tmpD44A TMP
tmpD44A TMP
tmpD44A TMP
The study of mitochondria in living cells has been undertaken using vital dyes and
bright field microscopy, phase contrast optics, video-enhanced differential interference contrast microscopy, and cine micrography (Michaelis, 1900; Lewis & Lewis,
1914; Frederic, 1958; Kacher, Brigman & Arnheiter, 1984) but there has only been
generalised study of placental cells in culture (Lueck & Aladjem, 1980). These
methods have provided interesting information about the distribution and behaviour
of m tochondria in cells (reviewed by Lehninger, 1964; Ernster & Schatz, 1981).
Effective research recently has been directed towards study of the association of
mitochondria with the microtubular cytoskeleton (Ball & Singer, 1982). This progress
has identified a bidirectional mobility of mitochondria that is facilitated by microtubules (Koonce & Schliwa, 1985).
Mitochondrial study has also progressed as a result of the use of the vital
fluorescent dye Rhodamine 123 (Johnson, Walsh & Chen, 1980; Johnson, Walsh,
Bockus & Chen, 1981; Kazuyuki & Murakami, 1984). This permits high definition
microscopy of mitochondria in living cells.
The present experiments were designed to estimate approximate length, distribution and number of mitochondria in cell cultures derived from human placental
tissue in the absence and presence of colchicine, a drug well known for its ability to
cause depolymerisation of cytoplasmic microtubules.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Permanent address: Department of Anatomy, University of Ghana Medical School, PO Box 4236,
Accra, Ghana.
8-2
221
222
.: '4
tT
:.
....
.ov::......
'
i:
223
<
''
0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1
sip
e N ~~*
...aI
A
L
#ge*
i1
f4 *w* w
A~~~
2b
(a) Polarity; the assemblage of strands concentrated at opposite ends ofthe nucleus
(dipolar perinuclear aggregation: Fig. 2), or on one side of the nucleus (unipolar
perinuclear aggregation: Fig. 3).
(b) Parallelism; the strands immediately adjacent to the nuclear envelope usually
lay parallel to it (Fig. 3).
Mitochondria appeared to radiate from the perinuclear aggregates towards the
cell periphery in a tangle of filaments. Hence, the topography of mitochondrial
arrangement was usually ill-defined near the nucleus, but was better revealed in the
224
FIR
.}
A=
.im
.;
...
Fig. 3(a-b). Unipolar (*) arrangement of mitochondria in a Rhodamine 123-stained cell. Note
the loop of a mitochondrion in an adjacent cell (arrow) and the apposition of mitochondria to
the surface of the nucleus. Living cultured human first trimester placenta cells. (a) Phase
contrast. (b) Fluorescence.
peripheral regions of the cells where the mitochondria were less densely packed.
Here mitochondria were generally elongated but were also branched (Fig. 4), curved
(Fig. 4), looped (Fig. 3) and possessed swellings (Fig. 4). Mitochondria commonly
terminated with free endings in the vicinity of the cell membrane (Fig. 5).
Living cultured choriocarcinoma (Be Wo) cells
The distribution of mitochondria in BeWo cells will be described in relation to
that in normal placental cells. A difference in the general organisation of mitochondria was very evident. Particularly noteworthy was the small size and close
225
Fig. 4(a-b). The peripheral regions of two adjoining cells showing branching, curving and
complex topography of mitochondria in a vital dye preparation. The arrowheads indicate
varicosities in the mitochondria. Living cultured human first trimester placenta cells. (a) Phase
contrast. (b) Fluorescence.
packing of these cells compared with the normal ones. The mitochondria, were
visually more slender and less prominent than in cultured placental cells. They were
also apparently shorter. The perinuclear aggregates described in normal cells were
not obvious in BeWo cells. Nuclei of choriocarcinoma cells, like those oftheir normal
relatives, did not stain with the Rhodamine dye. Similarly, they infrequently displayed
strands which lay above or below the nucleus. The mitochondria were diffusely
distributed in BeWo cytoplasm. Superpositioning of phase-dense structures in phase
contrast micrographs and fluorescent strands in epifluorescence micrographs of the
same cell was less striking in choriocarcinoma cultures (Fig. 7). A remarkable
finding was that the tumour cells required twice the exposure time needed by their
normal counterparts for sufficiently bright labelling of mitochondria by Rhodamine
123.
