Toolbox Last Version
Toolbox Last Version
Toolbox Last Version
Technical Assistance
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Page 1 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Page 2 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
1) TIP CLEARANCE
Tip Clearances are critical to the efficiency of a fan system. If there is too much distance
at the tip of the blade, this will cause air recirculation problems. This recirculation will
directly affect the duty exchanged by the air cooler due to a loss in airflow going through
the tube bundle.
Too big of a tip clearance can lead to a loss of 5% to 10% in airflow (depending on how
bad the tip clearance is to start with).
Tip Clearance
Fan diameter
Tip Clearance
Meters
Feet
Minimum
Maximum
1 and 3
3 and 9
6 mm (1/4 inch)
13 mm (1/2 inch)
> 9 and 11
6 mm (1/4 inch)
16 mm (5/8 inch)
> 3.5
> 11
6 mm (1/4 inch)
19 mm (3/4 inch)
Page 3 sur 36
Technical Assistance
03-2001 rv. : 0
Aim : If properly installed, a tip seal will re-create a tip clearance in line with API 661 (3/8"
3/4") regardless of fan ring irregularities, such as ovalness or eccentricity.
Page 4 sur 36
Cost : Approximately US$350 per tip seal (non installed) and US$ 200 per tip seal roller
Technical Assistance
03-2001 rv. : 0
Page 5 sur 36
TIP CLEARANCE
Effect of tip clearance on fan efficiency for different sizes of fans
Reference : AIRPOWER HUDSON Products Corporation
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
TIP CLEARANCE
Tip Seal: Installation procedure
Step 1
Step 3
Step 2 -
Page 6 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
2) AIR RECIRCULATION AT THE CENTRE OF THE FAN
Page 7 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
The value of the Seal Disk (made out of FRP) lies in that it bounces
the hot air back up into the airflow and helps to prevent air
recirculation at the centre of the fan.
Therefore, the Seal Disk will increase the amount of air going
through the bundle.
Page 8 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
3) SETTING OF PITCH ANGLE
Page 9 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
BLADE PITCH ANGLE SETTING
The following formulas illustrate the relationship between blade pitch angle variations and other variables. These formulas are valuable for
blade pitch variations of 5 :
absorbed power at fan:
tan 2
tan 2 3
Ps
2
3
tan 2
Page 10 sur 36
Technical Assistance
2/3
03-2001 rv. : 0
To maximise the air flow of a fan, it is important to set the correct pitch angle.
In practice, this setting is adjust to verify that the increasing in static pressure
(manometric measurement) increases like the angles tangent :
2/3
Ps
tan( 1 + )
= (1.06 )
Ps1
tan 1
If the static pressure does not increase as much as calculated, it is because the fan is in stall
conditions.
It is important to never increase the intensity of the electrical engine over the nominal
conditions.
Ps + 18%
Theoretical increasing in
electrical engine intensity
I + 28%
Ps + 14 %
The variations of intensity and static pressure for an increasing of 2 of blades angles
could be estimated as following.
Started pitch
angle
10 ( 20 %)
I + 21 %
Ps + 11 %
15 ( 13 %)
I + 18 %
Page 12 sur 36
20 ( 10 %)
Technical Assistance
03-2001 rv. : 0
The Fan stall phenomenon is a lot like a cavitating pump. At fan stall, the boundary layer
of air at the leading edge is changed from laminar to turbulent flow. The effect of a fan in
stall is a horsepower increase but the net fan work actually decreases.
Air
This phenomenon can often be seen on air coolers affected by an increase in static pressure as
a result of external fouling; a low RPM; or in case the blade pitch angle is too high. In practice
however, it is usually a combination of the three scenarios described above.
Air
Air
high blade pitch angle setting (compared to supplier recommended pitch angle)
fouled finned tube bundle
Air
In the field, A fan suspected of being in stall will show the following characteristics :
-
A simple remedy to cure the problem is to decrease the blade pitch angle. If decreasing the
pitch angle does not result in the static pressure behaving according to the following rule (i.e. it
stays constant), this demonstrates that the fan was in stall:
2
3
tan
2
Ps2 = PS 1 * (1.06)3 *
tan 1
Page 13 sur 36
Please note that a fan in stall not only decreases the airflow therefore duty - it can also lead to
vibration problems.
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Fan Blade Pitch adjustment to avoid Stall
Air flow
Air flow
Air flow
Air flow
As blade pitch is increased, air flow may stall and start to reverse. This may be evidenced using smoke or filament strips.
