Engaging Mathematics
Engaging Mathematics
Engaging Mathematics
Contents
Foreword . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .3 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5 What are you trying to achieve? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6 How will you organise learning? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .8 Planning a compelling learning experience Getting started what are rich mathematical activities? Some strategies for devising and working with rich mathematical activities Finding rich contexts for mathematics 8 8 9 13
How will you know that you are achieving your aims? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .20 Case studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .22 1: 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: 8: 9: Every Child Matters using recreational activities to engage learners Every Child Matters working inclusively with all ability groups Historical and cultural roots of mathematics understanding numbers Historical and cultural roots of mathematics the golden ratio Modelling with mathematics Mathematics in society number sense Mathematics in society technology and the environment Mathematics across the curriculum performing arts Mathematics across the curriculum STEM 22 23 24 26 27 28 29 31 32 33 34 34 35 36 37 38 39
10: Mathematics across the curriculum STEM and PE 11: Mathematics and curriculum dimensions healthy lifestyles 12: Mathematics and curriculum dimensions technology and the media 13: Mathematics and curriculum dimensions creativity and critical thinking 14: Using timetable opportunities for engaging mathematical activities 1 15: Using timetable opportunities for engaging mathematical activities 2 16: Working together to trial engaging mathematical activities (Bowland maths) 17: Working together to introduce rich tasks into the mathematics curriculum for all learners
Working together to engage learners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .40 Making it happen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .44 Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .46 Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .47
Foreword
If we want young people to do well in mathematics, it helps if they enjoy the subject. They need to see that the subject is fascinating and exhilarating, to see the way it affects everyday life and helps to change the world in which we live. We have to strike a balance between the challenge of incremental steps in understanding, knowledge and skills, and the joy, wonder and curiosity of learning. It is not about 'basics' and 'enrichment', all children should have a rich experience. 'Engaging mathematics for all learners' draws together the experience of teachers and their learners as an inspiration to other teachers of mathematics as they implement the new programmes of study. The rich variety of content, from using recreational activities as a starting point for classroom mathematics in a residential special school to using fashion design in a mathematics and art initiative in a selective girls' school, illustrate some of the possibilities. Working with other subject disciplines, exploiting ICT and making sense of mathematics and statistics in the media are some of the innovative approaches adopted by schools to enhance the learning of mathematics. Being willing to take risks, identifying the mathematics potential of rich tasks, giving learners the opportunity to tackle something different and unusual These are all themes to be exploited and used. Enjoy this publication, exploit the ideas and enjoy mathematics with youngsters. Mick Waters Director of Curriculum
Qualications and Curriculum Authority
Introduction
The new secondary curriculum aims to inspire all young people to become successful learners, condent individuals and responsible citizens. As a result, the mathematics programmes of study have changed signicantly. Every learner is entitled to experience mathematics as worthwhile, enjoyable and challenging, regardless of their prior attainment and background.
and experience
using mathematics to solve problems modelling with mathematics working collaboratively on mathematical tasks using a range of resources and technology to work on mathematics mathematics beyond the classroom.
One way of realising this is to make enrichment and enhancement tasks available to all learners. These tasks focus on collaborative mathematical problem-solving using a wide range of contexts, ranging from the purely mathematical to historical, cultural and social. They allow learners to experience mathematics as a worthwhile and enjoyable pursuit, thereby increasing participation and motivation. This guide will help you to reect on mathematics enrichment and enhancement in your curriculum and suggest ways to build them into your curriculum. There are some practical activities to help you stimulate a conversation about the mathematics curriculum in your school and decide on ways forward. The activities focus on three key questions: What are you trying to achieve? How will you organise learning? How will you know that you are achieving your aims? Case studies show how different schools have answered these three questions. They also offer examples of mathematics enrichment and enhancement in action, and should help you to make decisions about what you might do in your school. The Resources section gives sources of support. This publication can be downloaded as a pdf le, using the search function at www.qca.org.uk.
This 3-step sequence has been shown to be the key to successful curriculum innovation. It must be focused, based on evidence and closely monitored.
The development of school mathematics provision needs to build on things that currently work well by systematically identifying priorities for change that will improve outcomes for all learners. These need to be consistent with whole-school priorities such as meeting the Every Child Matters agenda, developing personal, learning and thinking skills, developing assessment for learning or embedding cross-curriculum dimensions. When considering how you want to move your learners forward, you might want to take into account their current views about mathematics. The Ofsted report Mathematics understanding the score says: Some schools have begun to collect pupils views of their experience of learning mathematics. This is a positive move, and action to respond to them has the potential to make learning mathematics more fun for pupils and their teachers. One student told Ofsted that: Maths makes you think your mind grows intellectually. But sometimes you learn more from your friends than your teacher. Explaining builds up our condence.
