CANADAS ACTION PLAN

to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions

from Aviation

TC 1004722

TP 15187

 Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada, represented by the Minister of Transport, 2012.
Transport Canada grants permission to copy and/or reproduce the contents of this publication for personal and public non-commercial use. Users must reproduce
the materials accurately, identify Transport Canada as the source and not present theirs as an official version, or as having been produced with the help or the
endorsement of Transport Canada.
To request permission to reproduce materials from this publication for commercial purposes, contact:
Publishing and Depository Services
Public Works and Government Services Canada
Ottawa ON K1A 0S5
[email protected]
TP 15187
TC 1004722
Catalogue No. T22-211/2012E-PDF
ISBN 978-1-100-20543-4
For additional copies of this publication, please visit http://transact-en.tc.gc.ca or contact Transport Canadas Publications
Order Desk at 1-888-830-4911 International at 613-991-4071.
For an accessible version of this publication, please contact Transport Canadas
Publications Order Desk at 1-888-830-4911 International at 613-991-4071.
An electronic version of this publication is available at http://www.tc.gc.ca/aviation-emissions/

Canadas Action Plan to Reduce Greenhouse

Gas Emissions from Aviation
Contents
Preamble
Executive Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
1.0 Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
2.0 Canadas Aspirational Goals for Aviation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
3.0 Canadian Context . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
4.0 Recent Achievements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
4.1 Actions Taken . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
4.2 Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
4.3 Moving Forward . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7

5.0 Measures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
5.1 Fleet Renewals and Upgrades . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
5.2 More Efficient Air Operations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
5.3 Improved Capabilities in Air Traffic Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

6.0 Additional Measures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10

6.1 Aviation Environmental Research and Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
6.2 Alternative Fuels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
6.3 Airport Ground Operations and Infrastructure Use . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
6.4 Regulatory Measures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
6.5 International Coordination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13

7.0 Governance and Reporting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

7.1 Governance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
7.2 Annual Reporting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
7.3 Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
7.4 Audit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

Appendix AFuel Consumption Baseline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17

Appendix BSummary Table of Measures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
Appendix CThe Working Groups Areas of Focus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
Appendix DFigures and Tables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31

Preamble

While air travel supports Canadas economy, trade and tourism, and connects Canadians separated
by great distances and rugged terrain, it also contributes to greenhouse gas emissions. This voluntary
Action Plan expresses how the parties, in good faith, intend to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from
aviation activities.
It does not contain legal obligations of any kind or impose unreasonable expectations on any party,
or intend to negatively impact any air carriers ability to do business in Canada.
The Government of Canada reserves the right to develop and implement appropriate regulatory or
other measures to achieve clean air and climate change goals. Nothing in this Action Plan will keep
the Parties from taking further actions relating to greenhouse gas emissions or fuel use.
Dated at Ottawa

this

1st

day of June

2012

Honourable Denis Lebel,

Minister of Transport, Infrastructure
and Communities
Transport Canada

Jim Quick, President and CEO

Aerospace Industries Association of Canada

John McKenna, President and CEO

Air Transport Association of Canada

Daniel-Robert Gooch, President

Canadian Airports Council

Sam Barone, President and CEO

Canadian Business Aviation Association

George Petsikas, President

National Airlines Council of Canada

John W. Crichton, President and CEO

NAV CANADA

Executive
Summary

Building on the success of the worlds first

voluntary agreement to address greenhouse gas
(GHG) emissions from aviation, the Government
of Canada and the Canadian aviation industry
have developed Canadas Action Plan to Reduce
Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Aviation (the
Action Plan).
Taking into account achievements to date, as
well as the Canadian context, the Action Plan
sets an ambitious goal to reduce GHG emissions
from both domestic and international operations,
which we expect to contribute to global efforts to
minimize aviations carbon footprint.
In line with the broad international consensus,
the Action Plan sets an aspirational goal to
improve fuel efficiency from a 2005 baseline
by an average annual rate of at least 2 percent
per year until 2020. To help ensure we reach
this goal, the Action Plan identifies three key
measures that are expected to have the greatest
environmental impact:
Fleet Renewals and Upgrades;
More Efficient Air Operations; and
Improved Capabilities in Air
Traffic Management.

The Action Plan also highlights a second set

of measures. The Canadian Aviation industry
expects these measures to have beneficial
environmental results, but these results are not
expressed in quantitative terms due to the nature
or current stage of the activity. These include:
Aviation Environmental Research
and Development;
Alternative Fuels;
Airport Ground Operations and
Infrastructure Use;
Regulatory Measures; and
International Coordination.
The Action Plan is a living document that will
evolve through:
Semi-annual meetings between government
officials and the Canadian aviation industry;
Annual reporting on the progress towards
achievement of the Action Plans fuel
efficiency target;
A review of the Action Plan, that will occur
in three years; and
An audit that will occur at least once over
the next five years.

1.0 Background
Under the Cancun Agreements, Canada has
committed to a national greenhouse gas (GHG)
reduction target of 17 percent below 2005 levels
by 2020. The Government of Canada has been
working towards this target by addressing GHG
emissions on a sector-by-sector basis.
The aviation industry1 and the Government of
Canada have been working together to reduce
domestic and international GHG emissions
from the aviation sector since 2005. Any future
efforts to reduce domestic aviation emissions
will contribute to Canadas broader 17 percent
climate change target.
In October 2010, the International Civil Aviation
Organization (ICAO) adopted a new Assembly
Resolution on climate change, Resolution A37-19.
It set several voluntary goals for international
aviation emissions, including:

A joint government-industry Working Group

on Aviation Emissions (the Working Group) was
established in 2010 to develop a plan to address
GHG emissions from the domestic aviation sector,
as well as to collaborate on the development
of the Government of Canadas submission to
ICAO. This collaboration builds on existing efforts
to address GHG emissions, such as:
The 2005 voluntary agreement signed
between the Air Transport Association of
Canada (ATAC) and Transport Canada;
The work undertaken by the Canadian
Airports Council (CAC) and Transport Canada
to develop a quantification methodology for
GHG emissions at Canadian airports; and
The efforts of NAV CANADA to identify and
quantify the results of past GHG reduction
initiatives in its annual CIFER (Collaborative
Initiatives for Emissions Reductions) Reports
since 1997.

A global annual average fuel efficiency

improvement of 2 percent until 2020;
A medium-term aspirational goal of keeping
the annual global net carbon emissions from
international aviation from 2020 onward at
the same (2020) level; and
A global aspirational goal of 2 percent
annual fuel efficiency improvement from
2021 to 2050.
To help ICAO track progress towards reaching
these goals, the resolution encourages Member
States to submit action plans detailing specific
measures to address GHG emissions related to
international aviation to ICAO by June 2012.

In this context, the aviation industry includes air carriers, air traffic management, airports, and aircraft and other aerospace technology manufacturers.

