Surrealism and Music Seminar2008
Surrealism and Music Seminar2008
Surrealism and Music Seminar2008
Although the surrealist movement and the literary and visual works associated with it
have been widely documented, little has been written about surrealist elements that have crossed
over into music. A close examination of the history of surrealism reveals two principal
components---automatism and collage---which are fundamental to the link between surrealism
and some contemporary music, especially some music for which the adjective postmodern is
appropriate.i Here I explore how some recent musical practices sustain and transform early
twentieth century artistic behaviors associated with surrealism.
The founder of surrealism, Andr Breton,ii insisted that surrealism embraced far more
than literary or visual arts, or politics, or social concerns---it was ultimately a way of knowledge,
with the potential for being eternally relevant. In his official definition of the term, Breton
aligned it closely with automatism (automatic writing): SURREALISM, n. Psychic
automatism in its pure state, by which one proposes to express---verbally, by means of the
written word, or in any other manner---the actual functioning of thought. (Breton
[1924]1972:26) Automatism was so central to the philosophy of surrealism in its early days that
surrealist writing and automatism were terms used interchangeably. Surrealists were,
i
. Breton, the central force at the vortex of surrealism, wielded a remarkable power that
alternately magnetized and repelled the most adventurous and experimental young male artists of
the 1920s.
however, careful to differentiate their use of automatic writing from the mechanical writing
engaged in by psychics and hypnotists.iii
The surrealists were intrigued by automatism since it would assist them in escaping the
shackles of supervised thought. Intensive indulgence in automatism could even lead to altered
states: Automatic writing, practised with some fervour, leads directly to visual hallucination.
(Breton [1933]1978:108) Euphoric with the intoxication of discovery, they felt like miners who
had just struck the mother lode. (Breton [1952]1993:44) Breton later stressed the requirement
for the detachment of the mind from the external world when engaging in automatism, and made
the point that such detachment is closer to Eastern thought, requiring extremely sustained
concentration and effort. (Breton [1952]1993:64-65)
Although automatism existed in surrealism from the outset, the role of collage only
developed as surrealism expanded to encompass the visual arts. Breton considered both to be
equally viable techniques for producing a surrealist text. The scholar Elsa Adamowicz, in
writing about the cutting and flowing natures of collage and automatism, clarifies the primary
importance of both techniques to the surrealists: The spontaneous verbal flow---and later the
graphic gesture---which characterizes early automatism on the one hand, and the deliberate
cutting up and assembling of disparate elements specific to collage on the other hand, were to be
elaborated as the two essential modes of surrealist production, breaking away from traditional
codes of mimesis and the aesthetics of coherence, and exploring the language of the irrational
and the chance encounter. (Adamowicz 1998:5)
Surrealist methods of collage became the visual parallel to automatism. Originating from
the French word coller, it means literally pasting, sticking, or gluing---techniques used by
iii
. The surrealists were apparently unaware of the initial automatic writing experiments of Leon
Solomons and Gertrude Stein some thirty years prior the publication of his First Manifesto.
Bretons instructions nevertheless echoed the original rules of literary automatic writing as
identified by Kittler: First, it is forbidden to reread anything written Second, the annoying
intrusions of an ego are to be put off by repeating prewritten sentences with an obstinacy that
matches their meaninglessness. (Kittler [1985]1990:227)
artists for centuries. Only in the twentieth century, however, did collage begin to function as a
structure of juxtapositions. Lautramonts verbal collages, such as the celebrated chance
meeting upon a dissecting table of a sewing machine with an umbrella, provided an early model
of systematic displacement for the surrealist graphic collagists. As opposed to the formal and
aesthetic considerations of cubist papier coll, surrealist collage aimed at initiating an
unprecedented encounter, to stimulate the imagination and to spark revelation.
The distinction between surrealist collage and other forms of twentieth-century collage,
especially cubist collage, is important to understand. Surrealists who worked with collage---and
most of them did, either exclusively or peripherally---transcended the literal cutting and pasting
techniques so attractive to the cubists. Collage elements in cubism principally functioned as
formal units. Surrealist collage, however, reinterpreted familiar fragments ---the cliched images
of advertisements, clippings from anatomical textbooks, illustrations from nineteenth-century
pulp fiction, ephemera such as bus tickets ---manipulating ready-made objects and elements into
newly charged works that conjured the marvelous.iv Far from merely enriching the palette of
the artist, the collage elements in surrealist art were powerfully iconic. What was expressed
superceded the means of expression; the represented object play[ed] the role of a word.
(Aragon [1930]1965:44)
The specific visual counterpart to automatic writing was frottage, a variation of collage.
Max Ernst, considered the foremost practitioner of surrealist collage, discovered the method of
frottage in 1925:
the spiritual faculties by appropriate and technical means, excluding all conscious mental
conduction, reducing to an extreme the active part of what has up till now been called the
author, this process is revealed as the veritable equivalent of automatic writing. (Ernst:
[1938]1970:208) In laymans terms, frottage means the process of rubbing---a familiar
iv
. The marvelous is always beautiful, anything marvelous is beautiful, in fact only the
marvelous is beautiful. (Breton 1924[1972]: 14)
technique to children, who delight in transferring images of tree leaves or bark in this way. The
groundwork for Ernsts discovery began some six years earlier, when he first stumbled upon the
potential of unexpected juxtapositions: One rainy day in 1919, finding myself in a village on
the Rhine, I was struck by the obsession which held under my gaze the pages of an illustrated
catalogue showing objects designed for anthropologic, microscopic, psychologic, mineralogic,
and paleontologic demonstration. There I found brought together elements of figuration so
remote that the sheer absurdity of that collection provoked a sudden intensification of the
visionary faculties in me and brought forth an illusive succession of contradictory images,
double, triple and multiple images, piling up on each other with the persistence and rapidity
which are peculiar to love memories and visions of half-sleep. These visions called themselves
new planes, because of their meeting in a new unknown (the plane of non-agreement). (Ernst
1936:14) As we shall see, what Ernst depicts in his epiphany resembles manifestations of
collage in music.
The bridge linking automatism with collage developed through the invention of a game
called the Exquisite Corpsev, in which different parts of drawings or writings (generally poems)
were accomplished by successive individuals, each oblivious to the prior material which had
been created. The individual artist relinquishes conscious control, surrendering to a collaborative
process that represents the antithesis of the world of assembly-line automatization. Boundaries
are dissolved, and a whiplash series of startling juxtapositions emerges, with a collective
collage as the end result of the game.
A Surreal Silence
Driven by a mixed bag of politics, jealousies, misunderstandings, philosophical
differences, and outright naivete, the predominantly negative attitude of many French surrealists
toward music was complicated and fluctuating. Giorgio de Chirico, one of the progenitors of
. The cadavre exquis was named after one of the first lines resulting from this game, The
exquisite corpse drinks the new wine.
surrealist art, established this tone in his essay of 1913, No Music. He proclaimed that a
picture has a music of its own, with the implication that music is ultimately superfluous. In the
decisive Le Surralisme et la peinture, published fifteen years later, Breton immediately
dismisses music as inferior to the assorted degrees of sensation and spiritual realizations made
possible by the plastic arts. Imparting value to forms of plastic expression that he
unconditionally refuses to grant to musical expression, he describes music as the most deeply
confusing of all art forms. It gets worse: Auditive images, in fact, are inferior to visual images
not only in clarity but also in strictness, and, with all due respect to a few megalomaniacs, they
are not destined to strengthen the idea of human greatness. So may night continue to descend
upon the orchestra, and may I, who am still searching for something in this world, be left with
open eyes, or with closed eyes in broad daylight, to my silent contemplation. (Breton
[1928]1972:1-2)
Sixteen years later, Bretons attitude toward music is far more circumspect, even humble.
In his sole essay on music, Silence is Golden, Breton professes his ignorance of music while
calling for a re-casting of certain principles of music and poetry in order to vaporize the
antagonism existing between these two arts. For the first audible diamond to be obtained, it is
evident that the fusion of the two elements music and poetry into one, could only be
accomplished at a very high emotional temperature. And it seems to me that it is in the
expression of the passion of love that both music and poetry are most likely to reach this
supreme point of incandescence. (Breton 1944:152)vi
Satie and Antheil
The composers most closely associated with the surrealists did not participate in the game
playing, the dream-dictation, or any of the other activities that were formulating the surrealist
vi
. In other words, he wishes to erase the distinction between poetry and song. Interestingly,
Wagners fusion of poetry and music was likely the closest to Bretons professed ideal. It should
therefore come as no surprise that the soundtracks to several surrealist films, including two of the
most celebrated---Bunuels Lge dor and Un chien andalou---used music by Wagner.
aesthetic by empirical process. Erik Satie began his second career in 1912 at the age of 48,
after being rediscovered by Debussy and Ravel. Satie, known for his eccentric texts that
embellish so many of his works for piano, also experimented with other radical departures from
the normal, such as the absence of bar-lines in the three waltzes, Precieux Dgout. Saties
biographer, Rollo Myers, describes these waltzes, with their displaced stresses, dry harmony, and
absurd association of ideas, as a surrealistic montage. (Myers 1948:128)
Saties stage works, projecting collaborative architectures of collage, would be
most representative of the transference of surrealist practices into music. Parade, for instance--a hybrid of fresh sounds, novel technologies, and new styles---resulted in juxtapositions that
would surely appeal to a surrealist. Saties contribution to the ballet Parade, his and Cocteaus
collaborative triumph, owed as much to the dada and futurist movements as it did to surrealism.
The score was to have included Morse code tickers, lottery wheels, airplane propellers,
typewriters, and sirens; due to crowding in the pit and lack of resources, only a typewriter and
siren were actually used. Parade outraged a large portion of the public, as well as critics,
delighting Satie. The performance set the tone for the postwar years. It was a serioushumorous exploitation of popular elements in art, a turning to jazz and music hall and to all the
paraphernalia of modern life, not in a spirit of realism, but with a sense of exhilaration in the
absurd. (Shattuck 1955:120-121)
Toward the end of his life, Satie went on to write three other works for the stage. The
last, Relche (billed as ballet instantaniste), his scandalous swan song that caused a legendary
uproar, carries the distinction of being the first ballet to incorporate film.vii One of his
collaborators for Relche, Francis Picabia, deliberately turned his back on the surrealist camp in
order to work with Satie. After the 1924 premiere, ironically coinciding with the year of
Bretons First Manifesto and birth of surrealism, Satie fell ill, succumbing to liver failure the
vii
. Ren Clair made a film sequence for the ballet, a fast-moving montage anticipatory of
surrealist imagery. Saties score for the film, Entracte, was one of the earliest examples of film
music.
following year.
Surprisingly, Satie was shunned by Breton and most of his followers. Breton took
exception to Saties ongoing artistic relationship with Jean Cocteau, whom he despised.
Bretons life-long loathing for Cocteau was fueled by a confused web of resentments, and he was
especially opposed to Cocteaus successful pandering to the bourgeoisie art establishment.viii As
a group, the surrealists werent especially fond of certain forays taken by Satie that were, as it
turns out, amazingly prophetic. His Musique dameublement (furniture music) anticipated a
genre steeped in neutrality that had yet to be named, but which now is termed ambient music and
its spin-offs---Muzak, dinner party music, new age music conducive to meditation, and so forth.
Saties own description of Musique dameublement alludes to the pragmatic incentive for its
invention: loud restaurant music, for which he proposed the antidote: I imagine it to be
melodious, softening the clatter of knives and forks without dominating them, without imposing
itself. It would fill up the awkward silence that occasionally descends upon guests. It would
spare them the usual commonplaces. At the same time it would neutralise the street noises that
tactlessly force themselves into the picture. (Toop 1995:198) Surrealists would oppose the
bland innocuousness of this new musical genre.
Erik Satie left an ambiguous yet highly visionary legacy. Since so many
movements lay claim to him, its difficult to make the case that hes principally a surrealist
composer. Like Picasso and Stravinsky, he never professed allegiance to any movement,
although he was familiar with them all. It is ironic that he wasnt recognized during his lifetime
as a musical contributor to surrealism, due to Bretons antagonism and also to the fact that
musicians in general were not a part of the movement.
