Water Sanitation Urban Madhya Pradesh
Water Sanitation Urban Madhya Pradesh
Water Sanitation Urban Madhya Pradesh
in Urban Areas
of Madhya Pradesh
WaterAid India
2006
Amod Khanna
Chitra Khanna
WaterAid India
2006
Research Team
Principal Researcher
Amod Khanna
Research Coordinator
Chitra Khanna
Research Associates
Sarita Thakur
Nagina Bano
Gauri Belapure
Ashish Sharma
Arun Kanan
Nidhi Shrivastav
Amit Sahu
Rupendra Kumar Sinha
Bharat Chauhan
Rajendra Pandey
Atul Sahu
Published by
WaterAid India
1st Floor, Nursery School Building
C-3, Nelson Mandela Marg
Vasant Kunj,
New Delhi - 110070
Tel: 0091-11-46084400
Fax: 0091-11-46084411
Contents
Foreword
iv
Abbreviations
Executive Summary
vi
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 WaterAid India
1.2 WaterAid India (West)
1.3 Summary of Desk Review
1.4 Field Study
1
1
1
3
Chapter 2
METHODOLOGY
2.1 Objectives of the Study
2.2 Research Question
2.3 Scope of Study
2.4 Sampling Plan
2.5 Method of Data Collection
2.6 Training of Research Associates
4
4
4
4
5
6
8
Chapter 3
9
9
9
10
Chapter 4
WATER
4.1 Water Source
4.2 Water Supply and Accessibility
4.3 Availability
4.4 Quality
4.5 Demands for Water
11
11
14
21
22
23
Chapter 5
SANITATION
5.1 Preamble
5.2 Sanitation Status
25
25
26
Chapter 6
RECOMMENDATIONS
6.1 Replication of Existing Models
6.2 Developing Demonstrative Processes
6.3 Issues in Advocacy
32
32
32
32
Annexure
33
Contents
iii
Foreword
The process of urbanisation in Madhya Pradesh gained
momentum during 1971-1981 when the state registered
an urban growth rate of 52.9 per cent. Though the
growth rate seems to be tapering off yet the growth
rate of urban population in the state is higher than
the national average. The decadal growth rate of
urban population of Madhya Pradesh has declined
from 43.92 per cent in 1991 to 31.19 per cent in 2001,
but this decadal growth rate in 2001 is higher than the
national average. With 26.6 per cent of the population
residing in urban areas, the state has gained an urban
character, a fact that has significant implications for
the provisioning of water and sanitation in the urban
areas of the state.
This is a study launched by the Regional Office (West)
of WaterAid India to assess the urban context in the
state and provide an overall framework for long term
and short term programming for the Regional Office.
This study on Water and Sanitation status of MP was
essentially done to profile the State, Institutions and
Policy Environment, in 2005. This was carried out
in two phases A desk study, focused on reviewing
different approaches and methodologies adopted by
government/non government agencies, the financial
resources available for WATSAN activities along with
the institutional mechanism responsible for delivering
WATSAN services to the communities and households.
This was followed by a field study to deepen our
understanding of the sector and which validated
most of the findings of the desk review. The desk
study reiterated and underlined the need to look into
ground realities in urban areas independently so as
to initiate dialogue with the state and discussions
among the development professionals on issues in
water and sanitation that are specific to urban areas
in the state. The present field study generates field
data and articulates issues that are biased in favour
of the citizens and the poorer sections of the urban
community.
Three critical institutional issues identified by
the report are noteworthy: firstly, the multiplicity
of institutions that are responsible for ensuring
water and sanitation in the urban areas dilute the
administrative responsibility and is disempowering
to the citizens as they are unable to locate the focal
point to address their grievances. Secondly, the half
hearted decentralisation with constitution of Mohalla
Samitis and Zonal Committees without delegation
of substantive powers makes peoples participation
tokenistic. Thirdly, the delay in handing over the
colonies by the development authorities and private
developers to the urban local bodies leads to loss
iv Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Abbreviations
BHEL
CMO
DUDA
GCF
LPCD
km
kilometre
MP
Madhya Pradesh
MGD
MPEB
NGO
OHT
Overhead Tank
O&M
PHE
SDM
sq
square
SWM
ULB
WAI
WaterAid India
WATSAN
Abbreviations
Executive Summary
1. Background
WaterAid India made a strategic shift in locating its
headquarter in India to Delhi and starting its regional
offices at Bhopal, Bhubaneswar and Bangalore. This
shift is expected to enable the organisation to work
closely with the policy makers and to work closely with
the most vulnerable communities in Madhya Pradesh,
Chhattisgarh, Uttar Pradesh, Orissa, Bihar
and Jharkhand.
