTION / Colorado Bureau of Investigation)

Page 1
02/29/2016
2016-59/15
recalled recommending a psychological exam to Mr. WIRTHs probation officer, but he didnt know if
one was ever ordered.
Mr. SPYKSTRA said his entire dealings with Mr. WIRTH was about a 2 or 3 month time frame during
2005. Mr. SPYKSTRA said he was at Mr. WIRTHs house on one occasion around 2012. By this time,
he was working for a propane company and he was one of the workers who installed a large propane
tank on Mr. WIRTHs property. Mr. SPYKSTRA said there was no contact with Mr. WIRTH that time.
I asked Mr. SPYKSTRA if he knew of any friends that Mr. WIRTH might have had. He described Mr.
WIRTH as a loner with very few friends that he was aware of. Mr. SPYKSTRA said his social circle
and Mr. WIRTHs social circle would have never crossed paths.
At the end of the interview, Mr. SPYKSTRA expressed his sorrow for the involved Deputies and said
he knew two of them personally through his sons high school athletics. He said, Knowing WIRTH,
this is the way he wanted to go out.
Nothing further.
BROWN, JEFF AGT (1107 / GRAND JUNCTION / Colorado Bureau of Investigation)

Page 2
02/29/2016

Primary Information
Description:
OFFICER/ CRIME SCENE PICS
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/26/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/01/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplemental report contains the crime scene photographs taken by CBI's Crime Scene Agents, KEVIN TORRES and MATTHEW
RICHARDSON.
This supplement does not contain a narrative.

03/01/2016 10:25
Last Update Date:
03/01/2016 14:42
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
Hospital Collection of Evidence
Reporting LEO:
SCHIERKOLK, JEFFREY DALE AGT (7723 / FRAUD UNIT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/05/2016
Approved By:
GAGLIARDI, RALPH A AIC (3011 / FRAUD UNIT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Synopsis
Agents were assigned to go to St. Anthony's Hospital to document injuries sustained by Park County Deputies prior to surgery.
Agents also took photographs and documented items taken from Park County Deputies while at the hospital.
Address #1 - BUSINESS #1 - 11600 W 2ND PL

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #3 - DOCTOR/PHYSICIAN #1 - VOGEL, REBECCA DR

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
VOGEL, REBECCA DR
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 9

Subject #4 - EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICE #1 - BLACKMORE, ABBIE
Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
BLACKMORE, ABBIE
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
Related Officers
LEO
PINDER, JOHN (Detective Corporal / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)
EVERHART, GREG (Jefferson County Sheriff's Office)
KREBS, TAMMI (FRAUD UNIT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)

SCHIERKOLK, JEFFREY DALE AGT (7723 / FRAUD UNIT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation Denver)
03/01/2016 11:32
Last Update Date:
03/05/2016 14:01
Reporting LEO
Date
SCHIERKOLK, JEFFREY DALE AGT (7723
/ FRAUD UNIT / Colorado Bureau of
Supervisor
Date
GAGLIARDI, RALPH A AIC (3011 / FRAUD
UNIT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - 5/26/2016
Denver)
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 9
2016-59/17
SYNOPSIS:
On February 24, 2016 Agents were assigned to St. Anthony's Hospital where they would document
injuries sustained by Park County Deputies who were injured / shot early this day in Park County.
Agents also took photographs and documented items taken from Park County Deputies while at the
hospital.
ACTION TAKEN:
On February 24, 2016 at approximately 11:15 PM, CBI Agent TAMMI KREBS and I (Agent JEFF
SCHIERKOLK, Reporting Agent) were assigned to go to St. Anthony's hospital, located at 11600 W.
2nd Place, Lakewood, CO 80228 and attempt to documents the injuries sustained by Park County
Deputy Sheriffs KOLBY MARTIN and MARK HANCOCK.
Upon arrival, Agent KREBS and I were ushered to a trauma room on the 2nd floor by Jefferson County
Deputy GREG EVERHART where we were met by Trauma Program Manager ABBIE BLACKMORE.
She indicated that they had stabilized Deputy MARTIN and I could obtain necessary photos prior to
him going into surgery.
Agent KREBS and I were required to put on sterile protective clothing to include gowns, hair bonnets,
gloves and booties. I spoke with Deputy MARTIN, identified myself and asked his permission to
photograph his injuries. He stated I could as long as I didn't post it on Youtube. He said it in a joking
manner, indicating his positive attitude.
I took a series of photographs with and without a scale of his injuries and the hospital staff rotated his
body to accommodate for the photographing of his extensive wounds.
I provided to Manager BLACKMORE a CBI Physician's Report of Serious Bodily Injury to be filled
out by Deputy MARTIN's doctor. Dr. REBECCA VOGEL later filled it out indicating Deputy
MARTIN's injuries were "Multiple gunshot wounds to pelvis and bilateral lower extremities. Left
midshaft, comminuted femur fracture." and that she considered them to have "Serious Bodily Injury"
occur.
I also provided Manager BLACKMORE a CBI Request for Protected Health Information for Deputy
MARTIN as he was unable to sign a consent form at the time for his medical records. The form stayed
with the hospital staff and later, Deputy MARTIN was able to sign a consent for his records with other
Agents.
Agent KREBS and I then went to the exam room where Captain MARK HANCOCK was being treated
at. I had him sign a CBI Patient's Consent for Disclosure of Protected Health Information document to
allow the CBI to obtain his medical records and obtained his consent to photograph his injuries. He
sustained a small wound to his left ear lobe and also showed me a scratch on his right calf. I inspected
his pants in the area of his calf and did not see any marks, marring or damage to his pants. He came to
the conclusion that he must have hit his leg on something in the course of the events and was not nearly
hit with another round in the leg. We took possession of a urine sample that he had provided that was
sitting on the counter. Neither Agent KREBS or I observed the urine sample being provided; it was
already in a container when we entered the room.
SCHIERKOLK, JEFFREY DALE AGT (7723 / FRAUD UNIT / CBI - Denver) 03/01/2016
Page 1
2016-59/17
Captain HANCOCK mentioned that the gun he used during the incident was still on scene and the
Sheriff had given him his own gun to take as he was transported, so he wouldn't be unarmed.
Afterwards, we met with Park County Sheriff's Office Detective Corporal JOHN PINDER. The
hospital staff had removed all of Deputy MARTIN's clothing and equipment as part of their process to
prepare him for surgery and the items were bagged and outside the trauma suite. We took possession of
the items and transported them down to another room provided by the hospital staff to document the
items. We also later received a bag containing the clothing and equipment worn by Captain
HANCOCK. Detective Corporal PINDER and I removed the items from each bag and I photographed
it while Agent KREBS documented the items. We spread them out onto a bed covered in a blanket for
photographing and packaging requirements.
After photographing Deputy MARTIN's clothing and equipment, I went back to Captain HANCOCK's
room and photographed his injury after it has been cleaned by hospital staff. His duty t-shirt he had
been wearing was in the room and I took that to be photographed with his other property. He had
removed his badge from his duty shirt and I also took that for photographing with his shirt. I later
returned the badge to him.
I then photographed his equipment and clothing. One item to note was, he had two fully loaded
magazines in the bag containing his clothing and equipment. One was in the magazine pouch and the
other was on the bottom of the bag with his radio, keys, knife and belt keepers. Both magazines were
fully loaded with 17 rounds of 9mm ammo.
As we were finishing, hospital staff brought us a bag containing a bullet that had been removed from
Deputy MARTIN's left lateral thigh. I photographed the bag and its contents, without removing the
bullet from the bag.
The property was turned over to Park County Detective Corporal PINDER per normal agency policy.
However, it was later retrieved back by other CBI Agents as it had been determined that CBI would
maintain control over the evidence in this case.
Agent KREBS and I confirmed with Manager BLACKMORE that no further material that would be of
evidential value to us would be removed from Deputy MARTIN during the next couple of scheduled
surgeries for him, so we left the hospital.
The photographs were downloaded onto a CD and the CD was later booked into evidence. The
photographs were also uploaded to the ACISS system.
PHOTO #
DSC_0001
DSC_0002
DSC_0003
DSC_0004
DSC_0005
DSC_0006
DSC_0007
DESCRIPTION
View from doorway of Trauma suite of KOLBY MARTIN
Left outer leg injuries of KOLBY MARTIN
Upper pelvic injury of KOLBY MARTIN
Upper pelvic injury of KOLBY MARTIN
Page 2
DSC_0008
DSC_0009
DSC_0010
DSC_0011
DSC_0012
DSC_0013
DSC_0014
DSC_0015
DSC_0016
DSC_0017
DSC_0018
DSC_0019
DSC_0020
DSC_0021
DSC_0022
DSC_0023
DSC_0024
DSC_0025
DSC_0026
DSC_0027
DSC_0028
DSC_0029
DSC_0030
DSC-0031
DSC_0032
DSC_0033
DSC_0034
DSC_0035
DSC_0036
DSC_0037
DSC_0038
DSC_0039
DSC_0040
DSC_0041
DSC_0042
DSC_0043
DSC_0044
DSC_0045
DSC_0046
DSC_0047
2016-59/17
Right leg injuries of KOLBY MARTIN

Right inner leg injury of KOLBY MARTIN
Right outer leg injury of KOLBY MARTIN
Right outer leg injury with scale of KOLBY MARTIN
Right upper leg injury with scale of KOLBY MARTIN
Left outer leg injuries with scale of KOLBY MARTIN
Left outer leg injuries with scale of KOLBY MARTIN
View of inner left leg injury not seen of KOLBY MARTIN
Left back leg injury with scale of KOLBY MARTIN
Right back leg injury with scale, left back leg injury of KOLBY MARTIN
Right back leg injury, left back leg injury of KOLBY MARTIN
Right buttock injury of KOLBY MARTIN
Upper pelvic injury with scale of KOLBY MARTIN
Bruise on left abdominal area of KOLBY MARTIN
Left hand injuries with scale of KOLBY MARTIN
Left hand injuries of KOLBY MARTIN
Left thumb injury of KOLBY MARTIN
Left index finger injury of KOLBY MARTIN
View from doorway of treatment room of MARK HANCOCK
Left ear injury of MARK HANCOCK
Right leg injury of MARK HANCOCK
Right leg injury of MARK HANCOCK
Bag #1 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #1 Knife in sheath, smokeless tobacco can and string
Contents of Bag #1 Knife removed from sheath, smokeless tobacco can and
string
Bag #2 KOLBY MARTIN
Bag #2 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #2 MARTINs wallet, dogtag, earpiece and ring
Bag #3 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #3 Rock found on clothes
Bag #4 KOLBY MARTIN
Page 3
DSC_0048
DSC_0049
DSC_0050
DSC_0051
DSC_0052
DSC_0053
DSC_0054
DSC_0055
DSC_0056
DSC_0057
DSC_0058
DSC_0059
DSC_0060
DSC_0061
DSC_0062
DSC_0063
DSC_0064
DSC_0065
DSC_0066
DSC_0067
DSC_0068
DSC_0069
DSC_0070
DSC_0071
DSC_0072
DSC_0073
DSC_0074
DCS_0075
DSC_0076
DSC_0077
DSC_0078
DSC_0079
DSC_0080
DSC_0081
DSC_0082
DSC_0083
DSC_0084
DSC_0085
DSC_0086
2016-59/17
Contents of Bag #4 Rear panel of ballistic vest

Contents of Bag #4 Rear panel of ballistic vest showing backup gun holster and
fathers badge
Contents of Bag #4 Close up of backup gun holster
Contents of Bag #4 Close up of fathers badge
Bag #5 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #5 Socks and shoestring
Bag #6 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #6 - Undershirt
Bag #7 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #7 - Underwear
Contents of Bag #7 - Underwear
Contents of Bag #7 Close up of bullet hole in right buttock area
Contents of Bag #7 Close up of bullet holes in front of underwear
Bag #8 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #8 Duty uniform shirt
Contents of Bag #8 Close up of bullet hole in right front shirt tail
Contents of Bag #8 Close up of bullet hole in left front shirt tail
Contents of Bag #8 Close up of badge, shoulder patches of uniform shirt
Contents of Bag #8 Close up of pins on right side of uniform shirt
Contents of Bag #8 Back of uniform shirt
Contents of Bag #8 Close up of rear of left sleeve of uniform shirt
Contents of Bag #9 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #9 Front ballistic vest, eye protection and gloves
Contents of Bag #9 Close up of front ballistic vest panel
Contents of Bag #9 Close up of front ballistic vest panel
Contents of Bag #9 Back of front ballistic vest panel
Contents of Bag #9 Back of front ballistic vest panel
Bag #10 KOLBY MARTIN
Contents of Bag #10 Right boot with shoe string
Contents of Bag #10 Right boot with shoe string
Contents of Bag #11 Left boot with shoe string
Contents of Bag #11 Plastic bag that MARTINs clothing came in to the
hospital
Contents of Bag #12 Inside of pants
Page 4
DSC_0087
DSC_0088
DSC_0089
DSC_0090
DSC_0091
DSC_0092
DSC_0093
DSC_0094
DSC_0095
DSC_0096
DSC_0097
DSC_0098
DSC_0099
DSC_0100
DSC_0101
DSC_0102
DSC_0103
DSC_0104
DSC_0105
DSC_0106
DSC_0107
DSC_0108
DSC_0109
DSC_0110
DSC_0111
DSC_0112
DSC_0113
DSC_0114
DSC_0115
DSC_0116
DSC_0117
DSC_0118
DSC_0119
DSC_0120
DSC_0121
DSC_0122
DSC_0123
2016-59/17
Contents of Bag #12 Inside of pants

Contents of Bag #12 Gloves and knife found in pants pockets
Contents of Bag #12 Close up of bullet hole in right pant leg
Contents of Bag #12 Close up of bullet hole in right buttock area
Contents of Bag #12 Close up of bullet hole in left pant leg
Contents of Bag #12 Right pant leg with tourniquet and knife found in pants
pockets
Contents of Bag #12 Rear of pants
Contents of Bag #12 Rear of right pants leg
Contents of Bag #12 Items found in pants pockets
Contents of Bag #12 Items found in pants pockets
Contents of Bag #12 Items found in pants pockets, plus two belt keepers
Blanket on bed used to photograph contents
Blanket on bed used to photograph contents
Left ear injury of MARK HANCOCK cleaned up
Bag #13 MARK HANCOCK
Bag #13 MARK HANCOCK
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Beenie cap worn by MARK HANCOCK
T-shirt of MARK HANCOCK obtained from hospital treatment room
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Duty uniform shirt
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Close up of collar of duty uniform shirt
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Close up of front of duty uniform shirt
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Close up of badge, shoulder patch of uniform
shirt
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Contents of pocket
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Back of duty uniform shirt
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Right side of duty belt showing key case and
holster
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Left side of duty belt showing handcuff case,
flashlight, radio holster and extra magazine holder with one magazine
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Sig Sauer 9mm magazine with 17 rounds
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Sig Sauer 9mm magazine with 17 rounds
Page 5
DSC_0124
DSC_0125
2016-59/17
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Keys in key case

Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 2nd Sig Sauer 9mm magazine found in
HANCOCK bag #1 with 17 rounds
DSC_0126
DSC_0127
DSC_0128
DSC_0129
DSC_0130
DSC_0131
DCS_0132
DSC_0133
DSC_0134
DSC_0135
DSC_0136
DSC_0137
DSC_0138
DSC_0139
DSC_0140
DSC_0141
DSC_0142
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 2nd Sig Sauer 9mm magazine found in bag
with 17 rounds
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Handcuff case with one set of handcuffs
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Duty uniform jacket
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Left side view of duty uniform jacket
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Duty uniform jacket
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Collar of duty uniform jacket
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Contents of jacket pockets
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Gloves worn by MARK HANCOCK
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Gloves worn by MARK HANCOCK
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Radio, keys, knife and belt keepers
Contents of HANCOCK Bag #1 Radio, keys, knife and belt keepers
Bag and contents MARK HANCOCK
Bag and contents Urine sample from MARK HANCOCK
Bag and contents Bullet fragment recovered from left lateral thigh of KOLBY
MARTIN
MARTIN
MARTIN
MARTIN
At approximately 4:30 PM, Agents HASSENSTAB and NORDGREN asked me to assist them in
retrieving two items from the evidence that Deputy MARTIN wanted that were of personal importance.
They had obtained the evidence turned over to Park County back from them and had it at the CBI
Denver office. The items Deputy MARTIN wished to be returned included his father's badge from
Arapahoe County that he wore on the straps of his vest and a dog tag and chain he had been wearing. I
provided to them the bag numbers the items were located in and assisted in the retrieval of the items. I
photographed the re-sealing of the bags and the two items retrieved. They were re-numbered due to
having the same photo numbers as listed above. The photographs were downloaded onto a CD and the
CD was later booked into evidence. The photographs were also uploaded to the ACISS system.
DSC_0001-1
DSC_0002-2
DSC_0003-3
DSC_0004-4
Bag #2 re-sealed
Bag #4 re-sealed
Items removed
Items removed
Nothing Further.
Page 6
2016-59/17
Page 7

Primary Information
Description:
Interviews with Mortgage company representation
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/01/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
Agents went to the offices of Medved Dale Decker & Deere, LLC to speak to representatives of the company concerning the
foreclosure proceedings against MARTIN WIRTH.
Agents spoke to HEATHER DEERE and HOLLY DECKER, both attorneys, who agreed to discuss the situation.
They provided copies of all public records on the situation.
Agent interviewed process server PHILLIP STERLING who served WIRTH the eviction notices.
Address #1 - BUSINESS #1 - 355 UNION BLVD

Primary Information
Address:
355 UNION BLVD #ste 250, Lakewood, COLORADO 80228 , UNITED STATES
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - DECKER, HOLLY L.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
DECKER, HOLLY L.
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #2 - WITNESS #2 - DEERE, HEATHER L.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
DEERE, HEATHER L.
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #3 - WITNESS #3 - HAGER, MARY

Primary Information
Race:
UNKNOWN
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HAGER, MARY
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 6

Subject #3 - WITNESS #3 - HAGER, MARY - Continued
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #4 - WITNESS #4 - STERLING, PHILLIP

Primary Information
Race:
UNKNOWN
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
STERLING, PHILLIP
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Page 2 of 6

Subject #6 - BUSINESS #1 - Medved Dale Decker & Deere, LLC
Primary Information
Record Type:
BUSINESS
Subject Name:
Medved Dale Decker & Deere, LLC
Juvenile:
NO
Related Officers
LEO

SCHIERKOLK, JEFFREY DALE AGT (7723 / FRAUD UNIT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation Denver)
03/01/2016 11:32
Last Update Date:
04/01/2016 11:56
Reporting LEO
Date
SCHIERKOLK, JEFFREY DALE AGT (7723
/ FRAUD UNIT / Colorado Bureau of
Supervisor
Date
Denver)
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 6
2016-59/18
SYNOPSIS:
Agents went to the offices of Medved Dale Decker & Deere, LLC to speak to representatives of the
company concerning the foreclosure proceedings against MARTIN WIRTH.
Agents spoke to HEATHER DEERE and HOLLY DECKER, both attorneys, who agreed to discuss the
situation.
They provided copies of all public records on the situation.
Agent interviewed process server PHILLIP STERLING who served WIRTH the eviction notices.
ACTION TAKEN:
On February 24, 2016 at approximately 3:45 PM, CBI Agent-In-Charge (AIC) RALPH GAGLIARDI,
Agent TAMMY KREBS and I (Agent JEFF SCHERKOLK, Reporting Agent) went to the offices of
Medved Dale Decker & Deere, LLC, located at 355 Union Blvd in Lakewood, CO and spoke to
HOLLY DECKER and HEATHER DEERE, both attorneys, who were knowledgeable on the
foreclosure proceedings against MARTIN WIRTH.
DECKER and DEERE were both willing to speak to us concerning their firm's involvement with the
foreclosure proceedings against the residence at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, CO.
They stated the residence on Iris Drive was initially foreclosed on in June 2014 and WIRTH was
evicted from the residence. This initial foreclosure was handled by the Castle Law Group on behalf of
the Federal National Mortgage Association (FNMA) or "Fannie Mae" as it is commonly known.
However, WIRTH later broke back into the residence and began to continue to live there (squatting), so
FNMA contracted with Medved Dale Decker & Deere, LLC to conduct a second foreclosure and
eviction process. Their contact at FNMA is ANDREW WILSON (202-752-5168). They felt that was
"better" than trying to get WIRTH evicted through trespassing or other action.
Their office has had no issues or contact at all with WIRTH throughout the eviction process. They
stated that after the judgement had been entered, WIRTH did file a pleading, arguing the judge should
not be allowed to hear the court case because the judge's retirement is with the Public Employees
Retirement Association (PERA) and PERA is invested in FNMA and has a conflict of interest.
The eviction was supposed to happen earlier; however, due to a conflict with the Park County Sheriff's
Office, the Sheriff's Office had to move the eviction to today at 10:00 AM. At the beginning of the
foreclosure process, a member of the PCSO notified them that WIRTH is dangerous and to not have
their real estate agent (MARY HAGER and KEVIN WHITE) they contracted with go near the property
anymore with or be near the property when they serve the eviction. Their agent's "crew" was not go to
the property until they received a go-ahead from the PCSO.
By state law, the agent has only one hour to remove the evicted person's property out the residence, so
their agent had hired a number of day laborers to go to the property once the eviction process was
completed and move WIRTH's property out of the residence.
03/01/2016
Page 1
2016-59/18
Their office filed the appropriate paperwork regarding the foreclosure process. They indicated the
process goes in this order:
First, a Demand For Possession/Notice To Vacate is posted on the property, which was done on
December 31, 2015 by a PHILLIP STERLING, who works for their process service company. He
indicated on his Affidavit that he served the Demand on December 31, 2015 at 3:15 PM by posting a
copy in a conspicuous place upon the premises.
Second, a Complaint for Unlawful Detainer Subsequent to Foreclosure is filed with the court,
which was completed on January 6, 2016.
Third, the Complaint for Unlawful Detainer Subsequent to Foreclosure and an Answer Form are
served to the property or the person. This was completed on January 11, 2016, again by STERLING,
who noted on his Affidavit that "the defendant ordered me off of his property and refused to accept
or allow me to post to the door. I threw the files inside the door behind him".
Fourth, a court hearing was held on January 21, 2016 at 11:30 AM and a judgement against WIRTH in
the matter was held.
Fifth, A Writ of Restitution is issued 48 hours after January 21st and served by the Sheriff. This
occurred on January 23, 2016.
An Answer to the Summons in Forcible Entry and Unlawful Detainer was filed by WIRTH on January
25, 2016 in which he argued under CRS 13-1-122, When judge shall not act unless by consent, arguing
that the judge should not be allowed to hear the court case because the judge's retirement is with the
Public Employees Retirement Association (PERA) and PERA is invested in FNMA and has a conflict
of interest. He provided supporting document to his argument and requested a jury trial. WIRTH also
filed a motion with the court to waive all court fees due to his being without adequate funds to pay
them and provided financial documents to support his argument.
The Writ of Restitution is valid for 45 days after issuance and it was signed on January 25, 2016.
WIRTH's motion concerning his inability to pay court fees was heard and allowed by the court on
February 17, 2016.
All documents filed were provided to us by them and are attached to this report.
They were aware WIRTH was part of the Colorado Foreclosure Resistance Coalition, but they had no
contact with the organization, nor have they had any of their foreclosures protested by
Copies of the Writ of Restitution and other documents were found inside the residence at the time of
the search warrant execution there.
At approximately 6:00 PM, I contacted the process server, PHILLIP STERLING, who was traveling
and had not heard about the incident in Park County. He stated that when he served the Complaint for
Unlawful Detainer at the residence, WIRTH "threw a fit" and was "cussing up a storm" with the
cussing being directed at him. He stated WIRTH was visibly angry and said, "The bank doesn't own
03/01/2016
Page 2
2016-59/18
this property" and that he was to "never step foot on the property again". He stated WIRTH was
standing at the front door during their interaction and he threw the documents behind WIRTH inside
the residence and left. He stated he was not physically threatened by WIRTH and WIRTH's verbal
assault wasn't threatening towards him.
Nothing Further.
03/01/2016
Page 3

Primary Information
Description:
DENVER PD REPORT - K-9 ASSIST AT CRIME SCENE
Occurence From:
02/26/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/26/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/01/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains an attached report by Denver Police Department's Explosive Detection K-9 Unit Technician, JEFF MEYER
(K-9 HERSHEY). Technician MEYER and Technican FRANK VESSA (K-9 KAZAM) were called to assist the CBI's Crime Scene Unit
with locating shell casings at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Related Officers
LEO
MEYER, JEFF (TECHNICIAN / DENVER POLICE DEPARTMENT)
VESSA, FRANK (TECHNICIAN / DENVER POLICE DEPARTMENT)

03/01/2016 13:04
Last Update Date:
03/01/2016 14:00
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
JEFFCO SO REPORT - STATE FARM INCIDENT
Occurence From:
01/20/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
01/20/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/01/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplemental report contains an attached report received by the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office reference an incident
involving MARTIN WIRTH and staff members at State Farm, which was located in Conifer, Colorado, on January 20, 2016.
This report does not contain a narrative.