Of the other major composers active in France during the 1920s and 1930s--Poulenc, Auric, Antheil, Milhaud, Stravinsky---George Antheil was the most outspoken and
viii
. Mark Polizzottis autobiography of Breton, Revolution of the Mind, goes into considerable
detail about the reasons for Bretons dislike of Cocteau.
proactive in identifying himself with the surrealists: The Surrealist movement had, from the
very beginning, been my friend. In one of its manifestoes it had been declared that all music was
unbearable---excepting, possibly, mine---a beautiful and appreciated condescension. (Antheil
1981:300) The surrealists promoted Antheils music, and he even began a collaboration with
Breton and Louis Aragon on an opera, Faust III .ix Mechanical repetition, distortions of time,
and the incorporation of noise characterized his music. Ballet Mchanique, originally scored for
eight pianos, one pianola, eight xylophones, two electric doorbells, and airplane propeller
sounds, incited rioting at the Paris premiere in 1925---a surefire sign of a successful surrealist
work.
Five years later, Antheil composed a set of thirty-five piano preludes, La Femme
100 Ttes, inspired by Max Ernsts collage novel of the same name. In her 1992 dissertation,
Surrealism in the Piano Music of Representative Twentieth-Century American Composers,
Kathryn Lea Fouse discusses several of these preludes, highlighting their burlesque qualities and
pointing out the references to humor, as in Prelude XVII, a parody of a traditional pianistic
exercise. These through-composed preludes sometimes depict Ernsts collages by means of
graphic- or text-painting. However, Antheils music, even at its most radical extremes, never
seems to fully exploit the techniques of collage and automatism so indispensable to many
surrealist writers and artists.
Surreal Music?
Poetry, prose, political manifestos, games, dream imagery, painting, sculpture, collage
forms, photography, and cinema converged to form a movement unlike any other in the twentieth
century. Why wasnt music an equal player in this dazzling array of literary, artistic, and
political activities? Many of the surrealists themselves wondered about the relative absence of
music in their vibrant universe, conspicuous in that virtually all other art forms were welcomed,
ix
. The opera was never finished, due to the split of the surrealist movement into two factions,
one led by Aragon and one by Breton. However, the libretto to four out of five acts had been
completed, and was retained by Antheil.
. The Belgian surrealists were more open toward the inclusion of music in surrealist efforts, as
shown by the three-way collaboration among the writer Paul Noug, the painter Ren Magritte,
and the composer Andr Souris. Their collaboration resulted in Clarisse Juranville, a poem
written by Noug parodying a popular grammar textbook, illustrated by Magritte in a booklet,
and set to music in a small cantata by Souris. According to Robert Wangerme in his article,
Magritte and the Universe of Sound, Souriss piece was sung at a concert in Charleroi in
1929, among an exhibit of nearly two dozen paintings by Magritte, and preceded by a lecture on
music by Noug. (Wangerme 1998:37-40)
xi
. The year of the date of this meeting wasnt given, only that it occurred from July 6 8.
10
process music, along with a more open and pluralistic musical landscape, provided an
environment for such surrealist techniques to flourish when placed at the disposal of composers.
Although early experiments with elements of musical surrealism didnt immediately take
root, they carved out a testing ground for others to eventually build upon.xii Many of the collage
works of Charles Ives---a person about as far removed from the surrealist ferment, and its
subversive aesthetics, as one can imagine---actually predate surrealist developments.
Furthermore, the sudden insertions, and more gradual sonic exuviations, of seemingly unrelated
music contribute to the surreal effect found in works by Ives that arent even considered to be
collage pieces. Nearly forty years ago, Peter S. Hansen, describing the abrupt hymn quotation
and perky march-tune in the Hawthorne movement from the Concord Sonata, remarks that
these allusions to popular music . . .result in an almost surrealistic incongruity with the general
climate of dissonance. (Hansen 1961:80) (my italics)
investigations and experiments of modernist sound pioneers such as Edgar Varse, Pierre
Schaeffer, Pierre Henry, and even John Cage functioned as yet another germination site for
musical surrealism.
Experiments with surrealist elements in music in the 1920s and 1930s were isolated,
and not substantial enough to participate equally with the literary and visual components so vital
to the realization of surrealist ideals. Most composers of this period were preoccupied with the
breakdown of tonality, and the most radical development in music of serialism was far removed
from surrealist aesthetics. In America, however, an early and simple automatistic rendering of
music, incorporating degrees of improvisation, was beginning to find voice in the music of blues
musicians and jazz bands.xiii Meanwhile, electronic music, a frontier for radical expansion of
xii
Sound and noise pieces by the dadaist, Kurt Schwitters, and the futurist, Luigi Russolo, became
beacons of early twentieth century musical adventurism, but neither was directly involved with
the surrealist movement.
xiii
. Paul Garon praises the surrealistss defense of non-European cultures, the arts of which often
confirmed and reinforced their own perspectives, and goes on to say: It follows that the
Surrealistss sympathetic attention could hardly fail to have been attracted by the vibrant and
11
multiple parameters in music, was poised at the cusp of its coming evolution, attracting the sonic
imagination of Varse in the 1940s.
By the early 1950s, music began to break free of prior limitations, including the
straitjacket of equal temperament. Newly favorable conditions, such as technological and
aesthetic developments made it possible to prioritize sound over notation, creating a fertile
environment for the infiltration of surrealistic factors. What began to emerge---surrealist-related
elements of displacement, of radical meshings, of intentions recorded instantaneously---reflected
the revolutionary effect that recording technology brought to music. Such a connection was not
lost on Pierre Boulez, who recognized that electro-acoustic tools could provide a means of
relating music to the other arts of a prior surrealism. Calling for an investigation of the
structural relationships possible between the language of music and the language of science (just
prior to the construction of IRCAM), he identified problems in the realm of instruments,
intervals, and electronic music. With respect to the latter, he asserted: the electro-acoustic
world, which is of course entirely new and has been taken over, in a way, by a kind of curiosityshop aesthetics, this bastard descendant of a dead Surrealism (Boulez [1968]1986:456) The
implication: although developments in electronic music have provided the tools to create music
in the surrealist mold, Boulez opposed the unleashing of prior constraints if musicians are
exploring new territory for the sheer fun of doing so.
Jacqueline Chnieux-Gendron also suggests a link between the beginnings of electronic
music and surrealism. She devotes several paragraphs in her book, Surrealism, to the French
surrealistss neglect of music as one system of signs. Citing the electroacoustic explorations of
Pierre Schaeffer and Pierre Henry as being close to the spirit of surrealism, she refers to the
optimistic statement of the musician Franois-Bernard Mche: Surrealist forms of music could
inspired music created by the American blacks, a music which not only recalls African rhythms
and chants, but which is also an impassioned revolt against the white bourgeois American way
of life. (Garon 1975:26) Elsewhere in what may be the only book that addresses a musical
form in relation to surrealism, Blues and the Poetic Spirit, Garon examines, with remarkable
insight, the spiritual revolt against repression as embodied in the poetry of the blues.
12
still arise, seeking the gold of sound as Breton sought the gold of time.xiv Yet, she not only
concludes that these suggestions give a very partial analogy with Surrealism, but also asserts
that from a historical perspective, the opportunity for any meeting between music and surrealism
has been irretrievably missed. (Chnieux-Gendron [1984]1990:167-168)
On the contrary, I contend that the profound influences of surrealism began to take hold
in the late 1950s and that surrealism in music only acheived its full potential in postmodern
musics. The more widespread developments in recording and electronic processing
technologies, and the abilities of performers and composers to break the molds of a previously
limiting syntactical and sonic palette, contributed to a fertile atmosphere that established the
necessary conditions for bringing the last major art form into the fold of surrealism.
xiv
. On the rare occasions when music is discussed in books written about surrealism, the
discussions invariably center around interactions of composers--- usually Satie, Auric, Antheil,
Milhaud, Stravinsky ---and surrealists during the 1920s and 30s. Chnieux-Gendron, along
with Garon, Sandrow, Kahn, and Schiff, were the only authors I found who addressed the
transference of surrealist elements into music. (Mche, Pierrepont, and Willenbrink, in their
cited articles, go to considerably greater lengths in drawing connections between surrealist
techniques and music.)
13
Did surrealist aesthetics begin to infiltrate modernist musics after World War II? Nicolas
Slonimsky, in his essay, Music and Surrealism, names over a dozen widely divergent
examples, after first establishing his ground: Musical Surrealism arose primarily as a reaction
against Contented Music, the music of the salon, the cult of the virtuoso, the art of tonal
tranquilization. (Slonimsky 1966:80) Slonimsky never really defines music that embodies
surreal qualities. For instance, in one statement, he implies that settings of surrealist texts qualify
as surrealist music, even if the accompanying music remains completely within the sphere of
Contented Music---such as Poulencs music for Apollinaires bizarre Les Mamelles de Tirsias.
But then, in the next breath, he makes the stark pronouncement: if its dissonant it must be
surreal.
Slonimskys arguments are occasionally convincing, such as his assertion that
Shostakovitchs satirical opera, The Nose, was surrealistic in its aesthetic derivation. Slonimsky
doesnt stop at the synopsis, but goes on to cite musical effects that he interprets as surreal, such
as the octet of janitors in a polyphonic glossolalia. (Ibid.) Claiming that Hindemith
contributed to surrealism in musical theater with his operatic sketch, Hin und Zurck,xv hes on
the right track. But when he remarks, The dissonant texture and rhythmic asymmetry of the
score contribute to the surrealistic effect of the music, his rationale begins to resemble the
proverbial kitchen sink.
Slonimsky takes a far broader approach to defining a musical surrealism than I do
even equating serialism with surrealism. Yet, he brilliantly zeros in on a couple of fundamental
issues. He points out the parallels between collage and Musique Concrte: The basically
Surrealistic techniques of montage and collage found their application in Musique Concrte,
born in a Paris studio, on a spring day in 1948, where the French radio engineer Pierre Schaeffer
amused himself by combining the sounds and noises of the studio and recording them on
xv
. Slonimsky describes this melodramatic palindrome: The action is reversed after the husband
in the play kills his adulterous wife; she comes back to life and the husband backs out of the
door. (Slonimsky 1966:80)
14
magnetic tape.xvi (Ibid. 83) Slonimsky even enlists Charles Ives as an example of a composer
practicing his own brand of Musique Concrte. Indeed, Ives was abruptly juxtaposing musical
quotations from a hodgepodge of sources---hymns, folk music, classical works, marching band
tunes---before surrealism was a viable artistic movement. Both Ives and Schaeffer, although
separated by decades and mediums, were capable of relentlessly shunning conventions such as
harmony, melody, or tonality.
Breaking the Fast
The two principal aesthetic components of the surrealist movement, automatism and
collage, have been reincarnated in some of the more vibrant music created in the latter half of the
twentieth century. The incorporation of these elements does not, however, imply a postmodern
surrealist movement. Rather, I argue that the impact of the original surrealist movement
reverberates in certain types of postmodern music. I demonstrate this reverbation by considering
the relationship of automatism to improvisation, and of collage to musical simultaneities,
pluralities, borrowings, and sudden juxtapositions of unrelated materials.
Many of the composers and musicians I discuss havent yet been written about
critically and deserve greater acknowledgement and wider exposure. More established
composers who could easily be discussed in this essay, such as Varse, Cage, Ligeti,
Stockhausen, or Oliveros, are already the subject of considerable critical and analytical study.
