Featuring: Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice May 11th, 2014 Brittany McCarel ARAMARK Dietetic Internship 2013-2014
1
Overview The outpatient clinic at which I am working provides basic primary care to area residents who are of low socioeconomic status. The clinics population is largely Hispanic, which affects how the population views both life and healthcare as a whole. With a large group of patients being diabetic as well, it was thought that the session should be especially helpful for diabetic patients, but also helpful for non-diabetic patients as well. An education session focused on whole grains, utilizing handouts and a cooking demonstration featuring Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice, was developed to benefit the clinic population. The featured meal was designed as something healthy, easy, fun, and affordable. Eight patients attended the 60 minute education session. First, a five question pre-test (based on the lesson plan goal and objectives) was utilized to assess how much accurate information the patients already knew about whole grains. After the session, a post-test was utilized to assess improved comprehension about whole grains. When asked the definition and benefits of whole grains, a comprehensive improvement was observed between the pre- and post-tests. Knowledge of whole grain sources, relative plate portions of food groups, and ability of oneself or a family member to be able to make a meal with whole grain also improved. Education sessions like this one, incorporating both handout information and demonstration, could be used to further community-based awareness of healthy nutrition.
2
Nutrition Assessment The clinic exists to provide healthcare to low-income individuals and families without health insurance (Socioeconomic Factors CH-3.1.1) 1(pp 16) . For treatment, a five dollar donation is requested at the time of each visit, but this donation is optional because many are unable to afford it. In general, those eligible to be served by the clinic must also live in the northern part of Lake County, Indiana (Geographic Location CH- 3.1.5) 1(pp 16) . According to the data provided by the clinic, roughly 72% of those utilizing the clinic are female (Gender CH-1.1.2) 1(pp 16) . The data also shows that one of the most prominent ethnicities that the clinic serves is the Hispanic population (Race/Ethnicity CH-1.1.3) 1(pp 16) . The CDC details that the religious affiliation of Hispanics/Latinos in the U.S. is 68% Catholic 2(pp 11) (Religion CH-3.1.7) 1(pp 16) . The clinic is affiliated with the Catholic church, as well. Throughout Coming Home to Salsa: Latino Roots of American Food, several foods such as rice, beans, maize, salsa, beans, squash, chili con carne, tamales, and tortillas are all provided as examples by the National Park Service as being traditionally Latino or Hispanic food choices 3 . The CDC adds that food is very important within this cultural subset 2 . Certain practices associated with the Hispanic cultures view of food include ingesting hot and cold food types, possessing a good appetite in relation to good health, honoring childrens food likes and dislikes, and matriarchs not feeding family members certain harmful foods which they believe make family members sick 2 . In relation to general health, the CDC warns that while Hispanics have a generally longer lifespan than average, high instance of chronic disease development within the Hispanic population is strongly concerning 2 . Heart disease and diabetes 3
mellitus are each numbered as one of the top 10 leading causes of death for Hispanics by the CDC 2 . The CDC also reveals that Hispanics have the highest uninsured rates (32%) of any racial or ethnic group within the United States, while only 15% the overall U.S. population is uninsured 2(pp 9) . The Hispanic culture is largely patriarchal 2 ; the CDC reveals that although the matriarch often determines when a family member needs medical care, the male head still gives permission to seek treatment 2(pp 8) (Role in Family CH-1.1.7) 1(pp 16) . Traditional Hispanic healing methods are often relied upon instead of modern healthcare methods due to the high cost of modern healthcare, especially when a family is uninsured 2 . Services provided by the clinic include (but are not necessarily limited to) nurse practitioner and doctor visits, provision of low cost medications, and (sometimes) nutrition education (Medical treatment/therapy CH-2.2.1) 1(pp 16) . However, the availability of a nutrition professional to volunteer at the clinic is often very sparing at best, which makes it crucial to provide as much quality and quantity of nutritional education to the clinics patients when a nutrition profession is able to come.
