ISJ034
ISJ034
ISJ034
Fair
value?
Mark-to-market
in a volatile world
Payments - Asia
Fund Administration - Japan
In Focus - Collateral Thinking
•R
ule Financial’s tri-party expertise is helping our clients navigate the changing financial
landscape. As collateralised lending supersedes unsecured, it’s crucial to retain full visibility
and control over your tri-party book.
•O
ur tri-party product provides a full, global picture across all tri-party agents: vital
intelligence for front, middle and back offices. Basel II compliance becomes achievable
and capital obligations shrink accordingly. Tri-party growth can be safely accelerated, new
agents integrated seamlessly and assets optimised.
•R
ead more now at www.rulefinancial.com about how Rule is accelerating and simplifying
the benefits of tri-party dealing. Our latest service summary on tri-party interfaces is also
available for free download.
Rule Financial is the UK’s leading independent provider of business consulting, change
management, IT services and complex technology to the investment banking community.
We employ over 200 people and count many of the world’s foremost financial institutions
on both sides of the Atlantic among our clients. To learn more please contact our Marketing
Department: [email protected]
Rule Financial
101 Moorgate, London EC2M 6SL
Tel: 020 7826 4444
www.rulefinancial.com
ISJ | Investor Services Journal Editor’s Letter
P.14 CEO Profile P.25 Benelux Custody P.32 Panel Debate P.42 Japan
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56
News
BNP Paribas’ assets under 7%
custody in Benelux in 9% The last month of updates in
June 2008 by country custody, clearing and settlement,
percentage. securities lending, legal and
Source: BNP Paribas 84% compliance and technology.
Ben Roberts - Editor Catherine Kemp - Reporter Giles Turner - Group Editor
Belgium 9% | Luxembourg 84% | Netherlands 7 [email protected]
[email protected] [email protected]
Contributors:
Joe Corcos
Editor’s letter been their familiarity with
Brian Bollen
Anthony Harrington
The billions spent on the territory and long-
financial restructure in many standing customers. The
Associate publisher:
Justin Lawson currencies around the world, Benelux region is a notable
E: [email protected]
Publishing manager: coupled with widespread example of this: despite
Monique Labuschagne
E: [email protected]
interest rate cuts among an array of opinions from
Account managers: national banks and the industry experts concerning
Craig McCartney
E: [email protected] ECB, have provided more the service benefits of the
Tarik Rekiouak
E: [email protected]
questions than answers as global-versus-local custodian,
David Valenzise to the outlook, attitude and ISJ encountered a greater
E: [email protected]
culture of the companies that sway towards a shrinking
Operations manager:
Sue Whittle have apparently benefited. circle of large players (see
E: [email protected]
Designer:
The future for structured this month’s feature on the
David Copsey products, bi-party trading region, page 25). The reasons meets the respective CEO
[email protected]
agreements, rating agencies for this forecast included the and chairman. On the other
Commercial director:
Jon Hewson
and trader monitoring are all bigger banks’ sophistication side of the world, Japan’s
[email protected] under the microscope, with in servicing esoteric assets traditionally insulated funds
CEO: the regulators and the world and their ability to provide industry has allowed a few
Mark Latham
[email protected] media turning the lens to get the full suite of services. global banks to develop local
Investor Intelligence
the situation in focus. But if the oligarchy of roots as its pension funds
16-17 Little Portland Street, As a result, securities global custodians offering diversifies – turn to page 42.
London W1W 8BP
T: +44 (0) 20 7299 7700 services across the board a similar breadth of service Japan is a key element
F: +44 (0) 20 7636 6044
W: www.ISJ.tv
are at the cusp of a new era. becomes the norm, the in our other Asian focus,
Bank consolidations – seen question becomes: what as Anthony Harrington
© 2008 Investor Intelligence
All rights reserved. recently in many countries, will be the new value-added explores the possibility of a
No part of this publication may
be reproduced, in whole or in both amicable and hostile - services? pan-regional payment and
part, without prior written
permission from the publishers.
can create new combinations Mergers, challenges settlement system. Can the
of expertise in the rebranded and innovation are also countries come to a decision;
ISSN 1744-151X.
Printed in the UK by Pensord Press. conglomerates, and highlighted this issue in is Asia’s uneven financial
occasionally monopolies. fund administration. Equity landscape a hindrance?
In custody, global players Trust, an opportunistic buyer Find out inside. ■
are strengthening their historically, recently sealed
position in small markets to a deal with Custom House Ben Roberts
challenge the local players to create a USD50 billion
whose key selling point had enterprise. Giles Turner
Contents
News Custody
Custody-Depositary / Trustee
Fund Administration
Corporate Trust
CACEIS benefits from an S&P AA- rating
www.caceis.com
Dear ISJ
Custody Legal and compliance measurement solution to assist LONDON - Barclays Capital has
its fund managers with their signed a contract to purchase
investment administration Caplin Trader - a web based
GERMANY - It is understood that LONDON – Standard & Poor’s, application platform, to be
BHF Bank – the private bank the financial market intelligence Eagle, a financial services used in Barclays’ Fixed Income
owned by Sal. Oppenheim – is provider, launched its Fixed technology and The Bank of eCommerce offering.
looking to spin off its custody Income Risk Management New York Mellon subsidiary, will
and Depotbank service offering Services (FIRMS) business. allow Axial to quickly and easily LONDON - Alberta Investment
into a separate entity. calculate returns in different Management Corporation
FIRMS’ capabilities include: formats and can consolidate (AIMCo), the Canadian
LONDON - The National market research and data from multiple sources to investment manager, has
Association of Pension Funds commentary on cross-market create different views of data chosen SimCorp Dimension an
(NAPF) has launched the final and cross-asset class valuations across its business. integrated, enterprise-level
version of its 16 Best Practice and relationships in complex tool that provides front, middle,
Principles on investment structured products; credit LONDON - BT now provides and back office solutions for the
advice to pension funds. The ratings information and data resilient connectivity to NYSE investment managers.
Principles - endorsed by 12 major distribution and insight through Euronext through the new
consultancies - are a key part of RatingsDirect; real-time Secured Financial Transaction Vantage Reporting, the provider
the NAPF’s Assessing Investment coverage of the leveraged loan Infrastructure® (SFTI®) to private investment firms,
Consultants Performance toolkit primary and secondary markets; network’s hubs in London and changed its name to Vantage
designed to help pension fund company cross-tagging of global Paris. This gives customers Software, reflecting the
trustees evaluate and compare identifiers, reference data, access to the new Universal company’s focus on delivering
investment consultancies on a counterparties and securities; Trading Platform that will out-of-the-box products
more consistent basis. credit risk models and solutions, support Euronext Cash Equities, implemented with or without
and independent securities Liffe Market Data and Trading customisation. David Sayles has
NEW YORK - The Bank of New evaluations for cash fixed through the Radianz Shared joined Vantage as director of
York Mellon was selected by the income and structured finance Market Infrastructure that sales and client service.
U.S. Department of the Treasury instruments offering, through connects users to the global
to support the government’s Standard & Poor’s Securities community of trading-related
Clearing
Troubled Asset Relief Program Evaluations, independent price partners, financial applications
authorised under the Emergency evaluations of almost three and services. Brussels and London –
Economic Stabilization Act. million hard-to-price fixed- Euroclear Bank’s FundSettle
income and structured securities LOS ANGELES - Vhayu platform has launched an
BNY Mellon is providing daily, and extensive fixed income Technologies has combined its automated link to EMXCo’s
accounting for the portfolio, reference data. tick bar data processing system, EMX Message System. This will
holding all cash and assets in Vhayu Velocity, with Alphacet further automate cross-border
the portfolio, pricing and asset Technology Explorer, a “codeless advanced flows in UK funds, providing an
valuation services and assisting historical backtesting engine” integrated, electronic means
with other related services. It will LONDON and BOSTON - Axial to create a tick database and for order input through to
also serve as auction manager Investment Management has alpha generation product. settlement and asset servicing. n
and conduct reverse auctions for selected Eagle Investment
the troubled assets. Systems LLC’s performance
Latest mandates
Month Winner Client Location Assignment Mandate size
October BNY Mellon Eureko B.V London Global custody EUR38 billion
October Pac Inv. Man Co. Fed Res’s comm. paper Washington Management n/a
September Northern Trust Maryland State Ret’mnt London Custody USD40 million
Some say rating agencies are partly to some of company solvency. Statpro, a data profit-seeking companies, then failure to
blame for the current crisis. Crippled by management company, has developed a produce the goods should result in either
conflicts of interest, these agencies let “dynamic” credit risk model integrating new companies rising to take their place
their paymasters (the very people they credit risk and market risk; the StatPro or a review of the system.
were supposed to rate), dictate ratings of VaR. This lets you know the current level Capitalism relies on trust. Companies
structured products, including mortgage of CDS spreads traded in the OTC mar- trust in their suppliers will deliver on
backed securities. If the rating agencies ket. Dario Cintioli, head of risk, StatPro, time, that fixed income payments will be
did their job, investors might have been advises that “One approach to isolating made, and that you have some forewarn-
better informed of these products’ falli- credit situations and spot potential prob- ing from the analysts you pay to examine
bility. lems in time, is to compare the evolution the market that one of the largest invest-
This may be letting investors off the of the StatPro VaR (or of CDS spreads) ment banks in the world is about to
hook, but by definition rating agencies of one issuer against its peers. Significant go bankrupt. Ratings are essential to any
have to examine the fundamentals behind deviations from the sector average may product or bond. But as soon as the rating
products and companies and give a risk provide strong signals relating to the start agencies realised that inordinate amounts
assessment. This involves an element of of credit problems”. of money could be made through posi-
soothe-saying and opinion making, but tive ratings and client relations, any hope
this clairvoyance involves sophisticated
A listed rating agency is a of independence evaporated. The rating
quantative analysis – one hopes. contradiction agencies became one with the financial
The quantative approach may ex- system.
plain Moody’s rational rating approach CDS spreads are an effective method The President’s Working Group docu-
of General Motors, reflecting its steady of analysing market risk in the short term, ment proposes to “reform the credit rat-
27-year decline from AAA to CCC. Leh- but do not offer an effective method for ing agencies processes for and practices
man Brothers, however, went from AAA long term analysis. Before a solution can regarding rating structured credit prod-
to junk in a single weekend. No amount be found, there are many dogmas that ucts to ensure integrity and transparen-
of hand-wringing and modelling can ex- need to be discarded. The first is the as- cy”. This reform must include the propo-
plain why Lehman Brothers continued to sumption that the free-market can find sition that the rating agencies cannot be
have high ratings across the board. the solution. A listed rating agency is a financed directly by the companies they
In the Policy Statement on Financial contradiction, and increased competition rate.
Market Developments by the President’s among listed rating agencies does not An alternative would be an investment
Working Group to George W Bush, improve rating quality. A paper entitled tax for all financial companies that go to-
signed by US Treasury Secretary Henry Reputation and Competition: Evidence wards a totally independent rating agen-
Paulson, the situation was reported as from the Credit Rating Industry (Bo Beck- cy. This tax will be a flat rate, required by
follows: “Faulty assumptions underly- er and Todd Milbourn, Harvard Univer- law, on every listed company and invest-
ing rating methodologies and the subse- sity and Washington University, St Louis), ment vehicle. The regulator within the
quent re-evaluations by the credit rating highlighted that the more credit rating country where the bond or company is
agencies led to a significant number of agencies competed with one another, the issued or listed would be in charge of is-
downgrades of subprime RMBS, even of greater likelihood they will issue higher suing and receiving the tax. The revenues
recently issued securities… The number ratings. Focusing on the ‘before and after’ would not only fund an efficient rating
and severity of negative ratings actions of the introduction of Fitch Ratings dur- agency, paying salaries at near the market
caused investors to lose confidence in the ing the mid-1990s, and its effect on the rate, but also any excess revenue would be
accuracy of the ratings of a wide range of Standard and Poor’s-Moody’s duopoly, funnelled into improving regulators, and
structured credit products.” the paper found that not only did ratings perhaps financing a ‘fund of last resort’,
To much, too late, perhaps, but what become friendlier with increase competi- for when, not if, the next liquidity crisis
are the alternatives? Some have put for- tion, but that bond yields and ratings be- occurs.
ward the notion that a more objective came less correlated. Rating accuracy must lead to profit.
method in analysing credit risk would The basket of services offered by the Over the past few decades, the rating agen-
be through the over-the-counter credit rating agencies failed to deliver satis- cies have made profits lead to accuracy. A
default swap (CDS) market – a gauge for factory results. If they wish to be listed, mild reform may not be enough. n
The importance
of being Erste
A beleagured CEE region has a champion in the Austrian bank, writes Ben Roberts
Austrian bank Erste, one of the most believe that current negative sentiments a slowdown at the end of 2007, gross
prominent custodians in Central and surrounding Central and Eastern domestic product growth accelerated to
Eastern Europe, has reported strong Europe in general and Hungary in 8.2% year on year. “Overall, we see the
growth in the region despite many of the particular do not reflect the tremendous GDP growth rate for the financial year
countries seeking financial help from the opportunities and underlying potential for 2008 at slightly above 7%, pointing
International Monetary Fund. of this region. We have made a long term to a stable and strong performance of
In the first nine months of 2008, strategic investment in Hungary and are the economy in terms of GDP growth.
many of the company’s regional determined to continue to support the In the mid run, we see stable economic
subsidiaries performed well. Net interest Hungarian economy and specifically to performance prospects,” said Alen
margin at 4.5% remained at a high level, meet our clients’ needs.” Kovac, macro analyst at Erste Group.
while operating result advanced by 52% The parliamentary elections
to EUR1.36 billion. In the mid-run, we organised in May were concluded, after
Though its total investment intense negotiations, with the pro-
in securities and other financial see stable economic European forces managing to assemble a
investments dropped in September of
this year to EUR44,066 million from
performance DS-led coalition and a new government
headed by DS candidate Mirko
EUR53,554 million in Sept 2007, its risk prospects Cvetkovic. Such a resolution alleviated
weighted assets grew to EUR105,342 a significant proportion of the political
million, up from EUR93,814 million in Alen Kovac, Erste risks to macroeconomic stability and
September 2007. was in line with our expectations,
Other liabilities, including minority according to Erste. “With political risks
interests, were stated at EUR15,537 considerably diminished, we see lower
million in September compared with The outpost in Serbia looks like a canny volatility on the FX market although
EUR20,293 million in the same month move by the bank, which in recent years towards the year-end there might still be
of the previous year. The return on has even outpaced its German rivals some room for mild depreciation”, an
equity has risen, up to 34.2% in Sept in establishing a CEE network. After Erste Group analyst commented. n
2008 from 12.9% 12 months before.
10%
Erste, which has operations in Hard times to great expectations: GDP 2-year forecasts 2008 2009 2010
Ukraine, Croatia, Hungary, Czech for year on year growth (source: Erste bank)
Republic, Slovakia, Romania and in 8%
September announced the opening of its
office in Serbia, has remained positive on
6%
the region despite the need for IMF help.
