2011 Article 265
2011 Article 265
2011 Article 265
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Received: 23 July 2009 / Accepted: 27 April 2011 / Published online: 7 May 2011
Association of Otolaryngologists of India 2011
insignificant (P [ 0.05). The togetherness of Staphylococcus aureus and other beta-lactamase producing bacteria
was found statistically significant (P \ 0.05). This study
demonstrates that there is polymicrobial aerobic-anaerobic
flora in both adenoids and tonsils. There was a close relationship between the bacteriology of the tonsil and adenoid
flora. Staphylococcus aureus and and other beta-lactamase
producing bacteria may be responsible for treatment failures in patients with tonsillitis.
Keywords Bacteriology Tonsil Adenoids
Beta-lactamases
Introduction
Recurrent tonsillitis is among the most common diseases of
the childhood. These children are prescribed various antimicrobial treatments but these treatments are usually
insufficient and surgery is required. Tonsil surface swabs
which are commonly used in recurrent tonsillitis do not
reflect the real pathogens so that the antibiotics chosen
according to the surface swabs are not appropriate [15].
Microorganisms other than Group A Beta Haemolytic
Streptococcus (GABHS) may be the cause of chronic
tonsillitis. Especially in recent years the domination of the
beta-lactamase producing bacteria (BLPB) such as Staphylococcus aureus and Haemophilus influenzae in microflora
cause penicillin resistance [6, 7]. Several researchers have
claimed that the failure of antibiotherapy may be due to the
underestimation of the resistant microorganisms [68].
The objectives of this study are to determine the core
and surface flora of the tonsils and adenoids, the reflection
of the core flora by the surface swabs and the pathogen
microorganisms beta-lactamase production rate.
123
224
Results
The study includes 91children, 54 males (59.3%), 37
females (40.7%) aged 313 years (mean age 6.6 years) The
distrubution af the childrens age was shown in Fig. 1.
Statistical analysis done with McNemar test indicates
that; Streptococcus viridans and beta-lactamase producing
Neisseria spp. were isolated more from the tonsil surface
swabs than from the tonsil core samples (P \ 0.05);
123
Aerobic bacteria
S. pneumoniae
2.7
5.5
5.6
30.6
29.3
26.9
22.8
GABHS
2.7
6.1
2.9
4.3
NANB BHS
0.4
0.9
0.4
1.2
CNS
8.9
10.5
9.6
14.8
S. viridans
S. aureus
GABHSGroup A Beta
Haemolytic Streptococcus;
NANB BHSNon A Non B Beta
Haemolytic Streptococcus;
CNSCoagulase Negative
Staphylococci
* 3 patients with no bacterial
isolation from tonsil surface and
core were not included in
calculation
** 15 patients with no bacterial
isolation from adenoid core
culture were not included in
calculation
225
6.6
H. influenzae
6.1
3.9
15.7
16.8
13
5.6
2.6
11
H. parainfluenzae
Neisseria spp.
3.1
23.3
19.7
22.9
21
Diphteroid
3.5
3.5
Micrococcus spp.
Moraxella catarrhalis
1.1
0.4
1.3
0.4
0.4
Candida albicans
1.5
0.8
0.4
0.4
Bacillus spp
0.4
0.6
Pseudomanas aeruginosa
0.4
0.9
0.4
0.6
100
100
100
100
Total
Table 2 Aerobic microorganisms isolated from tonsil and adenoid tissue along with the number and percentage of beta-lactamase producing
bacteria
Aerob bacteria
S. pneumoniae
Tonsil surface*
No/b-lactamase (%)
7/3 (42.8)
S. viridans
83/8 (9.6)
GABHS
NANB BHS
7/0 ()
1/0 ()
Tonsil core*
No/b-lactamase (%)
Adenoid surface**
No/b-lactamase (%)
Adenoid core**
No/b-lactamase (%)
7/3 (42.8)
15/6 (40)
67/7 (10.4)
75/9 (12)
37/1 (2.7)
8/0 ()
1/0 ()
7/0 ()
2/0 ()
14/0 ()
2/0 ()
9/2 (22.2)
CNS
24/16 (66.6)
24/8 (33.3)
27/15 (55.5)
24/16 (66.6)
S. aureus
18/18 (100)
14/14 (100)
11/11 (100)
13/13 (100)
H. influenzae
30/16 (53.3)
36/16 (44.4)
47/23 (48.9)
21/9 (42.8)
6/2 (33.3)
17/6 (35.3)
5/3 (60)
45/23 (51.1)
64/33 (51.5)
34/19 (55.8)
11/3 (27.2)
8/1 (12.5)
H. parainfluenzae
Neisseria spp.
