Criticisms of Ecotourism
Criticisms of Ecotourism
Criticisms of Ecotourism
The World Tourism Organization (WTO) says Ecotourism is the fastest growing
sector of the Tourism Industry. Some believe this is good news and others are
horrified at the otential environmental damage that Ecotourists and Oerators may
unwittingly cause.
Ecotourism has often been touted as the cure for the enormous Tourism Industry and
the environmental and cultural damage that the industry often inflicts on develoing
and even develoed countries. Ecotourism can wor!" but the roblem is that there is
not an agreed uon definition" nor international standards that tourists and oerators
must follow.
In its simlest form" Ecotourism is nature travel. In its more advanced form"
Ecotourism encomasses all asects of life# wildlife" lants" biodiversity" sustainable
economies" conservation" environment" culture" heritage" society" and human beings.
In this form" Ecotourism is a !inder" gentler form of environmentalism that recognizes
humans as being art of the ecosystem. This is a critical difference$ it affects how tour
oerators" environmentalists and conservationists" and tourists interact with the host
destination.
%or eons" western thought has dictated that humans are the masters of the earth that
we shae and control our world. Evidence of this is the constant battle against
weather$ floods and levees$ earth&ua!es and earth&ua!e roof buildings$ sea shore
homes and relenishing of beach sand. It's a continuing battle against nature and one
we will not win. One rule of nature is constant change and we in the western world
struggle to overcome this with increasingly advanced technologies.
Smaller cultures and societies recognize that change is inevitable and their lifestyle
reflects this. While it may seem that these societies have stayed constant over
hundreds or even thousands of years" they have adated to seasons and the natural rise
and fall of resources. (owever" with increasing contact with tourists" these cultures
want what is considered a better life$ western ways. ) new culture is born" one
*eborah +c,aren calls the -Tourism .ulture-" where the eole in the host country
become hustlers for tourists' dollars.
/ecause tourism is such a large industry" there is a vested interest in e0loiting
resources" creating aradises and increasingly offering adventures and destinations
that have never been offered before. Is this the industry's fault1 Or is this the
consumers' fault1 It's more of a cause and effect relationshi. +ost western nations
have an increasing amount of disosable income since the end of the second world
war. 2ecreation" including tourism" steed in to accet monies with the romise of
the good life that reviously was en3oyed by the very wealthy and rivileged. The
middle class was now able to go laces and see things that were never available
before. The annual vacation was now a fact and considered a right.
*uring the ast 45 years" it has become aarent that the mass tourism industry is
failing" from both an environmental and cultural oint of view. *egradation of sea
shores" coral reefs" forests" and other environments is evident from ollution"
overcrowding of humans" coral reef destruction through ractices such as souvenir
collection and anchoring of leasure boats. 6aradise" while not yet lost" is losing.
Ecotourism thought evolved about 47 to 45 years ago. It was artly in resonse to
consumer demand for something new and unusual and the realization that the
environment is facing ermanent damage. It was becoming aarent that mass
tourism is not sustainable and consumers want something e0otic" but once something
becomes more commonly available" it is no longer considered e0otic$ the definition is
being ushed further into the world's une0lored laces" where few westerners have
gone before. The remise offers unsoiled nature and cultures but there are reasons
why few eole have gone before$ they are fragile" inhositable laces that do not
easily suort human life.
There are many" many tour oerators that offer Ecotourism as an alternative to
traditional ac!ages. /ut" this is in name only. Where these oerators are failing is in
the sustainable economy sector. The money tourists send is suosed to tric!le down
into the host community but very little does. In a true ecotour" the money goes directly
into the community. )ll asects are covered from lodging" food" guides" activities and
nature viewing. The host community benefits and the industry they rovide is
sustainable.
There is hoe. Individuals such as 2on +ader" +arcus Endicott" 8an +oss and
*eborah +c,aren" and institutions such as the Ecotourism Society" .harles Stuart
9niversity" Tourism .oncern and a host of others are wor!ing towards Ecotourism
definition and Ecotourism ractice. %urthermore" the consumer is becoming more
aware of issues and roblems and are demanding more intelligent encounters with
other cultures and nature. +ore are realizing that humans the world over are humans
and should not be roviding entertainment at the cost of their dignity and way of life.