Cfa PDF
Cfa PDF
Cfa PDF
http://ppr.buaa.edu.cn/
ORGINAL ARTICLE
KEYWORDS
Rocket turbine;
Turbine disc;
Stress;
Deformation;
Finite element (FE)
Abstract Gas turbine discs have numerous applications in the aerospace industry, such
as in liquid rocket engines. In this study, the stresses and deformations of a turbine disc
were studied. The goal was to highlight the stress and deformation distribution to assist
in the design of a disc as well as to demonstrate the importance of using nite element
(FE) analysis in simulating an actual design case. Then, to present the real model, a twodimensional (2D) axisymmetric model for a non-uniform disc was analysed using FE
analysis. The stresses and deformations developed as a result of the disc operating
conditions at high rotational speeds and thermal gradients were evaluated using two
types of heat transfer modesconduction and convection, taking into consideration the
material behaviour at elevated temperatures. The FE model revealed that the weight of
the disc should be reduced optimally by using a non-uniform thickness because this
results in a huge increase in the applied stresses. The greatest stresses in the disc result
from the thermal load caused by conduction, and they are located at the centre of the
disc. In addition, an analytical method was used to evaluate and predict the stresses
along the disc, and it gave a good estimate of the stress values compared to the FE
model. Based on this estimate, a parametric study was conducted for a range of
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: [email protected] (Guozhu Liang).
2212-540X & 2013 National Laboratory for Aeronautics and Astronautics. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jppr.2013.01.002
Stress and deformation of rocket gas turbine disc under different loads using nite element modelling
39
rotational velocities under high temperature loads for a series of disc radii. Finally, it was
found that this method can be used for the preliminary design of different turbines.
& 2013 National Laboratory for Aeronautics and Astronautics. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.
All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Data
Temperature/1C
0
100
200
300
400
600
800
K
a/106
22
9.32
22
9.44
22
9.64
22
9.77
24
9.87
24
9.97
26
10.00
Data
Temperature/1C
E
n
Engineering constants.
Table 1
25
95
205
315
425
595
815
200
0.293
195
0.297
185
0.302
175
0.308
166
0.314
154
0.324
136
0.336
40
3. Finite element modelling
3.1. Real turbine disc modelling
3.1.1. Meshing
Because of the symmetry of the problem (loads and
geometry), the disc was simulated by a two-dimensional
(2D) axisymmetric cross-section. The disc was modelled
using the commercial multi-purpose FE software package
PATRAN. The geometry of the 2D non-uniform disc was
meshed with six-node solid triangular elements having two
translational degrees of freedom (DOF) per node (UX
and UZ), and each having a global edge length of 0.002 m.
The total number of elements used was 639. The mesh and
element shape are illustrated in Figure 3.
Load case 1
For the rotational load, as shown in Figure 4, the
maximum stress of 238 MPa occurred at the centre
of the disc, and the maximum displacement of
5.20 105 m occurred at the discs outer radius.
The shape of this deformation was caused by the hub.
Load case 2
For the shrink-tted load, as shown in Figure 5, the
maximum stress of 190 MPa occurred at the hub of
the disc, and the maximum displacement of
7.60 105 m occurred at the discs outer radius.
Load case 3
For the blades outer boundary load, as shown in
Figure 6, the maximum stress of 89 MPa occurred at
the lower surface of the disc, and the maximum
displacement of 3.52 105 m occurred at the discs
outer radius.
Load case 4
A thermal transient analysis was performed to dene
the temperature gradient along the disc at different
time intervals during operation. Figure 7 shows the
variation in the maximum thermal stresses with
the operating time at three selected positions along
the disc and the temperature variation at the centre
of the disc over time under two different types of
thermal loads: conduction only and conduction plus
convection. These three positions were at the centre
(r 0 m), middle (r 0.045 m), and outer radius
(r 0.09 m) of the disc. A transient thermal analysis
was conducted not only for 100 s, which represented
Stress and deformation of rocket gas turbine disc under different loads using nite element modelling
Figure 7 Thermal stress along disc and temperature of discs centre under conduction and convection.
41
42
Figure 8 Temperature distributions in disc at different operating times under conduction and convection. (a) Time 10 s (conduction),
(b) time 10 s (conductionconvection), (c) time 50 s (conduction), (d) time 50 s (conductionconvection), (e) time 100 s (conduction) and (f) time 100 s (conductionconvection).