Schools are responsible for developing a coherent curriculum that will enable young people to: be successful learners, condent individuals and responsible citizens achieve higher standards and make better progress in subjects and sectorrelated learning have and be able to use high-quality personal, learning and thinking skills have and be able to use high-quality functional skills be more engaged, motivated and committed to their learning engage with learning to the age of 19 and beyond. Learning and doing activities in mathematics contributes to the achievement of the curriculum aims.
Advice from teachers to other colleagues Take risks, if there is an area you dont feel comfortable then go into that area. Go try new things.
Advice from teachers to other colleagues Be brave, try it! If it doesnt work it doesnt matter, it is one lesson, but if it works, it may be something you may want to implement generally and bring it to other colleagues.
Tasks with these characteristics address key elements of Every Child Matters, in particular enjoy and achieve and make a positive contribution. The National Strategies have produced guidance on embedding rich tasks in schemes of work. NRICH has many sources of rich mathematical tasks and advice and guidance on how to use them. See also NCETMs Mathematics Matters. (See Resources).
Some strategies for devising and working with rich mathematical activities
Use simple starting points, then ask learners how they might be varied or what questions they could think up to answer next. Collect together suggestions and invite them to choose one to work on. Adapt tasks and questions from textbooks, tests or examinations so that learners can make decisions, look for patterns and relationships, and test conjectures. Encourage learners to look for connections between old and new situations, ideas and skills, and to ask themselves whether something theyve done before might be useful. When a student comes up with something that is not relevant at the time, avoid implying that this is the case and bank the idea for later.
Adapted from The raising achievement in mathematics project report (1992) by Ahmed and Williams.
Some examples of different types of rich mathematical tasks that have developed using these strategies include the following.
How many quadrilaterals can be made on a 9-pin geoboard?: This can lead to work on a wide variety of other geometric issues, Learner including properties and names of the quadrilaterals, congruence, transformations, classifying quadrilaterals according to properties, including symmetry, calculating area, calculating (by measuring or symbolising) perimeter, calculating and/or measuring angle. This activity was used with mixed-ability groups in year 9 and students were encouraged to work in a variety of ways: individually, in pairs, in small groups and taking part in whole-class discussions. Although there are online geoboards that could be used, they do not replace the hands-on practical experience of using the actual boards and the physical movements that are possible, such as rotating them to see if the shapes are congruent. The teachers made ongoing assessments, which determined the kinds of questions they posed to individuals and to groups to develop the work further.
Normally we have kind of a black and white view about maths, so books and whatever. But now we can see that maths is involved in a lot of things like building and so on. So it just expands our view of maths.
10
There are a variety of ways in which this task could be extended for further challenge. How do you classify shapes? What is the purpose of classication? How can you prove that you have found all the shapes? The NRICH website (nrich.maths.org) has examples of How many activities that schools have used, such as: M, M and M: How many different sets of ve whole numbers can you nd with a mean of 4, a median of 3 and a mode of 3? Semi-regular Tessellations: How many semi-regular tessellations can you make?
11
There are a number of possible methods, so this activity is suitable for a wide range of learners, including those at advanced level: Numerical different strategies for systematic trial and improvement, including using calculators and spreadsheets. Graphical using different combinations of graphs, possibly with the aid of graphing technology. Algebraic researching how to nd solutions by completing the square or using the formula for quadratic equations. Analytic trying different rearrangements of the original equation to generate iterative formulae and exploring convergence and divergence of the resultant sequences. This type of activity generates valuable assessment evidence: Which methods are learners condent with? What can they do with prompts and encouragement?
Use practical equipment and information and communication technology (ICT) to access challenging problems
This strategy was used with the geoboards activity and can also be used with examination and textbook questions. For example: Find the dimensions for the maximum volume open tray that can be made from a xed rectangle or square of paper (Max box). This activity is on the NRICH website as Cuboid Challenge. This is a typical AS examination question that expects use of differential calculus. However, it is accessible to a much wider range of learners if they can experiment with paper and use systematic trial and improvement. The use of ICT such as spreadsheets and graphing technology can make the activity more accessible. By generating many examples, I have learned how to nd the students move more quickly to higher level maximum volume of the cuboid and thinking. It also provides opportunities for what volume actually means. I believe comparing the efciency of different methods I have gained more of a mathematical of solution. This activity was used with an entire understanding of shapes and year 11 cohort. Posing questions and using improved my accuracy in measuring. prompts to challenge students generated rich Learner evidence for assessment of progress.
