7 Gendev PDF
7 Gendev PDF
7 Gendev PDF
BIOLOGY
Genes and Development
Animals that look nothing like each other develop by using
much the same basic toolkit of molecules and often in
much the same ways. M. PALOPOLI AND N. PATEL1
Development poses some of the central questions of biology: How
does a single cell become a complex multicellular organism like us?
What role do our genes play in the processes of development? From
the early decades of the twentieth century, geneticists knew about
mutants that altered phenotypes because of the actions of various
genes during development. In numerous cases biologists knew where
on the chromosome the mutant gene was located and how the mutant
allele was transmitted from parent to offspring. Nevertheless, the
actual role the genes play in development remained a black box
mystery until around 1980.
Starting in the late 1970s geneticists figured out the details involved in
the genetic control of development in model systems such as the
fruitfly Drosophila melanogaster. They found that many of these
developmental genes shared similar features. During the 1980s and
1990s geneticists made an even more surprising discovery: the same
principles, and often the same genes, involved in development in
model organisms (such as fruit flies and zebrafish) are also involved in
controlling development in most other animals, including humans.
Molecular to Global
Perspectives
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
If cells of an individual are genetically alike, how does differentiation
occur? Recall that proteins, not DNA, carry out most cellular functions.
(See the Proteins and Proteomics unit.) DNA serves a blueprint from
which RNA is transcribed. Proteins come from the amino acid chains
that are translated from the RNA. The levels of transcription and
translation of a gene determine how much of that genes protein will
be present in the cell. Gene expression, which encompasses
transcription and translation, is the general term to describe the
processes in which DNA produces RNA and proteins. It can also include
other factors, such as the rate at which RNA is degraded before it can
be translated. Differential gene expression will result in varying
concentrations and kinds of proteins in cells, causing them to look and
function differently. This differential transcription and translation of
genes ultimately allows for cellular differentiation. Thus, development
is a program that regulates gene expression at the appropriate
locations and times.
How is it that, for a given cell type, certain subsets of genes are
expressed and other genes are not expressed? As we will see later, the
protein product that results from the expression of one gene can
influence the expression of several other genes. In turn, the altered
expression patterns of these genes can then influence the expression
of an even larger number of genes. By this process, called a cascade, a
change in one or a few genes can alter the expression patterns of
numerous genes.
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
DROSOPHILA EMBRYO WITH BICOID PROTEIN EXPRESSED. Courtesy of Nipam Patel, PhD.
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
F1 offspring are heterozygotes and appear normal. In the reciprocal
cross, all of the F1 offspring are heterozygotes but have the mutant
phenotype (Fig. 3). Although the F1 offspring are genotypically
identical in the reciprocal crosses, they are phenotypically different.
This is because phenotype is due to the action of the mothers
genotype. Maternal effect is not the same thing as maternal
inheritance such as in mitochondria, where the genetic material is
transmitted only across maternal lines.
Responses to the
Concentration Gradient
PARENTS
OFFSPRING
- -
+
+ +
Phenotype: normal
+ +
+
- Phenotype: mutant
Unlike the coordinate genes, the gap genes are not maternal effect
genes. The activities of the embryos gap genes (and not those of the
mothers genes) determine the phenotype. Gap genes also encode for
transcription factors, and these affect the transcription of genes that
further refine the patterning of the Drosophila embryo (Fig. 4).
Gap genes
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
Homeotic Genes
At the end of this cascade is a class of genes that have a long history
among Drosophila researchers. Decades before Watson and Crick
ascertained the structure of DNA, and even more decades before
geneticists understood the principles of gene expression, biologists
were using Drosophila melanogaster as a model system for studying
the transmission of genetic traits from parent to offspring. Lets go
back to 1915 at Columbia University: In a small laboratory, crowded
with thousands of milk bottles containing stocks of the tiny fruitfly
Drosophila melanogaster, Thomas Hunt Morgan, the father of
Drosophila genetics, and his students worked. They examined this
fruitfly, focusing on ones that looked different in their quest to find
and map genes.