On 29th October it was announced that
Hungary was to receive EUR20 billion in 4%
10
www.securities.bnpparibas.com
11
12
14
founders, originated from the securities by lowering of values, has fallen 10%. and transferring data efficiently and
finance industry, and have been working It shows that during good times or bad effectively has yet to match other
closely as consultants and advisors securities financing is an important asset areas. However data companies
with all of the major participants in the central part of liquidity proposition can only go so far; it is yet to be seen
market for a long time. The demand for the capital markets. Once you have if managers make the most of the
for data has also been growing for some accepted this, it is a bit like looking back information available. n
time. “The primary fuel for growth has 40 years in time to the bond market or
been the appetite from participants the currency market, and realising that Biography
in the market to have more data there wasn’t a lot of data at first about Prior to joining Data Explorers, Donal
transparency and also the ability to those markets as they developed. The Smith was President and COO, EMEA and
correlate their data with third party data amount of data grew, the interest in the Asia of Thomson Financial. He joined
sources, all of which help them make data grew, and the necessity and value the company at the end of 2001 and was
responsible for driving the growth of
more profitable decisions,” says Smith. grew. I can see this industry definitely Thomson Financial’s international busi-
Data quality is often defined by your taking that track.” nesses.
ability to apply and analyse it. Smith At present, the job of the fund
highlights an interesting phenomena manager is multi asset, and multi- He also worked with the European Com-
mission to gain regulatory clearance
coming out of the recent disruption in geography. If anything, the majority for Thomson’s proposed acquisition of
the securities lending markets. “Over of the financial industry suffers from Reuters. Previously, he worked for the
the last month one might’ve suspected information overload. The most Financial Times Group, firstly as Manag-
the short selling bans to cause liquidity important factor today is finding the ing Director of Business Information at
FT Information and then as Director of
problems, yet we’ve seen quite an uptake right piece of information, at the right Electronic Publishing for the FT Group,
on the activity of lending. Stock-on-loan time, for those in the front office. This and as a member of the group’s manage-
was up 15%, according to our index, is the motivating factor for Smith, ment board. During this period he was
even though inventory, partly driven working in an area where collating responsible for the launch of FT.com.
Is your custodian
focused on you?
We are.
Swedbank Markets Hansabank
Custody and Banking Service – Custody and Banking Service –
Stockholm, Sweden Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania
Fair value?
As investors scramble to unwind deals and calculate positions,
regulation surrounding fair value has shifted, writes Joe Corcos.
The world’s governments have tinkered
with the financial system on a massive
scale in a desperate attempt to stave
off the worst of what started as the
subprime crisis, developed into the
credit crunch, and has since turned into
a full blown financial meltdown.
The developed world’s financial
sector, the very chalice of capitalism, has
taken a beating and changes to some of
the fundamentals of the system have had
to be made to fix it. And while bending
the rules may help avert another Great
Depression, nobody knows what the
long-term repercussions will be. Case
in point – the concept of fair value and
the recent relaxing of the rules that have
been built to enforce it.
Prior to the financial crisis the
concept of fair value was little known
or referenced outside the accountancy
universe. But in the last month or so a A debate over fair says: “In the normal market you don’t
have distressed sellers and people
debate over fair value and the role it has
played in the current crisis has hit the
value has hit the desperate to raise capital so they have to
sell no matter what the price.
mainstream media. mainstream media “That causes distortion, you’ve now
The concept of fair value, or mark
to market, is the practice of assigning with a vengeance got a disorderly market. Adoption of
fair value in a disorderly market is not
certain assets the price that the market an accurate reflection of the value of the
deems them worth. Since the early assets.”
1990s both Europe and the US, which pricing those assets far below what Banks forced into massive write-
use different accounting standards, they may actually be worth. So those downs have complained that having to
have instituted rules around fair value. who have assets that have no market price their assets in an illiquid market
Usually these rules and the concept of appetite anymore – ie, mortgage-backed is exacerbating the damage, and that
fair value in general are an important, securities – are being forced to price they are having to price assets that are
sensible part of the valuation process them at Lehman’s fire-sale prices, when not on the market in the same way as
that lends clarity and transparency to they may be worth more in the near those that are, making them seem to be
the market, especially where hard to future. worth much less than they believe they
price derivatives and other complicated This is the situation that banks and are in reality. Richard Fuld, the disgraced
instruments are concerned. Usually. other financial institutions are faced Lehman Brothers CEO told Congress
However fair value only works with today, one that they claim has made recently that fair value accounting rules
when there is an orderly market where their billions of write-downs even worse. had played a major part in the bank’s
voluntary transactions are taking place. And it is this situation that has resulted collapse.
But what if there is no market? Or a in furious debate over fair value. Thus the besieged financial services
market where an entity like Lehman Neil Beckley, UK manager for sector is begging for a suspension of the
Brothers or Bear Stearns is forced to Fernbach, a company specialising in risk fair practice rules, at least temporarily.
sell off assets on the cheap, therefore management and accounting solutions, On the other side of the fence are the
16
accountants, investors and regulators future cash flows and so forth to value are those that have the distressed sales,
who believe that scrapping fair value an asset. The statement went on to say so that gets you back to zero.
would essentially allow institutions that ‘disorderly’ transactions are not “We need a clear definition of what
to internally value their own assets, determinative when pricing and that fair value is in an illiquid market. And
leading to opacity, possible abuse, and an general transactions that take place in we need it very quickly.”
unknown consequences. an inactive market “may be inputs when Meanwhile, the SEC has been
When it comes to the rules governing measuring fair value, but would likely charged by Congress to conduct a study
accounting practices, most of Western not be determinative”. examining the influence of fair value
Europe and the rest of the developed In essence this allows banks to apply accounting rules on firms’ balance sheets
world fall under the auspices of the fair value as they see fit. and whether other accounting methods
International Accounting Standards However, when the FASB itself are more feasible.
Board (IASB). However, the US uses its issued a further clarifying statement Perhaps most importantly, included
own Generally Accepted Accounting on 10th October, it only succeeded in in the US Emergency Economic
Principles (GAAP). The idea is to muddying the already cloudy waters. Stabilization Act, more commonly called
eventually bring the US under the IASB In its statement the FASB says liquidity the ‘bail-out’, is a clause which allows the
umbrella. However, this is unlikely to risk has to be included in the cash flow SEC to completely suspend the fair value
happen in the next few years. Therefore calculation, which could result in values rules at the push of a button.
Europe is forced to stay aware of US being calculated to distressed sale levels. Whether this will happen or not is
actions when it comes to accounting in American Bankers Association (ABA) unknowable, but in the meantime it is
order to ensure its companies remain was among those unimpressed with the impossible for the SEC to go through
competitive. FASB statement. Donna Fischer, head every single financial instrument in
Deciding action was needed on of tax and accounting at the ABA, says: existence and determine whether fair
the fair value issue, the SEC released a “We don’t think the FASB position was value should apply to it. This is why so
statement on 30th September ‘clarifying’ useful. It was not helpful. It had some far it has resorted to giving guidance and
Financial Accounting Standards good points in it but it’s circular; it tells essentially letting the banks decide for
Board’s (FASB) statement 157, the you all of these things that do clarify themselves. This is a move that may be
statement which addresses fair value what fair value is, but at the end it says frustrating for the banks but is extremely
measurements. The clarification notice you must use liquidation risk that a disquieting for others.
essentially said that management can current market participant would use, Denise Valentine, an analyst at Aite
use internal estimates such as expected and the only current market participants Group says of the situation: “So now
0ENSIONS \ ,IFE )NSURANCE \ )NVESTMENT \ 0ORTFOLIO !DMINISTRATION \ 4RANSFER !GENCY \ 340 &INANCIAL -ESSAGING
&INANCIAL SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS
THAT STAND OUT FROM THE CROWD
WWWBRAVURASOLUTIONSCOM
)3*
!USTRALIA \ .EW :EALAND \ (ONG +ONG \ 4HAILAND \ )NDIA \ ,UXEMBOURG \ 5NITED +INGDOM \ 3OUTH !FRICA
you’re going to have judgement calls to exert pressure on the IASB to review holding these assets to maturity and am
being made. Now it becomes a question IAS 39. At the insistence of the EU, not really bothered if there is a market
of what doesn’t get valued. Now you’re currently chaired by France, the IASB out there or not. This is not something
getting all these judgement calls about duly relaxed the IAS 39, and allowed that’s new, it hasn’t just been created
what needs to have fair value applied to companies to value some assets on the with mortgage-backed securities. We’ve
it and what doesn’t. assumption that they would be held had for 30 years private placement,
“What happens with the SEC on to until they matured, rather than there’s no market price for a private
typically is they don’t give you a list of using the fair value price dictated by the placement, it’s always been priced on a
instruments, they give you interpretive market. model basis and nobody got excited.”
guidance. That’s the scary part. So until For a time many were worried that By relaxing IAS 39 and FAS 157
these companies and banks get audited the EU Commission would insist on a the regulators have saved many firms
or are heading south, or for some of billions of dollars in write-downs
them if they’re going to now be owned ahead of their third-quarter reporting.
by US citizens and get examined, you Relaxing the fair However, it is possible that the relaxing
don’t know. Until those reviews and of the fair value rules could have severe
audits occur you don’t necessarily know value rules could repercussions in the future.
if things are being done appropriately “Relaxing the fair value rules could
and in good faith.” significantly delay significantly delay realisation of losses
With the onus being on the and could result in the financial crisis
institutions to classify their own assets, the realisation of lasting longer”, says Andrea Cicione, a
the investor is left relying on the senior credit strategist at BNP Paribas.
individual companies to fully disclose losses Cicione goes on to give the example
how they are doing this. The need for of Japan in the 1990s as an example of
more instruction from the regulators is a full carve out of the rule which would what can happen without fair value rules
common theme across the industry. have allowed banks a free hand to in place. This is when Japanese banks
Paul zur Nieden, the vice president transfer assets out of trading books, and refused to admit the extent of bad assets
for product management and investment some thought that the EU may even they had on their books, which severely
accounting at SunGard, says: “I think create its own accountancy standards prolonged the country’s financial woes.
that there could be more regulatory body. However, when the Commission Then on 29th October, in a
guidance but it also comes down to the met on 21st October it decided political controversial decision, Japan’s finance
individual investment company how intervention was unnecessary and that minister said the country will join
they interpret that guidance. the IASB would be left to the decision- Europe and the US in easing its fair
“Where able to they should continue making regarding fair value. We are still value rules, as recommended by the
their fair value practices. Where there’s likely to see the IASB consider other Accounting Standards Board of Japan.
an excessive burden adhering to the fair changes in the future, such as letting In this time of massive flux in the
value rule they should say so and call firms have more leeway in classifying markets, regulators and governments
that out in the reporting.” assets which include derivatives as are quickly taking measures to ensure
Meanwhile, Europe has been keeping amortised, rather than fair value, which that swathes of important firms do not
close eye on America, and has been would leave them unaffected by further fail. Easing fair value accounting rules
making its own moves to ensure that market turbulence. is one of these measures. However,
European-based entities are given the Assets that are re-classified to be held no one, least of all the politicians,
same breaks. to maturity will then be classified by can fully understand the effects that
The French have long opposed fair the company using the mark to model these measures will have in the future,
value rules, which in Europe and much technique. This incorporates cash flows, especially concerning the financial crisis
of the rest of the world take the form of risk of default, market interest rates, and how long the recessions which swirl
the International Accounting Standards non-market risk, and other factors. in its wake will last.
(IAS) 39. Thus when the banks and Beckley says: “It is the fundamentals On whether fair value should be
others started clamoring for a relaxation that are the way every asset is priced, if relaxed or not, Valentine says: “What’s
or reinterpretation of the rules, and the ignored the liquidity, ie, the free flow of the lesser of two evils? Would you
SEC responded, the French President willing counterparties to buy and sell, rather be going about your business
Nicholas Sarkozy took the opportunity which basically means I’m an investor undervalued or overvalued?” n
18
Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) introduces TCS B NCS from TCS Financial Solutions, a complete suite
of business solutions covering Core Banking, Compliance, Islamic Banking, Channels, Payments,
Treasury, Corporate Actions, Securities Trading, Securities Processing, Market Infrastructure, Private
Banking, Wealth Management and Insurance. Across 240 financial institutions in over 80 countries, TCS
B NCS drives customer growth, reduces total cost of ownership, enhances new product development
and enables banks, insurance and capital market clients to experience certainty.
To learn how TCS B NCS can help your organization experience certainty,
log on to www.tcs.com/bancs or email us at [email protected]
MiFID: Anniversary
Alex Walker, global head of GL TRADE’s post-trade for securities
business line, looks at challenges and rewards that MiFID - now a year
old - can bring to the back office.
