Montana Music Running Head: MONTANA MUSIC 1
Montana Music Running Head: MONTANA MUSIC 1
Montana Music Running Head: MONTANA MUSIC 1
Julie Methot
EDCI 690
Dr Susan Barfield
Montana Music 2
Abstract
This document, intended for the teacher who is familiar with music, serves to introduce
the historic styles of music from the first people in Montana. Three culture groups are examined
in historical perspective: the Plateau area, the Plains area, and the Great Lakes area. Change
because of the pan-Indian movements is briefly explained, and the shape of modern Native
music is described. Additional references and resources are given for the reader to explore more.
Montana Music 3
Introduction
This paper will be an introduction to the music of the twelve registered tribes of Montana.
For the sake of convenience and brevity, they will be grouped into three 'culture areas' with
common elements of environment and language groups, the Plains, Plateau and Woodlands
(Great Lakes). History and tradition will start this examination, along with the powwow’s inter-
tribal effect on music, and the directions taken by modern musicians. The Crow and Northern
Cheyenne of southeastern Montana are classified with the Plains culture group. Fort Peck is
home to Assiniboine and Sioux, which are also Plains cultures. Fort Belknap is also home to
Assiniboine people, and to members of the Gros Ventre tribe (also a Plains culture). The
Chippewa and Cree, of Great Lakes/Woodlands origin, live on Rocky Boy's Reservation. The
Little Shell group is considered a part of the Chippewa people. The Blackfeet still live on the
eastern slope of the Rocky Mountains, and their music shares most of the characteristics of
Plains music. The Flathead Indian Reservation is home to the Confederated Salish and Kootenai
tribes, which are a combination of the Salish, the Pend d'Oreille and the Kootenai people. The
Flathead residents are considered members of the Plateau culture group. Merriam's (1955) study
of Flathead music took place on this reservation. The Plateau, the cultural region of people who
lived in the Columbia River drainage between the Rockies and the Cascades, influenced their
language and culture, but the Plains influenced their music. Music is only one part of a culture,
and it is shaped by other parts of the culture – religion, language, and environment (See map).
This paper will introduce the music of the twelve registered tribes of Montana, placing the music
into three major groups based on the original homes of each of the groups.
Montana Music 4
Map from
(MT.gov, 2008)
Montana Music 5
Where does music originate? “Native Americans consider music to be a gift from the
Creator. All music is part of the Universe and individuals are allowed by the Creator to 'catch' a
song from this source. Music might be the product of an individual...or a result of communal
effort” (Burton, 1993, p. 22). It then becomes part of oral history. “Music serves to join the
natural with the supernatural, the person with the Creator” (p.22). The sharp distinctions of
musician and non-musician, sacred and secular, do not seem to apply to this traditional music.
The harmony and community are intrinsic to the music. War songs, dance songs, lullabies,
hunting songs, work songs, and songs of peace and unity are links between members of families
Musical Characteristics
A vocable is a non-word vocal sound or syllable. “Vocables are used by virtually all
Native American groups....Vocables, however, may or may not have specific meaning to the
performer or a specific 'initiated' audience. In no case are they felt to be 'silly sounds' or
'nonsense syllables.' “A song may consist solely of vocables, solely of linguistic text, or contain
both text and vocables.” (Burton, 1993, p. 23) Burton said of the selections in his book, that he
was mostly using vocables for lyrics, either because that is how it was passed along, or for
In 1939, Oscar Lewis was invited to sing when he was leaving the Blackfeet. He
responded with an aria, and the listeners were amused because white music had so many words.
They wondered why he would sing, if he really wanted to talk (Nettl, 1989). It appears that the
few words used in much of Native music have rich connotations. The vocables are not nonsense
syllables, either. They are fixed, and may be remnants of forgotten earlier languages.
Montana Music 6
music. In the early Twentieth century, the Smithsonian published a series of bulletins from the
Bureau of Ethnology. Some have been reprinted, and are interesting resources for historic music
from an analytical view. One should remember, when viewing these collections of transcribed
music, that they are filtered through the musicologists’ scale and temperament training, so may
be only an approximation of what was actually sung at the time. There is no reason to expect the
traditional music of the Native American to conform to the European tunings. This is especially
apparent in the flute. The instrument from Woodlands group varies significantly from that of the
Plains group, and there is also variation in individual instruments within each group (Nakai &
Demars, 1996).