12
An activity in one year 7 scheme of work was Design an algebra board game. A sample game was given where players moved around a board according to the number thrown on a die. The rules were in both words and symbols. The NRICH website has a Transformation Game, which consists of a board containing a number of congruent right-angled triangles in different orientations and a pack of cards with details of transformations. In Guess my quadrilateral, one student makes a quadrilateral on a geoboard and the others try to identify it by asking questions that have yes/no answers. Card-matching and other games can be used equally well in advanced mathematics courses, for example routine practice of more complicated techniques in algebra or calculus, or matching equivalent representations.
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100
This type of strategy is also useful for activities such as T totals, used with an entire year 10 cohort. Initially students were asked to nd rules to predict the total of the numbers in a particular shape (T in this case, but any shape could be used) on a 1 to 100 square. They were then encouraged to suggest their own ways of changing the problem. This involved identifying possible variables in the original problem and suggesting ones that could be changed systematically, such as the shape, its size or the size of the grid.
13
Design activities
Design a container to The maximising and minimising activities can be developed further, as in the following examples. Design a container to hold 24 cubes / 500g of cereal / a litre of liquid / 18 sweets (as in the Bowland professional development materials) then negotiate with learners criteria for assessing their designs. Designing a container such as a barrel to hold a xed volume has the potential for a rich advanced activity by exploring suitable curves that could be used to model a barrel shape and nding volumes of revolution. Dynamic graphing software can make this activity more accessible. Another container design activity used successfully for an entire year 10 cohort was Design a container to package tennis balls. This has the potential for exploring many aspects of geometry and measures, including circle properties. It can also be extended to more complex problems that could be used with advanced level students such as nding the dimensions of the smallest tetrahedron to package four balls (3D trigonometry) and different ways of packing spheres to minimise the space occupied which has links with science.
14
Designs for living: Design activities that involve considering measurements of the human form can be rich sources of learning as not only do they tend to have links with science and design and technology, they can also incorporate a wide range of mathematical content from number, geometry and statistics. Examples include: Design an emergency shelter/tent what dimensions would it need to be to t two average people sleeping/sitting/standing? Design a bench for students to use in the school grounds. Garment design. A different activity that is based on building design considerations is 4 cube homes where students are asked to nd all the possible homes that could be made with four cubes and then choose the best design considering costs of painting, roong, ground rent, and so on. Real-life examples of this exist in Cube homes in Rotterdam and homes built from disused containers in Londons docklands. Visits to buildings can provide inspiration for mathematics work, for example students who visited modern buildings in London. In another school students constructed geodesic domes and used them for calculations in 3D.
15
Historical data: Investigate patterns in deaths during a plague, using the data for the plague in the village of Eyam in 1665. Global data: The United Nations (data.un.org) and CensusAtSchool (censusatschool.ntu.ac.uk) provide huge databases that students can use to nd answers to questions about global citizenship and sustainable development. For example: How close are we to achieving the Millennium Development Goals? (eight goals were set in 2000 for 2015). The Resources section contains a number of activity references and sources of world data. Some other possibilities are: sports data weather data data from newspapers including sports, nance and weather data from websites such as those comparing nancial products data that can be used to estimate risk, such as accident gures or crime statistics: the Bowland maths activity How risky is life? looks at this and has produced interesting reactions from learners.
There was a question on the mock exam paper about arc length and the students all got it absolutely correct. When they came out of the exam they told me, There was a question about the swing on the paper.
Teacher
Along with playgrounds, fairgrounds and theme park rides are also rich contexts for mathematical activities. All can be extended to advanced level.
16
Use learners as a resource, encouraging them to become aware of when they or their families might be using mathematics in their daily lives, possibly using their own experiences as a source of learning activities. This might include nding out where they used mathematics on work experience or in part-time jobs. Parents/guardians/carers may provide examples; for example a year 7 student who had been doing a project on codes brought in a semaphore manual and a pair of ags that were used by her father, a signaller in the Royal Navy. Use opportunities within the school such as school visits or trips. In one school, year 7 students worked in a number of different subject areas to plan out all aspects of an end-ofterm trip to a theme park, including route planning, timings and costing. Raising awareness of how others use mathematics in their daily lives Teachers: Some teachers may have experience of other workplaces or may have particular interests where they make use of mathematics. For example, one teacher formerly ran a travel agency, another worked for a City nance house and a third was employed as a statistician. Others may have particular interests where they might make use of mathematics, such as origami, patchwork, photography or astronomy. Other school contacts: Relatives, teachers spouses, governors, representatives of local rms who provide work experience placements and others connected with school may have roles that use mathematics and may be willing to talk to learners about this. Recent school leavers can provide good role models for current students. In one school, an ex-student now studying A levels in mathematics and science was employed to support an afterhours event linking mathematics and dance. In another school, a talk for mathematics students was arranged by an ex-student who is now a rocket scientist with the European Space Agency. Experts from outside the school: They can stimulate discussion and debate or work with students in various ways. One source of experts is the science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) directories (www.stemdirectories.org.uk). The Institute of Mathematics and its Applications, the London Mathematical Society, the Royal Statistical Society and the Royal Institution have lists of mathematicians who can visit schools. Current local, national or international events such as the Olympic Games: One school planned a series of events for a full day of mathematics with an Olympics theme. This included estimating activities related to Olympic records, and problem-solving and thinking skills activities. Current events or issues in the news. Newspaper and media articles or advertisements: These can be used to assess the validity of media stories based on quantitative data and identify misrepresentation and potential sources of bias. Visits to museums, local sites of interest, hands-on science locations, theme parks, and so on: Many places have mathematics trails, or students could devise their own for other students in the school.