03/01/2016 13:17
Last Update Date:
03/01/2016 13:58
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH PSCO SHERIFF FRED WEGENER
Occurence From:
02/29/2016 10:20
Occurence To:
02/29/2016 11:30
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
asked to respond to Bailey, Colorado, in reference to an Officer Involved Shooting. I was assigned to be the Case Agent for the
investigation.
On Tuesday, February 29, 2016, at approximately 10:25 A.M., CBI Agent KELLON HASSENSTAB and I interviewed Sheriff FRED
WEGENER at the PCSO's Substation in Bailey, Colorado.
Related Officers
LEO
WEGENER, FRED (SHERIFF / Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)

03/01/2016 13:27
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:36
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2
2016-59/21
SYNOPSIS:
Involved Shooting. I was assigned to be the Case Agent for the investigation.
On Tuesday, February 29, 2016, at approximately 10:25 A.M., CBI Agent KELLON HASSENSTAB
and I met with Sheriff FRED WEGENER at the PCSO's Substation in Bailey, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
Sheriff FRED WEGENER was interviewed with regard to the events of February 24, 2016.
Please see the attached transcription and audio recording for details on the interview.
Nothing further.

Page 1
03/01/2016

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH ELK CREEK FIRE LIEUTENANT TIMOTHY SANDER
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 12:35
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 12:35
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Probable
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Address #1 - BUSINESS #1 - 11993 BLACKFOOT RD

Primary Information
Address:
11993 BLACKFOOT RD ELK CREEK FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT, CONIFER, COLORADO 80433 , UNITED
STATES
Description:
FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Subject #1 - FIRE FIGHTER #1 - TIMOTHY SANDER

Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
TIMOTHY SANDER
Juvenile:
NO
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(303) 816-9385
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Relationship
ASSOCIATE
Page 1 of 4

Related Officers
LEO

03/01/2016 13:47
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 12:44
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4
2016-59/22
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I interviewed Elk Creek Fire Lieutenant TIMOTHY SANDER in
reference to an officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Agent ZENTNER and I
responded to the Platte Canyon Fire Department to speak with fire personnel, who responded to an
officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey. The following is a synopsis of my interview with
Elk Creek Fire Lieutenant TIMOTHY SANDER. Our conversation was audio recorded, and a copy of
it is attached to this report.
SANDER began his career with the Elk Creek Fire Department as a volunteer in 2009. He received his
Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) certificate approximately 7 years ago, and got his Paramedic
certification approximately 3 years ago. He was hired for a paid spot with Elk Creek after becoming a
Paramedic, and was promoted to the rank of Lieutenant approximately 1 and a half years ago.
SANDER advised that Elk Creek Fire received a "tone" this morning for mutual aid to Platte Canyon
Fire Department for a possible gunshot wound. SANDER drove the fire engine, and Elk Creek
firefighters/EMTs VANBINSBERGEN and WOOD rode in the ambulance. While they were en route,
they learned that there were possibly up to 3 patients. SANDER said they asked dispatch if "S.O." was
on scene, and was told by dispatch that they were. SANDER said it wasn't until he arrived on scene
and could see a deceased officer that he realized law enforcement was actually involved in the incident
(although when we talked about it later, SANDER had a difficult time remembering whether dispatch
advised them while en route or not). By the time he arrived, another officer had already been
transported to the "LZ" (landing zone for the medical helicopter). He also learned that a third officer,
who was injured, was still on scene, and was helping tend to the deceased officer.
SANDER told me he arrived on scene prior to the Elk Creek ambulance, and he could see Platte
Canyon's ambulance already at the top of the driveway. Platte Canyon Assistant Chief BURGETT told
SANDER over the radio to stage at the bottom of the driveway (Elk Creek switched over to Platte
Canyon's channel when they came into their district), therefore when WOOD and VANBINSBERGEN
got there, they stayed at the bottom with the ambulance.
SANDER said he walked up the driveway toward the house behind a second Platte Canyon ambulance
that was just driving up to the scene (driven by Platte Canyon Fire personnel with a first name of
PAUL). As SANDER approached the house, he observed Sheriff WEGENER, Captain HANCOCK,
and two other officers unknown to him gathered to the left of the front door around a downed officer.
At the time, SANDER did not know whether the downed officer was wounded or deceased, but advised
that when fire personnel later placed him on a backboard, SANDER could tell the officer was not
breathing.
03/01/2016
Page 1
2016-59/22
I asked SANDER to describe any other observations at the scene, and the only thing he talked about is
how he could tell the person they were working on at the scene was an officer. SANDER said he
recognized the Park County uniform pants, and as he got closer, he could see an officer's duty belt.
SANDER said he eventually figured out the officer was CARRIGAN due to his body type (according
to SANDER, he has known CARRIGAN for several years).
During this discussion, SANDER mentioned that CARRIGAN's gun was not in his duty belt and that
he never saw CARRIGAN's gun. He believed someone secured the weapon, but didn't know for sure.
When SANDER reached the group gathered around CARRIGAN, he asked what happened. He could
not remember who it was that responded, but someone said they breached the door. SANDER then
said he thought he heard Captain HANCOCK ask one of the officers, "You heard me tell him to breach
and clear, correct?" One of the officers replied, "Yes Cap - That's what we heard." SANDER told me
he also heard Chief BURGETT say CARRIGAN got hit breaching the door, and the suspect was down
somewhere in the back yard. SANDER did not know how BURGETT obtained the information about
the suspect's condition and whereabouts.
SANDER said he helped get CARRIGAN into an ambulance, and then instructed WOOD and
VANBINSBERGEN to go up to the scene to assess Captain HANCOCK's injuries. Shortly thereafter,
the Platte Canyon ambulance that initially transported the officer with the leg injuries to the landing
zone, arrived back at the scene. VANBINSBERGEN ended up driving the Platte Canyon ambulance to
the hospital, with Captain HANCOCK and 2 Platte Canyon fire personnel in the back.
I asked SANDER if he noticed any trauma on CARRIGAN, and he said all he could see was a gauze
pad under CARRIGAN's armpit that had a little bit of blood on it (SANDER mentioned earlier that
CARRIGAN's shirt had been taken off). He added that as he helped others get CARRIGAN strapped to
the backboard, he observed blood-tinged sputum coming out of CARRIGAN's mouth. In his
experience, the only way blood would have been present is if some sort of internal trauma occurred.
SANDER also noted CARRIGAN was cold to the touch, and that the color of his skin was indicative of
hypoxia (blue). SANDER described the hypoxia as more obvious around CARRIGAN's lips and eyes.
After CARRIGAN was placed in the back of the ambulance, SANDER asked Chief BURGETT if he
wanted anyone to ride in the back of the ambulance with them (BURGETT and CARRIGAN).
BURGETT said yes, so SANDER rode in the back of the ambulance during the transport to the fire
station. SANDER said they secured CARRIGAN's arms across his chest with straps and covered him
with a blanket, but otherwise, no other medical intervention occurred.
SANDER was unable to provide any additional information, and was provided with my business card.
He agreed to contact me if he remembered anything else, or anything differently.
03/01/2016
Page 2

Primary Information
Description:
PARK COUNTY SO REPORTS REF: OIS
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains attached reports by Park County Sheriff's Office Deputies, N. GILLESPIE and C. BREWER. Deputies
GILLESPIE and BREWER responded to 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, following the officer involved shooting. The reports
document their involvement at the scene as well as a crime scene log.

03/01/2016 14:02
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:37
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH NEIGHBOR ALIECE PLEMONS 2/25/16
Occurence From:
02/25/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/25/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
MOHR, CHRISTIAN AGT (5810 / PROGRAM SUPPORT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
investigation.
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, CBI Agent-in-Charge (AIC) CHRISTIAN MOHR and I interviewed MARTIN WIRTHs neighbor and
friend, ALIECE PLEMONS, at her residence, which was located at 57 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado. PLEMONS had called the
Colorado State Patrol dispatch center the day before to complain about the law enforcement officers involved in the officer involved
shooting.
Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - PLEMONS-ENDRESS, ALIECE MARIE

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
PLEMONS-ENDRESS, ALIECE MARIE
Sex:
FEMALE
Birth Date:
08/31/1956
Age:
59 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
500
Weight:
145
Eye Color:
HAZEL
Hair Color:
RED
Identifications
ID Type
Number
DRIVER LICENSE 94-284-0278
SOCIAL
521-92-5273
SECURITY
State
COLORADO
---
Country
-----
As Of Date
-----
Fictitious
NO
NO
Comment
-----

bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 3

03/01/2016 14:04
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:38
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/24
SYNOPSIS:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, CBI Agent-in-Charge (AIC) CHRISTIAN MOHR and I interviewed
MARTIN WIRTHs neighbor and friend, ALIECE PLEMONS, at her residence, which was located at
57 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado. PLEMONS had called the Colorado State Patrol dispatch center the
day before to complain about the law enforcement officers involved in the officer involved shooting.
ACTION TAKEN:
Please review the attached transcription and audio recording for full details on our interview with
PLEMONS.
Nothing further.

Page 1
03/01/2016

Primary Information
Description:
T-MOBILE SEARCH WARRANT (WIRTH)
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/05/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
investigation.
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, 11th Judicial District Attorneys Office Investigator, ALEX WALKER, applied for and was granted a
search warrant for T-Mobile related to MARTIN WIRTHs cellular telephone records (303.503.2043). The records from T-Mobile were
received on March 16, 2016, and are attached to this report.
On Tuesday, April 5, 2016, MARIA LUNN conducted analysis on the numbers associated on the records.
303-947-6421
Listed to a Ethos Business Solutions. Contact person is a Penelope Hodge-Zeller. Address is 3030 N Saint Paul St, Denver CO
80205. Realtor. Started a blog on post-foreclosure options. Facebook friend of WIRTH.
Called cell on 2/19/2016 for 100 minutes.
303-929-7868
Listed to Janet Matzen, WIRTH supporter, Occupy Denver activist
Called cell on 2/24/2016 at 12:30 after media articles on shooting.
732-493-0537
Listed to Martin C Wirth (father). Probably mother. Last call 2/18/2016

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 3

Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Related Officers
LEO
WALKER, ALEX IV (INVESTIGATOR / District Attorney - 11th JD - Chaffee County)

03/01/2016 15:04
Last Update Date:
04/05/2016 16:57
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/25
SYNOPSIS:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, 11th Judicial District Attorneys Office Investigator, ALEX
WALKER, applied for and was granted a search warrant for T-Mobile related to MARTIN WIRTHs
cellular telephone records (303.503.2043).
ACTION TAKEN:
WALKER, applied for and was granted a search warrant for T-Mobile related to MARTIN WIRTHs
cellular telephone records (303.503.2043).
On March 16, 2016, I received email copies of the T-Mobile records from Investigator WALKER. The
cellular telephone records as well as the signed copy of the search warrant are attached to this report.
Nothing further.

Page 1
03/01/2016

Primary Information
Description:
FACEBOOK SEARCH WARRANT (WIRTH)
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
investigation.
search warrant for Facebook related to MARTIN WIRTHs social media profile, [email protected]. The records from
Facebook were received on March 17, 2016, and are attached to this report.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Page 1 of 3

Related Officers
LEO

03/01/2016 15:06
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:42
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/26
SYNOPSIS:
WALKER, applied for and was granted a search warrant for Facebook related to MARTIN WIRTHs
social media profile, [email protected].
ACTION TAKEN:
WALKER, applied for and was granted a search warrant for Facebook related to MARTIN WIRTHs
social media profile, [email protected].
On March 17, 2016, CBI Criminal Intelligence Analyst, MARIA LUNN, received the requested records
from Facebook. The file, containing over 15,000 pages, is attached to this report.
Nothing further.

Page 1
03/01/2016

Primary Information
Description:
SEARCH WARRANT - STORAGE ONE #114 (WIRTH)
Occurence From:
02/25/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/25/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
investigation.
search warrant for Storage One, which was located at 63716 Highway 285 in Bailey, Colorado.
Property #1 - SMALL NOTEBOOK W/ HANDWRITTEN NOTES/PHOTOS

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
SMALL NOTEBOOK W/ HANDWRITTEN NOTES/PHOTOS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/01/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Location Found:
STORAGE UNIT #114
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #2 - "MY OCCUPY" BOOK

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
"MY OCCUPY" BOOK
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/01/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

Property #2 - "MY OCCUPY" BOOK - Continued
Location Found:
STORAGE UNIT #114
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #3 - COM-PORT COMPUTER TOWER

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
Description:
COM-PORT COMPUTER TOWER
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/01/2016
Quantity:
Serial No:
2294-H08-15357-C-0128
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Location Found:
STORAGE UNIT #114
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #4 - GRY PANASONIC LAPTOP

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
Description:
GRY PANASONIC LAPTOP
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/01/2016
Quantity:
Serial No:
CF-45RJ48JAM
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Location Found:
STORAGE UNIT #114
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #5 - SMALL BLACK NOTEBOOK

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
SMALL BLACK NOTEBOOK
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/01/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4

Property #5 - SMALL BLACK NOTEBOOK - Continued
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Location Found:
STORAGE UNIT #114
02/25/2016 00:00
Related Officers
LEO
MOHR, CHRISTIAN AGT (5810 / PROGRAM SUPPORT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
HORN, NICHOLAS AGT (AGENT / ATF - Denver)

03/01/2016 15:07
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:42
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 4
2016-59/27
SYNOPSIS:
WALKER, applied for and was granted a search warrant for Storage One, which was located at 63716
Highway 285 in Bailey, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, I received a phone call from Agent-in-Charge (AIC) CHRIS
SCHAEFER. AIC SCHAEFER informed me he received a phone call the night before from MARTIN
WIRTHs neighbor, RICH GABRISH. AIC SCHAEFER told me GABRISH recalled WIRTH had a
storage unit in Bailey, Colorado. After further investigation, Agents learned WIRTH did, in fact, lease
a storage unit (number 114) at Storage One, which was located at 63716 Highway 285 in Bailey,
Colorado. 11th Judicial District Attorneys Office Investigator, ALEX WALKER, applied for and was
granted a search warrant for Storage One (Unit 114).
The search warrant at Storage One (Unit 114) was executed on Thursday, February 25, 2016, with the
assistance of Investigator WALKER, CBI Agents GREG ZENTNER and JENNIFER MOORE, CBI
Agent-in-Charge CHRISTIAN MOHR, and ATF Agent NICHOLAS HORN.
Please review Investigator WALKERs attached report for full details on the search warrant and the
items seized.
Nothing further.

Page 1
03/01/2016

Primary Information
Description:
ATF REPORTS
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains information received from Special Agents with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives
(ATF).
The attachment includes reports generated by Special Agents with the ATF, which includes information pertaining to WIRTH's
firearms, contact with real estate agent, KEVIN WHITE, and contact with witnesses at the State Farm (including an attached email)
office in Conifer, Colorado. The attachment also contains various timelines and reports from the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office
concerning the incident with WIRTH at State Farm on January 20, 2016.
Related Officers
LEO
HORN, NICHOLAS AGT (AGENT / ATF - Denver)
AMON, CHRISTOPHER (SPECIAL AGENT / ATF - Denver)
PINE, TIMOTHY (SPECIAL AGENT / ATF - Denver)
ROBERTSON, DAVE AGT (SPECIAL AGENT / ATF - Denver)

03/01/2016 15:41
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 12:49
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
SUBMISSION OF FIREARM AND BULLET TO CBI LAB
Occurence From:
03/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
03/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
SUBMITTED ITEM NUMBERS KT8 AND ITEM 13 FROM KOLBY MARTIN, TO THE CBI LAB FOR PROCESSING. REQUESTED NIBIIN
TESTING AND COMPARISONS, DNA AND FINGERPRINTS.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Address #2 - RELATED #1 - 690 KIPLING ST

Primary Information
Address:
690 KIPLING ST #4000, DENVER, COLORADO 80215 , UNITED STATES

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Deceased:
YES

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 3

Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Related Officers
LEO

03/02/2016 07:47
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 12:50
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/29
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
CBI Crime Scene Units processed the scene and collected numerous items of evidence. CBI Agent
TAMMY LEE requested that I submit a firearm and a bullet to the CBI Lab for analysis. The firearm
was allegedly used by the suspect, MARTIN WIRTH, in the murder of PCSO Corporal NATHANIEL
CARRIGAN. The bullet was recovered from PCSO Deputy KOLBY MARTIN at St. Anthony's
Hospital in Lakewood, Colorado.
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, I submitted the firearm and the bullet to the CBI Lab for analysis.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Thursday, February, 25, 2016, I I submitted the firearm and the bullet to the CBI Lab for analysis.
The firearm is identified as item KT8.
The bullet is identified as item 13 from KOLBY MARTIN.
See attached letter requesting examinations.
See attached "Request for Laboratory Examination" document
See attached "Evidence Submitted Receipt"
See attached CBI Laboratory Report on item KT8, dated February 29, 2016. (firearm) This report
states there were no latent fingerprint suitable for comparison located on the firearm.
Nothing further,
G. Zentner
03/02/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH ECFD FIREFIGHTER/EMT VINCE VANBINSBERGEN
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Probable
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
ON WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 24, 2016, I INTERVIEWED ELK CREEK FIREREFIGHTER/EMT, VINCE VANBINSBERGEN, IN
REFERENCE TO AN OFFICER-INVOLVED SHOOTING AT 36 IRIS DRIVE IN BAILEY, CO.

