Planning and Conducting Audita
Planning and Conducting Audita
Planning and Conducting Audita
During recurring audits, the auditor may decide not to send a new engagement letter each period. According to the
standard, the following factors may make it appropriate to revise the terms of the audit engagement or to remind the
entity of existing terms:
Any indication that the entity misunderstands the objective and scope of the audit
Any revised or special terms of the audit engagement
A recent change of senior management
A significant change in ownership
A significant change in nature or size of the entitys business
A change in legal or regulatory requirements
A change in the financial reporting framework adopted in the preparation of the financial statements
Materiality
The auditor is required to determine three different level of materiality. These are
1. Materiality for the financial statements as a whole (overall materiality) the materiality determined at the
overall financial statement level. This materiality level helps auditor determine whether the proposed audit
adjustments are significant or not. If the audit adjustments exceed this level, the auditor may need to adjust
the financial statements
2. Performance Materiality (scoping materiality) calculated as a certain percentage of overall materiality, is
used in scoping of financial statement line items to be tested by the auditor. This will ensure that significant
accounts in the financial statements are covered by audit testing
3. Specific Materiality is the amount set by the auditor for particular classes of transactions, account balances
or disclosures for which misstatements, well though lower than overall materiality could reasonably be
expected to influence the economic decisions of users of the financial statements
The following factors are normally considered by the auditor in determining the appropriate benchmark for the
purpose of calculating overall materiality:
Components of the entitys financial statements
Focus of the users of the financial statements
Nature of the entity
Ownership structure of the entity
Volatility of the benchmark identified
Laws and regulations
Risks Assessment Procedures
Performed to obtain an understanding of the entity and its environment, including the entitys internal control, to
identify and assess the risks of material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, at the financial statement and
assertion level
Includes:
1. Inquiries of management and of others within the entity who in the auditors judgement may have
information that is likely to assist in identifying risks of material misstatement due to fraud or error
2. Analytical procedures
3. Observation and inspection
Steps in an Auditors Consideration of Internal Control
1. Perform a preliminary review of the internal control system***
2. Document the internal control system
3. Perform a walk through test
4. Identify cycle control objectives and control procedures
5. Perform tests of controls
6. Assess control risk
NO
N/A
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
QUESTIONNAIRE
Are purchases of goods or services executed based on appropriate written
authorization?
Are prenumbered purchase orders used to account for all orders?
Do the written authorizations such as purchase orders indicate the quantities,
description, prices and other terms of the orders?
Does the company account for the sequence of prenumbered purchase orders?
Are copies of purchase orders forwarded to the requisitioning, receiving, and
accounts payable departments for subsequent control?
Are lists of approved vendors, current prices, specifications, and terms made
available to purchasing department personnel?
Are goods received physically inspected and counted at the time of their receipt?
Are prenumbered receiving documents prepared in recording all goods and
services accepted?
Does the company account for the sequence of prenumbered receiving
documents?
Are prenumbered purchase orders periodically matched with receiving documents
to identify unmatched (undelivered) orders?
Are receiving department personnel independent of purchasing, accounts
payable, and cash disbursements?
Are all vendors invoices received accounted for by logging, numbering, or other
means to ensure that all goods and services received are recognized as liabilities?
Are all vendors invoices matched with purchase orders and receiving documents
by persons other than those who prepare purchase orders and receiving
documents?
Are control totals established for posting to control accounts before vendors
invoices are forwarded to subsidiary ledger clerks?
Does the company require verification of footings and cross footings of invoices by
persons other than those who prepare purchase orders and receiving documents?
Are adjustments to accounts payable properly documented?
Are the persons who maintain the subsidiary records other than those who check
or approve accounts payable documents or maintain the control account?
Are accounts payable subsidiary ledger records periodically reconciled with
control account in the general ledger by persons other than those who:
a. Maintain the subsidiary records?
b. Maintain the control account?
c. Prepare checks?
d. Have custody of signed checks?
Are vendors statements of accounts periodically reconciled with subsidiary
records by persons other than those who:
a. Maintain the subsidiary records?
b. Maintain the control account?
c. Prepare checks?
d. Have custody of signed checks?
Are checks prepared only on the basis of an approved voucher package?
Are the persons who prepare checks other than those who prepared checks other
than those who initiate or approve documents which give rise to cash
disbursements?