Air flow
Air flow
Air flow
Air flow
Page 14 sur 36
Technical Assistance
03-2001 rv. : 0
27
Pitch angle
(in degrees)
100
73
Measured airflow
(m3/s)
0.9
0.9
Static pressure
(mm H2O)
44
63
Power measured
at substation
(kW)
Fan in stall
Case of fan in stall encountered at the Flanders Refinery on an A-frame condenser of the
steam turbine carrying the cracked gas compressor of the FCC
20
Blade tip
Hub
A decrease of 7 in blade pitch angle generated an increase in airflow of 35% with an absorbed
power decrease of 30%. Please note that the static pressure has remained constant
Hub
Reversed airflow
on a large portion
of the blade
Blade tip
Page 15 sur 36
Another solution to solve the stall problem could be to decrease the pitch angle and increase
the RPM of the fan (by replacing the existing gearbox). This solution has the advantage that
the engine can be fully loaded (due to the increase in RPM), thereby increasing the airflow.
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
4) Fan blade positioning inside fan ring
An incorrect positioning inside the fan ring can considerably affect static fan efficiency due to air recirculation at the tip of the blade.
Wrong positioning
Correct positoning
Page 16 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
5) EXTERNAL CLEANING OF TUBE BUNDLE
EXAMPLE OF HEAVILY
FOULED TUBE BUNDLE DUE
TO EXCESSIVE SCALING
External cleaning of tube bundle must be carried out regularly, especially on units considered as critical. These cleaning projects
must be scheduled before the hot seasons.
Page 17 sur 36
Technical Assistance
03-2001 rv. : 0
Page 18 sur 36
This method basically unsticks deposits that are loosely attached to the surface of
the tube bundle. Although this method is very easy to use, it is also only seldom
used in our refineries.
03-2001 rv. : 0
Start cleaning the tubes of the lower layers engines on (only if the engines are
located above the bundle).
Proceed by cleaning the tubes of the upper layers engines off.
Finish the job by cleaning the tubes of the lower layers engines off.
Technical Assistance
Exact same procedure as in the case of the Air Cooled Heat Exchanger with
induced draft.
Extra precaution: stop the engines and protect these, together with the belts.
Note :
Page 19 sur 36
Before the upper layers of the tube bundles are cleaned, protection
will be secured (this to avoid crushing the fins). This type of
procedure is a standard maintained for all maintenance operations in
particular on Air Cooled Heat Exchangers with induced draft.
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
CLEANING OF THE BUNDLE
CASE HISTORY
Water wash procedure of the airside of fin fan air coolers
RN - Reforming unit (Cr6) - E13
(2)
Water wash efficiency - Airflow measurements and Duty
improvement
BEFORE
water wash
AFTER
water wash
150 000
195 000
3.8
4.2
(1)
Forced draft
INCREASE OF 30 % of airflow
INCREASE OF 10% of duty
Overall cost estimation of the water wash operation
300 US$ / fan
Page 20 sur 36
Technical Assistance
03-2001 rv. : 0
The efficiency of a fan depends on the shape of the blade (airfoil). In effect, a highly efficient fan
requires a minimum of power for a maximum volume of airflow.
CFM * Ps
The power required by a fan (BHP) for a given amount of airflow (CFM) and static pressure (P
through the bundle) is inversely proportional to the efficiency of the fan.
BHP
statique
(%)
43 %
static
80
m3/s
73
Airflow
34
Energy
consumption
kW
35
22
mm H2O
19
static Pressure
58 %
A blade replacement test was performed at the Normandy Refinery on the unit called huiles 3
(E807-A3). Aluminium blades were replaced with synthetic resin blades. Airflow measurements
were performed before and after the replacement of blades.
Aluminium
Blades
Synthetic resin
Blades
HUDSON
Using more efficient fan blades generated an airflow increase of 10% while simultaneously
using the same amount of electricity.
Page 21 sur 36
Using more efficient fan blades increases the volume of airflow going through a tube
bundle - thus the duty exchanged by the cooler - utilising the same electrical engine for
the powering of the fan (thus implying a reduction in costs). A reduction in power can
occasionally be observed, and in some cases it is possible to augment the level of speed
(transmission change), and thus the airflow.
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
s
p
e
e
d
Blade efficiency
(m/s)
Seal disk
Blade Tip
Hub
Page 23 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
These modifications had taken four nights of work - cost - 250kFF installed.
AIR SIDE IMPROVEMENT :
Before
Number of blades
Rotation speed (RPM)
Static pressure
Electrical (KW)
Static efficiency
Average Air Flowrate
6
200
7.2 mmH20
10 (design = 15)
51%
63 m3/s
After
(HUDSON blades)
4
278
9.2 mmH20
14
58%
80m3/s
=> Gain of air flowrate of 30 % (15% due to increase of electrical consumption and 15% due to blades efficiency, belts,....)