2.0 Canadas Aspirational

Goals for Aviation
Canadas Action Plan to Reduce Greenhouse
Gas Emissions from Aviation (the Action Plan)
describes ongoing and planned activities to
reduce GHG emissions from Canadas domestic
and international aviation activities. These
measures could contribute to both Canadas
national GHG emission reduction target of
17 percent below 2005 by 2020 and ICAOs
global goals.
In order to reduce GHG emissions from Canadas
aviation sector, Canada has set a target of:
Average annual improvements in aviation fuel
efficiency of at least 2 percent per year until
2020 from a 2005 baseline, measured in litres
of fuel per Revenue Tonne Kilometre (RTK).
The 2005 baseline is consistent with Canadas
commitments under the Cancun Agreements.
In 2005, the average fuel efficiency rate for
Canadian air carriers was 40.46 litres of fuel
per 100 RTK (see Appendix A for more details).
Through its efforts, Canadas aviation sector
supports the following global aspirational goals:
Carbon neutral growth from 2020
onwards; and

3.0 Canadian Context

Understanding the role of the aviation sector
in Canada helps put the potential impact and
feasibility of Canadas target and global goals
in context.
Based on land mass, Canada is the second largest
country in the world. Its population of 33 million
is scattered across 9 million square kilometres.
This means that air transportation is essential
to Canadas domestic and international trade,
as well as to connecting Canadians within the
country and to the rest of the world. Canadas air
industry also serves remote communities where
it is often the only way to move people and
basic commodities.
Average distances flown domestically per
passenger are considerably higher in Canada
than in countries with smaller landmass.
For example, in 2009:
The domestic average distance per
passenger flown was about 1325 kilometres
in Canada,2 compared to about 425
kilometres3 in the United Kingdom; and
The domestic average distance per
tonne of cargo flown in Canada, was
about 1050 kilometres4, compared to about
385 kilometres in the United Kingdom.5

Absolute GHG emission reductions by 2050.

Statistics Canada, AviationCivil Aviation, Annual Operating and Financial Statistics, Canadian Air Carriers, Levels I to III, 2009. (http://www.statcan.gc.ca/
pub/51-004-x/51-004-x2010007-eng.pdf).
3
The United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority, UK Airline Statistics: 2009 Annual Table 1.6 All Services, (http://www.caa.co.uk/docs/80/airline_
data/2009Annual/Table_0_1_6_All_Services_2009.pdf).
4
Statistics Canada, Air Carrier Operations in Canada Unit Toll Services, Statement 10 (I, II), 2009; Statistics Canada, Air Carrier Operations in Canada,
Charter Services, Statement 12 (I, II, III) 2009.
5
The United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority, UK Airline Statistics: 2009 Annual Table 1.7.4 Domestic Scheduled Services 2009
(http://www.caa.co.uk/docs/80/airline_data/2009Annual/Table_0_1_7_4_Domestic_Scheduled_Services_2009.pdf).
2

Figure 1National Airport System (NAS) Airports and 2010 Passenger Volumes

Passenger Volumes (2010)

Enplaned/Deplaned
90,000 to 500,00
500,001 to 1,000,000
1,000,001 to 10,000,000
10,000,001 to 31,000,000
NAS Airports
30000000
0

15000000
300

100000
600

Kilometers

Source: Transport Canada, Economic Analysis.

Note: Mirabel, a NAS airport, is not included because it does not serve passengers.

Aviation plays a key role in Canadas economy.

In 2009, the aviation sector carried over 71 million
passengers and 762,000 tonnes of freight to,
from and within Canada. Air transportation
contributes $33 billion to Canadas Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) and supports 401,000
jobs in Canada (2.4 percent of the Canadas
workforce). By including the sectors contribution
to the tourism industry, these figures rise to
2.8 percent of Canadian GDP and 551,000 jobs,
or 3.3 percent of the workforce.6

Oxford Economics, Economic Benefits from Air Transport in Canada, 2009.

The 26 National Airport System (NAS) airports

provide access to air transportation to Canadians
with airport passenger volumes of up to 31 million
in 2010 (see Figure 1). Airports across Canada
strive to be as competitive as possible to meet
the needs of local, provincial, and national
economies. To do so, airports must be safe and
secure, and have processes in place to efficiently
move people and goods, address environmental
issues, and provide excellent service.

4.0 Recent Achievements

4.1. Actions Taken
In 2008, aviation emissions made up 5 percent
of domestic emissions from transportation and
1 percent of total Canadian emissions (see
Figure 2).7 Despite the high and rising demand
for airline services in Canada, the Canadian
aviation industry has made real progress towards
limiting its carbon footprint.
In June 2005, ATAC and Transport Canada signed
the worlds first voluntary agreement
to address GHG emissions from both domestic
and international aviation operations.

The agreement set a goal of a 1.1 percent

average annual improvement in fuel efficiency
for each year to 2012, a cumulative improvement
of 24 percent, compared to the 1990 baseline.
In 2008, the large Canadian carriers (Air Canada,
Jazz Aviation LP, Air Transat, and WestJet) left
ATAC and formed the National Airlines Council
of Canada (NACC). Since then, both associations
have continued to fulfill their commitments under
the voluntary agreement, annually reporting
fuel consumption and activity measurements.

Figure 2Aviations Contribution to Canadas Total GHG Emissions

Agriculture
75Mt
(10%)
Building 79Mt
(11%)

Waste and
other 55Mt
(8%)
On-Road Freight
63.7Mt
(37%)

On-Road Passenger
77.2Mt
(45%)

Emissions-intensive
trade-exposed
industries 76Mt
(10%)

Transportation
171Mt
(23%)

Rail
7.1Mt
(4%)

Oil and gas

158Mt
(22%)

Other 1
8.5Mt
(5%)

Electricity 120Mt
(16%)

Total GHG Emissions: 734 Mt in 2008

Marine
5.8Mt
(4%)

Air
8.5Mt
(5%)

Transport Sector Emissions: 171 Mt in 2008

1

Other includes off-road gasoline (e.g. all-terrain vehicles) and refrigerant

leakage from vehicle air conditioners

Source: Environment Canada, Canadas Emissions Trends, 2011.8

Environment Canada, Canadas Emissions Trends, 2011.

(http://www.ec.gc.ca/Publications/E197D5E7-1AE3-4A06-B4FC-CB74EAAAA60F%5CCanadasEmissionsTrends.pdf)
8
Figure 2 is based on data that allocates emissions to the economic sector in which they are generated rather than by activity.
The latter approach is used in Canadas National Inventory Report. As a result, the numbers between the two approaches are not necessarily comparable.
7

A number of key initiatives have been put in

place to:
1. Increase the fuel efficiency of
the Canadian aircraft fleet and
its operations;
2. Improve the efficiency of Canadas air
traffic management system; and
3. Modernize airport facilities.

