Perinatal Mortality HUKM
Perinatal Mortality HUKM
Perinatal Mortality HUKM
*For reprint and all correspondence: Rosnah Sutan, Department of Community Health, Universiti Kebangsaan
Malaysia Medical Centre, Jalan Yaacob Latif, Bandar Tun Razak, 56000 Cheras, Kuala Lumpur.
Email: [email protected] or [email protected]
ABSTRACT
Accepted
22 February 2013
Introduction
Methods
Results
Conclusions
Keywords
241
INTRODUCTION
The fourth goal of the Millennium Development is
to reduce mortality among children under 5 years
old by two thirds between 1990 and 20151,2.
Worldwide, child mortality between 1980 and 2000
was reduced by one third while the neonatal
mortality rate was reduced by only a quarter 1,2. To
achieve MDG 4 goals, the neonatal mortality must
at least be halved2,3. Neonatal mortality is divided
into early and late neonatal death. Early neonatal
deaths occur during the perinatal period and have
similar obstetric origins as the stillbirth2,3.Reasons
for early neonatal deaths includes severe congenital
malformation, premature delivery, antepartum or
intrapartum obstetric complications (foetal
malpresentation or obstructed labour) or because of
harmful practices after birth that leads to infections
1-3
. Besides, another common adverse outcomes of
pregnancy is stillbirth3,4. It accounts for over half of
all perinatal deaths3. Perinatal period is measured
as completed 22 weeks of gestation and ends seven
days after birth3,4. Stillbirth can occur before onset
of labour (antepartum death) or during labour
(intrapartum death)3,4. Foetuses may die before
onset of labour due to pregnancy complications or
maternal diseases3. Distinguishing between these
two types is important. Through appropriate
intrapartum care, stillborn can be avoided.
Intrapartum death also known as fresh stillbirth
(FSB) refers to normal appearance of foetus after
delivery4. Antepartum death also known as
macerated stillbirth (MSB) refers to macerated
looking skin of foetus and implies that death is
more than 12 hours before delivery4.
Stillbirth and neonatal mortality data are
important health status indicators. In Malaysia, the
government and private hospitals data were
analysed by the Division of Family Health
Development and annual report are then produced.
In addition, data related to SB and NND in
specialist hospitals maybe published via their own
hospitals annual report or discussed during
departmental meeting. Suggestions for ongoing
improvement are then advised to prevent another
death in cases similar to the index case. Therefore,
in an attempt to lower the stillbirth rate, screening
and treatment strategies should be developed to
best suited local scene5 .
Vital and mortality statistics, community
survey or hospital data gives an overall estimation
of the problem. However, each has its own
limitation and underreporting is common. In
Peninsular Malaysia, the percentage of institutional
deliveries increased from 75.6% in 1990 to 96.6%
in 20046 . The antenatal coverage in 2008 was
94.4% as compared to 73.4% in year 2000 6. The
average number of antenatal visits by the pregnant
mother to public and private health facilities
increased from 8.4 in 2005 to 9.6 in 2008 7. This
was even higher than the minimum four antenatal
METHODS
This was a retrospective cross sectional study using
Rapid Reporting of Stillbirth and Neonatal Death
form in UKMMC (PNM 1/97) from year 2004 until
2010. National usage of this form was started since
19988. The format is simple, practical and can be
used without autopsy findings because permission
for autopsy is difficult to obtain in Malaysia due to
cultural and religious beliefs9,10. It is only a
reporting system and not a confidential inquiry
system8,10. The classification used was based on a
modified
pathophysiological
Wigglesworth
classification8,9.
UKMMC is located in Cheras, at the
outskirts of Kuala Lumpur but within Klang Valley
area. Klang valley area is the most populated in
Malaysia. It is an institution providing specialist
healthcare and also acted as referral centre for
places across Malaysia as well as from
neighbouring countries11.
All stillbirths and neonatal deaths reported
by UKMMC from 2004 until 2010 were included
in the study. The data of total births by ethnicity,
parity, gestational age, birth weight were collected
from the monthly census data which was kept in
the census files in Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Department. Data were grouped as maternal
related, and foetal related factor. Maternal related
factors are ethnicity, citizenship, age, parity status,
methods for gestational age estimate, antenatal
clinic follow up and maternal medical illnesses.
Foetal related factors includes place of delivery,
who delivered the cases, plurality of pregnancy,
birth weight and sex of the foetus. Exclusion
criteria were incomplete forms which cannot be
verified further. There were 526 forms collected
and 2 (0.4%) forms were rejected because of
incompleteness. Routinely, the form is filled by
the attending doctor on the delivery day of the
stillborn or on the day of death for the neonate.
In this study, stillbirth is defined as a birth
of a dead foetus of at least 22 weeks of gestation or
weighing at least 500grams12. Early neonatal deaths
were deaths of live born babies during the first
seven completed days after birth, and late neonatal
242
RESULTS
Total deliveries reported in UKMMC from year
2004 to 2010 were 45 277. There were 44,994 live
births, 453 perinatal deaths and 241 neonatal
deaths. Of the perinatal deaths, 283 (54%) were
stillbirths. Out of the stillbirths, 168 (32.1%) were
macerated stillbirths and 115 (21.9%) were fresh
stillbirths. Of the neonatal deaths, 170 (32.3%)
were early deaths and 71 (13.5%) were late
neonatal deaths.