226
_ R"[X~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
|
aa '
F
S.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. -4.,O49-..t
Fig. 5(a-b). The periphery of this vital stained cell is marked by the dotted line. Note the close
approximation of the distal ends of some mitochondria to the cell surface. Varicosities and
branching of mitochondria are apparent. Living cultured human first trimester placenta cells.
(a) Phase contrast. (b) Fluorescence.
227
Fig. 6. Fluorescence micrograph of a living cultured first trimester human placental cell treated
with colchicine (10 sgm/ml) for 3 hours and stained with Rhodamine 123. The positions of
cell nuclei are indicated by an area of absence of stain (n).
15-67 to 8-23 ,um for normal (untreated) cells. These data were obtained from cells
containing 32 and 23 mitochondria respectively. In the colchicine-treated cells, the
mean strand length per cell varied from 9171 ,um (22 mitochondria) to 4 69 #m
(44 mitochondria). Prior to making measurements, the colchicine-treated cells were
paired arbitrarily with untreated (normal) controls to facilitate statistical analyses.
Table 1 shows that in the paired cells examined, the mean lengths of mitochondrial
strands were perceptibly greater in the control cells than in their colchicine-treated
counterparts. In addition, the cell to cell variation in mean strand length was
more marked in normal cells compared with treated pairs. The dispersion of individual strand measurements from the mean length in each cell, as indicated by the
standard deviation (Table 1), showed higher values for controls. This confirmed
subjective observations that mitochondrial filaments were more uniform in length
in colchicine-treated than in normal placental cells. When the colchicine-treated and
untreated cells were compared in terms of the total number of mitochondrial strands
present in each cell (Table 1), appreciably higher numbers were found in treated cells
than in their untreated partners.
Table 1 also shows Student's t values resulting from a statistical comparison of
mean lengths in the random pairs of colchicine-treated and untreated cells. In fifteen
pairs, twelve values were significant at P < 0 01, one at P < 0 05, and only two were
not significant at P < 0 05. An analysis based on the total numbers of mitochondrial
strands per cell yielded a Student's t value of 2-49 with 28 D.F. which was significant
at P < 0-02. Thus the number of strands occurring in each treated cell was statistically greater than in untreated controls. However, a similar comparison of the total
length of mitochondria per cell (mean length x number of strands) gave a t value of
1I 74 that was not significant. This indicated that there was no statistically significant
difference between the total length of mitochondria in colchicine-treated cells and
their normal untreated controls.
228
'
C.'
o~
9-
0
4
a
WI
I.
en
in
N~~
~m
en
6~~o
00
on
co v
n
041
0%0~~~0
'A
e-4
0%
00
"3
('
0e.
('o00
A4
'
('I
".
<>o 6
a"
1a
&
*O
.0
o4
en300_
4i
0
0
u
00
m0
r0P
dN
en
u
4.0
el..
.l
?'3}
00
N.
N.
*H q
00
en3
S.E
Oo
o0
(.4
FQ
"-
iM.q
_A
-1
A.
*6~~
4)
, %>g
t*MeX~~01
:,.",;
*.,
'R
s
t!
lo
00
f
co
o% 0
40
at .0 t$U( %0
lS W
N00
u o"
2I]n
1 Xn |] i79
N01
N0
NWI
l1
|
Po
'4
00
~00
00
C"
'
v
t
10%
N~~~~~~~~c
00
0%
~0
10%
:8~ ~ ~ 0 e
00 ~ ~~~~0
~~~~~~Z~~~~~~o
229
230
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.
5:
ik-S
Fig. 7(a-b). Choriocarcinoma (BeWo) cells vital stained with Rhodamine 123 show less
organisation of mitochondria than the first trimester human placental cells. (a) Phase contrast.
(b) Fluorescence.
DISCUSSION
Mitochondrial distribution
The results show that disruption of the mic-rotubular cytoskeleton leads to reorganisation of the mitochondria, indicating that mitochondria are associated with
microtubules.