Diphteroid
15/6 (40)
63/33 (52.4)
11/4 (36.3)
8/2 (25)
Micrococcus spp.
3/1 (33.3)
3/0 ()
M. catarrhalis
1/1 (100)
()
Total
267/106 (39.7)
228/75 (32.8)
1/0 ()
1/1 (100)
279/107 (38.3)
()
()
160/64 (40)
GABHSGroup A Beta Haemolytic Streptococcus; NANB BHSNon A Non B Beta Haemolytic Streptococcus; CNSCoagulase Negative
Staphylococci
* 3 patients with no bacterial isolation from tonsil surface and core were not included in calculation
** 15 patients with no bacterial isolation from adenoid core culture were not included in calculation
The patients who did not use preoperative antibiotherapy, who used beta-lactam antibiotics and who used
beta-lactamase resistant antibiotics were compared for
BLPB production and the number of BLPB were found
lesser in patients who did not use preoperative
123
226
Table 3 Anaerobic microorganisms and the percentage of beta-lactamase producing bacteria from the tonsil and adenoid core cultures
Anaerobic bacteria
Tonsil core
No/b-lactamase
(%)
Peptostreptococcus
10/0 ()
8/0 ()
Actinomyces odontylicus
2/0 ()
1/0 ()
Peptostreptococcus prevotii
1/0 ()
1/0 ()
Peptostreptococcus
anaerobius
6/0 ()
5/0 ()
Peptostreptococcus tetradius
1/0 ()
2/0 ()
P. asaccharolyticus
Bacteroides spp.
Bacteroides eggerthii
Veillonella parvula
TOTAL
()
2/1 (50)
()
5/0 ()
27/1 (3.7)
Adenoid core
No/b-lactamase
(%)
1/0 ()
2/2 (100)
1/1 (100)
5/0 ()
26/4 (15.3)
Discussion
Adenoidectomy and tonsillectomy done because of recurrent infection or obstruction are among the most frequently
performed childhood operations [9]. Tonsils and adenoids
which play a protective role against infections in healthy
individuals, may become a reservoir for pathogenic
microorganisms in case of chronic infections [6, 10, 11].
Like other infectious diseases, the determination of the
pathogenic agent is important in antibiotic selection for the
medical treatment of tonsillitis. The routine practice is
the swab culture from the tonsil surface [1214]. However,
the tonsil surface swab mostly does not reflect the pathogenic agent [15]. Due to the constant contact of tonsil
surface with the bacterial flora of oral secretion, the
organisms isolated from the surface swabs may be the
surface colonized bacteria instead of the real infectious
agent. This situation discredits the reliability of the antibiotherapy chosen according to surface swabs. The therapies
chosen according to surface swabs become insufficient to
eradicate the pathogenic agent and cause chronic infections
with tonsillectomy indication [13, 15].
Various ratios are reported for the diversity of tonsil
surface and tonsil core cultures. The studies in the literature
show that tonsil surface cultures do not reflect tonsil core
microbiology in 3070% of patients [1, 4, 5, 8, 11, 1416].
There are also contrary studies in which no qualitative
differences are found between tonsil surface and core flora
[12, 13].
123
227
Key Messages
Isolation of beta-lactamase producing bacteria in all
patients shows that these pathogens often play a role in the
etiology of recurrent tonsillitis and penicillin treatment for
GABHS is ineffective. This situation leads to chronic tonsil
and adenoid infections and to surgical therapy requirement.