Given the generation of revenue in the the success Chi-X is having with its pan-
front end it is not surprising that most of European clearing solution. Ironically
the attention of the impact of the Markets though, sources say Chi-X approached
in Financial Instruments Directive (Mi- some of the existing established CCPs
FID) has focused there. However, as the for clearing purposes, but none of them
effects of the directive start to be felt, post was able or willing to deliver what the
trade processes are starting to be regarded MTF needed. Chi-X eventually imple-
as equally important. mented a novel solution using Fortis’
The efficiency of back office operations European Multilateral Clearing Facility
post-MiFID is important because the frag- (EMCF).
mentation of markets, particularly in eq- This pan-European CCP is provid-
uities, means that clearing and settlement ing competition at the clearing level,
functions are inevitably due to become which most institutions will embrace;
more complex. however, this implementation has in-
As well as all the regulatory require- troduced more complexity in the post-
ments around client classification, best trade arena. The purpose of new trad-
execution and transaction reporting, mar- ing venues is to provide access to better
ket participants also have to cope with the pricing and a wide range of markets. It is
technological complexities of connecting; very possible that Europe will eventually
not only to a greater range of trading ven- follow the American model with a pan-
ues, but also to multiple central counter- European clearer. Certainly Euroclear
parties (CCPs), which act as intermediary Single Settlement Engine is taking us in
between security market participants. the right direction. Until we get there
In addition, we see today the emergence though, without appropriate back office
of the new multilateral trading facilities systems, any gains achieved in the front
(MTFs), such as Chi-X, Equiduct and Proj- office could be soaked up in increased
ect Turquoise, as well as numerous dark clearing and settlement costs, with the
pools, creates competition right through risk of becoming uncompetitive.
the deal chain. Settlement instructions and their
For years, a debate has raged about the routing remain the ‘crown jewels’ of the
merits of vertical and horizontal exchange back office world. Middle and back of-
clearing models. Until the introduction of fice systems need to be able to handle
MiFID, these were mainly academic. How- complexity in this area catering for cus-
ever, horizontal and vertical models have todians and clearers preferences, and
at times allowed the incumbent exchanges perform netting. Users must have a flex-
to display a degree of monopolistic behav- ible interface allowing them in real time
iour. The control of clearing has allowed to see the status of their trades, coun-
them, to a large extent, to dictate where terparty exposures, stock and cash posi-
trading takes place. tions all at their fingertips. After all, why
Now MiFID is changing this and the stay with a system that will stop your
concept of ‘inter-operability’ between front office from taking advantage of the
various CCPs is starting to become a new business opportunities
reality. Industry watchers will have seen now available? n
20
As the central bankers of Europe and few years. He argues that the position area. The Asian bond market initiative
the US both know all too well, putting in in Asia is probably at least five years began in 2003, under the direction of
place pan-regional all singing, all danc- behind Europe’s efforts. However, as the ASEAN + 3 finance ministers, and
ing payments and settlements systems he says, “There are many initiatives in 2008, after much initial exploratory
is a tough act to pull off. Europe has ongoing and there is a great deal of talk, a taskforce on infrastructure was
additional challenges of mediating be- political and industry recognition that created.
tween multiple languages and customs, something needs to be done.” This had its first meeting in April
thought these are just two issues facing Despite the great variation between 2008 and at that meeting the task force
the creation of a pan-Asian payments the countries, he says that from a decided to create the Group of Experts
and settlement system. technical and legal perspective, there (GoE). “The Task Force has a two-year
One notable difference between are numerous similarities between the mandate. We are at the start of this
Europe and Asia is the way markets in continents. “We firmly believe that project in terms creating a forum with
the countries of the region span the there are lessons that the Asian project wide stakeholder input and onward
whole spectrum from very undeveloped initiators can learn from the European communication to the decision makers,”
(such as Vietnam), to developing (such experience,” he says. Cohen says.
as Malaysia), to very developed markets In fact, Euroclear is part of the The Task Force is left with a chicken
(Singapore, Hong Kong and, of course, Group of Experts convened earlier this and egg scenario. At present, cross
Japan). year as part of the ASEAN + 3 Asian border bond flows inside Asia are
Eli Cohen, General Counsel Asia, Bond Markets Initiative to put together insignificant and certainly do not
at Euroclear, based in Hong Kong, has a pan Asian settlements infrastructure warrant an infrastructure spend in
followed the various initiatives towards for the Asian bond markets. This is one the many tens of millions of dollars.
pan-Asian systems closely over the last of the most significant projects in the However, Cohen argues that, “like
21
in Europe, the Asian markets will habit of periodically slamming the door damage to their economies if there is a
be increasingly defined by their on any foreign currency inflows and/ run on their currency or if it becomes
infrastructures”. or outflows whenever the economic overvalued against other key currencies.
“At present, there is no easy way for climate gets a little perturbed. This Another problem in getting a pan-
Korean investors to invest in Japanese is an understandable policy tool and regional infrastructure off the ground
government securities, and vice-versa. there are still plenty of currency trading is the relative size gap between Japan
Both sides would have to convert local restrictions in place, and not just in and the rest, in market terms. “Japan
currency into dollars first and then to China. Whether they exempt this utility dwarfs everyone, and then there is a
the denomination currency to invest is a significant question. second tier, with China growing in
in the other party’s sovereign debt,” he “If you are in Korea with an FX significance. There is a growing volume
comments. This means that if Korean of licence there is no problem. You can of FX trading domestically in China and
Japanese investors wanted to invest in trade the won aggressively. But if you are we recently added the Bank of China as
sovereign debt, it is just far simpler for outside Korea there is no way to trade a shareholder in CLS.”
both sides to buy US Treasury bills. In a keynote speech on 18th October,
But with Japan and Korea already If you are outside Akinari Horii, assistant governor of the
massively overweight in US debt, Bank of Japan, presenting to the Global
finance ministers and central bankers Korea there is no Operations Managers’ Conference
in those countries want to see much
more cross-border investment. The
way to trade the in Tokyo, said that the Bank was
seeing strong growth in the number
Asia bonds settlement system would Korean currency of Japanese retail investors with a
be a huge enabler for Asian countries real appetite for Asian currencies and
to invest in each other’s debt and, it is and there is often “commodity” currencies. He argued
hoped, will cause a lot more of Asia’s
money to be retained in Asia for the
virtually no external too that the emergence of new entrants,
such as hedge funds and public sector
good of the region. visibility of the investors, has also added to trading
“We believe that the work we are volumes in what he termed “emerging
doing within the Group of Eight will trades taking place currencies”.
be very significant in helping to build Settlement issues continue to be very
the infrastructure Asia needs. It will the Korean currency and there is often important, he says, particularly in the
probably take ten to 15 years to achieve. virtually no external visibility of the current unsettled conditions, and there
But at the same time, there are several trades taking place in Korea, even for is necessity to work towards a reduction
private and national payment and a parent bank with a subsidiary inside in the settlement risk of FX transactions.
settlement initiatives on going. Some Korea. They sometimes seem astonished A pan-Asian payment and settlements
will assist the capital markets in the by the amount of FX business their system would be massive in this regard,
region as these markets move towards subsidiaries do in Korea!” but it is still a long way off. Toshiro
a standardised and common processing Butterfield says CLS has a good Muto, then deputy governor of the Bank
infrastructure,” Cohen says. relationship with the Korean Central of Japan, pointed out in a speech that
Jonathan Butterfield, executive Bank and firmly believes that it Japan’s payment systems have come a
vice president, Marketing and will continue to push for further long way in just two decades. Before
Communication at CLS Bank, the deregulation. But across the region the Bank of Japan Financial Network
global clearing and settlement system the tendency or instinct to shut up System, the BOJ-NET, which links the
for FX, argues that while a pan Asian, shop if it looks like external pressure Bank and Japanese financial institutions,
multi-currency payments infrastructure on the currency could damage the began working in 1988, payment
for bonds and securities is a very local economy, remains very strong. instructions for settlement using current
legitimate aspiration, it will be a tough “It happened in Malaysia and happens account deposits at BoJ, were delivered
act to pull off. There are several issues periodically in Thailand ,” he says. as cheques by clerks on bicycles.
around standards, legal commonality, A good many Asian economies are The payments system enabled the
operational cycling etc. but one of understandably nervous of, or adverse Bank to deal efficiently with the huge
the real issues, he points out, is that to, the free floating currency model growth in transaction volumes, but just
a number of Asian economies have a because they are only too aware of the as importantly, it enabled it to manage
22
Look no further
and reduce settlement risk – which rises and credit transfers and is all about
sharply as transaction volumes rise. providing a low cost payment and
In 2004 BOJ-NET settled transactions clearing service for high volume
totalling some YEN78 trillion, while the transactions.
Foreign Exchange Yen Clearing System The thrust of present initiatives in
(FXYCS) settled around YEN19 trillion. China are all concerned with scrambling
BOJ-NET moved to a RTGS approach in to help China’s fast developing banking
January 2001. and securities industries keep abreast
Japan moved to CLS when it was of change, while at the same time
launched in September 2002 and was finding ways of extending the payments
one of the seven founding currencies. infrastructure to provide access to
Today, via CLS foreign exchange, financial services in rural areas. Pan-
trillions of transactions are settled on a Asia these systems are not and building
payment-versus-payment basis among a pan Asian payments infrastructure
settlement members. BoJ moved earlier, promises to be hard work.
in 1994, to a delivery-versus-payment At present, the major driving force
system for securities transactions. pushing for a regional payments
China, with an economy that is on infrastructure, as Euroclear’s Cohen
course to become the largest in the notes, comes from the various finance
world, is already quite far along in ministries and central banks in the
the development of its own payment region. However, as is always the case
systems. The People’s Bank of China where national interests are concerned,
(PBOC) oversees the country’s payment the fact that there are multiple central
systems while also acting as a service banks is also itself part of the dilemma,
provider in the inter-bank clearing since there are multiple ambitions to
and settlement services arena. It works be fulfilled and political aspirations to
together with the China Banking be catered for. Japan, China, Korea and
Regulatory Commission (CBRC) which Singapore all aspire to have elements of
supervises individual banks and has such a pan-Asian infrastructure located
the twin responsibilities of promoting in their cities and arguments about who
financial stability and facilitating gets to run what could be a big diversion
financial innovation. A key part of of energy away from any pan-regional
the country’s financial system is China infrastructure project.
National Advanced Payment System Beyond this, as CLS’s Butterfield
(CNAPS). This provides clearing notes, there is also the fact that intra-
services for banks and the financial Asian flows are not of themselves
market and it consists of two separate sufficient to justify a huge spend. There
applications, the High Value Payment are real analogies here with the euro, he
System (HVPS) and the Bulk Electronic argues. “The aspiration to have a “scale
Payment System (BEPS). The former currency” was one of the drivers behind
began operating in June 2005 and settles the creation of the euro. It has clearly
large value payments on a trade by become the second reserve currency,
trade basis at gross value in real time. but one wonders whether, ex Japan , for
According to a study by the Federal the time being, whether the other Asian
Bank of San Francisco, the HVPS countries government bonds form a
system processed 170 million payments large enough pool for foreign investors
and clearing transactions in 2007 with to sustain the proposed infrastructure.
a total RMB value of 530 trillion, or “The argument that the East Asian
USD76 trillion. In effect it provides bonds settlement project will enable a
PBOC with a system for real-time fund brisk trade between Asian countries in
settlements of its securities trades. each other’s sovereign debt has yet to be
BEPS handles low-value debit payments bottomed out.” n
24
Benelux in flux
How have the three countries developed such a varied
custody landscape? Ben Roberts considers major market trends.
Mergers
Acquisitions
Alternatives
Value added
The takeover and part-nationalisation its own asset management arm that it fiduciary manager will hire and fire the
of Fortis at the turn of September-Octo- is looking to commoditise as a service: asset managers, sculpt the tactical asset
ber demonstrated the accord by which a corporate fund that is itself becoming allocation and help the trustees – who
three governments can tackle the res- something of a corporation. Belgium, by have ultimate responsibility for the fund
cue of a major financial institution. The contrast, is dominated by private pen- – define a strategy. They will also hire
bank’s arms met different fates – BNP sion plans. the custodian, which can give an inde-
Paribas swooped for the Belgian and However, according to Renaud Van- pendent view while providing core and
Luxembourg banking outlets while the denplas, head of location in Belgium for ancilliary custodial services.
Netherlands operation was nationalised BNP Paribas, new infrastructure is ex- How pension funds are valued, and
– but in a period of difficult takeovers it panding the market to the extent that cus- the frequency of valuation, has been
can be perceived as straightforward. The todians are offering value-added services one of the most significant events in the
Benelux alliance – the mutual parlia- such as securities lending. Luxembourg, Dutch market in what has been called
ment of Belgium, Netherlands and Lux- one of the world’s foremost investment the New Financial Framework. Asset/
embourg – appeared a steady region. fund domiciles, presents its own chal- liability ratios before were calculated as
Looking under the bonnet, the Ben- lenges to custodians in the proliferation if the interest rate was fixed at 4%. Now,
elux custody landscape is greatly varied. of specialised investment funds (SIFs) the Dutch National Bank demands that
Legislation in each market has spurred and SICAF (Société d’investissement à asset/liability calculation is based on the
new innovation, and as a result the three capital fixe) funds that demand the full real interest rates, with a pension fund
countries’ divisions are marked. The suite of services. In all, even the biggest altering its exposures in accordance.
Netherlands is well known as one of the custodians must be nimble and adapt as “There was a pure concentration on
most sophisticated pension fund mar- the space unfolds. the asset side of the balance sheet and
kets, with sizeable assets under manage- A Dutch pension fund is overseen not on the liability side,” explains Erwin
ment to match its ambition to diversify. by a tripartite of a board of trustees, a Reyes, head of location for Netherlands
APG – perhaps the biggest fund – has fiduciary manager, and a custodian. A at BNP Paribas. “This was changed be-
25
cause of the drop in interest rates. There pension funds, particularly those smaller mitigation improves, and the fee bills
wasn’t an interest in looking at the liabil- funds that may lack the sophistication to come down.
ities on the longer terms because it was deal with, for example, derivatives. However, this can pose problems for
fixed. But two years ago the New Finan- Adjusting the calculation of asset/lia- client reporting. “At an FvGR aggregate
cial Framework dictated that pension bilities is particularly pertinent given the level then it is simply reporting. But
funds need to calculate their liabilities recent debate over ‘fair value’ accounting. some of our clients need reports on the
against a market rate - if the interest rate In October, the International Accountan- underliers at a sub-fund level. In an ideal
goes down, it increases your liabilities. cy Standards Board announced a united world you would pool all assets through
The regulator requires a coverage ratio, front with the US’s Financial Account- one vehicle supported by one custodian,
if a pension fund falls under 105% today ing Standards Boards that portfolios of but in reality you need to work together
[every EUR100 worth of assets needs to financial institutions would be mark- with other custodians,” says Pouwels.
be offset by 105% liabilities] you have to to-market, despite the billions in losses Danloy also sees downsides. “You will
work on a recovery plan.” this could incur. This came in defiance of always have the issues surrounding the
More frequent adjustments to port- many banks and insurers that demanded taxation of the plan,” he says. “You pay a
folio calculation have shortened the premium to the plan but you don’t have
investment outlook for many pension Traditionally, the same tax process in the every coun-
funds. “The implementation of the new try.”
framework has definitely called for more Belgian pension The Belgian market, Danloy concedes,
focus on the short term,” says Eric Pou-
wels, head of location in the Netherlands
funds have been is everything and nothing in comparison
– as a Belgian himself he can admit this.
for Northern Trust. Reyes at BNP Paribas more cautious Of the three ‘pillars’ of pension types that
suggests that pension funds might be less retirees will fund themselves – namely,
weighted in equities and more in bonds the state plan, the corporate plan and the
to maintain balance as volatile markets private plan – the country is dominated
encourage the constant revision of inter- by the first and third pillars. A govern-
est rates. a parallel system of valuation between as- ment pension plan is more generous in
This bolsters the allocation into de- sets that are likely to be traded, and assets Belgium, Danloy explains, and there are
rivatives, already a popular asset class in that will remain on a bank’s books until tax advantages to creating your own.
the Netherlands, and this plays into the maturity. Sebastien Danloy, global head In this way, Belgian corporate pension
hands of custodians that have experience of sales and relationship management at funds, the second pillar, are playing catch
with such tools. “You need to hedge your Société Générale, had followed the devel- up on the international stage.
portfolio, how can you do that? Through opments of this debate, and comments “Traditionally Belgian pension funds
investment in swaps, for instance,” says simply: “We are in a global economy, so have been more cautious and still have a
Reyes, “but swaps need to be adminis- it only makes sense to have similar rules.” lot of money in equities and bonds,” says
tered and reported and that is a service Van Houwelingen is also in favour of an Renaud Vandenplas, head of location,
we provide.” Reinoud Van Den Broek, assured harmony of accountancy. Belgium at BNP Paribas. Derivatives
head of institutional sales and account The other key development in the are less popular, although he adds that
management for Benelux at Robeco, also Dutch market is the adoption of the the market from a custodial viewpoint
identifies this hedging technique, and Fonds voor Gemene Rekening (FvGR) has developed to the extent that certain
says socially responsible investing has in- pooling vehicle. This system, also preva- value-added services are on offer. “Secu-
creased in the Netherlands. lent in Luxembourg and Ireland, effec- rities lending is a good example because
Leonique van Houwelingen, head of tively brings together the strands of a BNP Paribas has just started a lending
relationship management, Continental large pension fund that has investments programme [in Belgium]. These extra
Europe at BNY Mellon Asset Servicing, in different countries using different services are requested more and more by
notes that the growing complexity of in- providers under a single custodian. Eric the biggest pension funds.”
vestment products and investment strat- Pouwels at Northern Trust explains that Luxembourg is a different market
egies, coupled with more onerous regula- this can have tax advantages for the pen- entirely. It has established an expertise
tory requirements, is putting a strain on sion fund overall, governance and risk for domiciling funds, although much
26
Custom
Custom House Offers
House Off ers 24/5
24/5Service
Service
Custom House Global Fund Services Limited now offers its clients a full “round the world”
andCustom
“round House Global
the clock” Fund
hedge Services
fund Limited now
administration offers through
service its clientsits
a full “roundofthe
network offiworld”
ces which,
following the merger with Equity Trust’s fund services business, includes Amsterdam, ces
and “round the clock” hedge fund administration service through its network of offi which, Curacao,
Chicago,
following the merger with Equity Trust’s fund services business, includes Amsterdam, Chicago, Curacao,
Dublin, Guernsey, Luxembourg, Malta and Singapore.
