WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT Part 1 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES AND MANAGEMENT OF SHORT TERM ASSETS AND LIABILITIES INTRODUCTION Working capital management is the management of the short-term investment and financing of a company. Goals: - Adequate cash flow for operations - Most productive use of resources Internal and External Factors that Affect Working Capital Needs Internal Factors External Factors Company size and growth rates Organizational structure Sophistication of working capital management Borrowing and investing positions/ activities/capacities Banking services Interest rates New technologies and new products The economy Competitors
Bottom line: There are many influences on a companys need for working capital. MANAGING AND MEASURING LIQUIDITY Liquidity is the ability of the company to satisfy its short-term obligations using assets that are readily converted into cash. Liquidity management is the ability of the company to generate cash when and where needed. Liquidity management requires addressing drags and pulls on liquidity. - Drags on liquidity are forces that delay the collection of cash, such as slow payments by customers and obsolete inventory. - Pulls on liquidity are decisions that result in paying cash too soon, such as paying trade credit early or a bank reducing a line of credit. SOURCES OF LIQUIDITY Primary sources of liquidity - Ready cash balances (cash and cash equivalents) - Short-term funds (short-term financing, such as trade credit and bank loans) - Cash flow management (for example, getting customers payments deposited quickly) Secondary sources of liquidity - Renegotiating debt contracts - Selling assets - Filing for bankruptcy protection and reorganizing. MEASURE OF LIQUIDITY LIQUIDITY RATIOS Ability to satisfy current liabilities using current assets Ability to satisfy current liabilities using the most liquid of current assets RATIOS INDICATING MANAGEMENT OF CURRENT ASSETS How many times accounts receivable are created and collected during the period How many times inventory is created and sold during the period OPERATING AND CASH CONVERSION CYCLES The operating cycle is the length of time it takes a companys investment in inventory to be collected in cash from customers. The net operating cycle (or the cash conversion cycle) is the length of time it takes for a companys investment in inventory to generate cash, considering that some or all of the inventory is purchased using credit. The length of the companys operating and cash conversion cycles is a factor that determines how much liquidity a company needs. - The longer the cycle, the greater the companys need for liquidity. OPERATING AND CASH CONVERSION CYCLES Acquire Inventory for Credit Sell Inventory for Credit Collect on Accounts Receivable Pay Suppliers Acquire Inventory for Cash Sell Inventory for Credit Collect on Accounts Receivable Operating Cycle Cash Conversion Cycle Operating Cycle = Inventory Days + Receivable Days Cash Conversion Cycle = Inventory Days + Receivable Days - Payable Days OPERATING AND CASH CONVERSION CYCLES: FORMULAS Average time it takes to create and sell inventory Average time it takes to collect on accounts receivable Average time it takes to pay its suppliers EXAMPLE: LIQUIDITY AND OPERATING CYCLES Compare the liquidity and liquidity needs for Company A and Company B for FY2: Company A Company B
FY2 FY1 FY2 FY1 Cash and cash equivalents !200 !110 !200 !300 Inventory !500 !450 !900 !900 Receivables !600 !625 !1,000 !1,100 Accounts payable !400 !350 !600 !825 Revenues !3,000 !950 !6,000 !6,000 Cost of goods sold !2,500 !750 !5,200 !5,050 EXAMPLE: LIQUIDITY AND OPERATING CYCLES Company A Company B FY2 FY2 Current ratio 3.3 times 3.5 times Quick ratio 2.0 times 2.0 times Number of days of inventory 73.0 days 63.2 days Number of days of receivables 73.0 days 60.8 days Number of days of payables 57.3 days 42.1 days Operating cycle 146.0 days 124.0 days Cash conversion cycle 88.7 days 81.9 days 1. How do these companies compare in terms of liquidity? 2. How do these companies compare in terms of their need for liquidity, based on their operating cycles? HOW CAN OPERATING CYCLE BE REDUCED 1. Production Management - Under Inventory Management 2. Purchasing Management - Under Inventory Management 3. Marketing Management - meaning sale and production should be synchronised 4. Credit an Collection Policy - Under Cash Management and Receivables Management 5. External Environment - fluctuation in demand analysis; entrants of new competitors, government and fiscal policies, price fluctuations, etc. ALTERNATIVE POLICIES IN WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT ALTERNATIVE POLICIES REGARDING THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF CURRENT ASSETS CARRIED 1.Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy - a relaxed current asset investment strategy leads to a company maintaining a higher level of current assets relative to sales. Using this strategy, the company will keep a higher level of A/R and inventory. 