Cutting The
Cutting The
Cutting The
Cover Story p. 10
www.foodmanufacturing.com January/February 2013
Vol. 26, No. 1
Cutting the
Mustard
From farmhouse basement to
70,000-square-foot manufacturing
space, Oregons Beaverton Foods
has been spicing up meals around
the world for nearly 80 years.
From farmhouse
basement to 70,000-
square-foot manufac-
turing space, Oregons
Beaverton Foods has
been spicing up meals
around the world for
nearly 80 years.
10 Cover Story:
8 Industry Target: Meat Processing
14 Questions and Answers: Pest Control
Patricia Hottel of McCloud Services discusses the risks
of Hantavirus and what food processors need to know to
keep their facilities safe.
16 Tech Niche: Pumps & Valves
18 Exclusive Feature:
Truth in Labeling & What It Means for You
The legal battle over industry labeling practices has begun.
Here's what food processors can do to ensure their brands
are safe from litigation.
20 Product Spotlight: Feeding
22 Brainstorm: Poultry Processing
Industry experts weigh in on the more automated future of
poultry processing.
30 Industry Insider: Poultry Industry
Foreign objects detection in poultry processing operations gets
a hi-tech upgrade.
CONTENTS
7 What's the Buzz
Insiders reflect on the latest news
26 Product Review
Latest product releases
28 Food Safety Update
Meat, poultry and seafood
FM1301_FrycoverDigital.indd 1 1/22/2013 8:41:31 AM
omega.com
74-05
1
4" Diameter Probe Design for Standard Duty,
or
3
8" to
3
16" Stepped Probe Design for
Heavy Duty Applications
Probe Lengths of 3", 4", 5" and 6" Available
From Stock, Other Lengths Also Available
Process Connection is a 1"-16 AMP Tri-Grip
(Tri-Clamp
Trademark of The Dow Chemical Company (Dow) or an afliated company of Dow. ProFume is a federally Restricted Use Pesticide.
Always read and follow label directions. 2013 Dow AgroSciences LLC U38-129-010 (12/12) BR 010-71598 DAPMPRFM0056
Keep food quality high and your facility up and running using ProFume
tools
and techniques. Fully customizable with real-time monitoring and results documentation, its technology that reduces
downtime in no time. Learn more about the intelligent solution for precise pest management at www.GetProFume.com.
FM1301_Ads.indd 13 1/7/2013 2:11:38 PM
14
January/February 2013
14
Q:
A:
January/February 2013
Briefly tell us about the recent hantavirus outbreak at
Yosemite National Park.
At last count, nine visitors to Yosemite National Park con-
tracted hantavirus while visiting the park, and three people
died from the disease. The majority of campers were stay-
ing at the Signature Tent Cabins in the Curry Village site.
The park service is still investigating the cause, but possible
causes include contamination in cabin sites by deer mice or
storage sites associated with the cabins.
What is hantavirus and what risks does it pose to food
manufacturing facilities?
Hantavirus is not a foodborne illness, so it doesnt pose a
risk to the food a facility produces but can place employees
at risk, especially if they are involved in pest management
procedures involving one of the rodent species that car-
ries hantavirus. Proper training should be provided to these
employees on how to prevent transmission. It is also impor-
tant to educate employees who may be involved in clean
up of fecal material and urine of the carriers. The disease is
relatively rare, but it does have a fairly high fatality rate.
How is hantavirus spread, and what risks does it pose to
plant safety?
It is important to make sure employees are educated in the
proper procedures to follow when handling equipment or
surfaces which may have been contaminated with fecal pel-
lets or urine of the hantavirus-carrying rodents. Hantavirus
is transmitted by airborne droplets of urine, saliva and fecal
material. The mode of transmission to humans is through
inhalation. So the
concern is for pro-
tecting employees
and contractors who might be involved in the capture, con-
trol and clean-up of these rodents.
What conditions are favorable for deer mice infestation?
We have seen higher numbers of deer mice in certain parts
of the United States this year. When environmental condi-
tions such as temperature are more favorable and food is in
greater abundance, we expect populations to be higher. We
had an unusually warm winter in 2012, and that seems to
be contributing to higher populations of rodents in general,
including deer mice.
What can food companies do to prevent deer mice infes-
tation and Hantavirus?
Exposure to hantavirus can be reduced by managing rodents
around the facility. Many of the procedures used for manag-
ing commensal rodents like the house mouse will work for
deer mice. Reducing conditions which support the growth
of rodent populations around the facility must be done in
conjunction with exclusion methods. Keeping vegetation
away from the structure and reducing exterior food spills are
important.
Seeds, insects and weeds around the structure can provide
food sources for these animals. They will also take advan-
tage of food spills, which may contain grains, nuts, pet
food, seeds or grain-based products. Maintaining vegetation-
free barriers and reducing food spills are important in deer
mouse management.
A recent outbreak of hantavirus at Yosemite National Park has raised
concern about potential rodent infestation and hantavirus outbreaks in
manufacturing plants, including food facilities. Patricia Hottel of McCloud
Services discusses the risks of hantavirus and how food companies can
keep their employees safe from the disease.
Q:
A:
Q:
A:
Q:
A:
Q:
A:
Hantavirus: Are Your
Employees at Risk?
with Patricia Hottel, Technical Director, McCloud Services
FM1301_Q&A.indd 14 1/9/2013 9:22:56 AM
15
January/February 2013
Clarion
Q:
A:
FM1301_Q&A.indd 15 1/9/2013 9:23:57 AM
16 TECH NICHE: PUMPS & VALVES
January/February 2013
Sanitary Pumps
Sanitary Pumps offer application versatility. They are ideal for any ap-
plication where bacteria and contamination must be avoided or frequent
clean-up is required. Product features include:
Quick disassembly design for easy cleaning
No valves to clog or vapor lock
Ability to handle thin liquids like soups and juices
Efficiently moves viscous slurries like peanut putter, candies and jam
Ability to handle fluid temperatures to 400F and solids up to one inch in
diameter
150 standard models meet 3A sanitary requirements
Standard mechanical seals
Close-coupled/open throat design
Moyno, Inc. www.moyno.com
Fire-Safe Globe
Valves
The Clampseal fire-safe
forged globe valves are
designed for plants where
fire safety is a major con-
cern. The fire-safe valves
are available in Y, angle and
T-pattern configurations in
0.5- through 4-inch sizes;
up to ANSI 4500 pressure
ratings; and with NPT, butt
weld or socket weld ends.
