Laser Treatment For Post Acne Scars - A Review
Laser Treatment For Post Acne Scars - A Review
Laser Treatment For Post Acne Scars - A Review
Abstract
Background: For years, there was no successful treatment for acne scars.
Now, things have changed. With the development of new technologies,
those suffering from acne scarring have multiple options to improve the
tone and texture of the skin. Laser treatments, including ablative and non
ablative laser skin resurfacing are among available treatment options.
*Corresponding Author:
Citation
Introduction:
Over the last decade, laser skin treatments for acne scarring
have been primarily centered on laser resurfacing with
carbon dioxide (CO2) and erbium- doped yttrium aluminum
garnet (Er:YAG) lasers. Although these lasers have proven
effective in improving scar appearance through collagen
remodeling and skin recontouring, they have been associated
with extended recovery periods, prolonged erythema, hypo
and hyper pigmentation, and in rare cases, induction of
additional scarring.5,6 As a result of these potential risks
and well-characterized adverse effects of ablative CO2 and
Er:YAG laser resurfacing, non ablative laser technology
using long- pulsed infrared (1,450-nm diode and 1,320-nm
neodymium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet [Nd:YAG])
laser systems were developed as a safe alternative.7
Page: 166
Review Article | Keyal U, et al. Laser treatment for post acne scars
thermal relaxation time of the 30 m of targeted tissue
(about 1 ms). Use of the CO2 laser for skin resurfacing
yields an additional benefit of collagen tightening through
heating of dermal collagen. The triple helical structure of
collagen is altered, resulting in shortening of the fibers by
one third.10 Persistence of this collagen contraction results,
in part, from these shortened fibers serving as a scaffold for
neocollagenesis. Several CO2 laser systems are available
and can be separated into two distinct groups: pulsed and
scanned. CO2 laser has been used effectively to treat atrophic
and other scars.11,12 Sculpting of scars with the laser yields
a more uniform skin texture and stimulates new collagen
formation within the dermal defects. Patients can expect a
mean improvement of 5080% in moderate atrophic scars,
with continued collagen remodeling and scar effacement
for 1218 months postoperatively.11,12 Patients with scars
previously treated with dermabrasion or deep chemical
peels may have additional fibrosis, which is more difficult
to vaporize, thereby reducing their potential outcome. In
addition, these patients also may have concealed hypopigmentation that could become more apparent after laser
skin resurfacing.12,13 Although patients with paler skin
tones are at lower risk for developing postoperative hyperpigmentation, those with darker skin tones can successfully
undergo CO2 laser resurfacing.
1.2. Erbium: Yttrium-Aluminum-Garnet Laser
The emitted wavelength of 2,900 nm is absorbed 1218
times more efficiently by superficial cutaneous tissues, and
approximately 25 m of ablation occurs per pass with
equally narrow zones of thermal necrosis.14 Clinically, this
translates into a shorter postoperative healing time with much
less post treatment erythema and risk of hyper pigmentation
than CO2 lasers. However, immediate collagen contraction is
only about 14%, and long-term collagen remodeling ranges
from 014%.8 Multiple passes with this laser are necessary
to ablate to a similar depth as one pass of the CO2 laser, and
because the Er:YAG effects are photomechanical instead of
photothermal (like the CO2), intraoperative hemostasis is
difficult to achieve.8,15 Therefore, the short-pulsed Er:YAG
laser is limited in its utility for moderate-to-severe acne
scars. Hybrid Er:YAG/CO2 laser systems (e.g., Derma-K,
Lumenis, Santa Clara, CA, USA) are capable of delivering
both CO2 energy for coagulation and Er:YAG energy for
fine tissue ablation. The dual mode Er:YAG (e.g., Contour,
Sciton, Palo Alto, CA, USA) combines short pulses (for
ablation) with longer pulses (for coagulation). The variablepulsed Er:YAG (CO3, Cynosure, Chelms- ford, MA, USA)
system has a range of pulse durations from 500 s to 10
Page: 167
Mild
complications
Moderate
complications
Severe
complications
Transient
erythema
Prolonged
erythema
Pigmentary change
Hypertrophic
scar
Localized
edema
Milia
Infection (bacterial,
viral, fungal)
Ectropion
Pruritus
Acne
Hypopigmentation
Contact
dermatitis
Postoperative erythema, lasting an average of 4.5 months,
is an expected occurrence in all CO2 laser treated patients
and is a normal consequence of the wound healing process.
Degree of erythema correlates directly with the depth of
ablation and number of laser passes performed.25,26 It may
also be aggravated by underlying rosacea or dermatitis.
Topical agents like retinoic acid derivatives, glycolic acid,
fragrance or chemical containing cosmetics and sunscreens
should be strictly avoided in early postoperative period until
substantial healing has occurred.25 Mild side effects includes
milia formation and acne exacerbation, which may be
caused by the postoperative use of occlusive dressings and
ointments particularly in patients who are acne prone.25-29
Milia and acne usually resolve spontaneously as healing
progresses and application of thick emollient creams and
occlusive ceases. Oral antibiotics may be prescribed for acne
flares that do not respond to topical preparation.25,29,30 Wound
infections associated with ablative laser resurfacing include
staphylococcus and pseudomonas infections and cutaneous
Page: 168
Review Article | Keyal U, et al. Laser treatment for post acne scars
scarring but it has yet a long way to go in order to get more
satisfying results in short time. The Results after treatment
will disappoint patients who desire dramatic improvement
in a short period of time. Additionally, although these
technologies have a much lower side effect profile, they
are not devoid of risks. Ultimate goal of any intervention
in acne scarring is not total cure or perfection; rather it is
making scars less visible. Selection of appropriate technique
requires that patient factors as well as the risks and benefits
of the procedure be weighed.
References:
1. Goodman GJ. The limitations of resurfacing techniques
the necessity to combine procedures. Dermatol Surg
1998;24:6878.
2. Jordan R, Cummins C, Burls A. Laser resurfacing of
the skin for the improvement of facial acne scarring:
a systematic review of the evidence. Br J Dermatol
2000;142:41323.
3. Kaplan EN, Falces E, Tolleth H. Clinical utilization of
injectable collagen. Ann Plast Surg 1983;10:43751.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Page: 170