Jos Pierre, for instance, writes that Cage was considered to be a surrealist composer in the
1940s. (Pierre 1999:37) Mche goes into greater detail: The fact remains that the complete
genesis of surrealism as a historical idea was revived and reincarnated in John Cage. Thirty years
xvi
. Mche, less than ten years after Slonimskys article came out, asserted that until the musique
concrete of the early 1950s, sounds were always filtered through, and affected by, poetic,
religious, or aesthetic screens before being received by musicians---and therefore would not
qualify as totally surreal. However, those early works of Schaeffer and Henry constituted the first
authentic illustrations of a musical surrealism, even though such works only occasionally joined
surrealism in the embodiment of its aesthetic, but never in its ends nor in its techniques. (Mche
1974:46)
15
after Russolo, Cage created the genuine confused intonations (intona-rumori) with his prepared
piano.xvii (Mche 1974: 46) Stockhausens attempts to advance into the areas of the musical
unconscious by means of an intuitive music actually grow directly out of surrealist automatic
writing techniques: playing instructions for his ensemble piece Es (1968) call upon the musician
to play only if that player has achieved the status of not thinking. (Willenbrink 1985:155) In
many of her works, Pauline Oliveros has investigated music-making that emanates directly from
the unconscious. Even Pierre Boulez, taking a typically rigorous approach, documents his own
experiment with automatism in the writing of his epochal Structures of 1951-52.xviii
Ive narrowed my analysis of surrealism and music to only a few musicians and
composers, principally people Ive performed with or have known personally. I will highlight
surrealist elements in my own music and in the music of several of my peers: Davey Williams,
LaDonna Smith, John Zorn, John Oswald, Eugene Chadbourne, Mark Steven Brooks, Shelley
Hirsch, Hal Freedman, and Eugene Chadbourne. Additionally, the music of Robert Ashley and
Gyimah Labi, composers from previous generations, shares such indelible affinities with aspects
of surrealism central to this essay, that I must include it as well.xix The fact that most of the
xvii
. Mche elaborates further, mentioning Cages aleatoric devices, launched with dice, and his
involvement with collective improvisation. Yet he concludes that Cages Zen-inspired return
to oneself is in opposition to the surrealist Don Quixotism. (Mche 1974:47) Cages
philosophy and approach to aleatoric and chance methods, and how these techniques and their
results relate to surrealism, offers a rich territory for further research, as does his association with
Marcel Duchamp.
xviii
. The first piece was written very rapidly, in a single night, because I wanted to use the
potential of a given material to find out how far automatism in musical relationships would go,
with individual invention appearing only in some really very simple forms of disposition---in the
matter of densities for example. For this purpose I borrowed material from Messiaens Mode de
valeurs et dintensits; thus I had material that I had not invented and for whose invention I
deliberately rejected all responsibility in order to see just how far it was possible to go. I wrote
down all the transpositions, as though it were a mechanical object which moved in every
direction, and limited my role to the selection of registers---but even those were completely
undifferentiated. (Boulez [1976] cited in Stacey 1987:23-24)
xix
. With the exception of Williams and Smith, none of the composers and musicians discussed
consciously employ surrealist techniques.
16
individuals Ive elected to discuss are also performers is no accident. Rather, its a testament to
one of the hallmarks of postmodern music, the dynamic breaking-down of the rigid separation of
composers from performers (and vice versa). Composer/performers often have the skills and
aesthetic desire to engage in improvisation. Such improvisation relates directly to my
interpretation of musical automatism, and can indirectly fuel collage technique.
In future writings I hope to extend my analyses to a more comprehensive investigation
which would include such artists as Christian Marclay, Earl Howard, Alfred Schnittke, Frank
Zappa, Captain Beefheart, Oscar Sala, The Residents, Mauricio Kagel, Ornette Coleman, Gyrgy
Ligeti, Micro-ritmia, Ruth Anderson, Stockhausen, Morton Subotnick, Giustino DeGregorio, the
Nihilist Spasm Band, Luciano Berio, Pink Floyd, Diamanda Galas, and Sun Ra.xx
The material that follows represents an inquiry into the myriad ways in which surrealism
has infiltrated, invigorated, and informed a variety of music drawn from the last three decades of
the twentieth century. Not only have defining elements of surrealism found their way into
musics of diverse origins and backgrounds, but technological advancements, in combination with
and parallel to energetic developments in non-referential improvisation, have made possible
sonic environments that are more receptive to the surrealist aesthetic than ever before.
Automatism translated into improvisation; collage transplanted into jump-cuts and cultural and
stylistic borrowing (along with its extreme form of appropriation in plunderphonics)xxi; the
keynote phrase convulsive beautyxxii transfused into the wake-up call of the unexpected
xx
. The legitimacy of surrealism in music has a proponent in the writer and scholar Richard
Taruskin, whose article, Thomas Ades: Surrealist Composer Comes to the Rescue of
Modernism, appeared in The New York Times on December 5, 1999. One response to his
article, a letter published a couple of weeks later, claims that musical surrealism is an
impossibility.
xxi
. A term coined by composer and musician John Oswald, pluderphonicler supreme, referring to
the musical practice of blatantly appropriating segments from recordings of other peoples
music, and, in the process, creating a new musical form.
xxii
. Convulsive beauty can be thought of as action playing against fixity. The clash between
opposed elements, the violence of a departure endlessly halted (Caws 1981:89) . . .as projected
by the surrealist hieroglyph of a train suddenly stopped dead in a virgin forest.
17
insertion; dreams and the unconscious fueled by previously unimagined transcultural dialogues;
distorted visual imagery (Dalis limp, melting timepieces, for starters) finding a whole new lease
on life in the audio realm of infinite possibility---these are some of the more vivid associations
breaking the intermittent fast between surrealism and music.
Automatism / improvisation
Since automatism is one of the key components of surrealism, it should have a musical
counterpart. One might argue that automatism could simply be another way of describing a
composers inspiration. Such an argument would posit that inspiration, particularly if it finds
its way onto manuscript without hesitation or subsequent revision, qualifies as an automatistic
activity. Virgil Thomson, in his derisive response to the pope of the surrealist movement in
French poetry, claimed that music has always emanated from the subconscious, and that
automatistic processes hold nothing new for composers. After grudgingly agreeing with
certain points made by Breton in Silence is Golden, he takes issue with Bretons assertion that
music trails poetry in its evolution, declaring that music is in fact, in many ways, more advanced.
The right of poets to express themselves by means of spontaneous, subconsciously ordered
sequences of material has seemed to many in our century a revolutionary proposition. It is,
however, the normal and accepted way of writing musicMost of the Surrealistss
psychological devices for provoking spontaneity represent a return to Romantic musical practice.
What they do not represent for the musical world is any kind of novelty. Musicians are only too
delighted, I am sure, to lend them for a while to poetry, with all good wishes for their continued
success. (Thomson [1944]1967:118) Thomson might say that Mozarts superb compositional
facility and prowess, or Bachs immense genius as an improviser, are equally representative
examples of musical automatism. But this assumption ignores two critical factors that would
impede the exercise of pure musical automatism: the constraints of musical syntax, coupled with
the requirements of style that molded the information emanating from either composers
unconscious into forms defining their respective periods. These interferences serve to slow and
shape the realization of the end product. Thus, equating inspiration with automatism misses its
18
.I use the term non-idiomatic to discriminate between improvisatory forms tethered to highly
identifiable or indigenous styles such as traditional jazz, Indian ragas, the Korean Sanjo (many
others could be mentioned) which are idiomatic and those that arent connected to any
identifiable indigenous form, style, or tradition.
xxiv
. Speed was actually a preoccupation in the process of automatic writing. When Breton
collaborated with Philippe Soupault in one of the initial explorations of this technique
(culminating in their book, The Magnetic Fields), there were lengthy marathon sessions marked
by experiments with different writing speeds. Different levels of velocity were described and
attempted: level v, for instance, was to occur several times faster than the normal speed at
which one could recall childhood memories. At the greatest speeds, the images poured forth so
quickly that the writers were forced to abbreviate everything. By varying the speeds with which
each chapter was written, they attempted to determine the limits of the bond between thought
and expression. (Polizzotti 1995:106)
19
out non-viable products. (Dean 1992:202-203) The existing elements that become the musical
object are selected arbitrarily, originating in the unconscious; filtering of non-viable products
simply refers to the musicians decision-making process, at a subconscious level, and is likely
bound up with technique and training (or the resistance against such). This algorithm, equally
descriptive of automatic writing or drawing, forms a kind of proof for the application of
surrealist automatism to a variety of artistic genres.
The originality of surrealist language demands an art of risk and the refusal of
past accomplishments and proven techniques in favor of delving into the unknown and
uncharted. The first stepone having to be taken over and over again, Surrealists warnis to
avoid developing a style, cliches, mannerisms, and fixed forms of expression such as every
Surrealist ascribes contemptuously to schools of literature and art. (Matthews 1986:9) The
composers and musicians who most vividly incorporate surrealistic elements of automatism and
collage in their work also demonstrate two essential requirements of surrealism: 1) the desire to
investigate new territory at the expense of adhering to a personal style; 2) the avoidance of
complacency and the comfort of the familiar, turning instead to expansion at the risk of
occasional failure. Each artist amplifies a conception of beauty while transforming a perception
of reality.
Just as the experiments with verbal automatism arose from a frustration with the inherited
approaches to poetic practices, many improvisers have been propelled by their dissatisfaction
with the accepted norms of musical performance. The postmodern principle of avoiding
sameness, and of embracing a plurality of styles, methods, and techniques of playing music, is
often part and parcel of free improvisation. Many of the musicians Ill discuss in this article are
well acquainted with, if not defined by, improvisation. The performances and recordings of
Davey Williams and LaDonna Smith exemplify the ideal of pure non-referential improvisation.
And, in their duo collaborations, an axial component of most successful improvisations is ever
present: the mode of listening to one another. To place the importance of their contributions to
the art and philosophy of improvisation within a context, its necessary to briefly examine where
20
and how they fit into the parallel streams of the growth of free improvisation in America and in
Europe.
In the twentieth century, prior to 1950, improvisation in Western music occurred
primarily in some folk musics and in traditional jazz. Much of the composed music from the
first half of the twentieth century was more complex than the predictable recycling of harmonic
patterns in jazz over a set number of bars. However, during the 1950s the rhythm sections were
either enlarged or subverted, expanding the role of improvisation. By around 1960, a collective,
improvised performance could reach a level of complexity comparable to the composed serial
compositions of the previous decades.
In America, the modernist origins of free jazz are commonly considered to reside
primarily in the music of John Coltranexxv, Eric Dolphy, Sun Ra, Miles Davis, Ornette Coleman,
and Cecil Taylor. However, Joe Harriot and Shake Keane, two musicians active in the 1950s
with strong ties to West Indian music, should also be counted among the first to explore free
improvisation. Many of these artists, essentially the generation coming after the pioneers of
bebop, embody postmodern tendencies as well, such as the melding of classical compositional
techniques in the music of Davis, Coleman, and Dolphy.xxvi
Although free improvisation began to develop in the late 1950s and 1960s
almost concurrently among musicians with backgrounds in both jazz and composed music in the
U.S., Europe, the U.K., Japan, Australia, and Russia, the different ways in which it evolved
(especially in Europe and the U.S.) are striking. With the exception of maverick composerimproviser Anthony Braxton, the Americans maintained closer relationships with conventions
associated with traditional jazz (such as repetitive harmonic structures and fixed rhythmic
xxv
. In his Preface to Bretons Posie et autre, Grard Legrand, a leading figure of postwar
surrealism, compares Bretons stance to that of jazz tenor saxophonists Coleman Hawkins and
John Coltrane. (Garon 1975:27)
xxvi
. The coalition of highly abstract jazz musicians with contemporary music techniques and
conventional orchestral instrumentation is commonly referred to as Third Stream.
21
pulses), while free jazz in Europe tended to demolish anything smacking of the formulaic. In
the liner notes to a 1970 LP recorded with Derek Bailey and Han Bennink, the British
saxophonist Evan Parker remarks: We operate without rules (pre-composed material) or welldefined codes of behavior (fixed tempi, tonalities, serial structures, etc.) and yet are able to
distinguish success from failure. He goes on to refer to rules of play, that could apply to their
music, including, You shall investigate the unfamiliar until it has become familiar.xxvii What
could be more empathetic with the vision of surrealism?
The abandonment of cliched conventions in American jazz in the 1960s was
more gradual, less radical than in the European free jazz movement. In the former, chord
progressions were treated more flexibly or simply discarded; preconceived harmonic structures
gave way to a linear, motivic kind of improvisation which could generate its own harmony; and
pulses were arranged in non-metered groupings. Change was the word on both sides of the
Atlantic, and a surrealist-style purging of the traditional jazz stables was underway.
One of the very earliest forays into textural improvising devoid of motivic
direction can be heard on Coltranes Ascension, recorded in 1965. As timbre supercedes single
notes or rhythms, dense group textures consume individual instruments. In the following year,
two recordings were made in Europe where density, also paramount, results from mass motivic
direction: Litany for the 14th June 1966, by the Dutch composer Willem Breuker and Globe
Unity by the German Alexander von Schlippenbach. Each of these recordings breaks away from
all traditions of improvised music prior to 1960, launching an altogether independent European
improvising movement. These two works also mark the beginnings of composer-controlled free
improvisation.xxviii
American musicians with classical music backgrounds, such as Pauline Oliveros,
xxvii
. These are rules drawn from Desmond Morriss outline in The Naked Ape of rules governing
all play activities.
xxviii
22
Richard Teitelbaum, and Lukas Fosss Improvisors Chamber Ensemble (formed in 1957!), were
forging new directions with improvisation in the early 1960s. Improvising groups such as the
New Music Ensemble (U.S.), Musica Elettronica Viva (Americans in Rome, including
Teitelbaum) and AMM (England) began to embrace the realm of electronic music---though
several years later than Sun Ra, who had performed with electronics in his Arkestra since the
1950s.