The valve contains a simple
mechanism that compen-
sates for thermal expansion.
As a result of this and other
design features, the valve
meets API fire-safe standards by high margins. The testing procedure
calls for the test valve to be placed in-line and pressurized for 75% of
rated pressure, then subjected to a 1,400 to 1,800F fire for 30 minutes.
The valve is then quenched with water to cool it to ambient temperature,
cycled to prove operability, then subjected to further testing. The valve is
required to maintain strict leakage allowances during and after the burn.
Conval www.Conval.com
Sine Pumps
for Cheese
Curds
Companys sine
pump technology
produces power-
ful suction with
low shear and no
pulsation. Large,
open cavities allow
the transfer of curd
with little damage,
producing a higher
yield and fat content
while reducing fines.
Undamaged curd requires less dressing, reduces fines and prevents
plugs in the drain table resulting in less down-time and higher productiv-
ity. Unlike lobe pumps, the pumps are engineered for long service life
eliminating the high cost and inconvenience of off-site factory remanu-
facturing or reconditioning. The pumps meet 3-A SSI.
MasoSine www.masosine.com
FM1301_TechNiche.indd 16 1/14/2013 11:10:52 AM
The most trusted name in Stainless Steel Conveyors
Since 1974, Kamflex has engineered and manufactured quality
stainless steel sanitary conveyors. Our engineering response
time is the best in the industry and our quality has no equal.
Contact Kamflex the next time you need a stainless steel conveyor.
Let us make it easy for you.
1321 West 119th Street, Chicago, Illinois 60643-5109 Tel. 1 800 323 2440
www.kamflex.com
17
www.foodmanufacturing.com
Rotary Valve with High-capacity Rotor
Design
The SD Series of rotary valves is designed to provide increased bulk
material throughput efficiency in feeding and metering applications. The
construction provides a larger pocket area between the vanes of the rotor,
enabling greater pocket-fill capacity. Calculated at 100% pocket-fill capac-
ity, the valves can move over 5% more cubic feet per revolution (CFR) of
bulk material than a comparable 8-vane rotary valve. The valve housings
are cast to ensure strength in the composition and solidification of the
housings metallurgy, and to eliminate dimples, crevices and pits on the
housings product contact areas and other surfaces. The valves are avail-
able in cast iron, or 304 or 316 stainless steel; in 4 square-flange sizes
from 6 to 12 inches; and 4 heights from 10 inches to 18 inches. They can
perform in temperature applications up to 250F.
ACS Valves www.acsvalves.com
AC Variable Speed Drive for Pump
Control
The AC30V series combines ease-of-use with high levels of control for
applications where reliable, accurate motor speed control are key re-
quirements. Offered in three frame sizes that cover a power range of 1
through 25 HP (0.75 kW to 18.5 kW) with additional models to 150 HP
planned, the series features conformally coated PC boards to protect
against corrosion when used in harsh environments and a choice of
integrated filtering options for compatibility with commercial and in-
dustrial instal-
lations. The
series can be
mounted as
either an IP20
backplate
or through-
panel drive.
Operating
temperature
range for the
new drives is
0C to +50C.
Modular de-
sign enables
the quick-
and-easy
addition of a range of extensions to suit specific applications. These
include popular communications options such as Profinet, Profibus and
EtherCAT, plus a range of I/O modules. A multi-language graphical key-
pad can be mounted on the drive or can provide remote access to all
drive functions to facilitate fast and easy configuration without expert
user knowledge.
Parker Hannifin Corporation www.parker.com
FM1301_TechNiche.indd 17 1/14/2013 11:11:08 AM
January/February 2013
18 EXCLUSIVE FEATURE
W
illiam Shakespeare once wrote:
Whats in a name? That which
we call a rose
By any other name would smell as
sweet.
Shakespeare, while perhaps the greatest
writer in the English language, would never
have made it as a lawyer. Because, as a recent
litigation trend makes clear, what is in a name,
what label one gives to describe an item,
makes a huge difference, at least with regard to
the potential liability of a food manufacturer.
One of the most explosive litigation trends
in our tort system right now is the large uptick
in the number of suits targeting the labeling
practices of food manufacturers. Indeed, a huge
number of such suits were filed in 2012 alone.
And more such suits appear to be on the way
in 2013. The New York Times documented
this trend in an article on Aug. 18, 2012, titled
Lawyers From Suits Against Big Tobacco Target
Food Makers.
The current landscape of such lawsuits can
be divided into three categories.
Lawsuits by individuals or
groups of plaintiffs against
a food manufacturer
Most of the lawsuits related to labeling
involve groups of plaintiffs suing a food manu-
facturer. Most allege that the labeling of a food
item was deceptive. One recent example is the
recently-settled suit against the maker of fruit
roll-ups alleging deceptive advertising based
on the word fruit
1
. The plaintiff alleged that
she relied upon the representations [that the
product was made from fruit] in making her
decision to purchase the products at [a] pre-
mium price
1
. The defendant moved to dismiss.
In what may have been a surprise to some in
the food industry, the court allowed parts of the
case to proceed toward trial.