17
Using ICT to support teachers and learners in engaging mathematics Ofsted (2008) comments that
Several years ago, inspection evidence showed that most pupils had some opportunities to use ICT as a tool to solve or explore mathematical problems. This is no longer the case; mathematics makes a relatively limited contribution to developing pupils ICT skills. Moreover, despite technological advances, the potential of ICT to enhance the learning of mathematics is too rarely realised.
There are six major opportunities for earners to benet from the use of ICT in mathematics: learning from feedback observing patterns seeing connections developing visual imagery exploring data teaching the computer. Some examples of how these opportunities can be realised include the following. Developing visual imagery: Digital images or video clips can be imported into dynamic geometry software or video analysis software to develop mathematical models for objects and motion. Three-dimensional dynamic geometry software can be used to create models that can be stretched and manipulated. Exploring data: A spreadsheet can be used to help analyse and represent data to test hypotheses about nutritional data. Graphing software could also be used for this. Teaching the computer: Logo programming (freely available software that learners can access on home computers) was used in an after-school club to produce loci relating to work in mathematics and design technology with Magic Mathworks. This is a travelling hands-on
18
mathematics exhibition for schools that enables learners to experience a multi-sensory approach to mathematics (see STEM directory). Providing students with hands-on access to ICT during normal mathematics lesson is a challenge for many schools. These are some of the ways that schools make ICT available: a mathematics classroom with a number of networked PCs around the edge of the room on which small groups of students access a range of software a set of laptops for use by pairs of students a set of graphing calculators or other hand-held devices that students use alone or in pairs to explore sets of data, plot graphs, etc a wireless network linking a set of hand-held devices to the teachers PC.
Cross-curriculum dimensions
To achieve the aims of the curriculum, learners need to experience opportunities to understand themselves and the world in which they live. Cross-curriculum dimensions provide important unifying areas of learning that help young people make sense of the world and give education relevance and authenticity. They reect the major ideas and challenges that face individuals and society.
19
Dimensions can add a richness and relevance to the curriculum experience of learners. They can provide a focus for work within and between subjects and across the curriculum as a whole.
20
How will you know that you are achieving your aims?
When making changes you need to be clear why they are being made and to identify the evidence that will indicate how successful the innovation has been. You may want to involve learners in the evaluation. Recently Ofsted found that in many schools, learners have little opportunity to: use and apply mathematics make connections across different areas of the subject extend their reasoning use ICT be challenged in lessons make links with other subjects develop mathematical understanding make connections with earlier learning and other topics investigate open-ended problems choose which approach to adopt reason and generalise work collaboratively and discuss their ideas. Although students wanted to do well in mathematics and knew that it was important, they lacked condence and understanding. They saw mathematics as boring, difcult and something to be memorised. This contrasts strongly with learners responses to the engaging mathematics activities in this publication. One school asked students to post comments about the Playground project (see Case studies) on the schools VLE: some of these are given below. The playground project allowed us to be free of the classroom and to try something new which was good as sometimes maths can seem like a terrible subject and a little bit samey and boring. This project was good because it helped us remember areas of maths more and is better for revision such as Pythagoras theorem, triangles, quadrilaterals and circles. Also linking with parks which is an everyday location makes the skills we have learnt stay in our memory because it is more original. This project shines a new light on maths and shows that technology is possible in every subject. I think that the project was very exciting and challenging and it also gave us something different to do which means that we were not in the same routine and we were able to remember the information easier. We learned many maths techniques such as angles, shapes and lengths and are now more familiar with working using geometry software. We both liked the project because we were working with our friends and also using the pictures to measure the equipment because it showed how it applied to real life situations. I enjoyed using the computers while doing maths work as it makes the topic a little more fun. I like using the graphics to measure as it was our own sources. It probably improved my use of tools and using dynamic geometry. There was nothing I really disliked and I learned a lot.