The regional office at Bhopal had commissioned a
study to profile the State, Institutions and Policy
Environment of Madhya Pradesh in 2005. The study
had highlighted the need for recognising urban
Madhya Pradesh as a critical and important sub-sector
for intervention within water and sanitation in the
state.
2. Field Study
The findings of the desk review identified issues that
were based on concerns expressed by the institutions
responsible for supplying services in water and
sanitation. The peoples issues and their expectations
from the service providers did not figure in the desk
review. Consequently the present field research was
undertaken as a primary level study with a purposive
sampling bias to initiate a detailed inquiry into issues
that have been identified during the desk review
and also to address concerns of communities and
individuals in water and sanitation in urban areas.
3. Research Question
The objectives of the present study were decided
mutually in consultation with WaterAid India regional
office. The main research question for the study will
be: What is the state & status of water and sanitation
in the urban areas selected for the study?
The term water includes water required for domestic
consumption; and sanitation refers to disposal of
human excreta, liquid waste and household solid
waste. The term state has been used to reflect the
present levels of demand and supply of water and
sanitation in the household and the term status is
used to make assessment of services in water and
sanitation with respect to their adequacy and quality.
The expression status has been interpreted to take
into account trends related to levels of services and
their demand and supply at the urban level.
4. Sampling Plan
The current study adopted a purposive sampling plan
for the selection of urban areas in the state. In all
four Municipal Corporations, namely, Bhopal, Indore,
Ujjain and Jabalpur; two Municipal Councils Badnagar
and Panagar and two Nagar Panchayats Tarana and
Shahpura were selected for the study.
Sampling within the city was undertaken to ensure
adequate geographical coverage as well as coverage
of problem and good areas as defined by the local
body. Within the selected area the issues of water
and sanitation were intensively studied in terms of
all the users of water residential (high, middle, low
and slum settlements), commercial, and institutional
groups.
vi Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Water Supply
Executive Summary
vii
Sanitation toilets
Availability
Water Quality
viii Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Institutional Issues
7. Recommendations
Replicating Good Practices
The systems for water supply and sanitation that exist
in township of BHEL and GCF are noteworthy. The
technological and the institutional system adopted by
these townships are worth replicating for small and
medium towns (at least). The study recommends that
the system in both these townships be studied in
their technical and economic feasibilities and use for
replication in other cities.
Advocacy
At a broader level two sets of issues are identified for
advocacy:
a) at the policy level that will affect all the areas of
Madhya Pradesh. This includes issues related to:
Setting minimum norms for water and
sanitation that each local body has to
ensure to qualify as an institution of good
governance.
Role of different institutions in ensuring
the provisioning of services in water and
sanitation. This should include the statement
on the role of parastatal organisations like
development authorities, housing boards etc.
Policy of urbanisation along with the policy
related to slums and their entitlements.
Debate on the advantages on having a
separate organisation like Jal Board for
supplying services in water and sanitation.
b) Issues related to specific city context
Level of awareness among the elected
representatives regarding procedures,
Executive Summary
ix
x Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
CHAPTER
Introduction
1.1 WaterAid India
WaterAid is an international NGO exclusively focused
to ensure the provision of safe domestic water,
sanitation and hygiene education to the worlds
poorest people. With its headquarters in United
Kingdom, WaterAid works in 15 countries, mostly in
Asia and Africa.
WaterAid India Programme started in 1986 with
a dominant presence in the southern states of
the country. With Country Programme office at
Tiruchirapalli, WaterAid worked with more than 70
partner organisations in Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh,
Maharashtra, Orissa and Karnataka.
A review of the India Programme in 2002 underlined
the commitment of WaterAid in developing
methodologies that were able to set standards of
good practice for water, sanitation and hygiene
projects in these states. The demonstrated impacts in
southern states gave confidence to WaterAid in India
to focus towards the poorer states in the northern part
of the country. As a strategic move the headquarters
of the country programme was shifted to New Delhi to
work closer with policy makers. Regional offices were
opened in Bhopal and Bhubaneswar in 2002 to work
closely with most vulnerable communities in Madhya
Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Uttar Pradesh, Orissa, Bihar and
Jharkhand.
Introduction
2 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Introduction
CHAPTER
Methodology
2.1 Objectives of the Study
The objectives of the present study were decided
mutually in consultation with WaterAid India
regional office. The study was conducted with the
objective to:
(i) identify and assess the state of demand for
and supply of water in towns and the strategies
adopted by urban local bodies, in fulfilling these
demands;
(ii) identify and assess the state of demand for and
supply of water in the slum areas of the towns
and the systems adopted by urban local bodies in
fulfilling this demand for water;
(iii) assess the measures undertaken by the
community/government for ensuring source
sustainability for drinking water;
(iv) identify the systems used by the service providers
and service receivers for ensuring the quality of water;
(v) identify the hygiene and sanitation system (private/
community latrine, liquid waste disposal and solid
waste management) of the town including the role
of the local body and/or government department in
operationalising the system;
(vi) identify the systems of O&M, grievance handling
on subjects of water and sanitation; and
(vii) analyse the findings in the light of current policies
and programmes of the government and non
government agencies (if any).