Stress and deformation of rocket gas turbine disc under different loads using nite element modelling
43
Figure 9 Load case 4: thermal load at different operating times under conduction only. (a) Time 10 s (conduction), (b) time 50 s
(conduction) and (c) time 100 s (conduction).
44
Figure 10
Load case 5: stress caused by rotation, shrink tting, blades, and conduction thermal loads at 10 s.
Figure 11 Load case 5: stress caused by rotation, shrink tting, blades, and conduction thermal loads at 100 s.
Stress and deformation of rocket gas turbine disc under different loads using nite element modelling
Figure 12
Table 2
45
Load case 5: displacement caused by rotation, shrink tting, blades, and conduction thermal loads at 100 s.
Type of loads
Max stress
/MPa
Max displacement
/m
238
190
89
432
800
Disc centre
Disc hub
At radius r 0.02 m
Disc centre
Disc centre
5.20 105
7.60 105
3.52 105
3.32 104
3.94 104
Disc
Disc
Disc
Disc
Disc
radius
radius
radius
radius
radius
outer
outer
outer
outer
outer
46
Figure 13
Radial stresses with deformed shape caused by rotational loads for uniform disc.
Figure 14
Figure 15
Radial stresses with deformed shape for disc with two thicknesses.
Radial stresses with deformed shape for disc with two thicknesses and hub.
Stress and deformation of rocket gas turbine disc under different loads using nite element modelling
Figure 16
Radial stresses with deformed shape for disc with two thicknesses and central mass.
Effect of mass removal from disc on stress and displacement caused by rotational load.
Table 3
Model
Disc
Disc
Disc
Disc
Disc
with
with
with
with
with
Table 4
Radius r/m
0
0.09
47
Mass/kg
Max displacement/m
2.24
2.79
2.10
2.23
2.11
238
194
189
196
244
5.20 105
4.10 105
3.71 105
4.67 105
3.74 105
Thermal load
sr/MPa
sy/MPa
sr/MPa
sy/MPa
sr/MPa
sy/MPa
197
45
197
109
412
45
412
322
564
45
564
256
48
Table 5
Rotational load/MPa
Thermal load/MPa
238
197
432
402
800
551
Z
B
1 3v
aE
2 2
sy A 2
ro r 2
Tr draET
r
8
r
Figure 18 Stresses in steel solid uniform disc caused by rotational and thermal loads at 550 1C temperature gradient between
disc centre and outer radius.
5. Conclusions
This paper presented an FE analysis of the stresses
and deformations developed in a gas turbine disc used
in a liquid rocket engine. A 2D axisymmetric disc was
created using general-purpose FE software for analysis.
The results were compared with a simplied analytical
Stress and deformation of rocket gas turbine disc under different loads using nite element modelling
49
References
[1] L. Witek, Failure analysis of turbine disc of an aero
engine, Engineering Failure Analysis 13 (1) (2006) 917.
[2] H. Callioglu, M. Topcu, A. Tarakcilar, Elasticplastic
stress analysis of an orthotropic rotating disc, International Journal of Mechanical Sciences 48 (9) (2006) 985
990.
[3] H. Jahed, B. Farshi, J. Bidabadi, Minimum weight design
of inhomogeneous rotating discs, International Journal of
Pressure Vessels and Piping 82 (1) (2005) 3541.
[4] V. Vullo, F. Vivio, Elastic stress analysis of non-linear
variable thickness rotating discs subjected to thermal
load and having variable density along the radius,
International Journal of Solids and Structures 45 (20)
(2008) 53375355.
[5] M.H. Hojjati, A. Hassani, Theoretical and numerical
analyses of rotating discs of non-uniform thickness and
density, International Journal of Pressure Vessels and
Piping 85 (10) (2008) 694700.
[6] M. Maziere, J. Besson, S. Forest, Overspeed burst of
elastoviscoplastic rotating discs, part I: analytical and
numerical stability analyses, European Journal of
Mechanics A/Solids 28 (1) (2009) 3644.
[7] G.J. Nie, R.C. Batra, Stress analysis and material tailoring in isotropic linear thermoelastic incompressible functionally graded rotating discs of variable thickness,
Composite Structures 92 (3) (2010) 720729.
[8] C.L. Clark, High Temperature Alloys, Pitman, New York,
1993.
[9] A.R. Ragab, S.A. Bayoumi, Engineering Solid Mechanics,
CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1999.
[10] P.P. Benham, R.J. Crawford, Mechanics of Engineering
Materials, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1987.