21
Below are some comments from year 8 students in a school that is developing a scheme of work based on rich tasks (see Case studies). What have you enjoyed in mathematics this year? Why? Working with a partner Because you can discuss things and be able to answer a question from a different point of view. Because it gives me more condence. Doing different activities Because it is much better than doing work from boring exercise books that dont help explain anything. Do you feel you have developed any of these skills? Having the condence to work by yourself Yes because I always used to ask the person next to me. Yes because what matters most is at least I have tried. I dont feel embarrassed to speak any more. I have gained a skill not to copy others but to do your own work by yourself. Think creatively Last year I needed help, this year I can think more for myself. Work as part of a team We work better as a team because two brains are better than one. I have developed condence working in a team because I never used to share my ideas but I do now. I like working together and having different jobs to do. I like to work as a team because the work gets easier when everyone is thinking about it and everyone can join in. Coping with challenge We have been talking more about the questions and doing less writing. Yes you feel proud and it also makes you feel you can take on the challenge. I enjoy problem solving and investigating things. It is alright because I want to learn more about it. What have you struggled with? Why? I struggled with algebra because I found it hard to calculate a sum but I didnt know what it meant. Now I understand and it is completely easy.
22
Case studies
A clear message is that, in most schools, mathematics does not contribute sufciently to the ve outcomes of the Every Child Matters agenda.
Case study 1: Every Child Matters using recreational activities to engage learners
Background
At a residential school for boys with extreme behaviour, emotional and social difculties, many of whom also have other learning difculties and/or disabilities, opportunities for students to engage in a wide range of activities beyond the classroom (for example evening games of table tennis, snooker, darts, dominoes and a oor-standing Connect four) were used as starting points for mathematics.
Ofsted (2008)
23
Case study 2: Every Child Matters working inclusively with all ability groups
Background
An 1118 mixed community school with specialist technology college status, teaching mathematics in mixed-ability tutor groups, used 9-pin geoboards.
Its a social thing. All students feel they are doing the same task and are not left out.
Teacher
24
Background
A boys comprehensive school with a coeducational sixth form used The power of two, a Royal Institution mathematics masterclass based on a historical episode, with year 9. The Josephus Problem: given a circle of people where every alternate living person is killed in succession, where should one stand in order to be the last person alive (the survivor)? The problem provides an accessible introduction to number systems and to the notion and importance of proof.
25
Learner Teachers were delighted by learners engagement and the way the activity reinforced understanding of place value. However, they felt that group work could have been more effective if learners had more experience of group work and more time.
Students said that they enjoyed working in a different environment and in groups, and being made to think. They wanted to know when something like that might happen again. They also enjoyed encountering a different number system and, in follow-up lessons, explored addition and subtraction in binary and other number bases.
26
Case study 4: Historical and cultural roots of mathematics the golden ratio
Background
An 1119 comprehensive coeducational specialist language community school wanted to motivate and engage year 10 learners.
I found it particularly interesting nding out all the natural things that have the golden ratio such as sunowers and shells, and also growing. Also how different things divided by each other equal to the golden ratio.
Learner
Staff noted the students enthusiasm and engagement across the entire cohort. The project had a lasting effect as students were proud of their work, regarding it as real maths, and were more willing to try different approaches when working on something new. The following term, some students were able to make links with the project when developing methods for solving quadratic equations and revising geometrical constructions.
27
28
females
Work on assessing risk incorporated resources from How risky is life? (Bowland maths) and data from the Ofce for National Statistics. Students used a population pyramid graph to analyse the different life expectancies and mortality rates for males and females.
29
Background
A boys 1116 specialist technology college used the Royal Institution masterclass Shape of space with year 9.
30
design requirements, the logistical limitations of cost, physical limits and material properties, all need to be included and balanced in architects work. It also raised awareness about STEM careers. Follow-up classroom activities were practical and exploratory, for example: stability of 3D shapes (inspired by the NRICH problem Building With Solid Shapes) plans and elevations (using the Standards Unit materials) Eulers formula folding an origami dodecahedron and a bucky-ball (adapted from Thomas Hulls Project Origami) folding a strip into perfect thirds (Project Origami).
31
Background
An 1116 comprehensive performing arts college used dance to aid mathematical understanding and increase motivation.
32
fuchsia FF00FF
maroon 800000
They planned for pupils to work on Calculating colours, as this provides an accessible and novel experience. Year 7 students undertook a practical activity mixing red and blue liquids to give them a tangible representation of fractions, percentages and ratios using colour. Given the experimental approach, students could access the activities at a variety of levels. This provided a context for discussing multiple representations of numbers and appreciating that there are innite possibilities for numbers, yet just a nite spread in this practical context given the limitations of our senses and technology. Mixed-ability year 9 students used spinning tops and mixed light with data projectors. They then designed and constructed their own tops. They were introduced to hexadecimal representation of numbers and the use of these for representing colour on the internet and in other computer-facilitated technologies (RGB monitors, CMYK printers).