One recent find includes a bone flute over 40,000 years old. The flute is one of the oldest
of human instruments, and it appears in all three culture groups. The traditions of flute-making,
performance and philosophy are not documented. Much traditional flute music was lost because
of colonization, government suppression and overt cultural change. (Nakai & Demars, 1996)
Each instrument is an individual. The flute is suited to individual expression and was not used
for ensemble performance. Each instrument is a personal work of art. One can find facsimiles of
traditional flutes sold today. The small animal on the block is actually a functioning part of the
instrument, not mere decoration. The instrument was highly personal in decoration and
intonation. “Flutes originated among the Plains tribes as courtship instruments although the
instrument is now used for all kinds of music” (Burton, 1993, p. 31). The traditional flute is
hand-made, to fit the player, usually by the player under the supervision of a teacher. Some
makers now are standardizing their instruments. “Each player ...attempts to match the instrument
Montana Music 7
to his voice and songs” (Burton, 1993, p. 31). The novice learns from the experienced player,
and gradually learns ornamentation and improvisation in the player’s own individualized style.
Burton (1993), in studying the traditional style, found an abundance of ornamentation - grace
notes, portamenti, tremolos and mordents. The flute or flageolet was also reported in the
Flathead reservation in 1950 (Merriam & Merriam, 1955). The music of Joseph Firecrow of
Montana is a modern player of traditional flute music, though he has added other instruments in
some pieces. Mary Youngblood, of Northern California, is one of the few female Native flute
players who records her work. The instrument has persisted through time among the cultures
The largest group of people living on Montana reservations are the people of the Great
Plains. Some authors group the Chippewa and Cree as Great Plains cultures, while others
consider them separately, as part of the Great Lakes culture groups. The Northwest Coast and
Traditional music is passed on from oral tradition, and language also shapes music. The
spoken languages here are grouped into Salishian, Siouan and Algonquian by linguists.
(Gabarino & Sasso, 1993 and WALS, 2005). Languages, while important, are another study
entirely.
Music is not static, but there are snapshots of historical patterns. Nettl (1954) and Burton
(1993), in describing traditional music from the Plains area, characterized certain common vocal
techniques and characteristics. Very loud singing, especially in unison, vocal tension, pulsations,
sudden changes in dynamics and pitch, and a predominance of descending patterns are typical.
Montana Music 8
Melodies start high, and the last note is the lowest. The large drum seen at powwows is a Plains
sense. The sound of a large drum and loud voices would be necessary to carry well in open
country. Nettl (1954) described the Northern Plains sub-genre. The range, he said, is about an
octave to a tenth, the scale is often tetratonic (a four-note scale) or pentatonic (a five-note scale),
and the intervals are mostly thirds (some find these to be between a major and minor third,
perhaps a microtone) and minor seconds. Some musicologists do not find a direct
correspondence with regulated pitches. Nettl described a frequent construction as “tonic, perfect
fourth, perfect fifth, major sixth, octave, and major ninth” (p 29). This limited number of notes,
(do, fa, sol, la, do, and re) though not a complete diatonic scale, still allows complexity in
melody. He continued, “The melodic movement is of the terrace type” (p. 29) and rhythmically
complex. Terrace movement is a melodic line wherein “each phrase descends, and each begins
somewhat lower than the previous one.” (p.24) These analyses were based on recordings and
transcriptions.
The Blackfeet of the nineteenth century had “much in common with other Northern
Plains tribes such as the Crow, Cheyenne, Arapaho, and Gros Ventre, but they also shared
customs and other culture traits with the Flathead, a Salish-speaking people on the western side
of the Continental Divide in Montana, and with the Algonquian-speaking Cree, directly northeast
This is not to say that there was only one cultural identity among all these tribes, but that
many had certain common characteristics. Certain ideas were linked, culturally and
linguistically. Conceptually, the idea of dance included the idea of ceremony and the idea of
Montana Music 9
singing included the idea of drumming, as the two were inseparable. Singing was tied to events,
not used as background music. Songs could be adopted from other tribes, however (Nettl, 1989).