4
Nutrition Diagnosis Less than optimal intake of types of carbohydrate (whole grains) (NI-5.8.3) related to food- and nutrition-related knowledge deficit as evidenced by hyperglycemia, limited knowledge of carbohydrate consumption of foods and of carbohydrate metabolism, and perceived limited availability of appropriate foods caused by economic concerns 1(pp 213-214) . Nutrition Intervention Clinic officials state that according to data, out of the roughly 700 patients that the clinic currently serves, roughly 200 patients have diabetes mellitus. However, since all patients at the clinic do not have diabetes, it was decided that a topic be chosen that was important for all patients, but especially so for those presenting with diabetes. To address the identified nutrition diagnosis, an education intervention was planned and provided. The intervention focused on increasing knowledge about the definition, health benefits, and incorporation of whole grains in the diet, for general health as well as for diabetes. 1. Nutrition Education-content, relationship to health and disease (E.1.4) 1(pp298)
2. Composition of meals/snacks (ND-1.2) 1(pp297)
3. Nutrition Education application, skill development (E-2.2) 1(pp298)
Healthy People 2020 and Emerging Trend
Healthy People 2020 is a United States-based program that sets health-based initiatives for the Americans 4 . In 10-year increments, the quantitative results of these initiatives are measured for success, and a reflective set of updated initiatives are then developed 4 . 5
One goal of Healthy People 2020 (NWS) is as follows: Promote health and reduce chronic disease risk through the consumption of healthful diets and achievement and maintenance of healthy body weights. 5 One associated objective (NWS-16) is as follows: Increase the contribution of whole grains to the diets of the population aged 2 years and older. 5
The objective was written in SMART criteria (meaning it was specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, and timed). First, the objective is specific by stating what types of grains (whole) need to be increased in what age group (2 years and older). It is measurable because we can measure increased whole grain consumption quantitatively. Increasing whole grain consumption in those 2 years and old is definitely achievable and realistic, with a stated time goal of this being accomplished by the year 2020. Nutrition education being central to promoting health, as well as preventing and managing chronic disease, is an emerging trend in dietetics that this objective addresses. Lesson Plan Summary The intervention event was a whole grains education and cooking demonstration, featuring Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice. This recipe is an original recipe by the presenter. The target audience for the event was all interested clinic clients, especially those with diabetes. The total event duration was 60 minutes, and the overarching goal was that participants would increase their knowledge about the definition and health benefits of whole grains, for general health as well as for diabetes, and understand ways to incorporate whole grains into their own diet. The success of whether the lesson goal and objectives were met was measured with a pre- and post-test. 6
Marketing Product Our product, a whole grain education session which included a cooking demonstration of Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice, provided a nice combination of familiarity and innovation with a healthy focus. This session provided a great way to educate clinic clients because it was applicable for those with or without diabetes, was culturally sensitive but not exclusive to Hispanics, and was taught with both visual and auditory materials. Price The presenter made presentation attendance free to clients. This decision was made because clients come to the clinic because they do not have a lot of income, and also to encourage clinic client attendance. Place The session was held in the front lobby of the clinic. The clinic lobby had roughly enough seating for 10-12 clients. This venue was chosen to hold the session because it is a location with which all clients are familiar, and hosting the event there was free of charge. The clinic also had a microwave and small refrigerator/freezer in the employee lounge, both of which were used. (The microwave was used to cook the frozen steamable vegetables, and the refrigerator/freezer was used to store food during the work day before the session started. Promotion The event was promoted using an Advertisement Flyer created by the presenter (available in the Appendix section). The flyer was made to be very colorful, as to entice 7