33
Teacher
I like the fact our teachers bother to put maths into some sort of context. It makes it a lot easier to learn.
Learner
The approach has been extended to design and technology, where students design and make a table tennis ball launcher. Results for Maths, in particular, were outstanding and beyond expectations. From September 2008, Maths is to be a lead department, linked to our specialism, raising standards in education throughout the college.
34
Case study 12: Mathematics and curriculum dimensions technology and the media
Background
An 1116 coeducational comprehensive arts college used the playground as a starting point for year 10.
35
Learner The following term, the teacher used the Bowland maths continuing professional development (CPD) activity Build a school with bottles in Honduras. She found that the students condence in using the software to assist their work was considerably increased and that they were really competent in using the dynamic geometry software to help them simplify and represent the problem. What does the school plan to do next?
Other teachers are beginning to try similar activities. They are also experimenting with less structure, for example: What mathematics can you nd in the playground?
Case study 13: Mathematics and curriculum dimensions creativity and critical thinking
Background
A girls grammar school used Geometry in fashion, a Royal Institution mathematics masterclass delivered by fashion designer Julian Roberts about his subtraction cutting technique. Stretching the comfort zone used the masterclass as a starting point and as a vehicle for exploring mathematics in a creative way and making links with art and design and technology.
36
Case study 14: Using timetable opportunities for engaging mathematical activities 1
Background
A large rural school with media arts status used NRICH activities in a school event.
Teacher
Its more working with other pupils and more problem solving than normal mathematics lessons. Its more of a real life situation. Were working in groups and its a bigger challenge.
Learner
37
Case study 15: Using timetable opportunities for engaging mathematical activities 2
Background
A 1216 girls technology college used fortnightly exidays for engaging mathematics.
38
Case study 16: Working together to trial engaging mathematical activities (Bowland maths)
Background
An 1118 specialist technology school used Bowland maths.
39
Case study 17: Working together to introduce rich tasks into the mathematics curriculum for all learners
Background
A rural 1116 village college developed its scheme of work.
40
Support networks
Some of the most successful activities or strategies developed by schools have been passed on from teacher to teacher through networks or other media and then rened or adapted to suit different needs. These include: local authority meetings for heads of mathematics, meetings for Specialist Schools and Academies Trust (SSAT) lead practitioners or for Advanced Skills Teachers etc professional development activities, including courses at masters degree level organised by universities national conferences such as those organised by the Association of Teachers of Mathematics (ATM) and the Mathematical Association (MA) the journals of the subject associations such as Mathematics Teaching, Mathematics in School and Mathematics Today online forums such as those available through the National Centre for Excellence in the Teaching of Mathematics (NCETM) Teachers TV programmes that show ideas in action in the classroom or groups of teachers sharing and discussing ideas (see Resources) teacher meetings and other offerings of the United Kingdom Mathematics Trust (UKMT).
41
identifying and sharing good practice developing more effective use of ICT exploring the use of newly acquired equipment, resources or software involving parents/guardians/carers, eg by organising events that allow them to do mathematics with their children.
42
When?
Engaging activities need to be part of the everyday mathematics curriculum. However, there may be particular opportunities within school: to test out activities before embedding them in the scheme of work to be more ambitious or adventurous to work in different ways with other subjects, in mixed-age groups, in mixed-attainment groups to organise visits or external speakers. These are some examples: exidays one day per fortnight when half a year group spends the entire day on a single subject after examinations the two weeks following a GCSE unit examination was identied as dead time so was used to trial some innovative mathematical activities in order to improve motivation and engagement one-off school events a whole day of mathematics provided the opportunity to use rich mathematical activities with an entire year, organised into mixed-attainment groups.
How?
Having identied possible activities or starting points, you need to consider how to introduce these activities to learners. What is the purpose of the activity mathematically, or more broadly? What choices and responsibilities will learners have? What questions will you ask? What questions might learners ask? How will you introduce the activity or situation to learners to engage them from the outset? How will you organise the classroom, and what resources might be needed? How will you group the learners? Who will decide the groupings or the roles within the group? How will learners communicate their thought processes or results? What other strategies might you use to encourage learners to get the most out of the activity? What problems do you anticipate? How might you prepare for these?
43
How will you know that you are achieving your aims?
