Approaches Report On Reading

Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2

LANGUAGE EXPERIENCE APPROACH (LEA)

The Language Experience Approach (LEA) is an effective method to help


promote literacy development. The basic premise of the method is that an effective
way to help students learn to read is through their own words. Students relate an
experience and a scribe (teacher, tutor, parent or more knowledgeable student) writes
down what they say. The transcription is then used as a literacy source. For example,
students retell group experiences such as a field trip, a science experiment, a story, or
a project in which they all participated. Since LEA is based on personal experiences
and are told by students, they provide highly meaningful and comprehensible reading
materials. Applications of LEA can be used with many different kinds of activities
and are applicable for all proficiency levels.

Basal reader approach


A basal reader is a collection of stories, poems and other text written at a specific reading
level. Basal readers are used to teach children reading in a systematic way.

Advantages of the Basal Reader Approach


A sequenced curriculum of instruction is provided by grade level
A continuous arrangement of instructional skills and concepts from
grade to grade is supplied
To save teachers time, a completely prepared set of stories,
instructional directions and activities, practice materials, and
assessment tools is available
Student texts are arranged in ascending difficulty
Reading skills are gradually introduced and systematically reviewed
Teachers are provided lesson plans
Students are exposed to a variety of literary genres
Organization and structure of basal readers are helpful to beginning
teachers just learning about the reading curriculum
A variety of beginning reading texts are typically available, including
trade books libraries, big books, leveled books, and decodable books
Organization and structure of basal reading programs are reassuring to
administrators that important reading skills are being taught

Limitations of the Basal Reader Approach


Some new decodable and leveled selections are dull and repetitious
Cropping illustrations from original childrens trade books are less
engaging
Skill instruction is rarely applied or related to decoding the text or
comprehending the selections content
The lesson design often fails to relate one part of the lesson, such as
vocabulary introduction, to subsequent parts of the lesson, such as
comprehension discussion
Stories often do not relate to students interests
Format of hard bound thick book is not as appealing as trade books
that are soft and thin
Teachers editions seldom contain useful directions on how to
teach/model reading comprehension strategies
A rigid adherence to the basal reader leaves little room for teacher
creativity and decision making
Use of this approach has traditionally been associated with the use of
round robin reading and ability grouping.
Censorship by special interest groups leads to the selection of content
that contain little real subject matter content, that deals with few reallife applications, or that presents little content that advocates ethical
living in society
Steps of the Basal Reading Lesson
1. Activate prior knowledge and building background
2. Skill lessons on phonics, spelling, vocabulary, and comprehension
3. Previewing and predicting
4. Setting the purpose
5. Guiding the reading
6. Confirm predictions
7. Comprehension discussion questions
8. Skill instruction and practice in oral language, writing, grammar,
phonics, handwriting, comprehension, and fluency
9. Enrichment ideas and projects
Teaching Children to Read: Putting the Pieces Together by Ray Reutzel
and Robert Cooter (2004).

You might also like