The study is thus comprehensive in nature. It treats
the issue of water from the point of view of source
and the measures taken to ensure its sustainability,
the demand and the supply system that have been
established for water within the city. There is an
inherent bias of the study in favour of the urban poor
as it seeks to place special emphasis on whether the
water requirements of the poor are being met as far
as water and sanitation needs are concerned. The
study takes the position where the urban consumer
is treated as a client and his satisfaction in terms of
availability, adequacy and quality of water forms the
basis of inquiry to assess the ability of the urban
local body to satisfy these needs. The term sanitation
is used in the wider sense to include place for
defecation, system for liquid and solid waste disposal
in the city.
4 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Table 2.1: Districts with Urban Population higher than the State Average
District
Percentage Urban
Population
Nagar Panchayat
Municipal Council
Municipal Corporation
Bhopal
80.53
Indore
71.57
Gwalior
60.33
Jabalpur
57.51
Ujjain
38.74
Hoshangabad
30.95
Ratlam
30.25
Sagar
29.25
Neemuch
27.88
Dewas
27.35
10
East-Nimar
26.95
Table 2.2 List of Districts with all the three types of Urban Local Bodies and the Urban Population in
the District and its Growth Rate
District
Nagar Panchayat
Municipal
Council
Municipal
Corporation
Urban Population
(in lakhs)
Gwalior
9.83
20.80%
Jabalpur
12.46
23.54%
Ujjain
6.62
21.15%
Ratlam
3.67
18.62%
Sagar
5.91
22.85%
Khandwa
4.60
16.78%
Methodology
Table 2.3
District
Municipal
Council
Nagar
Panchayat
Ujjain
Ujjain
Badnagar
Tarana
Jabalpur
Jabalpur
Panagar
Shahpura
Municipal Council
Nagar Panchayat
6 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Residential
Institutional
Naya Bazaar
George Town Market
Deendayal Slum
Sanchar Nagar Slum
Behind Bhola Nagar Slum
Chandal Bhata
(Transport Nagar)
Sai Colony (HB)
Krishna Nagar (PB)
Green City (PB)
Manmohan Nagar (MC)
ITI Colony (GC)
PNB Colony (GC)
Tri Murti Nagar (PB)
Mado Taal (OC)
Garha (49)
(Fluoride)
Bank Colony
Koshta Mohalla (OC)
Jhariya Mohalla
Garha Bauli (OC)
Garha Bazaar (OC)
Garha Bazaar
Tripuri (57)
(Fluoride)
Tripuri Bazaar
Medical College
Cherital (12)
Bus Stand
Shiv Mandir
Ashirwad market
Shivalaya Lodge
Satyam Shivam
Restaurant
Industrial Area
Sakshi Bhojnalaya
Pal Restaurant
Sonali Sweets
Hotels
Rishi Regency
Railway Station
Deen Dayal
(23)
Commercial
Anjuman Islamia
Mayur Hotel
Mahakaushal College
Bus Stand
Note: The figures in bracket in column one are the ward numbers; PB= Private Builder; HB= Housing Board Colony; GC= Government Colony; MC= Municipal
Corporation Colony; OC= Old City; AB= Ayodhya Basti
Methodology
(v) Councillors:
Secondary Sources
(i) Documents of ULBs
(ii) Relevant government reports and documents
(iii) Study reports and other similar documents
8 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
CHAPTER
Total
Population
(2001)*
Bhopal
14,33,875
Jabalpur
Ujjain
No. of Wards
Population Per
Ward
Gandi Basti#
(No.)
34.92
69
20780
209
8.81
9,51,469
28.24
60
15857
117
28.95
4,30,427
18.68
54
7970
113
28.15
Badnagar
34,065
7.97
18
1892
61
NE
Panagar
25,143
17.16
15
1676
NA
NE
Tarana
25,000
8.28
15
1666
NA
NE
11,961
20.71
15
797
NA
NE
Shahpura
* Source= Census 2001; # Source= Urban Local Body; NA = Not Available; NE = Not Enumerated
10 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
CHAPTER
Water
4.1 Water Source
The issue of water source for the city covered by the
study includes:
the water source used by the municipal body to
provide water to the households for domestic use,
commercial and industrial use; and
the water source that each user of water develops
for itself as a private source of water.