The chief focus in recent months has
appeared to be on foods labeled as natural
or healthy. One example is a recent lawsuit
filed against a manufacturer of granola bars
alleging that the bars were deceptively labeled
as all natural
2
. Another is a proposed class
action challenging All-Natural labeling against
a manufacturer of nutrition bars when the bars
allegedly contain synthetic ingredients. The suit
survived the defendants motion to dismiss in
late 2012
3
.
Such suits, at least in recent months, have
mostly been filed in one of two jurisdictions
California and New Jersey. California appears
for now to be the favored forum for these suits
based in large part on that states strong statu-
tory prohibitions against false or deceptive
advertising.
These suits have met with mixed success
thus far. While some have resulted in multi-
million dollar settlements against the food
manufacturer and certifications of class actions,
others have been dismissed. For instance, one
recent case resulted in a settlement that offered
consumers who had purchased the allegedly
deceptively labeled product $4 for each jar
previously purchased, up to $20 total
4
. On the
other hand, a California state court recently
dismissed a class action against a manufacturer
of coconut water, holding that allegations that
the defendants product contained a false nutri-
tional label were preempted by federal law
5
.
The court also found that other claims related to
the products superior hydrating powers were
allowable puffery
5
.
The fate of this litigation, whether it is merely
a blip, or as the New York Times suggests,
a threat akin to the tobacco litigation, is still
undecided as many of them have been filed
only recently. Whether these suits move forward
and result in large monetary awards will bear
watching by those in the food industry.
Lawsuits by one food
manufacturer against
another
There have also been recent lawsuits by
those in the food industry against others in the
food industry related to labeling. One example
is a lawsuit by a group of sugar growers against
Archer Daniels Midland Co. and three other high
fructose corn syrup producers, alleging that
the defendants conspired to deceptively brand
corn syrup as a natural product equivalent to
sugar
6
. The sugar growers allege that they have
lost business as a result of the alleged decep-
tion. Recently, the trial court rejected the defen-
dants motions to dismiss, and allowed the suit
to proceed against most of the defendants. By
all accounts, the financial stakes are potentially
huge, considering the plaintiffs have alleged
A Rose by Any Other Name Is a
Lawsuit: The Courtroom Battle
over the Labeling Practices of
Food Manufacturers
Trent Taylor, Partner, McGuireWoods LLP
FM1301_McGuireWood.indd 18 1/15/2013 11:00:31 AM
19
www.foodmanufacturing.com
January/February 2013
that the defendants have already spent at least
$50 million on their rebranding effort.
Actual and Threatened
Lawsuits by Governmental
Agencies Against Food
Manufacturers
The third category of recent labeling lawsuits
is perhaps the most fear-inducing for those
in the food industry. It involves actual and
threatened lawsuits by governmental agencies
against food manufacturers. This is perhaps
due to state and local governments becom-
ing alarmed at the escalating costs of caring
for people with diseases [caused by eating
unhealthy foods] and are putting pressure on
food companies, as noted by the aforemen-
tioned New York Times article.
An example of a threatened lawsuit is the
recent investigation by New Yorks attorney
general against the makers of energy drinks.
The investigation centers on whether these com-
panies are deceiving consumers in a number of
ways, including the amount of caffeine in their
drinks, the health risks generated by consump-
tion of large amounts of caffeine, whether all of
the ingredients in the drinks are properly dis-
closed, and whether the drinks are dietary sup-
plements or foods. To date, the New York attor-
ney general has issued subpoenas to the energy
drink makers as part of the probe. The FDA is
reportedly investigating the industry as well.
State and local governments are not the only
ones pursuing this strategy. The Federal Trade
Commission has won settlements from compa-
nies for claims related to a products health ben-
efits. In addition, public interest groups are also
getting into the act, suing over labeling of various
food products.
Overview of Proposition 37
On another front, various state legislatures
appear to be moving to expand laws requiring
accurate labeling of food products. For instance,
legislatures in at least 20 states have intro-
duced legislation that would require the label-
ing of genetically engineered food. Though only
one state has passed such legislation thus far
(Alaska), it appears to only be a matter of time
before more are passed. In fact, in California, a
new law requiring labeling of genetically engi-
neered food was narrowly defeated as a ballot
initiative in November 2012.
This proposed law, known as Proposition
37, or The California Right to Know Genetically
Engineered Food Act, would have required label-
ing on raw or processed food offered for sale to
consumers if it is made from plants or animals
with genetic material changed. In addition,
Proposition 37 would have prohibited the labeling
or advertisement of any such food as natural
or all natural. Enforcement of any violations
would have been through existing regulations
and the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, which
includes actual damages, injunctive relief, res-
titution, punitive damages, and attorneys fees.
Many observers believed that if Proposition 37
had passed, it would have had a huge impact on
the food industry increasing compliance costs
and opening the door to a whole new target of
litigation. Passage looked likely just a month
or two before Election Day with polls showing
that the measure was leading by more than 40
points, but a late focus on the proposed laws
problems turned the tide and led to a six-point
defeat of the Proposition.
However, the battle appears to be far from
over. The Proposition 37 campaign spokes-
woman, Stacy Melkin, said after its defeat that
they plan to win the
labeling debate over
the long-term and
that [w]e showed
that there is a food
movement in the
United States, and
it is strong, vibrant
and too powerful to
stop. It appears that
there may be a simi-
lar ballot initiative
in Washington State
in November 2013,
and there are current
legislative efforts to
pass similar mea-
sures in Connecticut,
Vermont, and New
Mexico. Moreover,
U.S. senators have
proposed legisla-
tion to permit states
to pass laws like
Proposition 37
(though the latest
effort picked up a
mere 26 votes in the
Senate).
The stakes in this
new wave of lawsuits
are high. The addition or omission of literally one
word in a label can potentially lead to millions of
dollars in liability for a company, millions more
in legal fees, and even lead to investigations into
such practices by federal and state authorities.
Those in the food industry should follow this
trend closely and take steps to prepare for pos-
sible litigation.