One day Calvin Bridges, one of Morgans graduate students, discovered
a most unusual fly. One of the hallmark features of flies is that they
have two wings; Diptera, the insect order to which flies belong, means
two wings. The fly Bridges found had one pair of normal wings and
one pair of somewhat developed wings. Four wings! Bridges found
that this four wing phenotype was a genetic mutation that mapped
to the third chromosome. After closer inspection, Bridges noted that
the third segment of the thorax in these flies looked a good deal like a
normal, second segment of the thorax (where wings normally grow).
He consequently named the gene associated with this mutant
phenotype bithorax. (Genes in Drosophila are traditionally named
for their mutant phenotype, not for what they do in normal flies.)
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
Figure 6. Genes that are expressed at
the anterior end of an animal are
located at the more anterior region of
the chromosome. Likewise, posteriorly
expressed genes reside on the posterior
end of the chromosome. This is
referred to as spatial colinearity.
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
Fate Maps
What Sulston and his colleagues did with tracing the entire cell lineage
would be exceedingly difficult for the vast majority of organisms. Most
multicellular organisms have far more cells than C. elegans. Moreover,
most dont have a transparent body or rather sedentary cells during
development. Nevertheless, for several different kinds of organisms,
researchers have been able to determine the type of tissue that cells in
developing embryos will become; fate maps are diagrammatic
representations of this (Fig. 7).
Figure 7.
Left: A photograph of an early stage
blastula from the Xenopus laevis frog.
Right: A representation of a fate map.
Photo-illustration
Bergmann Graphics
Scientists have been able to create fate maps for several organisms,
such as the sea urchin, since the early decades of the twentieth
century. To construct fate maps researchers use various methods,
including removing cells from embryos. If the adult that developed
from these embryos is missing specific tissues, researchers infer that the
removed cells would have become those missing tissues. Researchers
can also use a variety of stains to trace cells in the developing embryo.
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
transcription occurs. How does that happen? Most often, the binding
of the ligand causes the receptor protein to change its conformation.
This conformational change sets up a series of changes, and sometimes
cascades, which eventually lead to changes in transcriptional activity of
genes.
One example of a signaling pathway involves the hedgehog gene in
Drosophila. This gene was so named because larvae with the mutant
phenotype are covered with hair and look somewhat like a hedgehog.
The protein encoded by the hedgehog gene is a ligand and interacts
with several receptors. Among other functions, it triggers the early
steps in development of postsynaptic neurons. It is also involved in the
differentiation of the photoreceptor cells of the eye.
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
Now heres the really fascinating part! Gehrings lab did the same
ectopic expression experiment but with the mammalian homologue of
eyeless. They produced flies with eyes on their antennae, legs, wings,
and various other places. The eyes produced were the compound eyes
of flies but the machinery for making these eyes could be turned on by
mammalian eyeless protein. Despite the independent evolution of eye
structure and over 550 million years of independent evolution, the
control switch for eye development has been conserved.
There are differences between the role eyeless plays in flies and
mammals. Unlike in Drosophila, where eyeless is not required for
viability, homozygotes for the deletion of eyeless are inviable in
mammals. Furthermore, this gene is expressed in regions of the
mammalian forebrain. This is strong evidence that eyeless has
functions in addition to eye development.