The action of colchicine is interpreted as being mediated by its effect on microtubules (Dustin, 1978). Colchicine, however, is also known to affect other cellular
activities (Weatherbee, 1981) such as inhibition of nucleoside transport (Mizel &
Wilson, 1972), partial inhibition of protein synthesis (Creasy, Bensch & Malawista,
1971) and inhibition of fluid transport by membranes (Beebe, Feagans, BlanchetteMackie & Nau, 1979). There is a variety of reasons why these latter effects are not
likely to be important in the present context; perhaps the most convincing is the
231
finding that rotenone, also a microtubule inhibitor (Brinkley, Barham, Barranco &
Fuller, 1974; Ketelbant-Balasse & Neve, 1976; Dustin, 1978), but apparently without
the other effects on cells which colchicine might inflict, also changes mitochondrial
distribution in a similar fashion (Johnson et al. 1981). Further evidence is that
lumicolchicine, an ultraviolet light derivative of colchicine, which is inactive in
preventing microtubule assembly yet as active as colchicine in inhibition of nucleoside transport (Dustin, 1978), has been found by Johnson et al. (1980) to have no
effect on mitochondria revealed by Rhodamine 123 staining. Recent experiments
(F. K. Addai, unpublished observations), have indicated similar conclusions in the
chorionic villus culture system.
Prior to treatment, at least some of the mitochondria extend out to the periphery
of the cells where they may be associated with the cell surface. This type of distribution is also seen in microtubules (Ockleford, Dearden & Badley, 1984). The pattern
of disassembly of microtubules in cultured cells usually leads to shorter microtubules
based on more centrally localised microtubule organising centres from which they
grow out afresh during recovery. It is, therefore, very interesting to note that after
treatment of cells with antimicrotubular drugs the location of the mitochondria is
more central. Here, it may be of interest also to point out the possibility that the
uni/dipolar patterns of mitochondria observed in untreated human placental cells
may reflect the presence of either one or two organising centres (centrioles and
associated materials) which replicate as the cell cycle proceeds. Again on this point,
it is known that there are multiple microtubule organising centres in BeWo cells
(Ockleford et al. 1984) and in this location mitochondrial unipolar and dipolar
patterns are not distinguishable. There is, therefore, in the results of these experiments further confirmation of the suggested structural link between microtubules and
mitochondria.
The close association noted above (Figs. 2-4, 7) between mitochondria and nuclear
envelope is an intriguing one. Questions arise as to what are the functional significances of this association. Is the mitochondrion, which is a genetically inadequate
organelle (Tribe, Morgan & Whittaker, 1981), receiving informational macromolecules from the nucleus? Or amongst other possibilities, are these associated
mitochondria providing energy-rich substrates required for trans-nuclear envelope
transport processes? Another possibility suggested by Lehninger (1964) is that the
association reflects a biogenetic link between mitochondria and the nuclear envelope.
It is remarkable that the intracellular origin of mitochondria is still not understood.
232
233
BERNAL, S. D., LAMPIDIs, T. J., SUMMERHAYES, I. C. & CHEN, L. B. (1982). Rhodamine 123 selectively
reduces clonal growth of carcinoma cells in vitro. Science 218, 1117-1119.
BERNAL, S. D., LAmIDIs, T. J., McIsAAc, R. M. & CHEN, L. B. (1983). Anti-carcinoma activity in vivo of
rhodamine 123, a mitochondrial-specific dye. Science 222 (4620), 169-172.
BRINKLEY, B. R., BARHAM, S. S., BARRANCO, S. V. & FULLER, G. M. (1974). Rotenone inhibition of
spindle microtubule assembly in mammalian cells. Experimental Cell Research 85, 41-46.
CREsy, W. A., BENscH, K. G. & MALAWISTA, S. E. (1971). Colchicine, vinblastine and griseofulvin.
Pharmacological studies with human leucocytes. Biochemical Pharmacology 20, 1579-1588.
Dusr, P. (1978). Microtubules, pp. 8452. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer-Verlag.
ERNSTER, L. & SCHATZ, G. (1981). Mitochondria: an historical review. Journal of Cell Biology 91,
227-255s.
FRmmuc, J. (1958). Cytobiological research on the chondriome of cells in culture under normal and
experimental conditions. Archives de biologie 69, 167-349.
HAnm, T., MUNCK, J., FOURCADE, A. & LAMPIs, T. J. (1984). Cross-resistance to rhodamine 123 in
adriamycin-resistant and daunorubicin-resistant Friend leukaemia cell variants. Cancer Research 44
(12 Pt. 1), 5544-5549.