Highlights include:
Canadian airlines invested about
$13.5 billion from 2005 to 2010, to
modernize their fleets, which brings newer,
quieter, and more fuel-efficient aircraft into
operation. For example, Air Canada, Jazz
Aviation LP, and WestJet, Canadas three
largest airlines, have an average fleet age
of about twelve years (see Appendix D for
more details). They also adopted operational,
maintenance, and planning procedures to
ensure that their current aircraft operate
under optimal conditions to increase fuel
efficiency.
NAV CANADA, which is the private
corporation that owns and operates Canadas
civil air navigation service, has invested
over $1.7 billion since 1996 to modernize
Canadas air navigation system. These
investments have helped improve safety and
operational efficiency for all customers, and
have facilitated reductions in fuel burn and
GHG emissions.
NAV CANADA reports on the various
collaborative initiatives that support
the reduced impact of aviation on the
environment through the CIFER Reports.9
NAV CANADA has made significant
progress towards adopting performancebased navigation (PBN)10, using existing
specifications and instrument procedure
design criteria. Furthermore, NAV CANADA

Canadian airports have invested more

than $14 billion in capital infrastructure
commitments and improvements since the
devolution of airports began in 1992. These
upgrades include:
Using more renewable energy sources in
their operations;
Adding electrical and alternative fuel
vehicles to their ground support
equipment; and
Installing equipment at gates to reduce
the use of aircraft auxiliary power
units (APUs).
Together, these investments have greatly
contributed to modernizing Canadas airline,
airport, and air traffic management infrastructure,
which was ranked first according to the World
Economic Forum in 2011.11

4.2 Results
As of 2010, Canadas aviation industry had made
a 1.9 percent average annual fuel efficiency
improvement since 1990, or a 31 percent
cumulative improvement, which exceeds the
agreed-upon goal in the voluntary agreement.
While absolute domestic and international
emissions have grown at an average annual rate
of 1 percent between 1990 and 2010, this rate
would have been much higher without these
fuel efficiency improvements (see Figure 3). One
estimate suggests that the fuel efficiency gains
achieved between 2001 and 2010 from fleet
renewal, operational and air traffic management
improvements have reduced emissions by
18 million tonnes below what they would have
been without such measures.12

The CIFER reports are available at:

http://www.navcanada.ca/NavCanada.asp?Language=en&Content=ContentDefinitionFiles\AboutUs\Environment\CIFER\default.xml.
10
PBN procedures are more accurate and allow for shorter, more direct routes between two given points, as well as more efficient arrivals and departures.
This reduces fuel burn and aircraft emissions.
11
World Economic Forum, The Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report 2011: Beyond the Downturn, 2011.
(http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_TravelTourismCompetitiveness_Report_2011.pdf)
12
2010 Aviation Industry Report on Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions, March 2012. This estimate assumed that the 2001 fuel consumption rate of 0.4651 litres
per total Revenue Tonne Kilometres was held constant for each subsequent year until 2010. The resulting emissions were compared against the actual emissions
reported for those years to come up with a figure for total emissions displaced over that time period.
9

established a PBN Working Group with

customers and stakeholders, which
developed a PBN implementation framework
and concept of operations for Canada.
NAV CANADA has also played a key role in
developing the ICAO PBN guidance material
and navigation specifications.

48

20
18

46

Fuel Efficiency (L/100 RTK)

16
44

14
12

42

10
40

8
6

38

4
36

GHG Emissions (million tonnes CO2e)

Figure 3GHG Emissions Saved With Fuel Efficiency Gains between 2001 and 2010

34
2001

2002

Fuel efficiency

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

GHG emissions at 2001 fuel efficiency

2008

2009

2010

Actual GHG emissions

Source: 2010 Canadian Aviation Industry Report on Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions, March 2012.

4.3 Moving Forward

To build on the aviation sectors fuel efficiency
advances thus far, the Canadian aviation industry,
together with the Government of Canada, must
address a number of challenges and explore
new opportunities. This is why Canadas Action
Plan takes a sustainable development approach
by taking into account the economic, social and
environmental impacts of each measure.
Transport Canada forecasts that domestic air
traffic will grow at an average annual rate of
2.8 percent until 2020, while international air
traffic will grow at a rate of 4.4 percent (see
Figure 4). Transport Canadas forecast is largely
in line with the air traffic forecasts produced by
the aviation industry.13

13

The accuracy of all traffic forecasts depend

on a number of variables, including economic
conditions. Transport Canadas forecast was
produced in June 2011 and does not reflect
the recent economic turmoil in international
financial markets.
In response to changing markets, Canadian
airlines continually modernize their fleets and
adjust fleet use. NACC airlines plan to invest
over $13.7 billion more between 2011 and 2020.
When compared to earlier investments in fleet
modernization from 2001 to 2010, the resulting
fuel efficiency gains will be relatively small
because the next significant gains will likely
occur after 2020, through new aircraft designs,
new engines, etc.

For example, between 2010 and 2014, Transport Canada has forecasted domestic traffic to grow at a rate of 3.1 percent. In comparison, the October 2010
International Aviation Transport Association (IATA) has forecasted domestic growth to occur at a rate of 3.3 percent. For transborder traffic during the same
period, Transport Canada forecasts 4.3 percent compared with IATAs 3.7 percent.

Enplaned and Deplaned Revenue Passengers

(millions)

Figure 4Forecasted Growth of Passenger Traffic by Sector

90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
2010

2012

2014

Domestic

2016

2018

2020

International

Source: Transport Canada, Economic Analysis.

The fleet renewal efficiency gains are dependent

on two assumptions:
1. New aircraft will be delivered on
schedule. One major air carriers aircraft
acquisition program, for example, is
currently four years behind schedule
due to manufacturing issues. Delays
will impact anticipated fuel efficiency
improvements; and
2. All replaced aircraft will be retired from
service. However, if these aircraft remain
in or return to service, this could impact
fuel efficiency improvements. Older
aircraft may be brought back into service
to provide additional capacity to meet
market demand.
Canadas air traffic management system and
airport facilities have also been greatly improved
over the past two decades. So, while real
environmental benefits have been realized, the
expected growth in air traffic will require the
Canadian aviation industry to continue to make
further advances.

Moving forward, the development of sustainable

alternative aviation fuels will be a key initiative
required by the aviation industry to meet the
global aspirational goal of carbon neutral growth
from 2020. Substantial advances in developing
and commercializing sustainable alternative
aviation fuels will be needed in light of the
key issues related to limited fuel options and
availability of supply for aviation.
In 2006, the Government of Canada developed a
comprehensive renewable fuels strategy primarily
focussed on on-road transportation with four
key elements:
1. A regulation to establish minimum
biofuels content for gasoline and diesel;
2. Programs to support farmer participation
in the industry;
3. A production incentive to stimulate
domestic production; and
4. Initiatives to support next
generation technologies.

The Government of Canada will continue

to assess the progress of the renewable
fuels strategy and analyze areas for future
policy development.
Canada recognizes the interdependencies of
the environmental effects from aviation, such
as noise and engine emissions, which affect
the global climate and local air quality. Canada
also recognizes that there will be tradeoffs
among environmental objectives, such as
between noise and emission reductions. These
interdependencies will be considered when
establishing policies and measures to minimize
or reduce these effects, recognizing that
the interdependencies could limit the full
potential of the environmental benefit of
the proposed measures.

5.0 Measures
The measures detailed below will help Canada
achieve the fuel efficiency target over the next
five years (see Appendices B and C for more
details). These measures are listed separately
from those in the next section (Section 6) because
they represent the greatest opportunities to
improve fuel efficiency and reduce GHGs.

5.1 Fleet Renewals and Upgrades

Canadian airlines expect to achieve an
average annual fuel efficiency improvement
of 0.7 percent for both domestic and
international flights between 2005 and 2020
through further fleet changes.14
The Canadian Business Aviation Association
(CBAA) will encourage its members to take
advantage of opportunities to reduce GHG
emissions through fleet renewal.