Primary Information
Address:
STATES
Description:
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Subject #1 - FIRE FIGHTER #1 - VINCE VANBINSBERGEN

Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
VINCE VANBINSBERGEN
Juvenile:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

Related Officers
LEO

03/02/2016 08:10
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 12:58
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4
2016-59/30
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I interviewed Elk Creek Firefighter/EMT, VINCE
VANBINSBERGEN in reference to an officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
and I responded to the Platte Canyon Fire Department (PCFD) to conduct interviews of the PCFD and
Elk Creek fire personnel that had gathered there after the incident. Among others, I spoke with Elk
Creek Firefighter/EMT, VINCE VANBINSBERGEN. The following is a synopsis of the interview.
Our conversation was audio recorded, and a copy of the recording is attached to this report.
VANBINSBERGEN said he began his career with Elk Creek approximately 5 years ago as a volunteer
firefighter. He received his Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) certificate approximately 4 years
ago, and was hired as a paid employee approximately 2 years ago. Prior to being hired as a paid
employee for Elk Creek, VANBINSBERGEN worked with Columbine Ambulance (a private
ambulance company) as an EMT for approximately 2 years.
VANBINSBERGEN said Elk Creek got a tone call this morning for an assist to PCFD on a gunshot
wound. VANBINSBERGEN and WOOD started driving there in the ambulance, and Lieutenant
SANDER responded alone in the engine. They switched over to PCFD's radio channel, and therefore
were able to hear everything in real time (as opposed to the information being routed through dispatch).
While en route, he heard that two medical helicopters had been dispatched as well.
They were asked by whomever had command of the scene with respect to fire personnel (unknown to
VANBINSBERGEN exactly who it was at the time), to stage at the bottom of the driveway when they
arrived on scene. VANBINSBERGEN said he and WOOD maintained their position at the bottom of
the driveway until they received additional orders. I asked what he could see closer in to the scene, if
anything, and all he mentioned was seeing PCFD's ambulance #3 at the top of the driveway.
Lieutenant SANDER, who had arrived on scene prior to VANBINSBERGEN and WOOD, walked up
to the scene to see what was needed of them. SANDER eventually walked back down to
VANBINSBERGEN and WOOD's position, and instructed them to check on one of the involved
deputies. WOOD drove the ambulance toward the top of the driveway, and VANBINSBERGEN
walked up and made contact with Captain HANCOCK, who was standing with other deputies
approximately 5 feet away from the front door of the house.
I asked VANBINSBERGEN to describe HANCOCK's injuries, and he said there was slight bleeding to
the left earlobe, as well as some bruising to the left neck area. HANCOCK also complained of pain to
his right mid-calf, and VANBINSBERGEN observed an abrasion in that area.
VANBINSBERGEN asked HANCOCK what happened, and HANCOCK said he thought he was
grazed by a bullet, and also fell down onto his back. HANCOCK did not make any statements about
why they were there or what happened during the incident. While he was assessing HANCOCK,
however, VANBINSBERGEN heard other people talking about how other officers had been shot.
03/02/2016
Page 1
2016-59/30
As VANBINSBERGEN and WOOD were assessing HANCOCK, PCFD Firefighters/EMTs ERNIE

WALKER and DEVIN MACDONALD joined them and took over the medical assessment. It was
determined that HANCOCK would be transported to the hospital. VANBINSBERGEN was asked to
drive the PCFD ambulance to St Anthony Central with HANCOCK, WALKER, and MACDONALD
in the back.
I asked VANBINSBERGEN to describe any other observations about the scene, and he told me he
could see what he thought was blood in the snow near some equipment (possibly a ballistics vest) on
the ground. He also talked about seeing bullet holes "everywhere," specifically mentioning a window
next to the open door of the house.
I asked VANBINSBERGEN if he could hear any conversation about what happened during the drive
down to the hospital. The only statements he heard were related to conversations about medical care.
VANBINSBERGEN could not provide any additional information. He was provided with my business
card and requested to call me if he remembers anything else, or anything different.
03/02/2016
Page 2

Primary Information
Description:
WELD COUNTY 2014 LE CONTACT SUMMARY
Occurence From:
03/01/2016 13:30
Occurence To:
03/01/2016 13:30
Source Of Info:
Deputy Brandon Stupka
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Confirmed
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/02/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On 2/24/2016 I spoke with Weld County Sheriff's Office Deputy BRANDON STUPKA on the telephone (970-518-6525) concerning a
contact he and two other deputies made with MARTIN WIRTH on 9/4/2014. No report was written on the incident because the party
they were looking for was not contacted. Details of incident is based on recollection.
Address #1 - OCCURRED #1 - 14512 COUNTY ROAD 6

Primary Information
Address:
14512 COUNTY ROAD 6, FORT LUPTON, COLORADO 80621 , UNITED STATES
Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - WIRTH, MARTIN THOMAS

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
Number
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
Country
As Of Date
Fictitious
Comment
Page 1 of 4

Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - WIRTH, MARTIN THOMAS - Continued
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
As Of Date
---
Fictitious
NO
Comment
---
As Of Date
---
Fictitious
YES
Comment
---
Subject #2 - OTH AGY - LAW ENFORCE #1 - Weld County Sheriff's Office

Primary Information
Record Type:
AGENCY
Subject Name:
Weld County Sheriff's Office
Juvenile:
NO
Identifications
ID Type
ORI
Number
CO0620000
State
---
Country
---
Subject #3 - ASSOC OF SUBJECT #1 - ABBOTT, ETHAN CARTER

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
ABBOTT, ETHAN CARTER
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
06/30/1976
Age:
39 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Photo:
YES
Identifications
ID Type
Number
DRIVER LICENSE 942231757
State
COLORADO
Country
UNITED STATES

03/02/2016 08:29
Last Update Date:
03/02/2016 11:25
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4

Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 4
2016-59/31
SYNOPSIS:
On 2/24/2016 I spoke with Weld County Sheriff's Office Deputy BRANDON STUPKA on the
telephone (970-518-6525) concerning a contact he and two other deputies made with MARTIN
WIRTH on 9/4/2014. No report was written on the incident because the party they were looking for was
not contacted. Details of incident is based on recollection.
ACTION TAKEN:
Deputy STUPKA stated they went to 14512 COUNTY ROAD 6, FORT LUPTON, Weld County,
COLORADO, to serve an eviction notice to and execute a warrant on ETHAN ABBOTT when they
encountered MARTIN WIRTH. WIRTH was in a 5th wheel camper trailer on the property. Deputy
STUPKA stated they knocked on the door of the trailer and requested WIRTH to talked to him.
WIRTH initially refused to come out or open the door stating he did not want to come out or talk to
them. After a period of time (NFI), WIRTH opened the door to speak to the deputies but kept his right
hand hidden in the camper. The deputies continued to ask WIRTH to come out of the trailer, when he
kept refusing they eventually dragged (NFI) him out of the trailer. They did not enter the trailer so they
do not know if he had a weapon. Deputy STUPKA stated WIRTH was uncooperative and
argumentative stating that the cops couldn't be there and had no rights to be on the property. Eventually
WIRTH claimed he didn't know where ABBOTT was and that he was watching the property for
ABBOTT. After questioning WIRTH, the deputies left. Deputy STUPKA stated WIRTH was not
physically aggressive but was very uncooperative and argumentative. Deputy STUPKA does not know
how much longer WIRTH was on the property after the encounter.
On March 1, 2016, the Weld County Sheriff's Office published an Officer's Safety Bulletin for ETHAN
ABBOTT based in part on his association with MARTIN WIRTH. A copy of the bulletin is attached to
this report.
LUNN, MARIA ELENA (5369 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation) 03/02/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
EVIDENCE SEIZED ON FIRST DAY FROM HOUSE 02.24.2016, FROM CBI LAB PERSONNEL
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
RECEIVED ITEMS OF EVIDENCE FROM THE CBI CRIME SCENE UNIT ON WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 24, 2016.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
Country
-------
As Of Date
-------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-------
Page 1 of 6

ID Type
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
674951A
147567191
State
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----
As Of Date
-----
Fictitious
NO
NO
Comment
-----
Property #1 - 2 9MM SIG SAUER PISTOL MAGAZINES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
MAGAZINE/SPEED LOADER
Description:
2 9MM SIG SAUER PISTOL MAGAZINES
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
ITEMS SUBMITTED TO CBI LAB
Location Found:
DECEASED OFFICER'S DUTY BELT
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #2 - 9MM SIG SAUER PISTOL MAGAZINE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
9MM SIG SAUER PISTOL MAGAZINE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
ITEM SUBMITTED TO CBI LAB.
Location Found:
DJ HANNIGAN
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #3 - POSSIBLE FRAGMENT FROM PANT LEG

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
POSSIBLE FRAGMENT FROM PANT LEG
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/02/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 6

Property #3 - POSSIBLE FRAGMENT FROM PANT LEG - Continued
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
SUBMITTED TO CBI LAB.
Location Found:
OFFICER THREKEL
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #4 - SIG SAUER 9MM MAGAZINE FROM DJ HANNIGAN'S DUTY WEAPON

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
SIG SAUER 9MM MAGAZINE FROM DJ HANNIGAN'S DUTY WEAPON
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
Location Found:
DJ HANNIGAN'S DUTY WEAPON
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #5 - 9MM SIG SAUER- DJ HANNIGAN

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
9MM SIG SAUER- DJ HANNIGAN
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Make:
SIG SAUER
Model:
P-320
Weapon Sub-Type:
PISTOL-SEMIAUTOMATIC
Firearm Caliber:
9mm
Quantity:
Serial No:
58A010552
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
Location Found:
FROM DJ HANNIGAN
02/24/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 6

Property #6 - SIG SAUER 9MM PISTOL MAGAZINE COLLECTED FROM OFFICER HANCOCK
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
SIG SAUER 9MM PISTOL MAGAZINE COLLECTED FROM OFFICER HANCOCK
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
Location Found:
CAPTAIN HANCOCK
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #7 - 9MM SIG SAUER- CAPTAIN HANCOCK

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
9MM SIG SAUER- CAPTAIN HANCOCK
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Make:
SIG SAUER
Model:
P-320
Weapon Sub-Type:
Firearm Caliber:
9mm
Quantity:
Serial No:
58A016504
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
Location Found:
FROM CAPTAIN HANCOCK
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #8 - MASTER PIECE ARMS .45 ACP RIFLE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
MASTER PIECE ARMS .45 ACP RIFLE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/25/2016
Weapon Sub-Type:
RIFLE-CARBINE
Firearm Caliber:
45 caliber
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 4 of 6

Property #8 - MASTER PIECE ARMS .45 ACP RIFLE - Continued
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
Location Found:
FROM BACK PORCH AREA OF RESIDENCE AT 36 IRIS DR.
02/24/2016 00:00

03/02/2016 09:34
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 13:02
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 5 of 6
2016-59/32
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
I received evidence from CBI Crime Scene Agent KEVIN TORRES and transported the items back to
the CBI Denver Regional office located at 710 Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado and
placed them in a secure location.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I received evidence items KT1- KT8 and transported them to the
CBI Regional Office located at 710 Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado and placed them in
a secure location inside the office.
See attached list.
G. Zentner
03/02/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
EVIDENCE SEIZED ON SECOND DAY FROM HOUSE 02.25.2016 FROM CBI LAB PERSONNEL
Occurence From:
02/25/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/25/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
TOOK POSSESSION OF EVIDENCE ITEMS TA1 THROUGH TA88 AND TRANSPORTED THEM TO THE CBI DENVER REGIONAL
OFFICE.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Page 1 of 32

Property #1 - TA1- ONE (1) BRASS COLORED CASING
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
TA1- ONE (1) BRASS COLORED CASING
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DRIVEWAY EAST OF HOUSE
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #4 - TA4- ONE (1) SILVER COLORED CASING

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 32

Property #4 - TA4- ONE (1) SILVER COLORED CASING - Continued
Description:
TA4- ONE (1) SILVER COLORED CASING
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 32

Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #8 - TA8- POSSIBLE BLOOD

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BODY PRT/FLUID (BLOOD/ETC
Description:
TA8- POSSIBLE BLOOD
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #9 - TA9- COLT DEFENSE 9MM S/N HT018224

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
TA9- COLT DEFENSE 9MM S/N HT018224
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Make:
COLT
Model:
DEFENSE
Weapon Sub-Type:
Firearm Caliber:
9mm
Quantity:
Serial No:
HT018224
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DRIVEWAY EAST OF HOUSE (KOLBY MARTIN)
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #10 - TA9a- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE / ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE
Primary Information
Property Class:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
EVIDENCE FELONY
Page 4 of 32

Property #10 - TA9a- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE / ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE - Continued
Property Type:
Description:
TA9a- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE / ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
ITEM TA9
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #11 - TA10- SMITH & WESSON 380 AUTO S/N RAJ7389
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
TA10- SMITH & WESSON 380 AUTO S/N RAJ7389
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Make:
SMITH & WESSON
Weapon Sub-Type:
Firearm Caliber:
380 caliber
Quantity:
Serial No:
RAJ7389
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DRIVEWAY EAST OF HOUSE (MARTIN)
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #12 - TA11- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA11- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 5 of 32

Property #13 - TA12- BODY ARMOR AND EQUIPMENT
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
TA12- BODY ARMOR AND EQUIPMENT
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #14 - TA12a- MAXIMUM SMOKE CANISTER

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
TA12a- MAXIMUM SMOKE CANISTER
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
ITEM TA12
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #15 - TA12b- FOUR (4) LOADED MAGAZINES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA12b- FOUR (4) LOADED MAGAZINES
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
ITEM TA12
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #16 - TA13- MOTOROLA POLICE RADIO

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
RADIO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 6 of 32

Property #16 - TA13- MOTOROLA POLICE RADIO - Continued
Description:
TA13- MOTOROLA POLICE RADIO
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #17 - TA14- ONE (1) CARTRIDGE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CARTRIDGE
Description:
TA14- ONE (1) CARTRIDGE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #18 - TA15- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA15- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #19 - TA16- SIG SAUER S/N 58B012983

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
TA16- SIG SAUER S/N 58B012983
Property Status:
LAB CBI
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 7 of 32

Property #19 - TA16- SIG SAUER S/N 58B012983 - Continued
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Make:
SIG SAUER
Weapon Sub-Type:
Quantity:
Serial No:
58B012983
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #20 - TA17- FOLDING KNIFE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
KNIFE/SWORD
Description:
TA17- FOLDING KNIFE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #21 - TA18- DUTY BELT AND EQUIPMENT- 2 MAGS SENT TO LAB
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
TA18- DUTY BELT AND EQUIPMENT- 2 MAGS SENT TO LAB
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #22 - TA19- PROJECTILE FRAGMENT

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
TA19- PROJECTILE FRAGMENT
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 8 of 32

Property #22 - TA19- PROJECTILE FRAGMENT - Continued
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
NEAR FRONT DOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 9 of 32

Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #28 - TA25- BODY ARMOR

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
TA25- BODY ARMOR
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 10 of 32

Property #28 - TA25- BODY ARMOR - Continued
Location Found:
SOUTHEAST SIDE OF HOUSE ON GREEN BOX
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #29 - TA26- MOTOROLA POLICE RADIO

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
RADIO
Description:
TA26- MOTOROLA POLICE RADIO
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #30 - TA27- SAFETY GLASSES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
TA27- SAFETY GLASSES
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #31 - TA28- MAGAZINE WITH HAIR AND PROJECTILE- .45

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA28- MAGAZINE WITH HAIR AND PROJECTILE- .45
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 11 of 32

Property #32 - TA29- ONE (1) CARTRIDGE
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CARTRIDGE
Description:
TA29- ONE (1) CARTRIDGE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #33 - TA30- SIG SAUER 9MM S/N 58B012955

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
TA30- SIG SAUER 9MM S/N 58B012955
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Make:
SIG SAUER
Weapon Sub-Type:
Firearm Caliber:
9mm
Quantity:
Serial No:
58B12955
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #34 - TA31- ONE (1) MAGAZINE- 9MM

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA31- ONE (1) MAGAZINE- 9MM
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 12 of 32

Property #35 - TA32- ONE (1) CARTRIDGE- 9MM
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CARTRIDGE
Description:
TA32- ONE (1) CARTRIDGE- 9MM
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #36 - TA33- AR-15A3 .223 S/N 022692

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
TA33- AR-15A3 .223 S/N 022692
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Weapon Sub-Type:
RIFLE-SEMIAUTOMATIC
Firearm Caliber:
223 caliber
Quantity:
Serial No:
022692
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #37 - TA33a- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE AND ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA33a- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE AND ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
ITEM TA33
02/25/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 13 of 32

Property #38 - TA34- SMITH & WESSON S/N SW11580- .223
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
TA34- SMITH & WESSON S/N SW11580- .223
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Weapon Sub-Type:
RIFLE-SEMIAUTOMATIC
Firearm Caliber:
223 caliber
Quantity:
Serial No:
SW11580
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LEANING ON SOUTH WALL OF HOUSE
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #39 - TA34a- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE AND ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA34a- ONE (1) LOADED MAGAZINE AND ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
ITEM 34- .223
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTHWEST CORNER OF HOUSE
02/25/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 14 of 32

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #43 - TA38- ONE (1) 9 MM MAGAZINE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA38- ONE (1) 9 MM MAGAZINE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #44 - TA39- ONE (1) MAGAZINE- .45

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 15 of 32

Property #44 - TA39- ONE (1) MAGAZINE- .45 - Continued
Description:
TA39- ONE (1) MAGAZINE- .45
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #45 - TA40- PROJECTILE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
TA40- PROJECTILE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
WEST OF HOUSE
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #46 - TA41- POSSIBLE BLOOD

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA41- POSSIBLE BLOOD
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #47 - TA42- POSSIBLE BLOOD- SWABS

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA42- POSSIBLE BLOOD- SWABS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 16 of 32

Property #47 - TA42- POSSIBLE BLOOD- SWABS - Continued
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
WEST SIDE OF HOUSE
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #48 - TA43- BOLT CUTTERS

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
TA43- BOLT CUTTERS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTHWEST OF HOUSE IN WOODS
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #49 - TA44- ONE (1) CASING- .45

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
TA44- ONE (1) CASING- .45
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTHWEST OF HOUSE IN WOODS
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #50 - TA45- ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CARTRIDGE
Description:
TA45- ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 17 of 32

Property #50 - TA45- ONE (1) UNFIRED CARTRIDGE - Continued
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #51 - TA46- BROKEN DODGE KEY FOB

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
KEYS
Description:
TA46- BROKEN DODGE KEY FOB
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
MUD ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #52 - TA47- FIRED BULLET

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
TA47- FIRED BULLET
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
MUD ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #53 - TA48- BLACK PLASTIC GRIP

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
MISCELLANEOUS
Description:
TA48- BLACK PLASTIC GRIP
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
MUD ROOM
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 18 of 32

Property #53 - TA48- BLACK PLASTIC GRIP - Continued
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #54 - TA49- BROKEN KEY

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
KEYS
Description:
TA49- BROKEN KEY
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
MUD ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
KITCHEN FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
TA51- FIRED BULLET
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
UNDER STOVE
02/25/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 19 of 32

Property #57 - TA52- ONE (1) CASING
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
TA52- ONE (1) CASING
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
KITCHEN FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
TA53- FIRED BULLET
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
KITCHEN FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
TA54- FIRED BULLET
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
KITCHEN FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 20 of 32

Property #60 - TA55- ONE (1) CASING - Continued
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
CHAIR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
CHAIR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DINING FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 21 of 32

Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DINING FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DINING FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DINING FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #66 - TA61- ONE (1) FIRED BULLET

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
TA61- ONE (1) FIRED BULLET
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 22 of 32

Property #66 - TA61- ONE (1) FIRED BULLET - Continued
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DINING FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LIVING ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DINING FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
STAIRCASE LANDING
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 23 of 32

02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
STAIRCASE LANDING
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
STAIRCASE LANDING
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
STAIRCASE LANDING
02/25/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 24 of 32

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
STAIRCASE LANDING
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
STAIRCASE LANDING
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
STAIRCASE LANDING
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 25 of 32

Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
STAIRCASE LANDING
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
3RD STAIR
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #78 - TA73- ONE (1) EMPTY MAGAZINE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
TA73- ONE (1) EMPTY MAGAZINE
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTHWEST BEDROOM
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #79 - TA74- TWO (2) SONY CAMERA AND ONE (1) LENS IN BAG
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CAMERA/VIDEO CAMERA
Description:
TA74- TWO (2) SONY CAMERA AND ONE (1) LENS IN BAG
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 26 of 32

Property #79 - TA74- TWO (2) SONY CAMERA AND ONE (1) LENS IN BAG - Continued
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LIVING ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #80 - TA75- 38 SMITH & WESSON REVOLVER MODEL 10-5 S/N D425478
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
FIREARM
Description:
TA75- 38 SMITH & WESSON REVOLVER MODEL 10-5 S/N D425478
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Make:
SMITH & WESSON
Model:
10-5
Weapon Sub-Type:
PISTOL-REVOLVER
Firearm Caliber:
38 caliber
Quantity:
Serial No:
D425478
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
COMPUTER DESK
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #81 - TA75a- SIX (6) UNFIRED CARTRIDGES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CARTRIDGE
Description:
TA75a- SIX (6) UNFIRED CARTRIDGES
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
COMPUTER DESK
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #82 - TA76- HP LAPTOP S/N CND9104PS9

Primary Information
Property Class:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
EVIDENCE FELONY
Page 27 of 32

Property #82 - TA76- HP LAPTOP S/N CND9104PS9 - Continued
Property Type:
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
Description:
TA76- HP LAPTOP S/N CND9104PS9
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
COMPUTER DESK
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #83 - TA77- ONE (1) SAMSUNG FLIP PHONE AND CHARGER
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CELLULAR PHONE
Description:
TA77- ONE (1) SAMSUNG FLIP PHONE AND CHARGER
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LIVING ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #84 - TA78- IBM INTELLI STATION COMPUTER TOWER WITH POWER & KEYS
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
Description:
TA78- IBM INTELLI STATION COMPUTER TOWER WITH POWER & KEYS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LIVIING ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #85 - TA79- CYBER POWER BACKUP BATTERY

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
Description:
TA79- CYBER POWER BACKUP BATTERY
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 28 of 32

Property #85 - TA79- CYBER POWER BACKUP BATTERY - Continued
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LIVING ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #86 - TA80- APC BACKUP BATTERY

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
Description:
TA80- APC BACKUP BATTERY
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LIVING ROOM
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #87 - TA81- ONE (1) JOURNAL

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
TA81- ONE (1) JOURNAL
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LIVING ROOM FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #88 - TA82- CANON CAMERA

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CAMERA/VIDEO CAMERA
Description:
TA82- CANON CAMERA
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 29 of 32

Property #88 - TA82- CANON CAMERA - Continued
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
LIVING ROOM FLOOR
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #89 - TA83- INSURANCE PAPERWORK

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
TA83- INSURANCE PAPERWORK
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
COMPUTER DESK
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #90 - TA85- SERVER S/N USE636NAXZ

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
Description:
TA85- SERVER S/N USE636NAXZ
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
COMPUTER DESK
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 30 of 32

Location Found:
KITCHEN COUNTER
02/25/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
KITCHEN COUNTER
02/25/2016 00:00
Property #93 - TA88- NOTE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
TA88- NOTE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
TRAILER
02/25/2016 00:00

03/02/2016 09:35
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 13:04
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 31 of 32
2016-59/33
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
I received evidence from CBI Crime Scene Agent TONYA ATKINSON and transported the items back
to the CBI Denver Regional office located at 710 Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado and
placed them in a secure location.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, I received evidence items TA1- TA88 and transported them to the
CBI Regional Office located at 710 Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado and placed them in
a secure location inside the office.
See attached list.
G. Zentner
03/02/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
EVIDENCE SEIZED ON THIRD DAY FROM HOUSE 02.26.2016 FROM CBI LAB PERSONNEL
Occurence From:
02/26/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/26/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Page 1 of 12

Property #1 - TA89- ONE (1) BRASS COLORED CASING.223
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
TA89- ONE (1) BRASS COLORED CASING.223
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SNOWBANK
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SNOWBANK
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SNOWBANK
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 12