The exploratory nature of improvisation led not only to electronic enhancements,
but also to extended instrumental techniques. John Coltrane spearheaded the timbral expansions
of the saxophone with both controlled and purposely fractured multiphonics. Harmonic
complexities in the music of Cecil Taylor evolved from the late 1950s into the cluster-studded
galaxies of sound he came to generate from the piano. The superhuman circular breathing of
Evan Parker, the sung and played multiphonics of Vinko Globokar, and related techniques such
as microtonal playing, control of sustained simultaneous layers of tones or of multiphonics, and
rhythmic innovations, colored the playing of many musicians in the 1960s and 1970s, up
through the present.xxix
In the last decade of the twentieth century, a transcultural explosion among
improvisers has blurred distinctions that may have been based on ethnicity or race. Derek
Bailey, in his book, Improvisation, claims that free improvisation resists labeling due to its most
consistent characteristic: diversity. However, he goes on to qualify this diversity as resulting
from a lack of stylistic or idiomatic commitment, a neutrality intrinsic to free improvisation that
is primarily defined by the sonic identity of the players involved. Baileys position, admittedly
purist, hooks up beautifully with automatism. Bailey decries a certain sound which is produced
by a saxophone player when his soul is being stirred, which to me freezes the balls, it stops
xxix
. Other instrumentalists active as early as the 1960s deserve mention for expanding the sonic
potentials of their instruments, including Steve Lacy, Don Cherry, Irene Schweitzer, George
Lewis, Richard Teitelbaum, Derek Bailey, Tony Oxley, Peter Brotzman, Peter Kowald, Joelle
Leandre, Paul Lovens, Joseph Jarman, Albert Mangelsdorff, Leo Smith, Leroy Jenkins, Philip
Wachsman, Misha Mengelberg.
23
everything in its tracks. (Corbett 1994:234-235) The non-viable products of the previously
stated algorithm could, in Baileys case, represent just this sort of overhumanized, associative
sound that he so vehemently rejects.
Free improvisation, for me, has always been a journey into the unknown, a tool
for unearthing profound discoveries, and a method for generating complex structures---which
can contain referential as well as non-referential sounds and phrases. Although Im not a
purist, and sometimes have conflicting feelings about improvisation, Ive found ways to
reconcile composition and improvisation. Musicians who have spent years exploring methods of
combining these two ways of music-making sometimes grow ambivalent toward improvisation.
For instance, Anthony Braxton equates total improvisation with existential anarchy, implying
that he believes some structure is necessary to generate the kind of forward motion responsible
for any musical evolution. (Lock 1988:236-237) Anthony Davis articulates a similar position in
the liner notes to Episteme (1981): I have turned more and more toward precise musical
notation to insure that the improviser is consciously and physically tuned in to the overall
structure of a piece. On first glance this approach would seem to inhibit the improviser. This is a
valid criticism, but I believe that this inhibition is now a real necessity when one perceives that
free or open improvisation has become a clich, a musical dead end. Although I believe that
weve attempted to solve similar problems, I cant agree with Daviss conclusion. My
philosophy is more attuned to that of Lukas Foss, who writes some twenty years earlier, on the
record sleeve to Time Cycles, that in Composition all becomes fate, in Improvisation there
remains chance and hazard, which can be corrected by the will (of the improvisors).xxx
Automatism in postmodern music
Davey Williams and LaDonna Smith, proponents of free improvisation who make
their homes in Birmingham, Alabama, have managed to carve out a lively scene for
xxx
. Ironically, the reservations of Braxton and Davis are the result of far more extensive
experience with improvisation, and with improvisers, than Foss can claim to have had.
24
. The recording documents the live stage performance, presented in 1975 at the University of
Alabamas Ferguson Theater.
xxxii
. Fred Lane, the alter ego of Tim Reed, has become a cult figure, especially following the
Shimmy Disc release of his surrealist / vaudevillian recording, From the One That Cut You.
Craig Nutt observes that its impossible to fully appreciate Fred Lane without a knowledge of
American pop and advertising culture from 1920 on. According to Nutt, Lane once told a
reporter from the Tuscaloosa News, when asked where he got his ideas from (he also writes,
draws, and creates whirligigs that sell in craft shows, galleries and boutiques), replied They fall
out of my head and I pick them up and put them in a plastic bag.
25
on the recording anticipates the work of Andy Kaufman. In addition to Lanes send-ups of
covers, and the jokes, serious music was an equal participant in the Revue. It provided the
occasion for the premiere of my first collage composition, Concerto for Active Frogs. This piece
uses call-and-response techniques, organized on a graphic score, to bring human musicians
together with frog and toad vocalizations. In a collective work, Captains of Industry, the entire
company of musicians played appliances, televisions, and shavers on stage. Despite an
environment entirely uncomprehending of our art forms and indifferent to our experiments, we
put on an unforgettable show, arming ourselves with canned applause aimed back at the
audience.
The Raudelunas recording went through two pressings, and in 1998 was identified
in The Wire as one of the 100 Records That Set The World On Fire . . . While No One Was
Listeningxxxiii Some choice comments conclude Ed Baxters review: No other record has ever
come as close to realising Alfred Jarrys desire to make the soul monstrous---or even had the
vision or invention to try. Its all over the place. The sleevenotes describe it as the best thing
ever---time has not damaged this audacious claim. (Baxter 1998:35-36)
Some of the musicians involved in the Pataphysical Revue met on a weekly basis,
stretching the limitations of their instruments and exploring the dynamics of group
improvisation.xxxiv Our collective awareness of the first-generation European improvisers,
thanks to the recordings produced by Incus and FMP, was crucial for our morale, as there was no
audience to speak of for this kind of music at that point time in an Alabama university town
xxxiii
. The list of names that made the final 100 stretch from Captain Beefheart to Youssou
NDour to Public Enemy to Glenn Gould---and most were said to break the patterns imposed by
their previous successes.
xxxiv
. Free music, when it becomes a group activity, requires a synergistic approach and a
sublimation of the strong ego to insure that the group intuition remains unblocked. At the
moment of the conception of the music, all creative parties interact---and therein lies an essential
difference between the act of group improvisation and the act of composition. This synergy (and energy) blooms
naturally in groups that have performed together for many years, such as Smith and Williams, or the trio with Alex
von Schlippenbach, Evan Parker, and Paul Lovens, or the more structured but still highly improvisatory Willem
Breuker Kollektief.
26
obsessed with football and fraternities. The knowledge that kindred spirits across the ocean were
making music in a similar vein was immensely empowering.xxxv Did we associate the
automatism of the surrealist movement with improvisation when we began to pursue this avenue
of music making? Not right away, but we were all avid admirers of surrealist art and writing,
and gradually came to comprehend the obvious parallel.
The spirit of free improvisation, I believe, aligns itself squarely with the
democratic aesthetic of the surrealists. Breton never retracted his assertion, Surrealism is within
the compass of every unconscious (my italics), and repeatedly declared that the realm of the
surreal was open to anyone.xxxvi The recording Dinosaur Time, also on the Say Day-Bew label,
provides a cogent illustration of this ultra-postmodern philosophy of inclusion. Craig Nutt and
Nolan Hatcher, neither of whom had learned to play keyboards,xxxvii were the sole artists on this
album of keyboard duets. Not content to limit themselves to two Steinway pianos, they also
performed on esoteric reproductions of keyboards, including a 17th century Flemish harpsichord
and a triple-fretted clavichord.
The artistic underground in Tuscaloosa in the 1960s and 1970s has yet to be
documented and remains ripe for an extensive critical examination. However, this brief portrait
sets the stage for the milieu in which Davey Williams and LaDonna Smith hooked up with one
another, initiating an intensive development of their unique musical signatures.
Davey Williams, in his recordings and live performances, has created an
unparalleled, and much imitated, sonic world bursting with visceral imagery and ironic
xxxv
. Exchanges of letters and recordings with Derek Bailey, Peter Kowald, Paul Lovens, Evan
Parker, and others eventually led to performances and recordings in Europe (none of our core
group had ever been anywhere outside of the South).
xxxvi
27
commentary on the entire history of guitar playing. Williamss extremely personal style was
forged by his participation in blues bands led by Johnny Shines. For several years in the late
1960s and intermittently throughout the 1970s, Williams performed with Shines and company
in an assortment of juke joints and dives all over the rural and urban South. His fractured
playing, studded with the enormously rich vocabulary of the blues, exudes an ever-shifting
patina of irony, comedy and ironic solemnity. His guitar, like a magicians hat, spits out
fragmented folk tunes that he instantaneously warps into wry commentary, such as the
subversive duet with LaDonna Smith, Biscuits Mystic Birdhouse Blues on their duo CD,
Transmutating.
The fact that Williams also writes (fiction, poetry, criticism) and paints surreal
scenes (usually in oil see the cover to Charmed, Im Sure: a monstrous baseball glove hovers
over a sailor and his lover embracing in mid-air) shades and shapes his music in ways that are
absolutely unique. His performances are visually compelling, pierced by startling, quicksilver
changes. As early as 1970, he was summoning sounds from his guitar with eggbeaters,
eventually adding tape measures, electric motors, and all manner of other toys and obscure
mechanical gizmos.xxxviii In playing his electric guitar with mechanized or electronic gadgets, he
creates a discrete and highly personal universe of original timbral objects. On Babys First
Words, the last cut on his latest solo recording, Charmed, Im Sure, a standard slide guitar riff
over a gently throbbing bass, all very minimal, gives way to the commentary elicited from the
guitar by playing it with a cordless drink mixer. Its simultaneously hilarious and unsettling.
The normal guitar eventually drops out, leaving the rough semi-pitched drink mixer/guitar to be
rudely cut off by a cuckoo clock striking nine oclock. On track 2 of this same recording, he
single-handedly conjures a train streaking through the Southern darkness, with ominous
overtones, yet drenched in that convulsive beauty so central to surrealist aesthetics. Our Little
xxxviii
. Check out the riveting Sonata for Motorized Shark, Baseball Glove, and Electric Guitar
on Transmutating.
28
Sawmill, a superb example of one of Williamss signature sound worlds, seamlessly intertwines
exterior mechanical noises with guitar playing to produce striking timbral similarities between
the guitar and the saw, each acquiring a distinct personality in the course of the piece.xxxix
Williams shatters his vast blues vocabulary into sound objects. Integrating these
referential segments into his more abstracted musical language, he sometimes gravitates toward
collage forms. For example, New Boots, for bass and two electric guitars, weaves three
simultaneous planes of generic fragments from blues (slides, for instance) and rock guitar into an
arhythmic fractured collage. The deconstructing of the foundation of the almighty Beat
exposes techniques indigenous to highly identifiable musics (especially, in this case, the blues)
but removes the beat / body element, so that the piece seems to float in hyper-space. Williams
achieves a similar effect on The Nomads-- for bass, two electric guitars, and toaster oven. By
layering three distinct lines--a virtuosic, perpetual-motion figure, a lyrical foreground, and a bass
that projects the persona of a sawmill as well as a bass, all punctuated with the toaster-oven as
dysfunctional drum machine--Williams refers, albeit obliquely, to the stereotypical ways that
guitars tend to be played. Williamss uncanny and exquisite sense of timing, a testament to the
potency and generosity of his gift, confers a sense of twisted suspense to his performances.
Witnessing his performances, one can truly observe the lightening-quick gestures of an
abstracted musical automatism.
LaDonna Smith, violist and vocalist, has collaborated with Davey Williams in
their duo, Trans Museq, for over twenty years, with hundreds of performances principally in
Europe and the U.S.xl Also a visual artist, she has created an extensive body of surrealistinspired sculpture.xli A propelling force behind the explosion of free improvisation erupting
xxxix
. Our Little Sawmill was performed with three electric guitars, bass pedal, and features a
tape of a Dremel tool cutting a French perfume bottle.
xl
. Smith, like Williams, frequently performs with other musicians as well, and as a soloist.
xli
. The surrealists often engaged in overlapping artistic disciplines. For example, the painters
Giorgio de Chirico and Leonora Carrington each penned novels---the former published
Hebdomeros, and the latter The Hearing Trumpet. Pierrepont points out that Smiths sculptures,
29
from time to time in Birmingham, Alabama, Smith has devoted a vast amount of time and energy
to the journal she co-founded with Williams, the improvisor---the only international periodical
devoted to improvisation.