5.2 More Efficient Air Operations

Canadian airlines expect to achieve an
average annual fuel efficiency improvement
of 0.2 percent for both domestic and
international flights between 2005 and
2020 through improved operations.15
CBAA will encourage its members to
continue to adopt operational improvements
to reduce emissions.
Transport Canada will continue to work
through ICAO to help prepare and provide
guidance, and to encourage technology and
operational improvements. This includes
updating ICAO Circular 303 Operational
Opportunities to Minimize Fuel Use and
Reduce Emissions, which was published in
2003, into a new ICAO manual, expected
to be completed in 2012.
NACC, ATAC, and CBAA will encourage
their members to continue to take advantage
of the opportunities presented in the new
ICAO manual.

5.3 Improved Capabilities in

Air Traffic Management
Performance-based Navigation (PBN)
Shifting from sensor-based to performancebased navigation will enable more efficient
en route and airport operations for equipped
aircraft, reducing fuel burned and associated
GHG emissions.
Building on existing PBN activities, further
implementation could improve average
annual fuel efficiency by 1 to 2 percent
between 2005 and 2020. The benefits
resulting from PBN will be dependent
upon the following:
Approval by Transport Canada for use
of the United States Federal Aviation
Authority (FAA) Order 8260.54A
and 8260.52 instrument procedure
design criteria;

For more information on the National Airlines Council of Canadas efforts to improve fuel efficiency and reduce GHG emissions, refer to Improving Aviation
Efficiency and Reducing emissions: A NACC Framework, 2011. (http://www.airlinecouncil.ca/pdf/NACC_FuelEfficiency_Final_Eng.pdf)
15
Ibid.
14

 Development and approval of guidance

by Transport Canada for Operations
Specifications in support of the use
of FAA Order 8260.52 criteria;
Acceptance of new ICAO PBN Navigation
Specifications; and
Timely identification and incorporation
of necessary regulatory changes to
support PBN.
Transport Canada, NAV CANADA and the
Canadian aviation industry will work together
to develop and put in place an ICAO State PBN
Implementation Plan for Canada. To support
Canadas PBN Plan:
Transport Canada will develop a PBN
policy framework by spring 2012. It will
set out the scope, opportunities, and
guiding principles for adopting PBN
in Canada.
Transport Canada will continue to move
short- and medium-term solutions forward
to advance PBN in Canada. These
measures include:
Incorporating new PBN-based
Canadian air navigation procedures,
aligned with those of the United
States FAA; and
Continuing to work with ICAO
to develop and incorporate new
international procedures for Canadas
air navigation system.
The Canadian Aviation Regulation
Advisory Council (CARAC) PBN Working
Group, which includes representatives
from Transport Canada, NAV CANADA,
and the Canadian aviation industry, will
identify, within the next two years, the
regulatory requirements and any other
non-regulatory mechanisms to help

10

determine short-, medium-, and long-term

opportunities for adopting PBN. The work
of the PBN Working Group began in
fall 2011.
SurveillanceNAV CANADA has and will
continue to use technologies that increase
surveillance capability and coverage to
maximize benefits and minimize costs.
Increased surveillance capability, both
airborne and on the ground, will result
in more efficient air operations.
Benefits include:
Increased airspace capacity;
Faster response times to
pilot requests;
More flexible routing; and
Fewer ground delays.
NAV CANADA will also continue to use
existing mechanisms to engage customers
and stakeholders who may be affected by any
changes to the Air Navigation System.

6.0 Additional Measures

This Action Plan contains other measures
(see Appendices B and C for more details),
whose expected results are not expressed in
quantitative terms due to the nature of the
activity or their current stage of implementation.
These measures will be essential to achieving the
long-term aspirational goals.

6.1 Aviation Environmental

Research and Development
Significant research efforts are underway to
minimize or reduce aviations environmental
impacts and to inform the development of future
regulations. This research provides valuable
information to the Government of Canada, ICAO,
other governments, industry and communities

on how to best address these environmental

impacts. Research findings will be shared with
interested parties, including Working Group
members. The research is being directed in
a number of key areas, including:
Green Aviation Research & Development
Network (GARDN)With an initial budget
of $24 million over four years (200913), this
Canadian business-led Network of Centres
of Excellence continues to undertake
research and development of technologies
that will help reduce GHG emissions. GARDN
presently administers 15 projects involving
nearly 30 partners, half from industry and
half from academia and research centres.
These projects are guided by the following
research themes:
Source Noise Reductions;
Source Emission Reductions;
Materials and Manufacturing Processes;
Airport Operations;
Aircraft Operations;
Alternative Fuels; and
Product Lifecycle Measurement.
Partnership for AiR Transportation Noise
and Emissions Reduction (PARTNER)
This is a U.S. FAA Center of Excellence,
sponsored by the FAA, NASA, Transport
Canada, the U.S. Department of Defense,
and the U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency. PARTNER research fosters advances
in science and decision-making to improve
mobility, the economy, and the environment.
Canada is committed to continue its support
of PARTNER.

Since 2003, PARTNER has dedicated

US$44 million to research in areas such as:
Emissions;
Operations;
Alternative Fuels;
Tools, System-level, and Policy
Assessment; and
Noise.
Canadas National Research Council (NRC)
The NRC will continue to work on a number
of projects that provide scientific support to
inform regulatory decisions in Canada. These
projects include:
Developing methodologies to sample
and measure aircraft particulate matter
emissions; and
In-flight sampling of aircraft engine
emissions using innovative Canadian
technology to study, among other things,
climate change impacts from standard and
alternative aviation fuels.
The NRC will also continue its program on
the development and evaluation of aviation
alternative fuels, with support from industry
and other government departments.
The United States Transportation Research
Boards Airport Cooperative Research
Program (ACRP)The ACRP is an industrydriven, applied research program that
develops near-term, practical solutions
to problems faced by airport operators.
The environment is a key theme of ACRPs
research and reports relating to aircraft
noise, emissions, airport operations, air
and water quality impacts and metrics.
Transport Canada will continue to support
and participate in ACRP in a number of key
research areas.

11

In addition to these research initiatives, the

Aerospace Industries Association of Canada
(AIAC) will encourage its members to engage in
research and development, as well as to produce
new and innovative technologies on aircraft and
aircraft engines as soon as it is safe, legal and
practical, with a view to improve fuel efficiency
and reduce GHG emissions.

6.2 Alternative Fuels

Research, Development, and
DemonstrationThe Government of
Canada will continue to support research,
development and demonstration
of alternative fuels for aviation. This
includes ongoing federal research efforts
under the Program of Energy Research
and Development and research and
development opportunities in alternative
aviation biofuels under the research and
development component of the ecoENERGY
Innovation Initiative. In addition, Sustainable
Development Technology Canada16
administers two funding programs:
The $550 million SD Tech Fund 17, which
has allocated more than $10 million to
two alternative aviation fuel projects; and
The $500 million NextGen Biofuels
Fund, which could support the
commercial scale demonstration of the
production of next-generation renewable
fuels for aviation.
Canada will also pursue opportunities to
collaborate with its key trading partners,
particularly the United States, on alternative
aviation fuel research and development
and certification, and explore issues such as
commercial production. For example, the
ongoing Canada-United States Clean Energy
Dialogue includes next generation biofuels
as a priority research and development area.

The Government of Canada and the aviation

industry will work collaboratively to discuss
the potential for, benefits of, and barriers to
alternative aviation fuel production and use
in Canada.