interest in a fun demonstration for the prospective attendee. Flyers were placed over one week in advance in several areas of the clinics front lobby, and one flyer was hung in the office that the presenter had been using to conduct individual nutrition education appointments. In addition to the flyers, the clinics secretary called clients to ask if they would like to attend the session. It was asked that clients inform the clinic if they were attending two days before the event, so that sufficient time was available for purchasing supplies for the final number of attendees. Promotion was not conducted outside of the clinic because the session was purposely marketed toward clinic clients only. Financial and spacial resources would not have been sufficient to accommodate additional non-client attendees. Resources The budget for the event was very limited. The clinic does not have a great deal of extraneous funds, so all costs were incurred by the presented and the clinics lead nurse practitioner. Food-based materials totaled to roughly $25.00 (about $13.00 of those costs were incurred by the chicken breasts.) Cooking resources (rice cooker, griddle, spatula, etc.) were either brought in or already at the clinic (instead of needing to be bought specifically for the session), so the usage of cooking resources was completely free. Serving materials (disposable plates, silverware, and napkins) were already at the clinic in the employee lounge, so these resources were free. Educational materials were free to utilize, as well. Therefore, the overall cost of the session was roughly $25.00. The overall cost was feasible for an education session of this nature because it was not too great of an expense for the presenter and lead nurse practitioner to take on. 8
However, similar future demonstrations with food samples would need to be kept to a small attendance pool at this clinic (or a similar one) to remain cost effective, unless the clinic had extra finances to support it or if attendees were charged a fee. Below is the list of resources that were needed for the education session:
Food-Based Materials: 1. Chicken (2 large packs) 2. Frozen vegetables (3 boxes) 3. Brown rice (2 small bags) 4. Pam spray (1 can) 5. Pineapple (1 medium bowl) 6. Reduced fat shredded cheddar cheese (1 small bag)
Serving Materials: 1. Paper Plates 2. Plastic Silverware 3. Paper Napkins
Educational Materials (full handouts available in the Appendix section): 1. Welcome to Whole Grains Handout 6
2. 10 Tips Choose My Plate Handout 7
3. Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice: Recipe Handout (an original recipe) 4. Eating Better on a Budget Handout 8
5. Cooking & Eating Whole Grains Handout 9
6. Pre- and Post-Tests
Nutrition Monitoring and Evaluation Overall, the results of the education session were very successful, and could potentially assist in meeting the Healthy People 2020 goal of promot(ing) health and reduce chronic disease risk through the consumption of healthful diets and achievement 9
and maintenance of healthy body weights. 5 Education sessions similar to this one could also help with the associated Healthy People 2020 objective of increas(ing) the contribution of whole grains to the diets of the population aged 2 years and older. 5
Below is the overarching session goal with its associated objectives, with the quantitative results reflected by pre- and post-test knowledge. Goal: Participants will increase their knowledge about the definition and health benefits of whole grains, as well as understand ways to incorporate whole grains into their own diet. Associated Objectives: 1. By the end of the session through the use of a post-test, clients will be able to identify whole grain sources and their relationship to health and disease management. 2. By the end of the session through the use of a post-test, clients will be able to identify how to generally compose their plates with whole grains and other food sources. 3. By the end of the session through the use cooking demonstration observation, clients will know an example of how to cook a healthy, well balanced meal using whole grains. Only one of the eight participants knew what a whole grain was at the time of the pre-test; all participants knew what a whole grain was at the time of the post-test. Quantitatively, there was an 87.5% difference in attendant comprehension between pre- and post-test results (12.5% to 100%). Only two of eight attendees could name three benefits of whole grains at the time of the pre-test. All participants knew what three benefits of whole grains were at the time 10
