Attachment and Emotional Resilience
Attachment and Emotional Resilience
Attachment and Emotional Resilience
Chapter 1
ATTACHMENT
AND EMOTIONAL RESILIENCE
RESILIENCE
The ability of a child or adult to mentally represent himself and others without
distortion is thought to be a major factor in understanding the nature of
resilience. Therefore, a positive view of the self can help the individual to develop
a range of personal strengths to cope with lifes adversities, including the trauma
associated with death in the family.
Resilience is not just a matter of constitutional strength or a robust temperament,
it is also a product of how people perceive, appraise, approach and tackle
stresses and challenges.
Factors associated with resilience are thought to include secure attachments to
significant others, absence of early loss and trauma, high self-esteem and social
empathy, and an easy temperament. (Fonagy in Howe, 1994) Thus trauma and
maltreatment that disturbs a childs ability to represent and understand his own
and others emotions and behaviours, reduces his ability to make sense and cope
with distress, conflict and social failure. However, if a maltreated or a bereft child
can relate to a responsive figure outside of the traumatic situation, he or she
might be able to develop the capacity to manage relationships mentally with
increased accuracy and understanding, and without distortion, self blame and
negative self image.
Therefore, it is important for any person that is in a helping role with both
children and adults who are grieving and trying to come to terms with drastically
changing personal circumstances, to take into consideration the childs
experiences and model of attachment to his significant others. Understanding the
situation for members of the childs family, who are also grieving, is equally
important, as a better understanding of how the family as a whole relates to each
other will not only increase the likelihood of forming a positive working alliance
between helper, child and family, but also give the helper some information to
assist the healing process. At this time, the helper may need to temporarily
serve as the responsive adult figure outside of the home environment, and to a
child, the helping relationship may be the only one that is emotionally safe and
devoted to his needs.
ATTACHMENT
Attachment behaviours in humans, as indeed in lower forms of animal life, ensure
survival of the species. Throughout an individuals lifetime, attachments provide
connections to others, an aid in the quest for identity, they influence the nature
of future relationships, and it is widely accepted that they change in focus and
importance across the life cycle. The childs attachments in early years are
usually focused towards the parent figure who provides emotional and physical
security. These attachments shift towards peer group in adolescence, and
towards partners, and eventually towards children of their own in adulthood.
Therefore, during the life cycle, loss of a loved one may have a different effect
upon individual members of the family, and styles of grieving and methods of
coping may vary accordingly. The worker, who has some understanding of the
nature and process of how attachments develop, is in a better position to form
therapeutic relationships with grieving children and families.
QUALITY OF ATTACHMENTS
Positive attachments help the child to attain his full intellectual potential, think
and perceive in a logical manner, develop social emotions and conscience, and
begin to trust others as a result of this. Quality relationships help children to
become self reliant, develop self worth, better cope with frustration, envy and
jealousy, and overcome common fears and worries. A child, who is well attached
to one care giver, can more easily develop attachments to others, such as
siblings, extended family and eventually to friends.
ATTACHMENT BEHAVIOUR AND THE ATTACHMENT SYSTEM
Attachment behaviour is any behaviour designed to get children into a close and
protective relationship with their attachment figure when they experience anxiety.
This attachment system is an inbuilt mechanism for seeking proximity to a
caregiver for protection, food and social interaction. It provides opportunities for
learning about relationships and the environment.
Three main attachment
behaviours in infants are: signalling, such as cooing, laughing and smiling;
aversive behaviours such as distressed crying; and making a direct approach
towards caregivers.
Anxiety activates the attachment system, which increases attachment behaviour.
Therefore, behaviours and emotions associated with attachment are clearly seen
in situations of anxiety and distress.
Anxiety invoking factors come from three main sources:
The child
The environment
The attachment figure
CHILD EXPRESSES
NEED
CHILD RELAXES,
TRUST DEVELOPS
CHILD
PROTESTS
ADULT RESPONDS,
SOOTHES, MAKES EYE
CONTACT, SATISFIES
NEED
CHILD RESPONDS
POSITIVELY
POSITIVE CLAIMING
Claiming is a way of beginning the process of attaching the baby to the family of
origin. The child is claimed as special by the parent or parents, and a detailed
examination at birth of their unique features reinforces the ownership of the
child. It is the physical similarities (e.g. ears, nose, eyes etc) to the family of
origin that add to the feelings of entitlement to become part of the family.
However, claiming behaviours can be both positive and negative and have
implications for the way the child is perceived or perceives himself in the future.
The child may be likened to a family member who is disliked or in conflict with
others, or he may be associated with a parent whom the extended family dislikes.