1
Lam v. General Mills, Inc., no. 3:11-cv-05056
(N.D. Calif.)
2
Janney v. General Mills, no. 4:12-cv-03919
(N.D. Calif.)
3
Colucci v. Zoneperfect Nutrition Co., no. 12-
2907 (N.D. Calif.)
4
Nutella Marketing and Sales Practices
Litigation, no. 3:11-cv-01086 (D. N.J.)
5
Shenkman v. One World Enterprises, LLC, no.
BC467165 (Los Angeles County)
6
Western Sugar Cooperative et al. v. Archer-
Daniels-Midland Co. et al., case number 2:11-cv-
03473 (C.D. Calif.)
buntingmagnetics.com
(800) 835-2526
or 316-284-2020 (outside USA and Canada)
2013 Bunting Magnetics Co.
Rejection is Good
Ensure product safety with
integration into vacuum fillers
MeatLine 05
Metal Detector
FM1301_McGuireWood.indd 19 1/15/2013 10:44:52 AM
20 SPOTLIGHT ON: CONVEYING
January/February 2013
Conveyor
Changeover
Innovations
Company is ramping up
technology to help cus-
tomers with changeover
efficiency. Growing to
hundreds of available
application-specific in-
novative options, the
changeover offerings range from low-tech adjustable bracket and rail
assemblies to fully automated guide rail systems. The following pro-
grams and events are available:
New videos and web pages on conveyor changeover solutions
A new white paper, Packaging Line Changeover: Conveyor
Technology that Cuts Time
An upcoming webinar, How to Increase Line Efficiency by Reducing
Changeover Time, Live on February 7th at 2pm EST
An ROI analysis tool that compares purchase cost to changeover man
hours
Nercon Eng. & Mfg., Inc. www.nercon.com
Sanitary Vibratory
Conveyors
These sanitary vibratory conveyors
combine proprietary vibrating technol-
ogy with continuously welded stainless
steel troughs to effectively convey high
value and sensitive materials while
safeguarding against product contamination and protecting particle shape
and integrity. The conveyors feature Companys own forced vibration
drive system to create a gentle, efficient, linear conveying action suit-
able for low-maintenance, 24/7 operation. Designed to meet FDA, USDA
and 3-A standards and regulations, the conveyors eliminate the risk of
contamination common to belt and roller conveyors as well as the risk
to product and particle integrity common to pneumatic conveyors and
may be quickly accessed or disassembled by one person for inspection
and cleaning. The vibrating conveyors are available in 11, 17 and 23
standard rectangular widths in lengths up to 40 feet and in custom sizes
and configurations to suit a variety of product, process and plant require-
ments. Fully enclosed tubular trough designs are also available.
Witte Company, Inc. www.witte.com
Horizontal Motion
Accumulating
Conveyor
The Slipstick Horizontal Motion
Accumulating Conveyor is designed for
sanitary on-line storage of product. The
one-piece seamless conveyor pan elimi-
nates cracks, crevices and moving parts in
the process stream, reducing the risk of cross-contamination that com-
monly occurs when using a belt storage unit. The gentle horizontal mo-
tion of the conveyor is suited for the storage and discharge of the most
fragile products. The machines can be equipped with a pneumatically
actuated product dam and level sensors to meter product to downstream
equipment.
Triple/S Dynamics www.sssdynamics.com
Electric Pump
Options for Vacuum
Conveyors
Variants of the VS series of vacuum
conveyors feature electric pump op-
tions. These new pump options mount
a purpose-designed Electric Switch
Box Assembly (EPV) directly on the
receiver. Because the EPV includes a
non-return valve and vacuum relief
valve as standard, the unit can be
coupled to any electrically driven
vacuum pump assembly, providing
greater flexibility for end users.
Volkmann www.volkmannUSA.com
FM1301_ProductSpotlight.indd 21 1/14/2013 11:12:05 AM
22
Te Food Manufacturing Brainstorm features industry experts
sharing their perspectives on issues critical to the overall food
industry marketplace. In this issue, we ask:
Poultry has long been one of the least automated food pro-
cessing sectors. As automation equipment becomes more
sophisticated, how will poultry processors see their business
practices change?
John Kadinger, Market Manager, Key Technology
As poultry processors automate manual processes and as automated equipment becomes more sophisticated,
one of the most important business practices that will need to change is employee training. Automating manual
processes and transitioning the labor force from unskilled work toward becoming skilled technicians helps eliminate
highly repetitive manual tasks with high injury rates and addresses the challenges associated with a growing short-
age of unskilled labor. Having well trained people operating, maintaining, cleaning and supervising automated equip-
ment improves the effectiveness of that equipment.
As automated equipment becomes more sophisticated, business practices will also change in the areas of process
monitoring and record keeping. Many automated systems facilitate record keeping and utilizing this capability will
help satisfy the FDAs Food Safety Modernization Act and enable processors to quickly deliver the necessary data to
inspectors who visit the plant to verify compliance. In addition to addressing changing industry guidelines, improved
record keeping can help assure that final product quality and food safety is being maintained.
The processors that understand the interaction of the line components and consider the system as a whole can better select machines that
work harmoniously and integrate controls so the machines communicate seamlessly. This high level of integration, which could include connect-
ing equipment to a plant-wide SCADA network, helps maximize the output of the equipment while maintaining the highest product quality and
operational efficiency. In order to fully achieve the benefits of a well-integrated line, processors will likely become more dependent on suppliers
who can provide deep industry expertise and integration services.
BRAIN
STORM
January/February 2013 <
Lindsay Galas, Global Marketing Manager for Meat & Poultry,
Videojet
Sophisticated automation in poultry processing will further standardize packaging, increasing product safety. We
have seen some of this improvement due to the shift from in-store butchers to case-ready retail packaging. By elimi-
nating the handling of raw poultry in the backroom of supermarkets, today many food safety issues are better con-
tained. However, food safety challenges have shifted from butchers to processors, making it even more of a focus for
processors. While automation will continue to decrease contamination risks due to less potential hazard points in the
packaging process, the risk for incorrect labeling and coding on poultry products increases due to more system com-
plexity.