Dublin, Guernsey, Luxembourg, Malta and Singapore.
Custom House’s Dublin office, which is authorised by the Irish Financial Regulator under Section 10
Custom House’s Dublin office, which is authorised by the Irish Financial Regulator under Section 10
of of
thethe
Investment
InvestmentIntermediaries
Intermediaries Act 1995, achieved
Act 1995, achievedananexception-free
exception-free SAS70
SAS70 Type
Type II and
II and
was the fi rst hedge fund administrator to be awarded a Moody’s Management Quality
was the first hedge fund administrator to be awarded a Moody’s Management Quality Rating. Rating.
Custom House has in assets under administration US$50 billion acting
Custom House has in assets under administration US$50 billion acting for for
approximately
approximately210
210managers
managers trading throughmore
trading through morethan
than610
610funds
funds and
and sub-funds.
sub-funds.
For
Formore
moreinformation
information on Custom
CustomHouse,
House,please
pleasereview
review our
our website:
website:
www.customhousegroup.com
www.customhousegroup.com
or
or contact
contact
DermotButler
Dermot Butler ([email protected])
([email protected])
has definitely
for BNP Paribas, identifies three major believes that in Luxembourg, the biggest
trends. “Domiciled funds as well as in- asset managers will be looking at a “top
called for more surance and reinsurance funds putting
their assets in Luxembourg custody ac-
five” players to provide the stability and
value-added services. Erwin Reyes in the
focus on the short counts. These investors are looking for Netherlands is a little more generous to
term
alternative assets. The lightly regulated the niche provider, arguing that players
SIFs allow qualified investors a wide in- such as KAS bank are closer to the local
vestment policy. culture and long-standing relationships
“Secondly, the regulator introduced instead of a global reach. He adds: “I do
Eric Pouwels, a new circular widening the scope of know some Dutch pension funds that
head of location,
lending; you can now lend 100% of your refuse to work with Anglo Saxon firms;
portfolio, up from 50%. You have new they are much more comfortable work-
Netherlands, assets eligible as collateral, like corporate
bonds or money market instruments,
ing with a local provider that speaks
their language and understands the new
Northern Trust with no limitation of time in which to rules imposed upon them.”
recall the assets. Sebastien Danloy believes local pro-
“Thirdly, we see an increasing trend viders will be challenged in the face of
from asset managers that have assets bank takeovers and nationalisations and
with us to invest in hedge funds. What sees implications that go beyond securi-
we’ve seen with the SIFs is a trend to ties services. “For niche providers, what
fund of hedge funds, private equity and is becoming more important is to have
to an extent real estate.” specific players dedicated to securities
Danloy verifies this continued popu- services, but universal banks have prob-
larity for private equity funds, and spots ably a stronger business model because
two more new developments. “The first is clients not only want securities services
for life settlement funds: funds that buy but also want the bank to look at financ-
insurance policies from people who no ing, or if there are pension funds to be
longer wish to pay the premium and can- administered, it is the relationship you
not stop paying them. The other trend is have.
for art funds.” “Today a number of institutions are
Scherrer adds that there has been an reducing the number of their counter-
increased frequency in the launching parts so being a niche provider – niche
of exchange traded funds (ETFs). BNP in terms of exclusively in asset manage-
Paribas recently won a mandate from ment – that might play against you
Commerz bank that decided to launch going forward.” n
28
1998: Guernsey
office opens
1999: Singapore
office opens
2000: Buys
Matheson
Trust
office opens
While Rio Tinto and GM stumble not always been the case in the wider probably on the low side,” wrote Ftfm,
over potential mergers in their market. During the Banking Era of the Oct 20th 2008), Van Vredenbuch has a
respective fields, one corporate link-up past decade, many investment banks huge amount of faith that the alternative
went forward without a hitch. In the flush with profits followed the acquire- space will not only continue but also
beginning of September 2008, Custom then-fire method when bolting on thrive and eventually cease to be the
House, the fund administrator, and fund administrators to their business alternative space, but rather the norm.
Equity Trust Fund Services Business, portfolio. While this may be unfair to “Twenty years ago all pension funds had
announced that the partnership between banks - as any other method would have some real estate investment as some core
the two companies had received them classed under that dreaded term investment. Now it is considered as an
regulatory approval. The combined ‘uncompetitive’ - it is undeniable that alternative,” says Butler. “Why, I have no
business totals assets of USD50 billion, the deal suits both parties at a time when idea. Nothing has changed. Real estate is
acting for approximately 210 managers the banking industry is under the cosh. still bricks, mortar and yield.”
through around 610 funds. Van Vredenbuch also states that fund Both agree that in the future, we
Equity Trust has grown considerably administration has moved away from will be talking not of the alternative
through acquisition over the years. amateur hour some time ago; a time industry as one colossal monolith, but
In 2000, it acquired Matheson Trust; when you could get away with running as a number of different strategies.
in 2004, Standard Chartered’s trust your business off an excel spreadsheet. That these strategies may sprout their
operation; in 2005, the global trust and “There was next to no interaction own individual service industry is not
fiduciary business of ABN AMRO Bank between all our different offices in our anathema - if anything this is a return to
NV; and in 2006, it captured Ernst and different jurisdictions, plus our different the golden days of bonds, equities and
Young’s domiciliation business and offices were often using different property, where asset classes and their
related corporate secretarial services in platforms,” he explains. “Once we had services were siloed together.
Luxembourg. However, as Hugo Van decided that the fund administration Post merger, the combined businesses
Vredenbuch (pictured right, above) , business interacted with many of our have total assets under administration
CEO Equity Trust, explains: “Along with other business sections, we needed to of USD50 billion. “That puts us within a
these newly acquired portfolios came a grow it. However, gaining critical mass, comfort zone for institutional investors,”
number of legacy accounts within hedge an integrated global network, and says Butler. “[This is] perhaps more
fund administration, an area untouched integrated economies of scale is very important for institutional managers
by Equity Trust. Here we had to decide hard to do on your own. Custom House because the manager is concerned that
whether or not to cast out a number of had what we needed.” the administrator is acceptable. Perhaps
new customers we had acquired, decide While the average hedge fund has because we are not part of a big bank
to build a new fund administration lost 13% in the last nine months, and that makes us more of an attractive
business in house, or acquire someone amid a number of alarmist articles in the counterparty.” It is a promising start
who knows what to do in the first place.” press stating that half of the hedge funds in a time when comfort zones and safe
It looks to be a stable, amicable were going to evaporate (“estimates counterparties become anomalies. n
merge for the long term, which has that 30% of funds will disappear are
30
31
Mark C Faulkner is managing Guy d’Albrand is a global head of Mark Payson is the managing director Francisco Gonzalez is head of Eurex
director of Spitalfields Advisors and liquidity management at Societe generale of Trading & Asset Liability Management SecLend, reponsible for the market
Data Explorers. He has worked at L.M. Securities Services. He began as a futures for Securities Lending at Brown Brothers management regarding business and
(Moneybrokers) Ltd., Goldman Sachs broker in Japan in 1988. . He joined Harriman & Co. He joined the firm in product development of the electrnic
and Lehman Brothers. In 1995 he co- Fimat in 1997 to run the Tokyo office, 1999 as the Head of Securities Lending market place for international securities
founded Securities Finance International before becoming exective vice-president Trading and in July 2003 was appointed lending and borrowing at Eurex. Before
and Spitalfields Advisors in 2004. and special dviser to the CEO for Societe Co-Manager of Global Securities Lending. joining Eurex in 2001, he was head of
(NB, Question 3 will be answered by Generale, Japan. After further deputy Systems Development, in charge of the
David Carruthers, head of quantitative CEO and CEO roles he returned to Paris systems design for the electronic stock
analytics, Data Explorers.) in 2002. market at SWX Swiss Exchange.
1. What are your views regarding the to actually isolate the impact of any taken by each country varied in terms of undermine confidence in
international bans on short selling? short selling ban. In the RMA/ISLA timeframe, severity and practicability, financial markets.
Securities Lending Conference in Texas which is indeed detrimental to smooth
Faulkner: I think it’s been fairly inef- a gentleman at a round table said after operations and requires 2. Would you perceive a change in
fective and there’s work to be done the SEC brought in new legislation the specific monitoring. relationship with the regulators given
to analyse exactly how ineffective. I industry responded within 24 hours the recent kneejerk legislation?
think some of the bans were politically with 27 questions, with two answers. So Payson: Given the severity of the global
expedient and owed very much to the the practitioners in the epicentre of the credit crisis and the recent extreme Faulkner: I think the relationship with
school of ‘being seen to be doing some- lending and borrowing business don’t volatility in equity markets worldwide, it regulators on a global basis has been
thing’ rather than reflecting joined-up know the answers, so it’s no surprise to is not surprising that regulators around collegiate and communicative and
thinking. I think it’s clear when the me that the institutional suppliers don’t the globe have felt compelled to take these are extraordinary times. I think
FSA continually says it realises short know either. any action they feel may stem declin- it’s a bit odd to look at sec lending in
selling has a fundamental role to play in ing equity valuations. What remains isolation, but the regulators on a glob-
the efficient functioning of the capital D’Albrand: I believe that the bans were uncertain, however, is the actual impact al basis were as surprised as anyone
markets, and it’s just at this extraor- viewed as necessary to reassure the such actions have had upon capital else by what’s going on. The emergency
dinary time and it is clear to separate markets. Short selling was making markets. Our primary view is that the powers they’ve cited to allow them to
short selling from naked short selling. headlines in the newspapers so regula- various bans on short selling have been do things at pace are less soft touch
So that’s been quite constructive. But tors had to show that they were taking a relatively blunt instrument to address has been a shock to everyone, includ-
there’s a tremendous amount of uncer- active measures to protect market challenging and complex financial ing themselves. I think regulators will
tainty around certain authorities and I levels. However academic studies have stresses. There remains little evidence look and feel very difficult. Hector
know that ISLA is doing its very best to never shown that Securities Lending to support a causal link between short Sants of the FSA has said the body
seek clarity for the institutions. leads to lower share prices. Despite selling and declining equity market needs more focus, clarity, experience
The bans have not really stemmed the measures that have been taken it valuations. The practice of naked short and intellectual firepower in what is
the decline of markets. The period of is obvious that financial institutions’ selling had already been illegal in many effectively a much more serious game
extreme volatility that the market is stocks are decreasing faster than the countries while the announced ban on than they thought it was. Light touch
enduring has not been assisted by these declining market. This would indicate all short selling penalized legitimate may be replace by a heavier touch.
bans. The bans are also quite different, that Securities Lending is not a cause of investment practices. People will expect more regulation, and
it’s difficult to collectively deal with high volatility. The Securities Lending We are hopeful that global regulators strategies that have been blown out of
them. They haven’t necessarily achieved industry is paramount in providing will revisit the imposed rules while con- the water by the stroke of a regulator’s
the objective of the more balanced, liquidity in the market. Liquidity exists sidering all perspectives surrounding pen will be very difficult for people to
less volatile markets. The motivation because people borrow and lend. It is short-selling and ancillary transactions, embrace going forward. So there may
and justification I would question not banning the lending and borrowing including securities lending. We are be sections of the hedge fund market
as being political, not economic. So of securities that makes the market likewise in support of thoughtful and that may never recover from this.
many other moving parts have been more stable. well-planned regulation and enforce- Convertible bonds were having a chal-
applied to the markets – government Furthermore, countries did not agree ment actions designed to combat illegal lenging time, broadly speaking, a flat
interventions, bailouts – so it’s difficult upon a common rule. The measures naked short selling which works to year, and some of the largest players
32
Activate your dormant assets with Eurex SecLend and increase your profitability in the
securities finance business. This fully integrated electronic market place for fixed income
and equity lending & borrowing with a unique range of automated post trade services grants
secure high volume transaction processing at low cost. With Eurex SecLend your availability
of securities will find its market demand at highest pace. www.eurexseclend.com
Panel Debate Securities Lending ISJ | Investor Services Journal
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56
are nursing losses so large they may well the volume on loan has increased upgraded the quality of their collateral, treated each transaction on an ad hoc
be out of the business. The bottom line dramatically. How do you account for such as only accepting cash, with cer- basis to provide alternative solutions
is they were terribly shocked, and ‘once this discrepancy? tain counterparts. with counterparts who appeared on
bitten, twice shy’ is the people will look our watchlist.
at this going forward and in it will factor Carruthers of Data Explorers: Data 4. Have increased margins affected
into the contracts that are written, the Explorers has an index put together lending activity? Payson: As it relates to increased mar-
business done, the strategies pursued recently based around 300 stocks, gin, we assume this is in reference to
and the risk appetite of all people en- looking at quantities, not values. It is Faulkner: I think this is a very hot the prime broker’s decision to increase
gaged in all aspects of capital markets split between UK, US, Europe and Asia. topic. When one asks for margin on a the margin requirement for positions
that the game, rules and pitch can be For each region there are two indices: collateralised business, they are looking held by hedge funds. Although not a
changed by external factors. the amount of stock made available by for security and safety. It’s extremely direct impact to lenders it can be as-
beneficial owners, and how much of easy to ask for more margin; whether sumed that this has contributed to the
D’Albrand: Regulators were extremely that is on loan. Since 1st September or not you can get it is another thing. deleveraging phenomenon and, in turn,
proactive in changing rules but also very the amount available has dropped fairly Historically the industry has settled has caused balances at agent lenders
concerned with the industry’s opinion steadily, but particularly since Lehman at three levels: zero, 2% or 5%, and to decrease. As they sell long positions
of the markets. Many meetings between Brothers’ collapse it is now down 10- the industry has got comfortable with they will also be forced to cover shorts
the financial industry and regulators 12%. That’s partly from people doing that. Those numbers are shown to be and return shares to lenders.