Sonic Hedgehog
Researchers discovered that vertebrates have a homologue to the
Drosophila hedgehog gene. They named the vertebrate homologue
Sonic Hedgehog after the video game character Sonic the
Hedgehog. This gene, which encodes a ligand, has diverse functions,
including limb development, patterning of the neural tubes (and
hence the brain), and differentiation of regions in the gut. How does it
Genes and Development
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
work? Cells of the developing notochord send out Sonic Hedgehog
signals to the spinal cord. These cells respond to the signal and then
differentiate into the ventral part of the spinal cord, which makes the
motor neurons that permit muscular activity. Across mammals this
gene is highly conserved; the mouse and human Sonic Hedgehog
proteins are ninety-two percent identical at the amino acid level.
sepal
Whorl (Sepals)
Whorl 4
(Carpels)
Whorl 3
(Stamens)
Stem Cells
Certainly some plant cells, like the totipotent meristems, are more
versatile than animal cells. Recent discoveries, however, show that the
difference in the retention of competence between animals and plant
cells is not as great as once thought. During the late 1990s scientists
found that adult humans have a reservoir of cells that retain some
ability to become other cell types.
Cells derived from fetal tissue have been used to generate so-called
embryonic stem cells. In addition to the ethical dilemmas raised by the
source of embryonic stem cells, there are practical limitations to the
use of these cells for treating and curing diseases and regenerating
Genes and Development
10
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
tissues. Because the donors of these cells are immunologically different
from the recipient, immunosuppression would have to be used as it is
in organ transplantation. Because adult stem cells can be derived from
the individual patient, concerns about compatibility of the cells would
be obviated.
But do adult stem cells have the same ability to differentiate as
embryonic stem cells? Recent studies suggest that adult stem cells may
be more versatile than had been previously thought. Catherine
Verfaillie and her colleagues at the University Stem Cell Institute
derived what they call Multipotent Adult Progenitor Cells (MAPC) from
the bone marrow of adult mice. These cells appear to be able to
differentiate into virtually all cell types of mouse when injected into
mouse blastocysts. These MAPCs have also been injected into living
adult mice and have differentiated into liver, lung, and intestine tissue.
Coda
The fact that the same principles and many of the same genes direct
the development of such different and diverse animals has generated
renewed interest and study of how developmental systems evolve.
Given the striking similarity of genes used, how do the manifest
differences across animals arise and evolve? This question will keep
biologists busy for many years to come.
References
1) Palopoli, M. F., and N. H. Patel. 1996. Neo-Darwinian developmental
evolution: Can we bridge the gap between pattern and process?
Current Opinion in Genetics and Development 6:5028.
2) Raff, R. C. 1996. The Shape of Life: Genes, Development, and the
Evolution of Animal Form, 27. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
3) Halder, G., P. Callaerts, and W. J. Gehring. 1995. Induction of
ecotopic eyes by targeted expression of the eyeless gene of Drosophila.
Science 267:178892.
Further Reading
Books
Hartl, D. L., and E. W. Jones. 2001. Genetics: Analysis of genes and
genomes. 5th ed. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.
A college-level textbook on the principles of genetics; includes
an overview of the genetic control of development.
Griffiths, A. J. F., J. H. Miller, D. T. Suzuki, R. C. Lewontin, and W. M.
Gelbart. 2000. An introduction to genetic analysis. 7th ed. New York:
W. H. Freeman and Company.
A textbook that provides more in-depth, but somewhat more
difficult coverage, of developmental genetics.
Raff, R. C. 1996. The shape of life: Genes, development, and the
evolution of animal form. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
A look at the evolution of development.
11
R E D I S C OV E R I N G B I O L O GY
Glossary
Coordinate genes. Genes that
set the coordinate system, the
primary anterior-posterior and
dorsal-ventral axes, of the early
embryo.
Developmental pathway. A
sequence of genes that underlie a
developmental process.
Differentiation. The process by
which cells specialize during
development.
Ectopic expression. Expression
(transcription and translation) of a
gene at a time or place where it is
normally not expressed.
Fate map. The diagrammatic
representation of the cells in the
embryo and the eventual type of
tissue they will become in the
adult.
Homeobox. A 180-nucleotide
section of DNA that codes for a
specific class of DNA-binding
proteins; first found in the
homeotic genes of Drosophila
melanogaster.
Transgenic organism.
An organism that contains
hereditary information from two
different species of organisms.
12