3.4.1.impact Study Agri Gold Loan - May 2009
3.4.1.impact Study Agri Gold Loan - May 2009
3.4.1.impact Study Agri Gold Loan - May 2009
By
N.D.S.V.Nageswara Rao
Chief Manager (Research)
STATE BANK INSTITUTE OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT
HYDERABAD
MAY 2009
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Agri Gold Loan is the traditional safest advance with very low rate of
NPAs.
N.D.S.V.Nageswara Rao
Chief Manager (Research)
Hyderabad,
18th May 2009
INDEX
Executive Summary
Introduction
Objectives
Methodology
11
13
Availability of potential
17
Competitors moves
19
Conclusion
21
N.D.S.V.Nageswara Rao
Chief Manager (Research)
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Gold Loan was one of the agriculture loans, most popular in Hyderabad and
Chennai Circles.
Circles, Corporate Centre revisited the scheme and simplified the scheme in
June 2007. On a suggestion from Corporate Centre, the Institute conducted
impact study on how the simplified process helped in garnering more business.
Circle-wise performance indicated that Chennai Circle followed by Hyderabad
Circle topped the list with higher outstandings.
position whereas Bangalore Circle came at a distant fourth position. All other
Circles could not improve the performance even after simplification of the
scheme.
Further analysis brought out the fact that the growth in Chennai Circle peaked
up after June06 (well before the introduction of the simplified scheme) and
continued at the same tempo upto Mar08. However, the downfall till Sep08 and
a marginal growth thereafter indicated a disturbing trend.
In respect of
Hyderabad Circle the growth curve had reached a plateau and had not peaked
up even after the simplification process.
portfolio till June07 with a very small growth percentage, had peaked its
performance and there was no looking back after that. It was understood that the
campaigns launched by the Circle coupled with simplification of processes,
helped in this achievement.
The study also discussed about the campaigns launched by various Circles and
the views expressed by operating functionaries through SBIRDs Discussion
Forum on State Bank Times.
The study also had a look on the way various finance companies are poaching
the customers and the availability of vast potential for financing under Gold Loan
scheme.
Circles, Corporate Centre revisited the scheme and simplified the scheme in
June 2007. SBIRD was also involved in this process and provided useful inputs
in the simplification of the scheme.
Later on, while approving the Annual Action Plan of the Institute for the year
2007-08, Corporate Centre suggested an impact study to be conducted on the
simplified Gold Loan scheme. It was understood that the objective was how the
simplified process helped in garnering more business.
As the simplified scheme was circulated only after June 2007, it was decided that
the impact study to be conducted only after a period of one year, to have
sufficient data to analyze. Now that the data of business under the scheme is
available for more than one year (Sept 2007 to Dec 2008), the study was taken
up.
The business under Agricultural Gold Loan at whole bank level over the years
was as under :
As on
Mar 2005
Mar 2006
Mar 2007
Mar 2008
Dec 2008
503
1247
2413
3275
3376
Business Level
(Rs. in crores)
The growth percentage during 2005-06 and 2006-07 was on high trajectory,
whereas during 2007-08 it looked a bit low.
individual Circles indicated that some Circles had sizeably increased the Gold
Loan portfolio.
1
OBJECTIVES
The objectives of this study were as under :
i. Compare the growth position in Gold Loans vis--vis total Agri Loans for the
last 3 years
ii. Compare the growth position in Gold Loans before and after introduction of
the simplified Gold Loan Scheme
iii. Identify the Circles / Modules where there was high growth after the
implementation of simplified scheme
iv. Bring out the success stories / campaigns of various Circles and provide
suggestions for success in other Circles.
METHODOLOGY
i.
The data available in MIS ONLINE on State Bank Times was used for
analysis.
ii.
Interactions with the operating functionaries for their feedback on their growth
in Agri Gold Loan portfolio.
iii. Ideas generated in the discussion on Agri Gold Loans in the discussion
forum hosted on State Bank Times by the Institute.