Table 1 shows maternal related factors of
the cases. Majority of the patients were Malay
(88.5 %), with Malaysian citizenship (89.7%), age
more than 35 (79.7%), with multiparity (57.1%)
with 92.7% had antenatal clinic follow-up and
45.9% had specialist clinic follow-up.
SB
N
ND
n
Ethnicity
Malay
Chinese
Indian
Others
336
107
20
7
170
64
14
4
67.5
25.4
5.5
1.6
166
43
6
3
76.1
19.7
2.8
1.4
Citizenship
Yes
No
471
53
252
31
89.0
11.0
219
22
90.9
9.1
Maternal age
< 35
35
403
103
206
62
76.9
23.1
197
41
82.8
17.2
Parity
0
1-4
>5
207
296
15
122
144
12
43.9
51.8
4.3
85
152
3
35.4
63.3
1.3
ANC Follow up
Yes
No
484
37
254
26
90.7
9.3
230
11
95.4
4.6
72
41
14.6
31
11.8
349
180
64.3
169
64.5
1.1
1.2
Place of ANC
follow up
Government Health
Clinic
Hospital
with
specialist
Hospital
without
243
specialist
Private
clinic/hospital
Gestational
age
estimated
Last
menstrual
period
Ultrasound
Neonatal assessment
Unknown
Maternal
medical
illness
Hypertension
Diabetes
Vaginal bleeding
Anemia
Prolonged rupture of
membrane
Preterm labour
Other illness
115
56
20
59
22.5
388
109
3
23
210
53
2
17
74.5
18.8
0.7
6.0
178
56
1
6
73.9
23.2
0.4
2.5
68
33
25
17
37
45
21
16
12
16
13.0
6.1
4.6
3.5
4.6
23
12
9
5
21
9.6
5.0
3.8
2.1
8.8
369
35
210
25
60.9
7.3
159
10
66.5
4.2
at specialist
delivered by
weighing less
male gender
SB
n
ND
n
Gestational age
< 27 W
28- 32 W
33 36 W
> 37 W
147
120
110
109
77
69
64
46
30.0
27.0
25.0
18.0
70
51
46
63
30.4
22.2
20.0
27.4
Place of delivery
Home
Hospital with specialist
Private clinic/hospital
9
487
24
2
265
15
0.7
94.0
5.3
7
222
9
2.9
93.3
3.8
Delivery by
Doctors
Not doctors
475
49
248
35
87.6
12.4
227
14
94.2
5.8
Number of foetus
Singleton
Non singleton
471
50
254
26
90.7
9.3
217
24
90.0
10.0
Birth weight
Less than 2500g
More than 2500g
416
96
229
44
83.9
16.1
187
52
78.2
21.8
244
Sex of baby
Male
Female
Undetermined/unknown
Abbreviations: n, total cases
268
209
17
154
120
9
54.4
42.4
3.2
114
89
8
54.0
42.2
3.8
245
53.5
12.7
100
DISCUSSION
This study shows that stillbirths were the commonest
cause for perinatal deaths in UKMMC. This is
consistent with most studies done in analyzing
perinatal deaths 12,14,15. The stillbirths and neonatal
mortality rates in this study were higher compared to
the figures reported in Annual Report of Stillbirth and
Neonatal Deaths in Malaysia 2003-2006 or from
Department of Statistics, Malaysia 1998-20067. This
discrepancy could be due to deaths from complicated
cases managed in such tertiary referral center. In
addition, different definition of death was used. For
example, the Department of Statistics used 28 week
gestational age as the definition of death12. Another
reason is the differences in method of how notification
form was analyzed in Ministry of Health compared to
specialist hospitals. In public hospitals, the
notifications will eventually be submitted to the
national level whereby the findings will be tabulated
based on the patients residential address categorized
by states. This is because the patient may receive
antenatal care from one state in Malaysia but delivered
eventfully at another state. This differs to this study as
data collected were based on place of death i.e.
UKMMC. Nevertheless, the overall trend of SB rates
was not declining significantly.
Since there was a significant transient decline
in SB rate in 2004-2006, some intervention could have
been taken place prior to the study. Underreporting is
unlikely since notification was done by the respective
ward where death has taken place and it has been
counter check with monthly census.
There was non-significant transient declined
of neonatal mortality from 5.1 in 2004 to 3.3 in 2006.
In UKMMC, the neonatal resuscitation program (NRP)
was implemented in1998. The outcome of the program
was reviewed from 1996 to 2004 and concluded that
NRP was associated with improvement of neonatal
mortality rates16. However, the Malaysian NRP success
has yet to be reviewed since the last study which was
done in 2004. Given the circumstances of transient
significant increment of ND rate from 3.3 in 2006 to
7.7 in 2008, other factors besides the NRP could also
be at fault and further study is warranted. Factors such
as staffing, facilities, intrapartum interventions,
paediatric factors and parental data have been found to
have significant associations 17. However, no published
data available related to any intervention done in
UKMMC to explain this increment.
In developing countries, infection is estimated
to contribute to 25-50% of the stillbirths4,5. This is in
contrast to this study result. As mentioned previously,
NFMSB are the predominant classification (53.2%) of
deaths among stillbirth. This result is similar as
produced by the Report of Stillbirths and Neonatal
Deaths by Ministry of Health Malaysia. Infection as
the classification of death was none in the analysis of
stillbirth category as opposed to 15.1% as the cause of
death in live births. This is because the aim of the
246
2.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
15.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
16.
17.
REFERENCES
1.
247
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
248