How To Select The Best Earthing System
How To Select The Best Earthing System
How To Select The Best Earthing System
Function,
2.
System size,
3.
4.
Neutral point connection to earth + the connection method of the electrical installations exposed
conductive parts.
And I explained the first two categories in this Article, showing that the Types of Earthing Systems according to its
Function can be divided to Six types as follows:
1.
Static grounding,
2.
Equipment grounding,
3.
System grounding,
4.
Lightning grounding,
5.
6.
And the Types of Earthing Systems according To Its Size can be divided to Two types as follows:
1.
simple,
2.
complex.
Also, In Article " Types of Earthing System Part Two ", I explained the Types of Earthing Systems according To Neutral
point connection to earth, which were:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Resistance earthing,
5.
Reactance earthing,
6.
And the Types of Earthing Systems according To Neutral point connection to earth + the connection method of the
electrical installations exposed conductive parts, which were:
1.
2.
3.
TNC (If the N and PE neutral conductors are one and the same (PEN))
4.
5.
Today I will explain How to select the best earthing system for a new construction from the above types as follows.
Country Regulations,
Country development,
Type of building,
4.
5.
6.
7.
1- Country regulations
The regulations or standards applied in the country in some cases impose
certain types of earthing system arrangements (SEA).
The most common systems in most countries are TT and TN; a few
countries, in particular Norway, use the IT system.
The table in below figure#1 lists some examples for LV earting systems
for public distribution (LV consumers) for different countries. This table shows
that Anglo-Saxon countries mainly use the TN-C, whereas the TT is used in the
rest of the world.
2- Country development
The degree of development of the country should also be taken into
consideration, as should be national practices, climate, etc.
in private installations.
3- Type of building
1- In a certain number of countries, for some buildings or parts of a building,
the choice is laid down by legislations or standards, e.g. for hospitals, schools,
navy, worksites, mines, etc. In other cases, certain earthing systems are strictly
prohibited, for example the TN-C in premises with explosion risks.
2- The required level of dependability should determine which earthing system
is chosen for a specific building type.
Dependability means that electrical power should thus always be available and
be completely risk-free, i.e. out of sight, out of mind. The elements making
up installation dependability:
Safety;
Availability;
Reliability;
Maintainability,
Proper operation of low current communicating systems
Note:
In terms of the protection of persons, the three system earthing arrangements
(SEA) are equivalent if all installation and operating rules are correctly
followed. Consequently, selection does not depend on safety criteria.
The particular characteristics of the network and the loads will affect the
selection of earthing system arrangements as in below table in figure#3.
If the owner effectively has a choice, the decision on the SEA is taken
following discussions with the network designer (design office,
contractor), The discussions must cover:
1.
First of all, the operating requirements (the required level of
continuity of service) and the operating conditions (maintenance
ensured by electrical personnel or not, inhouse personnel or
outsourced, etc.)
2.
Secondly, the particular characteristics of the network and the
loads as infig.3.
6- Costs
The TN-S is the least costly to install, for example if the neutral is
neither protected nor switched. But be warned: the cost of curative
maintenance can be high.
Note:
In terms of complete cost over 10 to 20 years, all three earthing systems are
equivalent.
7-Complexity Of Design
2- Fire hazard
3- Safety
4- Availability
5- Maintenability
Fault tracking is fast in TN (thanks to the SCPD) but repair time is often
long.
Conversely, in IT, tracking of the first fault may be more difficult, but
repairs are quicker and less costly.
6- Reliability
The protection devices used are reliable, but reliability of the installation and
loads may be affected:
a- In TN-C by the fact that the PEN, not protected, may be damaged by
harmonic currents;
b- In TN-C and TN-S:
c- In IT, on a double fault, the risks inherent in TN described above also exist.
However if tracking and elimination of the 1st fault are rapid, installation
reliability is excellent.
d- in TT, by disruptive breakdown by return of the loads due to a fault in the
HV/LV transformers. However the likelihood of this fault occurring is small and
preventive solutions are available, e.g. use of surge arresters between one of
the live conductors and the load earth connection.