Are the check signers other than those who approve accounts payable or invoices
for payment?
Do the check signers review supporting documentation prior to signing checks?
Are supporting documentation perforated, voided, or otherwise cancelled
immediately after checks are signed? (Or are they placed under the control of
signatories to prevent re use?)
Are signed checks forwarded or mailed directly to payees without returning to
them those who processed the disbursement?
Are unissued and spoiled checks properly safeguarded?
Are the adequate controls over the custody and use of mechanical check signer
and signature plates?
Are the payees, amounts, and dates of recorded disbursements compared with
entries in the bank statement and with paid checks and other documents
supporting the bank statement?
Is the coding used to post cash disbursements to the general ledger adequately
checked?
Are summaries of cash disbursements prepared for posting to the general ledger?
YES
NO
N/A
periodic reconciliation should be performed by persons other those who maintain the accounts
receivable records (general and subsidiary ledgers), account for billing documents and debit/credit
memos, or those involved in the cash receipts function
Periodic (e.g., monthly) statements of accounts should be sent to customers. Exceptions noted by
customers should be promptly investigated
Periodic review of customers accounts with credit balances
Preparation of accounts receivable aging schedule
Identification of worthless accounts for write offs
Periodic review of the adequacy of valuation allowances such as bad debts, returns, and discounts
Adequate written procedures for accounting function
FUNCTION: CASH RECEIPTS
CONTROL OBJECTIVES:
All cash receipts should be immediately recorded upon receipt and deposited intact in bank
All cash receipts should be accurately entered in the accounting records
POTENTIAL ERRORS OR IRREGULARITIES:
Cash receipts could be misappropriated
Delays in recording cash receipts
FINANCIAL STATEMENT COMPONENTS AFFECTED:
Misstatement of cash, accounts receivable, and receivables from employees
SPECIFIC CONTROL PROCEDURES:
Use of prenumbered official receipts and accounting for its completeness
Preparation of a list of cash receipts at the time of receipt
Restrictive endorsement of checks received
Establishment of control totals for posting to control accounts before cash receipts documents are
routed to accounts receivable subsidiary ledgers clerk
Comparison of actual amount received with the initial cash receipts record
Comparison of cash receipts record with bank validated deposit slips, cash receipts book, and bank
statements
Adequate written procedures for cash receipts function
SALES RETURNS AND ALLOWANCES
CONTROL OBJECTIVES:
Goods being returned are properly inspected before acceptance
Goods returned are recorded at the time of receipt
POTENTIAL ERRORS OR IRREGULARITIES:
Customers may be given credit for goods returned but were not received
Damaged merchandised may be included in inventories at its original cost
Unrecorded returns
Goods returned in the current period may not be included in the inventory count
FINANCIAL STATEMENT COMPONENT AFFECTED:
Misstatement of accounts receivable, sales returns and allowances, and inventories
SPECIFIC CONTROL PROCEDURES:
The description, condition, and quantity of goods returned should be checked at the time of receipt
Use of prenumbered receiving reports and credit/debit memos
Accounting for the numerical sequence of receiving reports and debit/ credit memos follow up of
missing documents. A designated official should review and approve the results of follow up
procedures done.
Receiving reports should be matched with debit/credit memos
Check the validity of vendors invoices; quantities and prices billed should be compared with
receiving reports and purchase orders
Verify the accuracy of vendors invoices
A designated official should review and approved vendors invoices before they are recorded as
accounts payable
There should be periodic comparison of recorded balances with budgeted amounts and with those of
prior periods
The subsidiary records should be maintained by a person who neither approves disbursement
documents nor maintains the control account
There should be periodic reconciliation of subsidiary records with control account balance and with
suppliers statements of accounts
The validity of amounts and quantities shown on vendors credit memos should be checked by
comparing them with records of goods returned and original purchase invoices; extensions and
footings of credit and debit memos should be adequately checked
There should be adequate written documentation of procedures for processing and recording
vendors invoices
FUNCTION: CASH DISBURSEMENT
CONTROL OBJECTIVES:
All cash disbursement should be promptly and accurately recorded
All cash disbursement should be authorized, based on recorded liabilities
Access to cash should be limited to authorized company personnel
POTENTIAL ERRORS OR IRREGULARITIES:
Cash may be misappropriated by making fraudulent payments
FINANCIAL STATEMENT COMPONENTS AFFECTED:
Misstatement of assets, liabilities, expenses, losses from fraud, and income
SPECIFIC CONTROL PROCEDURES:
Use of and accounting for prenumbered checks and vouchers
Details of recorded cash disbursements such as payees, dates, check numbers, and amounts should
be compared with paid checks and bank statement
Follow up of missing checks and vouchers
Establish control totals for posting to control account prior to posting to subsidiary records.