Property #4 - TA92- ONE (1) BRASS COLORED CASING.223 - Continued
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SNOWBANK
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SNOWBANK
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SNOWBANK
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 12

Property #7 - TA95- ONE (1) BRASS COLORED CASING.223 - Continued
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SNOWBANK
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTH SIDE OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SNOWBANK
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 4 of 12

Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTH SIDE OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTH SIDE OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTH SIDE OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTH SIDE OF HOUSE
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 5 of 12

02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/24/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTH SIDE OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTH SIDE OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
SOUTH SIDE OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 6 of 12

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CASING
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
BATHROOM
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DEFECT MM
02/26/2016 00:00
Property #20 - TA108- ONE (1) FIRED BULLET/ PROJECTILE FRAGMENT

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 7 of 12

Property #20 - TA108- ONE (1) FIRED BULLET/ PROJECTILE FRAGMENT - Continued
Description:
TA108- ONE (1) FIRED BULLET/ PROJECTILE FRAGMENT
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DEFECT JJ
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DEFECT Y
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DEFECT LL4
02/26/2016 00:00
Property #23 - TA111- WOODEN PANEL PIECES (4)

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
MISCELLANEOUS
Description:
TA111- WOODEN PANEL PIECES (4)
Property Status:
LAB CBI
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 8 of 12

Property #23 - TA111- WOODEN PANEL PIECES (4) - Continued
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DEFECT E
02/26/2016 00:00
Property #24 - TA112- WOODEN PANEL PIECE (1)

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
MISCELLANEOUS
Description:
TA112- WOODEN PANEL PIECE (1)
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
DEFECT F
02/26/2016 00:00
Property #25 - TA84- MISC. CD'S AND EXTERNAL HARD DRIVES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CD AND DVD DISC
Description:
TA84- MISC. CD'S AND EXTERNAL HARD DRIVES
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
COMPUTER AREA IN HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
TA113- FIRED BULLET
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 9 of 12

Property #26 - TA113- FIRED BULLET - Continued
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
EAST WALL OF MUD ROOM
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
WOODS TO WEST OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
Description:
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
WOODS TO WEST OF HOUSE
02/26/2016 00:00
Related Officers
LEO
ATKINSON, TANYA (LABORATORY AGENT/CRIMINAL INVESTIGATOR II / CBI - Pueblo - Laboratory)

03/02/2016 09:38
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 13:32
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 10 of 12

Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 11 of 12
2016-59/34
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
On Friday, February 26, 2016, CBI Agent TAMMI KREBS received evidence items from CBI Crime
Scene Agent TANYA ATKINSON.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Friday, February 26, 2016, Agent KREBS received evidence items TA89- TA115 and transported
them to the CBI Regional Office located at 710 Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado and
placed them in a secure location inside the office.
See attached list.
G. Zentner
03/02/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
EVIDENCE SEIZED FROM KOLBY MARTIN AT ST. ANTHONY'S HOSPITAL
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
EVIDENCE COLLECTED FROM PARK COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPUTY KOLBY MARTIN AT ST. ANTHONY'S HOSPITAL

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
Address #3 - RELATED #2 - 59961 US HIGHWAY 285

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 11

Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Property #1 - SMOKLESS TOBACCO

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
TOBACCO
Description:
SMOKLESS TOBACCO
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
ST. ANTHONY'S HOSPITAL- KOLBY MARTIN
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #2 - COLDSTEEL KNIFE WITH SHEATH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
KNIFE/SWORD
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 11

Property #2 - COLDSTEEL KNIFE WITH SHEATH - Continued
Description:
COLDSTEEL KNIFE WITH SHEATH
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #3 - BROWN WALLET WITH IDENTIFICATION, BADGE, MISC ITEMS

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
WALLET
Description:
BROWN WALLET WITH IDENTIFICATION, BADGE, MISC ITEMS
Property Status:
RELEASED TO OWNER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
ITEMS RELEASED ON MARCH 1, 2016 BY AIC CHRIS SCHAEFER.
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #4 - DOG TAGS ON GRAY NECKLACE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
NECKLACE
Description:
DOG TAGS ON GRAY NECKLACE
Property Status:
RELEASED TO OWNER
Status Date:
02/25/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
RELEASED BY AGENT HASSENSTAB ON FEBRUARY 25, 2016.
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #5 - BAG WITH MEN'S RING AND EARPIECE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
JEWELRY (OTHER)
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 11

Property #5 - BAG WITH MEN'S RING AND EARPIECE - Continued
Description:
BAG WITH MEN'S RING AND EARPIECE
Property Status:
RELEASED TO OWNER
Status Date:
03/01/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
RING RELEASED BY AIC SCHAEFER ON MARCH 1, 2016
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #6 - ROCK
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
MISCELLANEOUS
Description:
ROCK
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #7 - FLACK VEST (REAR PANEL) WITH ARAPAHOE COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT BADGE (FATHERS)
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
FLACK VEST (REAR PANEL) WITH ARAPAHOE COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT BADGE (FATHERS)
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
BADGE WAS RELEASED TO OWNER BY AGENT HASSENSTAB ON FEBRUARY 25, 2016
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #8 - 2 WHITE SOCKS WITH BLOOD AND GREEN STRING

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 4 of 11

Property #8 - 2 WHITE SOCKS WITH BLOOD AND GREEN STRING - Continued
Description:
2 WHITE SOCKS WITH BLOOD AND GREEN STRING
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #9 - BLACK UNDERSHIRT- SIZE LARGE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
BLACK UNDERSHIRT- SIZE LARGE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #10 - BLUE MEN'S UNDERWEAR WITH BLOOD

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
BLUE MEN'S UNDERWEAR WITH BLOOD
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #11 - PARK COUNTY UNIFORM SHIRT WITH BADGE AND METALS
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
PARK COUNTY UNIFORM SHIRT WITH BADGE AND METALS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 5 of 11

Property #11 - PARK COUNTY UNIFORM SHIRT WITH BADGE AND METALS - Continued
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #12 - FLACK VEST FRONT PANEL

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
FLACK VEST FRONT PANEL
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #13 - 2 BLACK GLOVES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING ACCESSORY
Description:
2 BLACK GLOVES
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #14 - OAKLEY SUNGLASSES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING ACCESSORY
Description:
OAKLEY SUNGLASSES
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 6 of 11

Property #14 - OAKLEY SUNGLASSES - Continued
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #15 - RIGHT BLACK BOOT- SIZE 10 (THOROGOOD)

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BOOTS
Description:
RIGHT BLACK BOOT- SIZE 10 (THOROGOOD)
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #16 - LEFT BLACK BOOT- SIZE 10 (THORGOOD)

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BOOTS
Description:
LEFT BLACK BOOT- SIZE 10 (THORGOOD)
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #17 - BAG CLOTHES CAME IN WITH BLOOD

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BIO-HAZARD
Description:
BAG CLOTHES CAME IN WITH BLOOD
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 7 of 11

Property #17 - BAG CLOTHES CAME IN WITH BLOOD - Continued
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #18 - MEN'S PANTS, BLUE- SIZE 32

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
MEN'S PANTS, BLUE- SIZE 32
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #19 - 2 BLACK KNIVES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
KNIFE/SWORD
Description:
2 BLACK KNIVES
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #20 - 2 BELT KEEPERS

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
2 BELT KEEPERS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 8 of 11

Property #21 - 1 BLACK TOURNAQUET
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
1 BLACK TOURNAQUET
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #22 - 1 CHAPSTICK

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
MISCELLANEOUS
Description:
1 CHAPSTICK
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #23 - 2 GLOVES

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING ACCESSORY
Description:
2 GLOVES
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/03/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #24 - BULLET RETRIEVED FROM MARTIN'S LEFT THIGH

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
BULLET
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 9 of 11

Property #24 - BULLET RETRIEVED FROM MARTIN'S LEFT THIGH - Continued
Description:
BULLET RETRIEVED FROM MARTIN'S LEFT THIGH
Property Status:
LAB CBI
Status Date:
02/25/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
SUBMITTED TO CBI LAB ON FEBRUARY 25, 2016 BY AGENT ZENTNER.
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Related Officers
LEO

03/02/2016 09:41
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 13:36
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 10 of 11
2016-59/35
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
CBI Agent TAMMI KREBS responded to St. Anthony's Hospital to assist with the investigation.
Agent KREBS assisted with the collection of evidence from PCSO Deputy KOLBY MARTIN. This
evidence was taken back to the PCSO by Detective JOHN PINDER.
At approximately 8:30 p.m. I retrieved the evidence from Detective PINDER and took it back to the
CBI Investigations Section office located at 710 Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado, and
placed the evidence in a secure location.
ACTION TAKEN:
At approximately 6:45 p.m. on Wednesday, February 24, 2016, CBI Agent TAMMY LEE asked me to
respond to the PCSO substation located at 59961 U.S. Highway 285, Bailey, Colorado to retrieve the
evidence from St. Anthony's Hospital which was in the possession of the PCSO. The evidence was
specifically related to PCSO Deputy KOLBY MARTIN.
At approximately 8:30 p.m. I met with PCSO Detective PINDER and took possession of the items of
evidence. See attached sheets for specific items.
Theses items of evidence were then transported to the CBI Investigations Section office located at 710
Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado, and placed in a secure location.
Nothing further,
G. Zentner
03/02/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
EVIDENCE SEIZED FROM MARK HANCOCK AT ST. ANTHONY'S HOSPITAL
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
EVIDENCE COLLECTED FROM PARK COUNTY SHERIFF'S CAPTAIN MARK HANCOCK AT ST. ANTHONY'S HOSPITAL

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
Address #3 - RELATED #2 - 59961 US HIGHWAY 285

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 6

Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Property #1 - "SHERIFF" BLACK BEANIE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING ACCESSORY
Description:
"SHERIFF" BLACK BEANIE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
ST. ANTHONY'S HOSPITAL
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #2 - BLACK SIZE XL SHIRT

Primary Information
Property Class:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
EVIDENCE FELONY
Page 2 of 6

Property #2 - BLACK SIZE XL SHIRT - Continued
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
BLACK SIZE XL SHIRT
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #3 - PARK COUNTY UNIFORM SHIRT WITH BADGE AND MEDALS

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
PARK COUNTY UNIFORM SHIRT WITH BADGE AND MEDALS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #4 - DUTY BELT WITH 2 SIG SAUER MAGAZINES, 17 BULLETS, FLASHLIGHT, HANDCUFFS, KEYS
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
DUTY BELT WITH 2 SIG SAUER MAGAZINES, 17 BULLETS, FLASHLIGHT, HANDCUFFS, KEYS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
THE TWO SIG SAUER MAGAZINES WERE REMOVED AND SUBITTED TO THE CBI LAB FOR EXAMINATION.
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #5 - UNIFORM JACKET SIZE 2XL

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING
Description:
UNIFORM JACKET SIZE 2XL
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 6

Property #5 - UNIFORM JACKET SIZE 2XL - Continued
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #6 - 2 BLACK GLOVES WITH G/S RESIDUE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CLOTHING ACCESSORY
Description:
2 BLACK GLOVES WITH G/S RESIDUE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #7 - RADIO, KEYS, KNIFE, 2 KEEPERS

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
EQUIP/TOOL
Description:
RADIO, KEYS, KNIFE, 2 KEEPERS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/02/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
02/24/2016 00:00
Property #8 - URINE SAMPLE FROM HANCOCK

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
Description:
URINE SAMPLE FROM HANCOCK
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
02/25/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remarks:
URINE WAS PLACED INTO A REFRIGERATOR IN THE SECURED EVIDENCE ROOM.
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 4 of 6

Property #8 - URINE SAMPLE FROM HANCOCK - Continued
Location Found:
02/24/2016 00:00
Related Officers
LEO

03/02/2016 09:41
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 16:58
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 5 of 6
2016-59/36
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
CBI Agent TAMMI KREBS responded to St. Anthony's Hospital to assist with the investigation.
Agent KREBS assisted with the collection of evidence from PCSO Captain MARK HANCOCK. This
evidence was taken back to the PCSO by Detective JOHN PINDER.
At approximately 8:30 p.m. I retrieved the evidence from Detective PINDER and took it back to the
CBI Investigations Section office located at 710 Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado, and
placed the evidence in a secure location.
ACTION TAKEN:
At approximately 6:45 p.m. on Wednesday, February 24, 2016, CBI Agent TAMMY LEE asked me to
respond to the PCSO substation located at 59961 U.S. Highway 285, Bailey, Colorado to retrieve the
evidence from St. Anthony's Hospital which was in the possession of the PCSO. The evidence was
specifically related to PCSO Captain HANCOCK.
At approximately 8:30 p.m. I met with PCSO Detective PINDER and took possession of the items of
evidence. See attached sheets for specific items.
Theses items of evidence were then transported to the CBI Investigations Section office located at 710
Kipling Street, Suite 200, Lakewood, Colorado, and placed in a secure location.
Nothing further,
G. Zentner
03/02/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH ECFD VOLUNTEER FIREFIGHTER/EMT JOHN WOOD
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Probable
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
ON WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 24, 2016, I INTERVIEWED ELK CREEK VOLUNTEER FIREFIGHTER/EMT, JOHN WOOD, IN REFERENCE
TO AN OFFICER-INVOLVED SHOOTING AT 36 IRIS DRIVE IN BAILEY, CO.

Primary Information
Address:
STATES
Description:
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Subject #1 - FIRE FIGHTER #1 - JOHN WOOD

Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
JOHN WOOD
Juvenile:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

Related Officers
LEO

03/02/2016 15:16
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 17:03
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4
2016-59/37
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I interviewed Elk Creek Firefighter/EMT, JOHN WOOD, in
reference to an officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Agent ZENTNER and I
responded to the Platte Canyon Fire Department (PCFD) to interview medical personnel who
responded to the officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado. The following is a
synopsis of our conversation. The interview was audio recorded, and a copy of the recording is
WOOD advised that he became a volunteer firefighter with the Elk Creek Fire Department in the
beginning of 2015, and is still on probationary status. He received his Emergency Medical Technician
(EMT) certificate in December of 2015.
Prior to talking about what happened, WOOD showed me the call notification that he received this
morning on a phone application called "I Am Responding." The notification showed a time of 9:53
a.m., and stated "Stab/Gunshot/Penetrating Trauma" at 36 Iris Drive. I asked about the type of call that
was listed, and WOOD told me he thought the person who put out the alert had a list of codes to pick
from, and they chose the code closest to the type of call they received. WOOD agreed to let me take a
photograph of the call screen from the "I Am Responding" app on his phone. The photograph is
WOOD advised that in addition to the phone notification, they got a tone call over the radio to assist
PCFD with a gunshot wound. He and Firefighter/EMT VANBINSBERGEN responded in the
ambulance, and Lieutenant SANDER drove separately in the fire engine. SANDER arrived on scene
prior to WOOD and VANBINSBERGEN, and parked the engine toward the bottom of the driveway.
WOOD was instructed to stage at the bottom of the driveway, and shortly after getting situated,
SANDER joined them. SANDER told VANBINSBERGEN that a Park County deputy was still on
scene and had non life-threatening injuries that needed to be assessed. VANBINSBERGEN grabbed
some equipment and walked up the driveway, and WOOD drove the ambulance to the top.
WOOD said he saw approximately 4 officers on scene, one of which had some blood visible just below
his left earlobe. WOOD and VANBINSBERGEN began assessing the officer's (HANCOCK's)
condition, and according to WOOD, HANCOCK appeared to be in shock from what happened.
WOOD described HANCOCK's injury as a grazing wound to the earlobe, as well as some
bruising/swelling to his neck underneath the injured ear. HANCOCK also complained of pain to his
right shin area, and when HANCOCK pulled up his pant leg, WOOD saw an abrasion with a scratch in
the center. When I asked if HANCOCK made any statements about how he received the injuries,
WOOD again described HANCOCK as being in shock. WOOD explained that HANCOCK started
getting faint while he was talking to them, and it appeared that he was trying to process everything that
had just occurred.
03/02/2016
Page 1
2016-59/37
WOOD and VANBINSBERGEN got HANCOCK into the back of their ambulance, and shortly
afterward, a PCFD ambulance arrived back at the scene. HANCOCK indicated that he would rather be
taken to the hospital by PCFD, as Park County Sheriff's Office (PCSO) and PCFD work together often.
HANCOCK was eventually transferred over to the PCFD ambulance, and because the 2 PCFD EMT's
wanted to ride in the back with HANCOCK, they asked VANBINSBERGEN to drive them to St
Anthony Central hospital.
WOOD then picked up SANDER and took him down the driveway to the fire engine, and then the two
responded to PCFD and stood by in the event that other medical assistance was needed.
When I asked if there was any other information that might be important for me to know, WOOD
talked about a male and female in their mid-60's, who live across the street from 36 Iris Drive. He
advised that when he initially arrived on scene and was staged at the bottom of the hill, the couple
approached WOOD and the male asked something to the effect of "How many of you guys did they call
for?" When WOOD provided a vague answer to pacify the man's question, the man made a comment
about how the officers did not identify themselves when going up to the door. WOOD also thought the
couple said they heard the gunshots going off, but WOOD did not know whether the couple claimed to
be eyewitnesses or not. WOOD added that the couple appeared to be "sympathetic" toward the resident
and "agitated" by the presence of law enforcement.
During our conversation, WOOD pulled up an aerial map on his cell phone and pointed out the house
the couple came from, which was right off of the road toward the right side of the screen. I took a
photograph of the map he showed me and attached it to this report.
Toward the end of the interview, I asked WOOD about his observations of the scene. He told me he
saw bullet holes in a window to the right of the door. The door was left open, and he did not see
anyone go in or come out of the house while he was there. There was also law enforcement uniform
equipment lying on the ground, to include body armor and possibly a duty belt. WOOD mentioned that
he had to be careful not to disturb the equipment while he was parking the ambulance, as he was told
by law enforcement that it was part of the crime scene and could not be moved.
WOOD was unable to provide any additional information. He was given my business card, and asked
to contact me if he remembered anything else, or anything differently.
03/02/2016
Page 2

Primary Information
Description:
PCSO REPORTS/CAD RELATED TO WIRTH
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplemental report contains attachments received from Park County Sheriff's Office Captain, SVEN BONNELYCKE. The
attachments include CAD reports, search results related to WIRTHs name and address, as well as information related to WIRTHs
2014 eviction. Captain BONNELYCKE indicated the information related to WIRTHs 2014 eviction were located after cleaning out
former PCSO Sergeant, WELLES TONJES', office.
Related Officers
LEO
BONNELYCKE, SVEN (Park County Sheriff's Office - Fairplay)

03/03/2016 10:39
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:44
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2
2016-59/38
No Narrative Attached.

Page 1
03/03/2016

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH PCFD CAPTAIN DEVIN MACDONALD
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Probable
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/15/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
ON WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 24, 2016, I INTERVIEWED PLATTE CANYON FIRE CAPTIAN, DEVIN MACDONALD, IN REFERENCE TO
AN OFFICER-INVOLVED SHOOTING AT 36 IRIS DRIVE IN BAILEY, CO.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Subject #1 - FIRE FIGHTER #1 - DEVIN MACDONALD

Primary Information
Record Type:
FIRE OFFICIAL
Subject Name:
DEVIN MACDONALD
Juvenile:
NO
Property #1 - HAND-WRITTEN DIAGRAM OF CRIME SCENE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
HAND-WRITTEN DIAGRAM OF CRIME SCENE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/07/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 5

Property #1 - HAND-WRITTEN DIAGRAM OF CRIME SCENE - Continued
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Disposition:
02/24/2016 00:00
Related Officers
LEO