Automated systems are only more efficient if managed correctly. Increased regulation including traceability,
country-of-origin and allergy information make labeling and coding on even the most standard poultry products
confusing and often requires manual entry and system monitoring. One challenge for poultry processors today is
managing more and increasing complex codes which escalate the risk of coding and labeling errors, in turn risking product safety. Customers
are turning to more comprehensive and reliable coding systems which are integrated into automatic packing lines to reduce coding errors and
ensure product safety without downtime.
One way to reduce coding errors is investing in Code Assurance solutions, which use advanced coding equipment and software to ensure
the right code is on the right product every time. Combining automated packing technology with advanced coding equipment and networked
software can decrease the risk of human coding errors. For example, code selection during a line changeover can be as simple as scanning a
UPC, which enables poultry processors to easily and efficiently run pre-programmed production cycles, reducing code errors. Code Assurance
solutions in an automated poultry processing environment improve customer safety and the bottom line.
FM1301_BrainStorm.indd 22 1/17/2013 7:34:44 AM
Food &
Beverage.
Full-Strength.
Food Processing
Suppliers Association
When you make the effort to travel to a show, youre looking for
concentrated information from suppliers to your industry.
At PROCESS EXPO, youll find
Experts from every ||nk |n your supply chain
Over 500 |ndustry-focused exh|b|tors
Free up-to-the-m|nute educat|ona| sess|ons
Too|s to he|p optimize production efficiencies
Ways to ensure food safety
Food & beverage experts. Straight up.
www.myprocessexpo.com
NOV. 3-6, 2013
CHICAGO
McCormick Place
South Hall / North Hall
Get the free mobile app at http://gettag.mobi
2
0
1
2
F
P
S
A
No other North American show can match
PROCESS EXPOs precision focus on
food & beverage processing/packaging.
FM1301_Ads.indd 23 1/7/2013 2:12:02 PM
24
For pneumatic conveying and
air ltration inquiries contact:
Mac Process
7901 NW 107th Terrace
Kansas City, MO 64153
888-657-3098
[email protected]
www.macprocessinc.com
For weighing and feeding
inquiries contact:
Schenck AccuRate
746 E. Milwaukee Street
Whitewater, WI 53190
800-558-0184
[email protected]
www.accuratefeeders.com
Together as one company, Mac Process and Schenck AccuRate lead the industry in
the design of material handling systems for a wide range of food manufacturing
applications. From cereals to pasta, snack foods, baking, and many others, over 100
in-house engineers custom design/build 100% compatible systems for pneumatic
conveying, air ltration, and sanitary weighing and feeding. Our Clean Design Initiative
ensures easy to clean equipment without added cost or complexity. World renowned
technologies like E-nity, CRA Valve Line, SEntry Receiver Line, MECHATRON
3-A
Sanitary Feeding Systems, DEA Open Frame Weighfeeding, and our optimum control
systems are proven to improve food quality, reduce waste and lower operating costs.
Mac Process / Schenck AccuRate. Your global source for
pneumatic conveying, air ltration, weighing and feeding solutions.
Safe, quality products made from easy
to clean, sanitary food process systems
Kevin Stump, Product
Marketing Manager,
Bettcher Industries, Inc.
Historically, utilizing equipment designed
to mechanically debone poultry meat at
high volumes has led to quality and yield
problems. Consequently, much of this
product has
been classified
as mechani-
cally separated
chicken (MSC) a
lower-value des-
ignation. As time
and technology
evolves, these
systems are
becoming better
at avoiding bone
contamination, but challenges will always
remain regarding their ability to maximize
meat yields.
The answer lies in adopting automation in
concert with other processing methods that
are somewhat more labor-intensive but which
deliver a highly attractive ROI. This best of
both worlds approach involves using more
automation, while also augmenting poultry
yields and generating higher product prices.
As one example of this dual-track solu-
tion, the Whizard TrimVac is a light-
weight, powered hand tool that combines
trimming and vacuum technology for the
best possible white meat recovery. The
TrimVac tool enables processors to harvest
sub-tender white meat from beneath the
wishbone, eye muscle lean meat that
anchors the breast muscle to the breast
frame, as well as lean meat along the rib,
keel and back.
Tomorrows poultry processing plants
will find their greatest success in how they
exploit the best that automation offers,
while minimizing the downside problems
and risks. Innovations such as the TrimVac
make it easier for processing plants to
adopt automated production methods
without sacrificing product yields, quality or
price levels.
BRAIN
STORM
FM1301_BrainStorm.indd 24 1/18/2013 8:04:01 AM
www.foodmanufacturing.com
25
Christy Miller, Marketing Manager, Eagle Product Inspection
Automation is an important trend within the meat and poultry industry, as computerized equipment increasingly replac-
es manual work. Currently, automated machinery can perform tasks including inventory management, material handling,
quality control and product inspection. Automation improves yield by enhancing control and consistency, reducing the
potential for process errors at each stage of production. By limiting the scope for these errors, manufacturers can opti-
mize the process by which raw material is converted to commercial product, ensuring the highest possible levels of raw
material utilization and the minimal amount of waste.
For this purpose, poultry and meat processors are increasingly implementing x-ray inspection equipment, as it can provide multiple, simultaneous
inspections of different lines with conveyor speeds up to 120 feet per minute, for contaminants such as metal, stone, glass, dense plastics and calci-
fied bones. Other benefits of automation and x-ray inspection include reduced risk of contamination as a result of human error, reduced labor costs,
higher productivity and ensured product consistency. This in turn improves sanitization and aids process certification.