2.Restrictive Current Asset Investment Strategy - When using a restrictive current asset investment strategy a company will maintain a low level of current assets relative to sales. Accounts Receivables (A/R) are kept low and inventory is managed as tightly as possible. COST RELEVANT TO INVESTMENT IN CURRENT ASSETS Carrying costs - are the cost associated with having current assets Opportunity Costs - costs of having a capital tied up in the current asset rather than in a more productive fixed asset. Explicit costs - costs necessary to maintain the value of the current assets. (e.g. storage costs) Shortage costs - are the costs associated with not having the current asset Opportunity Costs - costs of not having the sale due to not having enough inventory Explicit transaction fees - costs paid up to replenish the particular inventory. (e.g. extra shipping cows, interest expense for money borrowed) ALTERNATIVE STRATEGIES IN FINANCING WORKING CAPITAL 1.Long Term / Permanent Assets - These consist of property, plant and equipment, long term investment, and the portion of the assets that remain unchanged over the year. 2.Fluctuating or Seasonal Assets - These are current assets that vary over the year due to seasonal or cyclical needs. ASPECTS TO TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION IN CHOOSING FINANCING POLICY The Financing Policies to be chosen should take into the consideration. Maturity Hedging Cash Reserves Relative Interest Rates Availability and Costs of Alternative Financing Impact on Future Sales END OF PART 1 Part 2 CASH AND MARKETABLE SECURITIES MANAGEMENT CASH MANAGEMENT REASONS FOR HOLDING CASH BALANCES Transactions Motive - to meet payments arising in the ordinary course of business Precautionary Motive - to maintain a cushion or buffer to meet unexpected cash needs Speculative Motive - to take advantage of temporary opportunities (Investment Opportunities) Compliance with Creditors Covenant - Firms using bank debt are required to maintain a compensating balance with the bank from which they have borrowed the money Compensating balance: when a bank makes a loan to a firm, the bank requires this minimum balance in a non-interest- earning checking account equal to a specified percentage of the amount borrowed DETERMINING THE TARGET CASH BALANCE 1. Cash Budget - is the tool used to present the expected cash inflows and outflows of the company 2. Cash Break-even Chart Fixed Monthly Mayments / Contribution Margin 3. Optimal Cash Balance Approach The Baumol Model Balances the opportunity costs of holding cash against the transactions associated with replenishing the cash account. The Miller-Orr Model It assumes that the distribution of daily net cash flow is normally distributed. THE BAUMOL MODEL Total Costs = Holding Costs + Transaction Costs = ( Average Cash Balance ) ( Opportunity Cost ) + ( No. of Transactions ) ( Cost of Transactions ) = C ( K ) + T ( F ) 2 C Where: C = Amount of Cash Raised C* = Optimal Cash to be Raised C/2 = Ave. cash balance C*/2 = Optimal ave. cash balance T = Total Amount of net new cash needed F = Fixed costs in obtaining cash k = opportunity cost of holding cash THE BAUMOL MODEL C* = 2 (T) (F) K Where: C = Amount of Cash Raised C* = Optimal Cash to be Raised C/2 = Ave. cash balance C*/2 = Optimal ave. cash balance T = Total Amount of net new cash needed F = Fixed costs k = opportunity cash of holding cash
Therefore minimum cash balance required: THE BAUMOL MODEL (EXAMPLE) Problem 4: Jaypee Inc. has 2 dates when it receives its cash inflows (Feb 15 and Aug 15). On each dates, it expects to receive P 30 million. Cash expenditures are expected to be set through out the subsequent 6 month period. Presently, the ROI in marketable securities is 8% per annum and the cost of transfer from securities to cash is P 125 each time a transfer occurs.
Required: A. What is the optimal transfer size using the Baumol model? What is the average cash balance? B. What would be the answer to (a) if the ROI were 12% per annum and the transfer cost were P75? Why do they differ from those in (a)? THE BAUMOL MODEL (EXAMPLE) C* = 2 (30M) (125) C*/2 = 153,093.11 8% C* = 306,186.22 Given: A T = P 30,000,000 F = P 125 k = 8%
Problem 4: THE BAUMOL MODEL (EXAMPLE) C* = 2 (30M) (75) C*/2 = 96,824.58 12% C* = 193,649.17 Given: B T = P 30,000,000 F = P 75 k = 12%
Problem 4: THE MILLER-ORR MODEL Z* = 3 3 F + L 4 i Where: L = Lower control Limit " = standard deviation iday = daily interest rate F = Trading Cost Z* = Optimal Cash Return point H* = Upper Control limit for cash balances
Miller-Orr Model Formula H* = 3Z* - 2L THE MILLER-ORR MODEL (EXAMPLE) Problem 10: Hot Foot Entreprises would like to maintain their cash account at a minimum level of P25,000, but expect the standard deviation in net daily cash flows to be P2,000. The effective annual rate on marketable securities to be 6.5% per year, and the trading cost per sale or purchase of marketable securities to be P200 per transaction. What will be the optimal upper cash limit THE MILLER-ORR MODEL Z* = 3 3 (200) 2K + 25K 4 (6.5%/365) Where: L = P25,000 " = P2,000 iday = 6.5% / 365 F = P200
Miller-Orr Model Formula Z* = P39,991.45 therefore: H* = 3Z* - 2L = 3(39,991.45) - 2(25,000) = 69,974.34 OTHER FACTORS INFLUENCING THE TARGET CASH BALANCE Option to incur short-term borrowing to meet unexpected demands.