03/03/2016 10:46
Last Update Date:
03/15/2016 15:53
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 5
2016-59/39
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I interviewed Platte Canyon Fire Captain, DEVIN MACDONALD,
in reference to an officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
and I responded to the Platte Canyon Fire station (PCFD) to interview medical personnel who
responded to an officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado. The following is a
synopsis of my conversation with PCFD Captain DEVIN MACDONALD. The interview was audio
recorded, and a copy of the recording is attached to this report.
MACDONALD started his career as a volunteer firefighter in 2000 in Grants, New Mexico. He
worked in Grants until 2005, and then began working wildland fires in Monument, Colorado. In
October of 2006, MACDONALD began working for the Platte Canyon Fire Department, and was
promoted to Captain approximately 4 years ago. He estimated that he received his current Emergency
Medical Technician (EMT) certificate approximately 4 years ago (according to MACDONALD, he had
his EMT certificate when he was in New Mexico, but it lapsed and he had to re-take the course).
With respect to the events of today, MACDONALD said PCFD Paramedic WALKER received a call
this morning from DJ HANAGAN with Park County Sheriff's Office (PCSO). MACDONALD
explained that WALKER is a SWAT medic for PCSO, and HANAGAN was asking if PCFD could
stage for an operation planned for 9:30 a.m. After the phone call, WALKER advised MACDONALD,
JOE BURGETT (PCFD Assistant Fire Chief), and the PCFD Chief of the request. At the time,
WALKER did not have much information about the operation or the people involved.
MACDONALD said PCSO came to the PCFD station prior to the operation for a briefing, but because
MACDONALD was getting his command vehicle ready to go, he missed the briefing. MACDONALD
was able to speak briefly with a deputy (unknown name), however, who told him the suspect involved
in the operation had made statements that he was not leaving his house unless he was dead, and wasn't
afraid to take officers with him. MACDONALD then got instructions from BURGETT, who told him
to follow the deputies toward the area of the property and to then stage nearby.
MACDONALD advised there was not an "800 radio" in the squad truck he was driving, therefore when
he arrived at the staging area, he got out of his truck and went into the ambulance with BURGETT and
WALKER so he could listen to PCSO's operation.
I asked MACDONALD what he heard over the radio, and he said he could hear officers going up the
driveway and getting into position, the advisement that the suspect was seen on the deck, the order to
make entry, and the call for medical because shots had been fired and an officer was down. As soon as
PCFD heard PCSO request medical over the radio, they contacted their own dispatch and requested a
medical helicopter to land near the PCFD. I asked MACDONALD if he could hear anything outside of
what was on the radio, and he said he could hear lots of gunfire.
03/03/2016
Page 1
2016-59/39
MACDONALD stated he could still hear gunfire as they were approaching the scene, and although he
couldn't remember exactly where they were in relation to the scene, he was thinking to himself that it
was not safe for them to enter. According to MACDONALD, they continued in without hesitation.
When they got to the scene, MACDONALD grabbed 2 backboards out of the ambulance (indicating at
that point he knew 2 officers were down). MACDONALD, WALKER, and BURGETT walked over to
where the injured deputies were. WALKER and BURGETT went to the deputy who they thought was
the most critical, and MACDONALD went to the deputy who had multiple gunshot wounds to his
lower abdomen/leg area (MACDONALD did not know any of the deputies' names). MACDONALD
said he verbally checked in with WALKER, who made a motion to MACDONALD that mimicked
chest compressions. MACDONALD believed WALKER was trying to relay the message that the
deputy he was with was deceased. MACDONALD then asked WALKER to join him with the second
deputy, and WALKER left his position with BURGETT and the deceased deputy to help
MACDONALD with the injured deputy.
During our conversation, MACDONALD agreed to draw a diagram of what he saw while he was on
scene. A copy of the diagram is attached to this report, and the original has been booked into evidence.
While he was drawing the diagram, MACDONALD talked about seeing a window with a lot of bullet
holes in it.
I then brought MACDONALD's attention back to the deputy with the abdomen and leg injuries, and
asked him to walk me through everything that happened. MACDONALD said the deputy was able to
talk to him, which was important to MACDONALD in terms of triage. He clarified that he initially
walked slightly past the deputy with abdomen/leg injuries because that deputy was able to talk, and as
MACDONALD got about halfway between the two deputies, he realized WALKER and BURGETT
didn't need help where they were. Therefore, MACDONALD went back to the deputy with the
abdomen/leg injuries, and spoke to a third uninjured deputy, who was with the injured one.
MACDONALD explained to the uninjured deputy what he was going to be doing with the injured
deputy, and enlisted the help of the uninjured deputy to help get his fellow officer loaded into the
ambulance. When asked specifically about the injuries, MACDONALD said he could see bullet holes
and blood on both pant legs, as well as obvious disfigurement to the left femur.
MACDONALD asked the uninjured deputy to disarm the injured deputy, at which point the uninjured
deputy removed a rifle, two other guns, and the duty belt from the injured deputy. I asked
MACDONALD if he heard either of the deputies make any statements about what happened or how the
injuries occurred, and he said no. According to MACDONALD, the uninjured deputy was able to
follow MACDONALD's instructions, but he appeared to have a "blank" affect during the time they
were in contact.
During our conversation about getting the injured deputy into the ambulance, MACDONALD
mentioned hearing a female citizen yell "What's going on over there?" to another deputy at the bottom
of the driveway. MACDONALD heard the deputy tell her to go back in her house, and she responded
by saying she wasn't going back in until the deputy told her why they were shooting at the resident
(MACDONALD said the woman called the resident by his first name, but MACDONALD couldn't
recall what it was).
03/03/2016
Page 2
2016-59/39
When they got the deputy in the back of the ambulance, MACDONALD went back to the scene to see
if BURGETT could drive the ambulance while MACDONALD and WALKER worked on the deputy
in the back. BURGETT said he was going to stay with the deceased deputy, therefore MACDONALD
requested one of the Park County deputies to drive the ambulance to meet the helicopter at the landing
zone. As they were driving to the landing zone, WALKER and MACDONALD began removing the
remainder of the deputy's clothing so they could better assess his condition. WALKER put an IV in the
deputy's arm, but they did not administer any medications because the landing zone was close to the
scene and they arrived at the helicopter quickly. They transferred the deputy into the helicopter, and
then they responded back to the scene.
When they got back, they saw Elk Creek Fire personnel attending to Captain HANCOCK. HANCOCK
stated he would rather be transported by PCFD since they knew each other, therefore he was transferred
over to MACDONALD and WALKER's ambulance.
In terms of HANCOCK's injuries, MACDONALD said HANCOCK told him he thought he was hit by
a bullet fragment that knocked him down on his butt. MACDONALD observed an abrasion on
HANCOCK's ear, as well as on his neck below the ear. MACDONALD added that he asked to see the
injuries on HANCOCK when MACDONALD was initially on scene, but HANCOCK was "amped up"
and he wanted fire personnel to work on the other deputies. MACDONALD had difficulty describing
what he meant by HANCOCK being "amped up", other than saying HANCOCK was walking around
and trying to get EMT's to help the other deputies. I asked if HANCOCK ever made any statements
about what transpired that day, and MACDONALD said no.
HANCOCK was ultimately transported to St Anthony Central, and was given an IV prior to arrival.
WALKER also administered an unknown dose of fentanyl for pain control.
When asked about HANCOCK's clothing, MACDONALD advised that he still had his pants and his
undershirt on, but the rest of his uniform did not go to the hospital with them. MACDONALD did not
know what happened with the remainder of HANCOCK's uniform.
MACDONALD could not provide any additional information. He was given my business card and
asked to call me if he remembers anything else, or anything differently.
03/03/2016
Page 3

Primary Information
Description:
REPORT FROM 11TH JD DA INVEST ALEX WALKER
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/04/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains an attached report received by 11th Judical District Attorney's Office Investigator ALEX WALKER.
Related Officers
LEO

03/03/2016 15:09
Last Update Date:
03/04/2016 09:34
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
EVIDENCE SUBMITTED TO THE LAB
Occurence From:
03/03/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
03/03/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/23/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
SUBMITTED ITEMS OF EVIDENCE TO THE CBI LAB FOR EXAMINATION AND TESTING
Address #1 - BUSINESS #1 - 690 KIPLING ST

Primary Information
Address:
690 KIPLING ST #4000, DENVER, COLORADO 80215 , UNITED STATES

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Deceased:
YES

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

Subject #3 - VICTIM #3 - MARTIN, KOLBY - Continued
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------

03/06/2016 12:21
Last Update Date:
04/23/2016 15:10
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4

Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 4
2016-59/41
SYNOPSIS:
morning.
CBI Crime Scene Units processed the scene and collected numerous items of evidence. Several of
these items were submitted to the CBI Lab for analysis or testing.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Thursday, March 3, 2016, I gathered 115 items from the evidence collected by the CBI Crime Scene
Unit and submitted them to the CBI Lab for examination, analysis, and testing.
Please see attached list of items submitted.
G. Zentner

Page 1
03/06/2016

Primary Information
Description:
ELK CREEK FIRE (VIA EVERGREEN FIRE) DISPATCH RECORDINGS
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Confirmed
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
ON WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 24, 2016, I REQUESTED THE ELK CREEK FIRE DEPARTMENT DISPATCH RECORDINGS AND DUTY
ROSTER FOR THE INCIDENT AT 36 IRIS DRIVE IN BAILEY, COLORADO.
Address #1 - BUSINESS #1 - 1802 BERGEN PKWY

Primary Information
Address:
1802 BERGEN PKWY EVERGREEN FIRE DEPARTMENT, EVERGREEN, COLORADO 80439 , UNITED STATES
Description:
FIRE DEPARTMENT
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - HUCKER, CAROL

Primary Information
Race:
UNKNOWN
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HUCKER, CAROL
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
Employment Information
Employed:
YES
Occupation:
HR EVERGREEN FIRE
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 3

Property #1 - ELK CREEK FIRE DISPATCH RECORDINGS
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
CD AND DVD DISC
Description:
ELK CREEK FIRE DISPATCH RECORDINGS
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/07/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Disposition:
02/29/2016 14:30
Property #2 - ELK CREEK FIRE DUTY ROSTER FOR 02-24-16

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
ELK CREEK FIRE DUTY ROSTER FOR 02-24-16
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/07/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Disposition:

03/07/2016 12:18
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 17:14
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/42
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I requested the Elk Creek Fire Department dispatch recordings and
duty roster for the officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I contacted CAROL HUCKER with the Evergreen Fire Protection
District to request dispatch recordings and a duty roster from the officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris
Drive in Bailey, CO. Evergreen Fire is the dispatch center for Elk Creek Fire Department, who
responded to the address after receiving a mutual aid request from Platte Canyon Fire Department.
HUCKER emailed a blank records request form, which was completed and emailed back to her on
Thursday, February 25, 2016.
On Monday, February 29, 2016, I responded to the Evergreen Fire Protection District to pick up the
recordings and duty roster. A CD copy of the recordings and the duty roster have been booked into the
CBI Denver evidence unit. A copy of the duty roster is also attached to this report.
03/07/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH TAMARA WILSON
Occurence From:
03/08/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
03/08/2016 00:00
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Probable
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
ON WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 24, 2016, CBI AGENT TAMMY LEE REQUESTED ME TO ATTEMPT TO MAKE CONTACT WITH A
TAMARA WILSON, WHO WAS A POSSIBLE ACQUAINTANCE OF MARTIN WIRTH. WILSON ALLEGEDLY LIVED WITH WIRTH AT
SOME POINT, AND WITNESSED WIRTH MAKE PAST STATEMENTS ABOUT NOT BEING TAKEN OUT OF HIS HOME ALIVE.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Address #2 - RESIDENTIAL #1 - 36070 CLINE RD

Primary Information
Address:
36070 CLINE RD, HONOBIA, OKLAHOMA 74549 , UNITED STATES
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - WILSON, TAMARA ANITA

Primary Information
Race:
UNKNOWN
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
WILSON, TAMARA ANITA
Sex:
FEMALE
Birth Date:
11/18/1962
Age:
53 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Related Officers
LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

03/08/2016 09:50
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 17:44
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4
2016-59/43
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I attempted to make phone contact with TAMARA WILSON.
Over the next couple of weeks, WILSON and I left several messages for each other, and were finally
able to connect on Tuesday, March 8, 2016
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, CBI Agent TAMMY LEE asked me to attempt to make phone
contact with a female by the name of TAMARA WILSON. I was told WILSON posted some
information over Facebook about the officer-involved shooting at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, CO. I was
provided with printed copies of the Facebook posts for the user name "TAWILLA WILSON," which
indicated that the person who posted the information lived with the suspect, MARTIN WIRTH, at some
point and heard him make statements about not being taken out of his home alive. Further research of
the Facebook account by CBI Analyst MARIA LUNN showed that it belonged to TAMARA WILSON.
Analyst LUNN provided me with several possible phone numbers for WILSON, and an address in
Honobia, Oklahoma.
I attempted to contact WILSON that same day, but had to leave a message requesting a call back. Over
the next couple of weeks, WILSON and I left several messages for each other, and were finally able to
connect on Tuesday, March 8, 2016.
WILSON told me she met WIRTH sometime in 2012, as they were both involved in the "occupy
movement", activism for homeless rights, and the Colorado Foreclosure Resistance Coalition.
WILSON advised that she and her son stayed with WIRTH at 36 Iris Drive from approximately
February of 2013 to March or April of 2013. I asked WILSON about the Facebook comment she made
referring to a previous statement WIRTH made about not being taken out of his home alive. WILSON
said they were sitting in his living room at the time, and WIRTH told her he hadn't made a mortgage
payment in a while because he disagreed with what was happening with the bank. She added that the
bank who was supposed to have the mortgage didn't, and he supposedly had issues with the other bank.
WILSON said WIRTH's statement was something similar to, "I've built this house with my own hands they're not taking me out of here alive, they can shoot me." WILSON said he only made a comment like
that once, and he never made any reference to using violence himself. WILSON added that she wasn't
even aware WIRTH owned any guns, as he never talked about them and she never saw any in the
house.
I asked WILSON to describe WIRTH in general, and she told me he was an all-around good guy who
cared about other people. She never saw him as violent or mean, but told me he had some "issues" with
women, which made her uncomfortable. She explained that WIRTH seemed to want more from her
than just letting her be a houseguest, and would often make flirtatious comments to her. WILSON
added that she knew of other women who stayed with WIRTH, and the same thing happened to them as
well. When I asked about the other women, the only female name WILSON gave me was a KENDRA
KELLOGG. She told me she actually knew of several people who stayed with WIRTH, which were
mostly men, but the only other name she could provide was KYLE JOHNSON. WILSON did not have
contact information for KELLOGG or JOHNSON, but said they should be on Facebook as well.
03/08/2016
Page 1
2016-59/43
I asked WILSON about WIRTH's source of income, and she said he was trying to design some sort of
tool and had been working with a company that was supposedly interested in buying it. She thought the
deal fell through, however. WILSON finally told me she didn't know what WIRTH's source of income
was.
I asked about drug and/or alcohol use, and WILSON said she never saw him use either substance. She
added that he was a recovering alcoholic and attended Alcoholics Anonymous meetings somewhere in
Pine, CO, but she didn't know if he was sponsored by anyone through AA.
WILSON told me she didn't maintain regular contact with WIRTH after she moved out, but talked to
him occasionally when they ran into each other at rallies. The last time she saw him was in June of
2015 at the funeral of a mutual friend. She also saw him at a rally in April, 2015, and he mentioned he
was living in his camper. She also noticed he lost weight and looked a lot healthier than when she was
living with him.
Toward the end of our conversation, I asked WILSON if she was aware of WIRTH having any contact
with law enforcement. She said she was not aware of any, other than the police presence at rallies
WIRTH attended. I asked if she knew what his perception of law enforcement was, and she told me he
was not supportive of law enforcement (pointing out how it was the general opinion of most people
involved in the "movement"). She told me there were people within the group who thought all law
enforcement was bad, as well as people who recognized that some bad behaviors by law enforcement
aren't representative of the group as a whole. WILSON believed WIRTH was leaning more toward the
group who thought all law enforcement was inherently bad.
WILSON could not think of anything else important for me to know, and agreed to contact me if she
thought of anything.
A copy of the recorded phone call is attached to this report.
03/08/2016
Page 2

Primary Information
Description:
Follow up re: Martin Wirth Threat to Scott Crowder
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/11/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
A threat was reported FBI's public access line on February 25,2016 from SCOTT CROWDER who he was contracted to do work at the
address of 36 Iris Dr. Bailey, CO. Upon his arrival, he reported MARTIN WIRTH, along with another unknown male, confronted him
and WIRTH pointed a shotgun at him.
Address #1 - RESIDENTIAL #1 - 36 IRIS DR

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - CROWDER, SCOTT

Primary Information
Race:
UNKNOWN
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CROWDER, SCOTT
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
02/26/1979
Age:
37 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #2 - WITNESS #2 - DEERE, HEATHER L.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
DEERE, HEATHER L.
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #3 - WITNESS #3 - HARRIS, ROBERT

Primary Information
Race:
UNKNOWN
Record Type:
PERSON
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 5

Subject #3 - WITNESS #3 - HARRIS, ROBERT - Continued
Subject Name:
HARRIS, ROBERT
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #4 - WITNESS #4 - PETERSON, SHANE

Primary Information
Race:
UNKNOWN
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
PETERSON, SHANE
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO
Subject #5 - WITNESS #5 - WHITE, KEVIN

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
WHITE, KEVIN
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
02/17/1957
Age:
59 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Related Telephones
Telephone Number
(970) 219-0242
Relationship
ASSOCIATE
Related Officers
LEO
MOEN, ROBERT (SPECIAL AGENT / FBI COLORADO SPRINGS)

03/09/2016 09:37
Last Update Date:
03/11/2016 16:54
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 5

Reporting LEO
Date
KREBS, TAMMI (FRAUD UNIT / Colorado

Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Supervisor
Date
Denver)
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 3 of 5
2016-59/44
SYNOPSIS:
A threat was reported to FBI's public access line on February 25, 2016 from SCOTT CROWDER who
was contracted to do work at the address of 36 Iris Dr. Bailey, CO. Upon his arrival, he reported
MARTIN WIRTH, and another unknown male, confronted him and pointed a gun at him.
ACTION TAKEN:
On February 24, 2016 CBI AIC RALPH GAGLIARDI, Agent KREBS (reporting), and Agent
SCHIERKOLK met with HEATHER DEERE and HOLLY DECKER, Attorneys at the Law Office of
Medved, Dale, Decker, and Deere. Fannie Mae contracts with this law office for assistance with
foreclosure matters. An interview was conducted with them reference the foreclosure at 36 Iris Dr.
Bailey, CO. See Agent SCHIERKOLK's supplemental report 2016-59/18 for further details.
During our interview, DEERE mentioned that she had heard that MARTIN WIRTH had threatened
somebody and told them, "If he had to go he was taking someone with him." She could not recall who
she heard this from or who WIRTH may have made the threat to. She recommended we speak with the
Remax real estate agent in charge of the property, KEVIN WHITE.
On February 26, 2016 I spoke with WHITE who told me he had heard, from a source he could not
recall, that a property management company (unknown name) was hired by Fannie Mae to provide
lawn service to the property. He stated that the service workers (unknown name) were threatened by
WIRTH with a gun and told to leave the property. I asked WHITE if he knew if they called the police
and he thought that they had. WHITE could not provide any further information reference the incident.
I informed Agent TAMMY LEE of this information and learned she had received an email from
ROBERT MOEN of the FBI summarizing a call made on February 24, 2016 to the FBI public access
line. The call was from SCOTT CROWDER (970) 219-0242. CROWDER reported he and his
nephew (unknown name) were at the Bailey property in July 2015 to mow the lawn. He stated initially
they could not find the property and contacted an unknown deputy to ask for directions. The deputy
told them "good luck" and they were aware there were squatters on the property. Upon CROWDER's
and his nephew's arrival, they walked around the property. CROWDER stated he looked in the front
window and a man he described as MARTIN WIRTH pointed a shotgun at him. He said a second man
then came from the back side of the house and pointed a gun at his nephew. CROWDER described the
second gunman as follows: "He looked very similar to WIRTH, so much so that the second man might
be related to WIRTH. He was approximately 62 tall, skinny, with a mountain man look. He had long,
unkempt, dark hair and a long, dark beard. The man appeared to be a little older than WIRTH."
After a short verbal exchange, the two men moved closer to CROWDER while continuing to point
their guns. CROWDER and his nephew then departed the scene.
No further information was provided in the phone message.
I attempted to call the number for CROWDER that was provided by the FBI and a law enforcement
TLO report four separate times and did not receive a return phone call.
KREBS, TAMMI (FRAUD UNIT / CBI - Denver)
03/09/2016
Page 1
2016-59/44
I next called PETE BECKEL at Fannie Mae (202) 752-2034 who provided me a contact name for
their property preservation contractor, Safeguard Properties. I next spoke with ROBERT HARRIS, a
legal advisor with Safeguard Properties (800-852-8306 ext, 1417.) On March 11, 2016 I spoke to
HARRIS who stated he was aware of the threats but had no record of authorities being called. He
provided me the name of the subcontractor they hired for the Iris address, Bullseye Services. The
owner of Bullseye Services are LORI and SHANE PETERSON (970-218-2001.) I called and spoke
with SHANE who told me the incident happened on July 30, 2015. He stated CROWDER called him
as soon as the menacing incident occurred, and as protocol he called Safeguard Properties who he
believed were responsible for reporting incidents to police. He did not think police came to the house
after the incident. SHANE provided me a cell phone number for SCOTT CROWDER who is still
currently an employee.
I called SCOTT CROWDER, DOB/02-26-79 at (970-219-0242) who explained the following:
He was hired to go to the address of 36 Iris Dr. and took his nephew, JORDAN HURST, with him.
Upon his arrival, he noticed a camper on the property and was not sure he had the right address. He
then went to the Park County Sheriff's Office where he spoke with an unknown Deputy at the counter.
He asked for directions to 36 Iris Dr. and the Deputy told him, "Good luck, there are squatters there and
we know all about it." CROWDER returned to the property and began to walk around the property
looking for hazards before mowing. He stated there was a white Dodge truck parked at the house.
CROWDER was near the front entrance of the house when WIRTH (whom he recognized from TV
reports) came out of the house and pointed a double barrel shotgun at him. He said another man that
looked similar to WIRTH came out from around the house with a rifle and pointed it at his nephew
HURST. CROWDER said he explained to WIRTH that he was not there for him or any other reason
other than to mow the lawn. WIRTH ordered him and his nephew off the property and they left
immediately.
CROWDER went down the street and called his supervisor SHANE PETERSON per protocol.
CROWDER thought that Safeguard Properties or Fannie Mae would possibly report the incident to
authorities. CROWDER said he never went back to the property and Bullseye Services decided they
would never send another employee to that address.
ATTACHMENT:
Email re: FBI Tip.
KREBS, TAMMI (FRAUD UNIT / CBI - Denver)
03/09/2016
Page 2

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW OF WIRTH'S FORMER ROOMMATE-DELGADO, PLACIDA
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains an attached report from Detective DANIELLE SPENCER with the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office in
Tampa, Florida. Detective SPENCER was asked to interview an inmate in their facility identified as PLACIDA "LEXI" DELGADO
(05/21/1987). During the investigation, we learned DELGADO and her infant daughter "TRANQUILLY" possibly lived with MARTIN
WIRTH several years ago. Some items belonging to DELGADO and "TRANQUILLY" were also located during a search warrant
executed on WIRTH's storage unit. Please read the attached report regarding details on DELGADO's interview.
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - DELGADO, PLACIDA

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
DELGADO, PLACIDA
Sex:
FEMALE
Birth Date:
05/21/1987
Age:
28 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
506
Weight:
120
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BLACK
Alias Information
Alias
DELGADO, LEXI
Related Officers
LEO
SPENCER, DANIELLE (DETECTIVE / HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE)

03/09/2016 15:14
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 3

Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:45
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/45
No Narrative Attached.

