Termination Guidelines
Termination Guidelines
Termination Guidelines
an Employee
the Legal Way:
6 Termination Guidelines
Editor
Editorial Director
Associate Publisher
Publisher
Kathy A. Shipp
Patrick DiDomenico
Adam Goldstein
Phillip A. Ash
2012 Business Management Daily, a division of Capitol Information Group, Inc. All rights reserved. Substantial
duplication of this report is prohibited. However, we encourage you to excerpt from this report as long as you include
a hyperlink back to www.businessmanagementdaily.com/TerminationGuidelines. The hyperlink must be included on
every usage of the report title. Alternatively, you may simply link to the aforementioned page on our site. Any
reproduction in print form requires advance permission by contacting the publisher at (800) 543-2055 or
[email protected]. Any violation is subject to legal action.
This content is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information regarding the subject matter covered. It is
provided with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal service. If you require legal
advice, please seek the services of an attorney.
The lesson: Fire away, but do it the right way. Use this special report, How to Fire an
Employee the Legal Way, as your guide on proper procedures to exercise your right to
fire at will, lay the groundwork with progressive discipline, avoid wrongful termination
lawsuits, and conduct termination meetings and exit interviews.
At-will limitations
Over the years, the employers right to fire at will has been limited, as courts have
recognized exceptions to the at-will doctrine. Here are three major exceptions:
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
Page 2
Exception 1: Discrimination. Under federal law its illegal to terminate workers because
of their age, race, religion, sex, national origin or a disability that does not influence their
job performance. Some states add other limitationsfor example, in many states, you
cant fire someone over sexual preference.
Exception 2: Public policy. You cannot legally terminate an employee for reasons that
violate public policy. That means you cant fire one of your engineers for informing the
EPA that your company has been dumping toxic waste in the river. By the same token, if
a court orders you to garnish the wages of a worker whos behind on child support, you
cant fire him merely to save yourself the hassle of additional paperwork.
Exception 3: Just cause promise. If you tell your workers that they will be fired for
cause onlyor otherwise establish guidelines that spell out how and when terminations
will be handledyou may be creating an implied employment contract.
The problem: If you dont follow your disciplinary rules to the letter, you could find
yourself on the losing end of a lawsuit.
In short, employment at-will still exists, but it has been so deeply eroded with exceptions
that youd be wise to follow a simple rule: Dont fire a worker without a good reason that
you can articulate clearly and document convincingly.
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
Page 3
If that doesnt work, write a few notes about what the employee is doing wrong or failing
to do right, and reference the standards youve communicated. Include the date of
specific failings. Document every warning. Keep enough of a record that you can
remember what happened, but not so much that it looks like a setup.
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
Page 4
see it coming. That doesnt mean, of course, that the process will be easy. Some
employees will get teary, others might turn violent, and all might try to distort the events
of the actual firing. To protect yourself:
Have someone else with you when you talk to the employee so theres no question
of what was said.
Write a memo afterward about the meeting and have the witness sign it.
Conduct an exit interview to give employees a chance to let off steam or express
their concerns.
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
Page 5
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
Page 6
5. Termination. If you make the decision to fire, meet with the employee and deliver a
termination letter that states the reasons for dismissal.
Does your company have a history of discharging employees for any of these reasons?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
Page 7
a demotion
reduction in salary
reduction in job responsibilities
reassignment to menial or degrading work
reassignment to work under a younger supervisor
involuntary transfer to a less desirable position
badgering, harassment or humiliation by the employer
offers of early retirement or encouragement to retire
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
Page 8
There are other factors that dont substantiate claims of constructive discharge, such as:
3. Do employers have to tread carefully when disciplining an employee who has filed a
complaint for fear of a constructive discharge claim?
You dont have to feel handcuffed in your dealings with an employee who has filed a
complaint. But you do have to be careful with any disciplinary action taken, particularly
after the charge has been filed. Here are six points to keep in mind before you discipline
an employee who could strike back with a claim of constructive discharge.
1. You must be able to show that the behavior of the employee you want to
discipline violates written company policy.
2. You have to prove that the employee was aware of the policy and the possible
consequences for violating it.
3. Your recommended discipline must be consistent with actions you have taken in
the past against other employees who have not filed any charges against the
company. Make sure both extremes are avoidedspecial treatment or retaliation.
4. You should never try to build a case against employees who have filed a
complaint. Putting them under special scrutiny or constructing a file filled with
reprimands and/or unsatisfactory performance appraisals will make matters worse.
5. Remember that even if an employees original complaint against the company is
dismissed, the person is still protected. Retaliation under such circumstances can
turn an innocent employer into a guilty one if the employee can prove retaliation.
6. Take a close look at all undesirable jobs. Make sure supervisors dont use them as
a weapon to punish complaining employees.
