International Breastfeeding Journal
International Breastfeeding Journal
International Breastfeeding Journal
BioMed Central
Open Access
Research
doi:10.1186/1746-4358-1-16
Abstract
Background: Although Autistic Disorder is associated with several congenital conditions, the
cause for most cases is unknown. The present study was undertaken to determine whether
breastfeeding or the use of infant formula supplemented with docosahexaenoic acid and
arachidonic acid is associated with Autistic Disorder. The hypothesis is that breastfeeding and use
of infant formula supplemented with docosahexaenoic acid/arachidonic acid are protective for
Autistic Disorder.
Methods: This is a case-control study using data from the Autism Internet Research Survey, an
online parental survey conducted from February to April 2005 with results for 861 children with
Autistic Disorder and 123 control children. The analyses were performed using logistic regression.
Results: Absence of breastfeeding when compared to breastfeeding for more than six months was
significantly associated with an increase in the odds of having autistic disorder when all cases were
considered (OR 2.48, 95% CI 1.42, 4.35) and after limiting cases to children with regression in
development (OR 1.95, 95% CI 1.01, 3.78). Use of infant formula without docosahexaenoic acid
and arachidonic acid supplementation versus exclusive breastfeeding was associated with a
significant increase in the odds of autistic disorder when all cases were considered (OR 4.41, 95%
CI 1.24, 15.7) and after limiting cases to children with regression in development (OR 12.96, 95%
CI 1.27, 132).
Conclusion: The results of this preliminary study indicate that children who were not breastfed
or were fed infant formula without docosahexaenoic acid/arachidonic acid supplementation were
significantly more likely to have autistic disorder.
Page 1 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
Background
Autistic disorder (AD), also called autism, is a severe
developmental disorder defined by deficits in reciprocal
social interaction and communication, and the presence
of repetitive and ritualistic behaviors that emerge before
three years of age [1]. Some parents report regression in
their children or a loss of previously acquired skills with
the subsequent development of AD [2]. Parental report of
regression in children with AD is estimated to occur in
approximately 22% of cases [3]. Recently, parental report
of regression has been validated with the use of videotape
of children's first and second birthdays [4]. In most cases
the cause of AD is unknown [5].
A report by the California Department of Developmental
Services shows a noted increase in individuals with a diagnosis of AD receiving services [6]. The proportion (and
number) of eligible individuals with AD in their client
population of special needs children rose from 3.5%
(2,778/80,389) to 12.4% (20,377/163,792) between
1987 and 2002. Changes in case definitions, administrative and diagnostic procedures, and service-related issues
have had an effect on the number of eligible individuals
with AD in California [7]. The increase in eligible individuals with AD in California may also be due to widening of
the case definition to include children with normal or
above-normal intelligence [8] or due to diagnostic substitution of children with mental retardation [9].
A world-wide review by Fombonne of autism epidemiological surveys concluded that changes in case definition
and improved awareness account for much of the recent
increases in autism [5]. A more recent study reported a stable incidence in Midlands, UK over 15 years when study
design features were held constant [10]. It is not known
whether AD incidence is increasing or whether increases
in prevalence are the result of changing diagnostic criteria
and better case ascertainment.
The prevalence of breastfeeding in the US increased during the 1970s, decreased during the 1980s, and rose again
during the 1990s [11]. For 2002, breastfeeding in the hospital and at six months of age reached an all-time high of
70.1% and 33.2% respectively [11]. Breastfeeding is the
recommended method for infant feeding, and increasing
the number of mothers who breastfeed their children to
six months of age is a goal of Healthy People 2010 in the
US [12]. Breastfeeding has been associated with increases
in cognitive ability and academic performance [13,14].
Breastfeeding may also be important for the cognitive
ability of children at risk for AD. In a study of 145 autistic
and 224 normal children, a significantly higher proportion of autistic children (24.8%) compared to control
http://www.internationalbreastfeedingjournal.com/content/1/1/
Page 2 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
Methods
The Autism Internet Research Survey was created by the
parent of a child with autism hoping to identify possible
causes for the rise in autism. The survey did not state
whether the rise in autism was due to a rise in incidence
or in the number of individuals registered for special education programs; however, parents who believe there is an
increase in autism incidence may have been more
inclined to take the survey. In order to quickly obtain the
number of cases required for this analysis, the internet was
used to solicit participants. Subsequently, this developed
into a New Jersey-based nonprofit organization, Autism
Internet Research Survey. Neither the organization nor the
survey is related to any commercial entity.