Municipal Body
The historical water sources for the city and the
current sources of water used by the municipal body
are given in Table 4.1.
The cities historically have been dependent on surface
water either through rivers or through storage of
surface water through ponds.
Historical
Sources of Water
for the city
Sources of Water
currently used by
Municipal Body
Bhopal
Upper Lake
Dugwells
Upper Lake
Kolar Dam
Tubewell
Handpump
Ujjain
Kshipra River
Dugwells
Gambhir Dam
Undasa Dam
Sahebkhedi Dam
Tubewell
Handpump
Jabalpur
Local Ponds
Dugwells
Badnagar
(Ujjain)
Chamla River
Dugwells
Dam
Tubewell
Handpump
Panagar
(Jabalpur)
Local Ponds
Dugwells
Tubewell
Handpump
Tarana
(Ujjain)
Dam
Tubewell
Handpump
Shahpura
(Jabalpur)
Local Ponds
Dugwells
Tubewell
Handpump
Water
11
Table 4.2
City
Domestic
Users
Commercial and
Industrial Users
Institutional
Users
Bhopal
Tubewell
Dugwell
Tubewell
Tubewell
Ujjain
Tubewell
Dugwell
Tubewell
Dugwell
Tubewell
Jabalpur
Tubewell
Dugwell
Tubewell
Tubewell
Badnagar
(Ujjain)
Tubewell
Dugwell
Panagar
(Jabalpur)
Tubewell
Dugwell
Tarana
(Ujjain)
Tubewell
Dugwell
Shahpura
(Jabalpur)
Tubewell
Dugwell
Tubewell
Handpump
Tubewell
Tubewell
Tubewell
Tubewell
12 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Badnagar
Badnagar draws it water from Chamla reservoir
throughout the year. The farmers near the reservoir also
draw water for irrigation from the dam. Every year by
January the farmers are asked not to draw any more
water or else the water for the city will not be available
during the summer months. However farmers do draw
water from the dam that often leads to conflict between
the Municipal Council and the farmers.
In 2005 one diesel pump was confiscated and an FIR
was lodged against the farmers who were found to be
drawing water from the dam. Since the Council does
not have the power to stop the farmers from using
the water they have to depend on the Sub Divisional
Magistrate to enforce the prohibition. According to the
SDM this role is to be played by the Municipal Council
of Badnagar. The issue is snowballing and might lead
to a higher level of conflict between the Municipal
Council and the farmers.
Water
13
Badnagar
Badnagar Municipal Council gets its water from the
reservoir from the dam of Chamla river. Till 1984-85 this
river used to have a perennial flow of water. However,
of late the water in the reservoir is not sufficient
to cater to the water requirements of the city. The
proposal to increase the height of the dam has been
rejected as it had been increased once in 1971. During
the summer months the municipal council takes over
the borewells in the vicinity of the dam and lifts water
directly from these wells to the filtration plant by
using the generator. The water supplied is not properly
treated as a result of which there is a peculiar odour in
the water during these months. This is despite the fact
that there are 33 tubewells and 42 handpumps
(32 functioning well) that are also used to supply water
to a population of 34065 persons. In addition the
Council has a pending bill of Rs 30 lakh on account
of electricity charges that they have incurred to supply
water to the city.
Master Plan
The three big cities covered by the study have had
Master Plans for the past 30 years now. The first
Master Plan of these cities have been reviewed and
updated. A perusal of the Master Plan of these cities
reveals that the plan does not devote more than a
page to the issue of water supply in the city. This
page documents the existing water sources and
estimates the water requirement for domestic purpose
during the planning period. The Master Plans give in
quite detail the land use of different sections of the
city. Of the different land uses a water body does not
appear as one of the possible land uses in any of the
Master Plans.
It needs to be pointed out that the Master Plan is
titled as the Development Plan of the city. It is indeed
sad that a Master Plan for water does not form part
of this plan. Since the growth of the city is expected
to be governed by the land use defined in the plan it
would only be logical that this plan also reflects on
the possible sources of water that the municipal body
can access to fulfill its incremental demand for water
as the city grows over a period of time.