In contrast to Williams, Smith was trained as a classical musician and composer.
Her playing is somewhat more abstract, less referential. However, her raw energy has a visceral,
animalistic quality that keeps her music from ever sounding studied. Her performances are
models for sheer stream of consciousness playing techniques. The relationship of her
instrument to her singing enhances the effect of this streaming: the viola morphs into a natural
extension of her voice.xlii
Smiths playing displays a fiery, freewheeling power. Several pieces from her
solo recording, Eye of the Storm, illustrate her sleight-of-voice technique: she knits her
vocalizations into sounds coaxed from her viola so seamlessly that its often impossible to know
where the voice enters and exits, and even whether its real or imagined. In Fire in the Old
Growth, she draws strands of harmonics, combination tones, and subharmonics out of her viola,
weaving them into polyphonies enhanced with and at times triggered by her voice. Viola
Coaster Rainbows lurches into a wild, vertiginous, swooping ride with shards of vocal
pyrotechnics spinning out from rapidly skittering bow work, a totally mad excursion. Smith
makes Laurie Anderson sound like a Lawrence Welk act.
Her aggressive, multi-layered playing style results in an astonishing variety of
textures that could never be precisely notated, such as the low register peregrinations in Flash
Flood in Downtown Decatur. Traveling Nimbocumulous hurdles along with hardly a pause,
an amazingly bountiful cornucopia of harmonics that are at times inflected to sound eerily like
and Williams hilarious texts, define them as surrealists as much as their music does.
(Pierrepont 1999:126)
xlii
. The origin of music in the body is an important concept for Smith. Decrying the tradeoff
resulting from the accessibility of all musics through the media, Smith concludes, the normal
person has lost his own inner vibration as an extension of himself. (Smith 1996:7)
30
Korean zither music. Smith even reinvents the drone composition in Oceanic Sleep, with its
intermittent open C string cushioning a host of progeny. The harmonics, all gyrating out of one
primal sound, are so active and multi-linear that its difficult to believe one person is playing the
music.
Williams and Smith have been outspoken in print and in public about the potential
inherent in everyone for musical improvisation.xliii Smith challenges trained musicians to let go
of convention and come back to invention. She speaks eloquently for the acceptance of any
sound: All sounds: pure and clean, fuzzed, split and dirty, thick, thin, high, low, loud, soft, free,
fat, limited, or loaded belong to the larynx of the soul and the minds rational counterpart, the
imagination. (Smith 1996:8)
The intense interaction and musical rapport between Smith and Williams are
legendary. They claim to communicate telepathically when performing in duo, and its difficult
to harbor any skepticism after witnessing their joint performances.xliv On their latest duo
recording, Transmutating, the first and longest piece moves toward a haunting lyricism between
low voice and guitar, suddenly veering into screeching voice/viola accompanied by sparse
subterranean guitar plunks from the opposite extreme of the registral spectrum. The two
instruments merge, swapping positions, and Smiths voice yaps out a parodic imitation of the
guitar figuration, sending it up to stratospheric, theremin-like heights. When an exposed circular
xliii
. The British guitarist Derek Bailey, a purist and great advocate of the power and value of
improvisation, writes of the psychic dimensions of group improvisation in Improvisation
Kunst ohne Werk (Wolke Verlag, Hofheim, 1987), Improvisation its nature and practice in
music (The British Library National Sound Archive, London, 1992): But ultimately the
greatest rewards in free improvisation are to be gained in playing with other people. Whatever
the advantages to solo playing there is a whole side to improvisation, the more exciting, the more
magical side, which can only be discovered by people playing together. The essence of
improvisation, its intuitive, telepathic foundation, is best explored in a group situation. And the
possible musical dimensions of group playing far outstrip those of solo playing. (Bosshard,
Fredi, in brochure announcement for Total Music Meeting 1999, August 11, 1999)
31
32
xlv
. Many of Ashleys works are fueled, in part, by the process, or thought, or ideal, of automatic
speech.
xlvi
. Bretons first wife, Simone Collinet, justified their collective play as a method of research, a
means of exaltation and stimulation, a gold mine of findings, maybe even a drug. (Breton
1975:30)
xlvii
. Some writers on surrealism believe that chance was the surrealists preferred method for
artistic organization. Their practice of automatism and their application of chance procedures
became so intertwined that it is often not possible to differentiate the two, a concept explored by
Martin Willenbrink. (Willenbrink, 1985:151-154)
33
performed with writing, were: 1) write a word or phrase on a piece of paper; 2) fold it so that the
writing couldnt be seen; 3) pass it around in this manner until a sentence was completed. A
prescribed and carefully followed grammatical structure provided a consistent framework. The
first sentence considered worthy of retention was Le cadavre exquis boira le vin nouveau
(The exquisite corpse will drink the new wine)---each of five players contributing one of the
principal words involved. Hence, the birth of the game Exquisite Corpse.
Breton defended the value of the game, admitting, however, that it was initially a source
of entertainment: If there is one activity in Surrealism which has most invited the derision of
imbeciles, it is our playing of games . . .Although as a defensive measure we sometimes
described such activity as experimental we were looking to it primarily for entertainment, and
those rewarding discoveries it yielded in relation to knowledge only came later.xlviii (Breton
[1954]1993:157) Many of these discoveries emerged from the visual variant of the game.
Instead of a sentence, participants would draw a figure, leaving only the ends of some lines
showing to insure continuity. The unexpected results were amusing, disturbing, revealing, and
have been compared to the art of madmen and of children. The resulting collage form
representing the Exquisite Corpse, born of a collective spirit, has proved to be remarkably
enduring.xlix
The trust in the power of the group to blindly fuse fragmentation into a whole (sentence
xlviii
. Bretons interpretation of the value of this amusement comes from his only essay on games,
quoted in a boxed compilation documenting surrealist games and related collaborative
techniques.
xlix
. The timelessness of this game was documented in an exhibit travelling during 1993 1995,
The Return of the Cadavre Exquis, produced by the Drawing Center in New York. More than
one thousand artists participated, using the bodys anatomy as points for metaphoric departure.
Many of their Exquisite Corpses have been documented in the exhibition catalogue of the same
name. At least one musician, Christian Marclay (one of the musicians playing on John Zorns
Cobra, discussed below), is represented in a striking collaboration with two other artists, in
which a pair of sutured lips, two green stripes, and a pair of legs cemented into one clay foot
yields an image of thwarted expression, an evocation of censorship not one of its parts belie.
(Schaffner 1993:55-56)
34
or drawing) reflects a facet of postmodernism embedded in the surrealist sensibility, even though
surrealism, as a movement, is far more frequently associated with modernism. Yet another
aspect of postmodernism embodied by the surrealists is their democratic attitude toward creating
art. In the exhibition catalogue for the Nesuhi Ertegun and Daniel Filipacchi collections of
surrealist art, shown at the Guggenheim Museum in 1999, Jos Pierre remarks that the most
inventive examples of Exquisite Corpse were not always those created by the most accomplished
artists, but were instead produced by the poets Breton, Eluard, and Tzara in collaboration with
their wives and mistresses. (Pierre 1999: 618-619) As weve seen in the prior discussion of
automatism in music, Smith and Williams also espouse a philosophy of inclusiveness.
Musical parallels to Exquisite Corpse are problematic, due to the simultaneous
dimensions of time and space that it inhabits. In the same year that the Corpse was born, two
Belgian surrealists attempted to transfer automatic writing into the musical medium. Modeled on
surrealist procedures of collective creation, Paul Hooreman and Andr Souris wrote Tombeau de
Socrate, a monodie in the form of a mazurka published in the magazine Musique I in 1925, to
commemorate the death of Erik Satie. (Willenbrink 1985:154) A simple mazurka-like statement
with no bar lines, it doesnt begin to convey the abrupt shifts and fantastical associations so
prevalent among the Exquisite Corpse-derived works of surrealist art and literature. The syntax
of music was not yet expanded sufficiently enough to allow for transmission of the very factors
that were so intrinsically identified with the Corpse.
Moving closer to the spirit of disruption, the American composers John Cage, Lou
Harrison, Henry Cowell, and Virgil Thomson, all mutual friends, took part in the creation of
sonorous corpses around the middle of the 1940s. Lou Harrison, in the preface to the
collaborative score, Party Pieces,l explains their procedures, directly derived from the surrealist
l
. Published by C.F. Peters in 1982, Party Pieces exists as a score of twenty brief collaboratively
written works, arranged by Robert Hughes for various combinations of flute, clarinet, bassoon,
horn, and piano. The front and back covers are illustrated with collective drawings by Thomson,
Cage, and Harrison.
35
game. Each composer present would write a measure, fold the paper at the bar line and, on the
new fresh sheet, put only two notes to guide the next composer in his connection. The next
composer would write a bar, fold at the bar line and leave two more black spots and so on. It
seems to me that we would begin simultaneously and pass them along in rotation in a sort of
surrealist assembly line and eagerly await the often incredible outcome. The twenty published
pieces display varying degrees of abrupt shifts in motivic and tonal consistency, while projecting
a lighthearted, irresistible charm.li
These examples employ traditional music notation, with the advantage that each
participant remains largely unaware of the previous contribution. Yet, they seem tame compared
to the startling images of the surrealist-produced Exquisite Corpse poetry and drawings. Fast
forward some forty years later, and the composer John Zorn is briskly capturing the lively spirit
of the Corpse, and of postmodernism in music, with the sheer exuberance and stunning collisions
that characterize one of his game pieces for improvising musicians, Cobra.lii A self-professed
new Romantic, opposed to neutrality and cold calculation, Zorn describes Cobra as a
psychodrama where everybodys personality comes out in very exaggerated ways. (Gagne
1993:515) A system based on rules, as opposed to a composition, Cobra generates a
smorgasbord of references run amok, ranging from a shameless appropriation of genres (blues,
country, jazz, rock, ambient, traditional Asian/generic pentatonic), to film noir soundtrack
stereotypes, to warped allusions to Beethovens Fifth, to clucking chickens and ringing phones,
to fragments of unidentifiable noise, to phrases from Fly Me to the Moon, and on and on.
Thick textures of simultaneities alternate with transparent soloistic episodes; random noise
improvisations bump up against quotes from Mozarts Concerto for Flute and Harp. The
li
. Interestingly, each of the twenty published works was the result of a collaborative effort
among three or fewer composers. Virgil Thompson participated in only five pieces, and never
shared a collaborative effort with Henry Cowell.
lii
. Zorn had previously constructed several game pieces in the late 70s: Lacrosse, Fencing, and
Archery. The name Cobra, designed in 1984, was taken from a war game. Totally contrasting
versions of the piece are represented on the studio and live recordings.
36
disjunct sonic images that flow from one into another like schizoid dreams simulate the Exquisite
Corpses fondness for unrelated images, and generate those ephemeral yet powerful frictional
sparks so coveted by the surrealists.
For the surrealists, the greater the jolt, the greater the value of the image. As
Andr Masson observed in Le Cadavre exquis, son exaltation, the important thing for the
surrealists engaged in the game of Exquisite Corpse was the arrival of the surprising image
(Breton 1975:28)---the consequence of a group interaction. Likewise, in Zorns Cobra, the rate
of change, the harmonic rhythm of the sound blocks, depends upon the complex interplay
among a community of musicians who are adept improvisers. Devoid of musical notation,
Cobras structure relies instead upon rules that provide a linguistic framework.liii The
unfettered individual contributions must still function within Zorns strict system of rules, an
oxymoronic proposition delivering an organized spontaneity that paradoxically doesnt sound
controlled. By capitalizing upon the unique skills of the chosen performers, who operate at full
tilt with the support of a quasi-structured environment, Zorns Cobra advances notions of
aleatoric composition into uncharted territory.