of the post-test, resulting in a 75% difference in attendant comprehension (25% to 100%). None of the eight attendees knew what five sources of whole grains were at the time of pre-test (four answered no, and four answered maybe/somewhat). Five out of eight attendees knew what five sources of whole grains were at the time of post-test (none circled no, and three circled maybe/somewhat). The change in percentage of those answering yes at pre-test time to yes at post-test time was 62.5% (0% to 62.5%). Only three out of eight felt they knew how much of each food group, including whole grains, should be on a plate at pre-test time (three answered maybe/somewhat, and two answered no). Six out of eight answered that they knew food group portion sizes by plate, including whole grain, at the time of post-test (two answered maybe/somewhat, while none answered no). The change in percentage of those answering yes at pre-test time to yes at post-test time doubled (37.5% to 75%). Only two attendees felt they or a family member could make a meal with whole grain included at pre-test time (four answered no, and two answered maybe/somewhat). At the time of post-test, seven of eight attendees felt they or a family member could make a meal with whole grain included (none answered no, and one answered maybe/somewhat). The change in percentage of those answering yes at pre-test time to yes at post-test time increased by 62.5% (25% to 87.5%). A factor facilitating session progress was that the attendees were excited to learn how to nutritionally manage their health, overall. Without interested attendees who listened to the information being provided, a successful session would not have 11
happened. A factor hindering session progress was the limited funds available to host the education session; however, the funds that were able to be gathered were utilized very well. One example of excellent financial resource management is that the fruit picked to go with the meal, pineapple, was in season and able to be obtained at great quality on sale. Comparable bowl sizes of non-seasonal fruit cost roughly $8.00-$10.00; the bowl of pineapple cost roughly $2.50. Due to the limited nutrition counselor lengths-of-stay at the clinic, extensive monitoring and evaluation post-session is not very feasible. However, if a nutrition counselor were regularly stationed at the clinic, this session could have been the start of a series of sessions based on eating for diabetes or even general healthy nutrition. However, clinics that do have regular nutrition counselor coverage could use a series of sessions like this one to improve their patients nutritional health management, as well as to help our nation meet the goals and objectives of Healthy People 2020.
12
Appendix A: Lesson Plan Venue: Clinic Lobby Lesson Plan: Whole Grains Education and Cooking Demonstration, featuring original recipe of Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice Target Audience: All interested clinic clients, especially (but not exclusively) those with diabetes Duration: 60 minutes: 5 minute pretest, 10 minute initial verbal education (definition, basic benefits, portion sizing), 30 minute cooking demonstration, 10 minute recipe sample provision combined with post-test completion, 5 minutes for questions/sharing. Goal: Participants will increase their knowledge about the definition and health benefits of whole grains, as well as understand ways to incorporate whole grains into their own diet. Specific Objectives: 1. By the end of the session through the use of a post-test, clients will be able to identify whole grain sources and their relationship to health and disease management. S: Specific to clients attending the educational session. M: Results measurable through participants responses on pre/post-test. 13
A: Objective to be attained within educational session time-frame. R: Improvement in the identification of whole grains sources and their relationship to health and disease management is realistic. T: Achieving the objective by the end of the class session is timely. 2. By the end of the session through the use of a post-test, clients will be able to identify how to generally compose their plates with whole grains and other food sources. S: Specific to the clients attending the educational session. M: Results measured through participants responses on pre/post-test. A: Objective to be attained within educational session time-frame. R: Improvement in the identification of generally composing their plates with whole grains and other food sources is realistic. T: Achieving the objective by the end of the class session is timely. 3. By the end of the session through the use cooking demonstration observation, clients will know an example of how to cook a health, well balanced meal using whole grains. S: Specific to the clients attending the educational session. M: Results measured through participants observation of cooking demonstration, as well as receiving the corresponding recipe. A: Objective to be attained within educational session time-frame. R: It is realistic that clients will be able to observe the cooking demonstration and understand the corresponding recipe. T: Achieving the objective by the end of the class session is timely. 14
Specific Objectives (Use SMART criteria) Procedure (State how each specific objective will be met) Learning Activity Evaluation Method
Introduction
Presenter introduces self and topic of demonstration Assess prior knowledge about topic with 5 question pre-test in true or false format (Estimated Time Frame: 5 minutes) Listening to speaker
Pre-test
Body of Lesson