Densmore (1972) analyzed many Chippewa songs. She wrote (p.6) that “in 70 percent of
the songs the first progression is downward and...that 65 percent of the entire number of
progressions of the song are downward. It has been noted that in 90 percent of the songs the last
tone is the lowest of the song.” This suggests the terrace movement that Nettl had described, but
there is a difference. Densmore (1972) stated, “[T]he correspondence between the music of the
Chippewa and the Sioux, which may be attributed to contact of the two tribes, is rhythmic, not
melodic.” (p. 11). However, she found that tones were not loud.
Burton (1993) described “Eastern Woodlands” style with several features including
“relaxed voices in medium and high range”, “use of song cycles”, and “frequent use of call and
response” (p 24). The Mide song cycle, a very important group of spiritual songs of the
Chippewa seems much closer to this description. Sadie and Ashkenazy (2004) stated that the
Chippewa (Great Lakes) sing short call- and -response songs with simple rhythms and
undulating melodies” (p 14). The region, historically, was a mix of evergreen and deciduous
forest, with abundant wildlife. Music from this region would be different from the Plains style,
and this can be seen to be the case with the Chippewa and Cree music. “The voices of
the...Ojibway are likened to the flute. Nasality only exists in the upper register and the tone
becomes harsh only when projection over distance is required; in a closed space the tone remains
mellow. An Ojibway male averages at least two octaves,” according to Lavonis (2004). The Cree
and Chippewa music is Woodlands style, though they moved westward in the late 1600s and
early 1700s. For more history of the Ojibway people, see http://www.tolatsga.org/ojib.html.
Montana Music 1
Plateau/Coastal
There is some disagreement concerning the origins of the Flathead people; “the Flathead
have a clear linguistic relationship to the Salishian-speaking peoples west of them” (Merriam,
1967, p. 148). However, “If we assume that the Flathead are indeed Salish, on linguistic and
some cultural evidence, then we should expect that their music system would also be Salish, or at
least that it was Salish at some time in the past.” (Merriam, 1967, p. 148).
If their music was typical of the Northwest Coast, we would expect complex percussion
rhythms, elaborate dramas with masks, slit drums, upward key changes, and polyphony (music
that is not unison, but more than one voice and rhythm) (Burton, 1993). Merriam (1967) pointed
out that the language is Salish, but the music is Plains. How could this happen? Did the language
change, or the musical culture change? “Flathead culture is definitely a mixture of Plains and
Plateau....Flathead music is Plains-type” (Merriam, 1967, p. 149). The borrowing of songs occurs
from time to time, but this is more than a few songs. The Flathead lived on the eastern Plateau,
near the Shoshoni people. History does not record the details.
Music is contextual, and there have been changes in the Flathead music also. How many
“As recently as the 1950's some old people whose contact with the traditional past was
firsthand were still alive. They were people who had made the trek from the Bitterroot to the
Jocko reservation area with Chief Charlot in 1891. They had lived in tipis..., had gone on the
annual hunting trek...been married under the conditions of the Marriage Dance, had participated
in the scalp dance...Since 1960, the two old women who persisted in practicing the First Roots
The loss of the ceremonies and rituals leads to the loss of the music, but the basic form
does not change. Music and cultural identity have strong links, and much more study of these
past treasures could be completed. Densmore, Nettl, and Merriam are good authors for the seeker
who wants to begin with the historical study of the Montana tribes’ music.
Some of the characteristics of traditional music are preserved today, but there have been
strong influences for change since the time of the contact of cultures in the past two centuries.