Concerning standard protocols for the integration of machinery in an industrial environment, the latest x-ray systems are network capable provid-
ing remote access. Remote access permits technicians to quickly diagnose and correct issues, reducing downtime and avoiding unnecessary ser-
vice call costs. This feature becomes increasingly important as production lines now employ x-ray systems as critical control points in their Hazard
Analysis & Critical Control Points (HACCP) program
and cannot run without this x-ray system being
fully operational. X-ray machines with networking
capabilities also improve the traceability of products
through software that gathers and communicates
data, such as barcodes, from different systems and
stores it for future reference. This advanced soft-
ware aids meat and poultry manufacturers in case
of recall, allowing them to trace a product back to
any point on the production line.
Eric Pfeiffer,
Director
of Sales &
Marketing,
Hyde Industrial
Blade
Solutions
In our experience, the
larger poultry processing
plants are utilizing a high level of automation pres-
ently, especially when compared to other meat cat-
egories. That being said, there is still a fair amount
of hand work involved, especially in the secondary
processing applications.
The major processors all seem to be keenly
focused on improving efficiency and through-put
(birds per minute) in order to pay for the increased
capitalization of the new technologies theyre
considering. Processors are eager for any pro-
cess improvement that they can utilize, and this
can range from expensive changes such as more
highly automated equipment to more affordable
alternatives such as faster or more efficient motors,
as well as innovations in blade design.
Processors will need to rely more heavily on
successful preventive maintenance programs as
any work stoppage is a cost in terms of labor and
lost production. And growers will continue to be
presses for bird size uniformity. Automation gener-
ally requires uniformity of work pieces.
Ultimately, its about removing variability. One
would think that employee costs (payroll, benefits,
health care, etc.) would decrease in the face of
increased automation. However, new technology
generally implies that a need will arise for more
highly trained and educated employees.
Register today at:
WestPackShow.com
Please use promo code: AB
Leave your ofce behind and expand your skill set at WestPack this
February. Increase your knowledge and your network as you engage
with like-minded peers and industry professionals. Gain fresh ideas
from stimulating sources and face-to-face meetings.
CUTthe
CORD
and connect live!
Industry Peers New Technologies Ideas and Inspiration Thought Leaders
Connections like these cannot be made at your desk!
February 1214, 2013
Anaheim Convention Center
Anaheim, CA
FM1301_BrainStorm.indd 25 1/17/2013 7:35:33 AM
26 PRODUCT REVIEW
Jan/Feb 2013
Bulk Bag Discharger with
Material Delumper
MATERIAL MASTER Bulk Bag Discharging
System features a fork-lift loaded bulk bag
lifting frame with adjustable height receiving
frame. Unit features a Flo-Master bulk bag
massaging system to promote positive material
flow, a Seal-Master bag spout access cham-
ber and a Sure-Seal spout clamping system
for dust-tight material discharge. Product dis-
charge transition includes a fully mounted ma-
terial delumper to break up material being fed
into downstream process. The Seal-Master
bag spout access chamber features interlock
switches to prevent material delumper from
operating unless both chamber doors are in the
closed, secured position. Equipment framework
features loss-in-weight load cells located above
floor level for enhanced protection.
Material Transfer www.materialtransfer.com
Programmable Temperature & Process
Controllers
Company introduces its new high quality, high accuracy series of 1/32 DIN programmable
temperature/process meters and PID controllers with RS-232 & RS-484 communications.
The user friendly, easy to configure Dpi32and CNi32 are the first full series of instru-
ments with programmable color displays. The CNi32 features two outputs control,
alarm or retransmission of process variable as well as universal inputs thermocou-
ple, RTD and process voltage/current. This series has free software, active X controls and
built-in 24 Vdc excitation, standard on units without DC power or communication options.
It can be used to monitor or control a process temperature in a heat treating application
fabricating metal parts.
Omega Engineering www.omega.com
Register today at:
SouthPackShow.com
Please use promo code: AB
Leave your ofce behind and expand your skill set at SouthPack this
March. Increase your knowledge and your network as you engage with
like-minded peers and industry professionals. Gain fresh ideas from
stimulating sources and face-to-face meetings.
CUTthe
CORD
and connect live!
Connections like these cannot be made at your desk!
Industry Peers New Technologies Ideas and Inspiration Thought Leaders
March 67, 2013
Orange County Convention Center
Orlando, FL
FM1301_NewProducts.indd 26 1/16/2013 2:28:59 PM
27
www.foodmanufacturing.com
January/February 2013
Multi-Lane Muffin Batter Depositing
Line
Companys family of pre-deposited muffin lines is available in sev-
eral sizes for production rates ranging from 264 to 800 muffins per
minute, with capacities up to 18,000 pounds per hour, for either
baked or pre-deposited frozen muffins. Automatic tray denest-
ing, automatic paper cup denesting and batter depositing using
Companys industrial depositor are included. These lines can be
operated with a minimal amount of labor, and the high percentage
of up time leads to high yield and low operating costs. The indus-
trial depositor uses diving spouts for clean, accurate depositing of
the most viscous batters including those containing a high concentration of frozen fruit or berries. Optional modules include a moist streusel deposi-
tor, a dry ingredient topper for nuts, sugar, chocolate chips, sprinkles and oat flakes, and an extra large intermediate hopper which can be insulated
and will accept multiple batches from the mixing bowls.
Hinds-Bock Corporation www.hinds-bock.com
Safety Interlock Switch
D4SL-N Safety Interlock Switches are available with four-, five- or six-contacts to satisfy varied
application needs. The IP67-rated unit can be mounted in four different directions without
needing to rotate the head. Two wiring methods minimize wiring time and make possible
one-touch attachment and removal. Easy-to-view LED indicators allow users to quickly
check switch status from any direction. The item delivers a minimum of one million opera-
tions and boasts a minimum key holding force of 1,300 N. It is available with two types
of wiring. Connector-type wiring models feature a conector cable that reduces potential for
mis-wiring, facilitates fast maintenance and allows easy switch replacement. Terminal block-type models
include a detachable terminal block to significantly increase wiring efficiency.