Page 1
03/09/2016

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH PCSO DEPUTY D.J. HANNIGAN
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/06/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Wednesday February 24, 2016, I interviewed Park County Sherriffs Department Detective DAVID HANNIGAN regarding his
involvement in this case.
Address #1 - OCCURRED #1 - 1180 CO RD 16

Primary Information
Address:
1180 CO RD 16, Bailey, COLORADO , UNITED STATES
Description:
Park County Sheriff's substation
Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - HANNIGAN, DAVID

Primary Information
Record Type:
Subject Name:
HANNIGAN, DAVID
Juvenile:
NO
Property #1 - DIAGRAM OF SCENE

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
DIAGRAM OF SCENE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
04/05/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Related Officers
LEO

03/09/2016 16:49
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 5

Last Update Date:
04/06/2016 13:17
Reporting LEO
NORDGREN, COLLIN (DENVER /
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 5
2016-59/46
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I interviewed Park County Sheriff's Department Detective DAVID
HANNIGAN regarding his involvement in this case. The interview was held at the Park County
Sheriff's Department Bailey Substation at 2:05 PM and HANNIGAN was accompanied by his legal
counsel, Attorney BRIAN HERBERT.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I interviewed Park County Sheriff's Department Detective DAVID
HANNIGAN regarding his involvement in this case. The interview was held at the Park County
Sheriffs Department Bailey Substation at 2:05 PM and HANNIGAN was accompanied by his legal
counsel, Attorney BRIAN HERBERT. During the interview I learned the following relevant
information:
Background for HANNIGAN:
HANNIGAN has over 20 years in Law Enforcement experience and has worked for the Park
County Sheriffs Department since 2006. (Other agencies in past: State Parks, Sheridan PD,
Castle Rock PD, Clear Creek SO, Woodland Park PD, DA Investigator Park County DAs
Office, Arapahoe SO)
HANNIGAN has never been involved in the use of Deadly Force prior to this incident
HANNIGAN carries a department issued Sig P320 9mm pistol with no alterations and recently
qualified with weapon
HANNIGANs normal shift is Monday through Thursday, day shift hours with a flexible start
time
HANNIGAN has no physical impairments or need for glasses at distance (glasses only for
reading)
Incident date Pre-Incident:
HANNIGAN was well rested and started his shift at 06:45 AM
At 7:30 AM HANNIGAN was contacted by Captain (Cpt.) HANCOCK and asked to assist with
eviction of WIRTH from the residence at 36 Iris Drive, Bailey
Was aware of past issues with WIRTH (threats to harm officers) and chase two weeks prior
involving Jefferson County/Park County law enforcement
HANNIGAN did not have any personal contact with WIRTH prior to the incident date
HANNIGAN attended a briefing at the Bailey substation led by Cpt. HANCOCK with the
following Law Enforcement personnel present: HANCOCK, THRELKEL, HANNIGAN,
MARTIN, LEFFLER, CARRIGAN, LOWRANCE, and Sheriff WEGENER attended for short
time

Page 1
03/09/2016
2016-59/46
During the briefing, HANNIGAN learned of the lawful scheduled eviction and saw an order
signed by a Judge of Park County Court
HANNIGAN learned WIRTH had been evicted before and had told neighbor that the next time
the cops come they will have to carry him out dead
Neighbor communicated threat to unknown person in the Park County Sheriff's Department
HANNIGAN was assigned to watch the back side of the residence opposite front door.
HANNIGAN was dressed in plain clothes with a vest, fleece jacket with patches and a badge,
and a stocking cap with Sheriff written prominently so he could be readily identified as Law
Enforcement
Incident:
LEFFLER responded to the area of 36 Iris Drive first and had eye with spotting scope
Medical was put on standby for officer safety
Responded to 36 Iris Drive at approximately 9:30 AM
Approached from the west with THRELKEL, MARTIN, LOWRANCE and took a position of
cover in a grove of trees
THRELKEL, MARTIN, LOWRANCE continued to the residence and out of sight
CARRIGAN pulled into the driveway in a marked unit, while Cpt. HANCOCK followed in an
unmarked vehicle and parked behind CARRIGAN
WIRTH appeared on the outdoor balcony on north side of residence and had a short
conversation with CARRIGAN and HANCOCK
HANNIGAN could not hear all of the conversations but heard WIRTH was advised Deputies
were on scene to evict him and heard a request for WIRTH to come down and talk with them
HANNIGAN saw WIRTH turn around and walk into the residence (No aggression observed at
that time and HANNIGAN believed WIRTH would be coming out of residence)
Radio traffic advised suspect went back inside of the house (HANNIGAN confused on time
frame of radio traffic after WIRTH went inside)
HANNIGAN estimated seconds later he heard over ten gunshots coming from other side of
residence and then radio traffic advising two officers had been shot (HANNIGAN afraid for the
safety of every officer on scene)
WIRTH appeared on the west side of residence with unknown make AR style rifle
HANNIGAN describes WIRTH as uninjured and sneaking with rifle at ready toward the
South/West corner of residence

Page 2
03/09/2016
2016-59/46
WIRTH reaches the South/West corner taking a position of advantage to ambush the other
Deputies
HANNIGAN was afraid for his safety and also believed WIRTH will kill the next Deputy that
came his direction
HANNIGAN aimed center mass and purposely fired his issued Sig pistol 2 to 3 times at
WIRTH, to stop the threat and keep him from killing any of the Deputies on scene
HANNIGAN does not know if he hit WIRTH and did not see obvious hits
HANNIGAN advised on the radio that the suspect was on the D side (West side)
WIRTH dropped to a prone position and began to his point rifle toward HANNIGAN as if
searching for him
Cpt. HANCOCK appeared from South side of residence to the west side and immediately began
shooting WIRTH
HANNIGAN does not know how many shots or what gun HANCOCK used (possibly 5 or
more shots)
HANCOCK advised on the radio that the suspect was dead
HANNIGAN moved up to the suspect and observed WIRTH was obviously deceased (no aid
rendered)
HANNIGAN moved to East side of residence and saw medical working on NATE and
MARTIN screaming in pain
HANNIGAN reported to HANCOCK and Sheriff WEGENER that he fired his weapon and
remained on scene until he was relieved
This supplement is only a summary. For further details see the recording of my interview with
HANNIGAN and the transcript produced from the recording.
Nothing further at this time.

Page 3
03/09/2016

Primary Information
Description:
INTERVIEW WITH MARTIN WIRTH'S BROTHER - JAMES WIRTH
Occurence From:
03/03/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
03/03/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/05/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I, Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Agent TAMMY LEE, was asked to respond to Bailey,
Colorado, in reference to an Officer Involved Shooting. I was assigned to be the Case Agent for the investigation.
This report documents my phone interview with MARTIN WIRTHs younger brother, JAMES WIRTH.
Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - WIRTH, JAMES P

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
WIRTH, JAMES P
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/12/1958
Age:
57 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Identifications
ID Type
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
147565769
State
---
Country
---
As Of Date
---
Fictitious
NO
Comment
---

03/09/2016 16:55
Last Update Date:
04/05/2016 16:55
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4
2016-59/47
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24, 2016, I, Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Agent TAMMY LEE,
was asked to respond to Bailey, Colorado, in reference to an Officer Involved Shooting. I was assigned
to be the Case Agent for the investigation.
This report documents my phone interview with MARTIN WIRTHs younger brother, JAMES
WIRTH.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Friday, February 26, 2016, CBI Deputy Director, TED MINK, received a phone call from MARTIN
WIRTHs parents, MARTIN (Sr.) and JOAN WIRTH. MARTIN (Sr.) and JOAN lived in New Jersey
and indicated they did not wish to make a statement to the police about their son because they did not
feel they had any additional information to offer.
On Wednesday, March 3, 2016, I was notified by DD MINK that MARTIN WIRTHs brother wanted
to call and speak with me. I spoke with MARTINs younger brother, JAMES WIRTH (516.971.3564),
who lived in New York. The phone call lasted approximately 1 hour and 45 minutes and was digitally
recorded. A copy of the recording is attached to this report. The following is only a summary of our
conversation. For full details on the interview, please review the audio file in its entirety.
During my interview with JAMES, he told me the following:
He spoke to MARTIN (who he referred to as MARTY) every 1-2 weeks.

MARTIN was never been married and did not have any children.
MARTIN was estranged from his other siblings.
He believed his other siblings did not care for MARTINs political postings on
Facebook.
He visited MARTIN at his home in Colorado and MARTIN visited him in November.
MARTIN had very negative feelings about the police.
MARTIN believed police were killing homeless people in Denver and MARTIN was
always posting anti-police things online.
MARTIN made posts online how police were rapists and murderers.
He believed MARTINs ill feeling towards government and the police stemmed from
MARTINs homicide arrest in1994.
MARTINs homicide arrest was not portrayed accurately in the media and had
nothing to do with a chess game.
MARTIN was acquitted after the homicide trial.
MARTIN spent three (3) months in jail following his arrest.
MARTIN could never understand why he was in jail for protecting himself.
MARTIN spoke about how the guards in the jail were always trying to control
everything he did.
MARTIN said it bothered him how the guards refused to shut off the lights when
he slept at night.
MARTIN was a dead eye shot with a firearm and could shoot a squirrel at 500 yards.
MARTIN could have shot the police as soon as they got into the drive-way.
MARTIN was convinced the police were going to kill him when they entered his house.

Page 1
03/09/2016
2016-59/47
If the police wouldnt have crossed the threshold of his door, MARTIN wouldnt have
shot at them.
MARTIN always said he wouldnt harm anyone, but he would defend himself.
MARTIN was known to put cameras around his house to record things.
He wanted to know why a tactical team or hostage negotiator wasnt used for a
high risk eviction.
He doesnt understand why the police made the decision to run in the door.
He does not excuse anything MARTIN did because it was horrible.
He told MARTIN he was defending a piece of dirt.
MARTIN told him (JAMES) he would defend himself against the police.
He heard MARTINs neighbor called to warn the police about MARTIN 4-6
weeks before the eviction.
He contemplated calling the police about his brother, but didnt know
what to say.
He would have told the police MARTIN lost everything, doesnt care
about life anymore, and was armed.
I hate to say it, but I dont think he wouldve stopped and once he started he
wasthats it Im going for it, I wanna die now and Im gonna take as many
people with me as I can because everyones coming to kill me and this is it.
If the police hadnt gone in the door, MARTIN may have shot himself.
Someone on the Colorado Foreclosure Resistance Coalition website
claimed to have talked to MARTIN the Friday before the shooting
(February 19, 2016) and said MARTIN indicated he was going to stay in
the house during the eviction.
(With regard to MARTINs threat at State Farm.) MARTIN said he tried to get insurance at
State Farm and found out his license was suspended.
MARTINs suspended license was the result of a speeding ticket MARTIN refused to
pay.
MARTIN said he was angry he couldnt get insurance and walked out of the office.
MARTIN said he drove back to his house on Hwy 285 and police cars followed him.
MARTIN said he drove to his house, refused to get out of his truck, and then turned his
back and flipped off the police.
MARTIN said the police pointed guns at him and then tackled him to the ground.
MARTIN said when he was tackled; one of the deputies punched him twice in the face
and broke the front teeth on his dentures.
MARTIN told him he knew the deputies who came to his house after the State Farm
incident.
He (JAMES) was upset to learn MARTIN wasnt arrested and taken to jail after the
State Farm incident
He didnt believe MARTIN was mentally ill.
MARTIN had issues and was suicidal and desperate.
He believed MARTINs actions were suicide by cop.
MARTIN was a genius at math, physics, and computer science.
MARTINs laptop was his most valued possession.
MARTIN could do anything involving machines, plumbing, or electrical.
MARTIN didnt drink alcohol for the last 10 years and was attending AA.
MARTIN would take in homeless people.

Page 2
03/09/2016
2016-59/47
A female named LEXI and another female who died last year (unknown name)
were two (2) of the women who lived with MARTIN.
When MARTIN was evicted in 2014, MARTIN moved to an organic farm.
The police came to the farm at least twice looking for guy who leased the land.
MARTIN found out the guy leasing the land embezzled all the money, so MARTIN
moved his camper somewhere in Denver.
While MARTIN lived in Denver, his camper was burglarized.
MARTIN decided he was going to move back to his property in Bailey because he had
several pending lawsuits.
MARTIN lived in his camper and then moved back into the house after he fixed the
plumbing (Spring 2015).
MARTIN had two lawsuits going on, one was fighting the actual foreclosure of his property
and a Federal lawsuit, which challenged the constitutionality of Colorados evidence laws
related to foreclosure procedures.
MARTIN lost his house after he lost his job.
MARTIN said he went to court three (3) times regarding his foreclosure with a county
judge and then a retired judge came in and dismissed MARTINs case.
MARTIN told him there were some men from Fannie Mae who came out to cut the grass and he
told them to leave because he could take care of his property.
MARTIN would never hurt the common man.
He knew MARTIN had a pistol and some sort of .45 caliber tactical rifle.
He never saw MARTINs rifle.
MARTIN was a big Second Amendment person, but never flashed his guns to
anyone.
If he knew about the most recent eviction, he would have called the Park County Sheriffs
Office and told them his brother doesnt care about life anymore.
Fannie Mae (unknown person) called his parents and told them they didnt request the
eviction.
He spoke to his mother (JOAN) on the phone approximately the Wednesday before the shooting
(February 17, 2016) and she told him a new eviction order was posted on MARTINs property.
He decided he would call MARTIN after he finished a construction job to tell him to
just leave the property.
MARTIN took his advice in 2014 when he told him to leave the property after the
eviction.
At the end of the conversation, I thanked JAMES for speaking with me and disconnected the call.
On Thursday, March 4, 2016, I received a voicemail message from JAMES WIRTH. JAMES said he
wanted to pass on some information he learned from his mother, JOAN. JAMES said MARTIN told
their mother that following the State Farm incident, a police car would constantly drive by his residence
and shine their lights into his house. JAMES said he also wanted to share that MARTIN told his
mother he had a bullet hole in the front picture window of his house and didnt know where it came
from.
Nothing further.

Page 3
03/09/2016

Primary Information
Description:
Reports of 1994 Homicide
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
03/10/2016 00:00
Source Of Info:
Ft. Collins Police Department
Source Reliability:
Reliable
Content Evaluation:
Confirmed
Reporting LEO:
SADAR, GREG AIC (7651 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/15/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Wednesday, February 24th 2016, the Reporting Agent (hereinafter referred to as RA) was assigned to assist with an officer
involved shooting in Park County. During the initial investigation, it was discovered the perpetrator, MARTIN WIRTH, had been
arrested for and charged with murder in 1994. After a jury trial in 1995, Wirth was acquitted and released. The RA initially could not
view official details of the 1994 case, as it had been sealed. The RA contacted the Larimer County District Attorney's office and the
Ft. Collins Police Department and was able to obtain a copy of the investigation on Thursday, March 10th, 2016.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
Country
-------
As Of Date
-------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-------
Page 1 of 3

ID Type
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
674951A
147567191
State
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----
As Of Date
-----
Fictitious
NO
NO
Comment
-----

SADAR, GREG AIC (7651 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
03/10/2016 16:33
Last Update Date:
03/15/2016 16:07
Reporting LEO
SADAR, GREG AIC (7651 / DENVER /
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/48
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, February 24th 2016, the Reporting Agent (hereinafter referred to as RA) was assigned
to assist with an officer involved shooting in Park County. During the initial investigation, it was
discovered the perpetrator, MARTIN WIRTH, had been arrested for and charged with murder in 1994.
After a jury trial in 1995, Wirth was acquitted and released. The RA initially could not view official
details of the 1994 case, as it had been sealed. The RA contacted the Larimer County District
Attorney's office and the Ft. Collins Police Department and was able to obtain a copy of the
investigation on Thursday, March 10th, 2016.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, February 24th 2016, the Reporting Agent (hereinafter referred to as RA) was assigned
to assist with an officer involved shooting in Park County. During the initial investigation, it was
discovered the perpetrator, MARTIN WIRTH, had been arrested for and charged with murder in 1994.
After a jury trial in 1995, Wirth was acquitted and released. The RA initially could not view official
details of the 1994 case, as it had been sealed.
During the morning of Thursday, February 25th, 2016, the RA made contact with Investigator
CHARLES ROBLES. The RA explained the nature of his investigation and asked for information
related to the 1994 case, as well as the RA's concern that the 1995 acquittal had been sealed.
Investigator ROBLES then put the RA in touch with Chief Investigator SCOTT ROGERS. ROGERS
acknowledged the case was sealed, but said it was the position of the DA's office, given the
circumstances, the case would be open to CBI for the purposes of this investigation. The RA then
emailed an information request form to Investigator ROGERS.
On Monday, March 7th 2016, the RA was contacted by RAY DANIEL of the Larimer County District
Attorney's office. Mr. DANIEL is the manger of their records. Mr. DANIEL advised the RA the DA's
office had no documents left from the 22 year old case. Mr. DANIEL said he had completed a detailed
search for the information, but there was no information left to deliver. Mr. DANIEL suggested the RA
contact the Larimer County Court, but was not confident they would have any documentation left
either. Mr. DANIEL advised the Ft. Collins Police Department was the original investigating agency
and the RA may wish to contact them as well.
On Wednesday, March 9th 2016, the RA contacted the Ft. Collins Police Department and spoke with
Commander DAN MURPHY. The RA repeated the original request and emailed a request for
information to Commander MURPHY. On Thursday, March 10th, 2016, the RA received an email
from LISA ROBLES, Records Manager for the Ft. Collins Police Department. The email contained an
attachment of the narratives of the 1994 investigation of the WIRTH homicide. The email indicated the
record had been redacted, but each time the RA read "XXXX" the X's were referring to WIRTH. Ms.
ROBLES email also declared their evidence unit has confirmed all evidence in the 1994 case had been
destroyed.
NOTE: All documents referred to in this report are attached. At the bottom of each page of the reports
there is a statement of "SEALED RECORD - RELEASE TO CBI-DO NOT DISSEMINATE"
SADAR, GREG AIC (7651 / DENVER / CBI - Denver)
03/10/2016
Page 1

Primary Information
Description:
Eviction Order documents
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/13/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On February 24, 2016, the Reprting Agent, Agent in Charge KIRBY LEWIS, was in the Park County Officer Involved Shooting
investigation command post at the church building. Park County Sheriff's Office Sergeant TONGES came in to the command post
and handed the following documents to me
1. A cover letter from MEDVED DALE DECKER & DEERE, LLC askin gthe sheriff to serve the Wit of Restitution on 36 IRIS DR.
2. A copy of the civil service document created by the Park County Sheriff's Office.
3. Writ of Restitution notice, dated Feb. 24, 10:00 AM.
4. Legal Description of the property.
5. Writ of Restitution notice, dated Feb. 17, 10:00 AM.
6. A copy of a two page Writ of Restitution Order signed by County Court Judge BRIAN GREEN.
When I received the documents, I gave them to CBI AIC DAN VOLZ. He returned the documents to me on March 10, 2016. I secured
them in my office and placed them in the evidence locker on March 13. A digital copy of the documents is attached to this
supplement report.
No further action for this report and no narrative is associated with this report.
Address #1 - OCCURRED #1 - 36 IRIS DR

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2

Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - WIRTH, MARTIN THOMAS - Continued
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Property #1 - Eviction order documentation

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
Eviction order documentation
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/13/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES

03/13/2016 13:32
Last Update Date:
03/13/2016 13:54
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 2 of 2

Primary Information
Description:
SECONDARY SEARCH - 36 IRS DRIVE - 03/16/2016
Occurence From:
03/16/2016 11:30
Occurence To:
03/16/2016 14:30
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
investigation.
This report documents additional evidence items recovered during a secondary search of 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, which
occurred on Wednesday, March 16, 2016.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER
Property #1 - .223 CASING

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
AMMUNITION
Description:
.223 CASING
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/16/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Location Found:
36 IRS DRIVE, BAILEY
03/16/2016 12:00
Property #2 - 9MM CASING

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
AMMUNITION
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

Property #2 - 9MM CASING - Continued
Description:
9MM CASING
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/16/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Location Found:
03/16/2016 12:25
Property #3 - BULLET
Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
AMMUNITION
Description:
BULLET
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
03/16/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Remote Bin:
DENVER LOCKER
Location Found:
03/16/2016 12:45
Related Officers
LEO

03/16/2016 17:05
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:46
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4
2016-59/50
SYNOPSIS:
learned three (3) Park County Sheriffs Office Deputies had been shot resulting in (2) of the Deputies
injured and one (1) Deputy who was deceased. The condition of the suspect was unknown during the
initial briefing. After the briefing, I was asked to respond to the scene of the shooting, which was 36
Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, as the CBI was requested to be the lead agency for the investigation. I
was assigned to be the Case Agent for the investigation.
This report documents additional evidence items recovered during a secondary search of 36 Iris
Drive in Bailey, Colorado, which occurred on Wednesday, March 16, 2016.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Wednesday, March 16, 2016, Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Agent JERRY MEANS and I
responded to 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, to search for additional items of evidence. Much of the
snow had melted and we responded to search for additional shell casings and bullets not located during
the original search. While enroute, I called and spoke with Re/Max Agent, KEVIN WHITE, who had
possession of the property following the original search warrant. I asked WHITE for permission to
enter the property to search for additional evidence items and he said it was fine and gave me the code
to the lockbox affixed to the outside gate (#2147). WHITE also said we could enter the residence, but I
informed him we were just searching for evidence located on the property surrounding the home.
Agent MEANS and I arrived at approximately 11:40 A.M. and drove up to the residence. During the
secondary search, Agent MEANS and I located three (3) additional evidence items. Item #1 was a .223
casing, which was located near a snowbank off of the drive-way. Item #2 was a 9mm casing, which
was located near a snowbank to the right of the mud room door. Item #3 was a bullet, which was
located on the make-shift walking path to the left of the mud room door. All of the items were marked,
photographed, collected, and placed into evidence. The photographs are attached to this report.
In addition, Agent MEANS and I observed a large tree on the property, which was almost directly in
line with the door to the mud room. The tree had several holes in the trunk, which appeared consistent
with bullet holes. Agent MEANS and I attempted to remove the bark from the outside of the tree to
locate the bullets, but according to the metal detector, the bullets were located at least six (6) inches
inside the tree. There was no way to recover the bullets without chopping down the entire tree. The
tree was photographed, but no items of evidence were removed. At approximately 2:20 P.M., we left
the property and secured the gate.
After returning to the office, I called and spoke with 11th Judicial District Attorney, THOM LEDOUX.
DA LEDOUX indicated the CBI did not need to conduct additional testing on the three (3) additional
evidence items located at the residence and did not find it necessary to cut down the large tree to
possibly recover additional bullets.
Page 1
03/16/2016
2016-59/50
Nothing further.