In the late part of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth, two major
pan-Indian movements occurred. The Ghost Dance started among the Ute people, and quickly
spread throughout the Plains. The founder advised his followers to live in peace, learn to farm,
and dance for the restoration of the grasslands. There were variations on this message, and the
The Peyote dance was part of the Native American Church, a mixture of Christian
teachings and the peyote spiritual quests, which was spread by the Comanche. The use of peyote
was believed to aid in communion with God and to promote physical and spiritual healing. This
practice is perhaps 3000 years old in Mexico. The Blackfeet people, however, resisted both the
Ghost Dance movement of the 1880s and the Peyote dance of the twentieth century (Nettl,
1989). The Ghost Dance was widespread in the Plains for a short time, but it is significant as a
pan-Indian musical movement. The “Arapaho had and still have large Peyote and Ghost Dance
In 1789, wrote Merriam (1967),the Hudson Bay Company trappers came to Flathead
country, along with 250 Iroquois. These Iroquois were Catholic, and shared their teaching and
Montana Music 1
hymns, and conducted services of preaching which also included singing and dancing,
Nettl (1989) pointed out that in the twentieth century, the Blackfeet repertoire added the
Grass Dance from the Assiniboine, the Owl or Rabbit dance and the Forty-Niner. Indian Days,
beginning in the 1940s and powwow culture in the 1950s also were strong influences. The songs
of certain ceremonies have been lost, and intertribal songs have been added. Singing retains the
Plains style – high and loud, with pulsations. “The Blackfoot style is essential” (p. 68), he adds,
suggesting that certain vocal stylistic elements remain in spite of additions to repertoire and new
Among the Blackfeet, “[i]n the 1980s, although women's “drums” were recognized and
some women were listed as members of singing groups, the title of “singer” or “drummer” was
gender-specific” (Nettl,1989, p. 83). The author continued, “The general implication of the
literature is that women participate in the same musical culture as men, but do so to a smaller
extent than men” (p. 84). Among the Blackfeet, songs are a link to the supernatural, and to
society. It appears that songs have a power of their own. B. Nettl (1989)
among the Ojibwé and the Oyaté people. Some saw the changes as inevitable, but others strongly
resisted the outside influences of a social event with a long history. The author made a
distinction between the traditional powwow, which renews the connection to earth and each
other, and the contest powwow, which is danced for money. The contest powwow style seems to
cause a blending of intertribal and traditional forms by the addition of new dances, regalia, and
music, and for many, the effect is quite uncomfortable. The origin of the powwow is traced back
to the Hethushka, a war dance, of the Omaha and Ponca, which was danced in their warrior
Montana Music 1
societies. The feathers, scalps (later replaced by sweetgrass) and feather bustles were used. The
dance spread to the Ojibwé, and became secular. The large drum was a change for the Ojibwé,
who had previously used hand drums. This dance was called the Omaha dance by some, and
became known as the grass dance among the Lakota (DesJarlait, 1997).
Even though competitive dancing was centuries old, the modern contest powwow is
thought to have begun in the 1880s in Oklahoma. “The 1950s and 1960s were formative years of
the modern contest powwow in which the organizational aspects were influenced by the rodeo;
the elimination point system, exhibition, day money, grand entry and retreat are but a few
examples” (DesJarlait, 1997, p. 120). This changed the Oyaté social dance significantly.
Northern Plains clothing styles, intertribal rules and regulations predominated, and the traditional
powwow fell into decline. Local tradition and custom often conflicted with the intertribal
traditions (DesJarlait, 1997). Though some may see powwows as a homogenization of the
cultures, this is not necessarily the case. “Our dance clothing reminds us of the beauty of our
culture and of our race. Through our dance, the dance outfit becomes the art that makes visible
the utterance of our soul-spirits...the dance outfit defines who we are and where we came
from”(p. 123).
Still, the majority of drum groups are exclusively male, though a few female groups are
appearing. In 1993, the Rising Hail Singers (Dakota) were not well –received at an Ojibwé-
Anishinaabé traditional powwow (DesJarlait, 1997). At contest powwows, drum groups with
female singers are more common. DesJarlait (1997) mentioned the Cathedral Lake Singers,
Little Boy Singers, and the Ironwood Singers as popular female drum groups. An example of
BM&feature=related . Notice the female singers standing back, but joining in the song; this is
The Sweetgrass Road Drum Group of Winnipeg sued the University of Saint Thomas
when the annual (2001) powwow excluded the group because they were female. The singers
cited preservation of the songs and the increasing responsibilities of women in modern society,
and the spiritual advisor cited traditional belief. The university claimed religious freedom in its
defense (Flores, 2002). (The powwow was canceled). In spite of the differences and the conflict
between traditional and competition powwow, the author said, “it is the Drum, which symbolizes
peace and good will between communities, that has brought people together” (DesJarlait, 1997,
p. 126). Individual differences remain, and tribal unity and identity are not disappearing.
Conclusion
What are responsibilities of the teacher? One cannot claim what one does not own. If one
is not a member of a tribe, one cannot claim authority about the tribe. Tradition and copyright
protect the songs, and so does respect for the owners of the songs. The music that is
recommended here for study is freely available in libraries.We must treat the works of other
nations and religions with respect, and any hint of condescension will not be tolerated. Do
children of the non-European nations feel disenfranchised when all they hear in schools are
English/German/Italian works? Possibly. Can presenting music from other cultures than one's
own be of benefit? Definitely. Local leaders can be consulted, and many are happy to help.