The collective, playful, and all-embracing nature of Cobra (and of the cadvre
exquis) opposes modernist principles of singularity, reductiveness, and rigid constraints, and is
thus symbolic of a musical postmodernism. In the exhibition catalogue, The Return of the
Cadavre Exquis, Ingrid Schaffners metaphor, related to consumerism, aligns the Exquisite
Corpse with an expansion of modernisms closed systems: the cadvre exquis, surrealisms
abject offspring, is a visual department store disgorged of its goods, an assembly line of absurd--at times, sublime---expressions. One could just as easily describe Cobra as an audible
department store disgorged of its goods, and, to borrow yet another phrase from Schaffners
discussion of the historic Exquisite Corpses, equally pertinent, these works exist as
liii
. The built-in safeguard of a guerilla system---akin to a system of checks and balances--allows the players to demolish, subvert, or redirect anything that has become too predictable or
otherwise not to their liking.
37
uninterpreted records, novel apparitions of point sublime, that spot on the distant horizon where
everything---rational and irrational, conscious and unconscious, abstract and concrete--converge. (Schaffner 1993:43)
Although the musicians playing Cobra can hear one another in the flow of time
(as opposed to the surrealists, from whom fragments of Exquisite Corpse words or drawings
were concealed, or the Party Pieces composers, who also played the game blindfolded), the
end result is the same: a collage, assembled in real time. In 1935, one group of surrealists went
so far as to introduce a variant, a kind of collage on collage, by making cadavres out of corpses
of by-gone publicity until our supply of old magazines was reduced to shreds. (Jean 1993:74)
This recycling of old material, pruning it and then repotting it in unfamiliar soil, finds its musical
twin in the radical technique of plunderphonics.
Collage
Plunderphonics, a form of self-referential audio collage, has been around for some
fifty years. The word itself, however, was only recently introduced by one of its foremost
practitioners, John Oswald. Plunderphonics is a term Ive coined to cover the counter-covert
world of converted sound and retrofitted music, where collective melodic memories of the
familiar are minced and rehabilitated to a new life. Oswald elaborates further, A
plunderphone is an unofficial but recognizable musical quote. (Oswald 1995:89)
When Max Ernst turned to collage as the underlying principle of his art, he
inaugurated a new chapter in art history: his own art became unabashedly dependent on
previously existing depictions of art, from which he fashioned his fantastic collage-novels.
Similarly, Oswald relies on recorded music for his elaborately constructed plunderings. One
major difference looms over this Ernst / Oswald analogy: Ernsts collages were constructed
from informative matter that wasnt copyrighted and that generally possessed no independent
aesthetic value, whereas Oswald deliberately selects portions of audio recordings that have
already acquired aesthetic and / or monetary value. Yet, Oswald is hardly beholden to the
baggage of values attached to his found sound objects. Obviously, he can ignore their origins
38
and treat his found objects as independent chunks of sound. Or, as Chris Cutler recognized in his
perceptive article on the subject of plunderphonics, a plundered object can also be exploited.
As a pirated cultural artifact, a found object, as debris from the sonic environment, a plundered
sound also holds out an invitation to be used because of its cause, and because of all the
associations and cultural apparatus that surround it. (Cutler 1995:74) Cutler goes on to compare
captured visual images of artists such as Warhol and Rauschenberg, or directly imported
objects such as the Readymades of Duchamp, with the potential for an analogous lassoing of
sound images.
The far more common, and accepted, practice of plundering among visual artists
hasnt escaped Oswalds attention. Its somewhat ironic that in visual arts, theres been all sorts
of appropriation issues and dialogues going on for a long time. Theres people who do much
more extreme things than I do, like take a photograph of a photograph and put their name on it
and say This is my art. This sort of transformation is old hat, like Marcel Duchamp painting a
moustache on the Mona Lisa. (Jones 1995:133)
Plunderphonics may be one of the most complex challenges yet to notions of
individuality and ownership. By drawing exclusively upon material created by another
individual, the practice itself demands a re-examination and re-evaluation of our understanding
of property rights and of originality itself. As practiced by Oswald and others, plunderphonics is
totally dependent upon recording technology. As technological developments in the audio field
have become more sophisticated, especially with the movement away from analog techniques
and into the digital realm, plundering techniques have likewise become increasingly widespread,
more refined, and have elicited greater controversy. Cutler makes the salient point that
plundered sound, with its unique ability to simultaneously refer and to be, offers not just a new
means but a new meaning. It is this dual character that confuses the debates about originality
which so vex it. (Cutler 1995:74)
In his fascinating historical synopsis of the use of the gramophone as an instrument,
Cutler cites a 1920 dada event where Stephan Wolpe used eight gramophones to simultaneously
39
play recordings at differing speeds. He cites plundering precedents by Schaeffer, Cage, the
Beatles, Zappa, the Residents, and Christian Marclay, among others. A brief account of pop
applications of plundering emphasizes Hip Hop, House, and Techno music (some DJ techniques,
in fact, are physically reminiscent of frottage). Cutler also addresses the sticky issue of
copyright, including salient facts regarding Oswalds Plunderphonics recording, and
summarizes plundering and its far-reaching tentacles into the five following types of
applications. 1) There it is: materials randomly derived from records or radio are manipulated
(as in Cages Imaginary Landscapes 2 and 4). 2) Partial importations: recordings are built
around ethnic music, animal vocalizations, sound effects. 3) Total importation: existing
recordings become the simultaneous subject and object of a creative work, raising the issue of
originality in the re-contextualisation of existing recordings. 4) Sources irrelevant: sampling of
generic sounds, where no self-reflexivity is involved and recognition of plundered parts isnt
important. 5) Sources untraceable: plundered sounds are so altered that their sources cannot be
ascertained. (Cutler 1995:67-85)
John Oswald carried the cut and paste technique of collage to its outer limits, shredding
and realigning pre-existing materials to form distinctive portraitures of a band, of a pop song and
its singer, and of an entire cross-section of pop and rock tunes from the decade spanning 19821992. The following three examples illustrate these plunder approaches. The cut and paste
method prevails, paralleling montage, the more time-oriented form of collage. Z, Oswalds
plunderphonicised version of Naked City (a band led by John Zorn), represents an extreme form
of plunderphonics: in fourteen seconds, he rips through 47 edits of 35 sound slices, each between
1/20 and 1 second long. With his choices of fragments and their ordering, Oswald not only
captures the breathless, manic energy of the band, but also invokes a kind of sonic fingerprint
that encapsulates the essence of Naked City.
Oswald takes his method of sonic portraiture to the next level with DAB, from the CD
40
Plunderphonics.liv In Creatigality, his article published in Sounding Off!, Oswald asserts that
transformation can be revitalizing. Indeed, by distilling Michael Jacksons hit Bad into a
brilliant series of fragments redolent of the songs very marrow, highlighting its iconic markers--syllables and words, falsetto whoops, breathy punctuations, percussive instrumentation,
syncopation, and so on---Oswald plays hide and seek with the range of perceptibility and
recognition. His skillful surgery proceeds quite naturally into an abstract non-referential sonic
realm, as though he were exploring the songs most intimate physical components. This pseudorevelation of the very atomic structure of a song, exposing its DNA, was initiated by James
Tenney in his classic 1961 realization, Collage #1 (Blue Suede), based on Elvis Presleys
version of Blue Suede Shoes.
Just as Oswalds DAB evokes Michael Jacksons singing (and, by association, his
dancing) in Bad, Tenneys Collage #1, with far more limited technical means, opaquely
resuscitates Elviss rendition of Blue Suede Shoes. Although thirty-two years of aesthetic and
technological developments separate these two plunderings, they are each marked, unmistakably,
by their source material (Presley and Jackson) as filtered through their re-creators (Tenney and
Oswald). In Collage #1, the identity of the source song, and Elvis himself, remain a mystery
until one minute and seventeen seconds into the piece, when the distinct timbre of Presleys
voice breaks through the more amorphous sonic material (also formed from Blue Suede Shoes).
For the remainder of the piece, snippets of phrases such as step in my flutter in and out of the
foreground, and are colored by portions of the song that have been processed beyond
recognition. Oswalds DAB, nearly twice as long (seven minutes), also begins without a clue as
to its origins, but not for long. At thirteen seconds into the piece, a close listening reveals the
liv
. This recording has become notorious, thanks to heavy-handed legal maneuvering by one of
the plundered artists. Released on October 31, 1989, the recording Plunderphonics represented
the culmination of ten years of work, with Oswald drawing upon source material by Michael
Jackson, Dolly Parton, Count Basie, Stravinsky, and many others. It was never for sale; releases
were directed to radio and other media. CBS Records rapidly pursued the destruction of the CD,
and as of January 30, 1990, distribution ceased and all extant copies were destroyed.
41
repetitive phrase whos bad. Present as a wordless rhythm only (although a wh sound triggers
the repeating motif), it quickly leads to more readily recognizable repetitions of the word bad
over a rhythm track and bass line. The technology available to Oswald, as well as the more
pronounced syncopation in Jacksons Bad, contribute to the visceral rhythmic sensibility of DAB.
Interestingly, Oswald chooses to devote the latter half of his rendering to a total deconstruction
of the original song, removing all obvious references or radically transforming them, whereas
Tenney employed a similar process during the first half of Collage #1.
What happens when vast collections of different songs are chopped into tiny fragments
that contaminate and hybridize one another? Oswald assembles a relentless barrage of such
snippets on his CD Plexurelv, featuring dozens of composite artists such as Moody Crue, John
Lennoncamp, Sinead OConnick Jr., They Might Be Grateful, 9 Inch Monkees, Spinal Top--well, you get the idea.lvi This time, whole chunks of boiled-down stereotypical pop images fly
out of the speakers, and the result is frequently hilarious as well as illuminating.
The idea for Plexure had its origins in Oswalds fascination with perceptual boundaries.
And the notion of perceptual limits is bound up with one of the central issues raised by
plundering: At what point does a sound claim ownership? (Jones 1995:132) This raises yet
another point: At what point does a fragment lose its recognizability? Surprisingly, Oswald
claims that he can recognize a sliver measuring twenty milliseconds (a 50th of a second),
provided that hes already familiar with the piece to which it belongs. In Plexure, he primarily
works with durations of one-third of a second, but sometimes goes beyond the threshold of
recognition with events that are five milliseconds long. Oswald has the seasoned improvisers
unerring instinct for fitting together thousands of puzzle pieces in his assemblages for Plexure.
A few visual guideposts are provided for the listener. In the liner notes, for instance, an attempt
lv
lvi
. The large number of sources precluded legal negotiations, hence the morphing of artists
names (a playful reflection of the audio morphings).
42
is made to transcribe the fractured lyrics. Ive been, I have weight, I wait, have I half have been,
I help hap hip wait, bin wading waiting, way been, whew, for you, reams that little phrase for
all its worth, and, by so doing, reinvigorates a banality.
But how, exactly, can the cutting up of a previously recognizable element serve to
rejuvenate it? Derrida, in distinguishing post-critical collage from conventional collage,
provides one explanation: a calculated insemination of the proliferating allogene through which
the two texts are transformed, deform each other, contaminate each others content, tend at times
to reject each other, or pass elliptically one into the other and become regenerated in the
repetition . . . Each grafted text continues to radiate back toward the site of its removal,
transforming that too, as it affects the new territory. (Dissemination cited in Ulmer 1983: 90)
Derridas description can be applied to Oswalds pieces on the Plexure recording as long as their
elements (sources) can be identified. At the end of the recording, identification becomes a moot
exercise as the progressively shortened clips create an effect similar to the closing fusillade of a
fireworks display, when explosions come so fast and furiously that they overlap spectacularly in
space and time.
As a polemical instrument, Oswalds wielding of plunderphonics to challenge current
assumptions regarding proprietary rights constitutes a courageous stance, befitting a pioneer of
the genre. Differentiating the blatant appropriation of sound fragments from related techniques
of wholesale sampling, of imitation, parody, or allusion, and even of outright theft ----i.e.,
Stravinskys good composer [who] does not imitate, [but] steals--- Oswald has carved out a
legitimate, vital, and inevitable subgenre, linked to the centuries-old practice of creative
borrowing among composers. By limiting himself to material of a consistent nature, or to a
period from cultural history, Oswald fashions a complex mnemonic concordance to a decade of
number ones with a bullet that skips across the radio waves like a K-Tel album gone insane,
channel surfing with a toddlers sense of wonder and an architects sense of structure. (Jones
1995:139) Plexure, the most ambitious and longest of the three examples cited, sacrifices an
articulate syntax for sheer power, a relentless bombardment reminiscent of Phil Spectors grand
43
wall of sound. DAB, however, confined to a singular mining site, reflects an original formal
structure riddled with multiple levels of signification.