6.3 Airport Ground Operations and

Infrastructure Use
Reducing GHG Emissions at the Gate and
on the GroundAirlines and airports are
working together to reduce emissions
from APUs and ground support equipment
(such as baggage tugs and tractors). For
example, Canadian airports are pursuing
opportunities to supply their loading gates
with preconditioned air, which helps to
minimize the use of APUs. Airlines and
Airport Authorities will also collaborate to
develop an effective way to track how these
efforts reduce emissions from these sources.
Taxi OperationsThe Canadian aviation
industry (airports, airlines, and NAV
CANADA) will continue to work together to
reduce GHG emissions by reducing airport
aircraft ground emissions through improved
taxi and queuing procedures. They will also
work to reduce taxi times associated with
de-icing procedures.
The CAC, NACC and NAV CANADA will
establish an average baseline for taxi times at
the four major airports (Vancouver, Calgary,
Toronto, and Montreal). Taxi times will then
be monitored using such tools as the NAV
CANADA Airport Performance Monitor
(APM)18 and airline taxi data to determine
where and when significant delays occur.
Delays could be due to weather, schedule
conflicts, runway/taxiway infrastructure, and/
or operational restrictions. This information
will be assessed to identify where improved
procedures and/or infrastructure could
reduce taxi times and queuing.

For more information on the Sustainable Development Technology Canada funds, please visit: http://www.sdtc.ca/index.php?page=about-our-funds&hl=en_CA.
Budget 2011 makes an additional $40 M available over two years.
18
For more information on APM, please visit:
http://www.navcanada.ca/NavCanada.asp?Language=EN&Content=contentdefinitionfiles\technologysolutions\iatc\default.xml
16
17

12

 Airport GHG Emission InventoriesOver

the past 40 years, airport ambient air quality
studies have provided real-time information
on airport air quality and helped to minimize
aviation emission impacts at Canadian
airports. Building on the success of this
work, the CAC and Transport Canada
completed GHG emission inventories
for 26 of the NAS airports, as well as all
Transport Canada-owned airports. The
Airport GHG Emission Inventories quantify
airport-related emissions from various
activities. The CAC and Transport Canada
will continue to refine and improve data
quality and explore opportunities to adopt
emission reductions strategies.

6.4 Regulatory Measures

CO2 Emissions StandardTransport
Canada will continue to participate in the
development of a CO2 standard for airplanes,
through ICAOs Committee on Aviation
Environmental Protection (CAEP). This
standard is targeted for completion within
the next two years. Once completed and
adopted by ICAO, Transport Canada will
adopt the standard domestically under
the Aeronautics Act.
Non-volatile Particulate Matter Standard
In addition to human health concerns, there
are concerns about the impact that aircraft
non-volatile particulate matter (nvPM) may
have on the global climate. Transport Canada
will continue to help develop a new nvPM
standard for aircraft engines, through CAEP,
targeted for 2016.

The National Research Council, supported

by Transport Canada, is participating
in the development of a sampling and
measurement methodology and an Aerospace
Recommended Practice document for the
certification requirement for the new ICAO
nvPM standard for aircraft engines.

6.5 International Coordination

Recognizing that efforts to address climate
change require international action and
coordination, Transport Canada will continue
to actively participate, through ICAO, on
the implementation of global approaches
and standards to address climate change,
including system efficiencies and marketbased measures. Transport Canada will
continue to engage the Canadian aviation
industry as part of the international dialogue
on these issues.
As the Canadian member of the International
Coordinating Council of Aerospace Industries
Associations (ICCAIA), AIAC will strive to
lead Canadian aerospace manufacturers
in working directly with its international
counterparts and through the ICAO CAEP
process in developing and producing aircraft
and engines that will meet or exceed ICAO
required improvements to aircraft and
aircraft engine fuel efficiency and GHG
emission requirements.

13

7.0 Governance
and Reporting
7.1 Governance
The Working Group on Aviation Emissions19 will
oversee Canadas Action Plan. Its members are
representatives from:
Transport Canada;
Air Transport Association of Canada (ATAC);
National Airlines Council of Canada (NACC);
Canadian Airports Council (CAC);
Aerospace Industries Association of
Canada (AIAC);
Canadian Business Aviation Association
(CBAA); and,
NAV CANADA.
The Working Group will meet at least twice
a year, to monitor individual and collective
progress made towards achieving Canadas
fuel efficiency target.

7.2 Annual Reporting

An Annual Report will summarize the progress
that has been made in meeting GHG emission
reduction goals and other Action Plan activities.
The first Annual Report will be published by
December 31, 2013 on the Transport
Canada website.

A list of member companies reporting; and

A quantitative and/or qualitative description
of the actions taken by all Working Group
members to achieve progress on the
measures identified in sections five and
six of the Action Plan.
For the first two years, the aviation activity and
emission data reported in the Annual Reports will
be aggregated for domestic and international
aviation. Beginning with the 2014 Annual Report,
domestic and international aviation activity and
emission data will be reported separately.
Subject to applicable laws of Canada, Working
Group members agree that any and all
company-specific information shall be treated as
commercially confidential and will not be released
to the public domain without the consent of the
relevant company.

7.3 Review
The Working Group will conduct a review
of the Action Plan in three years to assess
progress towards the environmental goals and
commitments, and update the Action Plan.

7.4 Audit
To ensure continued confidence in the reliability
of the reports, a qualified auditor, chosen by
the Working Group, will be given access at least
once over the next five years of the Action Plan,
to audit the reports, processes, and supporting
documentation that pertain to the Action Plan.

The Annual Reports will include:

A quantitative description of achievements
(including relevant indicators such as litres
of fuel consumed per type of fuel, and
Revenue Tonne Kilometres). NACC and
ATAC will collect all of the information
necessary to report on the fuel efficiency
improvements achieved;

19

14

The Working Group is chaired by Transport Canada and consists of one representative of each of the other member organizations.

15

Appendix A

16

Fuel Consumption Baseline

The 2005 fuel consumption baseline is referenced from data reported annually by ATAC and NACC
in the Canadian Aviation Industry Report on Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions.

Table 1Annual Results of Operations 2001 to 2010, compared with 1990,

as reported by ATAC and NACC
1990

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

Fuel use (million litres)

4,616

4,829

4,634

4,584

4,566

4,887

5,186

5,543

5,575

5,077

5,659

GHG emissions (millions of

tonnes of CO2-equivalent)

11.801

12.346

11.846

11.719

11.673

12.495

13.258

14.171

14.254

12.980

14.467

Available seat-kilometres
(ASK)

75.22

109.58

117.71

120.01

123.14

131.98

139.48

151.55

154.05

152.66

156.81

Revenue passengerkilometres (RPK)

66.37

86.68

89.08

89.24

95.18

105.22

112.98

124.15

125.55

117.62

128.77

Passenger revenue-tonnekilometres (pass. RTK) *

6.64

8.67

8.91

8.92

9.52

10.52

11.30

12.42

12.55

11.76

12.88

Cargo available tonnekilometres (cargo ATK)

11.12

13.63

13.37

11.85

12.21

13.22

13.54

14.45

14.12

14.11

15.26

Cargo revenue-tonnekilometres (cargo RTK)

1.72

1.71

1.74

1.49

1.54

1.56

1.52

1.81

1.56

1.37

1.93

Total available tonnekilometres (Total ATK)

18.65

24.59

25.14

23.85

24.52

26.41

27.48

29.61

29.52

29.38

30.94

Total revenue-tonnekilometres (Total RTK)