The Autism Internet Research Survey invited parents to
complete surveys for their children with or without AD.
Whether a child had AD was self-reported by clicking on
one of two links: "For those with autistic children who
want to take the survey click here." or "For those who want
to take the control survey (you have children, but not with
any autism spectrum disorder) click here."
Ads for the surveys were placed online using Google and
restricted to the United States. Individuals who performed
online searches containing keywords (autistic, autism
research, autism, MMR, autism education, etc.) were
shown an ad requesting their participation in a research
survey. The total number of keywords used was 306, and
they were grouped into the following categories: autism
and autistic features 262, treatment for autism 24, prominent people involved in autism 13, and possible causes of
autism 7. Participants completed the surveys from February to April 2005. The surveys included 91 questions on
breastfeeding, infant formula use, date of birth, and the
nature of their child's development. Limiting the age
range to children two to 18 years and the respondents to
parents yielded 861 case and 123 control children.
Breastfeeding data was recorded from a drop-down menu
with nine choices of duration of breastfeeding. This variable was recoded into five categories: none, less than 2
months, 26 months, more than 6 months, and
unknown. These breastfeeding categories were tested for
association with autism using logistic regression.
Infant formula use data was recorded from a drop-down
menu with 39 brand-name choices as well as "Other",
"None", and "I don't know". This variable was recoded
into three categories: None, Formula without DHA/ARA,
and Formula with DHA/ARA. Information regarding
DHA/ARA supplementation was ascertained from the
manufacturers websites. If parents chose the category
"Other" or "I don't know", no determination could be
made regarding DHA/ARA supplementation, and the data
http://www.internationalbreastfeedingjournal.com/content/1/1/
was excluded from further analysis (n = 38). The remaining three infant formula categories were tested for association with autism using logistic regression.
Children under two years old were excluded since AD is
rarely diagnosed before age two. For analysis of breastfeeding, the age range was limited to 218 years. Eighteen
years was chosen as the upper age for the range in an
attempt to minimize recall bias from the parents.
For analysis of infant formula, 24 years was chosen as the
age range. Four years was chosen as the upper age for this
portion of the study since supplementation with DHA/
ARA has only been available in the US since 2002. Children older than four would not have had the opportunity
to use DHA/ARA supplemented formulas during the first
year of life.
Parents of autistic children were also questioned about
the nature of their child's development. Three choices
were given in a drop-down menu: 1) My child developed
normally, then regressed (lost skills). 2) My child developed normally, then stopped. 3) My child never developed in a normal way. For the purposes of this study, if
response number 1 was chosen, the child was assumed to
have a regression in development, i.e. lost skills that had
previously been acquired.
In order to remove the effects of congenital conditions
associated with autism from the odds ratios seen in this
study, breastfeeding and infant formula use were also
tested for association with autism for the subset of children with reported regression in development.
All analyses, including characterization of the population
and logistic regression, were performed using SAS version
9.1 for Windows (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, North Carolina). This study was approved by the University of California, San Diego Human Research Protections Program
and the Institutional Review Board at San Diego State
University.
Results
Table 1 presents the characteristics of children in the
Autism Internet Research Survey. For those aged 218
years, there were 861 cases and 123 controls, and for those
aged 24 years, there were 150 cases and 38 controls.
Parental report of regression in development for these two
age groups was 25% and 23% respectively.
For children aged 218 years, the mean age of cases and
controls was similar at 7.8 and 7.4, respectively. Breastfeeding varied by group, with no breastfeeding being
reported more frequently for cases (28%) than controls
(16%) and breastfeeding for greater than six months
Page 3 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
http://www.internationalbreastfeedingjournal.com/content/1/1/
Cases
Controls
N = 861
Mean (SD)
7.8 (3.9)
%
28
23
19
25
5
25
N = 150
Mean (SD)
3.2 (0.5)
%
8
26
43
17
6
23
N = 123
Mean (SD)
7.4 (4.5)
%
16
20
22
36
6
--N = 38
Mean (SD)
3.0 (0.6)
%
16
58
18
3
5
---
versus breastfeeding for more than six months was significantly associated with an increase in the odds of having
AD when all cases were considered (OR 2.48, 95% CI
1.42, 4.35) and after limiting cases to children with regression in development (OR 1.95, 95% CI 1.01, 3.78). Duration of breastfeeding showed a dose-response relationship
with AD before and after limiting cases to children with
regression in development (chi square test for trend, p =
0.0007 and p = 0.031 respectively).
