Greece Crisis: The Top Ten Questions
Greece Crisis: The Top Ten Questions
Greece Crisis: The Top Ten Questions
Economics
Europe
Greece crisis
The top ten questions
Fears over a possible Greek exit from the eurozone are
growing...
as relations between the creditors and Greek negotiators
over reforms grow increasingly tense
We address the key questions surrounding ECB emergency
financing, capital controls, default and Grexit
1. Will the ECB raise the ELA limit on Wednesday 17 June?
The governing council will meet on 17 June to review the amount of emergency liquidity
assistance (ELA) that will be provided to the Greek banks (currently EUR83bn) and
potentially the haircuts it imposes on the Greek collateral. While it is possible that the
ECB could refuse to raise the limit this week in an attempt to put pressure on the Greek
government to compromise at Thursdays meeting of the Eurogroup (Eurozone finance
ministers), we would be surprised if this happened. We therefore expect that the limit will
be raised by EUR1-2bn. Note that in the case of Cyprus in March 2013, the ECB did not
cut off ELA to banks, but threatened to do so if Cyprus did not enter into a new
programme with the Troika.
Disclaimer &
Disclosures
This report must be read
with the disclosures and
the analyst certifications in
the Disclosure appendix,
and with the Disclaimer,
which forms part of it
abc
Economics
Europe
16 June 2015
Primary surplus
target
VAT system
Labour market
reform
Instead of insisting on new policies, the Institutions propose - To reinstate collective bargaining procedures, under a plan
a "consultation process" on minimum wage, mass dismissals to be approved by the ILO
and collective bargaining policies
- Minimum wage levels and private sector salaries to rise
gradually until end-2016 to 2010 levels. Wages to be freely
negotiated thereafter through collective bargaining
Pension reform
Economics
Europe
16 June 2015
abc
holidays before a third programme is in place, and so will be hoping that the IMF will agree to stay on
board in exchange for a commitment from the EU to do so in the future.
Meanwhile, as mentioned above, in Greece, protecting public sector pay and pensions is the crucial red
line of the Syriza-led government. But it will be virtually impossible to close the gap without some
concessions on pensions. Public spending on pensions accounts for more than 16% of GDP in Greece
which is the highest in the EU. The creditors are insisting that this is lowered by 1% of GDP and needs to
persuade the Greek government that this can be achieved while protecting the poorest pensioners.
Economics
Europe
16 June 2015
permission, for instance for legitimate business reasons which we assume would cover genuine foreign
trade transactions. Given Greece is quite a cash-based economy the impact on already-bad liquidity could
be very severe, depending on how long the controls are in place. Even in countries where capital controls
have been imposed to provide time to find an imminent solution to a specific problem, they stayed in
place for some time: two years in Cyprus and are still in place in Iceland seven years later though there
are plans to phase them out.
In terms of the details of any capital controls that could be imposed, it is impossible to assess the
implications for foreign investors at this stage as these would depend on the detail of the law passed by
the Greek government. In the case of Cyprus, the Ministry of Finance issued a Capital Controls Decree on
25 April 2013, which permitted the transfer of funds by international customers of credit institutions
which are a branch (or a more than 50% subsidiary of a foreign bank operating in Cyprus) unless the
transfer of funds involved domestic customers or domestic banks. Trade/business transactions were
restricted to EUR5,000 per day; payments of EUR5,000-200,000 were subject to the approval of a
Committee established within the Central Bank of Cyprus to deal with issues related to the controls. For
payments above EUR200,000 the committee took into account the liquidity buffer situation of the credit
institution.
Similarly, in Iceland foreign exchange transactions for commercial and service trading are the highest
priority. The Central Bank recommends that banks monitor larger transactions (no amount specified) and
evaluate the importance of each transaction. Priority products and services include groceries,
pharmaceutical products and oil products but transactions involving other imports and exports of goods
and services, travel, interest payments, contractual instalment payments and salaries are still permitted.
