Sealing Arrangement Design Guide
Sealing Arrangement Design Guide
Sealing Arrangement Design Guide
design guide
Contents
The complete SKF bearing and CR sealing system....
16
18
18
19
19
20
20
21
21
SKF bearings and CR seals complement each other and are always the
correct choice for bearing and sealing
arrangements of all kinds.
Bearing damage
a sign of sealing problems
The calculated life of a bearing is defined as the period of time for which the
bearing will operate until signs of fatigue
set in, and since most bearings fail for
other reasons, it may be argued that
most bearing failures are premature.
The development of the SKF New
Life Theory has made it possible to
take into account not only the effects of
material and lubricating conditions on
bearing life in addition to bearing load,
but also the effect of contamination
and the bearing damage it produces.
Solid contaminants, depending on particle size, hardness and brittleness will
produce indentations and/or wear on
the bearing surfaces. Water will affect
the efficiency of the lubricant and also
its rust inhibiting properties. Contamination in the lubricant can dramatically reduce bearing life so that good
sealing is of vital importance.
When a seal fails, contamination can
infiltrate the bearing area and enter the
lubricant and then the bearing. Also,
lubricant may be lost from the bearing,
leading ultimately to dry running and
bearing failure. Information regarding
the influence of lubrication and contamination on bearing life can be found in
the SKF General Catalogue.
Corrosion
Greyish-black streaks across the raceways
at intervals corresponding to the spacing of
the rolling elements (in this case cylindrical
rollers) indicate that water has penetrated
the bearing during standstill. General rust
indicates the presence of water or other
corrosive substances.
Surface distress
Small shallow craters with crystalline appearance can result from momentary brief
metal-to-metal contact. The cause may be
either the use of an unsuitable lubricant, or
the loss of lubricant through the seal.
The seal
Function
Static seal:
gasket
Static seal:
O-ring
Dynamic seal:
radial shaft seal
Types
There are several different types of
seal; for example, DIN 3750 distinguishes between the following basic
types:
1. seals in contact with stationary
surfaces,
2. seals in contact with sliding
surfaces,
3. non-contacting seals,
4. bellows and membranes.
Seals in contact with stationary surfaces are known as static seals and
their sealing effect depends on the radial
or axial deformation of their cross section when installed. Gaskets ( fig 1 )
and O-rings ( fig 2 ) are typical examples of static seals.
Seals in contact with sliding surfaces
are used to seal the passage between
machine components which move
relative to each other either linearly or
in the circumferential direction. These
seals, known as dynamic seals, have
to retain lubricant, exclude contaminants, separate different media and
withstand differential pressures.
There are various types of dynamic
seal, including packings and piston
6
Dynamic seal:
mechanical seal
Q;@
Q
@
;
Q;@Q;@Q;@Q;@
Q;@ ;@QQ;@
Q;@
;@QQ;@
Dynamic seal:
V-ring seal
Dynamic seal:
labyrinth seal
The seal
Bearing side
Environment
Shell
Garter
spring
Sealing
element
Hinge
Primary sealing lip
Typical radial
shaft seal
Type 1
Type 2
Type 3
Type 4
Type 5
Type 6
Radial shaft seals
to ISO 6194
All-rubber radial
shaft seal
a) with open
spring groove
b) with SpringLock
c) with SpringKover
Materials
The performance and reliability of a
radial shaft seal are largely dependent
on the material from which the sealing
lip is made. Where seals regularly fail
after a short period of operation, it
may be advisable to replace them
with seals of another material, e.g.
one which is more wear-resistant such
as CR LongLife fluoro rubber. Although
more expensive to buy, the reduced
maintenance and downtime may make
them an economic proposition.
Normally materials based on acrylonitrile butadiene are used for radial
shaft seals. For CR seals, the materials
described in the following are used.