Page 2
03/16/2016

Primary Information
Description:
Lone Tree Municipal Court Threat
Occurence From:
10/27/2014 00:00
Occurence To:
02/04/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/17/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
Information on WIRTH threats and angry statements at Lone Tree Municipal Court.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Page 1 of 3

Subject #2 - OTH AGY - LAW ENFORCE #1 - LONE TREE MUNICIPAL COURT
Primary Information
Record Type:
AGENCY
Subject Name:
LONE TREE MUNICIPAL COURT
Juvenile:
NO
Business Description
Business Type:
GOVERNMENT/PUBLIC BLDG
Subject #3 - OTH AGY - LAW ENFORCE #2 - Lone Tree Police Department

Primary Information
Record Type:
AGENCY
Subject Name:
Lone Tree Police Department
Juvenile:
NO
Identifications
ID Type
ORI
Number
CO0180700
State
---
Country
---
As Of Date
---
Fictitious
NO
Comment
---

03/17/2016 07:39
Last Update Date:
03/17/2016 09:18
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/51
SYNOPSIS:
On 27 October 2014, MARTIN WIRTH received a speeding ticket from the Lone Tree Police
Department for driving 84 mph in a 55 mph construction zone. WIRTH was found guilty and fined
$340 due by 28 May 2015. WIRTH had not paid the fine by 15 July 2015 and his license was revoked.
WIRTH discovered his license was revoked on 20 January 2016 when he attempted to get insurance at
State Farm. On 4 February 2016 WIRTH telephoned the Lone Tree Municipal Court to complain about
his cancelled license and became very belligerent and complained that Lone Tree Police Department
was conducting political profiling when they gave him a ticket because they didn't like his politics
when he ran for senate. WIRTH continued to make statements about political profiling, corruption of
the United States, and how all police officers are extortionists. He stated paying the fine would "kill"
him. Online credit card payment for full amount received later the same day.
ACTION TAKEN:
Summary of the Lone Tree Municipal Court notes and copy of ticket attached to case report.

Page 1
03/17/2016

Primary Information
Description:
Wirth YouTube video
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
Download of Martin WIRTH video on foreclosures posted in 2014.

03/23/2016 08:13
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:48
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2
2016-59/52
No Narrative, see attached video.

Page 1
03/23/2016

Primary Information
Description:
MEDICAL RECORDS FOR KOLBY MARTIN
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/25/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
KOLBY MARTIN MEDICAL RECORDS

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 3

Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------

03/24/2016 08:01
Last Update Date:
03/25/2016 09:04
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/53
SYNOPSIS:
On Tuesday, March 22, 2016, the CBI received KOLBY MARTIN's medical records from St.
Anthony's Hospital in connection to the officer involved shooting in Park County on February 24, 2016.
The records were scanned and are attached to this report.
No further action taken for this report.

Page 1
03/24/2016

Primary Information
Description:
MEDICAL RECORDS FOR MARK HANCOCK
Occurence From:
02/24/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/24/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/24/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
MEDICAL RECORDS FOR MARK HANCOCK

Primary Information
Address:
Description:

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
HANCOCK, MARK
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 3

Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------

03/24/2016 08:02
Last Update Date:
03/24/2016 09:30
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/54
SYNOPSIS:
On Wednesday, March 23, 2016, CBI received medical records for MARK HANCOCK from St.
Anthony's Hospital from officer involved shooting on February 24, 2016.
ACTION TAKEN:

Page 1
03/24/2016

Primary Information
Description:
JEFFERSON COUNTY REPORTS FROM OIS
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains attached reports received by the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office with regard to the officer involved
shooting in Bailey, Colorado (Park County).

03/30/2016 17:27
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:49
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2
2016-59/55
No narrative, see attachments.

Page 1
03/30/2016

Primary Information
Description:
CRIME SCENE REPORTS/ VIDEO/ DIAGRAMS
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
03/31/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains attached reports from CBI Crime Scene Agents, KEVIN TORRES and TANYA ATKINSON. The video taken
during the crime scene was too large to attach, so it will be available by disc.
Related Officers
LEO
ATKINSON, TANYA (LABORATORY AGENT/CRIMINAL INVESTIGATOR II / CBI - Pueblo - Laboratory)
HONDERD, MEGAN (LABORATORY AGENT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)
RICHARDSON, MATTHEW (CBI CRIME SCENE ANALYST / CBI - Denver - Laboratory)
KONING, AARON (Agent in Charge / CBI - Denver - Laboratory)

03/30/2016 17:32
Last Update Date:
03/31/2016 05:53
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2
2016-59/56
No narrative, see attachments.

Page 1
03/30/2016

Primary Information
Description:
Interview with TRAVIS THRELKEL
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/06/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Thursday February 25, 2016, I interviewed Park County Sheriff's Department Deputy TRAVIS THRELKELL regarding his
Address #1 - OCCURRED #1 - 710 KIPLING ST

Primary Information
Address:
710 KIPLING ST OFFICE #200, DENVER, COLORADO 80215 , UNITED STATES
Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - THRELKEL, TRAVIS

Primary Information
Record Type:
Subject Name:
THRELKEL, TRAVIS
Rank/Position:
DEPUTY
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
DIAGRAM OF SCENE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
04/05/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Property #2 - DVD of interview with THRELKEL

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
VIDEO TAPE (OTHER)
Description:
DVD of interview with THRELKEL
Property Status:
INVENTORY
Status Date:
04/05/2016
Quantity:
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 6

Property #2 - DVD of interview with THRELKEL - Continued
Submitted To PES:
YES
Related Officers
LEO

04/05/2016 14:46
Last Update Date:
04/06/2016 13:19
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 6
2016-59/57
SYNOPSIS:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, I interviewed Park County Sheriff's Department Deputy TRAVIS
THRELKEL regarding his involvement in this case. The interview was held at the CBI Denver
Investigations Office at 2:04 PM and THRELKEL was accompanied by his legal counsel, Attorney
BRIAN HERBERT.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, I interviewed Park County Sheriff's Department Deputy TRAVIS
THRELKEL regarding his involvement in this case. The interview was held at the CBI Denver
Investigations Office at 2:04 PM and THRELKEL was accompanied by his legal counsel, Attorney
BRIAN HERBERT. During the interview I learned the following relevant information:
Background for THRELKEL:
THRELKEL has completed just over 2 years in Law Enforcement and has worked for the Park
County Sheriffs Department since 01/16/2014
THRELKEL has been a SWAT Team member since January 2016
THRELKEL has completed a 100 hour basic SWAT school and completes weekly SWAT
training
THRELKEL has never been involved in the use of Deadly Force prior to this incident
THRELKEL carries the following firearms: department issued Sig P320 9mm pistol with no
alterations and department issued Colt AR15 (SWAT gun) with no alterations
THRELKEL recently qualified with both his pistol and rifle
THRELKELs normal shift is Patrol Wednesday through Saturday (day shift hours 6:00 AM to
4:00 PM)
THRELKEL wears contacts and was wearing them during the incident
THRELKEL was well rested and the date of the shooting was his first day back from 7 days off
(4 day vacation and 3 days normal days off)
THRELKEL began his shift at 6:00 AM and was dressed in standard patrol uniform (clearly
identified as an officer)
THRELKEL was informed of scheduled eviction at 36 Iris Drive and responded to the Park
County Sheriffs Department Bailey substation at 8:30 AM for a briefing
Attended the briefing at the Bailey substation led by Cpt. HANCOCK with the following Law
Enforcement personnel: HANCOCK, THRELKEL, HANNIGAN, MARTIN, LEFFLER,
CARRIGAN, and LOWRANCE
During briefing he learned of lawful scheduled eviction order signed by Judge of Park County
Court

Page 1
04/05/2016
2016-59/57
THRELKEL did not have any personal contact with WIRTH prior to the incident date
THRELKEL was aware of past issues with WIRTH (threats to harm Officers / shoot next
officer he sees) and chase two weeks prior involving Jefferson County/Park County law
enforcement
Someone in briefing said WIRTH had claimed it would be the Ok Corral if deputies came
back (did not know who stated that)
No actual confirmation of weapons during briefing, just threats
Discussed plan of approach and assignments during briefing
Incident:
THRELKEL responded to 36 Iris Drive and approached from west with HANNIGAN,
MARTIN, LOWRANCE
CARRIGAN pulled into driveway in a marked unit with Cpt. HANCOCK
WIRTH appeared on the outdoor balcony on the north side of the residence and had a short
conversation with CARRIGAN (looked non-confrontational)
THRELKEL saw WIRTH turn around put his arms up in frustration and walk into the residence
(no aggression observed at that time)
After 2 or 3 minutes, THRELKEL heard radio traffic from Cpt. HANCOCK advising get to
the back door
THRELKEL and LOWRANCE rapidly moved along the south side of the residence toward the
east side door area
MARTIN moved alone along the north side of the residence toward the east side door area
HANNIGAN stayed on west side to cover the rear
THRELKEL, LOWRANCE, and MARTIN joined Cpt. HANCOCK and CARRIGAN on the
east side of the residence
CARRIGAN and Cpt. HANCOCK knocked and announced Sheriff's Office come to the door
for 1 to 2 minutes
Cpt. HANCOCK gave order to breach and enter the residence
MARTIN, THRELKEL, and LOWRANCE staged in a stack toward the right side of the door
in that respective order
CARRIGAN staged toward the left side of the door and kicked the door three times to open it
(no ram was brought to the scene)

Page 2
04/05/2016
2016-59/57
MARTIN, THRELKEL, and LOWRANCE entered into the mud-room (CARRIGAN stumbled
just inside of the door to the left)
MARTIN, THRELKEL, and LOWRANCE moved through the mud-room and approximately
half way through the kitchen with MARTIN yelling show me your fucking hands
THRELKEL saw a dark figure move rapidly behind a wall at the end of the kitchen
THRELKEL felt they were in a bad fatal funnel and then large volume of gunfire began
coming through the wall toward them
MARTIN screamed in pain and advised he had been shot
THRELKEL dragged MARTIN backward and all three Deputies evacuated under continued
gunfire (No rounds were fired by any Deputies inside of the residence)
Outside of the residence, THRELKEL moved MARTIN approximately ten feet to the right of
the door and stayed with him to protect him
THRELKEL heard LOWRANCE firing from his right side toward the residence
THRELKEL observed WIRTH appear in a window directly in front of him with something
silver and was in fear for his life and the life of MARTIN
THRELKEL conscious fired 4 to 7 rounds from his SWAT rifle at WIRTHs center mass area
to stop what he believed to be a lethal threat
WIRTH disappeared from the window and THRELKEL does not know if he actually hit him
After a short time, THRELKEL heard HANNIGAN yelling that WIRTH was on his side and
then gunfire was heard from the west side of the residence
THRELKEL left MARTIN and ran to the west side of the residence toward the gunfire
On the west side of the residence, THRELKEL found Cpt. HANCOCK standing over WIRTH
with his pistol locked back and WIRTH was obviously deceased (No medical aid given)
THRELKEL took WIRTHs rifle and brought it back with him to the west side, where he placed
his SWAT rifle and WIRTHs rifle just left of the door
THRELKEL saw CARRIGAN face down but didnt see any blood
THRELKEL did not know if CARRIGAN was injured or had over-exerted himself
A medic ultimately told THRELKEL that CARRIGAN was dead
THRELKEL returned to MARTIN and tried to remove his gear so medical could help him
MARTIN was removed from the scene by medical and THRELKEL remained on scene until
relieved by other Sheriffs personnel

Page 3
04/05/2016
2016-59/57
This supplement is only a summary; for further details see the recording of my interview with
THRELKEL and the transcript produced from the recording.

Page 4
04/05/2016

Primary Information
Description:
Interview of KOLBY MARTIN
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/06/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Thursday February 25, 2016, at 5:06 PM, I interviewed Park County Sheriff's Department Deputy KOLBY MARTIN regarding his
Address #1 - OCCURRED #1 - 11600 W 2ND PL

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
Subject #1 - SUBJECT #1 - MARTIN, KOLBY

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
MARTIN, KOLBY
Sex:
MALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Property Class:
EVIDENCE FELONY
Property Type:
DOCUMENTS
Description:
DIAGRAM OF SCENE
Property Status:
EVIDENCE LOCKER
Status Date:
04/05/2016
Quantity:
Submitted To PES:
YES
Related Officers
LEO

bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 5

04/05/2016 15:13
Last Update Date:
04/06/2016 13:15
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 5
2016-59/58
SYNOPSIS:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, at 5:06 PM, I interviewed Park County Sheriff's Department Deputy
KOLBY MARTIN regarding his involvement in this case. The interview took place in MARTINs
hospital room at Saint Anthonys Central Hospital and he declined to have his legal counsel present.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Thursday, February 25, 2016, at 5:06 PM, I interviewed Park County Sheriff's Department Deputy
KOLBY MARTIN regarding his involvement in this case. The interview took place in MARTINs
hospital room at Saint Anthonys Central Hospital and he declined to have his legal counsel present.
During the interview I learned the following relevant information:
Background for MARTIN:
MARTIN has just over 15 years of Law Enforcement experience and has worked for the Park
County Sheriffs Department since November 2005
MARTIN is currently a SWAT Team leader and has been a SWAT member since 2007
MARTIN completed a basic SWAT school and also completes ongoing SWAT training
Prior to Park County, MARTIN worked for the Elbert County Sheriff's Department from 2000
to 2005
MARTIN was a founding member of the Elbert County SWAT team and completed a basic
SWAT School
MARTIN has never been involved in the use of Deadly Force prior to this incident
MARTIN carries the following firearms: department issued Sig P320 9mm pistol with no
alterations, and a department issued Colt AR15 SMG 9mm select fire SWAT carbine
(semi/full-auto)
MARTIN recently qualified with both his pistol and carbine
MARTINs normal shift is Patrol Wednesday through Saturday day shift hours (6:00 AM to
4:00 PM)
MARTIN began his shift at the normal time and was dressed in a standard patrol uniform
(clearly identified as Officer)
MARTIN was informed of scheduled eviction at 36 Iris Drive by Sheriff WEGENER and
responded to the Bailey substation for a briefing
MARTIN attended a briefing at Bailey substation led by Cpt. HANCOCK

Page 1
04/05/2016
2016-59/58
The following Law Enforcement personal were present during the briefing: HANCOCK,
THRELKEL, HANNIGAN, MARTIN, LEFFLER, CARRIGAN, LOWRANCE, and Sheriff
WEGENER
During the briefing, MARTIN learned of a lawful scheduled eviction order signed by Judge of
Park County Court
MARTIN knew WIRTH had been previously evicted and this was his second eviction
MARTIN knew WIRTH had made a statement about making it the Ok Corral if Law
Enforcement returned
MARTIN knew WIRTH was a proclaimed sovereign citizen
MARTIN does not know if he has ever had any personal contact with WIRTH prior to the
incident date
MARTIN was aware of past issues with WIRTH (threats to harm Officers) and the chase two
weeks prior involving Jefferson County/Park County law enforcement
No actual confirmation of weapons during briefing, just threats
Discussed plan of approach and assignments during the briefing
Incident:
MARTIN responded to 36 Iris Drive and approached from west with HANNIGAN, MARTIN,
and LOWRANCE
CARRIGAN pulled into the driveway in a marked unit followed by Cpt. HANCOCK in an
unmarked vehicle
WIRTH appeared on the outdoor balcony on the north side of the residence and had a short
conversation with CARRIGAN for 1 to 2 minutes
MARTIN heard CARRIGAN advising WIRTH of the eviction
MARTIN saw WIRTH turn around and walk into the residence
MARTIN yelled for WIRTH to stay outside , but WIRTH ignored him
MARTIN moved alone along the north side of the residence toward the east side door area
THRELKEL, LOWRANCE, and MARTIN joined Cpt. HANCOCK and CARRIGAN on the
east side of the residence
CARRIGAN and Cpt. HANCOCK knocked and announced Sheriff's Office, come to the door
for approximately 10 minutes
Sheriff WEGENER arrived on scene and parked in the driveway

Page 2
04/05/2016
2016-59/58
Cpt. HANCOCK gave the order to breach and enter the residence
CARRIGAN staged toward the left side of the door and kicked the door three times to open it
(no ram brought to the scene)
MARTIN entered first, followed by THRELKEL and LOWRANCE in a stack
MARTIN, THRELKEL, and LOWRANCE entered into the mud-room and moved through the
mud-room into the kitchen to the end of the cabinets
MARTIN announced their presence and yelled fucking show me your hands (never actually
saw WIRTH)
Gunshots began coming through the wall at the end of the kitchen and MARTIN was struck in
the groin area causing substantial pain
MARTIN attempted to turn to run out of the residence, but was struck by several more rounds
and fell to the ground
THRELKEL dragged MARTIN backward and evacuated under continued gunfire (No rounds
were ever fired by MARTIN)
As THRELKEL dragged MARTIN out of the door area, MARTIN observed CARRIGAN on
the left side of the door firing his pistol
MARTIN then heard CARRIGAN yell Im hit and he lost track of him
Outside of the residence, THRELKEL moved MARTIN to the right of the door and stayed with
him
MARTIN was in great pain and was screaming
MARTIN saw rounds coming out of the window in front of him and heard gunfire being
exchanged by Deputies, but does not know who was shooting or how many rounds
MARTIN heard someone yelling to CARRIGAN to keep breathing
Heard someone say hes down (referring to WIRTH)
Medical personnel arrived and MARTIN was evacuated from the scene via ambulance and then
flight for life to the hospital
This supplement is only a summary; for further details see the recording of my interview with
MARTIN and the transcript produced from the recording.

Page 3
04/05/2016

Primary Information
Description:
EVIDENCE SCANS - JOURNALS/ PAPERS
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/07/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains an attached file of scanned journal pages. The journals were seized during search warrants executed at 36
Iris Drive in Bailey, Colorado, as well as from Storage One (Unit 114) in Bailey, Colorado.

Primary Information
Address:
Description:
SINGLE FAMILY HOME
Regional Offices:
DENVER

04/06/2016 08:08
Last Update Date:
04/07/2016 18:02
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
DIGITAL EVIDENCE: RMRCFL
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
05/26/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
Colorado, in reference to an Officer Involved Shooting.
This report documents the submission and review of the digital evidence seized from MARTIN WIRTH's property and storage unit.

04/08/2016 17:17
Last Update Date:
05/26/2016 10:24
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 2
2016-59/60
SYNOPSIS:
was asked to respond to Bailey, Colorado, in reference to an Officer Involved Shooting.
This report documents the submission and review of the digital evidence seized from MARTIN
WIRTH's property and storage unit.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Friday, April 8, 2016, I received a signed search warrant from Judge STEPHEN GROOME out of
Park County Combined Courts to search WIRTHs digital media seized from his residence and storage
unit.
On Friday, April 8, 2016, I, Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) Agent TAMMY LEE, faxed a
Request for Service and a copy of the search warrant to the Rocky Mountain Regional Computer
Forensic Laboratory (RMRCFL) in Centennial, Colorado. The request was for the forensic
examination of four (4) computers, two (2) external hard drives, one (1) computer server, and a
Samsung cellphone.
On Tuesday, April 12, 2016, I received an email from RMRCFL Operations Manager, SCOTT
BUCKLEY. BUCKLEY indicated the search warrant needed to explain the type of information being
sought from the above items of evidence. In addition, BUCKLEY told me they would prefer to only
analyze 3-4 items of evidence. BUCKLEY also advised the lab would not examine the cellphone and
we were welcome to use the laboratorys kiosk. (Note: The Samsung cellphone was later downloaded
by CBI Agent GREG ZENTNER. See supplement 2016-59/64.) After speaking with BUCKLEY, the
search warrant was updated and signed by Judge STEPHEN GROOME. An updated copy of the search
warrant was emailed to BUCKLEY and is attached to this report.
After speaking with BUCKLEY, it was decided only the laptop computer and two (2) external hard
drives would be examined. BUCKLEY advised if we did not locate items of evidence on the laptop or
external hard drives, additional digital evidence items could be submitted. BUCKLEY explained it
would take less time if they imaged the laptop and hard drives and I was able to examine the evidence
using the Case Agent Investigative Review (CAIR) process.
On Friday, May 13, 2016, I began reviewing the digital evidence along with CBI Analyst MARIA
LUNN. Several items of interest were bookmarked during the process and a disc from the RMRCFL
will be mailed to the Park County Sheriffs Office and the 11th Judicial District Attorneys Office when
it is received.
Nothing further.

Page 1
04/08/2016

Primary Information
Description:
ALIECE PLEMONS PICTURES
Occurence From:
04/08/2016 09:00
Occurence To:
04/08/2016 09:00
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/23/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
During the investigation, I learned a witness, ALIECE PLEMONS, may have taken video of part of the incident at 36 Iris Drive in
Bailey. PLEMONS lives at 57 Iris Drive and the drive-way to her residence is across the street from 36 Iris Drive. After contacting
PLEMONS and downloading her camera, I observed she had taken fifty-one (51) photographs following the shooting incident. No
video was located on the camera.
Address #1 - RELATED #1 - 57 IRIS DR

Primary Information
Address:
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - PLEMONS-ENDRESS, ALIECE MARIE

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
PLEMONS-ENDRESS, ALIECE MARIE
Sex:
FEMALE
Birth Date:
08/31/1956
Age:
59 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
500
Weight:
145
Eye Color:
HAZEL
Hair Color:
RED
Identifications
ID Type
Number
DRIVER LICENSE 94-284-0278
SOCIAL
521-92-5273
SECURITY
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
COLORADO
---
Country
-----
As Of Date
-----
Fictitious
NO
NO
Comment
-----
Page 1 of 3

04/12/2016 09:15
Last Update Date:
04/23/2016 15:14
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 3
2016-59/61
SYNOPSIS:
During the investigation, I learned a witness, ALIECE PLEMONS, may have taken video of part of the
incident at 36 Iris Drive in Bailey. PLEMONS lives at 57 Iris Drive and the drive-way to her residence
is across the street from 36 Iris Drive. After contacting PLEMONS and downloading her camera, I
observed she had taken fifty-one (51) photographs following the shooting incident. No video was
located on the camera.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Monday, February 29, 2016, during an interview with Sheriff FRED WEGENER, Agents learned a
female witness (neighbor) had possibly taken video of part of the incident. Sheriff WEGENER
indicated he saw the neighbor, believed to be ALIECE PLEMONS, standing around holding up a video
camera after the incident.
I contacted PLEMONS on Tuesday, April 5, 2016, and asked her if she took video of the shooting
incident at 36 Iris Drive. PLEMONS indicated she took video and pictures and had them on her
camera at her residence. I asked PLEMONS why she never mentioned the video or pictures when we
spoke to her after the incident and she said she wasnt sure. PLEMONS agreed to meet with me at her
residence on Friday, April 9, 2016, to retrieve the video and photographs.
On Friday, April 9, 2016, I drove to 57 Iris Drive in Bailey to meet with PLEMONS. CBI
Agent-in-Charge (AIC) KIRBY LEWIS and CBI Criminal Intelligence Analyst, MARIA LUNN, were
also present. When we contacted PLEMONS, she handed me a cord and her digital camera.
PLEMONS said she was unable to download the video onto her computer and would like me to take
the camera and bring it back after the video and pictures were downloaded.
Analyst LUNN downloaded the camera several hours later using an SD card reader since the batteries
of the camera were depleted. Analyst LUNN indicated she only located fifty-one (51) photographs
related to the incident and no video. We returned the camera and cord to PLEMONS several hours
later and PLEMONS indicated she was positive she also took a video of the incident. PLEMONS said
she never reviewed the video after she took it, but was positive it was on the camera. PLEMONS was
asked to look in several folders on her computer for the video and to charge her camera and check it
again for the possible video. I asked PLEMONS to call me immediately if she located the video.
We thanked PLEMONS for her time and left her residence.
downloaded from PLEMONS camera are attached to this report.
The fifty-one (51) photographs
Nothing further.