Checks should be prepared based on approved voucher package
Company officials designated as check signers should review disbursement documents before
signing checks. Dual signatures should be required for disbursements involving unusually large
amounts
Disbursement documents should be stamped PAID, perforated, or voided to prevent re use
Adequate control over access to blank, used and spoiled checks
There should be adequate control over access to check signing equipment and signature plates
There should be adequate documentation of procedures for processing cash disbursements
The following procedures may help an auditor determine if the control policy or procedure is suitably designed to
prevent or detect misstatements and if it is functioning effectively:
1. Inquiries of appropriate personnel
2. Inspection of documents and records
3. Observation of the application of a specific internal control policy or procedure
In addition to the foregoing, an auditor may reperform a specific control procedure. These tests of controls should
provide evidence that will enable an auditor to answer the following questions:
1. Were the control procedures performed?
2. How were they performed?
3. Who performed the procedure?
TYPICAL TESTS OF CONTROLS FOR THE REVENUE/RECEIPT CYCLE ARE LISTED BELOW:
SALES
1. Obtain specimen signatures of officers who approve transactions, like:
a. Credit manager
b. Sales manager
c. Storekeeper
d. Shipping or delivery department manager
2. Obtain specimen initials of persons who double check the:
a. Sales invoices
b. Delivery receipts or bills of lading
3. Check the file copies for completeness of the numerical sequence of:
a. Sales orders
b. Charge sales invoices
c. Cash sales invoices
d. Delivery receipts
e. Credit memos
4. Select a sample of recorded sales invoices, and:
a. Check arithmetical accuracy
b. Trace to corresponding shipping documents
c. Test pricing by reference to official price list
d. Check approval for:
i. Credit
ii. Terms
e. Compare details with approved customer orders like merchandise specifications, price,
quantity, credit period, discounts, etc.
f. Trace postings to customers subsidiary ledgers
g. Check entries for promptness and accuracy
5. Select a sample of sales invoices, and:
a. Trace to sales register
b. Trace postings to customers subsidiary ledgers
c. Look for the initials of the person who double checked the accuracy of sales invoices
6. Select a sample of delivery receipts or bills of lading, and;
a. Trace to corresponding sales invoices
b. Compare with customers orders
c. Trace postings to stock cards and inventory records
d. Look for the initials of the person who double checked the accuracy of delivery receipts
7. Select a sample entries in the subsidiary ledger and trace to:
a. Corresponding sales invoices
b. Entries in the sales register
8. Check footings and cross footings of sales register and trace postings to the general ledger
9. Observe proper segregation of duties
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE
1. Select a sample of postings in the subsidiary ledger, and:
a. Trace to cash receipts register
b. Trace to debit/credit memo register
2. Reverse the procedures in no. 1
3. Check for evidence showing monthly reconciliation of the subsidiary ledger balances with the control
account in the general ledger
4. Scan and investigate any unusual items
5. Determine if write offs and other adjustments are properly documented and authorized
6. Observe proper segregation of duties
SALES RETURNS AND ALLOWANCES
1. Select sample of credit memos and trace to:
a. Entries in the debit/credit memo register
b. Corresponding receiving report
2. Reverse the procedures in no. 1
3. Select sample of credit memos and;
a. Review for proper approval
b. Check pricing and arithmetical accuracy
4. Check footings and cross footings of debit/credit memos register and trace postings to the general
ledger
5. Observe proper segregation of duties
CASH RECEIPTS
1. Select a sample of postings in the subsidiary ledger, and:
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
TYPICAL TESTS OF CONTROLS FOR THE PURCHASING/DISBURSEMENT CYCLE ARE LISTED BELOW:
PURCHASES
1. Obtain specimen signatures of officers who approve transactions, like:
a. Sales manager
b. Purchasing manager
c. Storekeeper
d. Check signatories
2. Obtain specimen initials of persons who double check the:
a. Purchase requisitions
b. Purchase orders
c. Price canvassing
d. Suppliers sales invoices
e. Suppliers delivery receipts
f. Items at minimum balances
3. Check the file copies for completeness of the numerical sequence of:
a. Purchase requisitions
b. Purchase orders
c. Receiving reports
d. Debit memos