10
4
2
flu L
or on
o
ru gLi
bb fe
Lo
er
ng
Li
fe
PT
FE
D
ur
at
em
p
D
ur
al
ip
Le
at
he
r
Po
ly
ac
ry
la
te
N
itr
ile
ru
bb
er
0
Si
lic
on
e
Temperature, C
300
250
200
Polyacrylate
Duralip
150
100
50
0
-50
Silicone
-100
Leather
Nitrile rubber
LongLife PTFE
The seal
10
LongLife PTFE
Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) has a
chemical resistance which far exceeds
that of all the materials described above
and the material is mainly used for
special seals. Dry running is permitted
and the operating temperature range
is 70 to +260 C although care should
be taken when using them above
+200 C so that they do not overheat.
The risks are the same as those outlined under fluoro rubber.
Other materials used in seals
The shells and any metallic reinforcements are made of deep drawn carbon steel as standard. Free surfaces
are treated for protection against corrosion. To special order they may be
made of stainless steel although not
for all cross sections and widths.
The garter springs are made of hard
drawn carbon steel wire except those
of the large HDS and HS seals which
are made of stainless steel as standard.
Bore-Tite is a special CR nonhardening material used as a coating
on some sizes of seal with steel outside diameter This green coating is
resistant to most oils, greases,
aqueous acids, alkalis, salts, alcohols
and glycols. It is not compatible with
aromatics, ketones or esters.
The environment
Even the best sealing mechanism
between housing bore and seal outside diameter as well as between sealing lip and shaft counterface cannot
guarantee optimum seal performance.
Besides these geometric considerations, the entire surroundings must
be taken into account. Therefore, the
most important environmental and
operating conditions will be briefly
discussed.
Contamination
Contaminants such as water, dust or
mud do more than just prevent optimum
seal performance. If they enter the bearing area they can pollute the lubricant,
cause corrosion, wear and premature
bearing failure. To prevent bearing
damage, heavy-duty seals with the
sealing lip facing the contaminants are
used. If the amount of contamination is
minimal and the function of the primary
seal is to provide fluid retention, then
a V-ring or a seal with a secondary lip
can be used for exclusion.
Pressure
Standard radial shaft seals perform
best and last longest if the pressure on
both sides of the seal is the same. The
slightest amount of pressure increase
on the inside of the seal will cause the
sealing lip to be pressed against the
counterface, thus widening the path it
traces. Friction will increase in the contact and heat will be generated. The
rise in temperature will cause the seal
to wear rapidly. An extreme excess
pressure in the housing can even force
the seal out of the bore. Permissible
Table 1
Differential
pressure
Shaft speeds
Rotational
Circumferential
max
permissible
max
MPa
r/min
m/s
0,02
0,035
0,05
3 000
2 000
1 000
5,6
3,2
2,8
Permissible
speeds under
pressure
11
The seal
Speed
The maximum circumferential speed
at the sealing lip at which the seal will
still perform efficiently is determined by
several factors simultaneously. These
include sealing lip material and design,
shaft finish at the counterface, pressure, temperature, shaft eccentricity,
lubrication and cooling of the sealing
lip/counterface contact, and the presence of any chemicals. General guideline values for permissible speeds
will be found in the table opposite
( Table 2 ). The values given are
valid when a mineral oil provides good
lubrication, cooling is adequate, and
there is no pressure differential across
the seal.
Retained fluid
The chemical resistance of the seal to
the fluid which it is to seal is an important selection criterion. If the seal lip
material is not compatible with the fluid
to be retained, the seal will be unable
to prevent leakage. Temperature is also
important. As temperature increases,
any chemical reaction will be accelerated and any aggressiveness will be
heightened.
When the seal is to retain oil it should
be remembered that as temperature
increases, the viscosity of the lubricating oil decreases. Some lubricant
additives may have detrimental effects
on the seal materials.