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
Page 9
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com Page 10
3. Tell the employee the real reason for the dismissal. Trying to sugarcoat a serious
problem can backfire later in court. Make sure the reason you state is fully supported by
the employees record. If you have done the job of progressive discipline properly, the
employee should know most of the facts already.
4. Be firm in your termination decision. Dont give the employee the impression the
decision may be reversed. If an employee tries to challenge the decision, let him or her
know that the termination is final.
5. Be prepared to answer questions. Few employees are fully prepared to be fired, and
may have questions regarding the reasons behind your decision.
6. Document. Complete a General Separation Notice (see page 12) and retain a copy
in the employees personnel file should any questions arise post-termination.
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com Page 11
Job Title:
Last
Working Hours:
AM
PM
AM
PM
Working Days:
Rate of Pay:
Overtime?
per
Yes
Union Involved?
OR
Annual Salary:
No
Yes
Voluntary Quit
No
Severance Pay:
Discharge
Lack of Work
List any disciplinary action(s) taken against the employee in the past two years.
Occurrence
Type of Discipline
Date Issued
Employees Comments:
Employees Signature:
Date:
Title:
Yes
No Reason:
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com Page 12
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com Page 13
Dept.: ________________
What would you have done differently if you had been the manager?
How would you rate your pay and benefits?
How would you rate the training you received?
How would you rate your overall working conditions?
What improvements to the job, department or company do you suggest?
Additional comments:
Date: ___________
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com Page 14
http://www.businessmanagementdaily.com/EffectivePerformanceReview
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/WorkplaceConflictResolution
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/MaternityLeaveLaws
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/OfficeOrganizer
Best-Practices Leadership: Team management tips and fun team-building
activities to boost team performance, collaboration and morale
Learn new team management tips and team-building activities to boost team performance, collaboration and morale.
Take our leadership assessment exercise to gauge your own performance as a team manager. See how businesses of all
sizes are getting creative with team-building icebreakers and activities. Fight off team complacency with 5 strategies
for making team-building exercises part of your daily routine.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/LeadershipTeamManagement
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/BackgroundCheckGuidelines
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/SalaryNegotiating101
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/FMLAIntermittentLeave
Overtime Labor Law: 6 compliance tips to avoid overtime lawsuits, wage-andhour Labor audits and FLSA exemption mistakes
Employers, beware: The Department of Labors Wage and Hour Division reports that wage-and-hour labor litigation
continues to increase exponentially. Federal class actions brought under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
outnumber all other types of private class actions in employment-related cases. Use this special report, Overtime Labor
Law: 6 compliance tips to avoid overtime lawsuits, wage-and-hour Labor audits and FLSA exemption mistakes, to
review your overtime pay policy and double-check your FLSA exempt employees status. Expecting a visit from a DOL
auditor? Get prepared by taking the self-audit at the end of this report.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/OvertimeLaborLaw
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/OfficeCommunicationToolkit
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/WorkplaceViolencePrevention
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/BusinessEtiquette101
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/EmployeeBenefitsProgram
The Case in Point Yearbook: Real-Life Employment Law Advice from Mindy
Chapmans Case in Point blog
Mindy Chapman, Esq., has been providing sound employment law advice in her Case in Point blog since 2007. In her
trademark entertaining style, she dissects an important employment law court ruling and provides essential
employment law advice via three "Lessons Learned." Topics include: ADA guidelines, age discrimination cases, sexual
harassment laws, EEOC cases, FMLA requirements and more.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/CIPYearbook
The Bully Boss Strikes Again! How to deal with bosses who make crazy
requests
And you thought your boss was unreasonable? Bet he never asked you to perform oral surgery or fill in for the bomb
squad. Talk about other duties as assigned! Even if your direct supervisor swamps you with petty tasks and doesnt
appreciate all you do, you can always manage up to make sure the bosss boss knows your worth. This report
includes practical advice on how to manage a toxic boss along with dozens of outrageous stories about bully bosses.
http://www.businessmanagementdaily.com/BullyBoss
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
http://www.businessmanagementdaily.com/MicrosoftEmailOutlook
17 Team Building Ideas: The team building kit for managers with team
building exercises, activities and games to build winning teams today!
With employees still reeling from workplace budget cuts, nows a great time for new team building ideas. No, you dont
need an expensive round of paintball to gain the benefits of team building exercises, but you do need to squeeze the
most out of them. This report provides teamwork examples, exercises and tips for leading winning teams. Go from
being a manager who oversees people to a leader who molds them into winning teams with these 17 team building
ideas.
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/TeamBuildingIdeas
www.businessmanagementdaily.com/TimeManagementTips
.
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com
www.BusinessManagementDaily.com