The surrealists frequently imported ordinary ready-made fragments into previously
unrelated contexts in their collages. In one of his first texts published on visual art (linked to
Ernsts first show in Paris, in 1921), Breton declared that, since human effort could produce
nothing new, artists must limit themselves to reapplications of existing materials. A typically
dogmatic stance, yet visionary, and confirmed nearly eighty years later by a leading analyst of
surrealist collage: Collage and assemblage, manipulating already existing signs, are a
privileged mode of creating the surreal. (Adamowicz 1998:11) Both writers make their
observations within the context of visual art, but they could just as well be referring to the
unconventional deployment of familiar music or sounds as raw material. Photography and film,
in providing the means for previously unimagined transformations of pre-existing visual (and
sonic) elements, parallel the introduction of possibilities for similar transformations in the audio
sphere, due to developments in recording technology.
Strategies of selection and combination of the pre-formed elements are paramount to the
successful effect of any collage, whether verbal, pictorial, or musical. In my own Concerto for
Active Frogs, natural vocalizations of frogs and toads were carefully selected and ordered to
achieve maximum theatrical effect. The resulting tapestry of sounds inhabiting the tape collage
inspires amphibian-like responses from the human vocalists and instrumentalists, while also
strongly influencing the dramatic rhythm.
Electroacoustic music offers a wealth of examples echoing surrealist collage
aesthetics. I here on a single example in which the composer uses signifying units to fashion a
sound portrait---or, more to the point, a caricature---of the late composer Morton Feldman. In
his dramatic piece for tape, The King of Buffalo, Mark Steven Brooks melds choice bits of
interview material, both raw and processed, to radical alterations of Feldmans music. In this
satirical, yet oddly moving, sonic depiction of Feldman, Brooks imprints his own compositional
markings onto the Feldman source materials. The listener can either play the detective---
44
identifying, decoding, and analyzing the disparate elements---or can submit to the inventiveness,
the humor, and the dream-like passages.
The piece begins with Feldmans Brooklyn-accented wish, I want to be the first
great composer that is Jewish, setting a tone of unbridled arrogance. Derisive laughter follows
(Feldmans own private joke?), and were suddenly immersed in an amorphous, eerie electronic
sound world that converges into a rhythm track, providing stability for an outpouring of
fragments and complete sentences that hints at things to come.
The phrase If I could be presumptuous, I could say that all important things
negate the world begins the next section, unified by a simple percussive motif tinged with
reverb. Feldman goes on to complain that people didnt care for his performances, asserting that
his music is important. Subsequent processing imbues these same remarks with a plaintive wail,
a whine that, paradoxically, reveals the actual feeling behind the disappointment and anger of the
statements when theyre first heard. What might be thought of as a development section follows,
ending with the sudden fragment, there is a fascistic element in the Rolling Stones. A
confession of sorts, I have great problems precedes the belligerent sounding I dont agree
with you, which abruptly triggers a cascade of activity---almost as though the music itself
embodies a fight or flight response to Feldmans implicit challenge.
One of the most extraordinary aspects of The King of Buffalo is the autointertextuality: Feldmans observations and music are manipulated by Brooks so that they
ultimately comment upon themselves. Brookss choice of fragments, of processing means, and
of combinations and juxtapositions are not only essential to the creation of the piece, but are also
indicative of a hidden subtext, and imply a difficult personal relationship between the composer
and his subject. The resulting hybrid, a biographical /autobiographical snapshot, is infused with
ambiguity. The subject becomes portrayed (betrayed?) by his own narcissism, as interpreted by
the complex attitude of his portrayer.
Such a richly penetrating sonic portraiture brings to mind the intensely personal work of
45
Shelley Hirsch, who performs as a vocalist primarily in her own compositions.lvii Hirschs work
on recordings, although meticulously constructed, gives the appearance of spontaneity---a
testament to her skills as an improviser. Enlarging her palette with electronics, applied live and
in studio recordings, she often layers strands of fractured syllabic repetitions with increasingly
complete linear phrases, placing the listener into a decidedly non-linear, multi-dimensional
space. Yet, her most complex vertical layerings, and her most jarring horizontal juxtapositions,
are framed by a listener-friendly transparency. Her distinct brand of slightly jaded optimism and
sincerity, spiked with humor, balances the occasional darker implications of her stories.
Going as far back as her childhood, Hirsch relentlessly mines her life experiences,
concocting brilliant collage-like reminiscences that are alternately, and sometimes
simultaneously, disquieting and euphoric. Embracing archetypal personas such as Blanche
Dubois, she weaves their reinvented essences into the maze of associations conjured by her
alchemical compositions. Investigating immediate consciousness, memory consciousness, and
image-making consciousness, she becomes a producer of sonic images, recycling the discarded
and the strange. Her remarkably unfettered access to the motherlode of automatism enhances her
gift of spontaneous ingenuity.
Hirschs command of extended vocal techniques imparts enormous variety to her music.
The tone of her voice can range from audacious vulnerability, to charismatic intimacy (especially
in the story-telling segments), to hallucinatory excursions floating effortlessly out of the
spoken/sung voice and into pure Hirschian singing. Such transitions always remain viscerally
connected to the text and in context. By judiciously inserting cliched musical phrases and even
covers of commonly recognized tunes, like Blue Moon in her composition States, she exploits
a network of culturally-specific signs, twisting them into a kind of parody that hovers between
homage and satire. Quotes from the Banda music of Central Africa and the voices of a Bulgarian
lvii
. Hirsch also collaborates with many musicians. Her performances take place in a wide variety
of venues, including concerts, radio plays, films, recordings, alternative operas, and multi-media
events.
46
chorus are used to globally expand her images in this composition. Skillful underscoring
enhances and propels these and other circular story/compositions.
A type of cultural anthropology, Hirschs musical creations embody the essence
of surrealism: the division between the real and the imagined dissolves, replaced by an imaginary
world that radiates out from a vast dynamic repository of memory and association. Harry
Lachner, in the liner notes to Hirschs recording, States, writes eloquently of her non-linear
poeticism: States is . . . a pandemonium of resuscitated ghosts from the past, the present, and
the future; an illustrious parade of characters; a vocal discourse between various impersonations
of imaginary people; an associative stream of the subconscious where Shelley Hirschs singing
in tongues reformulates our own collective nightmares and hopes.
Hirschs creative transformations of kitschy fragments and her skilled shaping of
multiple dimensions suggest a quality central to the surrealist doctrine, the merveilleux: a
rupture in the order of reality. (Adamowicz 1998:11-12) Her methods go beyond conventional
definitions of composition and of performance. By violating logical, linear narrative forms, by
opposing elements from our known world in disturbing ways, she plunges herself, and her
audience, into collective reminiscences so visceral that they seem almost visual---a surreal
accomplishment in itself.
In live performances, Hirsch often relies on layering techniques, piling up a
swarming multitude of voices while maintaining a distinct function for each independent line.
This ancient method of putting several processes into play at once can be subsumed under the
rubric of polyphony. Simultaneity, conceived with respect to the thousand-year history of
polyphony, refers to concurrent yet unrelated and self-sufficent processes which dont exhibit the
organic cooperation of independent strands bound by a common harmony. In the early twentieth
century, the principal of simultaneity was applied to the fields of tonality and rhythm. Bartoks
Fourteen Bagatelles, written in 1908, represent the earliest examples of two simultaneously
played melodic lines written in different keys. Melodic, harmonic, and tonal principles of
simultaneity, along with polymetric techniques, were eagerly adopted by leading composers at
47
the turn of the century, including Stravinsky, Satie, Mussorgsky, Prokofiev, Debussy, R. Strauss,
Ives, and Milhaud.lviii
How does simultaneity relate to pictorial and verbal collage? It actually preceded
collage-technique, influencing the generation of artists and poets of 1910 and foreshadowing the
effect collage would exert on all forms of twentieth-century art. In the discordant
representational and abstract forms found in Picassos Torero, in Chagalls I and the Village,
with its depictions of rural life juxtaposed and interwoven in a non-naturalistic fashion, and in
the poetry of Apollinaire, juxtaposed simultaneities paradoxically function as unifying elements,
while at the same time inducing fragmentation.
Hal Freedman has accomplished a feat analogous to Oswalds kamikaze cut-andpaste, with his extremist application of simultaneity to one of the most monumental works in
musical history, Wagners Ring Cycle. Superimposing the entire Ring on top of itself over two
hundred times, Freedman squeezed it into a three and one-half minute tape, a massive
compression one step away from white noise. In the liner notes to the Opus One recording of
Ring Prcis, Freedman summarizes: In spite of the density, some essence of Wagner can still be
heard through all of the layers. Individual lines emerge briefly, only to sink back into the wall of
sound. True enough, and its so perversely dramatic quality is certainly suggestive for the filmic
medium. Bartok Prcis, a companion piece, reduces the six Bartok String Quartets into four
minutes and thirty seconds. This compilation, however, sonically refers more transparently to its
original creator.
Ring Prcis was choreographed and danced by Alice Farley at the 1977 International
lviii
48
Surrealism Festival in Chicago, reinforcing its pedigree as an example of surrealist music. Other
performances of the piece have elicited extremely negative audience reactions. According to
Freedman, its 1976 Columbia University premiere was simultaneously booed by the faculty and
cheered by the students---a reaction befitting a work not only defined by the process of
simultaneity, but itself defining an expanded concept of simultaneity. The impact wasnt lost on
John Cage, quoted in the liner notes of the recording: Ive always had problems with Bartoks
larger works and all of Wagners, but Hal Freedmans Prcis works remove them. I find them
perfectly beautiful.
The more rough-hewn Jungle Cookies recordings, a highly personal sonic diary, were
heavily inspired by Eugene Chadbournes trips to Amsterdam. Their demented nature is hinted
at by the tag in the liner notes, More and more weird noise, combined in a manner to make it as
incomprehensible as possible. Chadbourne, an improvising musician, explains that the records
represent an attempt to capture the music he listens to in his daily routines and travels. In other
words, they are a product of his penchant for listening to, and recording, life---in this case, life
on the streets of Amsterdam, combined with tapes and themes already created by Chadbourne
from a Pandoras Box of sound artifacts. Listening to Jungle Cookies, one can experience the
audio analog of the premise behind the film, Being John Malkovich, and, with the flip of a
switch, inhabit the ears of Eugene Chadbourne. His entertaining liner notes help the listener to
understand what, exactly, is being heard. For instance, one theme began as snippets stolen from
a batch of old LPs tossed out by a neighbor suffering from dementia, before being carted away to
the sanitarium (an appropriate signification for the deranged effect of these recordings).
Chadbourne professes to organize the Jungle pieces based on the time of day.
Attempting to capture the 3:00 A.M. slot of eerie quiet, punctuated with occasional chaos, he
writes in the liner notes, led to one of the strangest bits of composing I have done in a lifetime
of being bizarre. Unearthing a duet CD by Sammy Davis Jr. and Laurindo Almeida that had
been buried (and consequently damaged) in his backyard for a year, Chadbourne co-opted its
endless repeating and skipping as one of his 3:00 A. M. motifs, combining it with a recording of
49
a skipping Stockhausen record. He continues, A final part of this set of themes was devised by
placing our dachshund Otto in a large box which he could not escape from, full of little hand
held drum machines and gadgets. As he pranced around in there, no doubt reminding me to feed
him, he came up with wonderful drum tracks.
A long segment of one of the recordings is dominated by a texture that starts with a
repetitive motor-like sound, randomly shot through with mechanized interjections of no no no
no no no no (perhaps the Sammy Davis Jr. broken CD?). Eventually, another mechanical
sound, like a rusty swing, is added to the mix. Five distinct strands gradually evolve, forming a
complex polymetric sound object punctuated from time to time with what must be Otto the
dachshunds random percussion contributions. This polymetric texture gives way, eventually, to
passages of banjo picking and accordion tunes, along with an unrestricted slew of everyday sonic
images, either live or processed. The slap-dash of Chadbournes simultaneities lacks
refinement, but makes up for it by the sheer spirit of adventure and enterprise.