PROCESS SIDE IMPROVEMENT :
Gain of 4% on the total overhead duty (air condensers and trim cooler). In consequence, increase of an average of 15T/j of
production of alkylate due to these modifications. Pay out time, for 3 months summer and 80$/T alkylate, is approximately POT 2.5
months.
Page 24 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Blade efficiency
Inlet bell +
Tip seal
Seal disk
Hub
Blade Tip
Page 25 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
7) EFFICIENCY OF BELTS
The following list provides an overview of the type of belts most frequently used by refineries:
- V-belt
- HTD belts
- Banded V-belt (HUTCHINSON POLY V)
Efficiency varies depending on the type of belt and on the craftsmanship of its installation. For instance, HTD belts are widely recognised,
particularly as to their transmission efficiency.
We have observed on site that the slipping of belts can reduce the rotation speed of a fan by 10%, thus a 10% reduction in airflow.
TYPE OF BELTS
USE IN REFINERIES
INTRINSIC
EFFICIENCY
DISADVANTAGE(S)
V-Belts
WIDELY USED
AVERAGE 80%
HTD Belts
Banded V-Belts
GOOD 98%
Page 26 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
EFFICIENCY OF BELTS
DIFFERENT TYPES OF BELTS
V-Belts
HTD-Belts
Banded Belts
Page 27 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
EFFICIENCY OF BELTS
EXAMPLE OF THE INSTALLATION OF AN HTD-BELT
CORRECT INSTALLATION
INCORRECT INSTALLATION
BELT IS FITTED TOO
TIGHTLY
INCORRECT INSTALLATION
BELT IS FITTED TOO
LOOSELY
Page 28 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Air recirculation
Air Flow
without inlet bell
Air Flow
with inlet bell
In the case of a straight air entry, turbulences emerge as a result of the brutality with which air enters the fan ring
(vena contracta ). The effective surface for air is reduced substantially.
Therefore, a smoother shape of the fans entrance will decrease the effect in question
Page 29 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Example:
For a fan with a diameter of 10 producing an airflow of 60m3/s under a static pressure of 13mmH2O, a straight entry will
generate, approximately, a P of 2mmH2O. Concretely, the implication is that the useable potential of the static pressure
is factually only utilised by as much as 11 mmH2O, instead of the 13 mmH2O that could have been achieved had the
appropriate Inlet Bell been installed.
The loss incurred amounts to a 15% decrease in static pressure, which itself translates into a 7% loss in airflow
through the bundle.
Page 30 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
INLET BELL
Page 31 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Page 32 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
INCREASE IN
AIRFLOW
+10 to +15%
+ 5%
+ 5 to + 20%
+ 10 to + 20%
+ 5 to + 15%
+10 to 30%
+ 5 to +10%
AUDIT RESULTS
RN HUILES 3
RF FCC/HDT/CDU
RP DEPROPANIZER
RP - ALKYLATION
RP - ALKYLATION
RN HUILES 3
RF FCC/HDT/CDU
RF FCC
RN REFORMER
RF FPP
RN FCC
RP - VDU
RN HUILES 3
RP - ALKYLATION
RP DGO3
RP - FPP
RP - ALKYLATION
+ 5%
Page 33 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Annex 1
Comparison between PUMPS and FANS
PUMP
FAN
A pump is a piece of equipment that transmits energy to a non- A fan is a piece of equipment that transmits energy to air via
compressible fluid via the intermediary of one or more wheels. the intermediary of blades.
When expressed in inches of water, reference is made to the When expressed in inches of water, the energy is referred to
elevation (H).
as the static pressure (Ps).
The manufacturer will provide a number of characteristic
curves. One such curve provides the elevation (H) for a given
pump running at a given speed taking the flow volume (Q) into
account.
The power absorbed by the pump is illustrated using the The power absorbed by the fan is illustrated using the
following formula : Parbre Q * H * d *
pompe
vent .
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Inefficient configuration
Improved configuration
Undersized
Seal disk
Inlet bell
Seal disk
Honey comb tip seal
New blades
Air leakage
air seal
Page 35 sur 36
03-2001 rv. : 0
Toolbox
Appendix 3
AIR COOLERS - Influence of speed rotation and blade angle
on a clean system
Induced draft
Forced draft
Ps
Ps
CFM
CFM
+ 5% of air flowrate
Increase of 11% of the static pressure
Increase of 17% of the horse power of the fan
+ 1.5% of duty
Page 36 sur 36