Human Security in Africa's Great Lakes Region
Human Security in Africa's Great Lakes Region
Human Security in Africa's Great Lakes Region
Human Security in
Africas Great Lakes
Region
Njoki Wamai
Table of Contents
1. Summary................................................................................................................
2. Introduction..........................................................................................................4
3. Conceptual Framework on Human Security.....................................................7
4. Human Security Challenges in the Great Lakes Region.................................11
Small Arms and Light Weapons and the Youth Bulge ......................................12
Refugees and IDPs..............................................................................................13
Natural Resource Governance.............................................................................16
Food (in) Security, Public Health and Environmental
Security.................................................................................................................18
Violence Against Women.....................................................................................21
Corruption and Lack of Rule of Law...................................................................23
Conclusion...........................................................................................................24
The Role of ICPC ............................................................................................... 25
ABBREVIATIONS
AU
Africa Union
CGLR
DDR
DRC
EAC
ECCAS
ICGLR
ICC
ICPC
IDPs
R2P
Responsibility to Protect
SALW
TJRC
UNHDR
Introduction
Since the end of the Cold War, the Great Lakes Region(GLR) has recorded the
most vicious conflicts in Africa. These conflicts have not only threatened the
national security of states in the Great Lakes but worse still the human security
of the people in the region. After the Rwandan Genocide genocide initiated an
exodus of unprecendented refugees in the region in 1994, the GLR has come
from one crisis to another.
The series of crisis have attracted various responses from regional and
international organisations leading to the emergence of normative frameworks
for conflict prevention such as Responsibility to Protect (R2P) and increased
attention to the International Criminal Court (ICC) which are both critical in
protecting and promoting human security.However, despite these developments
the international community is faulted for failing to respond effectively leading
to a cycle of the conflicts in the region which have so far claimed three million
lives.1
According to Khadiagala the term Great Lakes was formely a geographical
space which encompassed fresh water lakes and their river basins in the African
tropics.2However, today the GLR has assumed an analytical category while
1
2
retaining its geographical reach that combines East and Central Africa.3 Security
actors have since set up institutions to address political, security and economic
relationships in the GLR such as the International Conference of the Great Lakes
Region(ICGLR). According to Khadiagala, the core states of the Great Lakes
which
security challenges
Zambia, Angola and Central African Republic. The GLR challenges are
inextricably linked although each has its own unique challenges. Events in one
country invariably affect the others, and often the wider region.
The GLR unlike other regional security systems in Africa has had a difficult
regional integration process. The Communaute Economique Des Pays des
Grands Lacs, the premier organisation failed because it was an organisation
only in name centred around the former Zairean dictator Mobutu Seseko.When
Mobutu died the organisation died with him. A number of other regional
communities have since emerged with the Economic Community of Central
African States(ECCAS), East African Community (EAC) and the ICGLR being
the most notable.
The ICGLR
Ibid
response to the
This broad defination has led to the argument by critics that the concept is too
broad to be a useful construct for security and for foreign policy. These critics
see this new approach as one that will replace traditional approaches such as
national security. For instance, Roland Paris has argued that human security
should be seen as an analytical category as opposed to a concept. He criticises
the human security concept for lacking defined analytical categories. According
to Paris, human security is a category of research into military and non-military
threats into societies, groups and individuals.7
Other critics have concerns that securitizing new security challenges such as
food insecurity, pandemics and natural disasters or migration, for example, may
have unintended consequences that do more harm than good.8They have also
argued that diluting the security concept and dissipating its meaning raises
questions about the future role for traditional security forces. 9Additionally,
there are competing definitions of human security and there is no agreement on
how best to implement the concept.10
Despite the conceptual challenges presented by the human security concept, this
concept continues to generate interest among analysts and citizens especially in
the GLR in Africa where it finds resonance.
7
Freedman (1998 ) p. 50
Ibid
10
Ibid p. 87-102
Annan has argued that human security in its broadest sense,embraces far more
than the absence of violent conflict.It encompasses human rights, access to
education, healthcare and good governance and choices for every undividual to
fulfil his os her own potential.11
King and Murray have adopted multidimensional accounts of human security
that measure years lived outside a state of generalised poverty.12They have
argued that human security should be a measure of only those domains of
wellbeing that are important enough for human beings to fight over and put
their lives or property at great risk. 13
Thomas and Tow have argued that the human security approach has three
interlocking features.First, it recognises transnational threats and the role of
international norms. Second it asserts that states and individuals confronting
such vulnerabilites cannot address them adequately and thirdly, there is need for
a transnational approach through mobilisation of international civil society.14
Bellamy and McDonald have contested Thomas and Tows arguments that the
state and the international community should be the referent point for human
security. Bellamy and McDonald argue that a human security agenda has three
components. First, it must focus on the things that makes humans insecure such
11
15
10
16
Ibid.p.6
Ibid
18
See Alkire and Abass
17
11
challenges and the youth bulge leads to armed conflict and ultimately other
security challenges. Youth bulge is a youth crisis that results from an increase in
youthful population without corresponding socio-economic and political
opportunities for youth resulting to exclusion which can trigger conflict where
grievances exist.