took place in the post-Lehman period less lending. The quantity on loan has insufficient in many cases; so there is
that has certainly increased the regula- been moving a lot depending on the a broad but disparate effort on certain 5. How necessary is the current review
tors’ recognition of the importance of region. A lot of stock got caught in the parties to get those margins to change. of the Global Master Securities Lend-
the Securities Lending business. Regu- system, including repo, so a lot of the That means the margins – typically – ing Agreement for the industry?
lators were eager to listen and to ensure agent lenders made good to the owners go up. The capital that the borrowers
that the new rules were fully understood whose stock was temporarily missing by have to put up for raising margins is Faulkner: One thing that’s always neces-
by market participants. Although some borrowing. So there was a big increase extremely expensive and they’re very sary in any industry is the constant
traders complained about the restric- in loans that wasn’t necessarily to do reticent to do this; so put your margins review of the legal, tax, regulatory and
tions, most measures were implemented with short selling. Following various up too high and you will lose business. compliance environment. The GMSLA
as financial institutions’ management short selling restrictions, people went Some people have to put their margins has stood up reasonably well. The
were worried about a fall in their share looking for anything they could short, up to retain cash collateral. There’s this problem is most organisations don’t
price and were eager to see regulators so there was a big increase in loans - bilateral ‘one-to-many’ or ‘one-to-one’ use it and they have their own language
talk and take an active stance to protect and probably shorting - in Asia, where discussion and maybe there needs to that might cover some areas as critical
the market. there were fewer restrictions. Now the be a broader discussion of maybe the as indemnification and what happens in
Asian positions have come back down, adoptions of standards that people the case of default. I think it’s shown it-
Payson: While the recent extreme mar- but in the US it has bounced around can understand that factor in a whole self to be broadly robust, but everything
ket conditions have certainly demanded a lot. This has been partly down to range of different important variables: always needs updating. And again, the
a regulatory response, the effectiveness Lehman’s collapse, where people seek what are the asset classes - cash nor bilateral element – where people say
of this response cannot yet be fully to cover specific names, but also some non-cash – you’re taking as collateral ‘it’s a good idea that there’s a global
assessed. However, one benefit of the genuine build up in short positions in and lending; what is the credit quality, master, but here’s our idea of the global
recent changes has been an increase some very large stocks. not just the rating but maybe the CDS master’ - means it isn’t the real Agree-
in the dialogue between industry Amid hedge funds deleverage you brand, counterpart quality, what is the ment but a different version.
associations such as the RMA or SIFMA would expect to see a decline in short- foreign exchange volatility – which is I’m not sure how much of the business
and local regulators. The challenge for ing; shorting declined in UK stock quite absolutely huge at the moment. This done under the terms of the GMSLA
the industry will now be to foster these dramatically between September and business is broadly viewed through the without amendments, but it’s a good
relationships to increase communica- now; it’s beginning to stabilise. In eyes of someone mainly in US dollars. international framework for doing
tion and understanding, ensuring Europe it has bounced around but is The markets are off maybe 40% globally business. I think the challenges as-
future policy can be developed in a way pretty much where it was. In Asia it saw recently, and the dollar has appreci- sociated with the seizing of assets by
that maximises benefits to industry par- a huge increase followed by a decrease. ated about 20% against a basket of the administrators associated with
ticipants while minimising unintended In the US, the volume is bouncing currencies. That’s 60% that the market the Lehman Brothers prime brokerage
adverse impacts. As the awareness of around but growing. In general, people can’t control! That’s way beyond a 5% business will taint UK law and there will
securities lending increases, the role are shorting US stocks more, despite margin. It’s in nobody’s best interest to be potentially rigorous clarity required
it plays in support of efficient financial the deleveraging. have this constant operation expense. regarding this. I think if you don’t have
markets and the enablement of viable People want it to be capital and op- confidence and don’t have trust in your
investment strategies will become more D’Albrand: While I have seen a sharp erationally efficient. There’s a need for counterparts you shouldn’t be doing
clear. The level of dialogue between the decrease in lendable assets in the mar- the industry to sit down when the dust business with them, and you do need
securities lending industry and local ket, I have not witnessed any increase in settles to work through these issues and that confidence and trust reinforced by
regulators is likely to increase. the volumes on loans neither for bonds set more appropriate standards that can a valid and dependable legal contract.
nor for equities. What we have seen is a ratched up or down depending on I don’t think this contract is in anyway
Gonzalez: Our relation with regulators sharp increase in lending conditions of the marketplace. flawed; it needs revising, these thing as
remains very close and fruitful. We don’t those fixed income products that were always do, but it’s not a top-of-agenda
see any change in that as a result of the eligible for the central bank auctions. D’Albrand: Increasing margins in vola- item: the industry has bigger issues.
recent market turmoil. Due to the lack of market liquidity it has tile and risky markets is a normal course
certainly been difficult to recall loans of action. The most natural move was to D’Albrand: The current GMSLA works.
3. According to the latest research, and many lenders who had balances get cash collateral to eliminate market Nonetheless it is important for lenders
the available stock for lending globally with borrowers kept their balances but risk on collateral value. However, as and borrowers to review the legal
has decreased in the last month but increased dramatically the haircut or liquidity on the market was tight we coverage of default situations, such as a
34
35
product will likely gain momentum in insurance company or a mutual fund, securities lending program. institution, sign up to be part of a se-
the coming years as participants look to you’re an expert in what you do, and With sound leadership and prudent curities lending program, I want to buy
further enhance price transparency and this is a very important but peripheral management, securities lending will just that; I don’t want to be manoeuvred
manage counterparty risk. activity - you don’t want it to be more continue to be the lubricant to financial into an aggressive, leveraged securities
complicated that it needs to be. The markets allowing superior liquidity, financing business. If I chose to take
Gonzalez: SLB has a long history of op- industry needs a clear and single voice increased price transparency, and cash collateral, I want to make sure my
erating as an over-the-counter market. and think about how they communicate enhanced transaction settlement. risk appetite is clearly understood, and
However, the days when markets worked with clients, regulators and the press, Education and collaboration between the asset management process taken in
in splendid isolation are gone. If there so they can give central coherence an- associations and local regulators - as my name by my provider is appropriate.
is something introduced in one market swer to simple questions they struggle described in my response to the second-
which brings about efficiency, it will with. The challenge is how to communi- question - are key. D’Albrand: The high quality of securities
inevitably cross over into other assets. cate the benefits of participation in this received as collateral, diversification
The difficulty is that sometimes change business and put them into context. Gonzalez: There is a need to update of securities received and a sufficient
is resisted. This is understandable to the SLB market – to make it more haircut to cover for market volatility of
an extent. One of the biggest fears D’Albrand: Transforming securities standardised. It has played a key role in those securities received as collateral
surrounding greater use of electronic liquidity into cash liquidity is one of the liquidity provision over the past years, are all factors that mitigate the risks of
markets is that they erode margins. main functions of securities lending. but unfortunately SLB is relatively lending cash. The golden rule though is
However, history has shown that this is However, in the absence of liquidity backward when compared to many that as responsible bankers we should
more than compensated by an increase going into cash/money markets, the other markets. not do a trade because we think the
in volumes and counterparties, because upsurge in issuer risks and the risk The European repo market has seen quality of collateral is sufficient but be-
more particpants are willing to trade if & compliance constraints on cash the impact of standardisation over the cause the credit quality of the borrower
they know something’s value. So easier reinvestment, receiving cash liquidity past year. Clearly defined and easily ac- is solid. Customers’ asset protection
price discovery – or transparency – is as collateral has proved to be difficult. cessible baskets of securities are a must. dictates to remain simple. Subsequent-
something which is in the longer term Securities lending can play the role of a The standardisation is a pre-requisite ly, dynamic counterparty analysis is the
beneficial. There is no reason why this lock between the securities market and for technological development. The first step in entering into any trade in
won’t be the case in SLB. the money market provided that there is SLB market has been quite slow to the current market environment.
Electronic trading will make it easier liquidity in the two pools. This liquidity implement electronic trading and this
to integrate SLB activities into the is only there if confidence among partic- has made it harder for institutions to Gonzalez: The repo market does provide
general funding operations of financial ipants exists. The market is conservative integrate their systems with those they lessons about how SLB could develop.
institutions. If there was ever any doubt at the moment. For most institutions, use elsewhere. This hinders their ability Many people have been surprised that
of the importance of having an overall the current focus is primarily internal to get an accurate, real-time appraisal volumes generally in the Euro-Zone
view of an institution’s liquidity posi- as they need to provide liquidity to their of their funding position and, if they have declined since the start of the sub-
tion, there isn’t now. Electronic trading clients and not to the market. are client facing, their overall exposure prime crisis – credit fears have proved
also facilitates other efficiencies, such to their customers. Looking ahead, and too great for the bilateral market to
as straight-through-processing and Payson: The securities lending industry making a small prediction, it is clear function. The notable exception to this
genuine real-time risk management has enjoyed steady growth over the past that institutions will need to make their has been Eurex Repo, which provides a
and allows for a greater distribution 30 years in response to rising financial work as efficient as possible. To do this fully electronic collateralised funding
of product to a wider base of potential markets and increased participation by requires an efficient mechanism across marketplace, supported by a central
counterparties. There are many posi- beneficial owners. That confidence has the entire value chain –this will drive counterparty, which virtually removes
tives. been shaken recently due to a several the uptake of electronic trading and counterparty risk. In particular, its
high-profile negative events. This has standardisation in SLB. Eurex Repo’s GC Pooling segment has
7. Securities lending is often cited as a resulted in increased scrutiny from shown its true worth over the last
vital provider of liquidity. What more beneficial owners, regulators, and the 8. To what degree is lending cash – year. GC Pooling is an automated and
needs to happen for the industry to media. It is important for the industry with securities as collateral – a risk, standardised funding market, made up
gain even more prominence and fulfil to clarify that all securities lending and how do you mitigate that risk? of baskets of European Central Bank-
its promise/potential? programs are not structured in the eligible securities. It has become an
same way and that securities lending Faulkner: Not very well by some, much extremely important way of securing
Faulkner: I think the industry would can be managed in a way that avoids better by others. One of the things that central bank liquidity. In Switzerland,
probably be keen to have a lower profile. unnecessary risks to investors. Actions we’ve always advocated was the identi- the Swiss National Bank conducts its
The industry needs to regroup and that must be undertaken to confirm the fication that there were many routes for monetary policy almost totally via Eurex
come across to prospective customers continued viability of securities lending a lender to participate in the lending Repo. If you want central bank funding,
and regulators and press with a clear include: providing increased transpar- market. You could be exclusive, be in- it has to be done on a collateralised
message of the benefits of this activity. ency to participants, allowing them to dependent, go through an agent, go to basis. n
It struck me at the RMA Annual Confer- fully understand the risks and benefits a third party. But perhaps to the extent
ence on Securities Lending in Texas that of lending; adopt a “back to basics” that cash reinvestment and programs
when asked a question, most people mentality that avoids overly complex could be more bespoke at the style
can’t really articulate why the business transactions and transactions that do and experience to execute could differ
is a good one and how it contributes not provide a compelling return for provider to provider was overlooked.
to the efficient workings of the capital the risk assumed, and undertaking an Plain vanilla securities lending doesn’t
markets in words of one syllable. It initiative to unite the industry with the exist, nor cash investment – there are
becomes too complicated too quickly. goal of reinforcing the benefits provided so many ways to do it. What is required
If you’re a pension fund manager, an to capital markets by a robust and active is a ‘back-to-basics’ approach. If I, as an
36
Collateral thinking
Collateral in tri-party repo has shown itself to
be the answer when mitigating counterparty
risk, but it needs to be approached with
a degree of flexiblity in volatile markets, finds
Brian Bollen
period, comments Staffan Ahlner, man- organised through pooled group struc-
aging director, Global Collateral Man- tures, afforded some stellar returns with
agement, at The Bank of New York an overriding focus on revenue genera-
Mellon. “Tri-party repo had never been tion, not risk. But a number of recent
tested in the market until September 15; factors, not least the high profile collapse
no-one had ever gone into default on of Lehman Brothers, created market vol-
such a major scale, the default showed atility that forced certain lending agents
that tri-party worked. Some major in- to unwind cash investments in order to
stitutions had their collateral back by free up cash collateral as the correspond-
Monday 15th September, tri-party did ing loans were terminated. In some cases,
enable them to take very quick action to the unwinding of such investments can
protect themselves. The subsequent scale potentially lead to significant losses for
of selling of collateral might have driven engaged market participants – triggering
down the prices fetched, but that was is fresh client concern and creating poten-
market issue, not a tri-party repo issue.” tial reputation issues for banks running
Attitudes have changed too, he adds. cash-reliant lending programmes.