Census Data
The Census data for water sources is at two levels:
one, the source from where the households procure
water for a greater part of the year and second, the
14 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Table 4.3 Sources of Water for the Households in the Cities Selected for the Study
Sources of Water
Tap
Handpump
Bhopal
Jabalpur
Ujjain
Panagar
Badnagar
Tarana
Shahpura
No
222064
124412
64304
3792
4477
1560
1306
83
73
87
83
82
45
60
21069
23732
4359
529
313
1516
643
14
12
44
29
19040
10672
1695
23
606
270
199
11
3130
8318
2691
196
51
47
25
No
3468
2219
548
31
47
268771
169353
73597
4543
5478
3440
2182
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
No
%
Tubewell
No
%
Dugwell
No
Others
Total Households
%
Table 4.4 Location of Water Source for the Households in the Cities Selected for the Study
City
Total Households
Location
Within Premises
268,771
Bhopal
%
Jabalpur
%
Ujjain
%
Panagar
%
Badnagar
%
Tarana
%
Shahpura
%
155,230
Near Premises
80,279
Away
33,262
100
58
30
12
169,353
86,609
52,560
30,184
100
51
31
18
73,597
52,837
15,348
5,412
100
72
21
4,543
1,962
2,039
542
100
43
45
12
5,478
3,602
1,129
747
100
66
21
14
3,440
1,343
1,407
690
100
39
41
20
2,182
985
943
254
100
45
43
12
Water
15
Location
Tap
Handpump
Tubewell
Well
Others
222,064
21,069
19,040
3,130
3,468
% Within Premises
61
20
76
28
% Near Premises
30
42
12
32
27
% Away
38
12
39
66
124,412
23,732
10,672
8,318
2,219
% Within Premises
52
36
73
59
11
% Near Premises
32
36
17
26
19
% Away
16
28
10
15
69
64,304
4,359
1,695
2,691
548
% Within Premises
77
10
71
61
% Near Premises
18
61
20
22
34
% Away
30
16
63
3,792
529
23
196
% Within Premises
42
53
39
51
33
% Near Premises
46
41
26
39
67
% Away
13
35
10
4,477
313
606
51
31
% Within Premises
73
10
48
14
10
% Near Premises
18
46
24
47
23
% Away
44
28
39
68
1,560
1,516
270
47
47
% Within Premises
35
44
39
53
% Near Premises
47
38
14
45
57
% Away
18
17
47
43
1,306
643
199
25
% Within Premises
47
40
57
20
11
% Near Premises
47
45
17
20
44
% Away
16
26
60
44
Total Households
Bhopal
Total Households
Jabalpur
Total Households
Ujjain
Total Households
Panagar
Total Households
Badnagar
Total Households
Tarana
Total Households
Shahpura
Sources of Water
16 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Field Data
The water supply system in a city includes the pipes
to draw water from the source, process of treatment
of water, supplying water to the users through
network of main and subsidiary pipelines to the
point where the user is located (see Diagram of
Bhopal). The user is then responsible to connect his
private pipe line from the municipal line after making
payment to the municipal body. The payment for the
connection is based on the diameter of the pipe that
the user chooses to install and on the type of user
(see Box).
(a) Filtration Plant
Filtration plants have been installed where the water
is drawn from a surface source dams, ponds or
reservoir. In cases where the ground water is drawn
it is directly put into the pipeline for supply. This
water does not go through the process of filtration/
Water
17
(d) Colonies
The colonies here refer to the colonies that have been
developed by the Development Authority, Housing
Board and the private builders.
The study found out that the colonisers develop
their own source of water (tubewell) and supply
water to the residents. They normally do not apply
for connection from the municipal source. Neither
do they pay any royalty charge to the municipal
body for drawing ground water and selling it to the
residents. The charges paid by the residents are the
same as that charged by the municipal authorities (if
Bhopal Municipal Corporation is charging Rs 150 per
household the developers also charged Rs 150. When
the Corporation decreased its charges to Rs 60 the
developers also decreased their charges). The money
thus collected by the colonisers are appropriated and
Ujjain
Ujjain has 73597 households with 25851 tap
connections. There are 364 borewells and 19 overhead
tanks and the 20th one is under construction with
64.5 lakh gallon capacity that cater to the water
consumption of 17978 lakh litres per day.
Each of the overhead tanks houses a PHE office of the
Corporation below the tank. During interviews with the
PHE officials the study found out that they were not
aware of the housing colonies that are being serviced
by their tank. Their sole concern was to ensure that
water is pumped into these tanks and released at
the appropriate time. The second concern was with
respect to ensuring regular cleaning of the tank. The
information related to service area of the tank is
available only at the Corporation level.
Shahpura
There are two overhead tanks at Shahpura with
installed capacity of 2.86 and 3.20 lakh litres
respectively. Together these tanks serve water to
9 wards and to two wards partially. There are two
tubewells attached with each of the tank that take 8
and 10 hours of continuous running for the tank to be
filled completely. The remaining three wards are served
by drawing water from three tubewells and supplying
directly to the households. The electricity bill of the
Nagar Panchayat is Rs 35,000 per month.