Omron Scientific Technologies, Inc. www.sti.com
Traceability Software
The Specialized Inventory Management with Barcode Accuracy
(SIMBA) Lite 2012 is designed to provide food processors with the
ability to process, label and track their products from field or dock
to customer. The system is designed for companies that process
in bulk (similar or same products into constant weight cartons). The
system allows a production line worker to change content of product
labels with a fingertip on the computer or touch screen, capturing
product information (weight, size, color, grade) and printing a label
with a barcode identifier for that tote or carton. The label information
is stored in the units
inventory system,
which then provides
production and in-
ventory reports. The
cartons may then be
accumulated onto a
pallet and tracked
with a single pallet
identifier. This integrated system gives the user complete traceability
of the product from receiving to shipping. The cartons or pallets can
be stored and tracked by location within the warehouse, cooler or
freezer. At the time of shipping, the Van Loading feature tracks each
carton or pallet onto a specific van. A Bill of Lading is then produced
automatically.
Dynamic Systems, Inc. www.a-barcode.com
FM1301_NewProducts.indd 27 1/14/2013 11:13:07 AM
January/February 2013
28
FOOD SAFETY
Meat, Poultry and Seafood
F
ood safety is an important consideration
across the food processing spectrum, but
meat, poultry and seafood processors face
especially stringent regulatory standards. As
food safety regulations change with 2011s
Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) and, later,
the FDAs new food safety rules, proposed this
January the stringent standards that have
bolstered food safety in meat processing facili-
ties could act as examples for other manufactur-
ers looking to beef up their processes. For this
reason, weve asked meat, poultry and seafood
processors about their own food safety practices
and what they see for the future of food safety.
The FSMA has made Hazard Analysis & Critical
Control Points (HACCP) planning and other food
safety protocol already mandatory in seafood
and meat processing facilities mandatory
across all food manufacturing segments. We
asked meat, poultry and seafood processors: Do
you think this is an appropriate change? 95.2
percent of respondents reported believing that
all food segments should be held to the same
high standard, with only 4.8 percent respond-
ing that meat, poultry, seafood and juice have
unique challenges that
make higher standards
necessary. None of the
respondents to this sur-
vey reported believing
that food safety protocol
should be left up to the
discretion of the indi-
vidual processor and its
customers.
This response coin-
cides with another that
shows 100 percent of
survey respondents
believe the regulatory
guidance for food safety
planning in meat and
seafood processing facilities is appropriate to
address the specific challenges and critical con-
trol points associated with processing. Indeed,
much of the data weve collected across the food
industry tells us that, while frustrated with many
of the regulatory burdens placed on manufactur-
ers, food processors in very high numbers
support strict regulatory oversight of food
safety practices.
In fact, 90.5 percent of survey respondents
reported that the presence of USDA officials in
meat, poultry and seafood processing facilities
increases food safety, while 9.5 percent see
no impact on food safety. No respondents
reported seeing a decrease in food safety due
to the presence of USDA inspectors. When
asked to expand upon this topic, one respondent
noted the need for increased inspection, while
another stated: There are always operations
that will try to push the limits. Having inspec-
tion provides oversight at those operations. Still
another respondent observed that since USDA
officials are present in meat, poultry and seafood
processing facilities there is a higher standard
for safety (and quality). Someone is physically
present to ensure the safety of the food and that,
in turn, makes it [safer].
This broad-based support for USDA oversight
and inspection, however, doesnt mean meat,
poultry and seafood operators dont see room
for improvement. As seen in the pie chart at
left, though 90.5 percent believe the presence
of USDA inspectors in facilities increases foods
safety, only 68.4 percent think the program is
cost-effective. One reader noted: Any plant
operating under an effective and functional
HACCP program should mitigate the need for
constant regulatory oversight. An effective
HACCP program that is properly implemented
and managed, combined with periodic regulatory
audits of the program, can be very effective.
And like the rest of the food industry, meat,
poultry and seafood processors take HACCP
planning seriously. As seen in the chart above,
meat processors utilize a variety of resources
when writing, implementing and revising HACCP
plans. When asked about the frequency of
HACCP revision, survey respondents reported:
HACCP plans are a living document, con-
stantly open to revision47.6%
Once per year33.3%
Less frequently than once per year14.2%
Twice per year4.8%
With broad support for comprehensive HACCP
planning and strong regulatory oversight, meat,
poultry and seafood processors are committed to
keeping food safe for consumers.
1
2 -200 HP batch and inline
Free trials in your plant
Many sizes in stock
Ross will beat any major manufacturers quote!
1-800-243-ROSS
USA Tel: 631-234-0500 Fax: 631-234-0691
www.highshearmixers.com
Adhesive, Sealant, Coating
For Food Applications
Watch our video
www.masterbond.com Tel: +1.201.343.8983
LEEM Filtration
A Division of North American Filtration, Inc.
2b ARR0w R0AO RA|SE\, \J 0/44O
P|c|e. 201-28O-4888 |a/. 201-28O-2004
www.leemltration.com
Filter Leaves
for ALL Pressure Leaf Filters
+
NEW
+
REBUILT
+
+
RECOVERED
+
All Makes All Kinds
+DURCO +NIAGARA
+INDUSTRIAL +SWEETLAND
+HERCULES +SPARKLER
+AMA +LFC
+U.S. FILTER & Many Others
(We also manufacture pressure leaf
and tubular element lters)
FM1301_Classified.indd 29 1/15/2013 3:14:25 PM
IndustryINSIDER
30
January/February 2013
Improving Foreign Objects &
Contamination Detection
Joe Cowman, President, Gainco, Inc.
P
oultry processors strive to pro-
vide a finished product that
is 100 percent free of bone
fragments and foreign objects.
