Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 331 views

    Mushi Dokugo

    Uploaded by

    nieotyagi
    Mushi-dokugo refers to awakening or enlightenment achieved independently without a Zen master. It is considered suspect due to the risk of self-delusion. However, some notable Zen figures like Nōnin were considered examples of mushi-dokugo. While Dogen acknowledged its possibility, he emphasized the importance of critical reflection and studying under masters to avoid fake enlightenment. Ultimately, one can practice independently but should not claim to represent a lineage without proper transmission.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Mushi Dokugo

    Uploaded by

    nieotyagi
    331 views2 pages
    Mushi-dokugo refers to awakening or enlightenment achieved independently without a Zen master. It is considered suspect due to the risk of self-delusion. However, some notable Zen figures like Nōnin were considered examples of mushi-dokugo. While Dogen acknowledged its possibility, he emphasized the importance of critical reflection and studying under masters to avoid fake enlightenment. Ultimately, one can practice independently but should not claim to represent a lineage without proper transmission.

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Mushi-dokugo refers to awakening or enlightenment achieved independently without a Zen master. It is considered suspect due to the risk of self-delusion. However, some notable Zen figures like Nōnin were considered examples of mushi-dokugo. While Dogen acknowledged its possibility, he emphasized the importance of critical reflection and studying under masters to avoid fake enlightenment. Ultimately, one can practice independently but should not claim to represent a lineage without proper transmission.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    331 views2 pages

    Mushi Dokugo

    Uploaded by

    nieotyagi
    Mushi-dokugo refers to awakening or enlightenment achieved independently without a Zen master. It is considered suspect due to the risk of self-delusion. However, some notable Zen figures like Nōnin were considered examples of mushi-dokugo. While Dogen acknowledged its possibility, he emphasized the importance of critical reflection and studying under masters to avoid fake enlightenment. Ultimately, one can practice independently but should not claim to represent a lineage without proper transmission.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 2

    9/25/13

    Mushi-dokugo - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    Mushi-dokugo (?), sometimes calledjigo-jish (?, self-enlightened and self-certified), is a Japanese term used in Zen Buddhism which expresses the phenomenon known as "awakening alone, without a master."[1][note 1][2]
    Contents [hide] 1 Etymology 2 Examples of mushi-dokugo 3 Statements on mushi-dokugo 4 See also 5 Notes 6 References 7 Web references 8 Sources 9 External links

    Etymology

    [edit source]

    Mushi-dok ugo () is a Japanese term composed of four Chinese characters, or kanji, meaning "independent realization without a master." The charactermu () means "without" or "no", shi () means "master" or "teacher", dok u () means "independent" or "alone", and go () means "realization" or "understanding" (satoru), also translated as "enlightenment" (satori).[note 2]When strung together, the characters literally read, "no () master () independent () understanding ()." The equivalent Chinese pronunciation is wsh dw.

    Examples of mushi-dokugo

    [edit source]

    Nnin (died 1196) is an example of mushi-dokugo[1]: Nonin initially studied Tendai Buddhism, but he apparently became dissatisfied with it, even abandoning the traditional teacher-disciple relationship by declaring himself to be a self-enlightened Zen rshi.[3] During the Edo period in Japan, there were a great many priests who proclaimed to be "self-enlightened." These included... such notables as the Myshin-ji masters Daigu, Ungo, Isshi and the Stpriest Suzuki Shsan.[4] The famous Korean master Jinul could also be seen as an example.

    Statements on mushi-dokugo
    It is...

    [edit source]

    usually considered suspect since the risk of self-delusion or 'fake-Zen' is always high.[5] According to William M. Bodiford, To guarantee that his experience of the truth of Buddhism is genuine, the Zen disciple relies upon his teacher to authenticate and formally acknowledge his enlightenment.[5] Dgen, the founder of the St school of Japan, acknowledged in his lifetime that such a phenomenon exists. According to Hee-Jin Kim, [...] enlightenment-by-oneself, without a teacher" (mushi-dok ugo), [is] the ultimate Zen principle that every practitioner had to actualize, even while studying under competent teachers and reading the
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mushi-dokugo 1/2

    9/25/13

    Mushi-dokugo - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    sutras for a number of years. Dgen provided this well known dictum with a specific methodological/hermeneutic key that allowed one to unlock the mystery of existencethat is, to open the self and the universe. That key amounted, in essence, to critical, reflective thinking as an integral part of meditation. Without this key, it was impossible to attain one's own salvific independence [...] Meditation and wisdom alike had to be subjected to critical scrutiny and reassessed in the changing situation[6] Critical, reflective thinking as an integral part of meditation is mentioned in the fascicles of the Shbgenz.[6] Anyone practising alone or together, without dharma transmission, may be regarded a dharma practitioner: So although shiho alone is not much, no shiho at all qualifies you for nothing but being a dharma practioner in your own right, a follower of the buddha way who may practice on his own or along with others. You may even teach the dharma, but you should not pose as an authorized representative of a lineage or school. Believe it or not, that happens all the time. If you teach without shiho, you should make clear that you are not part of one of the existing schools, but the founder of your own school (which is OK of course, as long as you state so).[w eb 1]

    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mushi-dokugo

    2/2

    You might also like