8. Does the ECB have to cut off ELA in the event of default to IMF?
The ECB would almost definitely have to lower the amount of ELA (via higher haircuts) but would
probably but not cut off the Greek banks. ECB head, Mario Draghi and board member, Benot Cur,
abc
Economics
Europe
16 June 2015
abc
have been very consistent in their responses to questions on this, saying that the ECB would continue to
extend liquidity to the Greek banks, as long as they are solvent and have sufficient collateral. But they
have given no definitive answer to the question as to how they would respond in the event of a default by
the Greek government. Mr Coeure stated that a default "would make it more difficult for banks to obtain
liquidity" while Mr Draghi said that the ECB assesses "how the developments in the markets affect the
quality of our collateral, namely the quality of the Greek government bonds that have been posted as
collateral. So were the conditions to changewe would have to revisit our previous decisions". We
interpret this to mean that the size of the haircuts on the Greek government bonds which the Greek banks
use as collateral for ELA would be larger in the event of a default so the amount of ELA they are eligible
for would shrink.
Note that Mr Draghi reminded us at the last press conference that it requires a two-thirds majority on the
governing council to change a decision on ELA.
10. Does high public support for the euro rule out Grexit?
A poll published on 11 June by MARC continues to suggest that the overwhelming majority of the Greek
population wants to stay in the euro including 70% of Syriza voters and 50% of those interviewed
think that the Greek government should, if there is no alternative, accept the conditions imposed by the
creditors, compared to 37% that would prefer a break-down of the talks with the risk of a possible default.
This has been confirmed by another, more recent poll conducted by GPO for a political show on Mega
TV (the biggest Greek TV channel) on June 15. In response to a very bluntly-worded question If the
choice for Greece is between either a bad deal with austerity measures while remaining in the euro OR
Economics
Europe
16 June 2015
default followed by an exit from the euro? the response was that 56.2% preferred a bad deal with
austerity measures while remaining in the euro, 35.4% were in favour of default followed by an exit from
the euro and 8.4% didnt know/didnt answer. Other questions in the same survey showed even stronger
support: 68.5% said they would vote in favour of staying in the euro in a referendum. Therefore we
remain of the view that Mr Tsipras has a mandate to negotiate but a much stronger mandate to stay within
the euro and therefore to make the necessary concessions to do so.
But what if we are wrong and, irrespective of very strong opposition from within the domestic electorate,
the Greek government feels that it has been left with no option but to leave the euro? In our view Grexit
would inflict major damage on the monetary union and the rest of Europe, even though some are of the
view that the monetary union would be stronger for having rid itself of the bad apple and that Greeces
economy would revive on the back of currency devaluation.
While we accept that, in a world of QE and OMT (note the European Court of Justice finally ruled on its
legality on June 16) the initial market reaction may not be huge, there can be no doubt that a country
leaving the euro would change the fundamental nature of the Eurozone. The medium and long-term
implications could be very large indeed: economically, politically and geopolitically. It would be a
currency union where the risk of exit was greater than was previously the case. A union where any
country still battling with large budget deficits and high government debt would probably face a
permanently higher risk premium now that we would know that it is indeed possible for a member state to
leave the euro. At the first sign of bad news, be it signs of a budget deficit overshooting or a recovery
faltering, or anti-euro parties doing well in the polls, market pressure could quickly return. For
international investors could the euro really be such a reliable or stable source of value? And, if not,
would euro holdings decline?
For reasons of security it would not be in Europes interests to see Greece fall into the economic chaos
that we believe Grexit would represent (debt monetization, wage price spiral etc). In the EU treaties there
is no provision for leaving the euro (only the EU), which means it tends to be assumed that if Greece
leaves the Eurozone it would also have to leave the EU. But for geopolitical reasons we believe that, even
if we are proved wrong in our view that Greece stays within the euro, it would be in Europes interest to
keep Greece firmly in the EU and Nato, including providing it with further financial assistance.
abc
Economics
Europe
16 June 2015
abc
Disclosure appendix
Analyst Certification
The following analyst(s), economist(s), and/or strategist(s) who is(are) primarily responsible for this report, certifies(y) that the
opinion(s) on the subject security(ies) or issuer(s) and/or any other views or forecasts expressed herein accurately reflect their
personal view(s) and that no part of their compensation was, is or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific
recommendation(s) or views contained in this research report: Janet Henry
Important Disclosures
This document has been prepared and is being distributed by the Research Department of HSBC and is intended solely for the
clients of HSBC and is not for publication to other persons, whether through the press or by other means.