Further information on the chemical
resistance of the seal materials used
LongLife
fluoro rubber
70
60
50
40
30
Nitrile rubber
20
10
80
90
100
110
120
130
Temperature
Seal life as a function
of temperature
Test conditions
2500
2000
1500
1000
Automotive oil
to API GL-5
500
80
90
100
110
SAE 30 fluid
120
130
140
Temperature, C
12
Lubricant
Seal life as a function
of lubricant
Circumferential
speed
max
m/s
14
18
25
7,5 ... 12
Mechanical seals
HDDF
V-ring seals
Without extra location/support
With axial location
With support ring
7
7 ... 12
10 ... 20
25
Permissible
circumferential
speeds
13
The seal
The shaft
15/30
This corner must be
burr-free and blended
To obtain reliable sealing and a sufficiently long service life, the counterface
on the shaft for radial shaft seals should
meet the following requirements.
Shaft material
The seals perform best on medium to
high carbon steel which may be either
through hardened or case hardened to
a surface hardness of the counterface
of 55 HRC or 600 HV, the case depth
should be at least 3 mm. Lower hardness can be permitted, for example,
when circumferential speeds are low,
lubrication is good, or contamination
absent. Ceramic coated and chromium
or nickel-plated surfaces are also
acceptable, provided they are finished
to the recommended surface roughness. Brass, bronze and alloys of aluminium, zinc or magnesium are not
recommended.
Surface finish
The contact area between the sealing
lip and counterface is of vital importance to sealing efficiency. The surface
roughness to ISO 4288 of the counterface should be kept within the following
guideline values:
Ra
Rz
Rmax
Table 3
Shaft tolerances:
counterface/
chamfer
dimensions
14
Shaft
diameter
Nominal
over
incl.
Shaft diameter
deviations
(Tolerance h11)
high low
Circularity
Chamfer dimensions
(Tolerance IT8)
max
C
min
r
min
mm
mm
mm
10
18
10
18
30
0
0
0
90
110
130
22
27
33
0,75
1
1,25
1
1
1,5
30
50
80
50
80
120
0
0
0
160
190
220
39
46
54
1,7
2
3,5
2
2
4
120
180
250
180
250
315
0
0
0
250
290
320
63
72
81
3,5
3,5
5,5
4
4
6
315
400
500
400
500
630
0
0
0
360
400
440
89
97
110
5,5
5,5
6,5
6
6
7
630
800
1 000
800
1 000
1 250
0
0
0
500
560
660
125
140
165
6,5
7
7
7
8
8
1 250
1 600
780
195
15/30
Chamfer width
2,3 mm for 15
1,5 mm for 30
This corner must be
burr-free and blended
Bore-Tite coating
CR applies a coating of Bore-Tite to
the outside diameter of selected seals
with steel shells as standard. Bore-Tite
is a water-based polyacrylate sealant
which is green in colour. It is non-hardening and fills slight irregularities in
the housing bore. In most cases the
elastic Bore-Tite coating provides an
adequate static seal between the seal
outside diameter and the housing
bore.
Bore-Tite is resistant to most oils,
greases, aqueous acids, alkalis, salts,
alcohols and glycols. It is not compatible with aromatics, ketones or esters.
Table 4
Lead-in
In order for the seal not to be damaged
when it is being installed, the leading
or entering edge of the bore should be
made according to the illustration
above.
Housing bore/seal
outside diameter
Nominal
over
incl.
Bore diameter
deviation
(Tolerance H8)
high
low
mm
high
low
high
low
18
30
18
30
50
+27
+33
+39
0
0
0
+200
+200
+200
+80
+80
+80
+300
+300
+300
+150
+150
+150
50
80
120
80
120
180
+46
+54
+63
0
0
0
+230
+250
+280
+90
+100
+120
+350
+350
+450
+200
+200
+250
180
250
300
250
300
315
+72
+81
+81
0
0
0
+350
+350
+450
+150
+150
+200
+450
+450
+550
+250
+250
+300
315
400
500
400
500
630
+89
+97
+110
0
0
0
+450
+450
+500
+200
+200
+220
+550
+550
+300
+300
630
800
1 000
800
1 000
1 250
+125
+145
+165
0
0
0
+500
+550
+600
+240
+250
+270
1 250
1 600
+195
+650
+300
15
Seal selection
type of lubrication,
circumferential speed of the sealing
lip, and
coaxiality deviations and runout,
the choice is also affected by the environmental conditions and how they
affect the seal from chemical, mechanical and thermal points of view.