Furthermore the togetherness of S. aureus and other
beta-lactamase producing bacteria, confirms the theory of
S. aureus and other BLPBs may protect GABHS from
penicillin by inactivating. Therefore, it may be appropriate
to use beta-lactamase resistant antibiotics for the medical
treatment of recurrent tonsillitis.
References
1. Brook I, Yocum P (1984) Bacteriology of chronic tonsillitis in
young adults. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 110:803805
2. DeDio RM, Lawrence WCT, McGowan KL, Wetmore RF,
Handler SD, Potsic WP (1988) Microbiology of the tonsils and
adenoids in a pediatric population. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck
Surg 114:763765
3. Gaffney RJ, Timon CI, Freeman DF, Walsh MA, Cafferkey MT
(1993) Bacteriology of tonsil and adenoid and sampling techniques of adenoidal bacteriology. Respir Med 87:303308
zek O, Egilmez S, Ang O, Savas I (1967) A bacteriological
4. O
study of chronic tonsillitis. Acta Otolaryngol 63:455461
5. Timon CI, McAllister VA, Walsh MA, Cafferkey MT (1990)
Changes in tonsil bacteriology of recurrent acute tonsillitis: 1980
vs 1989. Respir Med 84:395400
6. Brook I (1984) The role of beta-lactamase producing bacteria in
the persistance of streptococcal tonsillar infection. Rev Infect Dis
6(5):601607
7. Brook I, Yocum P, Foote PA Jr (1995) Changes in the core
tonsillar bacteriology of recurrent tonsillitis: 19771993. Clin Inf
Dis 21:171176
zdogan A (2002) Tonsil
8. Inci E, Kakakullukcu B, Aygun G, O
surface and core microflora in children undergone tonsillectomy
for recurrent tonsillitis. Turkish Otolaryngol Arch 40(4):247251
9. Wiatrak BJ, Woolley AL (1993) Pharyngitis and adenotonsillar
disease. In: Cummings CW, Frederickson JM, Harker LA, Krause
CJ, Schuller DE (eds) Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery,
2nd edn. Mosby Year Book, Inc, St. Louis, pp 27952801
10. Brook I, Shah K (2001) Bacteriology of adenoids and tonsils in
children with recurrent adenotonsillitis. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 110:844848
123
228
123
20. Maw RA, Speller DCE (1985) Are the tonsils and adenoids a
reservoir of infection in otitis media with effusion? Clin Otolaryngol 10:265269
21. Teele DW, Healy GB, Tally FP (1980) Persistant effusions of the
middle ear. culture for anaerobic bacteria. Ann Otol Rhinol
Laryngol 89(Suppl A):102103
zs ahinoglu C, Aydogan LB (1992) The inflamatory
22. Soylu L, O
diseases of tonsil and adenoid tissue and tonsillectomy. Archive
(1)157165
23. Simon HJ, Sukai W (1968) Staphylococcal antagonism to penicilin-G therapy of hemolytic streptococcal pharyngeal infection: effect of oxacillin. Pediatrics 31:463469
24. Kundsin RB, Miller JM (1964) Significance of the Staphylococcus aureus carrier state in the treatment of disease due to group A
streptococci. N Engl J Med 271:13951397
25. Brook I (1986) Direct and indirect pathogenicity of Branhamella
catarrhalis. Drugs 31(suppl 3):97102
26. Brook I (1993) Infections caused by beta-lactamase producing
Fusobacterium spp. in children. Pediatr Infect Dis J 12:532533
27. Bernstein SH, Stillerman M, Allerhand J (1964) Demonstration
of penicilin inhibition by pharyngeal microflora in patients treated for streptococcal pharyngitis. J Lab Clin Med 63:1422
28. Brook I (2001) Failure of penicilin to eradicate Group A BetaHemolytic Streptococci tonsillitis: causes and management. J Otolaryngol 30:324329