“Previously, institutions were preparing Susan Pike, global head of market
for an event that they thought would products and services at RBC Dexia In-
The international financial services sys- never happen. Now that it has hap- vestor Services, says: “The cash-based
tem has been stress-tested almost to pened, they are taking a more practical approach to col-
destruction over recent months, and approach to the subject. How do I manage it? How do I get lateral manage-
few parts of it have emerged with much my assets? The market has had a crash course on insolvency ment has not
credit. The importance of collateral procedures and the knowledge of how to manage assets in been without its
management, however, has been recog- an insolvency has grown greatly. Collateral needs to be ring- problems in the
nised more than ever, and its reputation fenced and maintained.” In this more wary environment, the current market.
enhanced, if one agrees with industry transaction sizes being collateralised are significantly smaller, When providers
observations. every exposure is collateralised not only repo and stock loan took cash collat-
“I believe the recent market turmoil transactions. “Collateral management is eral they were, in
has given hard evidence for the need to collateralise exposures, being redefined,” he adds. “Where in the many cases, plac-
as well as to have risk-controlled procedures in place to mo- past we might have seen collateralised ing this in money
bilise and monitor collateral obligations,” says Cedric Gillerot, transactions of around USD200 million, market funds or
director, Collateral Services, Euroclear. “Recent events have today we are seeing collateral required pooled funds – in-
put the spotlight on those firms that have and have not fol- for USD10-USD20 million.” vested as a group.
lowed good business practices in this regard. The key lessons A number of custodian banks have This strategy was
learned are to know your counterparty and take the necessary traditionally provided collateral man- all about getting
precautions to protect your firm and your clients’ business in agement programmes heavily based a better return on
the event there are more casualties from the liquidity and credit on cash reinvested in money market investment. But
crisis.” instruments to generate high returns. the problem with
The landscape has changed completely in a relatively short Until recently these instruments, often money market
38
base in
bermuda
a proactive jurisdiction with a premier reputation • low cost set-up and administration • speed and precision
Cedar House, 20 Victoria Street, Hamilton HM12 Bermuda tel.441.292.0632 fax.441.292.1797 www.BIBA.org
Securities Lending ISJ | Investor Services Journal
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56
funds is that if, as agreements that support them. Going forward, the amount of volumes picked up as the trend towards
has happened in reporting clients are going to be asking for and the amount of secured financing developed. Today we
the recent mar- due diligence they are going to want to do on collateral mix and regularly register monthly outstanding
ket, you get a large counterparties involved will increase significantly. The param- volumes above € 400 billion when we
number of clients eterisation of how collateral is managed and the diversification only crossed the EUR300 billion thresh-
pulling out of away from cash into multiple types of instruments can only old a year ago. Growth is even more
them at the same grow.” significant when you look at the longer
time, then, depending on where those For Brian Staunton, Citi’s head term. Volumes grew 30% in 2007 over
investments are, you can actually realise of securities finance for EMEA, Global 2006 and are growing even more in 2008
losses on them. This has happened re- Transaction Services, the most signifi- compared to 2007. In 2005, monthly out-
cently – with a significant reduction in cant change in the market in recent times standing volumes were EUR183 billion,
the value of some money market funds.” is the sheer scale and complexity of col- in 2007 EUR327 billion and so far in
The issues surrounding cash-based col- lateral management. “Our business has 2008 EUR395 billion. The overall qual-
lateral management programmes are increased significantly over that period, ity of the collateral has also significantly
now encouraging some securities lend- partly because of the move by investors improved as eligibility criteria requested
ing clients to seriously consider other away from investing in the unsecured by all participants have been amended
programme options that reduce risk. markets and towards investing in the along the line.”
Collateral flexibility includes accessing secured markets like repo’s. This raises Wilkin believes secured lending is
more types of sovereign debt, allowing some questions. Can your systems han- “here to stay”, with many players look-
for a prudent mix of equities as collateral dle the volume, and the growth in the ing at all types of assets on the balance
and a better understanding of how a dif- volume? If it isn’t scaleable, you have a sheet and trying to turn them as much
ferent mix can affect risk. This entails an major problem.” as possible into some form of collateral
educative process for beneficial owners. Moreover, he adds, smaller players value. “Right now the issue for us is to
But the better the communication and will struggle to offer a global integrated cope with the demand from new cus-
strategic partnerships between provid- collateral management service. “If you tomers wanting to join our programme.
ers and underlying clients, the better the want to use Asian assets, for instance, for We see customers knocking on our door
recipe for creating additional value and repo collateralise in the US, you need a who we had never been able to attract
understanding what is driving that re- physical geographic presence in the US; before. And this includes new type of
turn. you need global capacity to meet local clients, such as corporates, or insurance
Although the current market has re- needs on a global scale, and not many in- companies when we see large corpora-
duced demand for some key securities stitutions can call themselves truly global tions asking for collateral from banks.”
lending demand drivers – such as short players.” As a result of the recent liquidity and
credit crisis, firms are monitoring their
The recent market turmoil has given hard risks, exposures and collateral positions
evidence for the need to collateralise much more tightly, says Cedric Gillerot.
“It is common knowledge that the inter-
exposure Cedric Guillerot, Euroclear bank money market has declined sub-
stantially over the past couple of months,”
he says. “Therefore, it should come as no
selling and hedge fund-related activity Jean Robert Wilkin, head of global se- surprise that when firms now trade with
– Pike believes demand will return over curities financing product management, each other, they are taking measures to
time, albeit with much greater scrutiny Clearstream, also has something to say collateralise their exposures vis-à-vis
of lending and collateral management on the question of volumes. “When the their counterparties across a broad range
arrangements. “In the months and years subprime crisis started a year ago we first of transactions. They are also seeking
ahead we expect collateral management saw a decline in the volumes of our glob- to make the collateralisation process as
to become one of the key focuses,” she al securities financings products which risk-controlled and efficient as possible.
says. “With everything that has happened encompass securities lending, tri-party We expect this trend will continue into
in the market in the last 12 months there repo, derivatives, collateralisation of cen- the foreseeable future as an appropriate
has been a big change in attitudes related tral banks and many other applications business practice and, in time, possibly
to the significance, risk and importance for collateral management,” he says. as a result of more stringent regulatory
of collateral management and the legal “Then after just a couple of months, the pressures.”
40
“We are now seeing a broader mix of offer is our statistics: In 2005, the aver- The pressure placed on the industry’s in-
firms that are collateralising exposures age daily collateral provision outstand- frastructure by recent credit events has
across a wider spectrum of transactions, ing within the Euroclear group was the had a direct impact on how a company
ie, repo, securities lending, secured loan equivalent of EUR480 billion, which has like Omgeo, the post-trade, pre-settle-
and derivatives transactions, as well as grown to nearly EUR600 billion per day.” ment management firm, is changing to
for central counterparty margin manage- Revel Wood, Northern Trust’s global reflect the evolving situation. “It height-
ment purposes. In addition, as a result of product manager for derivatives, reports ened our awareness of the extent of the
the recent increased intermediation by increasing demand for what he calls strin- challenge we face in servicing the indus-
central banks in order to ease the pres- gent and robust collateral management. try,” says Tim Lind, managing director,
sures within the inter-bank money mar- “The events of the past 12 to 15 months strategic planning, Omgeo. “Modern in-
kets, we have seen increased focus on the have highlighted the risks involved in vestment styles create ongoing credit and
collateralisation of central bank credit conducting transactions on an uncollat- counterparty exposure whether through
facilities. We have also seen a gentle tight- eralised basis; there is a whole lot more derivatives, repo or securities lending,
ening of the collateral eligibility profiles emphasis today on monitoring your col- and a new need for valuation services
in 2007 and a more sharply defined trend lateral at the individual risk and exposure when marking to market. Most opera-
in 2008. Collateral takers are now more level and knowing where it is at any one tions and settlement infrastructure is
thoroughly reviewing the basket of col- time. All the traditional players have seen designed to settle a security and hold it
lateral they are willing to accept. When a flight to safety in terms of where their in an account, but securities don’t sit in
going further, and comparing today with collateral is held. A huge number of cli- an account any more. They are pledged as
three to five years ago, today there is a ents who previously left collateral with collateral and change every day. We need
distinct trend of ever-increasing use of a counterparty now want it left with a a more effective way to monitor exposure
collateral to manage exposures and risks global custodian. A number of lessons intraday, and to adjust as necessary.”
associated with a growing list of trans- have been driven home by the collapse of The need for such adjustments ex-
action types. The best evidence we can a cornerstone of the banking world.” plain Omgeo’s recent purchase of Allus-
tra, the London-based provider of collat-
eral management solutions, which claims
to offer a suite of products that provide
customers the ability to consolidate trade
positions across asset classes, including
OTC derivatives, while mitigating the as-
sociated counterparty risk. “We looked
at how Omgeo could enter the market,
which is very adjacent to our traditional
markets. Given the speed at which we
think it will unfold, we didn’t have time
to design and build our own solution. We
had to acquire, and Allustra stood out.”
But how long will this new conser-
vatism last? Medical practitioners gen-
erally estimate that when they scare a
heavy drinker into giving up alcohol,
the subsequent dry period will only
last approximately six months. His-
tory suggests the financial markets be-
have in a similar way. “How long is col-
lective corporate memory?” asks BNY
Modern investment styles create ongoing Mellon’s Staffan Ahlner. “We have seen
41
Administering a nation
Catherine Kemp discovers a gradual opening in the insulated world of
Japanese fund administration
Japan is very much a scale business. The
three major Japanese ‘trustee’ banks for
fund administration - Master Trust Bank
of Japan (MTBJ), Japan Trustee Services
Bank (JTSB) and Trust & Custody Ser-
vices Bank (TCSB) - were created specifi-
cally to provide trustee and back office
fund administrative services for Japanese
mutual funds, institutional pension funds
and government pension funds and pro-
vide Japanese accounting at competitive
rates.
Major domestic banks have a vested
interest in these institutions. Mitsubishi
owns a 46.5% stake in MTBJ, Sumitomo
Trust and Mitsui Trust each hold 33%
stakes in JTSB, and Mizuho Financial
Group owns a 54% stake in JTSB.
The only two global banks with a sig-
nificant presence in the onshore retail
and institutional market are State Street
and Citi. State Street has 400 members of
staff and provides Japanese trust services
for pension funds and insurance compa-
nies. It also provides traditional middle
office and investment manager report-
ing services to global funds. Citi merged
with Nikko bank in 1999, and the result-
ing Nikko Citigroup provides trustee
and fiduciary services to retail and mu-
tual funds and also acts as an outsourcing
agent to fund managers - a pricing agent,
as they cal it in Japan – providing net as-
set value calculations for mutual funds.
The main driver of the Japanese funds
industry has traditionally been high net
worth individuals. The character and
shape of the mutual funds industry is
very much influenced by these investors.
The structure is similar to the US model,
except that in the US the fund manager is
the distributor; in Japan, the distributor
is an independent brokerage house. The
distributor will have retail clients, often
high net worth individuals, who will ap-
proach the fund managers and ask them
to develop specific products based on
42
market trends. The managers build the the one hand are the trustee banks that
products and the distributor offers it on focus on the retail and long only space. Japanese fund allocation
their platform. The distributor then ap- Then there are global banks like BNY
points the trustee bank, the global custo- Mellon with relationship managers that
dian, and anyone else that supports the offer investors access to the banks off-
portfolio. In a mutual fund sense, there- shore domiciled and administrated hedge
fore, the distributors instruct the fund funds.
manager as to what they need on their “There are a large volume of both tra-
platform. ditional and alternative investment strat-
Despite a tradition of long-only strat- egy offshore funds that are invested into
egies and mainstream asset classes, there by investors in Japan, some institutional
is an increasing drive into the alternative and some retail money, and the admin-
funds space. Matt Brown, regional head istrators for that part of the business are
of fund services at Citi, says: “The alter- not limited to the three large Japanese
43
few years, this has changed, and Citi and see how they can apply the newer invest- for investors.
State Street are preparing for this change. ment strategies in the best possible way, The recent acquisition of Lehman
State Street plans to reinforce its team and while the offshore business is a stable Brothers’ staff and technology by prime
in order to offer pricing services to this business and will continue to grow, you broker Nomura, and Mitsubishi’s acqui-
market, something Citi already provides. are going to see more organisations look sition of 20% of Morgan Stanley, has also
Andrew Erickson of State Street’s In- to do that onshore. I believe that onshore altered the banking industry in Japan.
vestor Services team explains: “This new complexity will continue to grow and These acquisitions signal the a greater
investment culture has been expanding both will increase overtime accordingly.” crossover between Japanese banks and
steadily for the past three years,” he says. While it may be time for change in the global financial system.
“We think it will definitely continue to Japan, with the breakdown of this rather However, the recent economic down-
grow and that the time is right to begin consolidated and inflexible system into a turn may hold back this process of expan-
servicing these new types of assets. We more fluid system, some say that this is sion. Japan’s direct exposure to sub prime
plan to bring global standards of pricing highly unlikely, at least in the alternatives or related issues was initially very small,
services to Japan and roll that out to a sector. with the domestic economy largely unaf-
44
Analyse This:
Caribbean Fund Service
Robert Briant, managing partner at law firm Conyers Dill & Pearman,
British Virgin Islands, provides a double header of legal analysis
an investor between a creditor and What are the fiduciary
a shareholder. duties of a director to a fund?
Of issue is the point in time at
which the directors and manager The statute requires directors to act
perceive the fund as starting to be honestly and in good faith in what they
“in trouble”. From this point onward, believe to be in the best interests of
they need to consider how to treat all the company. The memorandum and
investors fairly. Unless redemptions articles of association are generally very
were suspended as of such point in time, broadly drafted to be consistent with
anyone who submitted a redemption such a framework. The memorandum
request which has crystallised has ceased and articles of association also set out
to be a shareholder. Rather, the person the rules on which the fund operates.
is a creditor, and all shareholders who Hedge fund directors must be
have not submitted redemption requests particularly aware of the provisions
or whose redemption requests have not relating to the suspension of
What are the implications crystallised remain shareholders. redemptions and the calculation of
of the credit crunch to fund advice As with any corporate vehicle, net asset value. The memorandum
in the British Virgin Islands? creditors get paid prior to shareholders. and articles of association will govern
As such, these creditor redeemers may these provisions, rather than the private
Although we will, of course, feel the get a higher net asset value than non- placement memorandum. The two
effects of a global recession, the British redeemers. This puts considerable stress documents should be consistent, but this
Virgin Islands are perhaps less directly on the directors in determining when to is not always the case.
tied to the crisis than other jurisdictions. suspend redemptions. Where there is inconsistency
The large number of BVI holding Many funds are receiving redemption between these two documents, it is the
companies around the world continues requests that are triggering their gating memorandum and articles of association
to bring corporate work, and with the provisions. The directors, especially the which will govern the mechanics of
opening of the new commercial court independent directors, need to seriously redemptions, calculation of net asset
and the strength of BVI’s insolvency consider the future life of the fund, or value and suspension. There may be
legislation, BVI maintains its position as more specifically whether it has a life. If a remedy for breach of contract if the
one of the most popular offshore hedge the gate is being triggered, then the fund PPM differs, but you must look at the
fund jurisdictions. may be in crisis, and it may be more memorandum and articles of association
In the current climate, advising funds suitable to suspend redemptions and to determine the mechanics.
in distress is a busy area, particularly start treating all shareholders equally by Therefore, the directors cannot
for Conyers Dill & Pearman. It is times redeeming all shareholders and planning merely rely on the PPM of the offshore
like this when the efforts in structuring an orderly wind down. fund but rather should review the
funds come to the forefront and what This is difficult, especially for the memorandum and articles of association
works and what does not work becomes manager who set up the fund, but if the to determine their obligations.
more apparent. directors wait too long and rely on the Directors who do not do so may be
When a fund is in difficulty, its gate then they risk possible law suits for in for a surprise when counsel for an
directors must be careful to act within failing to suspend redemptions earlier. investor sets out a different redemption
the scope of the fund documents. In However, if the fund otherwise has legs parameter from that in the PPM. n
the case of redemptions, the timing of a as well as gates, then gates could be
redemption request and whether it has utilised if there are immediate but not
crystallised can dramatically differentiate long term liquidity problems. n
46
47
BHF-BANK is one of Germany’s most CACEIS, with EUR2.3tr under custody DnB NOR is the largest and leading
prestigious private banks. Its roots date and EUR950bn under administration is provider of Custody, Clearing and
GOAL is the widely-acknowledged back to the year 1854. As an advisory, one of the world’s leading asset servicing Remote Member Service in Norway. In
industry leader in providing creative service and sales & trading bank, we offer providers, dedicated to institutional addition, DnB NOR provides a wide range
products, services and solutions to our discerning clientele a comprehensive and corporate clients and the premier of value added services to both Foreign
automate and optimise the global array of customised solutions. BHF-BANK provider in the sizeable French market. and Domestic clients.
reclamation of withholding tax and class combines the strengths of a private bank We are rated AA- by S&P, which reflects Through an Alliance solution with banks
action compensation. Our research has with a long track record of capital market the significant financial support of our in Sweden, Finland and Denmark, DnB
shown that in excess of US$6 billion competence. shareholders, Crédit Agricole S.A. and NOR can offer seamless regional products,
of withholding tax remains unclaimed Trust, an individual approach and Natixis. Our services combine powerful IT which can be customized to our client’s
each year by the rightful owners and impartiality - these qualities are at the systems and expert staff to help clients needs.
beneficiaries and the amounts for class very heart of the long-term guidance reduce their costs, improve service quality
actions is even larger. and advice we provide for our clients. Our to their investors and focus on their core T: +47 22 94 92 95
bank’s activities are grouped within the business. F: +47 22 48 28 46
T: +44 (0) 844 499 6388 divisions Asset Management & Financial Through offices across Europe and North Contact: Bente I. Hoem
C: Saghar Bigwood or Services, Financial Markets & Corporates America, CACEIS delivers a comprehensive E: [email protected]
Stephen Everard and Private Banking. set of high quality services, covering W: www.dnbnor.com
A: 7th Floor, 69 Park Lane, The bank’s longstanding experience custody and depositary/trustee, fund
Croydon, CR9 1BG in the German securities services administration, transfer agency and
E: [email protected] or market goes hand in hand with a corporate trust.