e. Notice of defective goods
4. Select a sample of recorded purchases, and:
a. Check arithmetical accuracy
b. Trace to corresponding receiving reports
c. Trace details to corresponding purchase orders
d. Check entries for promptness and accuracy
e. Trace postings to suppliers subsidiary ledger
5. Select a sample of suppliers sales invoices, and:
a. Trace to purchase register
b. Look for the initials of the person who double checked the accuracy of invoices
c. Trace postings to suppliers subsidiary ledger
6. Select a sample of receiving reports, and;
a. Trace to corresponding suppliers sales invoices
b. Compare with purchase orders
c. Trace postings to stock cards and inventory records
d. Look for the initials of the person who double checked the accuracy of receiving reports
7. Check footings and cross footings of purchases register
8. Check postings to the general ledger
9. Observe proper segregation of duties
ACCOUNTS PAYABLE
1. Select a sample of postings in the subsidiary ledger, and:
a. Trace to Suppliers sales invoices
a. Trace to check register
b. Trace to debit/credit memo register
c. Trace to purchase register
2. Reverse the procedures in no. 1
3. Check for evidence showing monthly reconciliation of the subsidiary ledger balances with the control
account in the general ledger
4. Scan and investigate any unusual items
5. Determine if adjustments are properly documented and authorized
6. Observe proper segregation of duties
PURCHASE RETURNS AND ALLOWANCES
1. Select sample of debit memos and trace to:
The degree of subjectivity involved in the evaluation of the audit evidence gathered by the internal
auditors in support of the relevant assertions
e) To determine the adequacy of specific work performed by the internal auditors for the external auditors
purposes, the external auditor shall evaluate whether:
The work was performed by internal auditors having adequate technical training and proficiency
The work was properly supervised, reviewed and documented;
Adequate audit evidence has been obtained to enable the internal auditors to draw reasonable
conclusions;
Conclusions reached are appropriate in the circumstances and any reports prepared by the internal
auditors are consistent with the results of the work performed; and
Any exceptions or unusual matters disclosed by the internal auditors are properly resolved.
USING THE WORK OF AN AUDITORS EXPERT
AUDITORS EXPERT
An individual or organization possessing expertise in a field other than accounting or auditing, whose work
in that field is used by the auditor to assist the auditor in obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence
An auditors expert may assist the auditor in:
Obtaining an understanding of the entity and its environment, including its internal control
Identifying and assessing the risks of material misstatement
Determining and implementing overall responses to assessed risks at the financial statements level
Designing and performing further audit procedures
Evaluating the sufficiency and appropriateness of audit evidence
When planning to use the work of an auditors expert, the auditor shall evaluate the competence, capability
and objectivity of the auditors expert
The auditor shall obtain sufficient understanding of the field of the expertise of the auditors expert to enable
the auditor to:
Determine the nature, scope and objectives of that experts work for the auditors purposes
Evaluate the adequacy of that work for the auditors purposes
The auditor shall agree, in writing when appropriate, on the following matters with the auditors expert :
The nature, scope and objectives of that experts work
The respective roles and responsibilities of the auditor and that expert
The nature, timing and extent of communication between the auditor and that expert, including the
form of any report to be provided by that expert
The need for the auditors expert to observe confidentiality requirements
The auditor shall evaluate the adequacy of the auditors expert work for the auditors purposes, including:
The relevance and reasonableness of that experts findings or conclusions, and their consistency
with other audit evidence
If that experts work involve used of significant assumptions and methods in the circumstances
If that experts work involves the use of source data that is significant to that experts work, the
relevance, completeness, and accuracy of that source data.
If the auditor determines that the work of the auditors expert is not adequate for the auditors purposes, the
auditor shall:
Agree with that expert on the nature and extent of further work to be performed that expert
Perform additional audit procedures appropriate to the circumastances