Age-adjusted associations of infant formula use with AD
are presented in Table 3 for children 24 years old. Use of
infant formula without DHA/ARA supplementation versus exclusive breastfeeding was associated with a significant increase in the odds of AD when all cases were
considered (OR 4.41, 95% CI 1.24, 15.7) and after limiting cases to children with regression in development (OR
12.96, 95% CI 1.27, 132). Use of unsupplemented versus
supplemented infant formula was also associated with a
Table 2: Age-adjusted associations of breastfeeding and autistic disorder for children aged 218 years.
Variable
Odds Ratio
No Breastfeeding
2.48
Breastfeeding <2 months
1.70
Breastfeeding 26 months
1.27
Breastfeeding >6 months
reference
Limited to cases with reported regression in development
No Breastfeeding
1.95
Breastfeeding <2 months
1.84
Breastfeeding 26 months
1.59
Breastfeeding >6 months
reference
p value
(1.42 4.35)
(1.00 2.88)
(0.75 2.14)
0.001
0.050
0.373
(1.01 3.78)
(0.98 3.44)
(0.86 2.96)
0.048
0.057
0.141
Page 4 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
http://www.internationalbreastfeedingjournal.com/content/1/1/
Table 3: Age-adjusted association of infant formula use with autistic disorder for children aged 24 years.
Variable
Odds Ratio
p value
4.41
1.02
reference
(1.24 15.7)
(0.33 3.18)
0.022
0.977
12.96
2.76
reference
(1.27 132)
(0.28 27.4)
0.031
0.387
Discussion
The children with AD in this survey were significantly less
likely to have been breastfed and were significantly less
likely to have been fed infant formula with DHA/ARA
than typically developing children. A possible mechanism
for these associations is immune system dysfunction.
Without breast milk or infant formula supplemented with
DHA/ARA, some children's immune systems could be
compromised which could in theory lead to AD. Breast
milk provides the infant IgA and other humoral components from the mother which are important for the
immune protection of the infant. Also, use of formula
with DHA/ARA supplementation could be beneficial to
the infant immune system. DHA and ARA are discussed in
a review by Yaqoob as important for proper immune system functioning [24].
The results of this study are from an online internet survey
and should be viewed with caution. This survey was not a
random sampling of the population and has the attendant
problem of ascertainment bias. Only individuals who had
computers and were interested in taking an online survey
were participants. Also, the survey could have biased participant responses by telling them the purpose was to find
reasons for the rise in autism.
The present study relied on self-reported data regarding
the diagnosis of AD and therefore the accuracy of diagnosis was not confirmed. However, parental report of the
proportion of cases with regression in development in this
study (23% for children aged 24 and 25% for children
aged 218) was similar to that seen in a study by Siperstein and Volkmar in which 22% of parents reported
regression in their children diagnosed with AD using
DSM-IV criteria [3]. However, the present study did not
use the same question regarding regression, and the simi-
Page 5 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
Conclusion
While Tanoue and Oda [15] found a significantly higher
number of children with autism compared to control children had already stopped breastfeeding when assessed at
the end of the first week of life, the present study is the first
to show that increased duration of breastfeeding is associated with a decreased likelihood of AD. This is also the
first study to suggest a possible link between the use of
infant formula without DHA/ARA supplementation and
AD. However, this study was based on a small group and
should be followed by a larger more rigorous study to
confirm the results.
http://www.internationalbreastfeedingjournal.com/content/1/1/
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
Competing interests
The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.
20.
Authors' contributions
SS participated in the design, performed the analyses, and
helped draft the manuscript. CB participated in the design
and performed the survey. MJ participated in the design
and consulted on statistical analyses. HK-C, DW, CM, and
NA participated in the design and helped draft the manuscript.
21.
22.
23.
Acknowledgements
The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not
reflect the official policy or position of the Department of the Navy,
Department of Defense, or the United States Government.
24.
25.
Page 6 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
26.
http://www.internationalbreastfeedingjournal.com/content/1/1/
BioMedcentral
Page 7 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)