This document is for information purposes only and it should not be regarded as an offer to sell or as a solicitation of an offer
to buy the securities or other investment products mentioned in it and/or to participate in any trading strategy. Advice in this
document is general and should not be construed as personal advice, given it has been prepared without taking account of the
objectives, financial situation or needs of any particular investor. Accordingly, investors should, before acting on the advice,
consider the appropriateness of the advice, having regard to their objectives, financial situation and needs. If necessary, seek
professional investment and tax advice.
Certain investment products mentioned in this document may not be eligible for sale in some states or countries, and they may
not be suitable for all types of investors. Investors should consult with their HSBC representative regarding the suitability of
the investment products mentioned in this document and take into account their specific investment objectives, financial
situation or particular needs before making a commitment to purchase investment products.
The value of and the income produced by the investment products mentioned in this document may fluctuate, so that an
investor may get back less than originally invested. Certain high-volatility investments can be subject to sudden and large falls
in value that could equal or exceed the amount invested. Value and income from investment products may be adversely
affected by exchange rates, interest rates, or other factors. Past performance of a particular investment product is not indicative
of future results.
HSBC and its affiliates will from time to time sell to and buy from customers the securities/instruments (including derivatives)
of companies covered in HSBC Research on a principal or agency basis.
Analysts, economists, and strategists are paid in part by reference to the profitability of HSBC which includes investment
banking revenues.
Whether, or in what time frame, an update of this analysis will be published is not determined in advance.
For disclosures in respect of any company mentioned in this report, please see the most recently published report on that
company available at www.hsbcnet.com/research.
Additional disclosures
1
2
3
Economics
Europe
16 June 2015
abc
Disclaimer
* Legal entities as at 30 May 2014
Issuer of report
UAE HSBC Bank Middle East Limited, Dubai; HK The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited,
HSBC Bank plc
Hong Kong; TW HSBC Securities (Taiwan) Corporation Limited; 'CA' HSBC Bank Canada, Toronto; HSBC
8 Canada Square, London
Bank, Paris Branch; HSBC France; DE HSBC Trinkaus & Burkhardt AG, Dsseldorf; 000 HSBC Bank (RR),
E14 5HQ, United Kingdom
Moscow; IN HSBC Securities and Capital Markets (India) Private Limited, Mumbai; JP HSBC Securities
(Japan) Limited, Tokyo; EG HSBC Securities Egypt SAE, Cairo; CN HSBC Investment Bank Asia Limited,
Telephone: +44 20 7991 8888
Beijing Representative Office; The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited, Singapore Branch; The
Fax: +44 20 7992 4880
Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited, Seoul Securities Branch; The Hongkong and Shanghai
Website: www.research.hsbc.com
Banking Corporation Limited, Seoul Branch; HSBC Securities (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd, Johannesburg; HSBC Bank
plc, London, Madrid, Milan, Stockholm, Tel Aviv; US HSBC Securities (USA) Inc, New York; HSBC Yatirim
Menkul Degerler AS, Istanbul; HSBC Mxico, SA, Institucin de Banca Mltiple, Grupo Financiero HSBC; HSBC
Bank Brasil SA Banco Mltiplo; HSBC Bank Australia Limited; HSBC Bank Argentina SA; HSBC Saudi Arabia
Limited; The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited, New Zealand Branch incorporated in Hong
Kong SAR; The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited, Bangkok Branch
This document is issued and approved in the United Kingdom by HSBC Bank plc for the information of its Clients (as defined in the Rules of FCA) and those of its
affiliates only. If this research is received by a customer of an affiliate of HSBC, its provision to the recipient is subject to the terms of business in place between the
recipient and such affiliate. In Australia, this publication has been distributed by The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited (ABN 65 117 925 970,
AFSL 301737) for the general information of its wholesale customers (as defined in the Corporations Act 2001). Where distributed to retail customers, this research is
distributed by HSBC Bank Australia Limited (AFSL No. 232595). These respective entities make no representations that the products or services mentioned in this
document are available to persons in Australia or are necessarily suitable for any particular person or appropriate in accordance with local law. No consideration has been
given to the particular investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any recipient.