Page 1
04/12/2016

Primary Information
Description:
CORONER'S REPORTS
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
05/17/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This report documents the pathology, toxicology, and coroner reports.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
11/07/1980
Age:
35 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Deceased:
YES

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 1 of 4

Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Related Officers
LEO
KINTZ, DAVID (CORONER / Park County Coroner)

04/12/2016 09:24
Last Update Date:
05/17/2016 11:46
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Page 2 of 4
2016-59/62
SYNOPSIS:
This report documents the pathology, toxicology, and coroner reports.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Monday, April 11, 2016, CBI Agent-in-Charge DAN VOLZ received an email from Park County
Coroner, DAVID KINTZ JR. The email contained five (5) attachments, which included toxicology
reports for MARTIN WIRTH and NATHANIEL CARRIGAN, Coroner Summary Reports for
MARTIN WIRTH and NATHANIEL CARRIGAN, as well as a word document titled,
2016-010supp. All of the documents are attached to this report.
While reviewing the toxicology report for MARTIN WIRTH, I observed he tested negative for Ethyl
Alcohol, Benzodiazepines, Cocaine Metabolite, Methadone, Methamphetamine/MDMA, Opiates,
Oxycodone, and Tricyclic Antidepressants; however, I was unable to locate information related to
WIRTH being tested for Marijuana/Cannabinoids. I called and spoke to Coroner KINTZ who informed
me Marijuana/Cannabinoids is always part of their standard panel for toxicology testing. Coroner
KINTZ advised he was in the field working, but would look into the toxicology test as soon as possible.
On Wednesday, April 13, 2016, I received an email from Coroner KINTZ who indicated he had a call
into his toxicologist.
On Monday, April 18, 2016, I received a voicemail from Coroner KINTZ advising he spoke to the
toxicologist and WIRTHs blood would be tested for Marijuana/Cannabinoids and the results would be
rushed.
On Tuesday, April 19, 2016, I received three (3) additional attachments from Coroner KINTZ, which
included Dr. BEN GALLOWAYs Pathology report for NATHANIEL CARRIGAN, CARRIGANs
original toxicology report, and an amended toxicology report showing CARRIGAN tested for
Cannabinoids. Dr. GALLOWAYs Pathology report for CARRIGAN stated the following:
The wound of entrance involves the floor of the left axilla. The characteristics of the wound indicate
an entrance; an exit; and then a reentry; with extension downward through the soft tissues of the left
chest until impact of the 4th and 5th ribs of the 5th left intercostal space occurred; where it then
traveled inward through the 5th interspace; lacerating the pericardium; lacerating and establishing a
wound tract across the apex involving both the left and right ventricles of the heart. The projectile then
extended outward; impacted the lower lobe of the right lung; transecting the right lower lobe, and then
coming to rest adjacent to the internal wall of the chest involving the lateral posterior 8th rib. The
bullet is rather well preserved; large caliber; jacketed; consistent with a .45 caliber bullet measuring
1/2 in length and 3/8 in diameter at the base. This projectile traveled downward at an angle of 45

Page 1
04/12/2016
2016-59/62
degrees in the vertical plane, and anteroposterior, left-to-right at an angle of approximately 20 degrees
in the horizontal plane.
The autopsy findings in this case indicate that the cause of death is due to exsanguination secondary to
lacerations involving the heart and right lung secondary to a large caliber gunshot wound involving
the left axilla.
In addition, CARRIGAN tested negative for all drugs.
On April 19, 20, and 29th, 2016, I sent Coroner KINTZ emails to inquire on the status of WIRTHs
toxicology and pathology report. Coroner KINTZ indicated the lab was rushing the results and he
would send it to me as soon as he received it. I sent an additional email to Coroner KINTZ on May 6
and 10, 2016, regarding the status of WIRTHs results and reports. Coroner KINTZ advised he
expected the lab results to come in any day and would send them as soon as he received them.
On Monday, May 16, 2016, I received three (3) attachments from Coroner KINTZ, which included Dr.
GALLOWAYs Pathology report for MARTIN WIRTH, WIRTHs amended toxicology report, and the
scene drawing. Dr. GALLOWAYs Pathology report for WIRTH stated the following:
The autopsy findings in this case indicate that the cause of death is due to exsanguination associated
with multiple head and internal injuries secondary to multiple gunshot wounds, some of which are
through-and-through involving the back.
The autopsy reveals eleven entrance gunshot wounds involving the full spectrum of the back with a
predominance of the mid-back. The autopsy further reveals five exit wounds involving the lower right
neck and the mid and upper chest. A sixth exit wound is located in the upper abdomen, in the midline.
At the autopsy, three bullets were retrieved outside the body. One bullet is found in the clothing
related to the chest; a second bullet is found under the head while removing the clothing; a third bullet
is retrieved from the body bag. Two large caliber bullets are recovered from the right and left anterior
chest wall. One large caliber bullet remains deeply embedded in the left pelvis. The extensive internal
injuries in this case associated with six anterior exit wounds preclude a precise definition of wound
tracts.
In addition, WIRTH tested positive for Cannabinoids.
All of the reports are attached to this supplement.
Nothing further.

Page 2
04/12/2016

Primary Information
Description:
TRANSCRIBED RADIO TRAFFIC
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/23/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains an attached file of Park County Dispatch radio traffic transcripts.

04/19/2016 12:42
Last Update Date:
04/23/2016 15:14
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
WIRTH'S CELLPHONE DOWNLOAD
Reporting LEO:
Backup LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/23/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains attached files and reports related to the cellphone extraction of MARTIN WIRTH's Samsung cellular
telephone (IMEI: 355166053008520). The logical extraction was completed by CBI Agent GREG ZENTNER on Tuesday, April 19, 2016,
using a Cellebrite UFED Touch device. After the extraction, WIRTH's Samsung cellular telephone was returned to evidence.

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------
Page 1 of 2

04/19/2016 13:40
Last Update Date:
04/23/2016 15:50
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 2 of 2

Primary Information
Description:
FBI PRESERVATION REQUEST - CENTURYLINK
Occurence From:
02/26/2016 00:00
Occurence To:
02/26/2016 00:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/23/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains an attached facsimile received by Agent STEVE WHITTLE of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).
Agent WHITTLE sent a preservation request to CenturyLink regarding a phone number associated with MARTIN WIRTH
(303.838.2580). After reviewing the response by CenturyLink to the preservation request I learned MARTIN WIRTH received
"Standalone DSL - Internet Only- No Dialtone - No Call Detail" from CenturyLink. In addtion, CenturyLink advised they do not
normally track call detail to or from its landline customers. Due to this information, a search warrant was not obtained for the
records.

04/20/2016 15:48
Last Update Date:
04/23/2016 15:51
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
CBI FIREARMS REPORTS
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
04/27/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
This supplement contains attached laboratory reports from the Colorado Bureau of Investigation's (CBI) Forensic Services Division.
The laboratory reports pertain to all of the submitted firearms evidence.
Related Officers
LEO
HIGASHI, DALE (LAB AGENT / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)

04/26/2016 08:22
Last Update Date:
04/27/2016 11:47
Reporting LEO
bsena 05/26/2016 13:33
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
Page 1 of 1

Primary Information
Description:
PHONE INTERVIEW WITH PENELOPE ZELLER
Occurence From:
04/29/2016 11:00
Occurence To:
04/29/2016 12:00
Reporting LEO:
Approval Status:
Approved
Approved Date:
05/17/2016
Approved By:
Synopsis
On Friday, April 29, 2016, I conducted a phone interview with PENELOPE HODGE-ZELLER who was a friend of MARTIN WIRTH and
spoke to him by phone for over an hour and a half just five (5) days before the shooting.
This report documents my phone interview with PENELOPE HODGE-ZELLER who was present with her attorney, STEVEN HILL.
Subject #1 - WITNESS #1 - ZELLER, PENELOPE

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
ZELLER, PENELOPE
Sex:
FEMALE
Juvenile:
NO

Primary Information
Race:
WHITE
Record Type:
PERSON
Subject Name:
Sex:
MALE
Birth Date:
05/14/1957
Age:
58 YEAR(S)
Juvenile:
NO
Height:
600
Weight:
180
Eye Color:
BROWN
Hair Color:
BROWN
FULL BEARD
Deceased:
YES
Date Deceased:
02/24/2016 00:00
bsena 05/26/2016 13:34
Page 1 of 6

Identifications
ID Type
FBI#
DRIVER LICENSE
SID#
SID#
SOCIAL
SECURITY
Number
40100R4
922544026
694355
674951A
147567191
State
--COLORADO
COLORADO
NEW JERSEY
---
Country
-----------
As Of Date
-----------
Fictitious
NO
NO
NO
NO
NO
Comment
-----------

05/12/2016 10:08
Last Update Date:
05/17/2016 11:54
Reporting LEO
Date
Supervisor
Date
5/26/2016
bsena 05/26/2016 13:34
Page 2 of 6
2016-59/67
SYNOPSIS:
On Friday, April 29, 2016, I conducted a phone interview with PENELOPE HODGE-ZELLER, who
was a friend of MARTIN WIRTH and spoke to him by phone for over an hour and a half just five (5)
days before the shooting.
This report documents my phone interview with PENELOPE HODGE-ZELLER, who was with her
attorney, STEVEN HILL.
ACTION TAKEN:
On Tuesday, April 5, 2016, Colorado Bureau of Investigation Criminal Intelligence Analyst, MARIA
LUNN, analyzed MARTIN WIRTHs cellular telephone records, which had been received from a
search warrant executed on T-Mobile. While speaking with Analyst LUNN, she informed me
MARTIN WIRTH called cellular telephone number 303.947.6421, on Friday, February 19, 2016, and
the call lasted 100 minutes. Analyst LUNN advised the cellular telephone number WIRTH called listed
to Ethos Business Solutions in Denver, Colorado. The owner of Ethos Business Solutions was
PENELOPE HODGE-ZELLER, who was a Facebook friend of WIRTH and had also started a blog
on post-foreclosure options.
On Wednesday, April 6, 2016, I called and spoke with PENELOPE HODGE-ZELLER. PENELOPE
indicated she did have a lengthy conversation with WIRTH on Friday, February 19, 2016, which she
described as happy. PENELOPE said she had no problem speaking with me about her phone
conversation with WIRTH, but would need to seek the advice of her attorney, STEVEN HILL.
PENELOPE advised she would have HILL call me as soon as possible. I received a phone call from
Attorney STEVEN HILL, who indicated PENELOPE felt more comfortable making the call to me from
his office, so he could be present. A date for the phone interview was tentatively set up for April 14th
or 15th, 2016, and was subsequently cancelled due to an unrelated homicide investigation, which
required me to be out of town. I called and left HILL a voice mail the following week related to the
cancellation and asked him to call me so we could reschedule the interview.
On Friday, April 22, 2016, I received a phone call from PENELOPE, who indicated she still wanted to
do the phone interview (and speak the truth), but she was afraid for her safety and wanted her name
redacted from my report. I told PENELOPE I was unable to do an anonymous interview and if she
had concerns, her attorney could speak directly with District Attorney THOM LEDOUX. After
speaking with PENELOPE, I left HILL a voice mail to call me, so we could reschedule the interview.
The phone interview was scheduled for Friday, April 29, 2016, at 11:00 A.M. Both Attorney STEVEN
HILL and PENELOPE HODGE-ZELLER were present on the phone line, which was audio recorded.
During the interview with PENELOPE, she told me the following: (Note: This is only a summary of
the interview. Please review the audio recording in its entirety for full details.)
She first met WIRTH in 2013 or 2014.

She and WIRTH began to speak on a regular basis in late 2014 or early 2015.
Most of her conversations with WIRTH were done over the phone.
She occasionally saw WIRTH at various public events.

Page 1
05/12/2016
2016-59/67
WIRTH stayed at her residence a few times. She would fix him dinner, and also
provided him with groceries from her pantry to take home.
WIRTH had a website (no longer active), where he would post most of his legal filings related
to his foreclosure and eviction.
(With regard to her phone conversation with WIRTH on Friday, February 19, 2016.) She and
WIRTH had a wonderful conversation.
It was the first conversation she had with WIRTH in several months.
She last spoke to WIRTH when he was in New Jersey visiting his parents.
During their phone call, they spoke about gardening, bears in the area, and how he had a
nice holiday break from the local sheriffs harassing him.
WIRTH told her he got pulled over by a Jefferson County Sheriffs Deputy after
being tracked 6-7 miles into Park County.
WIRTH told her they claimed he had a revoked drivers license, which he
claimed was bullshit.
WIRTH said, You know meI got into an argument and uh, they ended up
beating me down.
She asked WIRTH who hit who first.
WIRTH said he didnt remember, but believed the officer pushed him
and he reacted, so they beat him down.
WIRTH said the police knocked his teeth out.
She and WIRTH discussed if he could cut a deal with the public defender and
courts, so he was able to do his probation in New Jersey.
WIRTH felt the Jefferson County Sheriffs Office, the Park County
Sheriffs Office, and the courts were all colluding, so his energy was
scattered and he couldnt file a new lawsuit against the bank.
She told WIRTH to call his bank and offer to voluntarily vacate the home
in the summer.
WIRTH said, Well, I think they are getting ready to serve me and try to evict
me again.
She and WIRTH had a 10-15 minute conversation on the perceived new
eviction attempt.
She and WIRTH discussed what he would do if the police came to his
property to serve him an eviction notice.
She told WIRTH not to engage the police if they showed up to post the
eviction notice.
She told WIRTH to go back into the house if he is outside when the
police come and allow the police to post the notice on his door.
WIRTH promised her that he would not engage the police.
WIRTH told her he would have to watch out for the notice because the
winds were high.
WIRTH told her, Maybe they posted down at the end of the drive-way.
She reminded WIRTH that the police are nothing but the tools for the bank.
WIRTH never mentioned anything about an eviction already posted on
his property.
She was aware WIRTH lost one of his filings against the mortgage company in September or
October (2015), which started the eviction process all over again.

Page 2
05/12/2016
2016-59/67
(With regard to WIRTH ever talking about using violence towards the police.) WIRTH was a
pacifist.
At times, WIRTH would go into that male testosterone bravado and start shooting
off at the mouth.
Most of WIRTHs comments were defensive in nature.
WIRTH was always pointed, passionate, and precise when he spoke.
She never heard WIRTH say anything about harming the police or bankers.
WIRTH was very Zen and philosophical.
WIRTH couldnt even squish spiders.
She cannot imagine WIRTH going out of his way to take an offensive action.
(With regard to WIRTH talking about owning any firearms or weapons.) WIRTH had rifles for
bears and had smaller handguns for fox and smaller animals.
In no way was any of his weapons cache purchased or designed for use against
peopleit was all about animal control up there.
(With regard to WIRTH talking about his prior homicide case.) WIRTH only spoke about his
prior homicide case on one occasion.
WIRTH only made a brief comment about it and said he just didnt have a choice.
WIRTH alluded to the fact that it was a self-defense situation.
She has seen WIRTH lose his temper in the past.
WIRTH was passionate and loud, which put people off.
WIRTH would lose his temper when he learned about people being screwed around.
For WIRTH, math was his Zen.
WIRTH was working on an algorithm, which they were going to discuss in more detail
at a future meeting.
WIRTH developed an algorithm, which would be integrated into the voting system, so
people could use their smart phone to track their vote from the time they voted all the
way up until the count.
She and WIRTH discussed speaking to political friends, who could give them advice on
his algorithm.
At the end of the phone conversation on Friday, February 19, 2016, she and WIRTH discussed
going to an upcoming RV show and also discussed his algorithm.
She and WIRTH were going to go to the RV show at the National Western Complex a
few weeks later.
WIRTH offered for her to stay at his house or in his 5th wheel camper.
She does not feel WIRTH would have invited her to his property if he felt there was a
risk to her safety.
She does not believe WIRTH expected the police to show up at his residence.
(With regard to if WIRTH discussed being harassed by the police.) In December 2015, WIRTH
mentioned he felt the police were spying on him.
On one occasion, WIRTH told her he was at the gas station or a store and was
approached by a police officer, who whispered something awful in his ear.
She told WIRTH not to engage any police officer because the police were just
trying to incite him.
(With regard to WIRTH documenting his thoughts or feelings in journals or on his computer.)
She asked WIRTH to do a backup of his computer and send the copy to his parents.
She was concerned about WIRTHs algorithm because it was a valid product, which
has value.

Page 3
05/12/2016
2016-59/67
In August or September 2015, WIRTH mentioned that one of his neighbors really got under
his skin.
WIRTH said he felt like his male neighbor was trying to put him (WIRTH) in a position
to get into a gun battle with the police.
She told WIRTH he shouldnt allow the neighbor on his property.
At the end of the interview, PENELOPE again mentioned her report not being made public, due to
safety concerns from other activists. I told PENELOPE we already had a conversation about
contacting the District Attorney prior to the interview. I reminded PENELOPE that I recommended she
speak with HILL who could call and discuss the matter with DA LEDOUX. HILL said he used to be a
DA and would call DA LEDOUX.
Nothing further.

Page 4
05/12/2016

ACISS Tip Information T2016-466
Entry Date: 02/24/2016 13:08
Primary Information
Number:
T2016-466
Category:
TIP
Entry Date:
02/24/2016 13:08
Call Taker:
Brief Description:
Park County Request -Officer Involved Shooting
Reporters Name:
Park County SO
Type:
Homicide
Status:
CLOSED
Status Date:
03/01/2016 00:00
Related Case:
2016-59
Synopsis
On February 24, 2016 Park County Sheriff's Office Requested assistance in an Officer Involved Shooting - Suspect Deceased, One
Deputy Deceased - two othe Park County Deputies injured by gunfire.
Denver Field and Lab dispatched to Park County 36 Iris Drive in Bailey, Park County, Colorado.
Current Forward/Assignment
Assigned To:
AGENCY:
DIVISION:
INVESTIGATIONS
OFFICE:
DENVER
Assigned By:
Assignment Date/Time:
02/24/2016 13:21
Priority:
PRIORITY 4 (15 DAYS)
Response Due Date:
03/10/2016
Followup Information
Followup Regular Time:
1:00
Followup Comments
"All hands" response from the Denver Office
bsena 05/26/2016 13:34
Page 1 of 1

Park County Shooting Report

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Park County Shooting Report

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Park County Shooting Report

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

What was the incident reported on?

What was the incident reported on?

What details are provided about the suspect?

What details are provided about the suspect?

Colorado Bureau of Investigation

ACISS Case Master Report 2016-59

COLORADO BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

LEE, TAMMY AGT (5202 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)

Officer Involved Shooting

CLOSED ASSISTANCE GIVEN

Case Status Date:

CLOSED ASSIST GIVEN

bsena 05/26/2016 13:32

ACISS software licensed by Colorado Bureau of Investigation

Colorado Bureau of Investigation

MEANS, JERRY AGT (5640 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)

Address #1 - DISPATCHED TO #1 - 36 IRIS DR

36 IRIS DR, BAILEY, COLORADO 80421 , UNITED STATES

SINGLE FAMILY HOME

Record Status Information

MEANS, JERRY AGT (5640 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)

Record Origination Date:

Last Update Operator:

Last Update Date:

bsena 05/26/2016 13:32

ACISS software licensed by Colorado Bureau of Investigation

Colorado Bureau of Investigation

Narrative begins on the following page.

bsena 05/26/2016 13:32

ACISS software licensed by Colorado Bureau of Investigation

COLORADO BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

COLORADO BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

LEE, TAMMY AGT (5202 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation)

Colorado Bureau of Investigation

FIRST DEGREE MURDER OF CPL NATHANIEL CARRIGAN

LEE, TAMMY AGT (5202 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)

SCHAEFER, CHRIS AIC (7713 / DENVER / Colorado Bureau of Investigation - Denver)

Address #1 - CRIME SCENE #1 - 36 IRIS DR

36 IRIS DR, BAILEY, COLORADO 80421 , UNITED STATES

SINGLE FAMILY HOME

MURDER 1 OF PEACE OFF-EXT INDIFFEREN-ATT

bsena 05/26/2016 13:32

ACISS software licensed by Colorado Bureau of Investigation

Colorado Bureau of Investigation

Subject #1 - VICTIM #1 - CARRIGAN, NATHANIEL

Subject #2 - VICTIM #2 - HANCOCK, MARK

Subject #3 - VICTIM #3 - MARTIN, KOLBY

Subject #4 - SUSPECT #1 - WIRTH, MARTIN THOMAS

WIRTH, MARTIN THOMAS

bsena 05/26/2016 13:32

ACISS software licensed by Colorado Bureau of Investigation

Colorado Bureau of Investigation

Sick Or Injured Type:

Sick Or Injured Treated By:

Sick Or Injured Transport By:

Sick Or Injured Transport To:

bsena 05/26/2016 13:32

ACISS software licensed by Colorado Bureau of Investigation