8.36

10.38

10.65

10.42

11.06

12.08

12.81

14.22

14.12

13.14

14.81

Litres/ASK

0.0614

0.0441

0.0394

0.0382

0.0371

0.0370

0.0372

0.0366

0.0362

0.0333

0.0348

Litres/RPK

0.0695

0.0557

0.0520

0.0514

0.0480

0.0464

0.0459

0.0446

0.0444

0.0432

0.0425

Litres/Total ATK

0.2475

0.1964

0.1843

0.1922

0.1862

0.1850

0.1887

0.1872

0.1889

0.1735

0.1824

Litres/Total RTK

0.5523

0.4651

0.4350

0.4401

0.4128

0.4046

0.4047

0.3898

0.3949

0.3865

0.3790

CO2e grams/ASK

156.89

112.67

100.64

97.65

94.79

94.68

95.05

93.51

92.53

85.02

89.00

CO2e grams/RPK

177.81

142.43

132.98

131.32

122.64

118.75

117.35

114.14

113.53

110.36

108.65

CO2e grams/Total ATK

633

502

471

491

476

473

482

479

483

442

466

CO2e grams/Total RTK

1,412

1,189

1,112

1,125

1,055

1,034

1,035

996

1,010

988

969

Traffic (billions)

Fuel consumption rates

Emission rates

Source: 2010 Canadian Aviation Industry Report on Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions, March 2012, p.10.
*Note that Passenger RTK are calculated by dividing RPK by 100 kg, which is the industrys conventional assumption
of the average weight per passenger, including luggage.

17

Appendix B

18

Summary Table of Measures

Measure

Description

Start Date

Date of Full
Implementation

GHG / Fuel
Efficiency
Impact

Economic Cost
(CDN$)

List of
Stakeholders

Fleet Renewals
and Upgrades

Retire older airplanes

and bring newer, more
efficient airplanes into
service.

Ongoing

Ongoing

Average
annual 0.7%
fuel efficiency
improvement
from 2005
to 2020

$13.7 billion
from 2011 to
2020.

Canadian airlines,
CBAA

More Efficient
Air Operations

Canadian airlines to
improve fuel efficiency
through more efficient
air operations.

Ongoing

Ongoing

Average
annual 0.2%
fuel efficiency
improvement
from 2005
to 2020

To Be
Determined

Canadian airlines,
CBAA

Guidance on
Operational
Opportunities
New ICAO Manual

Transport Canada
to continue to work
through ICAO to
encourage technology
and operational
improvements.

Update
expected
in 2012

Ongoing

N/A

N/A

Transport
Canada, ICAO,
Aviation industry
stakeholders

Performance Based
Navigation

Shift from sensorbased to performancebased navigation.

Ongoing

Ongoing

Average annual
1 to 2% fuel
efficiency
improvement
from 2005
to 2020

To Be
Determined

NAV CANADA,
Transport
Canada,
Aviation industry
stakeholders

Aviation
Environmental
Research and
Development

Active engagement
and support of
aviation-related
research initiatives,
including: GARDN,
PARTNER, the NRC,
and the U.S. ACRP.

Ongoing

Ongoing

N/A

To Be
Determined

Transport
Canada, Industry
Canada,
Aviation industry
stakeholders

Alternative Fuels

The Government of
Canada to continue
to support research
in the development
and demonstration
of alternative fuels
for aviation.

Ongoing

Ongoing

To Be
Determined

To Be
Determined

Government
of Canada,
Aviation industry
stakeholders, U.S.
partners

Alternative Fuels

The Government of
Canada and aviation
industry to discuss the
potential for, benefits
of, and barriers to
alternative aviation
fuel production and
use in Canada.

Ongoing

Ongoing

To Be
Determined

To Be
Determined

Government of
Canada, Aviation
industry, other
stakeholders

19

20

Measure

Description

Start Date

Date of Full
Implementation

GHG / Fuel
Efficiency
Impact

Economic Cost
(CDN$)

List of
Stakeholders

Reducing GHG
Emissions at the Gate
and on the Ground

Reduce emissions from

using APUs and ground
support equipment.

Ongoing

Ongoing

To Be
Determined

To Be
Determined

CAC, Canadian
airlines, CBAA

Taxi Operations

Reduce taxi times,

thereby improving
fuel efficiency.

Ongoing

Ongoing

To Be
Determined

To Be
Determined

NAV
CANADA,
CAC, Canadian
airlines, CBAA

Airport GHG
Emission Inventories

Use existing GHG

inventories for airports
to adopt GHG reducing
measures.

Ongoing

Ongoing

N/A

N/A

Transport
Canada, CAC,
Canadian
airlines, CBAA

CO2 Standard for

Airplanes

Through ICAO, develop

a new CO2 standard
for new airplanes and
adopt the new standard
domestically.

Standard for
new airplanes
targeted for
completion
within two
years.

Domestic
regulatory
implementation
within two
years of ICAO
adopting the
new standard

To Be
Determined

To Be
Determined

Transport
Canada,
Aviation
industry
stakeholders

Non-volatile
Particulate Matter
Standard

Develop the certification

requirement for a new
non-volatile particulate
matter standard for
aircraft engines.

Standard
expected by
2016

Domestic
regulatory
implementation
within two
years of ICAO
adopting the
new standard

N/A

To Be
Determined

Transport
Canada,
Aviation
industry
stakeholders

International
Coordination

Active participation
through ICAO on
implementing global
approaches and
standards to address
the impact to the global
climate.

Ongoing

Ongoing

N/A

To Be
Determined

Transport
Canada,
Aviation
industry
stakeholders

21

Appendix C

22

The Working Groups Areas of Focus

The Working Group identified areas of focus where industry cooperation and synergies can help achieve
future emission reductions. To help explore these areas of focus, subgroups were established to identify
and advance emission reduction opportunities in the following areas:
Performance-based Navigation;
Surveillance;
Auxiliary Power Units and Ground
Support Equipment;
Taxiing; and
Alternative Fuels.

Performance-Based Navigation
Description:
Performance-based Navigation (PBN) will provide benefits to equipped aircraft operators by allowing
more efficient and flexible en route and terminal (airport) operations than existing ground-based
navigation. PBN includes both Area Navigation (RNAV) and Required Navigation Performance (RNP).
The PBN concept represents a shift from sensor-based to performance-based navigation. Performance
requirements are identified in navigation specifications, which also identify the choice of navigation
sensors and equipment that may be used to meet the performance requirements. These navigation
specifications are defined at a sufficient level of detail to facilitate global harmonization by providing
specific implementation guidance for States and operators. The PBN concept specifies that aircraft
RNAV system performance requirements be defined in terms of the accuracy, integrity, availability,
continuity and functionality, which are needed for the proposed operations in the context of a particular
airspace concept.

Partners:
NAV CANADA (Air Navigation Service Provider); Transport Canada; Aircraft Operators;
and Airports.

Strategic Goals:
Improved Air Navigation Services (ANS) and air operator efficiency.

Considerations:
Transport Canada is committed to working with NAV CANADA and industry stakeholders
to develop its State PBN plan, in accordance with ICAO resolution A36-23.

23

 Work is underway to review where amendments to the Canadian Aviation Regulations may be
required to reflect the PBN concept and to include the PBN design specifications. Interim measures,
such as Exemptions to the Regulations, Operations Specifications and Aeronautical Information
Circulars (AICs) are providing opportunities for NAV CANADA and Canadian air operators to
use PBN.