18 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Water
19
Table 4.6
Slum
No. of
Houses
No. of Tap
No. of
connections Households per
tap connection
BHOPAL
Banganga*
2820
1315 private
Shiv Nagar
500
2000 litre
tank
Ayodhya Nagar
750
250
Fatma Nagar
150
75
Kolar Colony
700
175
JABALPUR
Deendayal Nagar
700
2
connections
350
Bhola Nagar
150
2
connections
75
Rajeev Nagar
700
70 private
10
Temar
300
30 private
3
community
UJJAIN
Nagjhiri
150
No
connection
2.144
20 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
4.3 Availability
Availability in case of urban areas implies, frequency
of supply, duration of supply, supply pressure and the
issue of water reaching the tail end of the pipeline.
Frequency of Supply
The frequency of water supply was an issue in all the
towns. In the cities studied it was reported that there
is at least one part of the town that did not receive
water supply for a day.
In Badnagar water is supplied on alternate days till
the month of February. During March and April the
Duration of Supply
Shahpura is able to supply water two times a day for
one hour each. But it faces a problem of maintaining
fixed timings as the water is supplied directly from the
tubewells, the functioning of which is dependent on
the availability of electricity.
Shahjanabad colony in Bhopal gets water for 10-15
minutes. Ayodhya Nagar in Bhopal gets water for one
hour as per the contractor, but the residents say that
the water comes for 15-20 minutes from March to June
and from July to December the supply is for one hour.
The Sai Housing Board Colony gets water for four
hours though the houses on upper slope in the colony
get water for two hours only.
Nehru Nagar in Ujjain gets water for 30 minutes on
alternate days. Mahananda, Mahashakti and Police
Line areas are given water for three hours every day.
Indira Nagar gets water for two hours, Chhatri Chowk
for one hour and Gopal Mandir Hospital area get for
half an hour.
The above examples highlight the fact that there is
difference in supply of water to different parts of the
city and also to different parts of the same colony.
However it seems that the better off colonies get
water for a longer duration than the colonies that
are not economically prosperous including the
slums. The government policy defined on the
basis of lpcpd does not differentiate between the
economic classes. The supply agencies seem to
have a different notion as duration of water supply
is directly correlated to level of economic prosperity
of the residential area.
Water
21
Ujjain Corporation
Ujjain Municipal Corporation takes pride in the fact
that they have highest LPCD in the state. The ground
reality is that there are large pockets in the city that
do not get water every day. Moreover when they get
water it is less than the minimum LPCD defined by the
government.
Pressure
In Shahjanabad, Bhopal the water supplied by the
pipes does not reach the houses on the upper slopes.
These households have to bring their vessels in the
lower regions and fill water from the pipeline by
making a pit below the outlet without a tap to fill
the water. A housing board colony near Berasia is
adopting the same practice of coming downhill and
filling water.
Madotal, Jabalpur
The water in pipes in secured from the tubewells
located on the circumference of the pond. The old
residents (approx.200 houses) near the lake, few (3-4)
houses in Kasondha Nagar and ITI colony (50 houses)
get water from this source. But all the three pumps
have to be working at the same time, so that pressure
is built and ITI Colony gets water.
In Jabalpur, the Tripuri area is housed by middle
income group houses. The houses are located on
the hill. The houses located on the lower side of
the hill have been provided pipe connections by
the Corporation. The residents uphill are not given
connections as the water pressure was likely to be
insufficient. Similar situation exists in Madan Mahal.
The Chief Engineer of the PHE department disclosed
that in some colonies in the city the water from
borewell is added to the water in the pipeline to
increase the pressure so that water reaches the tail
end of the pipeline.
Issues in Availability
Water Security
The issue of frequency, duration and pressure of
water supplied by the local body was a major source
of discontent in most of the residential colonies and
slum settlements of the city. From the users point
of view these are the three factors that define the
assurance of regular and sufficient water supply to the
household. According to most of the households these
three factors constitute the basis of assessing the
performance of the local body in their ability to supply
water to the city.
Any shortfall in frequency, duration and pressure of
water constituted the situation of water insecurity
for the households. The households in such cases
would undertake their own measures depending on
their affordability. For example the well-off sections
of the city would resort to installation of tubewells,
4.4 Quality
The System: The PHE department in all the towns
specified that the water is checked regularly. However
on deeper inquiry it was revealed that it is the water
from the surface source that is checked regularly. The
testing of water from the tubewells is done only when
a problem is reported as happened at Shahpura in July
2003, when water from all the tubewells was tested
after there was a report of illness. Since then no such
test has been undertaken.
The study was unable to procure a test plan or list of
parameters to be tested from any PHE official in any
of the cities. One of the reasons for lack of regular
testing of water reported by the department was
lack of resources to undertake this task regularly.
In contrast, the BHEL personnel in Bhopal gave a
detailed plan of the tests to be carried out daily,
weekly, monthly and annually.