[email protected] or corporate culture that values prompt
[email protected] acknowledgements and short decision- International: Olivier Storme
making channels. T: +352 4767 2847
BHF-Bank offers tailor-made custody E: [email protected]
Consultants|Consultancy services to meet its clients’ particular
requirements. It’s reporting services France: Patrick Lemuet
include a comprehensive SWIFT reporting T: +33 (0)1 57 78 03 34
matrix as well as its Internet-based E: [email protected]
reporting tool cds@web. Assets under
Custody: EUR309 bn No of funds: 409
C: Cornelia Keth
T: +49 69 718 3738
SMA Financial is the UK’s premier provider
F: +49 69 718 6050 Nordea is the leading financial services
of SWIFT services and a long standing
E: [email protected] group in the Nordic and Baltic Sea region
business partner of SWIFT. SMA’s vast
C: Moritz Ostwald KBL, leading service provider in the and operates through three business
experience in the banking and securities
T: +49 69 718 6838 Luxembourg fund industry, offers areas: Nordic Banking, Banking & Capital
industry has provided high quality
E: [email protected] one-stop shop facilities to international Market Products and Savings & Life
provision of SWIFT related consultancy,
A: Strahlenbergerstraße 45, fund promoters. Product structuring Products.
training, system care and bureau services
63067 Offenbach a.Main (of SICAV, FCP, SIF, SICAR, SEPCAV, Nordea is the leading custody services
which is second to none. SMA prides itself
Germany …), global custody services as well as provider in the region. Nordea provides
on their in-depth and highly experienced
W: www.bhf-bank.com an efficient fund administration and high quality, tailor-made custody services
team of consultants chosen from the
transfer agency infrastructure are some for local and foreign investors dealing
banking and securities industry. The
of our fields of expertise that will bring with Nordic, Baltic or global securities.
introduction of the SWIFT bureau service
added value to the management of your
has witnessed much success by providing
assets. - The leading financial services group in
cost effective and quality hosted
For all kinds of Undertakings for the Nordic and Baltis Sea region
connectivity services to many satisfied
Collective Investment going from plain - A world-leading Internet banking and
clients.
vanilla cash, money-market, equity and e-commerce operation
bond funds to sophisticated alternative, - The largest customer base of any
Simon Murby
venture capital/private equity, pension financial services group in the region
Managing Director
pooling and funds of hedge funds, KBL
SMA Financial Limited
offers expert legal, fiscal and technical T: +47 2248 6238
Telephone : +44 (0)20 7940 4200
advice as well as access to the global Contact:
Bramah House,
markets. Anne-Lise Kristiansen
65-71 Bermondsey Street,
London. SE1 3XF Head of Sub-custody and Clearing
Business Development – Email:
Website: www.sma.co.uk Investment Fund & Global [email protected]
Custody Services 43, boulevard Royal
L-2955 Luxembourg
Stéphane Ries
E: [email protected]
Sandra Cortese
E: [email protected]
Stéphane Pesch
E: [email protected]
T : (352)4797 3512
F: (352)4797 73910
www.kbl.lu
48
49
Swedbank provides client-focused custody Market Data & Analytics provides high- Interactive Data Corporation (NYSE:
Santander is Spain’s leading financial
services to domestic and international value real-time market data, indices IDC) is a leading global provider of
institution and the largest bank in the
securities lending (including auto-borrow and back office services. Information financial market data, analytics and
euro zone by market capitalization. Our
facilities), derivative clearing services, from diverse sources are provided to related services to financial institutions,
commitment and contribution to the
proxy voting, full corporate actions and its customers, tailored to their specific active traders and individual investors.
securities industry is well established
income service. Flexibility is an important information needs. Accuracy and The Company’s businesses supply
after more than a century of providing
aspect of Swedbanks products and reliability are ensured by collecting real-time market data, time-sensitive
services in this field.
services. Our dedicated Client Relations the data from the Group’s own trading pricing, evaluations and reference
Santander’s cutting edge technology
Managers and Account Managers are platforms, such as Xetra® and Eurex® data for millions of securities traded
enables it to offer a comprehensive
focused on personalized processing and and cooperation partners like STOXX Ltd. around the world, including hard-to-
array of innovative services in a broad
reporting solutions. and the Irish Stock Exchange. Avox®, value instruments. Many of the world’s
range of markets. Santander currently
Other Features: a majority-owned subsidiary, validates, best-known financial service and
has full local capabilities in Iberian and
- ISO9001:2000 quality certification. corrects, enriches and maintains software companies subscribe to the
Latin American markets along with a
- Swedbank Markets Online (SMO) internet business entity data. With an operational Company’s services in support of their
franchised presence in many others.
information and reporting toolfor Custody model, unique in the industry, Avox® trading, analysis, portfolio management
Santander`s experience and product
and Securities Lending. enables clients to comply with regulatory and valuation activities. Through its
range ensures that every aspect of the
- Nordic Custody alliance with DnB requirements and to achieve a holistic businesses, Interactive Data Pricing
securities business is fully contemplated.
NOR (Norway), OKO Bank (Finland) view of the risk exposure towards a and Reference Data, Interactive Data
and Amagerbanken (Denmark) to offer client. Real-Time Services, Interactive Data
T: Europe: (34) 91 2893932 / 28
regional custody product. Fixed Income Analytics, and eSignal,
T: USA: (1212) 350 39 02
Institutional Assets under Custody: USD Avox the Company has approximately 2,300
W: santanderglobal.com
70 billion Redwither Tower employees in offices located throughout
E: globalsecurities@
Redwither Business Park North America, Europe, Asia and
gruposantander.com
T: +46 8 5859 1800 Wrexham, LL13 9XT Australia.
F: +46 8 7237 147 United Kingdom
C: Neal Meacham, Head of Custody www.interactivedata.com
E: [email protected] T: +44 (1978) 661 813 T: 020 7825 7800
A: S tockholm SE 1 05 3 4 Sw eden F: +44 (1978) 661 668 F: 020 7608 3514
W: www.avox.infow Brendan Beith
European Sales Director
[email protected]
Fitzroy House
13-17 Epworth Street
London EC2A 4DL UK
Standard Chartered leading the way in
Asia, Africa and the Middle East. Unicredit Markets & Investment Banking
(MIB) serves as UniCredit Group’s global
Standard Chartered has a history of over product and competence center for global Telekurs Financial specialises in
150 years in banking and is in many of financial markets and investment banking the procurement, processing and
the world’s fastest-growing markets services, including Custody throughout distribution of international financial SmartCo is a leading provider of data
with an extensive global network of over Central and Eastern Europe, including information. Financial market management solutions for the financial
1,200 branches (including subsidiaries, Austria. specialists at Telekurs Financial gather industry.
associates and joint ventures) in over 50 information from all the world’s major SmartCo’s software, Smart Financial Data
countries in the Asia Pacific Region, South Brand diversitiy under which the group trading venues – directly and in real Hub, covers all the data area, including
Asia, the Middle East, Africa, the United operates (Bank Austria Creditanstalt, time. The Telekurs Financial database financial instruments, market data,
Kingdom and the Americas. HVB, Bank BPH, Bank Pekao, Zagrebacka with its structured, coded securities third parties, funds, transactions, and
Banka and International Moscow Bank), management data is unique in terms provides full connectivity, a powerful
As one of Asia’s leading custodians, has its roots in local market presence and of its depth of information and data and user friendly front-end, traceability,
Standard Chartered has an impressive knowledge, contributing into a single coverage. With offices in 22 countries, quality control, data enrichment and
track record across the 16 Asian markets unified product across the region. In Telekurs Financial combines the customisable workflow.
in which it provides securities services. 2006 the group was recognised by no advantages of global presence and local Our solutions are based on SmartPlanet,
It serves global, regional and local less than 3 independent surveys as being know-how. an innovative technology focused on
custodians and broker-dealers, as well the best region custodian. The group’s data management, and able to meet
as local and regional fund managers. The ability to deliver service excellence Telekurs (UK) Ltd evolving business requirements.
Bank plays a key role in promoting the across 13 markets is the cornerstone of 15 Appold Street SmartCo offers to its customers the
development of these markets and keeping our success. From participation in local London ability to respond in the fastest way to
the international investor community market associations to our inter group EC2A 2NE regulatory and business changes.
informed of industry developments across training sessions, to a client consultative For further information: www.smartco.fr
the region. approach, the group continues to work T: +44 (0) 20 7550 5000 or [email protected]
towards making a single impression - F: +44 (0) 20 7550 5001
C: Neil Daswani, excellence. E: [email protected] SmartCo
Global Head, Securities Services W: www.telekurs.co.uk 37 rue de Liège
T: +65 6517 0022 T: +43 50505-58510 75008 Paris
E: F: +43 50505-58579 France
Neil.Daswani@sg. C: Andreas Petzl , Head of Sales T: + 33 1 58 22 29 60
standardchartered.com and Relationship Management E: [email protected]
W: www.standardchartered.com E: [email protected] W: www.smartco.fr
W: www.hvb-custody.com/
50
Fund Administration
CACEIS is an Investor Services company Folio Administrators Limited, part of the Established in 2002, IMFC Fund As one of the world’s leading third-party fund
with six offices across Europe. Owned Folio Group of Companies supplying fund Services B.V. is a boutique hedge fund administrators, PFPC has over 30 years of
in equal parts by Crédit Agricole and administration, company management, administrator and a trustee with its experience delivering personalised solutions to the
Natixis, CACEIS provides Custody, director services and insurance offices in Amsterdam and Sydney. IMFC global marketplace. PFPC services an international
Fund Administration and Corporate management, is the leading fund offers third parties administration and client base from the United States, Luxembourg,
Trust services to demanding Corporate administration company in the British related services to all type of onshore Ireland and Poland, and from a presence in the
and Institutional clients. We have Virgin Islands. and offshore funds combining high Cayman Islands and London.
considerable expertise in Cross-Border We specialize in servicing the needs of quality, independency, technology,
Fund Distribution Support as well as start-up to medium sized hedge funds, timely calculation with flexibility, A: PNC Financial Services Group, USX Tower,
Alternative Investment and Private Equity covering all aspects of fund formation, experience, custom-made solutions and 600 Grant Street, Mailstop P6-PUSX-36-1,
servicing. structuring and on-going operations. competitive rates. Our services include: Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Our staff have the language skills and We work closely with an extensive number fund set-up and corporate services,
industry knowledge to develop business of banks, brokers, custodians, auditors NAV calculation and other accounting C: [email protected]
relationships into strong partnerships and services, R&T agent and other investors C: [email protected]
and lawyers
our powerful IT systems are constantly to ensure that our clients receive and compliance services.
updated to ensure high levels of process the best independent advice
automation. and structures. For more information visit our website:
CACEIS is responsible for over EUR1.75 www.imfcfundservices.com
trillion held under custody, and over Daniel Cann, Director
EUR850 billion under administration. [email protected] www.imfcfundservices.com
t +31.20.644.4558
International: Olivier Storme William Harris, Director f +31.20.644.2735
T: +352 4767 2847 [email protected] Mrs. Consuelo Nardon
E: [email protected] e: [email protected]
Folio Administrators Limited Rivierstaete Building, Amsteldijk 166,
France: Patrick Lemuet Folio House, Road Town 1079 LH Amsterdam, Netherlands
T: +33 (0)1 57 78 03 34 British Virgin Islands
E: [email protected] www.folioadmin.com
W: www.caceis.com T: 284 494 7065
F: 284 494 8356
51
International Finance
Hedge Fund Administration
Centres
52
Securities Lending
Data Explorers Limited, a specialist and EquiLend is a leading provider of trading eSecLending is a leading global provider JPMorgan’s Securities Lending program
independent company, offers impartial services for the securities finance industry. and administrator of customized securities is unparalleled due in no small part to
quantitative measurement of securities With its robust suite of automated trading lending programs and they have grown the Firm’s breadth of capability, financial
lending performance services to the tools, EquiLend enables its clients to scale their to become one of the largest lending strength, professional expertise and
global securities financing industry. We businesses with great efficiency on a global agents in the marketplace. Their program seamless operations.
help our clients monitor and understand basis in all securities finance markets. Used by has been adopted by some of the world’s
the relative performance of their lending borrowers and lenders throughout the world, largest and most sophisticated asset Our program enables investors to access
activity and risk, and turn raw lending, the EquiLend platform automates formerly gatherers including pension funds, mutual a broad spectrum of lending markets,
borrowing and collateral data into useful, manual trading and post-trade processes. funds, investment mangers and insurance with a diverse borrower base, offering
actionable information. We also provide Using EquiLend’s complete end-to-end companies. eSecLending’s approach has a broad indemnification against
proxies for short selling information. services reduces the risk of potential errors and introduced investment management borrower default, while achieving very
Working with the industry we ensure eliminates the need to maintain costly point- practices to the securities lending competitive bids for their securities - all
information flows are appropriate and to-point connections while allowing firms to industry, offering beneficial owners an of this in an environment designed
peer groups relevant. We are not involved drive down unit costs. Firms can then free more alternative to the custodial lending model. not to compromise the activities of
in transactions. resources to expand their business and grow Through eSecLending, beneficial owners their fund managers. As one of the
All of our services: Performance trading volumes without increasing costs. This have achieved optimal returns, greater founding members of EquiLend, a global
Explorer, Transaction Explorer, Risk makes the EquiLend platform a cost-effective transparency and increased control over automated platform for borrowers and
Explorer, Index Explorer and Report choice for all institutions, regardless of their their program as compared to traditional lenders, JPMorgan is at the forefront of
Explorer are web based and available to size. lending models. technology and is ideally placed given
clients over the internet. eSecLending maintains offices in Boston, its integrated lending, custody and
London and Burlington, Vermont. accounting platforms.