Timelines:
Short-Term (201015)Short-term implementation objectives are based on projects that
have begun or are identified in NAV CANADAs business plans as well as those that use PBN
specifications that currently exist and are approved in Canada.
Medium-Term (201520)Transition from a sensor-based environment to a PBN environment will
begin as PBN specifications are approved for use in Canada. Implementation will be subject to a
positive business case and customer consultation.
Long-Term (2020 and beyond)NAV CANADA will transition to primarily a PBN environment with
ground based navigation aids available only as a back-up capability. The 4D RNP operations are
expected to be available to support a full gate-to-gate flight management environment.

Targets and Performance Measurement:

To implement PBN, NAV CANADA will transition on a schedule dictated mostly by customer needs,
levels of equipage, and positive business cases.

Initiative Management:
NAV CANADA

Reporting Schedule:
Annually in the CIFER report.

Surveillance
Description:
Increased airborne and surface (airport) surveillance capability will make ground and air operations more
efficient. This means increased airspace capacity, faster response times to pilot requests, more flexible
routing and less ground delays.
There are various technologies that can increase surveillance capability and coverage in what is todays
procedural airspace. NAV CANADA will use a mix of surveillance technologies to maximize benefits and
minimize costs, using a business case process.

Partners:
NAV CANADA (Air Navigation Service Provider); Department of National Defence (DND); Aircraft
Operators; and Airports.

24

Strategic Goals:
Improved Air Navigation Services (ANS), airport, and air operator efficiency.

Milestones:
ADS-B Surveillance
Hudson Bay implemented (2009);
ADS-B North East Coast (Labrador and Baffin Island) implemented (2011);
ADS-B Oceanic (Greenland) in 2012;
Other locations (To Be Determined).
Wide Area Multilateration (WAM)
Implemented at Fort St. John and Vancouver Harbour, BC;
Implementation in the Kelowna area planned for 2012;
Other sites under review.
MultilaterationSurface Detection
Project initiated at Pierre Elliott Trudeau Airport in Montral;
Planned for Calgary and Toronto international airports;
Other airports are being assessed and will be subject to Airport Authority approval/funding.
North Warning SystemRadar Integration
Eastern portion completed in November 2010;
Western portion under review.
Video Surveillance
Under test and evaluation at various sites, including London, Ottawa, and Montral;
Other sites being assessed for application.

Targets and Performance Measurement:

To be determined from individual business cases.

Initiative Management:
NAV CANADA

Reporting Schedule:
Annually in the CIFER report.

25

Auxiliary Power Units and Ground Support Equipment

Description:
Airlines and airports have been working closely together to identify ways to reduce emissions from the
use of auxiliary power units (APUs) and ground support equipment (GSE).
Emissions from an aircrafts APUs can be greatly reduced if ground-based alternatives are available and
used. GSE is either owned directly by airlines or contracted by airlines from third-party providers and is
a major part of airport ground operations. Airlines and airports are:
Working to improve technology;
Adding fixed gate infrastructure;
Developing and adopting operating procedures to more effectively use the infrastructure; and
Using alternative fuels to improve efficiency and reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and
criteria air contaminants.
These emission reduction opportunities support the Action Plans targets. The range of potential
GHG reductions from these opportunities will be quantified as appropriate and feasible. The Working
Group understands that these targets are intensity-based and will take into account an increase in flight
schedules and equipment inventory.

Partners:
Canadian Airports Council; Air Transport Association of Canada; National Airlines Council of
Canada; Canadian Business Aviation Association; Transport Canada.

Strategic Goals:
Identify and implement opportunities to reduce emissions from APUs and GSE.

Milestones:
Over the next five years (2012-2017), the APU/GSE subgroup will meet quarterly in order to:
Confirm status of emission inventories: who conducted them; how were they developed; what is the
contribution from GSEs and APUs;
Develop baseline of existing equipment: i.e., GSE fleet mix; existing PCA/GPU equipment at gates;
Identify regulatory framework, policies and procedures for use of equipment;
Identify current emission reduction initiatives: reviewing what has worked and what has not;
Identify gaps, barriers and issues that currently prevent optimal use of existing infrastructure;
Identify initiatives that will lead to resolving these gaps, barriers and issues;
Research emerging technologies and determine ability to adopt.

26

Targets and Performance Measurement:

Specific targets and performance measures will be determined from individual initiatives.
The subgroup will meet by conference call quarterly and will hold face-to-face meetings on
an annual basis.

Initiative management:
The partners mentioned above have agreed to:
Collect data on inventory of GSE and their fuel burn;
Collect data on auxiliary power use, use of pre-conditioned air and ground power units; and
Take inventory of gate infrastructure.

Reporting:
Responsibility of ReportSubgroup Co-Chairs

Taxi Operations:
Description:
The importance of managing aircraft taxi times increases with the increased number of aircraft ground
movements (the busier the airport the more important this initiative becomes). This group will identify
opportunities to reduce GHG emissions through improved taxiing and queuing procedures at Canadian
airports and reduce overall taxi times. In simple terms, the goal is to limit aircraft main engine run time
on the ground.

Partners:
NAV CANADA; Canadian Airports Council; Air Transport Association of Canada; National Airlines
Council of Canada; Transport Canada

Strategic Goals:
There are five areas targeted:
1. Data collection on various elements of airport taxiing and queuing operations;
2. Push-back operations;
3. Ground crew availability;
4. Ground surveillance improvements; and
5. Taxi infrastructure improvements.

27

Milestones/Implementation Considerations:
All of the initiatives above are underway, as they generally provide improvements to efficiency,
safety and reduce fuel costs and GHGs. Initiatives 1, 4 and 5 are linked with the Surveillance
initiatives of this Action Plan, and are chaired by NAV CANADA.
Estimated timeframe of outputs
Short-term (5 years)
Multilateration (aircraft ground surveillance) installed in Montral and planned for Calgary
and Toronto;
PARTNER (Partnership for AiR Transportation Noise and Emissions Reduction) computer
simulations on airport surface movement optimization may be available within the next
five years.
Medium-Term (510 years)
Identification and addition of new taxiways and runways are an ongoing process.

Targets and Performance Measurement

Airside taxi out times can be reduced by an estimated 20 percentPARTNER;
Emission reductions and benefits can be measured against ICAO specified times.

Initiative Management:
The partners mentioned above have agreed to advance:
Data collection on various elements/segments of airport taxiing and queuing operations;
Push-back operations;
Ground Crew availability;
Ground surveillance improvements; and
Taxi infrastructure improvements.

Reporting:
Responsibility of ReportSubgroup Co-Chairs

28

Alternative Fuels
Description:
To meet the global aspirational goal of carbon neutral growth from 2020, substantial advances in
developing and commercializing sustainable alternative aviation fuels will be required. The alternative
fuels subgroup will work to identify potential opportunities to advance alternative fuels for aviation
in Canada.

Partners:
National Airlines Council of Canada; Transport Canada; Air Transport Association of Canada;
Aerospace Industries Association of Canada; Environment Canada, Natural Resources Canada,
National Research Council, Industry Canada, Agriculture Canada, Department of National Defence.

Strategic Goals:
Identify opportunities to advance alternative fuels for aviation in Canada.