Dec 2005
June 2007
Dec 2008
1150.98
2537.59
3375.72
24564.09
36921.77
52314.74
The growth in Agri Advances during Dec05 to June07 was 50%, whereas the
growth in Agri Gold Loans during the same period was 120%. However, the
growth in Agri Advances during June07 to Dec08 was 42% and the growth in
Agri Gold Loans during the same period was only 33%. This indicated that the
growth percentage in Agri Gold Loans could not be maintained in the second half
of the period under review.
3
Coming to the Circle-wise performance in Agri Gold Loans during the period
under review (ie., Dec05 to Dec08) indicated as under :
Rs.Crores
Circle
Dec' 05
June' 07
Dec' 08
Ahmedabad
0.42
1.16
33.03
Bangalore
9.28
18.38
42.07
Bengal
2.77
4.74
16.45
Bhopal
0.38
0.52
0.76
Bhubaneswar
9.70
12.79
12.59
Chandigarh
0.79
1.40
5.84
570.31
1733.12
1958.11
0.10
0.44
0.86
509.10
665.29
1018.02
46.49
75.57
282.91
Lucknow
0.16
0.27
0.37
Mumbai
1.45
1.46
3.05
--
0.06
1.22
0.03
0.17
0.44
Chennai
Delhi
Hyderabad
Kerala
North east
Patna
(Source : MIS ONLINE)
12.79
1.4
0.42
9.28
2.77
0.38
9.7
0.79
Bangalore
Bengal
Bhopal
Bhubaneswar
Chandhigar
570.31
0.44
Dec' 08
0.44
509.1
75.57
0.27
1.46
0.06
0.17
June' 07
46.49
0.16
1.45
0.03
Dec' 05
0.1
Circles
Patna
0.52
0.86
North east
4.74
1.22
Mumbai
18.38
3.05
Lucknow
1.16
0.37
Kerala
5.84
1018.02
12.59
Hyderabad
0.76
282.91
665.29
Delhi
16.45
1733.12
42.07
Chennai
33.03
Ahmedabad
1958.11
2500
250
2000
200
Outstandings
1500
Chennai
150
Hyderabad
Kerala
1000
100
500
50
Dec'
05
March' June'
06
06
Sept'
06
Dec'
06
March' June'
07
07
Sept'
07
Dec'
07
March' June'
08
08
Sept'
08
Dec'
08
Chennai
570.31 649.46 745.13 1143.7 1461.9 1638.8 1733.1 1916.2 2036.7 2124.4 1982 1892.9 1958.1
Hyderabad
509.1 511.61 506.43 567.43 661.07 667.62 665.29 747.01 837.35 842.86 818.2 846.97 1018
Kerala
46.49 47.36
47.13
55.56
62.17
69.78
75.57
Period
98.44
From the above graph, it could be interpreted that the growth in Chennai Circle
peaked up after June06 (well before the introduction of the simplified scheme)
and continued at the same tempo upto Mar08. However, the downfall till Sep08
and a marginal growth thereafter indicated a disturbing trend. And it was not
possible to interpret whether the simplification of Gold Loan helped the branches
or not.
While the performance of Hyderabad Circle was satisfactory all through the
period, the growth curve had reached a plateau and had not peaked up even
after the simplification process.
569.85
545.25
501.77
Outstandings
500
404.52
416.98
400
301
300
213.49
172.82
200
100
0
157.33
156.42
83.73
Chennai
Coimbatore
Madurai
Dec' 05
83.73
172.82
157.33
156.42
June' 07
213.49
404.52
569.85
545.25
Dec' 08
301
416.98
738.36
501.77
Module-wise
Tiruchirapalli
The Coimbatore module, Madurai module and Tiruchirapalli module were almost
at the same level in Dec05.
June07 and also after June07. Coimbatore module also done well till June07
but the growth stagnated almost at the same level even in Dec08. However,
Tiruchirapalli module which peaked up till June07 showed a negative trend and
the outstandings fell down by Dec08. Chennai module had a normal continued
growth all through the period.