1. By the end of the session through the use of a post- test, clients will be able to identify whole grain sources and their relationship to health and disease management. Summarize the definition and basic benefits of whole grains (Estimated Time Frame: 5 minutes) Listening to speaker
Handout Verbal Q&A
Post-test 2. By the end of the session through the use of a post- test, clients will be able to identify how to generally compose their plates with whole grains and other food sources. Describe in general what portions of protein, grains/starches, and non-starchy vegetables to compose a plate for optimal nutritional value (Estimated Time Frame: 5 minutes)
Listening to speaker
Handout Verbal Q&A
Post-test 3. By the end of the session through the cooking demonstration observation, clients will know an example of how to cook a well balanced meal using whole grains. Demonstrate to attendees how to cook a balanced healthy meal using affordable whole grain: Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice (Estimated Time Frame: 30 minutes)
Listening to speaker
Handout Verbal Q&A
Post-test 15
Materials List (divided by material category):
Food and Beverage 1. Chicken 2. Frozen vegetables 3. Brown rice 4. Pam spray 5. Pineapple 6. Reduced fat shredded cheddar cheese 7. Bottled Water
Serving Materials: 1. Paper Plates 2. Plastic Silverware 3. Paper Napkins
Educational Materials (Title List): 1. Welcome to Whole Grains Handout 2. Choose My Plate: Ten Tips to a Better Plate Handout 3. Recipe: Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice Handout (Original Recipe by the Presenter) 4. Eating Better on a Budget Handout 5. Cooking & Eating Whole Grains Handout 6. Pre- and Post-Test
Conclusion
Provide samples of prepared recipe to attendees, as well as a post-test (identical to pre-test) to complete during sampling to assess if post-demonstration knowledge Wrap Up with Questions and Answers, and the provision of complementary take home materials (Estimated Time Frame: 15 minutes) Sampling prepared recipe
Handouts Verbal Q&A
Post-test 16
Appendix B: Educational Handout Materials 1. Welcome to Whole Grains Handout (Front and Back) 6
17
2. Choose My Plate: Ten Tips to a Great Plate Handout 7
18
3. Recipe: Tropical Chicken and Rice Handout (Original Recipe by the Presenter) Recipe: Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice By: Brittany McCarel Serves: 4
Ingredients: 16 ounces/1 pound Raw, Skinless, Boneless Chicken Breast (thawed) 1 7-oz. Bag Frozen vegetables (Green Giant Antioxidant Blend: Olive Oil Seasoning) 2 cups Bag brown rice (Dry, uncooked makes 4 cups total cooked) 1 spray Non-stick Spray (to prevent sticking to pan) 4 cups Pineapple 1 cup Reduced-fat shredded cheddar cheese 1 tablespoon Soft margarine (for rice - optional) 1 dash Mrs. Dash Lemon Pepper, lime juice, lemon juice (optional)
Cooking Materials: Rice Cooker Griddle Microwave
Estimated Calories and Carbohydrate Servings: Estimated Calories: 585 calories Estimated Carbohydrate Servings: about 4 servings
Instructions: Rice 1. Place 2 cups of dry rice in rice cooker. Add roughly 3 - 3 cups of water. Add 1 tablespoon of soft margarine if desired. Close lid to rice cooker and press button to start. Cooking of rice may take up to roughly 45 minutes -1 hour to complete. Chicken 2. Season chicken as desired (optional). 3. Turn griddle on to medium heat. Allow to heat up for roughly 10 minutes. (The low heat setting may not cook the chicken completely, while the high heat setting may char the chicken or cause it to cook too dry.) 4. Spray griddle with non-stick spray while it heats up. 5. Place chicken on griddle. Flip chicken as soon as downside of meat appears cooked. Remove chicken from griddle when other side appears cooked. (Before eating, cut into chicken to make sure that it is white all of the way through, with no pinkness or rawness even in the middle. If chicken is found to not be thoroughly cooked, place back on griddle until it is fully cooked through.) Vegetables 6. To steam vegetables in microwave, follow instructions on package as directed. Putting it All Together: 7. When rice, chicken, and vegetables are finished cooking, place of prepared rice, chicken, and vegetables on each plate. 8. To each plate, add 1 cup pineapple, cup reduced-fat shredded cheese, and seasoning as desired (optional). 9. Enjoy your tropical creation!!! 19
Appendix C: Pre-Test and Post-Test Whole Grains Education and Cooking Demonstration Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice Pre-Test and Post-Test
Directions: Before the presentation, circle the answer that fits best under the Pre-Test column. Keep your sheet during the presentation. When prompted to complete the post-test at the end of the presentation, please circle the answer that fits best under the Post-Test column. The purpose of the pre-test and post-test is to evaluate if this demonstration has been helpful in teaching you. Please give this sheet to Brittany McCarel before leaving.