Milestones:
Survey actions underway on alternative fuels for aviation in Canada, including barriers and
opportunities, and propose options for next steps;
Undertake research on alternative fuels for aviation in Canada and share results with
relevant parties;
Identify opportunities to collaborate with key trading partners, particularly the United States,
on alternative aviation fuel research and development and certification, and explore issues
such as commercial production;
Identify the potential for, benefits of, and barriers to alternative aviation fuel production
and use in Canada.

Targets and Performance Measurement:

To be determined

Initiative management:
NACC and Transport Canada

Reporting:
Responsibility of ReportSubgroup Co-Chairs

29

Appendix D

30

Figures and Tables

1) Improvement in Canadas Air Traffic Management
Significant improvements in Canadas Air Traffic Management system have resulted in fuel savings and
avoided emissions. It is estimated that over 20 million cumulative tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent
(CO2e) will be avoided by 2020.
This figure below represents the potential of achievable benefits, and includes all initiatives that have
been implemented up to and including 2010. Examples of these initiatives include RVSM, Northern
Radar Expansion Program, Polar Routes, ADS-B Hudson Bay, and RNAV/RNP procedures. It does not
include any PBN initiatives planned for implementation post-2010 timeframe.

Figure 5Cumulative Tonnes (000) of CO2 Equivalent and Millions of Litres of Fuel
Burn Avoided 1997 - 2020 - Canadian and International Carriers

8,000
7,000

18,000

6,000

13,052

15,000

5,000

7,849

12,000

1,000

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

720
2006

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

350

3,000

2,000

2,500

1,892

6,000

4,000
3,000

4,964

6,574

9,000

2005

000 Tonnes of CO2e Avoided (line)

21,000

9,000

Million Litres of Fuel Burn Avoided (Area)

20,637

24,000

Year

Source: NAV CANADA CIFER Report 2012

31

2) Comparisons of Canadian Airlines Fleet Age

Canada has a relatively young and modern fleet, with the exception of airlines primarily providing
service in the North. For example, the weighted average age of Canadas three largest airlines
(Air Canada, Jazz Aviation LP, and WestJet) is about 12 years.

Table 2Average Fleet Age of Canadian Airlines

Airline

Average Age of Fleet (years)

Number of Aircraft

Air Canada

11.8

207

Jazz Aviation LP

15.8

139

WestJet

5.8

96

Air Inuit

28.5

27

First Air

26.7

23

Porter Airlines

2.6

26

Air Transat

16.9

18

Sunwing Airlines

6.0

18

Canadian North

24.3

16

Air North Charter

32.8

Total Weighted Average Age of Fleet:

13.4

Source: Back Aviation Fleet PC (fleet as of December 14, 2011)

Table 3Comparison of Fleet Age by International Airlines

Airline

Country

American Airlines

US

15.0

Delta Airlines

US

16.1

Southwest Airlines

US

11.9

Air France

France

9.4

Lufthansa

Germany

13.3

British Airways

United Kingdom

12.6

Singapore Airlines

Singapore

7.2

Air China

China

7.9

Air India

India

10.2

Japan Airlines

Japan

8.4

Source: Back Aviation Fleet PC (fleet as of December 14, 2011)

32

Average Age of Fleet (years)

3) Aviations Impact on the Canadian Economy

Aviation plays a key role in the Canadian economy. The following tables show the value and types
of goods shipped by air.

Table 4Value of International Goods Shipped by Air, 200010 (millions of dollars)

Sector/ Year

Air Exports*

Air Imports

Air Total

All Modes Exp.& Imp

Air Share (percent)

2000

23,845

23,643

47,488

588,947

8.1

2001

21,875

21,114

42,989

570,040

7.5

2002

18,905

17,414

36,319

563,861

6.4

2003

17,290

15,428

32,719

530,457

6.2

2004

15,688

16,254

31,942

556,545

5.7

2005

16,556

15,760

32,316

580,041

5.6

2006

14,597

15,704

30,301

575,352

5.3

2007

15,559

17,571

33,129

576,510

5.7

2008R

15,218

18,056

33,274

602,726

5.5

2009R

13,177

16,101

29,278

456,865

6.4

2010

11,870

14,915

26,785

501,385

5.3

2000

12,214

30,238

42,451

181,258

23.4

2001

12,572

27,357

39,929

177,153

22.5

2002

12,488

26,406

38,894

181,473

21.4

2003

14,721

24,804

39,524

186,626

21.2

2004

18,818

28,648

47,466

209,943

22.6

2005

21,524

31,755

53,279

234,518

22.7

2006

24,984

34,834

59,819

257,592

23.2

2007

25,202

38,028

63,230

280,745

22.5

2008R

28,180

40,015

68,194

314,761

21.7

2009R

26,857

37,839

64,696

268,156

24.1

2010P

31,250

42,409

73,659

299,881

24.6

2000

36,059

53,881

89,940

770,205

11.7

2001

34,447

48,472

82,918

747,193

11.1

2002

31,394

43,820

75,213

745,334

10.1

2003

32,011

40,232

72,243

717,083

10.1

2004

34,506

44,902

79,409

766,488

10.4

2005

38,079

47,515

85,595

814,559

10.5

2006

39,581

50,538

90,119

832,944

10.8

2007

40,761

55,599

96,360

857,255

11.2

2008

43,398

58,071

101,469

917,487

11.1

2009R

40,034

53,940

93,974

725,021

13.0

2010P

43,120

57,324

100,444

801,266

12.5

Canada/United States

Other International

Total Canada/World

Source: Transport Canada, Transportation in Canada 2010: Addendum Table A22,

(http://www.tc.gc.ca/media/documents/policy/addendum2010.pdf)
*Notes: R = Revised.
P = Preliminary.
* Total exports include domestic exports and re-exports.

33

Table 5Main Commodity Groups Shipped by Air in Canadas International Trade,

2009 and 2010 (millions of dollars)
Exports by air*

2009R

2010P

Percent Change

Misc & other manufactured goods

24,411

28,106

15.1

aviation-related equipment

7,574

7,423

-2.0

Machinery & electrical equipment

11,839

11,239

-5.1

Plastics & chemical products

2,542

2,508

-1.3

Food products

537

552

2.7

Metal & Steel products

498

544

9.2

Automobiles & other transport equipment

82

96

17.8

Cement & non-metallic products

38

36

-3.6

Forest products

36

33

-6.9

50

-94.4

Minerals, ores & concentrates

105.3

Total Exports by air

40,034

43,120

7.7

Machinery & electrical equipment

22,362

23,732

6.1

Misc & other manufactured goods

20,221

22,865

13.1

includes aviation-related equipment

3,770

3,362

-10.8

Plastics & chemical products

9,511

8,769

-7.8

Metal and Steel products

962

994

3.3

Automobiles & other transport equipment

349

395

13.2

Food products

312

325

4.1

Cement & non-metallic products

132

132

-0.2

Forest products

61

60

-1.2

LNG & Petroleum products

28

51

85.3

Minerals, ores & concentrates

39.1

Total Imports by air

53,940

57,324

6.3

LNG & Petroleum products

Imports by air

Source: Transport Canada, Transportation in Canada 2010: Addendum Table A25,

(http://www.tc.gc.ca/media/documents/policy/addendum2010.pdf)
Notes: R = Revised.
P = Preliminary.
* Total exports include domestic exports and re-exports.
+ LNG = Liquefied natural gas

34