United Kingdom (London) A: 54 Lombard Street, London, EC3V 9EX
2 Seething Lane, T: UK- +44 (0)20 7743 9510 T: US- +1 617 204 4500 New York: William Smith
London, EC3N 4AT C: Michelle Lindenberger T: UK- +44 (0)20 7469 6000 T: 212-623-5664
T +44 (0) 20 7264 7600, E: michelle.lindenberger C: Christopher Jaynes E: [email protected]
F +44 (0) 20 7392 4004 @equilend.com E: [email protected]
United States (New York) W: www.eseclending.com London: Michael Fox
75 Rockefeller A: 17 State Street, 9th Floor A: 175 Federal Street, 11th FL, Boston, MA T: 44 207 742 0256
Plaza, 19th Floor New York, NY, 10004 02110, US E: [email protected]
T: US- +1 212 901 2224
New York C: Michelle Lindenberger A: 1st Floor, 10 King William Street, Sydney: David Brown
10019, USA E: michelle.lindenberger London EC4N 7TW, UK T: (61-2)92504606
T +1 212 710 2210 @equilend.com E: [email protected]
F + 1 212 710 2212 W: www.equilend.com W: www.jpmorgan.com/wss
Julian Pittam
T +44 (0) 207 264 7616
E:julian.pittam@dataexplorers
.com
New York:
Richard Allin Eurex is one of the largest derivatives
T +212 710 2210 (ext 353) exchanges and the leading clearing house Around the world, USD9 trillion
E: richard.allin@data in Europe. Wherever you are located, we in securities financing is managed
explorers.com Santander is the only Spanish financial provide you with access to the benchmark on SunGard’s proven solutions for
www.dataexplorers.com institution with a team exclusively futures and options market for European international and U.S. domestic
dedicated to securities finance & with derivatives. Eurex also offers short term securities lending and repo for over
the purchase of Abbey in 2004 has funding products, such as Eurex Repo. 250 clients. Through our Loanet,
expanded its capacity on a Global basis Eurex Repo is among the forerunners in Global One, Martini and Astec Analytics
with trading teams in London (UK) & providing integrated trading and clearing products and services, we provide
Connecticut (USA). for repo transactions. Eurex’s latest comprehensive business solutions and
Santander’s leading local capabilities innovative marketplace is called Eurex information with worldwide reach for
FINACE® is the only fully integrated in Spain, Portugal, UK, USA & Latin SecLend. equities or fixed income securities
solution today which supports the America, along with its solid balance Eurex SecLend. Europe’s leading financing. These solutions – all in an
future business model within the area sheet & combined with the state-of- investment banks participate as borrowers integrated, exception-based processing
of Securities Finance and Collateral the-art technology, provides its clients in the Eurex SecLend marketplace, architecture – includes order routing,
Management. The architecture of with the broadest range of solutions in acting as principal brokers, dealers and pre-trade analytics, trading, position
FINACE® is based on a stable, leading securities lending & financing, including intermediaries. They all benefit from management, operations, accounting,
edge technology platform, which availability across all assets classes, as Eurex’s leading state-of-the-art trading settlement and reconciliation.
was developed with performance and well as access to uncommon emerging and processing services. For Eurex,
robustness as the focus of design. With markets. service and technology innovation is not Email:
flexibility at its core, customer-driven just a buzzword. New trends are being [email protected]
extensions and modifications can be W: www.gruposantander.com transformed into inventions through the
quickly and easily applied to the standard T: (3491) 289 39 42/54 adoption of advanced trading practices. Contact: Switch board: +44 (0) 208 081
component set. E: securitieslending@ Find out more on www.eurexseclend.com. 2000 Marketing: +44 (0)208 081 2853
gruposantander.com
T: +41 (0)44 218 14 14 W: www.eurexseclend.com Visit: www.sungard.com/loanet www.
F: +41 (0)44 218 14 18 T: +41 58 854 2066 sungard.com/globalone www.sungard.
E: [email protected] F: +41 58 854 2455 com/martini www.astecgroup.com
A: COMIT AG, Buckhauserstrasse 11, E: [email protected]
CH-8048 Zurich, Switzerland Eurex Zurich Ltd., Selnaustrasse
W: www.finacesolution.com 30, 8021 Zurich, Switzerland
53
Technology
Advent Software EMEA, established in BI-SAM is a leading provider of analytics Broadridge Financial Solutions, Inc., with
1998, provides trusted solutions for the software, client reporting and data over $2.0 billion in revenues and more
front through to back office operations, management solutions to the investment than 40 years of experience, is a leading
Accuity is the leading provider of data, based on a true real-time fund/portfolio management community. global provider of technology-based
software and services that enables banks accounting platform, to the investment Our integrated and innovative solutions outsourcing solutions to the financial
and corporations to maximise payment management community throughout have already been adopted by many services industry.
efficiency and AML compliance for Europe, Middle East and Africa. Advent renowned asset managers in France, Our systems and services include
financial transactions. has an established network of offices Belgium, Luxembourg, UK, Hong Kong investor communication, securities
Our Payment Solutions are designed to across the region serving a growing and Singapore who have assets under processing, and clearing and outsourcing
deliver the critical payment information client base of asset managers, hedge management ranging from 10 to 450 solutions. We offer advanced, integrated
necessary to improve payment straight fund managers, prime brokers, fund billion Euros. systems and services that are dependable,
through processing rates. Our Compliance administrators, wealth managers, The B-One suite of products covers: scalable and cost-efficient. Our systems
Suite offers a complete range of private banks and family offices who performance measurement, performance help reduce the need for clients to
caution lists and screening tools that continue to improve their businesses attribution (equities, balanced and make significant capital investments
defend against participation in illicit using Advent’s suite of integrated fixed income), risk attribution (ex-post in operations infrastructure, thereby
financial activities. Accuity’s Strategic investment management solutions. and ex-ante), as well as multi-lingual allowing them to increase their focus
Services Group provides businesses with Advent Software EMEA is part of Advent client reporting and factsheets. This on core business activities.The product
consulting, training and services. Software Inc. (Nasdaq: ADVS), a global suite of products can be used either as listings will still stay the same apart from
Since 1836 we have helped businesses organisation that has been providing stand-alone applications or ASP hosted Securities Data Management needs to be
around the world and our role as the solutions to the world’s leading financial solutions. replaced by the following:
Official Registrar of the American Bankers professionals since 1983. Firms in The Company has approximately SWIFT Service Bureau - provides fast-
Association (ABA) Routing Numbers more than 50 countries using Advent 45 employees in offices located in track access to the SWIFT network for
since 1911 has enabled us to compile and technology manage investments totaling Europe (Paris, London, Luxembourg). full range of SWIFT messages including
maintain the most authoritative and more than US $8 trillion. Offices in Asia and North America are securities, treasury, derivatives, payments
comprehensive database of global bank under consideration. The Company is and corporate actions, all in a complete
information available. T: +44 (0)20 7631 9240 headquartered in Paris. service environment.
F: +44 (0)20 7631 9256
Luis F. Rolim E: [email protected] A: BI-SAM Ltd Broadridge Financial Solutions
Marketing Manager - EMEA and Asia A: One Bedford Avenue, 1 Cornhill The ISIS Building
Pacific Accuity London WC1B 3AU, UK London EC3V 3ND 193 Marsh Wall
1 Quality Court W: www.advent.com T: +44 (0)20 3008 5834 London E14 9SG UK
Chancery Lane F: + 44 (0)20 3008 5831 T: +44 (0) 20 7551 3000
London WC2A 1HR E: [email protected] E: [email protected]
United Kingdom W: www.bi-sam.com W: www.broadridge.com
t: +44 20 7014 3454
f: +44 20 7061 6478
e: [email protected]
www.AccuitySolutions.com
Aquin are the market leader in investment Financial Tradeware provides integrated
compliance software with MIG21® powered solutions for medium to small sized Eagle Investment Systems LLC is a global
by Aquin LawCards® for global compliance Investment Management firms, Fund provider of financial services technology,
including UCITS III and SEC 1940. Managers and Hedge Funds, covering the serving the world’s leading financial
The company has built its reputation on full trade life cycle. It is part of the Dharma institutions. Eagle’s Web-based systems
DST International is the world’s premier Group of companies and benefits from the support the complex requirements of
solid compliance and IT experience in long
vendor of technology solutions to the global joint contributions and experiences within firms of any size including institutional
term relationships with its clients.
investment management community with the group of market traders, business investment managers, mutual funds,
Aquin services a blue-chip client base of
over 700 clients in 55 countries, and 1500 analysts, financial services professionals hedge funds, brokers, public funds, plan
the world’s leading investment
employees in 19 of the world’s leading and skilled Microsoft Certified sponsors, and insurance companies. Eagle
management companies, hedge funds,
financial centres. Our wide range of asset programmers. The company has developed is committed to providing enterprise-
fund administrators and custodians.
management solutions meet the needs of a suite of applications that integrate and wide, leading-edge technology and
These include Citi, State Street, BNP
fund managers, dealers, settlement staff, Straight Through Process (STP) real-time professional services for investment
Paribas, Credit Suisse, CACEIS Investor
custodians and record keepers operating trading, back office administration, accounting, data management, and
Services, Allianz Global Investors, Pioneer
as international asset managers; from front accounting and compliance. Ultra.net®, performance measurement. Eagle’s
Investments and Commerzbank. The
office simulation, opinion management S-Messenger® and H-Fund® arwe the product suite is offered as an installed
company has its headquarters in Frankfurt,
and modelling functions, through data company’s flagship products all based on application or can be hosted via Eagle
Germany with subsidiaries in Boston,
management, dealing and settlement to Microsoft.NET infrastructure. The company ACCESS, Eagle’s application service
London, Paris, Dublin, Luxembourg and
custody and corporate actions. The suite of also offers a Member Concentrator for provider. Eagle Investment Systems LLC is
Zurich.
products can be used either as stand-alone hosted SWIFT connectivity and Member a division of The Bank of New York Mellon
applications or brought together in flexible Administered Closed User Group (MA-CUG) Corporation. To learn more about Eagle’s
Annette Lindinger
combinations according to specific needs. services for Corporates and Hedge funds. solutions, contact [email protected]
[email protected]
T: +49 69 21 93 66 600 or visit www.eagleinvsys.com.
T: UK +44 (0)20 8390 5000 F: +49 69 21 93 66 650 W: www.f-tradeware.com
Boston +1 617 482 8800 Mainzer Landstr. 199 T: +44 (0)20 7493 2773 W: www.eagleinvsys.com
Hong Kong +85 225 812 880 60326 F: +44 (0)20 7495 4858 T: +44 (0) 20 7163 5700
F: +44 (0)20 8390 7000 Frankfurt am Main C: GrahamBright F: +44 (0) 20 7163 5701
E: [email protected] Germany E: [email protected] A: Mellon Financial Centre 160 Queen
A: DST House, St Mark’s Hill, Surbiton, W: www.aquin.com A: 31 Dover Street Victoria Street London, EC4V 4LA
Surrey, KT6 4QD London W1S 4ND UK
W: www.dstinternational.com
54
E: [email protected]
W: www.odyssey-group.com
55
Further Contacts:
Misys provides integrated, comprehensive US T: +1 212 946 2685
With annual revenue of USD5 billion,
solutions that deliver significant results to Singapore T: +65 9616 7732
peterevans is a leading provider of front SunGard is a global leader in software
over 1,200 financial institutions globally.
to back office solutions for the financial and processing solutions for financial
Our buyside solutions help asset servicers,
services sector. With 23 years experience services, higher education and the public
asset managers and hedge funds handle
peterevans takes a sophisticated and sector. SunGard also helps information-
the latest complex products, streamline
dynamic approach to assist customers dependent enterprises of all types to
processes, reduce costs and improve
ensure the continuity of their business.
in reducing costs and witnessing an STP. Misys Summit is our award winning,
SunGard serves more than 25,000 Founded in 2002, Redi2 Technologies is
increase in margins by seamlessly replacing multi-asset class solution that boasts 18
customers in more than 50 countries, a leading provider of fee billing solutions
costly and restricting legacy platforms. years OTC derivatives market expertise.
including the world’s 50 largest financial to the global financial services industry.
peterevans works in a collaborative manner With extensive OTC buyside coverage and
services companies.
and sees clients as partners to help meet the market leading structured products Redi2 offers flexible, feature-rich
all the demands in today’s marketplace. module, solutions that help firms streamline
Visit SunGard at
Misys Summit delivers the solution you operations, improve cash flow, reduce
The xanite product suite offers a highly www.sungard.com
need for handling the end to end process costs, enhance client service and meet
configurable, flexible and fully integrated,
for OTC. We also provide a customisable compliance obligations.
browser based, comprehensive front
ASP service for fast implementation and Redi2’s flagship fee billing and revenue
to back solution that complies with lower costs.
message standardization and settlement management solution Redi2 Revenue
harmonization. Deployed as a single Manager helps financial professionals
www.misys.com
application or integrated as components [email protected] more easily manage the fee billing
into your existing platform. Each of the process, including client setup, multi-
xanite modules can be delivered via an Netik’s team have spent the past 25 years currency fee and accrual calculations,
ASP or self-hosted. Covering: wealth perfecting the art of bringing together invoice and advice generation, accrual
management, custody corporate actions market, reference, portfolio accounting, reconciliation, adjustments and reversals.
clearing and settlement private client and performance and risk data from Our open APIs and support for industry-
on-line stock broking. disparate sources into a single version standard relational databases ease
of the truth (SVOTTTM). The result is integration with third-party solutions,
peterevans a highly scalable and sophisticated including accounting, performance
New Broad Street House business data model that has been measurement and CRM systems.
35 New Broad Street designed to process all securities and
London EC2M 1NH offers a complete model for traditional Redi2 Technologies, Inc.
T: +44 (0) 29 20 402200 and alternative markets. 1771 Broadway St.
E: [email protected] Oakland, CA 94612
W: www.peterevans.com For more information please visit: T: +1 (510) 834-7334
www.netik.com E: [email protected]
or email: [email protected] W: www.redi2.com
56
Probedruck
Diversity of services means the
world to our clients.
Now we have a name that
reflects this.
*2008 Global Custodian Hedge Fund Administration Survey. ©2008 The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. All rights reserved. PFPC PDF 1108-012