Hyderabad Circle :
Agri Gold Loan - Hyderabad Circle
450
411.32
391.21
400
350
Outstandings
300
273.14
249.27
250
212.88
191.43
200
157.68
150
105.71
100
71.39
57.81
50
0
33.4 37.17
Hyderabad
Tirupati
Vijayawada
Dec' 05
33.4
212.88
191.43
Visakhapatnam
71.39
June' 07
37.17
273.14
249.27
105.71
Dec' 08
57.81
391.21
411.32
157.68
Module-wise
Tirupati and Vijayawada modules which were leading from the beginning,
continued the same tempo during the entire period of 3 years with good growth
momentum. However, the growth percentage was better during the second half,
as could be seen above. The simplified loan might have helped in this regard.
CIRCLE
Module
Region Branch
June 07
Dec 08
Amt.
Amt.
outstan-
outstan-
dings
dings
Rs.lacs
Rs.lacs
Chennai
Madurai
Madurai
6
1
3
Sundarampalli
Madurai ADB
a/cs)
1512.93
3350.81
(5365)
(9629)
2208.32
2579.86
(6347)
(5583)
Chemanvilai
1948.97
(5464)
Chennai
Chennai
Madurai
Madurai
Hyderabad Vijayawada
3
3
1
Udangudi
Vilathikulam
Kakumanu
1509.72
2393.79
(5059)
(6837)
577.33
1400.60
(2347)
(5023)
746.85
976.31
(3904)
(4146)
Now, let us see the various campaigns launched by different Circles. While the
Gold Loan campaign in Chennai Circle was launched before simplification of the
scheme, the following campaigns were launched after the simplification of the
scheme.
10
Minimum Rs. 100 Crores levels by the Circle as at 31st March 2009.
2) The scheme was applicable to all branches that have potential for
financing under Agriculture.
3) The Scheme was in operation from 1st August 2008 to 31st December
2008.
4) During the campaign, processing charges for Agri Gold Loans were
50% of the applicable charges
6) Competent Authority had approved an incentive based approach for
Branches as well as Regions for promotion of the scheme.
The
11
CHANDIGARH CIRCLE
AGRICULTURE GOLD LOAN : INCENTIVE SCHEME
To popularize the Gold Loan scheme, the Circle had approved a Gold Loan
incentive scheme to encourage financing under Agri Gold Loan Scheme for
Rural and Semi Urban branches of the Circle. The incentive scheme was
implemented during the period 01-07-07 to 30-09-07 and the award was given
based upon the performance during the said period.
Need not wait for closing and opening new gold loan every time need
arises.
(Branches with no locker facility can suggest Gold loan as KCC to farmers)
BENEFIT TO BANK:
12
The security environment is conducive for the people to wait and take the
loan;
d.
While redeeming the loan also the borrower should be able to remit cash at
the SWO counters within a reasonable time and take possession of the
ornaments;
13
e.
f.
The campaign for gold loans can be taken up as a project in Quality Circles;
There are ever so many advertising methods to popularize the scheme outside
such as distribution of hand bills, putting slides in theatres, scrolling in cable
network, announcement through mobile vans with loudspeakers etc. The positive
aspects like low interest rates, charges, security for the ornaments should be
highlighted in the campaigns.
While sanction of
Most of our
branches easily achieve their budget because of gold loans. One of my cluster
branch sanctions minimum 18 loans per day because that cash officer has very
good knowledge about gold loans and its importance in achieving branch budget.
Encouragement by giving excellence certificate may motivate others also
towards this end.
D S Arunakumar, Manager (Training), SBLC, Dharwad says
There is a very large potential for gold loans business.
very strong family attachment for Gold ornaments. There is very little chance for
the loans becoming NPA as simple notice prevents them from falling into this
category.
increase our business in this particular segment. This will increase our standard
asset portfolio which is very safe and profitable and also very useful to the farmer
in times of need. Gold loan business is hidden treasure for Bank.
14
the borrower in time, there will be no NPAs in this segment. I used to contact the
wife of the borrower whenever my branch Ag Gold Loans were about to become
NPA. The wives never allowed their ornaments to be sold in auction under any
circumstances and pressurised their husbands to some how settle the matter
with the bank.
Ultimately timely sanction of loans without making the applicants visiting the
branch more than once, timely reminders, auction notices when the resale value
is much more than the loan outstandings, will help to keep a healthy Ag Gold
Loan portfolio. The customers should know that whenever they require urgent
funds, SBI will come to their rescue.