JAws, T. W. & BOHMAN, R. J. (1981). Proliferation of mitochondria during the cell cycle of the human
cell line (HL-60). Journal of Cell Biology 88, 256-260.
JOHNSON, L. V., WALSH, M. L. & CEN, L. B. (1980). Localisation of mitochondria in living cells with
rhodamine 123. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the U.S.A. 77, 990-994.
JOHNSON, L. V., WALSH, M. L., BOCKuS, B. J. & CHEN, L. B. (1981). Monitoring of relative mitochondrial
membrane potential in living cells by fluorescence microscopy. Journal of Cell Biology 88, 526-535.
KACHAR, B., BRIuMAN, P. C. & ARNHuTER, H. (1984). Movement and plasticity of mitochondria in
cultured cells. Journal of Cell Biology 99, 49a.
KAzUyui, T. & MuRAKAm, K. (1984). Reduction in mitochondrial membrane potential of Toxoplasma
gondil after invasion of host cells. Journal of Cell Science 70, 73-82.
KEELBANT-BALAS, P. & NEVE, P. (1976). New ultrastructural features of the cream hamster thyroid
with special reference to the second kind of follicle. Cell and Tissue Research 166, 49-63.
KOONCE, M. P. & SCHLIWA, M. (1985). Bidirectional organelle transport can occur in cell processes that
contain single microtubules. Journal of Cell Biology 100, 322-326.
LmIDIs, T. J., BERNAL, S. D., SUMMERHAYEs, I. C. & CHEN, L. B. (1983). Selective toxicity of rhodamine
123 in carcinoma cells in vitro. Cancer Research 43 (2), 716-720.
LEHNINGER, A. L. (1964). The Mitochondrion: Mokcular Basis of Structure and Function, pp. 1-263.
New York and Amsterdam: Benjamin Inc.
LEWis, M. R. & LEWis, W. H. (1914). Mitochondria (and other cytoplasmic structures) in tissue cultures.
American Journal of Anatomy 17, 339-401.
LoKE, Y. W. (1983). Human trophoblast in culture, in Biology of Trophoblast (ed. Y. W. Loke &A. Whyte),
pp. 663-701. Amsterdam: Elsevier North Holland Science Publishers.
LOKE, Y. W. & BORLAND, R. (1970). Immunofluorescent localisation of chorionic gonadotrophin in
monolayer cultures of human trophoblast cells. Nature 228, 561-562.
LUECK, J. & ALADJEM, S. (1980). Time-lapse study of normal human trophoblast in vitro. American
Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 138, 288-292.
MICHAELIS, L. (1900). Die vitale Farbung eine Darstellungsmethode der Zellgranula. Archiv far mikroskopische Anatomie 55, 558-575.
MIZEL, S. B. & WILON, L. (1972). Nucleoside transport in mammalian cells. Inhibition by colchicine.
Biochemistry 11, 2537-2578.
OCKLEFORD, C. D., DEARDEN, L. & BADLEY, R. A. (1984). Syncytioskeletons in choriocarcinoma in
culture. Journal of Cell Science 66, 1-20.
SUMMERHAYES, I. C., LAMPIDIS, T. J., BERNAL, S. D., NADAKAvuKAREN, J., NADAKAVUKAREN, K. K.,
SHEPHERD, E. L. & CHEN, L. B. (1982). Unusual retention of rhodamine 123 by mitochondria in muscle
and carcinoma cells. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the U.S.A. 79, 5292-5296.
TANPHAICHITR, N., CHEN, L. B. & BELLVE, A. R. (1984). Direct effect of gossypol TR-ST cells: perturbation of rhodamine 123 accumulation in mitochondria. Biology of Reproduction 31, 1049-1060.
TRIBE, M. A., MORGAN, A. J. & WHrIrAKER, P. A. (1981). The Evolution of Eucaryotic Cells, p. 23.
London: Edward Arnold.
WATHERBEE, J. A. (1981). Membranes and cell movement: interactions of membranes with proteins of
the cytoskeleton. In International Review of Cytology, Suppl. 12 (ed. A. L. Muggleton-Harris), pp. 113176. New York and London: Academic Press.