This can also happen if the child has a disability, and he can be disclaimed as a
result.
DISTURBED ATTACHMENT CYCLE
This cycle, illustrated below, does not relieve the childs anxiety or satisfy the
childs emotional needs. It can lead to frustration and eventually despair. This
model of the external world becomes internalised. In other words, negative
expectations of what adults have to offer are developed in the childs internal
world, influencing the childs Internal Working Model.
PROTESTS,
SIGNALS FOR HELP
OR CRIES
CHILD PROTESTS
EVEN LOUDER
MODELS OF ATTACHMENT
These have been classified as:
Secure
Insecure Avoidant
Insecure Ambivalent
Insecure Anxious
Disorganised
Unattached
do not particularly care whether or not they have relationships. They do not
enjoy being with others because they do not feel safe. Such people tend to be
overly independent and become enraged or highly anxious when forced to rely on
others for help. Their belief is that nobody can make them do anything they do
not want to do, and they delight in showing others this.
They are often sullen and openly oppositional, but primarily in a passiveaggressive way. Such behaviour is characterised by frequently forgetting to do
things, being persistently late and breaking things accidentally. They attempt to
avoid all feelings, but when they cannot ignore how they feel, they almost always
experience negative emotions such as anger, frustration, and boredom. Taking
such children on treats can result in them being unable to enjoy themselves.
INTERNAL WORKING MODEL OF AMBIVALENT ATTACHMENT
These children have usually been subjected to widely differing responses by
parent figures, from overly affectionate to angry and neglectful. As adults they
often feel unloved and ineffective, and they have a strong need for love, attention
and approval. They have positive expectations, but low satisfaction, and see
others as unavailable, unreliable and disinterested.
They can be quite
hyperactive and sometimes use coercive behaviours to control others, for
example by making them feel guilty.
Although they have the ability to allow some closeness with others, they tend to
quickly sabotage this. The relationships they do form tend to be short-lived
because they easily feel rejected and often push people away first to avoid facing
rejection. Their charming behaviour can change quickly for no apparent reason
into an excessive expression of anger, and destruction. Most of their behaviour
has a high degree of inconsistency about it, and this often prevents their own
children, when they are infants, from perceiving them as reliable and predictable.
Hence the cycle repeats itself in the next generation.
INTERNAL WORKING MODEL OF INSECURE ANXIOUS ATTACHMENT
This working model sometimes develops from the belief that the attachment
figure is available, but only with certain conditions, and that she/he is likely to
withdraw that comfort and support if the child no longer meets those conditions
such as being well behaved or co-operative.
These children and adults tend to be overly clingy and become excessively upset
when separated from their mothers or significant others. In children this
clinginess differs from what is seen as age appropriate dependence on the adult
caregiver.
They are able to make friends, but usually demand attention and unconditional
acceptance from others, in a clingy manner. In their teens these young people
use sex to hang onto boyfriends/girlfriends, or they buy gifts to keep friends.
These people usually allow others to physically or emotionally hold them and they
are seldom openly defiant. However, they have a tendency to switch mood and
become overtly destructive when their safety is threatened.
10
11
The helper can use Attachment Theory to promote a positive relationship with the
child when working with them individually. Actively listening to the child and
responding to them promptly will be more likely to enhance the therapeutic
relationship. This will begin to help the child experience a positive model of
communication. It is very important that the helper has the ability to react
consistently to the child and familys requests or demands, thereby helping them
all to predict how the support will be delivered.
In some cases, where the attachment style of the family is less helpful, it may
take all the helpers skill not to react in a similar way to the family model. Such
feelings from the family, which are directed towards the helper, are a usual part
of this very challenging work, and therefore should be expected as part of the
role. These strong feelings could be a high degree of dependence or neediness, as
well as withdrawal or hostility. What is important in the work is that these
feelings, which are transferred to the helper, should not result in the helper
believing that they must take all the responsibility for the child or familys
welfare. Of course, the first consideration is the protection of the child, but so
long as the child is safe, helping the family to retain their independence, once the
shock has subsided, will be the best course of action for their recovery.
The worker must also remember that the childs negative and sometimes hostile
feelings are most likely to be as a result of their situation, and should not be
taken personally. The response to negative outbursts or rejection from the child
needs to be delivered with empathy, and not reflect the mood of the child. By
remaining constant in their interaction with that child, the worker can help the
child to feel emotional safety in the therapeutic relationship. This does not mean
that children can be exempt from the normal boundaries set by appropriate
parents. Rather these boundaries need to be established in a firm but
compassionate way. Remember that undue criticism may well be perceived by
such children as persecutory, and will reduce the chance of a positive outcome.
12
13