7- Disturbance
Step#4: Finally allow for the special features of network and loads as follows:
Very long network or, even more important, leakage current: Prefer the
TN-S,
Use of replacement or standby power supplies: Prefer the TT,
Loads with low natural insulation (furnaces) or with large HF filter (large
computers): Prefer the TN-S,
However, the prime components and accessories of an earth well will be:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Earth Rod,
Earth Plate,
Earthing Clamp,
Earthing Rod Coupling,
Earthing Rod Tip,
Earthing Rod Driving Head with driving sleeve,
Earth Access Pit,
Earth Pit Cover,
Earth Enhancement Materials.
1.
2.
3.
Notes:
Notes:
During the hammering or driving of rod into the ground, and to
protect the earth rod against impact of hammering, a driving head is
screwed onto the top of the rod.
For easy and convenient driving of the earth rod into the ground an
earth rod tip with sharp point is screwed to the first rod.
Earth rods are used in installation of plain earthing well where, based
Also, UL467-9.2.2 states that the stainless steel jacket shall not be
less than 0.015 inches thick at any point.
Usually in Europe and Middle East, Earthing rod and the associated
accessories (coupling, tip and head) are made of both steel and copper. A
steel core, coated with pure copper to the appropriate thickness, provides
the sufficient rigidity for the earthing rod to help driving it straightly into
the ground without any harm and bending. The copper coating of the earth
rod provides the sufficient conductivity for the earthing system.
As per UL467- 9.2.1, the solid rod electrode shall have a diameter not
less than inch thick.
In Europe and middle east, The range of diameter for the earth rods
vary from 13 mm to 25mm (13mm,16mm, 20mm, 25mm).
b- Length:
Different lengths of earthing rods are used in design and installation of earth
wells, The standard lengths are:
In North America: 2, 3, 5, 8 and 10 feets.
Copper ground plates are used instead or with the ground rods in the following
situations:
For securing good electrical connections with the ground plate, ground plate
use:
1.
One cable connector,
2.
Two dual cable connectors,
3.
18 or 24 inches (depending on the plate size) copper conductor
exothermically welded to the plate cable connectors
normally 75 sq-mm.
1.
2.
Mechanical Clamps,
Exothermic Welding Clamping.
1- Mechanical Clamps:
The mechanical earhing clamp may come with one bolt or two bolts, the
two bolts give more good electrical connection with the earh rod.
Mechanical Earthing clamps and associated bolts nuts, washers, etc. are
There are three types of rod couplers according to the used type of
ground rods as follows:
1.
Unthreaded Coupler for Non- sectional ground rods,
2.
Threaded Coupler for sectional ground rods externally threaded,
3.
Coupling Dowel for sectional ground rods internally threaded.
The coupling material is essentially the same as the material for the
earth rod with respect to the rigidity and the required conductivity.
Earth rod coupling shall have the same diameter of the earth rod.
The earth rod tip is used for easy and convenient driving of the earth
rod into the ground because it secures a sharp head for the first rod driven
into ground.
The earth rod tip material is not necessarily the same as the earth
rod itself, as only a rigid quality is essentially required for the tip other than
conductivity. Therefore the earth rod tip is primarily made of steel with
slight coating of the copper for conductivity purpose as well as protection
against corrosion reasons.
Earth rod tip shall have the same diameter of the earth rod.
The driving head material is not necessarily the same as the earth rod
itself, as only a rigid and robust quality is essentially required for the driving
head to withstand the impact of hammerings. Driving head is practically
discarded when the earth rods are all driven and installed in the ground.
B- According to Material
Earth pits side walls are constructed of insulating material to appropriately
isolate the earth rods top connection from the surrounding soil and protect it
Note:
the ASTM specifications for Earth Pit Covers are as in the below image.