Fluoride: Tripuri and the stretch from Dev Tal to
medical college in Garha zone of Jabalpur have
fluoride. Many of the handpumps have been closed
and/or marked, though some are still in operation.
Water from these handpumps is being used for
washing utensils and for other domestic work. People
use drinking water from the wells, bawadis or tankers
supplied by the corporation. Dental fluorosis seems
have set in amongst the population in the area as
yellowing of teeth has become visible in disturbing
levels. The officials at the zonal office reported that
though the people know that water is contaminated
by fluoride and its adverse effects, they still consume
it. Information about fluoride has been displayed
on boards. The study team found out that though
people are not taking contaminated water for drinking
purposes they are consuming it for other domestic
purposes.
Other Contaminations: In Moti Nagar at Ujjain
handpumps with saline water were reported to the
study team. In fact according to the residents salinity
22 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Issues in Quality
Disclosure of information
The PHE cell of the local body undertakes quality
surveillance but the information so collected does
not become part of the information fed to the public.
Discussions with citizens revealed that they did not
have any information regarding the quality of water
being supplied to them. In case of Jabalpur where
water has been found to be contaminated with
fluoride the citizens did not have information on
the extent of contamination and the implications of
consuming such water. The information with respect to
quality of water does not form part of the report that
is tabled during the meeting of the general body of
the urban local body.
Peoples Concern
The consumer is concerned about the quality of
water she/he is consuming. Where the people can
afford they have spent money in getting their water
tested. In fact, during the course of study the
households that had installed tubewells reported
that they had got their water tested to assess its
quality. Similar concern was also observed in slum
settlements where people did distinguish between
sources with better quality.
Surveillance System
Surveillance system that monitors quality of water
from all sources (supplied by local body, colonisers,
development authorities, housing boards etc) is
assessed by the study team as a need of the citizens.
The reports of such a system need to be fed at the
public and organisational domain in a manner that
is understood by the lay man. The excuse for lack of
resources, as stated by the officials of the urban local
body, cannot be taken as either valid or tenable.
Water
23
Nature of demand
Middle
and upper
middle
class
Lower
income
group
Slum
dwellers
Drinking water
Washing clothes
Cleaning of utensils
Cleaning of house
Washing of vehicles
Watering of plants
24 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
CHAPTER
Sanitation
5.1 Preamble
Scene I
Researcher
Commissioner
There is no sewerage network in the city. You should talk to the Health Officer. He will
give you information in detail.
Health Officer
Giving details of the cleaning zones of the city and number of staff employed he said,
there are sufficient toilets in the city.
Researcher
Health Officer
Researcher
Health Officer
PHE department
The sewerage was handled under a specific project and the project is now over. Mr. X
was deputed in the project. Only he can give you the details.
Scene II
Scene III
Mr X:
The project was to prevent waste water from entering the river. The project has been
implemented but not functional as the Municipal Corporation is not taking over. They
have put the project in cold storage (thande baste mein).
Can you tell us how is the local body geared up for the project and what are your
preparations after the project is over?
The project is going to take 5 years, we will see then. Right now the officials are being
nominated from the PHE.
about the study?
There is no need for any more study.
Sanitation
25
5.2.1 Toilets
The issue of toilets in the cities selected for the study
was essentially at three levels:
Conversion of dry latrines into flush type toilets in
smaller cities.
Toilets in slum settlements in larger cities.
Toilet facilities in institutions.
Conversion of Toilets
The Nagar Panchayats and Municipal Councils covered
under the study received funds for creation of basic
infrastructure to convert the dry type toilets to flush
type. The coverage as stated by the urban local body
and as found during the field survey are being given
in Table 5.1.
There is a wide variation in the data collected from
the field and the claims stated by the urban local
body. The officials from the urban local body expect
the elected representatives to play a proactive role
whereas the elected representatives were either
unaware of the process of procuring funds or were
indifferent towards this issue. The team assessed
that the elected representatives did not have a
vision or idea regarding cleanliness and sanitation
of the city and the activities that are required for
the same.
Slum Settlements
The slums in all the towns have a small percentage
of houses having private latrines. The number of
community toilets in the slum does not commensurate
with the population of the slums. The data collected
for larger cities is given in Table 5.2.
The households that report no facility of private or
community toilets are resorting to open defecation.
The site for defecation depends on the space available
near the settlement nallah, railway line, trees, mines,
open ground, dried up ponds.
The experiment with community toilets has not been
encouraging. The present study found that community
toilets have been made at six slum settlements.
Amongst these three are being used. The main reason
for non-use of the community toilets is the nonavailability of water (the local body has not installed
water connection).