Transaction Cost and Time Element
Maintenance of minimum balance in the companys deposit CASH MANAGEMENT TECHNIQUES Synchronizing Cash Flows - is a situation in which inflows coincide with the outflows of the firm therefore reducing transaction balances. Using Floats - is the difference between the balance in the books and the balance in the banks. Accelerating Cash Collections Slowing Disbursements Reducing the need for Precautionary Balance THE USE OF FLOATS Disbursement Floats - represents the value the checks the firm has written but which are still processes Collection Floats - represents the amount of the checks that have been received but not yet credited to the firms bank account Mail Floats, Deposit Float (Processing and Availability) Net Float - is the difference between the positive disbursement float vs. its negative collection float In Financial Accounting this is more commonly noted as the bank reconciling items other than book and bank errors. FLOAT REDUCTION VALUATION If Miguel Motors expects its gross revenue from sales to be P80 million. The firms treasurer has projected its marketable securities portfolio will earn 6.50% over the coming budget year. What is the value of one days float reduction to the company. (Use 365 days working year as basis for the assumption)
Solution:
Value of One days Float = P80M 365 x 6.5% = P14,246.57 CASH COLLECTION ACCELERATION Prompt Billing and Periodic Statements Incentives such as trade and Cash discounts Prompt deposit Direct Deposit to firms bank account Electronic depository transfer Maintenance of regional collection office CASH COLLECTION ACCELERATION (EXAMPLE) ABC Co. is evaluating a new bank facility which expects to accelerate its cash collection. In a typical year the firm usually receives Php 5M by check where the company record and process 2,500 checks in the same time period. Bank A has advised the firm that the new facility will cost an extra P0.50 per check. The firm projected that the firm can invest the freed cash to a marketable security with an eight percent yield per annum. Calculate the minimum days freed by the process in order to accept the bank facility. (Use 365 days working year for the analysis) CASH COLLECTION ACCELERATION (EXAMPLE) Solution: Ave. check value = Php 5M / 2,500 = Php 2,000 per check Opportunity cost per day = 0.08/365 = 0.02192% where: added cost = added benefits P0.25/check = (N)(P2,000/check)(0.02192%) N = 1.7534 days OTHER METHODS IN ACCELERATING CASH COLLECTION Lockbox System - customers are instructed to mail their remittance to a lockbox location. Advantage - Reduces the mailing and processing float Disadvantage - Cost of creating such a system ( Not advantageous to small remittances) Concentration Banking - the process of having lockbox accounts or field bank accounts to a central cash pool residing in a concentration bank. Depository Transfer Check - Funds are not immediately available upon receipt of the DTC. Automated Clearinghouse (ACH) Electronic Transfer Wire Transfer SLOWING DISBURSEMENTS Centralized Processing of Payables - this permits the finance manager to evaluate the payments for the whole firm. Zero Balance Accounts - a function in concetration banking sometimes called in-house banking where a master account is used to control all of the firms accounts. Delaying payment Playing the Float Less Frequent payroll REDUCING THE NEED FOR PRECAUTIONARY BALANCE More accurate cash budgeting Lines of Credit Temporary Investments CASH RECEIPT ACCELERATION AND FLOAT VALUATION CALCULATIONS Uses the concept of cost - benefit comparisons The usage of break-even analysis Usually compared to opportunity costs MARKETABLE SECURITIES MANAGEMENT REASONS FOR HOLDING MARKETABLE SECURITIES They serve as a substitute for cash balances They are held as temporary investments They are built up to meet known financial requirements FACTORS INFLUENCING THE CHOICE OF MARKETABLE SECURITIES Risks Default Risk - the risk that it cannot be paid on the due dates Interest rate risks - the risk in the decline in market values Inflation risk Marketability (liquidity) risk - risk that security cannot be sold at quoted price Event Risk - the probability that an event will happen and increase the firms default risk. Maturity - is that if security can be sold when the cash is required Yield or return on securities - the higher the risk, the higher the yield or return. TYPES OF MARKETABLE SECURITIES Money Market Securities Discount Paper - sells less than its par or face value Interest bearing securities Treasury Bills (Government Security with one year or less maturity) Other Short-term Commercial Papers - typically unsecured with maturity of less than 270 days. Usually discounted but can be interest bearing. Negotiable Certificate of Deposits Repurchase Agreements (REPOS) - securities with an agreement to repurchase. Bankers Acceptance - a time draft drawn on and accepted by a bank usually used as a source of financing in international trade Money Market Mutual Fund - open ended mutual fund that invests in money market instruments. Highly liquid because they can be sold back to the fund any time. END OF PART 2