Traditional methods of finding foreign
objects rely on human inspection and
tools such as metal detectors. But
detecting certain objects like soft bone
fragments and very small metal particles
remain big challenges. Left undetected,
they can degrade the quality of the
finished product, affect product pricing
adversely, and hurt brand reputation.
The most serious cases can bring
about costly product recalls, resulting in
significant monetary fines plus damage
to a companys reputation that may take
years to reverse.
Flawless Information Instantly
The volume of product output by the
typical poultry processing plant neces-
sitates speed as well as accuracy in the
detection of foreign objects. Ideally,
processors would like to be able to cap-
ture flawless information instantly. The
more equipment and systems can help
processors achieve that outcome, the
better it is for product quality and bot-
tom-line financial performance.
The Technology is Here but what
about Practical Applications?
There is a significant degree of
research going on to find better and
faster ways to test and safeguard pro-
cessed poultry products. Fortunately, a
good deal of this pure research has
been transferred into commercial appli-
cations that are as effective as they are
affordable.
For example, newer dual energy
x-ray detection systems such as those
manufactured by Anritsu can analyze
two different x-ray energy signals, allow-
ing them to distinguish between the
product and the contaminants. This
capability results in a higher detection
rate of certain types of bones and bone
fragments such as wishbones, fan bones,
scapula bones and other thin, low-den-
sity bones.
Newer detection equipment is also
more adept at inspecting overlapping
and randomly oriented poultry products
without negative side effects like false
positives or a missed detection.
Pipeline Inspection Systems
There have also been new improve-
ments in the speed and accuracy of
pipeline x-ray inspection systems for
pumpable products such as poultry trim
and first-grind chicken or turkey meat.
Not only are these pipeline systems
highly accurate and effective in detect-
ing small bone fragments, metal and
other foreign material, theyre capable
of processing as much as eight tons of
product per hour.
With preset memory capabilities able
to handle 100 or more separate recipes,
todays pipeline systems are highly ver-
satile and flexible for poultry plants that
process a variety of products.
Case Inspection Systems
Detection systems have also been
commercialized for end-of-line inspec-
tion activities. These systems provide
the assurance of confirming quality after
products have been packaged. Its not
unheard for foreign objects to end up
in a packaged product even after all of
its contents have gone through prior
detection screening, so this step pro-
vides an added measure of assurance
for processors.
Consider the Big Picture
In our dealings with poultry proces-
sors, sometimes we find that detection
systems and equipment have been
installed at different times and in dif-
ferent places along the processing line.
Often, this piecemeal approach has
ended up causing operational inefficien-
cies or worse, dangerous holes in
the system.
Thats why its important for a proces-
sor to work with specialists who can
view an entire process line and offer rec-
ommendations that will achieve all qual-
ity objectives in the most cost-efficient
and labor-saving manner. Its even better
if that specialist can deliver a full sys-
tem or equipment solutions, saving the
processor time, effort and added costs
in an attempt to devise a solution using
multiple suppliers.
Gainco, Inc. is a Gainesville, Ga.-based
manufacturer and supplier of yield man-
agement and food safety, plus weighing,
sizing and distribution systems. Gainco
is the exclusive authorized distributor
of Anritsu detection systems to the U.S.
poultry processing industry. Contact
Joe Cowman at (770) 534-0703 or
[email protected].
This month's
topic:
POULTRY
FM1301_IndustryInsider.indd 30 1/15/2013 7:36:09 AM
2012 Baldor Electric Company
Fluid Performance
Drive Down Your Energy
Use
In a motor-pump system, the life
cycle cost of the motor is about
2% of the total expense with
electricity consumption comprising
over 97% of the motors total
cost. By upgrading to a Super-E
NEMA Premium
efficiency motor,
substantial energy can be saved
immediately. Since most pump
systems are oversized for worst
case conditions and are operated
well below that point, adding an
adjustable speed drive to operate
the motor at a lower speed (instead
of using a valve) can, in most cases,
save over 60% of the energy used.
These applications can pay for the
cost and installation of the drive
in less than a year with rebates
available from most utilities, while
reducing energy consumption for
many years afterwards. Both the
U.S. Department of Energy and
Natural Resources Canada accept
Baldors Super-E motors as an
energy-saving upgrade.
and API 547 compliant
designs are
available. ABB
brand IEC metric
motors are offered
in standard or ATEX
configurations
for export or
replacement
on imported
equipment through
100,000 Hp.
OEM pump
manufacturers and
pump assemblers will find a wide
range of BaldorReliance stock
and custom motor configurations
to meet your specific application
requirements. For OEMs that
manufacture their own submersible
pumps, Baldor can supply stator-
rotor sets in many different frame
sizes and ratings for low and
medium voltage use.
All BaldorReliance motors are
made in America and distributed
through 32 stocking warehouses
in North America, giving you the
fastest stock motor delivery in the
industry.
Motor-driven pump systems
represent 30% of all motors used in
North America.
Baldor Electric
Company
recognizes
the
need for robust, energy efficient
motors for this application and
offers a wide range of motors for
practically any pump application:
56J
Close-coupled
Explosion-proof
Vertical P-base with solid shaft
Submersible and immersible
designs
plus, an unlimited number of
custom designs.
With medium voltage motor
horsepower ratings to 15,000 and
stock motor voltages in 115/230
and 230 for single phase and 200,
230/460, 460, 575 and 2300/4000
volt for three phase designs, theres
a BaldorReliance
pump motor
for your next pump system design
or retrofit replacement need. For
special applications and strict
industry specification requirements,
IEEE 841-2009, API 610, API 541
Lifetime Cost
of an Electric Motor
Energy 97.3% Initial Purchase 2%
One Rewind 0.7%
www.baldor.com
479-646-4711
FM1301_Ads.indd 31 1/7/2013 2:12:17 PM
FM1301_Ads.indd 32 1/7/2013 2:12:27 PM