At three places where the community toilets are being
used their coverage is very small given the size of the
settlement. However what is significant is that the
users are paying for the use of these toilets at Idgah
and Shiv Nagar (see Box) the family is paying Rs 10
per month whereas at Arjun Nagar the user-families
are making efforts to secure water and maintaining the
facility.
Toilets in Institutions
90 per cent of the institutions covered under the
study had functional toilet facilities. These institutions
were well connected with water facility and had
Table 5.1 Status of Conversion of Dry to Flush Type Toilets in Cities Selected for the Study
City
Panagar
Shahpura
Badnagar
80% toilets
9 community toilets
1 Sulabh 15 seater at the
Bus Stand
Tarana
26 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Table 5.2 Private and Community Toilets in Slum Settlements in Cities Selected for the Survey
Name of the Slum
No. Of Houses
Toilets
Jabalpur
Deen Dayal Nagar
600-700
No Toilets
500-600
No Toilets
150
No Toilets
Rajeev Nagar
600
10% Toilets
Muslim Mohalla
100-125
200-250
1600
No Toilets
Community Toilet under construction
750
No Toilets
600
Arjun Nagar
1000
Rahul Nagar
100-125
No Toilets
200-250
Indira Nagar
250
Rajeev Nagar
200-250
247
Bhopal
Ujjain
Sanitation
27
28 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Sanitation
29
Issues in Sanitation
Whose Concern is Sanitation
Private toilets and drainage are the responsibility of
the PHE cell of the urban local body, sewerage network
is the responsibility of the PHE department and SWM
is the responsibility of the Health Department of the
municipal body. In this scenario of multiplicity of
institutions it is difficult to assess the overall body that
has the vision and the resources to draw up a master
plan for sanitation in urban areas. The two primary
questions that need to be addressed are:
(a) How can the agencies come together and develop
a coordinated plan of action?
(b) What are the minimum norms that apply for
sanitation that can be followed by the agencies
responsible for different aspects of sanitation?
Role of Elected Representatives
The interviews with elected representatives in all
the local bodies covered under the study indicated
30 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
Sanitation
31
CHAPTER
Recommendations
The recommendations for the current exercise are
related to the programming interventions for WaterAid
India for urban areas in Madhya Pradesh. There are
two broad set of recommendations: one, that are
city specific interventions; and second, interventions
that relate to WATSAN sector for the urban areas.
The former would include direct interventions for the
city to develop demonstrative models under Water
and Sanitation and the latter would include advocacy
based interventions that seek to have an impact on
the system and its procedures as well as on the policy
related to the sector.
d)
e)
32 Water and Sanitation in Urban Areas of Madhya Pradesh: WaterAid India 2006
The research/views contained in the publication are the sole responsibility of WaterAid India and can
under no circumstances be regarded as reflecting the position of European Union
WaterAid in India
WaterAid began working in India in the latter part of the 1980s with a few small projects and has since
grown in strength and coverage. Today, WaterAid works in more than 10 states with three regional offices
in Bhopal, Bhubaneshwar and Bangalore, in partnership with local NGOs and government departments
and ministries that seek assistance in the specific areas of rural and urban water supply, sanitation
and hygiene promotion. Community sustained improvement in drinking water and sanitation has been
WaterAids watchword in all its programmes.
Different models of community participation and management, of both rural and urban water supply and
sanitation, alternate delivery mechanisms, school hygiene promotion programmes, water conservation
and recharge measures have been demonstrated to the sector. These projects have a strong partnering
component with state governments and departments and have proved to be the inspiration behind successful
replications in other states. A vast array of publications, including training manuals for development workers,
issue sheets and concept papers for advocacy initiatives and IEC material have been jointly developed with
NGO partners and are in wide circulation.
WaterAid has participated in collaborative initiatives with the government and other agencies including the
Water Supply and Sanitation Collaborative Council (WSSCC), the Water and Sanitation Programme (WSP)
of the World Bank, UNICEF and DFID. Alliances are important for core programming concerns of rural and
urban programming for water and sanitation, Integrated Water Resources Management and Networking with
a range of government departments and government organisations, at the national and regional levels in
India. WaterAid India is committed to making its own contribution to the MDG challenge and is open to
exploring ways of partnering with all stakeholders for achieving water and sanitation for all.
WaterAid
India Country Ofce
WaterAid India
1st Floor, Nursery School Building
C-3, Nelson Mandela Marg
Vasant Kunj,
New Delhi - 110070
Tel: 0091-11-46084400
Fax: 0091-11-46084411
Regional Ofces
Regional Ofce East
Plot No. 1266,
Bhoinagar, Unit 9,
Bhubaneswar - 751022
Orissa
Telefax: 0674-2382262