Ploriferation of SALW in the GLR can be traced to a number of factors in the
region. First, the prolonged humanitarian crisis in the region from the Sudan
Wars of Liberation to seven military coups in Uganda, intrastate conflict with
the Lords Resistance Army, the Rwandan Genocide, Burundian Civil War and
conflicts in the DRC have all increased availability of illegal SALW.
Additionally, inadequate and ineffective Disarmament, Demobilisation and
19
Mbugua (2007),p.5
12
13
SALW has led to diversion of development funds such as health care and
education to equipping police to fight crime in the Great Lakes region. 20
By managing the GLR porous borders effectively, implementing
DDR
20
21
Ibid
Bernstein and Bueno (2007) p.73
14
in the early nineties was as a result of failed governance in many states which
led to catastrophic results such as the Rwandan genocide.
The challenging issue of refugees in the GLR can be traced back to the 1950s
when the Tusti refugees fled persection and war in Rwanda for Uganda . In the
1990s, Tutsi and modertate Hutus fled again after persectuion by the Hutu
leadership and later Hutu refugees fled Rwanda due to fear of reprisal attacks
from genocidaires. The Hutu refugees who fled to Goma in Eastern DRC and
Tanzania were intimidated by the Hutu genocidaires and militants who fled with
them.
Refugees and IDPs raise a number of security threats to the host country and to
the the refugees themselves. According to Mills and Norton, refugees impact on
three types of security: Human security, societal security and national security of
the host country.
Firstly, refugees have had a profound impact on state security in the great lakes
region. As earlier noted state security or national security is about territorial
integrity, political autonomy, internal stability and economic wellbeing. Refugee
populations may harbour rebels leaders who continue to plunder and instigate
armed conflict in the host country as evident in Eastern DRC where former Hutu
genocidaires patnered with local rebel causing insecurity.
15
Secondly, human insecurity is the motivation for the refugee crisis since people
become refugees when they fear for their personal safety.22 Displacement also
makes people vulnerable to other humans security threats such as lack of access
to food, healthcare,water, shelter,lack legal and physical protection from
physical violence and
22
16
23
24
Alao (2010),p.103
Kameri-Mbote( )p.7
17
The DRC is the couldron of human security challenges in the GLR. After the
end of the Cold War, the local and international groups descended on an
unstable DRC, with interests in its natural resources. Alao notes that at one stage
there were up to ten interrelated conflicts simultenously taking place in
DRC.25These include:DRC government vs assorted rebels groups;Rwandan
government vs Rwandese insurgents; Rwandan government vs DRC
government;the Ugandan government vs Sudanese supported rebels; the
Ugandan and Rwandan government vs Zimbabwean and Angolan governments;
Ugandan government vs Rwandese government; Rwandan government backed
DRC rebels vs Ugandan backed DRC rebels; Burundian government vs
Burudian rebel factions; Angola government vs UNITA and any group
supporting UNITA; the Mai Mai elements vs Rwandan government and the
RCD ( Rally for the Congolese Democracy); the Sudanese government vs
Ugandan government. Although a peace process championed by Mbeki in 2003
restored relative stability, the country is yet to attain sustainable peace and
achieve human security.
Although processes like the Kimblerly Process and the Extractive Industry
Transparency Iniatiative (EITI) have been introduced as international policy
initiatives to address human security concerns, stability of the country and the
region rests with improved governance at national and regional level.The next
25
Ibid ,110
18
Civil strife and lack of governance in the GLR have exacerbated food insecurity
in the region by eroding farming bystems and rural livelihoods. 85% of the
population in the GLR depends on agriculture for their livelihoods. Apart from
Kenya which constantly suffers draughts and famine, the GLR has fertile soils
which attract migrants to the region.
The region has so far recorded one of the highest population densities in the
world in Rwanda and Burundi. Armed conflict has also led to increased
population in the region with Rwanda leading with 600 people per square
kilometer.26The high population density in the GLR has increased vulnerability
to environmental security challenges as the number of people depending on
scarce resources for food, housing and energy increases through practices such
as deforestation.
The Great Lakes Declaration on Peace, Security and Democracy identifies
evironmental security as a challenge of the GLR and proposes equitable and
26
19
well managed land reform programmes which can enable food security and
arrest resource scarcity conflicts.
Despite improving health conditions in the Great Lakes region, the region faces
a desperate humanitarian crisis and most countries in the region have the
greatest maternal and child mortality rates. Additionally, HIV/Aids among other
sexually transmitted infections is highly prevalent partly due to the transient
nature of IDPs and refugees in the region in addition to sexual violence which
many women and children face during armed conflict.