Even under ideal circumstances, soil structure can vary and make it
difficult to achieve uniform, low levels of resistivity across a wide area. Under
almost all soil conditions, the use of a ground enhancement material will
improve grounding effectiveness. Some are permanent and require no
maintenance.
As a backfill when you have to drill because the ground is too hard to
drive, or where ground rods cannot be driven, when used as a backfill for earth
electrodes, soil conditioning agents effectively act to increase the electrodes
surface area thus lowering its resistance to earth.
The above image clearly shows, GEM has a resistivity factor more than 20 times
lower than bentonite clay.
Note:
4- GEM Installation
GEM is supplied in easy-to-handle bags for one-man installation. GEM can be
installed dry or wet (recommended). GEM quickly absorbs moisture from the
soil when used dry, to reach its maximum conductivity in days. To accelerate
curing time, water can be added after GEM is installed, or it can be pre-mixed
with water.
A- Trench Installation
1.
Dig a trench at least 4 inches wide x 30 inches deep or below the
frost line, whichever is deeper. Spread out enough GEM to uniformly
1.
Auger a 3 inch or larger diameter hole to a depth of 6 inches less
than the length of the ground rod.
2.
Place ground rod into augered hole and drive one foot (if possible)
into bottom of the hole. The top of the ground rod will be approximately
6 inches below grade. At this time, make any connections to ground rod
using CADWELD connections.
3.
Pour the appropriate amount of GEM around the ground rod. To
ensure the GEM material completely fills the hole, tamp around the
ground rod with a pole.
4.
Fill remainder of augered hole with soil removed during augering.
For various augered-hole diameters and depths, see the below table.
Notes:
If premixing GEM into a slurry form, use a standard cement mixer or
hard-mix in a mixing box, wheelbarrow, etc. Use 1-1/2 to 2 gallons of clean
water per bag of GEM.
moisture out of the atmosphere. This saline solution leaches out of the bottom
of the rod, which gradually lowers resistivity of the surrounding soil, forming
"electrolytic roots" over time.
There are two basic styles, vertical and horizontal (L-shaped) as in above
image. Enhanced Ground Rod includes a variety of lengths, sectionals and
different kits to meet many specific requirements.
Interconnecting conductors used for the grid are in the following forms:
1- Cable and wire system
The available conductors may be soft-drawn (copper wire that has been heat
treated) or hard-drawn (copper wire that has not been annealed after
drawing), the available grounding conductors are in the following forms:
1.1 Stranded Copper Conductors:
Note:
There are other types of grid conductors used especially for lightning
protection system and will be explained later in lightning protection system
Articles.
Second: Selection criteria for the best grounding conductor for certain case:
There are two basic criteria for grounding conductor selection:
1- Physical Characteristics
The physical characteristics of the conductor must be of a robust nature,
sufficient for the environment as follows:
The most common ground conductor is a soft drawn, stranded copper
conductor which used for direct buried grid in dry and noncorrosive grounds.
Flat copper strip / tape is also popular because it offers a large surface
area and usually used for direct buried grid in dry and non-corrosive grounds
(soils).
Single core stranded copper conductor with PVC sheath: for direct buried
grid in wet or corrosive grounds.
Note:
When site conditions are corrosive towards copper (eg. sulphurous soil), a
tinned copper conductor is often the first choice.
2- Maximum Fault Current
The cross sectional area of the conductor must be of sufficient size, so
that it shall successfully conduct the maximum fault (surge) current for a
period, which allows the operation of protection equipment (or the dissipation
of this energy).
The outgoing earthing cables, connected to the earth bus in one end,
shall be connected to the corresponding equipment on the other end.
All the connections of the main incoming and outgoing earth cables shall
1.
Cable lugs the compression type and zink coating, using bolts,
nuts, flat washers and spring washers for well-tight connections,
2.
Exothermic Welding process.
1.
Cable lugs the compression type and zink coating, using bolts,
nuts, flat washers and spring washers for well-tight connections,
2.
Exothermic Welding process.
Earthing wires (cables) sizing will be explained later in the Articles for
grounding system design calculations.