16
AVAILABILITY OF POTENTIAL
Report of the Technical Group Set up to Review Legislations on Money
Lending dated 24th July 2007 (headed by Shri S.C.Gupta, Legal Adviser-inCharge, Legal Department, Reserve Bank of India) in its report stated as under:
QUOTE
The AIl India Debt and Investment Survey (NSS Fifty-Ninth Round) has revealed
that share of institutional agencies in the total cash dues of urban households
had increased from 72 per cent in 1991 to 75.1 per cent in 2002 and that of
moneylenders had also increased during the period from 10.2 per cent to 14.1
per cent. In the case of rural households, on the other hand, the share of
institutional agencies had in fact declined from 64 per cent in 1991 to 57.1 per
cent in 2002. And more significantly, the share of moneylenders had increased
in the same period from 17.5 per cent to 29.6 per cent in the case of rural
households.
The survey reveals that out of every Rs.1,000 outstanding of farmer households
in the country, Rs.257 was sourced from moneylenders. The share of
moneylenders in the indebtedness of farmer households in Bihar, Manipur,
Punjab, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh were well above the
national average, with Andhra Pradesh at the top. The penetration of
moneylenders is significant even in States that are regarded as being adequately
banked (Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu).
In the profile of Informal Credit Providers the report further states that :
Various categories of informal credit providers are in existence in most of the
States where the survey was conducted. The categories of informal credit
providers in order of frequency are pawnbrokers followed by input suppliers,
arthiya/commission agents, kirana shopkeepers, lender against land, etc.
According to what was reported by the 11 Regional Offices of the RBI there were
12,601 registered moneylenders as on March 1995. This number has increased
17
As on March 2006
Gujarat
38.34
139.65
Maharashtra
29.90
82.28
Kerala
25.00
138.00
Karnataka
19.22
87.70
Uttar Pradesh
34.22
181.92
Purpose: The loans provided by the informal credit providers were generally
short-term in nature and mainly for the purpose of meeting social obligations
associated with weddings, birth or death ceremonies. Loans for farming and
livelihood were also common.
Security obtained: Mostly all the loans were granted against the security of
gold jewellery, land documents, cultivation rights, promissory notes and even
against utensils.
UNQUOTE
The available data as above indicated that the moneylenders are still
thriving, where our branches were not able to market the safest advance
i.e., Gold Loan.
18
COMPETITORS MOVES
Not only that, Manappuram General Finance & Leasing Ltd. proudly
advertises in its website as well as airs in FM radios that
Welcome to India`s Largest Listed and Highest Credit Rated Gold Loan Company!
Pledge your gold ornaments with us and draw cash against it.
We have various Schemes that will enable you to make your favourable choice !
Attractive features:
Pay interest only for the number of days your pledge is with us.
19
An ISO 9001:2000
20
CONCLUSION
All the indicators discussed in previous pages explain that there is plenty of
potential available in the market for Gold Loans. But, the branches are not able
to encash that potential.
An earlier study conducted by this Institute on Potential for Agri Gold Loans in
Ahmedabad Circle brought out the following observations :
62% of respondent farmers are not aware of Agri Gold Loan being
provided by SBI.
Sources of Agri Gold Loan from private money lenders constitute 47% and
those from Co-operative Banks constitute 33% leaving the share of SBI
and other PSBs at 10%.
Present marketing effort on the part of branch officials is not upto the
mark. It needs greater attention to make the farmers community aware of
our product.
There appears to be mental block on the part of Cash Officers / Sr.
Assistant or Special Assistant in charge of cash not to finance gold loan.
The figures of Agri Gold Loan in Ahmedabad explain the situation. The Agri Gold
Loan portfolio was Rs.0.42 crores as on Dec 05 and in June 07 it was Rs.1.16
crores. The figure went up to Rs.33.03 crores mainly because of business came
from e-SBS. This amply shows that e-SBS could garner a portfolio of nearly
Rs.30 crores in the same State, whereas the erstwhile Circle could not do the
same.
21
22