The available space, efficiency requirements and last but not least economic considerations must all be taken
into account when selecting a seal.
Depending on the application, one or
more of the influencing factors will
dominate. Therefore, it is not possible
to establish general rules for seal
selection. The following recommendations are intended to highlight the properties of the various seal designs and
to facilitate selection.
The matrix provides an overview of
the seals, their design characteristics
16
(very good)
(good)
(normal)
(satisfactory)
(poor)
D
P
R
V
Shell (outside
diameter)
Seal types
CRS1
CRSA1
CRW1
CRWA1
HDS1, 2
Sealing lip
(primary)
normal
R, V
HMSA27
Bore-Tite
normal
R,V
Bore-Tite
Waveseal
R, V (P)
Bore-Tite
Waveseal
R, V (P)
normal
R, D, V
normal
R, D, V
normal
normal
R, V (P)
normal
R, V (P)
R, V (P)
normal
R, V (P)
R, D, V
one-piece
normal
R, D, V
R, D (V)
split
normal
R, D (V)
Secondary
lip
a = rubbing
b = non-rubbing
Less suitable
Unsuitable
Material
Design
Design
retain lubricant,
exclude contaminants,
separate fluids or gases, and
withstand differential pressures.
Elastomer
This matrix can only provide a rough guide and the final seal selection should
only be made after a more detailed examination of sealing properties with
respect to the actual operating conditions and environment. If several seal designs and materials are shown together then the ratings apply to the specified
design/material.
Steel
CRSH1
CRSHA1
HMSA27
CRWH1
CRWHA1
a: CRS(H)A
b: HMSA27
HDS3
HDSA1,2
Radial
shaft
seals
HMS1
HMSA1, 2, 3
a
HMS4
HMSA7
HS5
HS6, 7, 8
V-ring seals VR
Steel
R (V)
R (V)
Suitability
Housing bore/
outside diameter
Sealing lip/
counterface
Sliding speeds
14 m/s
Sliding speeds
> 14 m/s
Temperatures
100 C
Temperatures
> 100 C
Runout
Coaxiality deviation
Grease
Oil
Moderate particulate
contamination
Heavy particulate
contamination
Media
+++
CRSH
++
+++
CRSH
++
++
+++
CRWHA
++
+++
CRW5
++
++
+++
+++
CRWHA
++
+++
CRWA5
++
++
+++
++
+++
++
++
++
++
++
+++
++
++
++
++
++
+++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
+++
++
++
++
++
++
++
++
+++
+++
+++
+++
+++
+++
+++
+++
++
++
++
+++
+++
+++
+++
++
Tight fit
Ease of installation
Media
Operating conditions
Thermal expansion
Pressure
differential
Rough surface
Seating conditions
+++
17
Seal selection
Grease retention
Oil retention
Greases are generally easy to retain in a bearing arrangement because of their relatively high consistency. This,
therefore, places comparatively small demands on the
seal and most types of seal can be used.
Radial shaft seals without garter spring, e.g. the CR HM
design, are very suitable where circumferential speeds are
low. They should be installed with their lip facing the grease,
i.e. for bearing arrangements, the lip should point inwards.
However, spring-loaded radial shaft seals are equally
suitable for grease retention. If frequent relubrication is
required, it is recommended that at least one of the seals
is mounted with its lip facing outwards. This enables excess
grease to escape past the sealing lip, thus preventing a
build-up of grease and the consequent generation of heat.
In cases where it cannot be guaranteed that grease will be
supplied to the sealing lip, it is recommended that a seal
with secondary lip is used and the space between the two
lips filled with grease. Because of the unfavourable cooling
conditions associated with grease lubrication, the permissible
speeds are only approximately half those for the same seal,
when it is used for oil retention.