Check with the nearest cultural outreach office, as listed in the appendix. Music can be a bridge
rather than a barrier. There is no such thing as a single music or tribe that defines all of the
cultural richness and beauty of Native people. Each individual and group has a sound and music
“There are occasional experiments mixing styles, with harmony, on guitar or piano, the
incorporation of modern Indian tunes into rock and roll, the adoption of hymn and popular
melodies into Blackfoot repertory” (Nettl, 1989, p. 68). There are certainly examples of this
available to the seeker today. A number of Native performers incorporate traditional sounds and
modern styles in their recordings. Some examples show a rich variety: Rezawrecktion, from
Crow country, plays Christian rap. Joseph Firecrow, of the Northern Cheyenne, plays a blend of
traditional flute and modern synthesizer. Paul Underwood of Exitwound, also Northern
Cheyenne, plays heavy metal/new age but with some elements of traditional music. Under the
Green Corn Moon is a collection of lullabies from various tribes. The Rocky Boys Singers have
recorded powwow and traditional Cree-Chippewa music. Jack Gladstone of the Blackfeet sings
in a country-western style. Jared Stewart (Crow) plays blues; Young Grey Horse preserves songs
Scott Prinzig of Billings, who writes music reviews for the independent newspaper
Outpost, has written a guide to Native Music called “American Indian Music: More Than Just
Flutes and Drums” for the Office of Public Instruction, and has also given similar information in
presentations about Native American performers. Paul Underwood and Jack Gladstone have
(Personal communication, October 14, 2008 and November 19, 2008, respectively).
Teachers may find the following selections useful: Joseph Fire Crow's “Wolf Song” and
“Wind in My Mind” from Northern Cheyenne Flute, Exitwound's “Spirits of the Pack” from
After the Storm, lullabies of Under the Green Corn Moon, the music of Brule, “Buffalo Cafe” by
Jack Gladstone and “Someone Else's Door” from Scott Prinzig's CD to accompany the OPI
collection. Though the focus is on Montana tribes and groups, students may find the South
Montana Music 1
Dakota group Brule interesting. A few examples are included of music from tribes not
represented on Montana reservations, since the reservations are not the total Native population of
our state. Additional Resources are given at the end of this paper.
The seeker needs only to listen. Many people believe that music comes from the heart,
and opening one's heart to someone else's music is a journey worth taking. The reader is
encouraged to explore the musical heritage of the students who attend our schools.
Our students, and we, can benefit from what Paul Underwood said. “Don't let anybody
tell you that you can't live your dreams” (personal communication October 14, 2008).
Montana Music 1
References
http://www.nris.mt.gov/gis/gisdatalib/downloads/ab9.gif
Burton, B. (1993). Moving within the circle. Danbury, Connecticut: World Music Press.
Densmore, F. (1972). Chippewa music. [Reprint of no. 45 and 53 of the Smithsonian Institution,
Bureau of American Ethnology bulletins]. New York: DaCapo Press. (Original work
published 1913)
DesJarlait, R. (1997). The Contest Powwow versus the Traditional Powwow and the role of the
Native American community. Wicazo Sa Review, 12(1), 115 - 127. Retrieved October 23,
2008, from JSTOR: Wicazo Sa Review Vol 12, No. 1 (Spring 1997): http://jstor.org
Flores, C. (May 31, 2002). Drumming up a lawsuit? The Chronicle of Higher Education, 48, 38.
EBSCO
Gabarino, M., & Sasso, R. (1993). Native American heritage (3rd). Prospect Heights, Illinois:
Waveland Press.
Lavonis, W. (2004). A study of Native American singing and song. Lewiston, New York: Edward
Mellen Press.
Company.
Merriam, A., & Merriam, B. (1955). The ethnography of Flathead Indian music (2). Missoula:
Western Anthropology.
Nakai, R. C., & Demars, J. (1996). The art of the Native American flute. Phoenix: Canyon
Records.
Montana Music 1
Nettl, B. (1954). North American Indian musical styles. Philadelphia: American Folklore
Society.
Nettl, B. (1989). Blackfoot musical thought. Kent, Ohio: Kent State University Press.
Sadie, S., & Ashkenazy,., V. (2004). In Billboard encyclopedia of classical music (Billboard
Additional Resources