Chadbournes music, redolent of many aspects of surrealism, not to speak of dada, freely
quotes, borrows, and modifies other works. Hallelujah, Im a Bum, a parody of the religious
song, provides the scaffolding for what sounds like an obnoxious little girls comments on the
modified words. Screeching threats and obscenities and riffing about gambling squads, she
sometimes jumps into the melody, suddenly in sweet unison with the singer/guitarist, before
careening off into another deranged rant. Meanwhile, a sax player dithers around with a totally
unrelated tune, and street noises invade, all attempting to obliterate the theme tune, which
keeps returning for more abuse.
Chadbourne, an improviser, spins out multiple layers, plunders and poaches from existing
recordings, and has amassed an arsenal of skills that he can apply at will to skewer a familiar
tune and adapt it to his own purposes. These techniques have their roots in the creative
borrowings, quotations, and allusions traded among composers and musicians for centuries. The
seminal figure, of course, of our own century, whose oeuvre would be vastly different had his
rampant use of musical quotation been quelled, is Charles Ives.
50
In his landmark study of Ivess borrowing procedures, All Made of Tunes, J. Peter
Burkholder divides the composers uses of existing music into fourteen categories, ranging from
direct quotation to paraphrase, and including collage and stylistic allusion. Burkholder describes
the reaction that such borrowings may elicit as a kind of aesthetic dissonance, violating the
expectation that compositions should be original, self-contained, and based on newly invented
ideas. (Burkholder 1995:2) In committing the nihilistic act of dissolving his own boundaries,
becoming coexistent with common tunes, Ives foreshadowed the eventual merging of high art
and low art. Not only was Ives essentially the first composer to invent collage procedure, he
was very likely the first postmodern composer.lix
Others, much later, adapted collage and related borrowing techniques for their own
purposes. Berios Sinfonia, Stockhausens Hymnen, and Schittkes Symphony No. 1 are three
major works that come to mind. In my own Southern Ephemera, originally written for flute,
cello, surrogate kithara and harmonic canon (two instruments built by Harry Partch), the intent
was to evoke a dream-like state populated by half-remembered tunes that accompanied my
childhood in the South.lx To accomplish this, I applied techniques of paraphrase, fracturing,
quotation with new accompaniment, and simultaneity to seven songs from folk and religious
traditions that had special nostalgic meaning for me, weaving them through an independent, nonnostalgic structure. The use of a microtonal system dividing the octave into 43 discrete tones
enhanced the evocation of the ephemeral nature of distant memory. At the beginning of the
piece, the players--and audience--are asked to imagine themselves lying in the grass at dusk,
watching the stars pop out in the ever-blackening sky. They hear (or play) string instruments
lix
. Burkholder specifically defines musical collage found in Ives as a swirl of quoted and
paraphrased tunes added to a musical structure based on modeling, paraphrase, cumulative
setting, or a narrative program, citing Overture and March 1776, and Country Band March.
(There are many other examples.) Ivess collages, far from being an indiscriminate hodgepodge
of tunes, are carefully structured with distinct functions assigned to the borrowed elements.
lx
. The orchestral version (without any Partch instruments) is written in 12-tone equal
temperament, and adds passage calling for extended techniques.
51
being strummed behind the bridge with picks, generating a swarm of random, hard, high pitches.
The opening of Southern Ephemera, along with its intentional evocation of childhood
memories, has a counterpart in Giorgio de Chiricos writings and paintings from his
metaphysical period.lxi The eerily lit objects that almost float in space, seemingly unrelated to
one another, evoke a dream world. In The Lassitude of the Infinite, a statue of a reclining female
figure, surrounded by an expansive piazza, looks out toward a steam train, outlining the distant
horizon. In his writings, de Chirico describes memories from his childhood that resonate in the
painting: The whistles of trains, there beyond the wall, beneath the tremendous mystery of the
stars. (Baldacci 1997:131-132)
What role does nostalgia play in efforts of artists and composers to excavate their
past, resuscitating elemental objects, rummaging through old feelings and emotions, reviving the
bygone? Neville Wakefield gets to the heart of the matter: Seeking moments of stability and
perspective from within the chaotic and contradictory violence of the present, we increasingly
find ourselves seeking refuge in nostalgiain a vision of the past from which the worst wrinkles
of contradiction have been ironed out, in a past that has been domesticated to suit the desperate
needs of the present. (Wakefield 1990: 69)
American Icons, my other nostalgia-induced piece, pays homage to pop music
from the 1950s and 1960s, but is hardly an exercise in seeking refuge.lxii Snaring stylistic
idioms and referring obliquely to familiar songs, it employs allusion far more than quotation to
conjure the aural equivalent of perfume.lxiii Tiny fragments and larger chunks of referential
lxi
. Not thought of as a collage artist, de Chirico was, for the duration of his metaphysical period,
highly influential in the development of surrealism. Although once a composer himself, he
abandoned music, asserting that it had no meaning.
lxii
. Scored for large orchestra, American Icons was commissioned by the National Symphony
Orchestra in 1996 to commemorate the twenty-fifth anniversary of the John F. Kennedy Center
in Washington, D.C.
lxiii
. Everyone has experienced the rush of rediscovering a scent from ones past, triggering a
flood of memories and associations. I wanted to attempt the same feat with this piece.
52
patterns swarm and swirl over, under, and into a whirlwind of superimposed layers, capturing the
sounds of the era. Tim Page, in The Washington Post review, highlighted the aspect of
simultaneity: A bright, brash mixture of jazz, pop, folk and 57 other varieties of homegrown
music, this might be likened to listening to five radios at the same time, each of them playing a
tune youd like to hear more of. (Page 1996)
A more radical rebirth, the transferal of music from its origins into a strikingly
contrasting realm, is brilliantly carried out by the Ghanian composer Gyimah Labi in his Five
Dialects in African Pianism. I first heard this work performed during a conference exploring the
concept of African Pianism held at the University of Pittsburgh in October 1999.lxiv Labi so
skillfully insinuates Africanisms into Western harmonic conventions that I thought I was hearing
quotes from, or near literal allusions to, Western composers ranging from Beethoven to
Gershwin to Nancarrow, especially in Dialect 5, The Ancients Revisited. I discovered,
instead, that Labi achieves this remarkable effect with his idiosyncratic method of reducing
Western functional harmony to a few basic structures. These structures have a dual role: while
signifying their origins, they simultaneously support Labis recasting of African folk elements,
such as traditional Akan singing traditions. This striking fusion, cemented with chromatic
passages, hymn-like sections, quartal harmonies, is funneled through carefully constructed
rhythmic grids, which are in turn ensconced in a large-scale form replete with the repetitions and
sequences commonly found in African drumming.lxv The Ghanian identity is preserved, while
moving beyond the confines of ethnicity.
Labis grafting of Ghanian and other African musical elements onto a structure
that mimes its object of study (Western music) results in a wholly original syntax. From a
lxiv
. The concept of African pianism, pioneered by Akin Euba, is concerned with the transferal of
indigenous African rhythmic and tonal languages to the Western acoustic piano.
lxv
. Labi sets forth his theories in his textbook, Exploring Resources in Creativity: Quartal
Generation of Motions, soon to be published. In this first volume of the projected African Music
Theory Series, he explores three topics: meter in African music; the time line as a formal
structure in African music; and the quartal basis in Dipo and Yewe music.
53
Western perspective, the Dialects are startling. Labi boldly reincarnates clumps of harmonic,
motivic, and rhythmic entities common to the Western canon, shaking off the dust of subliminal
association by subjecting his constructed illusions to a process of hybridization. This integrative
approach used in the Dialects mimics the collage process by combining mirages of Western
music with African rhythmic techniques, achieving a metamorphosis of the commonplace. A
visual analogue might be LAnnonciation, one of Magrittes oil paintings where pictorial objects
are viewed in disparate scales. The pictorial elements are articulated in conflicting spaces,
meeting on the planar surface of the canvas rather than in the illusory depth of representational
space, signaling their origin in collage construction. (Adamowicz 1998: 47) Indeed, the
conjunction of Western and African elements in Labis Dialects occurs on the surface of the
music, while allusions to Western music and rhythmic applications of Africanisms are expressed
in disorienting ways that refresh and renew jaded perceptual habits.
Conclusion
The vibrancy of the surrealist aesthetic continues in the present, its impact and
longevity and immense impact anticipated by two originating artists. Louis Aragon proclaimed
surrealisms commitment to radical change as well as to the future in his collection of poems and
prose texts, Le Libertinage, published in 1924.lxvi In the preface, he remarks, Lets accept once
and for all the epithet messianic. Its silly, its empty: we didnt choose it. But finally thats
whats held against us, we are messianics. Fine. To the traditional idea of beauty and the good,
we will oppose our own, however infernal it may appear. Messianics and revolutionaries, I
agree. (Aragon 1924:271-272) Toward the end of his collection of interviews with Breton,
Andr Parinaud asks: Can a movement such as Surrealism be limited to poetic or pictorial
forms? If you had the choice, in which domains would you find it useful to express Surrealisms
positions? Bretons enigmatic answer leaves the door open: It hardly matters. The main thing
lxvi
. A banner year for surrealism, 1924 also marked the official founding of the surrealist
movement, as well as the publication of Bretons First Surrealist Manifesto.
54
is for Surrealism to express itself regularly, and globally. Its incursions in different domains
would thus be much more perceptible. (Breton [1952]1993: 247)
Breton may not have imagined the extent to which surrealism would express
itself, especially in the ubiquitous use of the word itself. The term surreal has permeated our
language (and others) more intensively than any other word representing a major artistic
movement in the twentieth century. Unfortunately, its often slung around without a real
understanding of its meaning. Film, theater, literature, poetry, visual arts, fashion, sports,
photography, music, politics, economics, wine, breast implants, mass suicide, natural disasters,
even health scares, have been described, during the past twenty years or so, with a smorgasbord
of surreal-isms.lxvii
Octavio Paz defended surrealism as not merely an esthetic, poetic and
philosophical doctrine. It was a vital attitude. A negation of the contemporary world and at the
same time an attempt to substitute other values for those of democratic bourgeois society:
eroticism, poetry, imagination, liberty, spiritual adventure, vision. Paz nails the essence of
surrealism: a state of mind---not just an avant-garde movement, and not a superficial flash in the
history of art or literature. Gabriel Garca Mrquez claims that surreality informs daily existence
as much as banality, when he said, In Mexico surrealism runs through the streets.
Has the real become surreal? The central question here, however, remains: can
surrealist aesthetics function in the time-dominated, essentially non-representational realm of
music? My answer is an unqualified affirmative: music can, indeed, operate as one of the
domains of surrealism, even when composers and musicians are not consciously utilizing
surrealist techniques, or deliberately aiming for surrealistic effects. Ive shown three things here:
1) how surrealism invaded music when the conditions were finally ripe, 2) how two facets of
lxvii
. A quick search through the New York Times archives, from 1976 to 1999, excavated a
colorful array of variants such as semi-surrealism, cracker-barrel surrealism, sophomore
surrealism, along with a host of other adjectives applied to surrealism: cheapo, ghoulish,
disorienting, playful, airy, flamboyant, weirdly plausible, deft, pure, pop, and carnival.
55
surrealism were translated into musical expressions, and 3) how postmodern tendencies
embedded in surrealism have surfaced in postmodern music. However, my essay also raises
questions. Does music basically lag behind the progressiveness of other art forms? Did isolated
developments in music, predating but related to elements of surrealism, in any way effect or
influence the surrealist movement? In what ways did American jazz musicians influence
composers and free jazzers in Europe? How did music and sound events associated to dadaism
and futurism intersect with surrealism, and eventually with postmodern musics? What surrealist
elements might be commonly associated with postmodern electroacoustic music? How has
collage evolved in twentieth century music? Will collage forms in music eventually attract
critical assessments? What about other motifs orbiting the surrealist pantheon---objective
chance, convulsive beauty, revolutionary thought---and how these are manifested in music? Will
technological advances in music production further expand the application of surrealist
techniques in postmodern musics?
The surrealist movement spawned a mammoth and multifaceted network of literary, art,
and musical manifestations, influenced by and influencing one another. Not just an artistic
movement, not just a revolutionary concept, surrealism reached beyond such limitations, and
became a way of living. Reverberating with imagination, analogy, and desire---dislodging
reality, provoking and challenging the acceptance of everyday routines---this mode of life, of
making art, continues to evolve, offering itself as a porthole into alternate realities as we move
toward unforeseen ways of creating, perceiving, and evolving.
56
Endnotes