In addition to radial shaft seals, without or with garter
spring, V-ring seals and felt seals are also appropriate for
grease lubrication.
HM14
18
CRW1
V-ring
Felt seal
CRWA1
HMS4
HMSA7
HDDF
Exclusion
Exclusion/retention
CRW1
HDS2
CT3
;;
V-ring
2 HDS3
2 V-ring
19
Seal selection
2 CRW1
20
HDSD2
CRW5
CRWA5
HDW1
HDS3
Restricted space
Installation restrictions
;
Often the available space is insufficient for a standard radial
shaft seal. A special seal design with narrow shell or low
cross section is required, or a V-ring seal can be fitted outside the seal cavity.
Where radial and axial space are limited and large-diameter shafts are involved, radial shaft seals of the HS design
can be used.
For cases where a V-ring can be used, an economic sealing arrangement will be achieved; the V-ring seals are very
simple to install. The V-ring seals axially, exerting a light
pressure on the counterface, which may be a stationary, or
even rotating, machine component.
HMS1
HS5
HS8
V-ring
CRWH1
HDS3
V-rings
21
Seal installation
No matter how well constructed a seal
is, or how well suited it is for an application, incorrect installation will prevent it
from performing properly. In fact, improper installation resulting from lack
of knowledge or care (including cleanliness) is the most common cause of
premature seal failure.
Since radial shaft seals should have
an interference fit in the housing bore,
the use of a mechanical or hydraulic
press with suitable accessories is recommended when mounting. It is very
important that the pressure is applied
evenly around the whole circumference of the seal and preferably as close
as possible to the outside diameter. If
a suitable press is not available a softfaced mallet and bearing cup or mounting dolly can be used. Blows to the
seal itself should be avoided, so as
not to damage the sealing lip. It is also
possible to use a wooden block and
hammer to drive the seal home.
22
Check that the dimensions of the selected seal match those of shaft
and bore.
Check the new seal for any damage (dents, scores or cuts). Never use
damaged seals. Carefully clean the seal if it has become dirty.
Chamfer and blend the housing bore corner to prevent damage to the
outside surface of the seal.
All shaft edges over which the seal has to be passed must be chamfered or rounded.
After installation
Once radial shaft seals have been
installed, care should be taken to see
that they do not become contaminated,
e.g. with paint, if the equipment is to
be painted. This also applies to the
counterface area on the shaft. The
seals can be protected during painting
by cardboard discs, for example. Any
housing vents should also be masked
so that they do not become clogged.
After painting has been completed, all
the masking material must be removed
before operating the equipment.
If painted or lacquered equipment is
to be baked or unpainted equipment is
to be heated for any reason, care
should be taken not to apply direct
heat to the seals and to ensure that
they are not heated to a higher temperature than the maximum permissible
for the material.
If seals have to be cleaned, e.g. for
inspection, warm soapy water (not
above 30 C) can be used, and the
seals should be allowed to dry at room
temperature. Solvents such as trichloroethylene, carbon tetrachloride or hydrocarbons should be avoided. Sharpedged objects, wire brushes, emery
cloth, sand paper etc. should not be
used.
23
When the sleeve has been correctly positioned, the flange can be removed if desired.
25
Seal maintenance
When to inspect and replace
Unlike bearing life, seal life cannot be
calculated. The purpose of seals is
to contain lubricants and exclude contaminants, and their role is sacrificial
when they are used to protect bearings, i.e. they are used to help the bearing achieve its required life. As seal
failure is almost entirely governed by
environmental conditions, the only life
formula which can be applied to seals
is experience.
As the environment plays such a
dominant part in determining seal life,
and as the amount of contamination
the seal encounters influences its usefulness, it may be expected that a seal
operating in a dirty, dusty environment,
or one subjected to routine wash-downs
will not last nearly as long as a seal
used in a clean, dry environment.