Look at your aims for your learners and the activity you have chosen. Can you write down some questions for teachers or learners to answer that will show how well you are achieving your aims? This might be one broad question or more targeted questions. Some broad questions and responses from learners are given in the main section entitled How will you know that you are achieving your aims?. More specic questions could relate to key concepts or key processes, or specic aspects of personal, learning and thinking skills. For example, to evaluate learners creative thinking, ask: Did the learner generate ideas? explore possibilities? ask questions to extend their thinking? Involving learners in evaluating their progress is an important part of engaging them in the learning process. One way to do this is to share evaluation questions with them. Questions need to be open to give learners the opportunity to show what they have achieved. Here are some examples of questions you might use: Were there any things you had to nd out before you started work? What assumptions did you make? Did you consider more than one method? Which one did you choose? Why? Did you look for any patterns? What did you nd? What predictions did you make? How did you test them out? How did you record your work? Why did you choose this method? Did you consider others? How did you reach your results? What do they mean? Did you get stuck? Why, and what did you do about it? How did you check your work? In what ways could you extend the work?
44
Making it happen
I dont have the time to nd and prepare tasks!
Allocating time in department meetings for staff to look at, attempt to solve and then discuss one or two rich activities helps to reduce what teachers perceive to be the time burden associated with preparing to use rich activities. It also helps teachers to experience for themselves how learners might feel when approaching unfamiliar problems, and gives them an opportunity to work with their peers in a different way, becoming excited about the mathematics, and then discussing: why they would use the activity who they would use the activity with how they would use the activity which key questions they would ask what support they would provide. This enables most teachers to use the activities with their classes, and may inspire them to investigate which other activities they could use. In one school, teachers formed into collaborative working parties to plan the next two weeks lessons, with an expert leading each group. In another, teachers produced interactive whiteboard ipcharts based on NRICH problems to share with other colleagues. Collaborative planning sheets were prepared to support this activity.
I dont feel condent in my ability to manage the classroom environment when I change the lesson structure.
Observing colleagues managing student activity in lessons where problem-solving is the norm can be particularly helpful. This allows colleagues to discuss and identify strategies that they might use. In several schools, good use was made of enthusiasts in the department who were willing to be observed by their colleagues. This acted as a catalyst for joint planning and further peer observation. In some schools, lessons were videotaped for staff development purposes. In one school, a video was used during a department meeting to focus on questioning skills and on how to support students through activities, without doing the thinking for them.
My results are very good anyway why should I change my teaching style?
Teachers have found that attainment levels do not decline when they use rich activities. Students become more enthusiastic about mathematics and more successful when tackling open-ended problems. It is hoped that this may lead to more students choosing to study mathematics post-16. Are students really achieving as well as they might? Could they do even better?
45
Parents/guardians/carers of some students expressed concern over the lack of formal written work and marking in students exercise books. They also worried about the challenge presented by open-ended homework tasks and by the amount of time their child spent on homework (both too little and too much). Communication with parents helped to overcome this problem. One school held a year 7 mathematics evening at which they explained to parents/guardians/ carers how and why rich activities would be used as a teaching resource. One teacher suggested time limits for investigative homework. Preparing learners to think for themselves to solve problems will become increasingly important as examinations change to take account of the new curriculum.
I am concerned about the reaction of senior staff and inspectors to this style of teaching.
Problem-solving is at the heart of the new programmes of study and an essential component of learners classroom experiences. Senior staff need to be aware that a greater emphasis on process skills will be reected in lesson objectives and in how learners work (for example being stuck is normal in a problem-solving environment). In some schools, a senior member of staff has attended department meetings when rich tasks are being discussed, or observed lessons when they are being used.