The advent of HIV/Aids in the region has exacerbated household food insecurity
in affected households.27 In 2000 alone, 18 million people died from disease as
compared to 300,000 who died from conflicts.28Threats such as HIV/Aids have
killed more people more than conflicts since the end of the Cold War, yet few
states and international organisations have accepted public health concerns as a
security challenge.29The GLR has some of the leading prevalence rates of HIV
in world. These are: Kenya (6.3%), Uganda (6.5%), Rwanda (2.9%), Burundi
( 3.3%), Zambia (13.5%) and Tanzania (5.6%) all 2009 estimates from the
CIA.The next section will review how certain groups of the population face
human security challenges.
27
Ibid
Owen (2008),p.446
29
Owen (2008),p.447
28
20
Despite the significant achievements made in the quest for gender equality
through norm setting such as the ratification of the Convention on Elimination
of all Forms of Discrimination against Women(CEDAW) and the Womens
Protocol to the Africans Charter on Human and Peoples Rights, women in the
GLR continue to face gross human rights violations and ultimately their human
security is threatened. For instance, during armed conflict rebel groups and
national armies use rape as a weapon of war, prompting the UN to pass Security
Council Resolution 1820 which identifies sexual violence as a crime against
humanity.
Apart from discrimination based on sex and the consequent threats to their
human security, women in the great lakes region experience discrimination
based on economic status, ethnic group, birth, age, disability, marital status,
30
21
Zambian constitutional court in the Longwe case, where a woman was denied
entry into a hotel because she was unaccompanied shows that discrimination of
women based on citizenship is common in the GLR.33Additionally, other courts
in Uganda and Kenya have ruled to prevent discrimination of women based on
cultural practices such as inheritance.
States should ensure traditional, historic, religious and cultural attitudes are not
used to justify violations of womens right to equality before the law and to
equal enjoyment of rights as noted by the Human Rights Council.
31
Ssenyonjo(2010),p. 176
Ibid.p.193
33
Ibid. P.209
32
22
34
Durojaye(2010),p. 219
23
Conclusion
This policy brief has identified the most pervasive human security threats in the
GLR. These include Small Arms and Light Weapons and the Youth Bulge,
Refugees and IDPs, Natural Resource Governance, Food (in) Security, Public
Health and Environmental Security,Violence Against Women, Corruption and
Lack of Rule of Law.
These different security challenges call for different yet interconnected and
regional policy priorities for effectiveness. For instance, implementation of
regional policies on IDPs or SALW should accompany improved governance
and zero tolerance to corruption while arresting impunity.
There is need for increased vigilance and partnership within civil society in the
GLR if the human security challenges presented are to be addressed. ICPC and
other civil society organisations can assist the GLR states in various
peacebuilding priorities which include accountability
24
25
26
sexual offences and set up gender desks with trained police officers.ICPC
should also lobby the regional ICGLR to make punishments for sexual
violence harsher.
Gender sensitive transtional justice mechanisms and processes should be
instituted for sexual violence among other violations faced by women in
the region. Individual and communal reparations should be encouraged
for women who have suffered.
Lobby the great Lakes Forum on Peace (AMANI Forum), which is
comprised of parliamentarians in the region to pass laws that will end
violence against women such Sexual Offences Acts while domesticating
the Maputo Protocol.
27
Bibliography
Ademola, Abass ed. (2010), Protecting Human Security in Africa (Oxford:
Oxford University Press)
Alkire, Sabina (2003), A Conceptual Framework For Human Security. Working
Paper
28
Bernstein, J and Bueno O. 2007. The Great Lakes Process: New Opportunities
for Protection. Forced Migration Review No. 29. January. p. 73. [Online]
http://www.fmreview.org/FMRpdfs/FMR29/73.pdf
Brown Edward (2003 ),Grave New World: Security Challenges In The 21st
Century (Georgetown :Center for Peace and Security Studies)
Cilliers Jackie (2004), Human Security in Africa A Conceptual Framework for
Review (Pretoria: ISS)
Daley, Patricia (2006), Challenges to Peace: Conflict Resolution in the Great
Lakes Region in Africa in Third World Quaterly,Vol.27:2, pp.303-319
FAO (2006),Voluntary Guidelines on the Right to Food (Rome: FAO)
Freedman, Lawrence (1998), International Security:Changing Targets
in
Mbugua , Njoroge (2007), Small Arms and Light Weapons in Kenya in The
Problem Of Small Arms In Africa in Africa Files Vol. 5 (January-May 2007)
<http://www.africafiles.org/atissueezine.asp?issue=issue5> Downloaded on 6
November 2011
Mills Kurt and Norton Richard (2007), Refugee and Security in the Great Lakes
in Africa in Civil Wars,Vol.5:1,pp 1-26.
Owen, Taylor (2008), The Critique That Doesnt Bite: A Response to David
Chandlers Human Security: The Dog that Didnt Bark in Security Dialogue
Vol.39 Vol.4 ,pp.445-453
Paris, Roland (2001), Human Security. Paradigm Shift or Hot Air? In
International Security Vol. 26. No.2 (Fall 2001), pp. 87-102
Thomas, N. and Tow, W (2002) The Utilitity of Human Security:Sovereignity
and Humanitarian Intervention in Security Dialogue Vol. 33 No.2 pp.177-190
30
31