Machine operating cycles, shaft
speeds and operating temperatures
all influence maintenance and replacement intervals. One thing is certain,
however, and that is that seals are the
components of a bearing arrangement
which keep lubricant in the arrangement and keep it clean so that long
bearing life can be realised.
Seal replacement should not automatically entail simply replacing the
seal with a new one of exactly the same
design. If it is found that the oil has
become dirty, for example, it may be
worthwhile upgrading the whole sealing
arrangement. A tougher, more chemically resistant material may be called
for, or additional sealing elements may
be required to ward off contaminants.
Generally speaking, a seal should
be replaced just as soon as the first
signs of wear or leakage are discovered.
There are other causes of premature
seal failure besides contamination.
Improper installation
A common cause of early failure arises
during installation. The seal may be
26
allowed to get dirty, the lip is not properly lubricated at the start, correct
tools are not used, or the seal is not
properly seated in its housing. These
problems can be rectified through proper training in mounting procedures.
Change of lubricant
Frequently, new lubricants with additive packages are introduced with a
view to extending service intervals for
machinery and equipment. However,
many of these additives can produce
negative reactions in the sealing materials. If rapid seal failures suddenly
start to occur where none has been
experienced before, the cause may be
a changeover to an improved lubricant.
Wrong replacement seal
A simple error in taking the wrong part
number or designation can result in
sudden mysterious seal failure, e.g. a
nitrile rubber seal might be installed
instead of a much more resistant fluoro
rubber seal, although the design is
otherwise identical.
Wrong seal choice
The choice of a seal which is unsuitable for the particular application is
also a cause of premature seal failure.
A systematic investigation of such seal
failures by an expert will soon expose
the cause. If adequate experience is
not available in-house it is advisable to
either conduct trials or to contact SKF
for assistance with the selection.
The original packaging should be intact and the seal should be kept
lying down in the original packaging until immediately before use.
Seals should never be hung from pegs or nails.
The work area should be clean and protected against dirt from the
environment.
The chosen seal should be checked to see that its maximum permissible circumferential speed will not be exceeded.
The chosen seal should be checked to see that it can withstand the
media involved.
The chosen seal should be checked to see that it is suitable for the
operating temperature.
The counterface region of the shaft should have a hardness appropriate to the application, but at least 35 HRC.
The shaft end and any edges over which the seal must pass, should be
chamfered or rounded.
The runout should be within the permissible limits (e.g. max. 0,25 mm
for a shaft diameter of 75 mm).
By checking the points listed and following the advice, the service life of the
seal, and of any bearing it protects, will
be maximised. For additional information on the selection and use of seals,
please contact SKF.
27
A brief history
of CR Industries
CR Industries was founded in
America in 1878 as Chicago
Rawhide. The company cured or
tanned hides, which were natural
by-products of the busy Chicago stockyards, and turned them into rawhide
leather belting. These were the belts
that literally drove the industrial development of the American
Midwest.
In the early 1900s CR worked closely with Henry Ford
and other automotive pioneers to produce leather products
for early automobiles. In 1928, the company patented the
first self-contained shaft seal, initially designed for use in
automobile wheel hubs.
In the mid-1930s, CR pioneered the development of
custom formulating, compounding and moulding of elastomers (synthetic rubber) to develop higher performance sealing materials. This produced other innovations in manufacturing processes, new sealing techniques and expanded
industrial applications.
Today, CR is the worlds leading supplier of fluid sealing
devices for the truck, automotive, agricultural machinery and
machine tool industries. CR also produces seals for
aerospace applications, earth moving equipment, household appliances and a wide variety of pumps, hydraulic
systems, motors and sub-assemblies.
The CR range comprises more than 200 types of seal,
over 3 000 stock sizes and over 10 000 variants for the shaft
diameter range of 3 to 4 500 mm. CR has an ongoing programme of work to improve the performance and reliability
of their products. New sealing units, for example, for the
automotive industry, and the development of new materials
and processes will further expand the range of applications.
CR has received quality manufacturing awards from more
than 200 companies. The company has been part of the
SKF Group since 1990.
29
30
31