46
Resources
Bowland Maths www.bowlandmaths.org.uk Developing reasoning through algebra and geometry (QCA, 2004) www.qca.org.uk Integrating ICT into the mathematics classroom (ATM) www.atm.org.uk/buyonline/products/rea02 5.html Key stage 3 National Strategy ICT across the curriculum: ICT in mathematics http://publications.teachernet.gov.uk/ default.aspx?PageFunction=productdetail s&PageMode=publications&ProductId=Df ES+0176+2004G Making mathematics count (Smith, 2004) www.mathsinquiry.org.uk/report Mathematics: understanding the score (Ofsted, 2008) www.ofsted.gov.uk/Ofstedhome/Publications-and-research/Browseall-by/Documents-by-type/Thematic-repor ts/Mathematics-understanding-the-score Oliver Byrnes 1847 edition of Euclids Geometry where colour represents congruence http://sunsite.ubc.ca/DigitalMathArchive/E uclid/byrne.html Plus magazine www.plus.maths.org/ QCA Respect for all: Mathematics www.qca.org.uk/qca_9580.aspx QCA - RSS review of handling data and statistics in GCSE mathematics www.rsscse.org.uk/qca/resources0.htm QCA curriculum website http://curriculum.qca.org.uk/ Science learning centres for STEM Enrichment & Enhancement www.sciencelearningcentres.org.uk STEM directories www.stemdirectories.org.uk STEMNET The Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics Network www.stemnet.org.uk Teachers' TV mathematics eg Hard To Teach - Secondary Maths www.teachers.tv/video/19119 The Association of Teachers of Mathematics (ATM) www.atm.org.uk The FunMaths Roadshow www.maths.liv.ac.uk/lms/funmaths The Mathematical Association (MA) www.m-a.org.uk The National Centre for Excellence in the Teaching of Mathematics (NCETM) www.ncetm.org.uk includes Resources; Courses and events; Research; Communities e.g. ICT in mathematics, Bowland forum The National Strategies www.nationalstrategies.org.uk includes guidance, support, resources The NRICH Mathematics Project http://nrich.maths.org/public/ includes activities, teacher notes, curriculum mapping documents The Practical Support Pack: Learning and teaching using ICT www.dcsf.gov.uk/psp The Royal Institution of Great Britain www.rigb.org The Royal Statistical Society Centre for Statistical Education www.rsscse.org.uk The Standards Unit - Improving Learning in Mathematics www.ncetm.org.uk/Default.aspx?page=13 &module=res&mode=100&resid=1442 UK Mathematics Trust www.ukmt.org.uk Video analysis software: Tracker 2 from www.cabrillo.edu/~dbrown/tracker Sources for statistics CensusAtSchool www.censusatschool.ntu.ac.uk/default.asp Experiments at school www.experimentsatschool.org.uk International Statistical Literacy Project www.stat.auckland.ac.nz Understanding Uncertainty www.understandinguncertainty.org Ofce for National Statistics www.ons.gov.uk Stats4schools www.stats4schools.gov.uk United Nations cyberschoolbus cyberschoolbus.un.org View and compare United Nations data from Countries around the world. The State of the Worlds children www.unicef.org/publications/index.html
47
Acknowledgements
With thanks to the schools and colleges whose work with learners has fed into this publication. They represent a wide range of institutions working in a variety of contexts. Baliol School, Sedbergh, Cumbria Belper School and Sixth Form Centre, Belper, Derbyshire Bottisham Village College, Bottisham, Cambridgeshire Brune Park Community College, Gosport, Hampshire Christ's College Finchley, Finchley, London Comberton Village College, Comberton, Cambridgeshire Davison Church of England High School for Girls Technology College, Worthing, West Sussex Finchley Catholic High School, Finchley, London Gable Hall School, Stanford-le-Hope, Essex Homewood School and Sixth Form Centre, Tenterden, Kent Imberhorne School, East Grinstead, West Sussex Kidbrooke School, Greenwich, London Kingston College, Kingston upon Thames, Surrey Longsands College, St Neot's, Cambridgeshire Oak Lodge School, East Finchley, London Pleckgate High School Mathematics and Computing College, Blackburn, Lancashire Portchester Community School, Portchester, Hampshire Range High School, Sefton, Liverpool Sawston Village College, Sawston, Cambridgeshire Sharnbrook Upper School and Community College, Sharnbrook, Hampshire Shuttleworth College, Burnley, Lancashire The Angmering School, Angmering, West Sussex The Henrietta Barnett School, Hampstead Garden Suburb, London The Henry Cort Community College, Fareham, Hampshire The Romsey School, Romsey, Hampshire The Westgate School, Winchester, Hampshire Thomas Deacon Academy, Peterborough, Cambridgeshire Tolworth Girls' School and Centre for Continuing Education, Surbiton, Surrey Westhoughton High School, Bolton, Lancashire Whitehaven School, Whitehaven, Cumbria Wildern School, Southampton, Hampshire William Edwards School and Sports College, Grays, Essex Woolwich Polytechnic School for Boys, Greenwich, London
Whats it about
Making mathematics more exciting, meaningful and relevant to learners.
Whats in it
Principles for engaging mathematics; case studies from a wide variety of schools.
Related materials
QCA curriculum website: www.qca.org.uk/curriculum
QCA wishes to make its publications widely accessible. Please contact us if you have specic accessibility requirements.
Qualications and Curriculum Authority 83 Piccadilly London W1J 8QA Telephone 020 7509 5555 Enquiries line 020 7509 5556 Minicom 020 7509 6546 Fax 020 7509 6666 Email [email protected] www.qca.org.uk QCA Orderline www.qca.org.uk/orderline Telephone 08700 60 60 15 ISBN 978-1-84721-937-4 Order ref QCA/09/4157