3. I know 5 or more sources of whole grains. Pre-Test Post-Test Yes Yes No No Maybe/Somewhat Maybe/Somewhat 4. On a plate, I know in general how much of each food group there should be. Pre-Test Post-Test Yes Yes No No Maybe/Somewhat Maybe/Somewhat 5. I feel that I (or a family member, such as my wife, mother, husband, etc.) could cook a well-balanced meal with whole grains at home. Pre-Test Post-Test Yes Yes No No Maybe/Somewhat Maybe/Somewhat 23
Appendix D: Advertisement Flyer
Please join us for a fun-filled cooking demonstration, focused on whole grains as a part of healthy nutrition!
Meal: Tropical Chicken and Brown Rice
Location: The McAuley Clinic in Hammond, Indiana
Date: Wednesday, April 30 th , 2014
Time: 5:30 pm
Lead Presenter: Brittany McCarel
Please call the McAuley Clinic to RSVP by Monday, April 28 th , 2014. Look forward to seeing you there!
24
References: 1. Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. Pocket Guide for International Dietetics & Nutrition Terminology (IDNT) Reference Manual: Standardized Language for the Nutrition Care Process. Chicago, IL; 2013. 2. Building Our Understanding: Culture Insights Communicating with Hispanic/Latinos. Center of Disease Control (CDC). 2011; 1-17. Available at: http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dch/programs/healthycommunitiesprogram/tools/pdf/his panic_latinos_insight.pdf. Accessed on April 11 th , 2014. 3. Pilcher, J. Coming Home to Salsa: Latino Roots of American Food. National Park Service (NPS). 184-197. Accessed on April 11 th , 2014. Available at: http://www.nps.gov/latino/latinothemestudy/pdfs/Food_web_final.pdf 4. About Healthy People. Healthy People 2020. 2014. http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/about/default.aspx. Accessed on April 23 rd , 2014. 5. Nutrition and Weight Status. Healthy People 2020. 2013. http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicid=29. Accessed April 11 th , 2014. 6. Welcome to Whole Grains: Healthy, Convenient, Delicious. The Whole Grains Council. 2011. http://wholegrainscouncil.org/files/WholeGrains101brochure.pdf. Accessed on April 23 rd , 2014.
25
7. Choose My Plate: 10 Tips to a Great Plate. Choose My Plate. http://www.choosemyplate.gov/food- groups/downloads/TenTips/DGTipsheet1ChooseMyPlate.pdf. Accessed on April 23 rd , 2014. 8. Eating on a Budget: 10 Tips to Help Stretch Your Food Dollars. Choose My Plate. http://www.choosemyplate.gov/foodgroups/downloads/TenTips/DGTipsheet16Eating BetterOnABudget.pdf. Accessed on April 23 rd , 2014. 9. Cooking and Eating Whole Grains. The Whole Grains Council. 2013. http://wholegrainscouncil.org/files/CookingWholeGrains.pdf. Accessed on April 23 rd , 2014.
Nutrition Education: Strategies for Improving Nutrition and Healthy Eating in Individuals and Communities: 92th Nestlé Nutrition Institute Workshop, Lausanne, September 2018