The document is distributed in Hong Kong by The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited and in Japan by HSBC Securities (Japan) Limited. Each of the
companies listed above (the Participating Companies) is a member of the HSBC Group of Companies, any member of which may trade for its own account as
Principal, may have underwritten an issue within the last 36 months or, together with its Directors, officers and employees, may have a long or short position in securities
or instruments or in any related instrument mentioned in the document. Brokerage or fees may be earned by the Participating Companies or persons associated with them
in respect of any business transacted by them in all or any of the securities or instruments referred to in this document. In Korea, this publication is distributed by either
The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited, Seoul Securities Branch ("HBAP SLS") or The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited,
Seoul Branch ("HBAP SEL") for the general information of professional investors specified in Article 9 of the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act
(FSCMA). This publication is not a prospectus as defined in the FSCMA. It may not be further distributed in whole or in part for any purpose. Both HBAP SLS and
HBAP SEL are regulated by the Financial Services Commission and the Financial Supervisory Service of Korea. This publication is distributed in New Zealand by The
Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited, New Zealand Branch incorporated in Hong Kong SAR.
The information in this document is derived from sources the Participating Companies believe to be reliable but which have not been independently verified. The
Participating Companies make no guarantee of its accuracy and completeness and are not responsible for errors of transmission of factual or analytical data, nor shall the
Participating Companies be liable for damages arising out of any persons reliance upon this information. All charts and graphs are from publicly available sources or
proprietary data. The opinions in this document constitute the present judgement of the Participating Companies, which is subject to change without notice.
This document is neither an offer to sell, purchase or subscribe for any investment nor a solicitation of such an offer. HSBC Securities (USA) Inc. accepts responsibility
for the content of this research report prepared by its non-US foreign affiliate. All US persons receiving and/or accessing this report and intending to effect transactions
in any security discussed herein should do so with HSBC Securities (USA) Inc. in the United States and not with its non-US foreign affiliate, the issuer of this report. In
Singapore, this publication is distributed by The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited, Singapore Branch for the general information of institutional
investors or other persons specified in Sections 274 and 304 of the Securities and Futures Act (Chapter 289) (SFA) and accredited investors and other persons in
accordance with the conditions specified in Sections 275 and 305 of the SFA. This publication is not a prospectus as defined in the SFA. It may not be further
distributed in whole or in part for any purpose. The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited Singapore Branch is regulated by the Monetary Authority of
Singapore. Recipients in Singapore should contact a "Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited, Singapore Branch" representative in respect of any matters
arising from, or in connection with this report. HSBC Mxico, S.A., Institucin de Banca Mltiple, Grupo Financiero HSBC is authorized and regulated by Secretara de
Hacienda y Crdito Pblico and Comisin Nacional Bancaria y de Valores (CNBV). HSBC Bank (Panama) S.A. is regulated by Superintendencia de Bancos de Panama.
Banco HSBC Honduras S.A. is regulated by Comisin Nacional de Bancos y Seguros (CNBS). Banco HSBC Salvadoreo, S.A. is regulated by Superintendencia del
Sistema Financiero (SSF). HSBC Colombia S.A. is regulated by Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia. Banco HSBC Costa Rica S.A. is supervised by
Superintendencia General de Entidades Financieras (SUGEF). Banistmo Nicaragua, S.A. is authorized and regulated by Superintendencia de Bancos y de Otras
Instituciones Financieras (SIBOIF).
The document is intended to be distributed in its entirety. Unless governing law permits otherwise, you must contact a HSBC Group member in your home jurisdiction if
you wish to use HSBC Group services in effecting a transaction in any investment mentioned in this document. HSBC Bank plc is registered in England No 14259, is
authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority and is a member of the
London Stock Exchange. (070905)
In Canada, this document has been distributed by HSBC Bank Canada and/or its affiliates. Where this document contains market updates/overviews, or similar materials
(collectively deemed Commentary in Canada although other affiliate jurisdictions may term Commentary as either macro-research or research), the Commentary
is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to sell or subscribe for, any financial product or instrument (including, without limitation, any currencies, securities,
commodities or other financial instruments).
Copyright 2015, HSBC Bank plc, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, on any form
or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of HSBC Bank plc. MICA (P) 073/06/2015 , MICA
(P) 136/02/2015 and MICA (P) 041/01/2015